The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

How about you tell us in what way God dictated the original text (which has become corrupted down the years) to a variety of different people? Was what was written down originally accurate? Having gone to that trouble, why does he choose to stand back and see his word altered and misinterpreted? Why has he stopped talking directly? Since you believe the god of the Jews is not your god, why do you not dismiss the Old Testament?
I doubt that God dictated much Himself, other than what was given directly to the prophets in vision. Even with that, as seen by the testimony of Daniel and John the Revelator, God still had to send an angel to explain what it was they saw.
As for accuracy, something that should be looked at is the Book of Genesis. It is likely something that stated out as a history that came out of Egypt with the Israelites. Moses would have time to sit down with God and go over it to correct any inaccuracies that may have been in it.
It may be that the important thing was to get the word out at all, even if it was not entirely accurate in some translations. It could always be fixed later.
The church decided that there should be a cut off for additions to the canon with the last of the writings that could be attributed to the Apostles. This does not mean God stopped speaking directly to people but these revelations do not bear the same force of authority as the Apostolic writings.
I am Arian, and being such, branded as a heretic by the "Church" and worthy of hell fire. I do not subscribe to the Athanasian Creed or take their day. That being said, I am under no delusion of being a Jew, hence the name Ethnikos, which is the Greek word in the New Testament for gentiles.
 
Last edited:
I am actually trying to be more literal. If you look at old languages you see they are not simpler, but more complex. Like the example I gave where there are 80 words that can be translated as eat, in the Hebrew.

Ethnikos,

Out of many of your outrageous claims you said that there are over (or around) 80 different words for 'eat' in the Hebrew language. I have never heard of this.

As far as I know, there's only 'ochel' which is spelled with an alef, chaf, and lamed. And then there's 'sova', I guess. Please cite your source where they list perhaps 20+ of these words?

Also, why don't you mull over this cliche, overused quote.

"I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours"

When you can disprove Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, Judaism, etc. then perhaps people will listen to what you have to say.

I mean you could have at least picked one of those religions instead of Christianity. I think we can all agree that out of all the religions Christianity is definitely the lamest and most boring. (Just look at church services!)
 
People in general do not do the picking. In the case of the Israelites, God appeared and spoke his day, then did miracles to illustrate that he meant what He said. On either side of that day, you find another day, representing another religion, and, in my opinion, another god.
Yes, people DO do the picking. Could you give us the source for the statement that God appeared and "spoke his day"? Then prove that God exists.
“And the LORD said unto Moses, Lo, I come unto thee in a thick cloud, that the people may hear when I speak with thee, and believe thee for ever. . . And mount Sinai was altogether on a smoke, because the LORD descended upon it in fire: and the smoke thereof ascended as the smoke of a furnace, and the whole mount quaked greatly. . . And God spake all these words, saying, I am the LORD thy God, which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt. . . the seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD thy God. . .”
He set a day as a sign between Him and His people.
How so?
“. . .my sabbaths ye shall keep: for it is a sign between me and you throughout your generations; that ye may know that I am the LORD that doth sanctify you.”
God's plan seems to not be completely successful on account of lapses into idolatry.
Examples.
Ahab and Jezebel adopted idolatry. Later kings followed that example until God allowed them to be destroyed.
No. God exists, as in the (what passes for a-) name, I Am.
What? No he doesn't. And what does that sentence even mean?
God is not a being, in the normal sense of the word. There is something of a substance involved with being a being, which God would not have, since He created everything, and so must have existed before there was a such thing as substance.
The so-called name of God, to me is an anti-name. There is a verse (in the Apocrypha) were an angel tells someone, “If I told you my name, you would not understand it.”
 
Last edited:
If you noticed, God's plan broke down pretty much right away, as soon as it was placed into human hands.
And this all-knowing so-called god didn't know this from the start, in fact before the start. What a goof, just one goof-up after another. Needed I list them all, I think not.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
And this all-knowing so-called god didn't know this from the start, in fact before the start. What a goof, just one goof-up after another. Needed I list them all, I think not.

Which should bring us to ask who is the more foolish: the Fool, or the fools who follow Him? :D
 
**Notice: a bunch of criticism was snipped** *(just kidding. a bunch of helpful hints)*You also have a habit of ignoring posts which point out errors in yours; it is rude, if not actually dishonest.
Is this better?
**edit to make addition**
Not sure what you mean. I have a habit of deleting what I am not directly addressing. I suppose I could make an indication that I did.
Usually what I try to do is answer anything in the form of a question. If a post is not addressed to me specifically, I usually do not reply. I am not especially interested in a back and forth sort of argument about who is right, so I do not respond to a bunch of pure criticism. A lot of the criticism is understandable.
I do not want to be mean or rude so go ahead and point out if I am doing something wrong.
 
Last edited:
Ethnikos,
Out of many of your outrageous claims you said that there are over (or around) 80 different words for 'eat' in the Hebrew language. I have never heard of this.
As far as I know, there's only 'ochel' which is spelled with an alef, chaf, and lamed. And then there's 'sova', I guess. Please cite your source where they list perhaps 20+ of these words?
Also, why don't you mull over this cliche, overused quote.
"I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours"
When you can disprove Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, Judaism, etc. then perhaps people will listen to what you have to say.
I mean you could have at least picked one of those religions instead of Christianity. I think we can all agree that out of all the religions Christianity is definitely the lamest and most boring. (Just look at church services!)
Apparently there are a lot of things you can do with those three letters. Someone, I guess named Strong, decided all these words are somehow derived from the one root. 80 was an estimate. I think it is more like 116, if I counted right.
lkay, lkat, wlkat, lka, lkal, wlkay, wlkayw, lkatw, lkayw, hlkaw, lkaw, wlkaw, wlka, wlka, Mtlkaw, tlkaw, wnlkat, lwkal, lwka, ytlka, hnlkat, wnlkay, Mylka, Mylkah, tlka, lkan, ylka, Mlkat, Mlkay, ylkat, whtlka, lkwa, whlkay, whlkaw, hlkanw, Mtlka, wylka, hlkwa, ytlkaw, tlkah, Mlkaw, whlkat, lkab, ylkab, hnlkay, Nwlkay, lkah, lkahw, Mlkab, Klkat, wnlkanw, Mlkatw, hnlkatw, lkays, *ynlka {wnlka}, Mwlkat, Ktlka, ylkaw, lwkaw, whnlkaw, whlkanw, lkayh, ynlka, whlykayw, hylkwa, wmlkay, ytlkahw, hwlkay, Mytlkahw, hwlkaw, ynlkayw, tlkanh, wlkal, lykwa, Mklka, hswls, lkwah, lkam, lkak, wnlkab, lykam, *tlka {ytlka}, *lkal {lwkal}, Nwlkat, Mylkaw, lwkah, whlykahw, whlkahw, yntlka, whlkah, lkalw, whlka, Kytlkahw, Kylka, Kytlkah, wylkaw, Mxl, Mklkab, Mwlkaw, Klkayw, lkahm, Klka, wnlka, Mlkak, Mwlkayw, Mlkayw, hwlkayw, Mklkat, ytlkah, Mwlka, lykhl, Mwlkay, Klkamh, Mtlkah, *wlkaw {lwkaw}, lkanw, Mlykam
http://net.bible.org/strong.php?id=0398
These seem to be all straightforward transliterations.
I think the ancient writers used language differently than we do today, and apparently the Hebrews liked to make all kinds of variations on words.
Christianity might be boring and I try to keep mine pretty boring. I hate it when people try to hype it up to where it seems exciting.
 
Last edited:
Huh. I'm not an atheist, but I can't ever make my beliefs sound interesting enough to keep it up for 52 pages!! I think I'm going to work on other goals... like knitting a sweater from cat navel lint....
 
The so-called name of God, to me is an anti-name. There is a verse (in the Apocrypha) were an angel tells someone, “If I told you my name, you would not understand it.”

And in the old Superman comics there was a character from another dimension who brought bad luck to everybody, especially to Superman. His name was something like Zwpvrkflstc, and in order to get him to go back to his own dimension you had to trick him into saying his own name. And Superman's Fortress of Solitude is in the Arctic, and since the Arctic exists all of Superman is true.
 
And in the old Superman comics there was a character from another dimension who brought bad luck to everybody, especially to Superman. His name was something like Zwpvrkflstc, and in order to get him to go back to his own dimension you had to trick him into saying his own name. And Superman's Fortress of Solitude is in the Arctic, and since the Arctic exists all of Superman is true.
Saying it backwards and it was Mr. Mxyzptlk.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
...
As for accuracy, something that should be looked at is the Book of Genesis. It is likely something that stated out as a history that came out of Egypt with the Israelites. Moses would have time to sit down with God and go over it to correct any inaccuracies that may have been in it.
It may be that the important thing was to get the word out at all, even if it was not entirely accurate in some translations. It could always be fixed later.
...

http://www.infidels.org/library/modern/gerald_larue/otll/
"The literary history of the Bible can be said to have begun in the time of Solomon when two men, or groups of men, produced what was to become the nucleus of the Old Testament. One concentrated on the story of David, drawing, no doubt, from court records and other sources, to produce a rather matter-of-fact and intimate account of David's rise to power, the weaknesses and strengths of the man and his family, and the successful coup by which his son, Solomon, gained the throne. The other writer or writers delved into the oral and written traditions of the past to enrich the understanding of the present. Stories of patriarchal ancestors, songs and folk-tales of the tribes, explanations concerning the origin of the world, and accounts of the action of God in the affairs of men, were gathered and woven into a saga explaining how the nation Israel came to be, and how God, who had acted in the past on behalf of his chosen people, was acting in the present and could be counted upon to act in the future. The theologized tradition or "sacred history," as it has been called, was probably utilized in the festivals and cultic rites of the temple."
.
Moses is fictional.
The OT wasn't in written form before Solomon.
.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Book_of_Genesis
 
Last edited:
Huh. I'm not an atheist, but I can't ever make my beliefs sound interesting bizarre enough to keep it up for 52 pages!! I think I'm going to work on other goals... like knitting a sweater from cat navel lint....


My correction above is offered kindly. :)


If you want to acheive a 52-page thread of bizarre, you'll need to keep your real beliefs locked in a cupboard and make up some whacky stuff to post about.

Also don't forget that you'll need an ironyectomy before you begin.

I further note that you were asking for name suggestions for your theology. May I offer "Maianor"? It seems to "flow" better than Anewageist.


Having said all that, my own efforts to win converts for the Aten have been somewhat underwhelming (none), so my advice might require a second opinion.

The fact is, the Thorists seem to be making quite a good case in various threads that their belief system contains more truth than Christianity, and young Marduk is not without his fans as well.

It seems that the playing field is wide open, so good luck with your "ism" and welcome to the Bizarreum. ;)


Cheers,

Nepherkheperure Waenre Akhenaten

Whose name shall also be known as Dave.
 
Does the word "retrofit" mean anything to you at all, Ethnikos?
To me it means putting a part on that was not on the thing originally.
As friend of mine has pointed out: if I decide to back a horse in the 3:30 I have to make a specific prediction. I can quite see that neither I nor the bookie will know if my prediction is correct till after the race is run. But I do NOT see that the bookie is going to take my bet if I refuse to actually name the horse till after the race is run. And he is not going to pay me if I say "although I wrote Laughing Boy on my betting slip; and although Star of the East won the race; I still won because "Star of the East" is actually the true translation of "Laughing Boy" if you use this handy online translator in just the way I do
Prophecy in the Bible is not there in order for us to be able to make specific predictions about future events, in a way that could not done by ordinary means. It is meant to motivate people to change their behavior in such a way as to avoid the more negative of the possible outcomes. If you read the Old Testament prophecies, you notice there are alternating negative and positive outcomes, almost from one verse to another. The same sort of thing is found in the New Testament prophecies but they are not so closely alternating. If you continue in idolatry, this bad thing will happen. If you return to God, these good things will happen.
There are some notable exceptions. Elijah easily comes to mind. This may be a reason why the Jews in Jesus' time expected Elijah to come to save things for them. He declared that he had the power to stop the rain.
'Now Elijah the Tishbite, who was of the settlers of Gilead, said to Ahab, "As the LORD, the God of Israel lives, before whom I stand, surely there shall be neither dew nor rain these years, except by my word."'
The phrase, before whom I stand, is significant because this is the position of the Messiah, as found in the Jewish writings from before Jesus' appearing on the scene. So Elijah was more a prototypical Messiah than an ordinary prophet. He did not just predict things but made them happen.
 
And in the old Superman comics there was a character from another dimension who brought bad luck to everybody, especially to Superman. His name was something like Zwpvrkflstc, and in order to get him to go back to his own dimension you had to trick him into saying his own name. And Superman's Fortress of Solitude is in the Arctic, and since the Arctic exists all of Superman is true.
That's sort of the thing. God does want people to imagine they can get a handle on Him through his name. The fact that He does not have a proper name is to indicate that he is the ultimate power and that no one has power over Him.
 
Huh. I'm not an atheist, but I can't ever make my beliefs sound interesting enough to keep it up for 52 pages!! I think I'm going to work on other goals... like knitting a sweater from cat navel lint....

Good idea and more productive. At least you can keep someone warm. :D
 
Last edited:
That's sort of the thing. God does want people to imagine they can get a handle on Him through his name. The fact that He does not have a proper name is to indicate that he is the ultimate power and that no one has power over Him.


No, no, no. That's Zorro you're thinking of there. Or maybe Spiderman.
 
My correction above is offered kindly. :)


If you want to acheive a 52-page thread of bizarre, you'll need to keep your real beliefs locked in a cupboard and make up some whacky stuff to post about.

Also don't forget that you'll need an ironyectomy before you begin.

I further note that you were asking for name suggestions for your theology. May I offer "Maianor"? It seems to "flow" better than Anewageist.



/QUOTE]

I LOVE Maianor!! :) Thanks.

It may take awhile to work out the theology. However, it will be based on the Goddess Maia, who flits about scattering flowers from an apron and wearing one of those flowing Grecian gowns with gold trimming. Lots of pagan rituals will be involved, especially fertility rites, and worship will be based on a film of great artistic merit I've long pondered. The plot of this film would be a little thin, but nude jello-wrestling, Robert Pattinson,and Tom Felton would be involved. In fact, I've often thought about a "Robert Pattinson's Butt" religion, but that's another thread. ;) All meant in good fun, satire, parody, and no offense whatsoever intended to Warner Brothers or whoever those two actors have signed away their souls to.
 
I LOVE Maianor!! :) Thanks.

It may take awhile to work out the theology. However, it will be based on the Goddess Maia, who flits about scattering flowers from an apron and wearing one of those flowing Grecian gowns with gold trimming. Lots of pagan rituals will be involved, especially fertility rites, and worship will be based on a film of great artistic merit I've long pondered. The plot of this film would be a little thin, but nude jello-wrestling, Robert Pattinson,and Tom Felton would be involved. In fact, I've often thought about a "Robert Pattinson's Butt" religion, but that's another thread. ;) All meant in good fun, satire, parody, and no offense whatsoever intended to Warner Brothers or whoever those two actors have signed away their souls to.


Good try, but not bizarre enough.

Now, throw in Colin Firth... ;)
 
Council of Nicea

Anyone studied that carefully?
I shall put here the history. I apologize for it's length. It will run to three posts, but I consider it important to get at the truth about Christianity:

The whole of the bible seems to be rehashes of fables from other religions from places like Sumer, Assyria,, Babylon, Egypt, and the Greek people. What makes the BIblegod true and all other gods false? Why does the Roman Catholic Church claim it is the "One True Church". Lets look at the founding of the Roman Catholic Church.

The New Testament is a FORGERY on the orders of Constantine I

What the Church doesn't want you to know
It has often been emphasised that Christianity is unlike any other religion, for it stands or falls by certain events which are alleged to have occurred during a short period of time some 20 centuries ago. Those stories are presented in the New Testament, and as new evidence is revealed it will become clear that they do not represent historical realities. The Church agrees, saying:
"Our documentary sources of knowledge about the origins of Christianity and its earliest development are chiefly the New Testament Scriptures, the authenticity of which we must, to a great extent, take for granted."
(Catholic Encyclopedia, Farley ed., vol. iii, p. 712)
Edited by Tricky: 
This appears to be lifted, mostly verbatum, from this site.
http://www.exminister.org/Forgedorigins_ofNT.html
Accordingly, it has been edited as per the membership agreement to a significant part and the link is added if anyone wants to read the whole thing.

Rule 6 of the Membership agreement stipulates that you will not "spam" or "flood" the forum. While it acceptable to cut and paste a reasonable amount from other websites, long articles, even if you are the author of the article, are not considered "reasonable". Anyone who wants to read them can follow the links. Check the footnotes to the Membership Agreement if you need clarification.

Thank you
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 
Last edited by a moderator:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom