The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

Yes, someone did mention this to me. This quote of mine was something I wrote in response to a proposition that the world would be better off if there was no god, or if people would just stop thinking there was a god.
Even if you look at Hammurabi, his code was given to him by the sun god, Shamash. My contention is that men make laws and substantiate their legitimacy through the supposed approval of some sort of divine deity.

So, you're trying to have it both ways, again?
 
I don't think common law works like that
I thought about that. Common law came out of a very Christian culture and we get the US Constitution that is written in the language of common law that says things like "endowed by our creator".
 
The point I was trying to make is something like what Rush Limbaugh says, "Words mean things."

[derail]Except that Rush is an idiot who doesn't understand communication theory. Words don't mean jack-all. People mean. Words are symbolic and are assigned meaning by people within a particular context. Take, for example, the terms white, black and power. By themselves they don't mean much, and only convey very general concepts. Put them together and provide a context such as the US and you get something vastly different: White Power, Black Power. Given cultural signifigance as assigned by people in the US, and you get two very charged terms . . . but only as assigned by people conveying meaning, and then interpreted by other people.

Words don't mean.[/derail]

Different forms of words in some languages have slightly different meanings as modified by additional letters. What I was trying to get at is that there is no good reason to take the word, in this verse being examined, to mean to enjoy, when every other verse the strictly spelled same word is always used to mean eat, in the most literal sense possible.

Absolutely agreed . . . and this is the problem with religious interpretation of the Bible as a free-for-all when it comes to terminology: when do we interpret an author's intent as literal and when do we interpret it as figurative? If it suits my needs to interpret a particular phrase literally in one place and then figuratively in another, I can completely change the entire meaning of a particular set of scriptures. Evidence may suggests a particular interpretation, but there is no way to be certain, which leads us back to the road of cherry-picking (even best-intentioned cherry-picking) what we like and interpreting in any fashion that suits our particular interests.

At the end of the day it leaves a religious document in complete shambles as far as general understanding of the message.
 
I thought about that. Common law came out of a very Christian culture and we get the US Constitution that is written in the language of common law that says things like "endowed by our creator".
You buy into that BS don't you.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
So, you're trying to have it both ways, again?
It could sound that way because I am trying to not recognize other gods as being The God. It could be that some laws were influenced by The God, even if the people involved attributed their inspiration to a named god of their choice.
 
Ethnikos said:
I thought about that. Common law came out of a very Christian culture and we get the US Constitution that is written in the language of common law that says things like "endowed by our creator".

I don't think that is true of Scandinavia, for example
 
I thought about that. Common law came out of a very Christian culture

What 'very Christian culture' do you mean?

ETA:
and we get the US Constitution that is written in the language of common law that says things like "endowed by our creator".
Where in the Constitution does it say that?
 
Last edited:
Like so many American's Ethnikos, you don't know your US Constitution from The Declaration of Independence. And it is "that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights" that is in The Declaration of Independence.

Paul

:) :) :)

Now, not having a Creator, I am endowed by ME.
 
Last edited:
It could sound that way because I am trying to not recognize other gods as being The God. It could be that some laws were influenced by The God, even if the people involved attributed their inspiration to a named god of their choice.

I'm curious as to what the difference is between "The God" and "a named god of their choice"? If I call "The God" by any other name, isn't He still Him? Is the name for God important for proper association?
 
It could sound that way because I am trying to not recognize other gods as being The God. It could be that some laws were influenced by The God, even if the people involved attributed their inspiration to a named god of their choice.

Let's rewind to the beginning of this. The original exchange was:

Ethnikos said:
If there was no god, would you rape, murder or rob?
If there was no god who takes vengeance on perpetrators of heinous crimes, you could have groups of outraged citizens out for blood.

Followed by:
Ethnikos said:
In civilised countries, we have a police force and a court system.
What would they base their legal system on, if there was no Bible? Maybe it would end up as, murder someone, pay a fine. Some people might be reluctant to trust in the system to deal out adequate justice and do some home made justice, themselves.

After it was pointed out that current law in the US is at odds with the bible, and that there are many countries who have or had systems of law defined completely in isolation from the bible, you come back with:
Yes, someone did mention this to me. This quote of mine was something I wrote in response to a proposition that the world would be better off if there was no god, or if people would just stop thinking there was a god.
That is not an accurate summary of what you were replying to. Luckily we can read for ourselves what was actually said.

Even if you look at Hammurabi, his code was given to him by the sun god, Shamash. My contention is that men make laws and substantiate their legitimacy through the supposed approval of some sort of divine deity.

(I would not disagree with the bolded part, btw.)

Could you clarify whether you believe the bible is in any way proof of the existence of God? If so, how does it differ from the code of Hammurabi? How can you determine your god is so different from all the others you freely admit to be false?
 
[derail]Except that Rush is an idiot who doesn't understand communication theory. Words don't mean jack-all. People mean. Words are symbolic and are assigned meaning by people within a particular context. Take, for example, the terms white, black and power. By themselves they don't mean much, and only convey very general concepts. Put them together and provide a context such as the US and you get something vastly different: White Power, Black Power. Given cultural significance as assigned by people in the US, and you get two very charged terms . . . but only as assigned by people conveying meaning, and then interpreted by other people.

Words don't mean.[/derail]
Concepts. When is a word conveying a concept, and when is it just conveying a particular color? (as in your example) The Greek language is great for concepts, like Logos, for example, where there are huge philosophies centering on that one word. You have the mention of that word in John 1:1 and it brings to mind all sorts of meanings.
In English, black and white can have a lot of connotations, so there should be a context to narrow down the intended meaning. It seems to me that the Hebrew is not like that so much. If it was, it would be impossible to know what that context was, because of how far we are removed from the milieu of contextual information. As it is, even with the much more recent New Testament, there are difficulties in understanding what the context really is. I think the Old Testament uses a more direct way of developing meaning by creating a context by making comparisons with known things or events.


Absolutely agreed . . . and this is the problem with religious interpretation of the Bible as a free-for-all when it comes to terminology: when do we interpret an author's intent as literal and when do we interpret it as figurative? If it suits my needs to interpret a particular phrase literally in one place and then figuratively in another, I can completely change the entire meaning of a particular set of scriptures. Evidence may suggests a particular interpretation, but there is no way to be certain, which leads us back to the road of cherry-picking (even best-intentioned cherry-picking) what we like and interpreting in any fashion that suits our particular interests.

At the end of the day it leaves a religious document in complete shambles as far as general understanding of the message.
You can get into some amusing discussions with preachers over interpreting Revelation. "Well you are trying to make it sound like it is symbolic!" And? as if the whole thing is not.
Cherry picking can be useful on a personal level and is called for in eventualities where it can give encouragement to hold up to persecution. Making the results of your cherry picking into a dogma is where it falls down.
 
Last edited:
Like so many American's Ethnikos, you don't know your US Constitution from The Declaration of Independence. And it is "that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights" that is in The Declaration of Independence.

Paul

:) :) :)
.
The lack of even a hint of an education in history is rampant in the ramblings here of E, and kk, and y and all those absolutists.
If they'd ever Google anything they'd find out about the rest of the world, not just the closet they've walled themselves in and preach from.
 
I don't think that is true of Scandinavia, for example
I know about English common law. Like the Magna Carta and King John and the desire for natural, or god given rights. I do not know about Scandinavian common law.
 
Concepts. When is a word conveying a concept, and when is it just conveying a particular color? (as in your example) The Greek language is great for concepts, like Logos, for example, where there are huge philosophies centering on that one word.

Actually, the philosophies don't center on that word, but on the application of that word. Greek sophists used it to mean simple discourse. Aristotle defined it as argument through reason.

You have the mention of that word in John 1:1 and it brings to mind all sorts of meanings.

Which is the exact problem with the Rush Limbaugh quote. Words don't mean. People mean. John's use of the term logos, as adopted by Philo means the incarnation of the source of all things. If Philo and Aristotle had a conversation about logos, they'd have been talking about two very different things.

In English, black and white can have a lot of connotations, so there should be a context to narrow down the intended meaning. It seems to me that the Hebrew is not like that so much. If it was, it would be impossible to know what that context was, because of how far we are removed from the milieu of contextual information. As it is, even with the much more recent New Testament, there are difficulties in understanding what the context really is. I think the Old Testament uses a more direct way of developing meaning by creating a context by making comparisons with known things or events.

What's your point?

You can get into some amusing discussions with preachers over interpreting Revelation. "Well you are trying to make it sound like it is symbolic!" And? as if the whole thing is not.

Depends on who you ask now, doesn't it?

Cherry picking can be useful on a personal level and is called for in eventualities where it can give encouragement to hold up to persecution. Making the results of your cherry picking into a dogma is where it falls down.

So only personal interpretation is valid?
 
Last edited:
Without meaning to be offensive, Ethnikos, I get the overwhelming impression that you do not know very much outside a narrow milieu. You have shown you are prepared to make quite big claims on the basis of little knowledge and I do not think this is doing your case any good.
 
I'm curious as to what the difference is between "The God" and "a named god of their choice"? If I call "The God" by any other name, isn't He still Him? Is the name for God important for proper association?
What's a name? And what is an idol? They are creations of your own hand. You chop down a tree. Some of it you burn and part of it you carve into a figure and worship it. You go through steps like kill a sheep and skin it and make a parchment and then put down characters of your devising onto the parchment, then worship it.
These are both idolatry.
 
What's a name? And what is an idol? They are creations of your own hand. You chop down a tree. Some of it you burn and part of it you carve into a figure and worship it. You go through steps like kill a sheep and skin it and make a parchment and then put down characters of your devising onto the parchment, then worship it.
These are both idolatry.

None of this has anything to do with the question I asked. If you call your god "The God" and I call mine "Allah" or "Jehovah" or "Yehweh" or "Bob", what's the difference?
 
What's a name? And what is an idol? They are creations of your own hand. You chop down a tree. Some of it you burn and part of it you carve into a figure and worship it. You go through steps like kill a sheep and skin it and make a parchment and then put down characters of your devising onto the parchment, then worship it.
Or stick two pieces together in a cruciform shape?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom