The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

This kind of reinforces the point Kurious_Kathy has been working on. There really is no argument in favour of any specific religion or sect that you can't substitute another religion or sect into and leave it just as valid.
I am not conceding that point.
I already made a point about how the two religions have a different way of coming to belief. One is through endless repetition of saying you believe, the other has belief coming from hearing the gospel. One is a self induced hypnoses and one comes from God.
The Muslim religion is contradictory by saying God is not divided and does everything. Then Mohammad claims to be the comforter and the Holy Spirit and Jesus. He takes the attributes that Christians apply to the different persons of the godhead and applies them to himself. This is not a sign of the unity of god, if the godlike powers are delegated out. The whole religion turns out to be just a counterfeit of Christianity except it makes a sinful man as receiving the positions and titles and powers reserved for gods.
 
I am not conceding that point.
I already made a point about how the two religions have a different way of coming to belief. One is through endless repetition of saying you believe, the other has belief coming from hearing the gospel (which is endless repetition). One is a self induced hypnoses and one comes from God.
The Muslim religion is contradictory by saying God is not divided and does everything. Then Mohammad claims to be the comforter and the Holy Spirit and Jesus. He takes the attributes that Christians apply to the different persons of the godhead and applies them to himself. This is not a sign of the unity of god(Like father son and holy ghost are), if the godlike powers are delegated out. The whole religion turns out to be just a counterfeit of Christianity except it makes a sinful man as receiving the positions and titles and powers reserved for gods(like Jesus).
OK, better.....

Paul

:) :) :)
 
I am not conceding that point.
I already made a point about how the two religions have a different way of coming to belief. One is through endless repetition of saying you believe, the other has belief coming from hearing the gospel. One is a self induced hypnoses and one comes from God.
The Muslim religion is contradictory by saying God is not divided and does everything. Then Mohammad claims to be the comforter and the Holy Spirit and Jesus. He takes the attributes that Christians apply to the different persons of the godhead and applies them to himself. This is not a sign of the unity of god, if the godlike powers are delegated out. The whole religion turns out to be just a counterfeit of Christianity except it makes a sinful man as receiving the positions and titles and powers reserved for gods.

See, Ahmed told me Christianity was a counterfeit of Islam, as it negates the majesty of God.

So, we're back where we started. On what objective measure can I tell your competing claims apart? He says you're wrong. You say he's wrong. How do I figure this out?
 
One is through endless repetition of saying you believe ... a self induced hypnoses ...

To me, it sounds like the praying stuff the Christians do.

Then Mohammad claims to be the comforter and the Holy Spirit and Jesus. He takes the attributes that Christians apply to the different persons of the godhead and applies them to himself.

Dude, you are so utterly wrong, it ain't no fun anymore. Please, before you make any statements about what figure in what religion represents what, take some time and read up on the topic.

I'm surely no expert on any religion at all, but even i can see that you are wrong. For your information: Mohammad is the prophet. Not the holy spirit, and not Jesus.

Whatever arguments you made so far, they sound like mere rabulistics.

Greetings,

Chris
 
I bet those are some of the verses that are either not to be taken literally, or are culturally specific to the time and place and not to be taken as any kind of universal moral decree.

To paraphrase the apologists I've heard regarding this passage, the Midianites (and everyone else the apocryphal genocidal army of Moses and Joshua slaughtered during their 40-year nature hike) were so evil and wicked that the were beyond redemption. As for the young virgins who will be used as sexual playthings by the conquering Hebrews, they get to know "God's love and mercy."

No matter how much they try, they really can't dig themselves out of this hole. I've always said that the Abrahamic religions would be far more honest if they just drop the "love" and "mercy" lie and admit that their God is a totalitarian prick who demands our worship or he'll hurt us. They might not get as many deluded and desperate people to follow them, but at least they'll be consistent.
 
Last edited:
Are you trying to trick me? I have an opinion about what makes peoples prayers be hindered if you care to hear it?

Off the top of my head... I think unless one is made righteous through Christ living in him I do not think God answers all peoples prayers, not until someone is forgiven for their sins.(I could be wrong) Scripture says he causes the sun to rise on the just and the unjust so this makes my opinion a bit more complicated.

I believe God does know if a person has a heart to know him (but your allah and my God are not the same) I am concerned many get their blessings here and now but in the end they will have no reward because they are following false gods!

What does it profit a man if he gain the world but lose his soul?

What does it profit a person when they get religion and lose the ability to think?
 
imgres
 
Last edited:
Well, it's hard to claim he didn't:
I especially like verses 17-18.
Your link goes to Numbers 31. You can look at the Hebrew at
http://net.bible.org/verse.php?book=Num&chapter=31&verse=18
Look where it says in bold, HEBREW.

וכל הטף בנשים אשר לא־ידעו משכב זכר החיו לכם׃

The convention for representing the consonant only form used by netbible, for chayah is wyxh. Click on the number below that (02421) to go the definitions for that word. There is something like 67 variations of the word. Since the particular form of the word translated as live is only found once in the Bible, it is my opinion that it is open for interpretation. I have decided to translate it "the ability to live in such a way", making it more of a noun than a verb. At the end of the verse is a word, לכם which doubles up the verb, which in this sentence is to know. So according to my translation, the meaning of the verse is the opposite of how it is normaly translated.
All the female children who have not known a man's bed will be able to live without having to know a man.
So what you end up with is Moses saying, "Joke's on you, fools. You were supposed to kill everyone and you come back with all these females, as if you were going to have a good time, or something. Forget it, you must kill all the women who you killed the husbands of, and the younger ones you can not have sex with."
 
Last edited:
Your link goes to Numbers 31. You can look at the Hebrew at
http://net.bible.org/verse.php?book=Num&chapter=31&verse=18
Look where it says in bold, HEBREW.

וכל הטף בנשים אשר לא־ידעו משכב זכר החיו לכם׃

The digital representation for chayah is wyxh. Click on the number below that (02421) to go the definitions for that word. There is something like 67 variations of the word. Since the particular form of the word translated as live is only found once in the Bible, it is my opinion that it is open for interpretation. I have decided to translate it "the ability to live in such a way", making it more of a noun than a verb. At the end of the verse is a word, לכם which doubles up the verb, which in this sentence is to know. So according to my translation, it means the opposite of the normal translation.
All the female children who have not known a man's bed will be able to live without having to know a man.
So what you end up with is Moses saying, "Joke's on you, fools. You were supposed to kill everyone and you come back with all these females, as if you were going to have a good time, or something. Forget it, you must kill all the women who you killed the husbands of, and the younger ones you can not have sex with."

Oh, well that makes the whole thing just dandy. Phew!
 
Last edited:
So, even if your "opposite" translation of Numbers were true, Ethnikos, are you really okay with a god who asked his followers to: kill all the men, kill all the married women, kill all the male children, and keep the virgin females as celibate housepets? Are you working on a translation where there's no killing or is that harder to ignore because of its frequency?
 
Oh, well that makes the whole thing just dandy. Phew!
I was about to type the exact same thing.

What does it say about god's inerrant word that the bible can be translated in two ways that have opposite meanings? My answer is that the implication is that the english version set in our current culture is meaningless.
 
Dude, you are so utterly wrong, it ain't no fun anymore. Please, before you make any statements about what figure in what religion represents what, take some time and read up on the topic.
This is what my cousin told me when he came over today. He has a collection of books by Edward Gibbon who wrote The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Gibbon, who was a sceptic of the organized religions, made an assessment of the Muslim religion and says that Mohamed made these claims about himself.
I admit to being ignorant about it somewhat. Most of what I know comes from books by and about Richard F. Burton, and Lawrence of Arabia and stories about Chinese Gordon, and some other writers from the nineteenth century who lived with them, mainly by being captured.
 
Last edited:
What does it say about god's inerrant word that the bible can be translated in two ways that have opposite meanings? My answer is that the implication is that the english version set in our current culture is meaningless.
What it means is that the Septuagint was written in a later time, as a translation from the Hebrew, into the Greek, by people who seem to have it in for the women in the Bible. The problem is that all the English translations of this verse follow the Septuagint which puts in autav, which comes out as "for yourselves".
My opinion is that before making up your mind about what a particular verse means, especially if it has anything to do with women, look at the Hebrew. I see no reason whatsoever for the addition of autav at the end of the verse, other than to make the girls seem, by the translators, like objects to be possessed, which does not seem like an obvious reading of the original.
 
Last edited:
Oh, well that makes the whole thing just dandy. Phew!
I am sure to be criticized for my version, since this is one of the favorite verses of god bashers as an example of where God approves of rape.
There is some killing going on which some people might take issue with. And there might be some rape going on here and there in different parts of the Bible, but I think using this one does not hold up.
 
There is some killing going on which some people might take issue with. And there might be some rape going on here and there in different parts of the Bible, but I think using this one does not hold up.
Oh, well that makes the whole thing just dandy. Phew!



To coin a phrase. :)
 
There is some killing going on which some people might take issue with. And there might be some rape going on here and there in different parts of the Bible, but I think using this one does not hold up.

"'Tis but a flesh wound!"
 
So, even if your "opposite" translation of Numbers were true, Ethnikos, are you really okay with a god who asked his followers to: kill all the men, kill all the married women, kill all the male children, and keep the virgin females as celibate housepets? Are you working on a translation where there's no killing or is that harder to ignore because of its frequency?
One of the reasons I go on religious forums is to get some inspiration about what sort of stuff I should study. Unless you are challenged, it is easy to sit back and think you know everything you ever need to know. For some reason I have not been too concerned about all the killing too much. I can come up with three reasons why that might be. It's in the past. It was necessary to set up a nation dedicated to God for, besides other reasons, a savior to come from. Jesus established an apocalyptic era, where the gates are opened to the nations, for admission into the kingdom.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom