The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

This is what my cousin told me when he came over today. He has a collection of books by Edward Gibbon who wrote The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Gibbon, who was a sceptic of the organized religions, made an assessment of the Muslim religion and says that Mohamed made these claims about himself.

Let me get this straight. You try to make an argument about a figure of the Islam, based on your recollection of what someone else said that he read in a book about the roman empire?

You don't see some strangeness in that, do you?


I admit to being ignorant about it somewhat.

So, you blindly want to defend the cult you belong to by bringing up arguments about something that you are ignorant about. Way to go, really. Does "laughing stock" ring a bell with you?

See, you could simply have took a look here, for starters. Right at the start it says:

Wikipedia said:
Muhammad ibn ‘Abdullāh (Arabic: محمّد; Transliteration: Muḥammad; pronounced [mʊħɑmmæd̪]; also spelled Mohammed or Muhammed) (ca. 570 Mecca[مَكَةَ ]/[ مَكَهْ ] – June 8, 632 Medina), is the founder of the religion of Islam [ إِسْلامْ ] and is regarded by Muslims as a messenger and prophet of God (Arabic: الله‎ Allāh), the last and the greatest law-bearer in a series of Islamic prophets as taught by the Qur'an 33:40–40. Muslims thus consider him the restorer of the uncorrupted original monotheistic faith (islām) of Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and other prophets. He was also active as a diplomat, merchant, philosopher, orator, legislator, reformer, military general, and, according to Muslim belief, an agent of divine action.

And guess what, you even have a whole section at the bottom called "Further reading".

Now, tell me, where in the above quote do you see anything that say that "Mohammad claims to be the comforter and the Holy Spirit and Jesus. He takes the attributes that Christians apply to the different persons of the godhead and applies them to himself"?

Now, as others have asked you, what makes your version of a cult better than another version or another cult? And please, please, please. Come up with some arguments that are not based on circular logic, bible-thumping or ignorance of the other side.

But i guess that if you would really try to think of an good answer, you would suddenly see that there simply is none. Meaning that there is no single religion or version of it that has "the truth" or is superior. Which in turn would somewhat shake your belief. And that, of course, is something that you religious fanatics try to avoid at all cost. Even if that means ignorance or outright lies.

Greetings,

Chris
 
So, where do you draw the line? Who decides if someone is reading something that's not there?
The line is someone claiming authority to impose their will on you, which is why the U.S. Constitution has a first amendment that starts out with freedom of religion.
There is an understanding that godly people can have and is useful to listen to but you have to search the things out for yourself once you hear them and not just accept that anyone is right about everything.
 
Now, tell me, where in the above quote do you see anything that say that "Mohammad claims to be the comforter and the Holy Spirit and Jesus. He takes the attributes that Christians apply to the different persons of the godhead and applies them to himself"?
". . .according to Muslim belief, an agent of divine action."
According to the Christian religion, Jesus is the agent of divine action, as The Word, which was in the beginning with God and was divine by virtue of coming out of God and sanctified by God, and sent into the world by God.
 
This is what my cousin told me when he came over today. He has a collection of books by Edward Gibbon who wrote The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Gibbon, who was a sceptic of the organized religions, made an assessment of the Muslim religion and says that Mohamed made these claims about himself.

I'm reading Edward Gibbon's The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire myself, for college. While I appreciate his language and the information given at the context of his time, I wouldn't exactly call him a religious authority. I'd also add that he gave no more praise of Christianity or Judaism in his book.
 
Last edited:
". . .according to Muslim belief, an agent of divine action."
According to the Christian religion, Jesus is the agent of divine action, as The Word, which was in the beginning with God and was divine by virtue of coming out of God and sanctified by God, and sent into the world by God.


What does this even mean?
What point do you think you are making?
Is the problem with english? Or what?
 
". . .according to Muslim belief, an agent of divine action."
According to the Christian religion, Jesus is the agent of divine action, as The Word, which was in the beginning with God and was divine by virtue of coming out of God and sanctified by God, and sent into the world by God.

First of all, you seem to ignore the "according to Muslim belief" part, which is pretty much the opposite of what you said:

Then Mohammad claims to be the comforter and the Holy Spirit and Jesus. He takes the attributes that Christians apply to the different persons of the godhead and applies them to himself.

See, at least try to get your story straight. You do notice the difference between the part of the WP quote and your quote, do you?

Next, you again fall into circular logic. Yes, Christianity says something about Jesus. However, you can not take that as any kind of proof for Christianity being the "truth" or "superior". See, simply because Islam says something about Muhammad.

And that exactly is the topic of this thread. So far, you miserably fail to show any shred of evidence of why Christianity, or a certain branch of that cult, is better than any other religion. You keep referring to your cult as an explanation why your cult is best.

Sorry, but that just doesn't fly. Again, try to make an argument without using circular logic. You seem to be stuck in a religious trap and don't notice it. Or maybe you notice, but are too afraid of getting out of it.

So, as volatile already asked:

And Ahmed told me that Allah inspired the Qran directly. So he's one up on you guys already.

Well, kinda. But Ahmed told me the same thing about the Qran. In fact, he missed out the Jesus part and explained that the Qran is directly inspired, and always studied in its original language. None of those messy translations. So if "direct way as possible" is your criteria, I'm afraid he's winning so far. In fact, I think Tom Cruise, relying on the teaching of on L. Ron Hubbard - a man who definitely existed, and wrote in Tom's mother tongue - also has one up on you on that basis.

How do you suggest I compare your claim with his? How do I know he's mislead, and your telling the truth? You still haven't explained. I mean look, to be honest, I'm suspicious of you both. I don't know who to believe. But I don't want to burn in hell.

So I need to know how to figure out who's telling the truth. What do you suggest?

And now please try to be honest, and do not try to bring up arguments that are so utterly flawed like the ones you brought up so far. Oh, and if you intend to bring up how or what other religions do or define, please, read something about those first. Otherwise you again end up making the same kind error that you made with Muhammad and Islam.

If you can't really say why your cult is better, then simply don't claim it to be and say so. Stand up, be honest and say you have no idea as to why. But don't try to continue to defend something that you obviously fail to defend.

Greetings,

Chris
 
You appear to be asking the impossible, Christian Klippel. Although I did not realise it before, Ethnikos does not know anything about at least one other religion. It is therefore unfair to ask him to show why his is true compared to all other belief systems (and, on present showing, any other belief systems) because he cannot have any idea whatsoever
 
You appear to be asking the impossible, Christian Klippel. Although I did not realise it before, Ethnikos does not know anything about at least one other religion. It is therefore unfair to ask him to show why his is true compared to all other belief systems (and, on present showing, any other belief systems) because he cannot have any idea whatsoever
I mentioned in an earlier post that I got onto this thread to talk about prayer, since someone was on here claiming that prayer was useless. Kind of a chain reaction thing got me stuck here. Then people started thinking I should say something that matched the thread title. I am not too interested in the prove you are the right religion thing since I think everyone needs to examine them selves for idolatry and be responsible for their own beliefs.
Sorry if I did not solve whatever the dilemma is that this thread was started for.
 
. I am not too interested in the prove you are the right religion thing since I think everyone needs to examine them selves for idolatry and be responsible for their own beliefs.
"Examine themselves for idolatry"? I'm not sure what implies. Is idolatry necessarily a bad thing?
 
I think everyone needs to examine them selves for idolatry and be responsible for their own beliefs.

Well, I'm doing that, and still don't know. Are you right, or is Ahmed right? How can I tell?

I mean, it's all very well and good you telling me "Jesus was a nice guy; so pick me!", but Ahmed says that too about Mohammad. It's all very well you telling me that following your book is what God wants, but then Ahmed tells me that too about his book. You say you're right because Jesus just kinda comes to you (as it says in your book) and Moslems have to pray regularly; he says he's right because Moslems have to pray regularly (as it says in his book) whereas you guys just kinda pretend you felt Jesus. You see my dilemma, I'm sure - two contradictory claims, made with equal conviction and with almost identical evidential bases.

So, I'm still stuck. On what basis can I examine which one of you is right? Help me!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom