The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

Council of Nicea (cont)

The First Council of Nicaea and the "missing records"

Thus, the first ecclesiastical gathering in history was summoned and is today known as the Council of Nicaea. It was a bizarre event that provided many details of early clerical thinking and presents a clear picture of the intellectual climate prevailing at the time. It was at this gathering that Christianity was born, and the ramifications of decisions made at the time are difficult to calculate. About four years prior to chairing the Council, Constantine had been initiated into the religious order of Sol Invictus, one of the two thriving cults that regarded the Sun as the one and only Supreme God (the other was Mithraism). Because of his Sun worship, he instructed Eusebius to convene the first of three sittings on the summer solstice, 21 June 325 (Catholic Encyclopedia, New Edition, vol. i, p. 792), and it was "held in a hall in Osius's palace" (Ecclesiastical History, Bishop Louis Dupin, Paris, 1686, vol. i, p. 598). In an account of the proceedings of the conclave of presbyters gathered at Nicaea, Sabinius, Bishop of Hereclea, who was in attendance, said, "Excepting Constantine himself and Eusebius Pamphilius, they were a set of illiterate, simple creatures who understood nothing" (Secrets of the Christian Fathers, Bishop J. W. Sergerus, 1685, 1897 reprint).
Edited by Tricky: 
This appears to be lifted, mostly verbatum, from this site.
http://www.exminister.org/Forgedorigins_ofNT.html
Accordingly, it has been edited as per the membership agreement to a significant part and the link is added if anyone wants to read the whole thing.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Council of Nicea (cont)

Forgery in the Gospels
When the New Testament in the Sinai Bible is compared with a modern-day New Testament, a staggering 14,800 editorial alterations can be identified. These amendments can be recognised by a simple comparative exercise that anybody can and should do. Serious study of Christian origins must emanate from the Sinai Bible's version of the New Testament, not modern editions.
Of importance is the fact that the Sinaiticus carries three Gospels since rejected: the Shepherd of Hermas (written by two resurrected ghosts, Charinus and Lenthius), the Missive of Barnabas and the Odes of Solomon. Space excludes elaboration on these bizarre writings and also discussion on dilemmas associated with translation variations.
Edited by Tricky: 
This appears to be lifted, mostly verbatum, from this site.
http://www.exminister.org/Forgedorigins_ofNT.html
Accordingly, it has been edited as per the membership agreement to a significant part and the link is added if anyone wants to read the whole thing.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Is this better?
**edit to make addition**
Not sure what you mean. I have a habit of deleting what I am not directly addressing. I suppose I could make an indication that I did.
Usually what I try to do is answer anything in the form of a question. If a post is not addressed to me specifically, I usually do not reply. I am not especially interested in a back and forth sort of argument about who is right, so I do not respond to a bunch of pure criticism. A lot of the criticism is understandable.
I do not want to be mean or rude so go ahead and point out if I am doing something wrong.

To give one example, you said
What would they base their legal system on, if there was no Bible? Maybe it would end up as, murder someone, pay a fine. Some people might be reluctant to trust in the system to deal out adequate justice and do some home made justice, themselves.

To which several people replied with counter-examples, none of which I recall you acknowledging.
 
I LOVE Maianor!! :) Thanks.

It may take awhile to work out the theology. However, it will be based on the Goddess Maia, who flits about scattering flowers from an apron and wearing one of those flowing Grecian gowns with gold trimming. Lots of pagan rituals will be involved, especially fertility rites, and worship will be based on a film of great artistic merit I've long pondered. The plot of this film would be a little thin, but nude jello-wrestling, Robert Pattinson,and Tom Felton would be involved. In fact, I've often thought about a "Robert Pattinson's Butt" religion, but that's another thread. ;) All meant in good fun, satire, parody, and no offense whatsoever intended to Warner Brothers or whoever those two actors have signed away their souls to.


We are just so going to get along. :)
 
Future events written about in a figurative way may have to be fulfilled before they can be properly understood. ...
:eye-poppi

Okay, let me ask you a question, if I may. Do you believe horoscopes are often accurate simply because they are good predictions, or because they're carefully written in such a way that they can almost always be "properly understood" after the events have transpired?

Also, if 'retrofitting' doesn't ring a bell, how about 'confirmation bias'?

[SNIP!!!]

..."em hotep"
Eccles, I'm going out on a limb here, and assume you're not the author of this text. If that is correct, then these posts are against forum rules. The right way to do this is to quote some relevant paragraphs and provide a link to the original document.
 
Last edited:
lkay, lkat, wlkat, lka, lkal, wlkay, wlkayw, lkatw, lkayw, hlkaw, lkaw, wlkaw, wlka, wlka, Mtlkaw, tlkaw, wnlkat, lwkal, lwka, ytlka, hnlkat, wnlkay, Mylka, Mylkah, tlka, lkan, ylka, Mlkat, Mlkay, ylkat, whtlka, lkwa, whlkay, whlkaw, hlkanw, Mtlka, wylka, hlkwa, ytlkaw, tlkah, Mlkaw, whlkat, lkab, ylkab, hnlkay, Nwlkay, lkah, lkahw, Mlkab, Klkat, wnlkanw, Mlkatw, hnlkatw, lkays, *ynlka {wnlka}, Mwlkat, Ktlka, ylkaw, lwkaw, whnlkaw, whlkanw, lkayh, ynlka, whlykayw, hylkwa, wmlkay, ytlkahw, hwlkay, Mytlkahw, hwlkaw, ynlkayw, tlkanh, wlkal, lykwa, Mklka, hswls, lkwah, lkam, lkak, wnlkab, lykam, *tlka {ytlka}, *lkal {lwkal}, Nwlkat, Mylkaw, lwkah, whlykahw, whlkahw, yntlka, whlkah, lkalw, whlka, Kytlkahw, Kylka, Kytlkah, wylkaw, Mxl, Mklkab, Mwlkaw, Klkayw, lkahm, Klka, wnlka, Mlkak, Mwlkayw, Mlkayw, hwlkayw, Mklkat, ytlkah, Mwlka, lykhl, Mwlkay, Klkamh, Mtlkah, *wlkaw {lwkaw}, lkanw, Mlykam

Excellent! Now we can safely reinterpret the bible however we want. Yay for personalised faiths!
 
That's sort of the thing. God does want people to imagine they can get a handle on Him through his name. The fact that He does not have a proper name is to indicate that he is the ultimate power and that no one has power over Him.

How do you have power over something with a name ?
 
Ethnikos said:
lkay, lkat, wlkat, lka, lkal, wlkay, wlkayw, lkatw, lkayw, hlkaw, lkaw, wlkaw, wlka, wlka, Mtlkaw, tlkaw, wnlkat, lwkal, lwka, ytlka, hnlkat, wnlkay, Mylka, Mylkah, tlka, lkan, ylka, Mlkat, Mlkay, ylkat, whtlka, lkwa, whlkay, whlkaw, hlkanw, Mtlka, wylka, hlkwa, ytlkaw, tlkah, Mlkaw, whlkat, lkab, ylkab, hnlkay, Nwlkay, lkah, lkahw, Mlkab, Klkat, wnlkanw, Mlkatw, hnlkatw, lkays, *ynlka {wnlka}, Mwlkat, Ktlka, ylkaw, lwkaw, whnlkaw, whlkanw, lkayh, ynlka, whlykayw, hylkwa, wmlkay, ytlkahw, hwlkay, Mytlkahw, hwlkaw, ynlkayw, tlkanh, wlkal, lykwa, Mklka, hswls, lkwah, lkam, lkak, wnlkab, lykam, *tlka {ytlka}, *lkal {lwkal}, Nwlkat, Mylkaw, lwkah, whlykahw, whlkahw, yntlka, whlkah, lkalw, whlka, Kytlkahw, Kylka, Kytlkah, wylkaw, Mxl, Mklkab, Mwlkaw, Klkayw, lkahm, Klka, wnlka, Mlkak, Mwlkayw, Mlkayw, hwlkayw, Mklkat, ytlkah, Mwlka, lykhl, Mwlkay, Klkamh, Mtlkah, *wlkaw {lwkaw}, lkanw, Mlykam
This kind of makes me wonder whether any vocalization in ancient Hebrew didn't mean something? By the look of it though a bunch of them look like different spellings of the same word - Mylka,Mylkah,ylka,.... I bet if you trawled all the different spellings of the same word in 400 in Ye Olde English you'd come up with quite a decent sized list (lyst,liste,lyste,layst....). Is this proof of anything other than in the olden days nobody cared much about how words were spelled?
 
How do you have power over something with a name ?

When I was a New-Age whack-a-doo, I ran into this superstition a lot. I don't know where it originates or what cultures believe(d) it, but the basic idea is that to know someone's name is to have power over him. It's supposed to be especially so in the case of gods or spirits. The example of this "power" in its simplest form is to note that when someone calls your name, you respond. (duh.) This superstition would account for why we do not know the name of the christian god, and why we must not take his name in vain. Of course, since we don't know his name, we can't take it in vain.

As a young smart-arse, I usually wise-cracked that "God" is not his name. It's his title. So I can say "goddamn" all I like. :p

ETA: I believe the notion also exists that you cannot summon a demon or djiin unless you know its name.
 
Last edited:
What would they base their legal system on, if there was no Bible? Maybe it would end up as, murder someone, pay a fine. Some people might be reluctant to trust in the system to deal out adequate justice and do some home made justice, themselves.

Has anyone told you yet that several legal systems existed long before your bible was written?

It's as if you think humans have no minds or emotions until and unless they've read your book.

Ethnikos, is murder wrong only because your god told you not to do it?
If your god had said murder is okey-dokey with him, would you smile as someone killed your child, and thank him for it afterwards?
 
This kind of makes me wonder whether any vocalization in ancient Hebrew didn't mean something? By the look of it though a bunch of them look like different spellings of the same word - Mylka,Mylkah,ylka,.... I bet if you trawled all the different spellings of the same word in 400 in Ye Olde English you'd come up with quite a decent sized list (lyst,liste,lyste,layst....). Is this proof of anything other than in the olden days nobody cared much about how words were spelled?
Glockjaw was right on post #2042 that the word eat in Hebrew is based on the three letters, alef, chaf, and lamed. If you use my chart on my profile picture album, you see that these are transliterated as a, k, and l in this list of words. So the core word is akl, or in the list, since it is Hebrew, it looks like this: lka. (remember these are read right to left)
In your above example, two of the three words you quote have an M at the end (left hand, which is the end of the word in hebrew). That usualy indicates the plural.
The addition of a prefix or a suffix can indicate the tense.
Then there are other properties, like gender, person, voice (7 of those), and mode. Then there are 8 different conjugations.
All this gets a little involved, so the easy way for me, until I get better at it, is to use the method I described earlier, which is to look at the verses that use the spelling of the word in question. These are easily found using the NetBible tool. You just click on the right one out of the 116 different spellings and see how, (in the case of the one in Deuteronomy 20:14) in the 15 other verses, it is used.
 
Last edited:
There are some notable exceptions. Elijah easily comes to mind. This may be a reason why the Jews in Jesus' time expected Elijah to come to save things for them. He declared that he had the power to stop the rain.
'Now Elijah the Tishbite, who was of the settlers of Gilead, said to Ahab, "As the LORD, the God of Israel lives, before whom I stand, surely there shall be neither dew nor rain these years, except by my word."'
The phrase, before whom I stand, is significant because this is the position of the Messiah, as found in the Jewish writings from before Jesus' appearing on the scene. So Elijah was more a prototypical Messiah than an ordinary prophet. He did not just predict things but made them happen.

Glendower:
I can call spirits from the vasty deep.

Hotspur:
Why, so can I, or so can any man;
But will they come when you do call for them?
 
Glockjaw was right on post #2042 that the word eat in Hebrew is based on the three letters, alef, chaf, and lamed. If you use my chart on my profile picture album, you see that these are transliterated as a, k, and l in this list of words. So the core word is akl, or in the list, since it is Hebrew, it looks like this: lka. (remember these are read right to left)
In your above example, two of the three words you quote have an M at the end (left hand, which is the end of the word in hebrew). That usualy indicates the plural.
The addition of a prefix or a suffix can indicate the tense.
Then there are other properties, like gender, person, voice (7 of those), and mode. Then there are 8 different conjugations.
All this gets a little involved, so the easy way for me, until I get better at it, is to use the method I described earlier, which is to look at the verses that use the spelling of the word in question. These are easily found using the NetBible tool. You just click on the right one out of the 116 different spellings and see how, (in the case of the one in Deuteronomy 20:14) in the 15 other verses, it is used.
But you're using this to back up a claim that:
"If you look at old languages you see they are not simpler, but more complex."
on the basis that there are more words for 'eat', and I'm sure similar words. What makes you think that word counting like this is a good indication of the complexity or otherwise of a language? Is complexity a good thing? Under your criteria, English was probably quite a bit more complex in Shakespeare's time than today. It could be that having lots of words is a consequence of the language being unable to cope with expressing new concepts using existing vocabulary, or an obsession with linguistic showing off. It could be the result of needless complexity arising from having a ridiculous number of tenses and modifying the verb with every single one.

Your overall observation could be the result of complex languages being more likely to die off because people just couldn't be bothered. If there is any evidence that old languages are more complex than modern ones I would be interested to hear about it. I suspect it would be a next to impossible task to make meaningful comparative statements about the relative complexity of modern languages, let alone ancient ones, that weren't hopelessly subjective.
 
But you're using this to back up a claim that:
"If you look at old languages you see they are not simpler, but more complex."
on the basis that there are more words for 'eat', and I'm sure similar words. What makes you think that word counting like this is a good indication of the complexity or otherwise of a language? Is complexity a good thing? Under your criteria, English was probably quite a bit more complex in Shakespeare's time than today. It could be that having lots of words is a consequence of the language being unable to cope with expressing new concepts using existing vocabulary, or an obsession with linguistic showing off. It could be the result of needless complexity arising from having a ridiculous number of tenses and modifying the verb with every single one.

Your overall observation could be the result of complex languages being more likely to die off because people just couldn't be bothered. If there is any evidence that old languages are more complex than modern ones I would be interested to hear about it. I suspect it would be a next to impossible task to make meaningful comparative statements about the relative complexity of modern languages, let alone ancient ones, that weren't hopelessly subjective.
The point I was trying to make is something like what Rush Limbaugh says, "Words mean things." Different forms of words in some languages have slightly different meanings as modified by additional letters. What I was trying to get at is that there is no good reason to take the word, in this verse being examined, to mean to enjoy, when every other verse the strictly spelled same word is always used to mean eat, in the most literal sense possible.
 
ETA: I believe the notion also exists that you cannot summon a demon or djiin unless you know its name.
Indeed. Even made it into an episode of the BBC series The Young Ones where Rik(?) accidentally calls up a demon (Ftumch) by reading a misprint in a newspaper article. Boring_(Young_Ones_episode)WP
 
The point I was trying to make is something like what Rush Limbaugh says, "Words mean things." Different forms of words in some languages have slightly different meanings as modified by additional letters. What I was trying to get at is that there is no good reason to take the word, in this verse being examined, to mean to enjoy, when every other verse the strictly spelled same word is always used to mean eat, in the most literal sense possible.
But surely this ignores context? Programs like BabelFish translate in the manner you're describing. Have you ever passed a given text through BabelFish and had it translate it back?

the first line of your quote translated to Greek and back becomes:
babelfish said:
Is the subject that I tried to offend something as what hurried Limbaugh does say, "? Do the words mean things."?

I've no idea where the 'offend' comes from. That's a new meaning introduced by this process.

Here's what I'd be concerned about. Are you investigating alternative meanings across the board, or just where you are uncomfortable with the standard translation? By ignoring the context in the original language and choosing your meaning by an alternative method, a decent percentage of the time you are going to find a new meaning which, since you didn't like the original, probably seems to you like an improvement.
 
Has anyone told you yet that several legal systems existed long before your bible was written?
It's as if you think humans have no minds or emotions until and unless they've read your book.
Ethnikos, is murder wrong only because your god told you not to do it?
If your god had said murder is okey-dokey with him, would you smile as someone killed your child, and thank him for it afterwards?
Yes, someone did mention this to me. This quote of mine was something I wrote in response to a proposition that the world would be better off if there was no god, or if people would just stop thinking there was a god.
Even if you look at Hammurabi, his code was given to him by the sun god, Shamash. My contention is that men make laws and substantiate their legitimacy through the supposed approval of some sort of divine deity.
 
But surely this ignores context? Programs like BabelFish translate in the manner you're describing. Have you ever passed a given text through BabelFish and had it translate it back?
Here's what I'd be concerned about. Are you investigating alternative meanings across the board, or just where you are uncomfortable with the standard translation? By ignoring the context in the original language and choosing your meaning by an alternative method, a decent percentage of the time you are going to find a new meaning which, since you didn't like the original, probably seems to you like an improvement.
There is a web side that purports to have a program that translates the Hebrew in Bible verses into English. I tried it a while back and was not impressed.
There is a principle of using the context to understand the meaning, but that only works in the Greek. That is because of how that language is structured. In the Hebrew, you can isolate a word and know what it means by how it is spelled. So, you have two different approaches to translating the Bible, between the Old Testament and the New testament; word structure (in the first), and context (in the second).
The "just where you are uncomfortable with the standard translation" answer would be the most correct.
I've looked at a site where they have "evil meters" for different verses to indicate where places in the Bible show how bad God is. To me it is very sad that people fall for these tricks. If your very soul depended on how you react to these accusations, don't you think it might be a good idea to closely examine those verses? Or are you like what I am accused of, just accepting whatever seems to reinforce what you already believe. (I don't mean you, personally, just a figure of speech)

BTW: I did a google search using "why is Christianity right". Since I have been eating of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil at JREF, I had to look askance at what I found. Pretty pathetic, and their arguments would not hold up to rebuttal. I also found out at "10 reasons why Christianity is wrong" that I am a good argument against Christianity. Number three is the argument that what passes today for Christianity today, in no way can be what it originally was. Then he mentions the Council of Nicea, where we got the Athanasian Creed from. I would say that at least one out of a thousand Christians would say they believe in the old religion.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom