The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

And that is the problem... If the bible is the word of God, then shouldn't your opinion be irrelevant? Shouldn't the meaning shine through all the different possible translations? Shockingly, the bible is open to interpretation - and those who are the best contortionists are most often those who support the bible...
Not sure what you mean.
I had a wake up 25 years ago when Holy Blood, Holy Grail came out. I realized that a lot of assumptions about Jesus were just that, and were not based on the Bible. (of course I disagree with most of what the writers say, but it made me take a different look at how a belief system is put together.)
People looked at the Bible, for the first time for many, a few hundred years ago. A lot of what we have is the result of one translation on top of another, resulting in several layers of opportunity for injection of opinions. The interpreters got a hold of the latest translations and immediately started their commentaries loaded with their opinion of what the Bible means to say. You can see how there is a chain of traditions that build from the earliest commentaries to the more recent versions where it starts with one error and successively builds as it is passed from one to the next.
There comes a point where the individual has to say, It stops right here, and take a very serious look at what the book is really trying to say. Not the easiest thing in the world to do, but think about how much time you spend doing things like watching tv, that you can live without.
 
Last edited:
I had a wake up 25 years ago when Holy Blood, Holy Grail came out. I realized that a lot of assumptions about Jesus were just that, and were not based on the Bible. (of course I disagree with most of what the writers say, but it made me take a different look at how a belief system is put together.)


Have you read Misquoting Jesus by Bart Ehrman? The scholarship is far, far better than the book you are referring to, and he takes a careful look at translation/transcription issues through time. He does have a solid grounding in the source languages, and explains how he does his translations, providing source material whenever possible. It is an interesting (and easy) read.
 
Was there any purpose to all that bible thumping?
paximperium was saying I was making up stuff about Satan. I figured I should list a few verses that might back up some of what I am saying. What I was trying to get across was the concept that there are witnesses to what happens and when Satan gets killed it is a really big deal. God has to do it when there is solid proof that Satan's way leads to a bad ending.
 
Apologies for butting in, but I've long wondered whether there was an answer to volatile's question about Ahmed. It avoids all this subjective stuff about the bible where everybody has their own interpretation. If there isn't an answer that's fine, but I'm curious what believers think the lack of an answer means.
 
Have you read Misquoting Jesus by Bart Ehrman? The scholarship is far, far better than the book you are referring to, and he takes a careful look at translation/transcription issues through time. He does have a solid grounding in the source languages, and explains how he does his translations, providing source material whenever possible. It is an interesting (and easy) read.
Someone else recommended that book to me, so I just ordered one from Amazon.
A little concerned about the review on it they had up at Amazon from the Library society or something. (I will probably write a review on the amazon page, later) I do not want to throw the Bible into the dustbin of history or treat it like it is to be considered as just a relic. I do think we should be aware of what is going on and to take the steps necessary to come to a proper understanding of it.
(I will have to wait 'till next month to buy Tim Callahan's books.)
One way of looking at how to approach your quest to enlightenment is to realize the most popular commentary or "study" Bible is going to be the worst you can buy because they were produced with foundation money to promote an agenda.
 
One way of looking at how to approach your quest to enlightenment is to realize the most popular commentary or "study" Bible is going to be the worst you can buy because they were produced with foundation money to promote an agenda.

and the bible wasn't ?
:D
 
Apologies for butting in, but I've long wondered whether there was an answer to volatile's question about Ahmed. It avoids all this subjective stuff about the bible where everybody has their own interpretation. If there isn't an answer that's fine, but I'm curious what believers think the lack of an answer means.
I doubt that most Christians realize there might be a problem.
I think the standard answer would be to say, "Judge them by their Fruits."
If "W" is an example of a Christian, I think there might be a problem with that answer.
You have to Look at things on the grass roots level. At church, we got this little story about a missionary in a Muslim country who hired a local to help him. The guy told the missionary he did not know anyone who was so nice, and he decided to become a Christian too.
Missionaries are kind of special sometimes. I know a woman at my church who when she was in college, she volunteered to do a year of teaching English class in a foreign country. Beirut, Lebanon, in the middle of the civil war, when they were kidnapping westerners. I asked her if she was ever worried and she acted like she had no idea what I meant.
 
Jesus ... is the living word
Please, dispense with the marketing hype

I do not want to throw the Bible into the dustbin of history or treat it like it is to be considered as just a relic.
I think you'll find that no-one here is suggesting that you "throw the Bible into the dustbin of history"... However, it would be conducive to meaningful discussion if you were to move it from the history section of your library and place it where it belongs: mythology
 
I am not advocating tossing out the Bible. What I am talking about is people reading something into a verse that is not there, in my opinion.

I'm all for people coming up with their own definitions.
In fact, I think it is imperative.
That's my mission, I guess, if it could be put in so many words. Don't look at the version of what is really the remnants of what Christianity was, as presented to you by whoever may have been geographically closest to you, and think that's it, and that no other thinking is required. You need to deconstruct it and then put it all together, in your own mind by your best understanding that God, through the Holy Spirit, can assist you with.
You don't have to accept my version, just see that people can do such a thing, then do the same sort of thing yourself.

So, where do you draw the line? Who decides if someone is reading something that's not there?
 
Did you bother to even try to read my post and the post it was in response to? No, you just took it as yet another opportunity to preach and tell us that everyone is a sinner. Kathy, just stop it. We do not believe in sin, and even if we did, we surely do not believe in a ridiculous concept like original sin.

Well why then? Obviously this world has been affected by it and death is truly a reality because of it, so why do you choose not to believe in the concept of original sin?
 
Kathy why don't you answer some questions instead of ignoring them?

You know why at present I am barely able to find time to get on here as we are on a family vacation. You may just need to be a bit more patient with me. Sorry!
 
Well why then? Obviously this world has been affected by it and death is truly a reality because of it, so why do you choose not to believe in the concept of original sin?

Speaking for myself:

For a number of reasons, starting with "because there isn't a damn bit of evidence for it." But mostly because I find the idea that I am responsible for the deeds/misdeeds of my ancestor(s) to be morally repulsive.
 
kurious_kathy,
if a Muslim person were to pray to Allah for work and subsequently found a job, would you think that Allah had intervened? Yes or no will be fine, thanks.
 
Jesus speaks to us directly, as God in human form, in the Bible. He is the living word that is the source, through the Spirit, of the written word. By the power of God, Jesus can tell us in his own words, what to believe.

JesusMohammed speaks to us directly, as GodAllah in human form, in the BibleQur'an. He is the living word that is the source, through the Spirit, of the written word. By the power of GodAllah, JesusMohammed can tell us in his own words, what to believe.

See the problem, Ethnikos?
 
Kathy, I do commend you for answering at least part of my questions on what constitutes sin, and if we're all allegedly slaves to something beyond simply "being born human."


Others have already addressed this, but I assume you have not committed murder. I personally haven't committed murder or adultery, and I do honor my parents. I don't worship or keep the sabbath, but I've also never lied in court. Oh, and I don't consider my neighbors' wives to be property, so I ignore that commandment entirely.


Do you honestly believe that everybody would be a drunken sexually-charged violent sorcerer if they didn't come to Jesus? I've never come to Jesus, and I'm also not guilty of most of the debauchery you listed here. I'm not going to say I'm perfect, not by any stretch, but I'm living a very mundane existence in the suburbs. No drinking, no orgies, no violent rages. Just working hard to help support my family, doing a bit of charity work, paying my taxes, staying faithful to my husband, reading books and doing my best to stay healthy. I'm sorry, but your magic man is not going to tell me that I'm evil for living my life in a very healthy and happy way, when I'm not hurting anybody.

Especially when your magic man promotes rape as a great reward. I haven't twisted any scriptures, and there's more than one instance of rape in the bible. If you think I've twisted the story of Abraham, Sarah, and Hagar, you tell me what I'm missing and how it would be somehow allowable for God to tell Abraham that he should impregnate his wife's servant. When you're done with that, maybe you can tell me how it's permissible that God impregnated Mary. We don't allow coaches and teachers to have sex with their students because the relationship can never be one of two equals. Are you going to tell me that Mary is somehow God's equal, or did he take advantage of their unequal relationship?

You my dear SC are probably one of the hardest people to reach because what I'm hearing from you is you think you on good enough on your own merit so God should just let you into heaven. Even the smallest little sin is bad. Ever lied? Ever stolen anything?? Ever had a bad thought towards anyone, especially God???

As for Sarah's sin, she was the one who got impatient waiting for God's promise and started a whole lot of trouble because of her disobedience. God never said it was okay for Abraham to sleep with Hagar!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom