The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

Originally Posted by Ethnikos
Having intention to commit acts, regardless of the harm against others as a consequence, for no other purpose than for self gain.
BTW: That is the definition of your god as described in the Bible.
God has nothing to personally gain from things. He does have to maintain the integrity of his rule. If people are harmed in the process of what He has to allow to happen, it is for the better of everyone involved, in the long run, and for those we do not yet know about.
 
God has nothing to personally gain from things. He does have to maintain the integrity of his rule. If people are harmed in the process of what He has to allow to happen, it is for the better of everyone involved, in the long run, and for those we do not yet know about.

Ahhh, the old "God works in mysterious ways" bit... Moving on...
 
God has nothing to personally gain from things. He does have to maintain the integrity of his rule. If people are harmed in the process of what He has to allow to happen, it is for the better of everyone involved, in the long run, and for those we do not yet know about.

Pure speculations on your part, based on a lot of "if" and your picking and choosing from a very ambiguous and self-contradictory book ...
 
Kathy, I do commend you for answering at least part of my questions on what constitutes sin, and if we're all allegedly slaves to something beyond simply "being born human."

1. The Ten Commandments I broke all of them and am sorry for it.
Others have already addressed this, but I assume you have not committed murder. I personally haven't committed murder or adultery, and I do honor my parents. I don't worship or keep the sabbath, but I've also never lied in court. Oh, and I don't consider my neighbors' wives to be property, so I ignore that commandment entirely.

2. I was guilty of trying to please my flesh which has all kinds of sins attached to it. Did you read what I posted on Galatians 5:19-21? The acts of the sinful nature are obvious: sexual immorality, impurity and debauchery; idolatry and witchcraft; hatred, discord, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions, factions and envy; drunkenness, orgies, and the like. I warn you, as I did before, that those who live like this will not inherit the kingdom of God. The only one I never did experience on this list was orgies.
Do you honestly believe that everybody would be a drunken sexually-charged violent sorcerer if they didn't come to Jesus? I've never come to Jesus, and I'm also not guilty of most of the debauchery you listed here. I'm not going to say I'm perfect, not by any stretch, but I'm living a very mundane existence in the suburbs. No drinking, no orgies, no violent rages. Just working hard to help support my family, doing a bit of charity work, paying my taxes, staying faithful to my husband, reading books and doing my best to stay healthy. I'm sorry, but your magic man is not going to tell me that I'm evil for living my life in a very healthy and happy way, when I'm not hurting anybody.

Especially when your magic man promotes rape as a great reward. I haven't twisted any scriptures, and there's more than one instance of rape in the bible. If you think I've twisted the story of Abraham, Sarah, and Hagar, you tell me what I'm missing and how it would be somehow allowable for God to tell Abraham that he should impregnate his wife's servant. When you're done with that, maybe you can tell me how it's permissible that God impregnated Mary. We don't allow coaches and teachers to have sex with their students because the relationship can never be one of two equals. Are you going to tell me that Mary is somehow God's equal, or did he take advantage of their unequal relationship?
 
Do you honestly believe that everybody would be a drunken sexually-charged violent sorcerer if they didn't come to Jesus? I've never come to Jesus, and I'm also not guilty of most of the debauchery you listed here. I'm not going to say I'm perfect, not by any stretch, but I'm living a very mundane existence in the suburbs. No drinking, no orgies, no violent rages.

You're missing out!
 
And... people like KK and Ethnikos continue to show how evil religion can be. Now, I understand that people are asking them questions, but KK's determination that you can ONLY be a good person if worship and accept Jesus, and Ethnikos.. Well, I'm not ksure, save that he feels that HIS religion is the one pure God tested and approved worship, while all others are evil and Satanic.

I'm starting to lean heavily more towards 'No religion' as the sane choice.
 
If you are allowed to make up the definition, then why can't I?
I'm all for people coming up with their own definitions.
In fact, I think it is imperative.
That's my mission, I guess, if it could be put in so many words. Don't look at the version of what is really the remnants of what Christianity was, as presented to you by whoever may have been geographically closest to you, and think that's it, and that no other thinking is required. You need to deconstruct it and then put it all together, in your own mind by your best understanding that God, through the Holy Spirit, can assist you with.
You don't have to accept my version, just see that people can do such a thing, then do the same sort of thing yourself.
Being in the majority, when it comes to religion, is not a virtue. When you read the Bible, you see people like Noah, who was one out of millions, Abraham who was the only one in Ur who rightly knew god, and got out of that place, Moses did not stick with the Egyptian religion, Elijah felt he had to run off and live in a cave, Jesus was rejected by the supposedly religious, Paul was a virtual outcast even among the Christians.
 
I'm all for people coming up with their own definitions.
In fact, I think it is imperative.
That's my mission, I guess, if it could be put in so many words. Don't look at the version of what is really the remnants of what Christianity was, as presented to you by whoever may have been geographically closest to you, and think that's it, and that no other thinking is required. You need to deconstruct it and then put it all together, in your own mind by your best understanding that God, through the Holy Spirit, can assist you with.
You don't have to accept my version, just see that people can do such a thing, then do the same sort of thing yourself.
Being in the majority, when it comes to religion, is not a virtue. When you read the Bible, you see people like Noah, who was one out of millions, Abraham who was the only one in Ur who rightly knew god, and got out of that place, Moses did not stick with the Egyptian religion, Elijah felt he had to run off and live in a cave, Jesus was rejected by the supposedly religious, Paul was a virtual outcast even among the Christians.
Certainly, but why do I need to do this under the auspices of christianity?

In the bible, I can find god and/or Jesus condoning
1.) Slaughtering of babies
2.) Slavery
3.) Abuse and misstreatment of women
4.) genocide
5.) Revenge
6.) beating of slaves
7.) killing of children for mockery

The list goes on. Certainly there are good lessons in the bible, but there are good and bad lessons everywhere.

So, I say again, Why do I need christianity to define my morality? Indeed, I can define it in spite of it. And It seems to me that most christians do as well.
 
Only as quoted by Christian writers.

Well, you're missing out.

The point is that the Bible does not have a monopoly on moral philosophy. In fact, why did you snip this bit of my post:

"More to the point, what do you think the United States of America bases its legal system on? It certainly isn't the bible - there are plenty of things that the bible expressly forbids that are permitted in the USA, plenty of punishments the bible calls for that the USA does not implement, and plenty of things the bible is fine with that the USA thinks are rather illegal.

That would suggest, would it not, that the basis of the legal system is something other than the Bible?"

No response?
 
Certainly, but why do I need to do this under the auspices of christianity?
3.) Abuse and mistreatment of women
The list goes on. Certainly there are good lessons in the bible, but there are good and bad lessons everywhere.
So, I say again, Why do I need christianity to define my morality? Indeed, I can define it in spite of it. And It seems to me that most christians do as well.
This (3) is the thing I was arguing about on the "teachings" thread. Genesis 3:16 is a verse people make out as God's great curse on womankind, or whatever. I do not get that from it, the great "I will do this" thing that is putting words into God's mouth. You can google for examples of how there were places in the Old Testament that were deliberately mistranslated to change it from where women had equal status with men, in a lot of aspects. What I mean is that one should not blame God for some things that were manipulated in the religion much after the fact.
Jesus tried to rectify some of the bias, as in the story of the woman taken in adultery. He pointed out that they were equally guilty, if they were judged equally. So, to me, the superiority of Christianity is in the fact that it has Jesus in it.
 
That would suggest, would it not, that the basis of the legal system is something other than the Bible?"

No response?
The actual system could be borrowed from the Romans, as evidenced by all the Latin legal terms. A lot of stuff comes from English Common Law. A lot of the ideas of right and wrong comes from the Bible, including the Supreme Court ruling supporting the "christian sabbath" Sunday laws.
 
You did not go on to read more. Jesus never condoned slavery, but he did warn people if they owed people they would go into captivity or if they turned from his ways they would not be protected anymore from evil men who would take them captive. Quit blaming God for peoples sins that get them in trouble as sin surely has consequences in everyones lives.

God is quite clearly the source of all sin.

What about the real issue being sin? Can't you see how people are enslaved by it?

Enslaved by your own actions ? How does that work ?

Jesus taught turn the other cheek and love your enemies

Wasn't that Buddha ?
 
The actual system could be borrowed from the Romans, as evidenced by all the Latin legal terms. A lot of stuff comes from English Common Law. A lot of the ideas of right and wrong comes from the Bible, including the Supreme Court ruling supporting the "christian sabbath" Sunday laws.

Wait, what? Are you reading what you're responding to? What are you talking about? What does that have to do with my post?

I'll ask again: How can the legal system be "based on the Bible", when it permits things the bible forbids and forbids things the Bible permits? Does that not prove that it is perfectly possible for a legal system to be extra-Biblical? Does that not prove that whatever the "source" of the American legal system is, it certainly isn't the Bible? Does it not expressly demonstrate that moral and legal philosophy is not reliant on the Bible at all?

PS: #1773?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom