The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

I am sure to be criticized for my version, since this is one of the favorite verses of god bashers as an example of where God approves of rape.

Well you can't blame the "god bashers", can you ? It says so in the book.

What's funny about fundies and litteralists is that they always interpret the bible more than atheists.
 
You appear to be asking the impossible, Christian Klippel. Although I did not realise it before, Ethnikos does not know anything about at least one other religion.

Of course. It would be much harder to believe in a particular fairie if he was aware of other possibles fairies or <gasp> the possible absence of fairies.
 
No. I am trying to get back to why I started posting on this thread and that was to tell stories about how God helped people, me included. D.'s story had Jesus helping him to realize life can be good, and not to let it slip away. So, his personal experience would, for him, affirm the truthfulness of his belief in Jesus.

Uh-huh, except that no. There are tons of ways to discover that, and many of them have nothing to do with religion.

I think what people here are asking of you is evidence that your specific religion is TRUE. You are on a skeptics forum, in case you haven't noticed.
 
The method of timekeeping, when it comes to weeks, is by using the names of the planets and the gods they represent. The fact that they are invested with supernatural powers guarantees that the week will not be tampered with, since the adherents of said gods would not allow it.

"The fact that they are invested with supernatural powers"? Please tell us more.
The significance of a day is that there is one real God. He set a day as a sign between Him and His people.
Which real God do you mean? The one that had a day set aside in the Old Testament, or the same one which Christians worship on the next day?
A made up god has a day other than that because the very purpose of having a fake god is to divert attention from the real God.
So, a special day means that the god is real. It also means the god is fake?
Having two extra days means two extra gods in my opinion. I just happen to be biased toward the God that Jesus had.

You do realise that the days of the week in English are all named for gods, none of them the Abrahamic god?

Do you read what you write?
 
Don't. Here is a link to the page this verse is on.
http://net.bible.org/verse.php?book=Deu&chapter=20&verse=14
NetBible does a transliteration from the original. I have a chart I made to figure out what it means. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=216&pictureid=1404
Look where it says HEBREWand start at the bottom right and read to the left and up, starting at qr(20:14). Put your cursor over 07535 and translation hints pop up. Or click on it and look for the spelling that matches the one in the verse, to see how it is translated in other verses.
Here is where you can read it in the original.http://biblos.com/deuteronomy/20-14.htm
I think with today's knowledge and internet tools available, we can do a decent job of making our own translations.


Fascinating.

How about you tell us in what way God dictated the original text (which has become corrupted down the years) to a variety of different people? Was what was written down originally accurate? Having gone to that trouble, why does he choose to stand back and see his word altered and misinterpreted? Why has he stopped talking directly? Since you believe the god of the Jews is not your god, why do you not dismiss the Old Testament?
 
Make up your mind, Kathy. Is Jesus dead or isn't he? If he isn't dead, he didn't die for our sins or anything else.
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naked-eye_planet

This says nothing about seven-level ziggurats, just that the ancient civilizations believed the planets to be gods.

People in general do not do the picking. In the case of the Israelites, God appeared and spoke his day, then did miracles to illustrate that he meant what He said. On either side of that day, you find another day, representing another religion, and, in my opinion, another god.

Yes, people DO do the picking. Could you give us the source for the statement that God appeared and "spoke his day"? Then prove that God exists.

The method of timekeeping, when it comes to weeks, is by using the names of the planets and the gods they represent.

Agreed. At least, it was before.

The fact that they are invested with supernatural powers guarantees that the week will not be tampered with, since the adherents of said gods would not allow it.

:cs: No. You think that the people in theological positions of power can't alter the week so that their god appears more powerful? No one would disagree, because these people are speaking the word of that god.

The significance of a day is that there is one real God.

How the hell do you reach that conclusion? There's not even ONE. Now you're claiming that there's SEVEN?

He set a day as a sign between Him and His people.

How so?

A made up god has a day other than that because the very purpose of having a fake god is to divert attention from the real God.

Okay, so these six (four? there's three of yours) OTHER gods are fake now. Then why did they appear and show miracles to their people and declare that THIS IS MY DAY?

Having two extra days means two extra gods in my opinion. I just happen to be biased toward the God that Jesus had.

Oy vey.

Ethnikos said:
I understood you but I wanted to establish a few facts first.
God intended to establish a nation of priests.

It would have died out pretty fast then.

There should have been an unbroken chain of knowledge passed down through these dedicated people to always retain the integrity of the proper understanding of the scripture.

Assuming that no one ever, ever changed the wording in the slightest. This is just a highly unlikely occurence.

God's plan seems to not be completely successful on account of lapses into idolatry.

Examples.

If it had been completely successful, we could just look it up and see it exactly as it was written and having perfect understanding of all the words in it.

Yes, but just because we understand it doesn't mean that it's holy, or that the practices encouraged by it are morally right, or that the god it describes is real.

Sadly this is not the case, so we have to do the best we can with what we have.

*nods*

This is because of our own failing, as humans, and is another in the list of evil things in the world, caused by the falling for the deception of Satan by our earliest predecessors.

This is because of God's failing, as an omnipotent being, to exist. And, once again, THE GARDEN OF EDEN IS DEMONSTRATABLY A PILE OF BULLS***.

Ethnikos said:
If you find an author who somehow knows exactly what all these sort of verses mean, you can pretty much bet he is speaking for Satan.

Oh, so the people who wrote them are speaking for Satan? Then why listen to them?

Real people just do not have perfect understanding of how to interpret these.

:notm

The greatest prophet, Daniel could not understand even what he was prophesying himself, perfectly.

Warning bells again. Think about what you just said.

Ethnikos said:
No. God exists, as in the (what passes for a-) name, I Am.

What? No he doesn't. And what does that sentence even mean?

So it might be safe to say God is an entity. The He and Him and His thing is a convention but should not be taken as an admission that we understand what it is exactly that God is.

He is a superstition.

Jesus obviously is a person and is definable at least in his human nature aspect.

Perhaps he was a person. But you are wrong in implying that there was anything other than the "human nature aspect". Give us proof.

There is not something about the person Jesus that would make him less than fully human. Being a human, he subjected himself to the undefinable God.

Congratulations! You just entirely avoided the statement!
 
So, you just admitted that he is imperfect, can't follow his own plans, and is definitely not omnipotent.
If you noticed, God's plan broke down pretty much right away, as soon as it was placed into human hands.
In short, he failed. Doesn't sound godly to me. In fact, it sounds human. Which, of course, is no surprise, because the whole thing is made up by humans.
The explanation is something I thought up, as far as the exact wording goes, and based on things I got from other people. That's just the way the world works. God gives suggestions but does not force the unwilling. God would like for humans to get involved in his plans but there is an opposing plan that gets a lot of recruits, enticed by instant gratification offered by Satan.
Now, how does that compute with Christianity being the one and true cult? I would say it doesn't compute at all. However, since all religions have these flaws when you take them under evaluation, it's no surprise to me.
There are sub-cults within the main cult who belong to Satan and promote a religion of gratification, which is idoatry.
 
Last edited:
If you noticed, God's plan broke down pretty much right away, as soon as it was placed into human hands.

I'd say it broke down at one of the following points:

- The first day of creation.
- The creation of Eve from Adam's rib, which left the human race with only two people TOTAL to be descended from, resulting in massive inbreeding. This amount of inbreeding would, of course, have eventually killed everyone off, so I just ignore the Garden story entire, but whatever.
- The planting of the Tree.
- Allowing the Snake into the Garden.
- Not putting some magic spell on the Tree to make sure it couldn't be touched.
- And on and on and on and on...


The explanation is something I thought up, as far as the exact wording goes, and based on things I got from other people. That's just the way the world works. God gives suggestions but does not force the unwilling.

That's not for lack of trying, though. Look at all the people preaching fire and brimstone...

God would like for humans to get involved in his plans but there is an opposing plan that gets a lot of recruits, enticed by instant gratification offered by Satan.

Who the hell defined "instant gratification" as evil in the first place? It ain't always bad.
Anyway, Christianity promises instant gratification in its own way (want to be born again? Sure, come on up!).


There are sub-cults within the main cult who belong to Satan and promote a religion of gratification, which is idoatry.

Examples. And no.

You continue to make outlandish claims while ignoring every argument put to you. And without presenting any evidence to support your claims.
 
Dude, do you even realize what gibberish you spill out here? You claim that some god has caused some book to be written, that is supposed to be his words. You say that people need to understand these words. However, as soon as they do understand it, they speak for Satan?
Future events written about in a figurative way may have to be fulfilled before they can be properly understood. There are people who would like for others to believe that they have a perfect understanding of a prophecy and how exactly they will be fulfilled. That can not be right because they were written with with a conditionality built into them, especially the Old testament variety. The Satan thing comes into play when you examine the motivation behind why someone would want others to believe their particular interpretation. Are they selling a book, or is someone paying him from some foundation to promote an agenda.
Well, that would in fact mean that the Bible does not come from some god, but from some evil being? If that is the case, and if the bible is supposed to be his word, then he simply failed big time in getting his word through.
I was giving Daniel as an example of how someone given the prophecy may not understand it themselves. Many of them he had were said to be understood later, once most had already been fulfilled. John the Revelator had further visions that build upon the ones Daniel had. Today, we have enough history behind us where we can have a better perspective about how they are being fulfilled in our time.
 
Last edited:
Ethnikos,

you still don't get the point, and by now it's pretty obvious that you make no attempt to get it. You avoid it like the pest. All you want to do is convincing people by using silly arguments. Pretty much the same as the senseless preaching that KK does. Guess such behavior comes as a special gift when someone decides to follow some of these stupid cults they call religion.

None of your outlandish rabulistics help you. I call you ignorant to reality.
 
Dude, do you even realize what gibberish you spill out here? You claim that some god has caused some book to be written, that is supposed to be his words. You say that people need to understand these words. However, as soon as they do understand it, they speak for Satan?

Well, that would in fact mean that the Bible does not come from some god, but from some evil being?



If that is the case, and if the bible is supposed to be his word, then he simply failed big time in getting his word through.

In the end it looks more and more like what it really is: some fantasy book written by some dudes who simply want to drive a cult forward, in an attempt to control people.

Think about that for a while.

Greetings,

Chris

You can take a horse to water,but you can't make it think.
 
I already have Jesus in my heart.

No. You believe you have Jesus in your heart. All other believers in other faiths have similar beliefs that are just as convincing to them. That you choose to believe that particular one when you know this shows that you are not interested in reality.
 
Does the word "retrofit" mean anything to you at all, Ethnikos?

As friend of mine has pointed out: if I decide to back a horse in the 3:30 I have to make a specific prediction. I can quite see that neither I nor the bookie will know if my prediction is correct till after the race is run. But I do NOT see that the bookie is going to take my bet if I refuse to actually name the horse till after the race is run. And he is not going to pay me if I say "although I wrote Laughing Boy on my betting slip; and although Star of the East won the race; I still won because "Star of the East" is actually the true translation of "Laughing Boy" if you use this handy online translator in just the way I do
 
Last edited:
How convenient. Are there any other passages whose literal interpretation you choose to ignore ? And how do you go about determining how it should translate, other than gut feeling ?
I am actually trying to be more literal. If you look at old languages you see they are not simpler, but more complex. Like the example I gave where there are 80 words that can be translated as eat, in the Hebrew. I think there might just be a reason for that. I am no expert so I look at how that one particular strict spelling of the word is used in other verses, with the goal of seeing how it gets used. In this example of the word life in the verse about what was to happen to the maidens, that one version of the word only appears in that one verse, making me think it has a special meaning.

Also, how exactly does it make it any better ? God still orders the massacre of thousands.
This verse is one used to prove God condones or orders the rape of young women or even children. That would be pretty disgusting if it was true.
 
As an aside, Pure Agent, please learn how to use the Quote button. It's fun, rewarding and you can earn bonus points redeemable at the House of Uri Geller.
 
Future events written about in a figurative way may have to be fulfilled before they can be properly understood. There are people who would like for others to believe that they have a perfect understanding of a prophecy and how exactly they will be fulfilled. That can not be right because they were written with with a conditionality built into them, especially the Old testament variety. The Satan thing comes into play when you examine the motivation behind why someone would want others to believe their particular interpretation. Are they selling a book, or is someone paying him from some foundation to promote an agenda.
I was giving Daniel as an example of how someone given the prophecy may not understand it themselves. Many of them he had were said to be understood later, once most had already been fulfilled. John the Revelator had further visions that build upon the ones Daniel had. Today, we have enough history behind us where we can have a better perspective about how they are being fulfilled in our time.

You might want to step back and examine the whole host of assumptions you are making. To mention just a few:

- Angels and Demons are real
- Prophecy is real
- The bible was actually somehow dictated by god
- Satan is real

Not to mention:
- God is real

You also have a habit of ignoring posts which point out errors in yours; it is rude, if not actually dishonest.
 
"The fact that they are invested with supernatural powers"? Please tell us more.
In the minds of the people who worship that particular god.
Which real God do you mean? The one that had a day set aside in the Old Testament, or the same one which Christians worship on the next day?
The God who showed up in person to establish a law. Interestingly, they made a definition of God with the Athanasian Creed about the same time that Sunday was adopted as an official day of rest. To me, a religion was invented that had the name but not the beliefs of an existing religion, then went about to crush the adherence to the traditional religion by instituting a new tradition. So you have a God of Abraham, and a "Christian" god, if you were to believe that what uses that name is truly Christian. I just happen to be highly skeptical.
So, a special day means that the god is real. It also means the god is fake?
Most people couldn't care less about technicalities in theology, so this argument would make no difference to them. I think it is something Satan is highly aware of, though, and uses any discrepancy to his advantage, even things that are true can be used to cause schisms and divide people. In the final outcome he will side with whatever is wrong.
You do realize that the days of the week in English are all named for gods, none of them the Abraham god?
Yes, I am. The Romans were very influential and affected the naming of the days by others. The point is, there was no switching of days to match different planets. The associations between a day and a planet stuck, from earliest recorded history, to now. There are ancient texts of people thinking that Jews believed in Saturn.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom