The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

Post 1773, Ethnikos?

What would you like? God wants you to die, so He does not give you a calling?
Join up with Allah. Since God has rejected you. From what I looked up, if you recite the five times a day prayer, Allah gives you the discernment between good and evil. I suppose that might mean that if you say you believe enough times then eventually you will. See how that works for you.
 
This (3) is the thing I was arguing about on the "teachings" thread. Genesis 3:16 is a verse people make out as God's great curse on womankind, or whatever. I do not get that from it, the great "I will do this" thing that is putting words into God's mouth. You can google for examples of how there were places in the Old Testament that were deliberately mistranslated to change it from where women had equal status with men, in a lot of aspects. What I mean is that one should not blame God for some things that were manipulated in the religion much after the fact.
Jesus tried to rectify some of the bias, as in the story of the woman taken in adultery. He pointed out that they were equally guilty, if they were judged equally. So, to me, the superiority of Christianity is in the fact that it has Jesus in it.
Genesis 19:6-8.

Anyway, that's just one of a list of 7 things that are condoned IN THE BIBLE, that are clearly immoral by today's western civilization form of morality.

Again, Why should I accept christianity as a source of morality?
 
So, I'm confused. I have two people, telling me contradictory things,presenting the same quality of evidence for both claims. How do you suggest I figure out whether you're right, whether Ahmed is right, or whether you're both wrong?

Oh, and can I ask you a direct question, as analogies seem to trouble you? Why don't you believe in Zeus?
What would you like? God wants you to die, so He does not give you a calling?
Join up with Allah. Since God has rejected you. From what I looked up, if you recite the five times a day prayer, Allah gives you the discernment between good and evil. I suppose that might mean that if you say you believe enough times then eventually you will. See how that works for you.
So your answer is go on a nonsensical rant. Great arguments in showing your abject fail.
 
What would you like?

I don't want God to punish me. So I need to figure out which God is real.

You tell me Jesus. Ahmed tells me Allah. You both have books, and visions, and a strong moral philosophy. So I'm not sure. You both have the same evidence, the same conviction, and whilst I like Jesus' take on wine at parties, frankly, Ahmed's guys have nattier beards...

So help me out here. Save me from burning in hell. How do I figure out if you're right, or he is? On what basis can I tell if you're telling the truth, or he is?
 
Last edited:
This (3) is the thing I was arguing about on the "teachings" thread. Genesis 3:16 is a verse people make out as God's great curse on womankind, or whatever. I do not get that from it, the great "I will do this" thing that is putting words into God's mouth. You can google for examples of how there were places in the Old Testament that were deliberately mistranslated to change it from where women had equal status with men, in a lot of aspects. What I mean is that one should not blame God for some things that were manipulated in the religion much after the fact.
Jesus tried to rectify some of the bias, as in the story of the woman taken in adultery. He pointed out that they were equally guilty, if they were judged equally. So, to me, the superiority of Christianity is in the fact that it has Jesus in it.

1) On another thread, Ethnikos, you and I have gone round and round on this Gen. 3:16 retranslation that you - and you alone - insist is the proper meaning of this very plain, straight-forward and simple verse. The fact is that as it is presently translated it fits perfectly in the context of Genesis 3. Your weird re-transaltion would be totally out of place.

2) If the Bible is truly the inspired word of God, how could it have gross errors, such as what you say is the case with Gen. 3:16. Are you seriously saying that God went to the trouble of inspiring the biblical text, but either didn't bother or was powerless to correct mistranslations, scribal errors and deliberate tampering with the text?

3) The story of the woman taken in adultery is not in the earliest nearly complete copy of the Gospel of John, the Papyrus Bodmer II, dating from ca. CE 200, even though the codex contains all the other material in that section of the gospel. Thus, the story appears to be a later addition to the Gospel of John, hence neither written by the original author of that gospel nor even necessarily portrying an actual event in the life of Jesus.
 
Ethinikos: are you saying that we would have no moral code nor legal system if we did not base it on the bible: and saying at the same time that we should not base on the bible because it is corrupt and immoral? Cos that is what I seem to be reading
 
I do not agree, Jesus taught turn the other cheek and love your enemies which is way harder than liking people who are nice to you. And just because some people do care that does in no way mean they aren't sinners, we all are. This is why we need the savior!

It's also important to know God is the author of love so if we love others we are pleasing to him as this is somethings God wants from us and I believe he honors this. As scripture puts it... love covers a multitude of sins.

&... the greatest of all the gifts is faith, hope, and love!

Did you bother to even try to read my post and the post it was in response to? No, you just took it as yet another opportunity to preach and tell us that everyone is a sinner. Kathy, just stop it. We do not believe in sin, and even if we did, we surely do not believe in a ridiculous concept like original sin.
 
I'll ask again: How can the legal system be "based on the Bible", when it permits things the bible forbids and forbids things the Bible permits? Does that not prove that it is perfectly possible for a legal system to be extra-Biblical? Does that not prove that whatever the "source" of the American legal system is, it certainly isn't the Bible? Does it not expressly demonstrate that moral and legal philosophy is not reliant on the Bible at all?
You were presenting a hypothetical where God does not exist. Who knows what people might come up with, or if there would be any people at all.
 
You were presenting a hypothetical where God does not exist. Who knows what people might come up with, or if there would be any people at all.

Wait, are you talking to me, or with someone else? What you say in response to my posts seems to have no relation to what I actually said.

You asked "What would we base the legal system on, if not the Bible". I showed that the legal system we have NOW is not based on the Bible, and quite demonstrably - and this is true whether or not God exists.

Do you agree that it is manifestly obvious that the American legal system is not based on the Bible?
 
How do you make the world a better place?
Easy, plant a tree, feed the hungry, teach a child, be good to your neighbors, basically just be a decent, caring person. It's not all that hard and people contribute in other ways. Just because you are obsessed with finding conspiracy theories around every corner doesn't mean other people are. And it doesn't mean they're are massive conspiracies out there.

You are paranoid.

What if we had Madison Avenue promoting the idea that a particular religion was the source of disunity in the world and if we could eliminate its followers, we could have world peace?
Only small minded, ignorant people would believe them. Remember WWII? We've seen genocide on a massive scale first hand.

Monopolistic institutional "religion" that could benefit by having whatever is left of an opposition squashed, once and for all. Of course the ones being squashed would be the true saints who see the real head of the institution as being Satan.

Oh yes, your paranoia of organized religion. Admittedly, I don't like organized religion much either but it's not planning the massive conspiracies that you think of. You've read too much DaVinci code-like books. :rolleyes:
 
So your answer is go on a nonsensical rant. Great arguments in showing your abject fail.
My religion is a mixture of Calvinism with Methodism and Presbyterianism, so if I leaned to the Calvinist view, it can be argued that there is a such thing as predestination. Even Luther is not sure how God picks out who will be saved. So, I do not think my question is necessarily nonsensical.
When one hears the Gospel, the Holy Spirit impresses upon you the truthfulness of it. You have the ability to reject the inspiration from God, if you so choose. The more you reject it, the less you hear that voice, until it goes away. Faith is not automatic or something you have of your own power, but is a gift from God.
 
Are you speaking English, Ethnikos? I recognise the words, the grammar kinda resembles my mother tongue, but the sentences make little or no sense. It's as if your posts have been auto-generated by a poorly-programmed chatbot.

What do you mean? How can I reject the inspiration, if I haven't had it? How am I meant to evaluate the completing claims for you and Ahmed - he says the same things you do, but about Allah. He says I will know when Allah has spoken to me, as he has to him.

So help me. How can I test the truth of your completing claims?
 
Last edited:
1) On another thread, Ethnikos, you and I have gone round and round on this Gen. 3:16 re translation that you - and you alone - insist is the proper meaning of this very plain, straight-forward and simple verse. The fact is that as it is presently translated it fits perfectly in the context of Genesis 3. Your weird re-translation would be totally out of place.
I did a little more study on that and what I have found reinforces what I thought about it. It is not something to beat people up about, as if everyone has to agree with me, but I find my interpretation personally useful.
2) If the Bible is truly the inspired word of God, how could it have gross errors, such as what you say is the case with Gen. 3:16. Are you seriously saying that God went to the trouble of inspiring the biblical text, but either didn't bother or was powerless to correct mistranslations, scribal errors and deliberate tampering with the text?
I don't know, but the Christians were ready to toss out the whole Old Testament, at one time. They decided to keep it since there were supposedly proofs in it that Jesus was legitimate. So some more minor errors might not be so much a concern, looked at from that perspective. We need to keep studying the Bible and fixing things about it, if that is possible. We have tools at our disposal that makes it a lot easier than people had in the past, like computers and the internet.
3) The story of the woman taken in adultery is not in the earliest nearly complete copy of the Gospel of John, the Papyrus Bodmer II, dating from ca. CE 200, even though the codex contains all the other material in that section of the gospel. Thus, the story appears to be a later addition to the Gospel of John, hence neither written by the original author of that gospel nor even necessarily portraying an actual event in the life of Jesus.
Maybe the better version is the one with that story. Maybe someone did not like the idea of this woman being let go, and conveniently left it out. This is the sort of thing I was talking about. It is not a good idea to underestimate some of the hatred there is against women. How about just the fact that someone would be a monk, in the first place?
 
Ethinikos: are you saying that we would have no moral code nor legal system if we did not base it on the bible: and saying at the same time that we should not base on the bible because it is corrupt and immoral? Cos that is what I seem to be reading

I am not advocating tossing out the Bible. What I am talking about is people reading something into a verse that is not there, in my opinion. Look up Genesis 3:16 in the Hebrew at http://net.bible.org/verse.php?book=Gen&chapter=3&verse=16
There are 16 words for the Hebrew version of the verse. It reads right to left. (start at (3:16) on the lower line) Put your cursor on the number below the word and a little window pops up with translation suggestions. Stop at each word for a few seconds each and read it to yourself, with the suggested words, in English. Then ask yourself if this is proof that women are cursed by god and will be forced to be in submission to men, by their own desire for it, or whatever men like to interpret it as, for whatever reason. (you can access further details for each word by clicking on them)
That's one example of a mistranslation, in my opinion. The other one I ran across while googling articles on the Septuagint version of the Old Testament is about the camp in the wilderness and the tabernacle service. What is changed is that there was a part that women played, where they were like prophets who prayed for and blessed the people as they entered the temple area. It got changed to say that they washed the men's feet.
 
Last edited:
I may be late to this thread and totally missing the point, but a couple of previous posts on recent pages lead me to say this: a long while ago I woke suddenly and knew that I didn't dare move. By moving my eyes, I could catch a glimpse of a dark, skinny figure moving in the darkness at the foot of my bed. I could feel the sheer evil of it as I lay there and I was utterly terrified.

This is a totally real experience that I went through, I'm not lying and it was of course a simple, run of the mill case of sleep paralysis. Steve Novella and crew have explained it a few times and I have had several more experiences like this in my lifetime...and I have never touched any mind-altering substances (discounting caffiene etc). I hope that people realize the point that I'm making and that I haven't wasted anyone's time.


Yep, your point is loud and clear. :)

I will go even further and suggest that if you had been raised in a Hindu society, you may have interpreted your sleep paralysis differently.
 
I am not advocating tossing out the Bible. What I am talking about is people reading something into a verse that is not there, in my opinion. Look up Genesis 3:16 in the Hebrew at http://net.bible.org/verse.php?book=Gen&chapter=3&verse=16
There are 16 words for the Hebrew version of the verse. It reads right to left. (start at (3:16) on the lower line) Put your cursor on the number below the word and a little window pops up with translation suggestions. Stop at each word for a few seconds each and read it to yourself, with the suggested words, in English. Then ask yourself if this is proof that women are cursed by god and will be forced to be in submission to men, by their own desire for it, or whatever men like to interpret it as, for whatever reason. (you can access further details for each word by clicking on them)
That's one example of a mistranslation, in my opinion]/b]. The other one I ran across while googling articles on the Septuagint version of the Old Testament is about the camp in the wilderness and the tabernacle service. What is changed is that there was a part that women played, where they were like prophets who prayed for and blessed the people as they entered the temple area. It got changed to say that they washed the men's feet.


And that is the problem... If the bible is the word of God, then shouldn't your opinion be irrelevant? Shouldn't the meaning shine through all the different possible translations? Shockingly, the bible is open to interpretation - and those who are the best contortionists are most often those who support the bible...
 
So help me. How can I test the truth of your completing claims?
Jesus speaks to us directly, as God in human form, in the Bible. He is the living word that is the source, through the Spirit, of the written word. By the power of God, Jesus can tell us in his own words, what to believe.
This is as direct a way as possible to hear the message that you are to believe. It does not come from repeating a line, over and over. It is not some mind game or hypnoses. It is the "still small voice" that speaks to you, and may not be some sort of ecstatic experience.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom