The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

This is my interpretation, after reading John Gill's commentary. http://www.studylight.org/com/geb/view.cgi?book=zec&chapter=014&verse=002
This might not be especially helpful, but go ahead and check it out.

I tried, but he just does the same thing you seem to be doing: making up whatever fits, so he gets the "interpretation" he wants.

The first verse he quotes is very plain, but he qualifies it for no reason, save to make it fit what he wants it to fit. The verse says "all nations," and he says "meaning, not the Romans." What? How do you get "except for these guys" from an absolute statement of "all nations?"

No, sorry, but that's not an acceptable source.

Since I found this really nice tool, NetBible, that breaks down the word eat into like 80 different spellings in the Hebrew. You can click on the one form used in the verse in question and, in this case, find all 16 verses in the Bible that uses the same strict spelling. The 15 other verses use the word in the most literal sense possible. That causes me to reject the given translation of enjoyment.
Guess so, I was focused on this one verse mostly.

I made a chart to use with NetBible to understand the system of transliteration they use to represent the Hebrew characters into normal Latin letters. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=216&pictureid=1404

All you've really done is offer more proof that the bible is a collection of fully human and fully flawed writings. The Creator of the universe should be able to be so clear as to need no "interpretation."
 
You say it should be two separate sentences when other, more experienced scholars disagree. Why should we listen to you?
Don't. Here is a link to the page this verse is on.
http://net.bible.org/verse.php?book=Deu&chapter=20&verse=14
NetBible does a transliteration from the original. I have a chart I made to figure out what it means. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=216&pictureid=1404
Look where it says HEBREWand start at the bottom right and read to the left and up, starting at qr(20:14). Put your cursor over 07535 and translation hints pop up. Or click on it and look for the spelling that matches the one in the verse, to see how it is translated in other verses.
Here is where you can read it in the original.http://biblos.com/deuteronomy/20-14.htm
I think with today's knowledge and internet tools available, we can do a decent job of making our own translations.
 
No. I am pretty sure the form that the Old Testament is in today in the Hebrew did not happen before the time of Moses, quite a bit later than the tower of Babel.

Sorry to say, but to me it's quite obvious that your reading comprehension is pretty nonexistent. Maybe you can guess what that means for any attempt by you to read and interpret anything in your bible.

See, it's quite simple. It is said that god inspired men to write his words in a book called the bible. He caused Babylon, so that people speak different languages. That means that whatever was written or meant had to be translated. Since he is directly responsible for all these things, one would assume that he knew what he did, and what that means when it comes to translating the bible. However, it's quite obvious that he failed miserably to inspire people to get an translation right.

Do you really fail to see that this just doesn't make sense? If that god is so omnipotent, and all knowing, how comes he didn't take steps to prevent these wrong translations? After all he is the reason that translations are needed at all.

I guess the thing is not that you don't get it, but that you don't want to get it.

Greetings,

Chris
 
In the old mesopotamian world you could find a temple, like a ziggurat, having several levels, each representing a planet or god, seven in number.
Source, please.
In some cultures, the Sun and Moon have also been counted as planets, to make the seven classical planets, as well as the names of the seven days of the week - Sun-day, Moon-day, Saturn-day, and in Latin, 'Martis' (Mars, Tuesday), 'Mercurii' (Wednesday), 'Iovis' (Jupiter, Thursday) and 'Veneris' (Venus, Friday).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naked-eye_planet
In Roman times you find a planet or god represented in one of seven days of the week. Looking at today's week, you find three gods being represented three different days. Friday for Allah, Saturday for yAhwEh, Sunday for "Christianity?".
Yeah? So? What does it matter what DAY people pick to worship their god on? It doesn't mean it's a different god.
People in general do not do the picking. In the case of the Israelites, God appeared and spoke his day, then did miracles to illustrate that he meant what He said. On either side of that day, you find another day, representing another religion, and, in my opinion, another god.
None of these can be right because they all demonstrate a degree of rebellion. The first says, god is not like person who could get tired and need to rest. The second says, we do not accept this version of the Messiah. The third says, watching for the sunrise reminds us of Christ raising from the tomb, and the day of the sun replaces the Sabbath of the Jews.
How does it say any of this? The day chosen for worship matters nothing; the methods of timekeeping have changed since Jesus' time. I think. Correct me if I'm wrong.
The method of timekeeping, when it comes to weeks, is by using the names of the planets and the gods they represent. The fact that they are invested with supernatural powers guarantees that the week will not be tampered with, since the adherents of said gods would not allow it.
The significance of a day is that there is one real God. He set a day as a sign between Him and His people. A made up god has a day other than that because the very purpose of having a fake god is to divert attention from the real God. Having two extra days means two extra gods in my opinion. I just happen to be biased toward the God that Jesus had.
 
Last edited:
What are you talking about?
The original texts, that later became part of the Bible, have to have been written some time. I was just trying to point out that they most likely all, and at least most, would have been written after God confused the languages at the tower of Babel.
 
For some reason I decided it might be useful to eliminate the possibility that we both could be right, first.

Well, yes, Beth already eliminated that one.

However, you've done nothing to acknowledge that both you and Ahmed could be wrong.
 
I get it! So it's sort of like a Chinese take-out menu. You have 80 choices for one word, 66 choices for another, and 58 for yet another. You choose the ones you like! I understand. That being said, I'd like wonton soup, pork fried rice, kung pou chicken and almond cookies for dessert. :)
No. What I mean is there is a specific word that is written out in a verse. What I happen to think is useful in figuring out what otherwise might be a rather obscure reference, is the ability that this NetBible system has of directing you to the verses that have that exact same word in it, rather than the old concordance method which can group together 80 different words under one listing, without any further division.
You don't just pick one out at random that you like. You look at how the word, that is strictly the same, is used in other verses, and understand why it is translated the way it is.
 
Sorry to say, but to me it's quite obvious that your reading comprehension is pretty nonexistent.
. . .
I guess the thing is not that you don't get it, but that you don't want to get it.
I understood you but I wanted to establish a few facts first.
God intended to establish a nation of priests. There should have been an unbroken chain of knowledge passed down through these dedicated people to always retain the integrity of the proper understanding of the scripture. God's plan seems to not be completely successful on account of lapses into idolatry. If it had been completely successful, we could just look it up and see it exactly as it was written and having perfect understanding of all the words in it. Sadly this is not the case, so we have to do the best we can with what we have.
This is because of our own failing, as humans, and is another in the list of evil things in the world, caused by the falling for the deception of Satan by our earliest predecessors.
 
Last edited:
No, sorry, but that's not an acceptable source.
If you find an author who somehow knows exactly what all these sort of verses mean, you can pretty much bet he is speaking for Satan. Real people just do not have perfect understanding of how to interpret these. The greatest prophet, Daniel could not understand even what he was prophesying himself, perfectly.
 
No. What I mean is there is a specific word that is written out in a verse. What I happen to think is useful in figuring out what otherwise might be a rather obscure reference, is the ability that this NetBible system has of directing you to the verses that have that exact same word in it, rather than the old concordance method which can group together 80 different words under one listing, without any further division.
You don't just pick one out at random that you like. You look at how the word, that is strictly the same, is used in other verses, and understand why it is translated the way it is.

Still seems like you're picking and choosing what meanings you like. As you believe in the Tower of Babble, how is it that God could not arrange things so that translations could be accurate? That the meaning of the Word would not be clearly understood? Why have so many Christians interpreted the Bible in so many ways? If God is truly all knowing, couldn't he have forseen this problem. Why make it obscure? If it is the Truth and the Way, why disguise it?

If so, seems like God didn't want us to understand his message. He wanted us to scrape through the muck and the ooze to find meaning. Pretty nice loving god eh?
 
At the risk of a derail, I thought Jesus was god. Aren't god, jesus and the holy bedsheet just three different manifestations of the same entity?
No. God exists, as in the (what passes for a-) name, I Am. So it might be safe to say God is an entity. The He and Him and His thing is a convention but should not be taken as an admission that we understand what it is exactly that God is.
Jesus obviously is a person and is definable at least in his human nature aspect. There is not something about the person Jesus that would make him less than fully human. Being a human, he subjected himself to the undefinable God.
 
God's plan seems to not be completely successful on account of lapses into idolatry. If it had been completely successful, we could just look it up and see it exactly as it was written and having perfect understanding of all the words in it. Sadly this is not the case, so we have to do the best we can with what we have.

So, you just admitted that he is imperfect, can't follow his own plans, and is definitely not omnipotent.

In short, he failed. Doesn't sound godly to me. In fact, it sounds human. Which, of course, is no surprise, because the whole thing is made up by humans.

Now, how does that compute with Christianity being the one and true cult? I would say it doesn't compute at all. However, since all religions have these flaws when you take them under evaluation, it's no surprise to me.

Greetings,

Chris
 
If you find an author who somehow knows exactly what all these sort of verses mean, you can pretty much bet he is speaking for Satan.

Dude, do you even realize what gibberish you spill out here? You claim that some god has caused some book to be written, that is supposed to be his words. You say that people need to understand these words. However, as soon as they do understand it, they speak for Satan?

Well, that would in fact mean that the Bible does not come from some god, but from some evil being?

Real people just do not have perfect understanding of how to interpret these. The greatest prophet, Daniel could not understand even what he was prophesying himself, perfectly.

If that is the case, and if the bible is supposed to be his word, then he simply failed big time in getting his word through.

In the end it looks more and more like what it really is: some fantasy book written by some dudes who simply want to drive a cult forward, in an attempt to control people.

Think about that for a while.

Greetings,

Chris
 
So, either God is impotent, stupid, or is purposefully allowing himself to be misinterpreted. Or maybe that's a false trichotomy; he could be any two or all three.

Either way, I remain unimpressed.
 
I have decided to translate it "the ability to live in such a way", making it more of a noun than a verb.

How convenient. Are there any other passages whose litteral interpretation you choose to ignore ? And how do you go about determining how it should translate, other than gut feeling ?

Also, how exactly does it make it any better ? God still orders the massacre of thousands.

And, excuse me, but your interpretation doesn't work. It doesn't make any sense in the context. Sure, it allows you to sleep at night by ignoring that monstrous chapter, but it doesn't mesh.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom