The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

A few others have already addressed this post, but I'd like to have a go at some of the points I don't see mentioned:

Zechariah 14 is a prophecy about some apocalyptic events associated with what we would think of as Armageddon. It is allegorical and may be describing how the pure religion is misused and abused by false religion. The raping is a way of making a mental picture of how truth is treated by the world religion of the future end times.
Deuteronomy 20:14, as quoted, is not the best translation, in my opinion. I worked on it for some time and came up with one I think is better.

I love how any time you find a biblical passage that you personally don't like, or that doesn't fit with your personally perfect religion, you:

1) claim that it was interpreted incorrectly by the evil church
2) claim that your interpretation is 'better' when you have no true scholarly experience translating (and have been shown to translate inaccurately before).
3) post a translation that really, truly doesn't even change the meaning of the passage (here, I'll show you some examples: )

Deuteronomy 20:10-14 said:
As you approach a town to attack it, first offer its people terms for peace. If they accept your terms and open the gates to you, then all the people inside will serve you in forced labor. But if they refuse to make peace and prepare to fight, you must attack the town. When the LORD your God hands it over to you, kill every man in the town. But you may keep for yourselves all the women, children, livestock, and other plunder. You may enjoy the spoils of your enemies that the LORD your God has given you.."

Ethnikos said:
Deuteronomy 20:14, as quoted, is not the best translation, in my opinion. I worked on it for some time and came up with one I think is better.

"Certainly the women and the children and the cattle of the city, all the plunder is to be seized for yourselves. Eat the goods of the enemy, that God gives to you."

Some other translations have it sounding like, "grab the women for your enjoyment." which is wrong because it should be two separate sentences, and the word ואכלת means literally to eat. To me this is another example of the translators being influenced by a flawed Greek translation from the original.
Now, note first of all that the first phrase of your translation makes utterly no sense on it's own (dependent clause), so we look to the second half of the sentence for clarification or we can simply rearrange the phrases as such:

all the plunder is to be seized for yourselves, certainly the women and the children and the cattle of the city.
Now that we have a more intelligible sentence, lets analyze what it's saying. In your sentence, women and children are lumped in with other property (cattle) and are awarded as plunder to the conquering 'heroes.' That would entail slavery (I could stretch this to reach rape as masters raping slaves was not unheard of *cough*Abraham*cough*). So, your reinterpretation of the first sentence still has God ordering the 'chosen people' to take and own slaves.

Judges 5:30 said:
They must be dividing the spoils they took: there must be a damsel or two for each man, Spoils of dyed cloth as Sisera's spoil, an ornate shawl or two for me in the spoil.
Ethnikos said:
The story in Judges is from the song of Deborah describing the demise of the general of the enemy army that went to war against Israel. It is his mother waiting for him to come home and attributing his lateness to having to spend time dividing the spoils.
In no way, whatsoever, does his mother is waiting deny the fact that women being raped was considered part of the plunder. In fact, it rather hurts your position as it shows that it was considered normal and proper for women to be raped or, at the very least, considered property for dividing spoils of war - so, slavery or rape (and again, slavery generally brings rape with it), which one do you and your god advocate?

Zechariah 14:1-2 said:
Lo, a day shall come for the Lord when the spoils shall be divided in your midst. And I will gather all the nations against Jerusalem for battle: the city shall be taken, houses plundered, women ravished; half of the city shall go into exile, but the rest of the people shall not be removed from the city.
Ethnikos said:
Zechariah 14 is a prophecy about some apocalyptic events associated with what we would think of as Armageddon. It is allegorical and may be describing how the pure religion is misused and abused by false religion. The raping is a way of making a mental picture of how truth is treated by the world religion of the future end times.
Excuse me, what???
Show me the context in which this passage somehow is equated to truth being treated by the world religion of the future end times. That doesn't even make sense given a re-reading of the passage presented. The passage explicitly states that women will be ravished (ravished = rape, btw) and that the Lord is advocating this ravishment (rape). To take those two words as anything else would mean to completely extricate them from the current context (for example):

Lo, a day shall come for the Lord when the spoils shall be divided in your midst. And I will gather all the nations against Jerusalem for battle: the city shall be taken, houses plundered, truth will be treated by the world religion of the future end times as a woman ravished; half of the city shall go into exile, but the rest of the people shall not be removed from the city.

So, now we have 2 passages that advocate slavery (and the ensuing rape associated) and 1 passage that still advocates rape.
 
Ethnikos said:
Zechariah 14 is a prophecy about some apocalyptic events associated with what we would think of as Armageddon. It is allegorical and may be describing how the pure religion is misused and abused by false religion.

Prove that it's allegory and the rest of the Bible isn't. And prove that Christianity isn't a false religion.

The raping is a way of making a mental picture of how truth is treated by the world religion of the future end times.

Excuse me? What?

Deuteronomy 20:14, as quoted, is not the best translation, in my opinion. I worked on it for some time and came up with one I think is better.

"Certainly the women and the children and the cattle of the city, all the plunder is to be seized for yourselves. Eat the goods of the enemy, that God gives to you."

Okay, so now you're better at translating this stuff than scholars who devote their lives to it? And the first sentence of your translation doesn't make any sense, unless it means to give all the plunder to the women and children. And I doubt that's what it means.

Some other translations have it sounding like, "grab the women for your enjoyment." which is wrong because it should be two separate sentences, and the word ואכלת means literally to eat.

You say it should be two separate sentences when other, more experienced scholars disagree. Why should we listen to you?

To me this is another example of the translators being influenced by a flawed Greek translation from the original.

Please show the flawed Greek translation.

The story in Judges is from the song of Deborah describing the demise of the general of the enemy army that went to war against Israel. It is his mother waiting for him to come home and attributing his lateness to having to spend time dividing the spoils.
The other verse you quoted, I addressed in an earlier post, #1869.

I'm not experienced enough in scripture to address that last part, so I'll let the others do it - they know more than I do.
 
Huh? Look, if two absolutely competing claims are made, there are only two possibilities:
1. One is right and the other is wrong.
2. Both are wrong.
So if you say, "Jesus," and Achmed says, "Allah," then either:
1. Achmed is right and you are wrong.
2. You are right and Achmed is wrong.
3. BOTH of you are wrong.
What Volatile is asking you is, how do you know 2. is the correct resolution to the conflict, rather than 1. or 3.?
I disagree with the idea that Judaism, Christianity and Mohammedism share the same god. I think we end up with three different gods. In the old mesopotamian world you could find a temple, like a ziggurat, having several levels, each representing a planet or god, seven in number. In Roman times you find a planet or god represented in one of seven days of the week. Looking at today's week, you find three gods being represented three different days. Friday for Allah, Saturday for yhwh, Sunday for "Christianity?".
None of these can be right because they all demonstrate a degree of rebellion. The first says, god is not like person who could get tired and need to rest. The second says, we do not accept this version of the Messiah. The third says, watching for the sunrise reminds us of Christ raising from the tomb, and the day of the sun replaces the Sabbath of the Jews.
 
Ethnikos" said:
I disagree with the idea that Judaism, Christianity and Mohammedism share the same god. I think we end up with three different gods.

Why?

In the old mesopotamian world you could find a temple, like a ziggurat, having several levels, each representing a planet or god, seven in number.

Source, please.

In Roman times you find a planet or god represented in one of seven days of the week. Looking at today's week, you find three gods being represented three different days. Friday for Allah, Saturday for yAhwEh, Sunday for "Christianity?".

Yeah? So? What does it matter what DAY people pick to worship their god on? It doesn't mean it's a different god.

None of these can be right because they all demonstrate a degree of rebellion. The first says, god is not like person who could get tired and need to rest. The second says, we do not accept this version of the Messiah. The third says, watching for the sunrise reminds us of Christ raising from the tomb, and the day of the sun replaces the Sabbath of the Jews.

How does it say any of this? The day chosen for worship matters nothing; the methods of timekeeping have changed since Jesus' time. I think. Correct me if I'm wrong.

*required message outside the quotes: ignore*
 
I disagree with the idea that Judaism, Christianity and Mohammedism share the same god. I think we end up with three different gods. In the old mesopotamian world you could find a temple, like a ziggurat, having several levels, each representing a planet or god, seven in number. In Roman times you find a planet or god represented in one of seven days of the week. Looking at today's week, you find three gods being represented three different days. Friday for Allah, Saturday for yhwh, Sunday for "Christianity?".
None of these can be right because they all demonstrate a degree of rebellion. The first says, god is not like person who could get tired and need to rest. The second says, we do not accept this version of the Messiah. The third says, watching for the sunrise reminds us of Christ raising from the tomb, and the day of the sun replaces the Sabbath of the Jews.

:confused: What? What does any of this have to do with the question you were asked?
 
I disagree with the idea that Judaism, Christianity and Mohammedism share the same god. I think we end up with three different gods. In the old mesopotamian world you could find a temple, like a ziggurat, having several levels, each representing a planet or god, seven in number. In Roman times you find a planet or god represented in one of seven days of the week. Looking at today's week, you find three gods being represented three different days. Friday for Allah, Saturday for yhwh, Sunday for "Christianity?".
None of these can be right because they all demonstrate a degree of rebellion. The first says, god is not like person who could get tired and need to rest. The second says, we do not accept this version of the Messiah. The third says, watching for the sunrise reminds us of Christ raising from the tomb, and the day of the sun replaces the Sabbath of the Jews.


What on earth does THAT mean? :confused:
 
I disagree with the idea that Judaism, Christianity and Mohammedism share the same god. I think we end up with three different gods. In the old mesopotamian world you could find a temple, like a ziggurat, having several levels, each representing a planet or god, seven in number. In Roman times you find a planet or god represented in one of seven days of the week. Looking at today's week, you find three gods being represented three different days. Friday for Allah, Saturday for yhwh, Sunday for "Christianity?".
None of these can be right because they all demonstrate a degree of rebellion. The first says, god is not like person who could get tired and need to rest. The second says, we do not accept this version of the Messiah. The third says, watching for the sunrise reminds us of Christ raising from the tomb, and the day of the sun replaces the Sabbath of the Jews.
Unlike many on the JREF, I was raised with no religion. Even I know that Christianty and Islam regard themselves as deriving from the God of Abraham. They only worship different God's in the same sense that Mormons worship a different God to Quakers.
 
Ethnikos said:
I disagree with the idea that Judaism, Christianity and Mohammedism share the same god. I think we end up with three different gods.

You would be wrong.
 
And, once more, we see just how morally bankrupt the extreme members of the Evangelical crowd truly are.

As DOC, Kurious Kathy, and Ethnikos bleat about the evil that exists in this world, about the vile works of Satan, (things like Racial Equality, Gay Rights, Living Wages, and other abominations to their god), there would seem to be a few things missing in all of this.

The first thing I see lacking is any evidence that what they're declaring evil actually is evil. Quite the contrary, what I see is that when these kind of attitudes and actions are in play, this "evil" that they say we need to abandon, society tends to work a lot better. It's far from perfect, but I fail to see how denying someone rights they are not only guaranteed in the Constitution but in Natural Law has helped anyone...

Where has any Christians on this site spoke against Racial Equality, and Living Wages?

And it sounds like you believe evil exists even though I assume you are an atheist. What is your definition of evil if you are an atheist?
 
I disagree with the idea that Judaism, Christianity and Mohammedism share the same god. I think we end up with three different gods. In the old mesopotamian world you could find a temple, like a ziggurat, having several levels, each representing a planet or god, seven in number. In Roman times you find a planet or god represented in one of seven days of the week. Looking at today's week, you find three gods being represented three different days. Friday for Allah, Saturday for yhwh, Sunday for "Christianity?".
None of these can be right because they all demonstrate a degree of rebellion. The first says, god is not like person who could get tired and need to rest. The second says, we do not accept this version of the Messiah. The third says, watching for the sunrise reminds us of Christ raising from the tomb, and the day of the sun replaces the Sabbath of the Jews.

You make no sense. In addition, you do realize that most of the days were named for pagan gods don't you?

Origin of Names of Days

Sunday - ME sun(nen)day, OE sunnandaeg, translation of Latin dies Solis, "Day of the Sun"
Monday - ME mone(n)day, OE mondaeg, translation of Latin Lunae dies, "Day of the Moon"
Tuesday - ME tewesday, OE tiwesdaeg, OHG ziestac, Day of the war god Tiw, translation of the Latin dies Martis, "Day of Mars"
Wednesday - ME Wednesdai, OE wednesdaeg, mutated version of Wodnesdaeg, Woden's day, compare with Dutch Woensdag, Danish onsdag, translation of Latin Mercuru dies, Day of Mercury
Thursday - ME OE Thursdaeg from Norse Thursdagr, "Thor's day", Germanic translation of Latin dies Jovis.
Friday - ME OE Frigedaeg, "Freya's day"
Saturday - ME Saturdai, OE Saternesdaeg, partial translation of Latin Saturni dies, "Saturn's day

ME = Middle English
OE = Old English
OF = Old French
OHG = Old High German
 
Where has any Christians on this site spoke against Racial Equality, and Living Wages?

And it sounds like you believe evil exists even though I assume you are an atheist. What is your definition of evil if you are an atheist?

Almost the same as yours, except we accept that people alone are responsible for evil.

I can't say I care much for the word "evil" as a descriptor for wrongdoing or harm. It sounds superstitious to me, and fictive.

At any rate, I don't believe in any god or gods, and I know right from wrong.

Excuse me, my honey-roasted baby is ready to eat.
 
Where's the reference for this? I'd like to read the full article.
This is my interpretation, after reading John Gill's commentary. http://www.studylight.org/com/geb/view.cgi?book=zec&chapter=014&verse=002
This might not be especially helpful, but go ahead and check it out.
You're a translator?
Or do you mean, "That one sounds icky. I'll make it say something nicer"?
Since I found this really nice tool, NetBible, that breaks down the word eat into like 80 different spellings in the Hebrew. You can click on the one form used in the verse in question and, in this case, find all 16 verses in the Bible that uses the same strict spelling. The 15 other verses use the word in the most literal sense possible. That causes me to reject the given translation of enjoyment.
You missed the whole "forced labor" part, conveniently.
Guess so, I was focused on this one verse mostly.

I made a chart to use with NetBible to understand the system of transliteration they use to represent the Hebrew characters into normal Latin letters. http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=216&pictureid=1404
 
Last edited:
I can't say I care much for the word "evil" as a descriptor for wrongdoing or harm. It sounds superstitious to me, and fictive.

Superstitious isn't how I'd describe "good" and "evil." Rather, I dislike "evil" and "good" as descriptors as they denote black and white with very little room for shades of gray. After all, who decides what's "good" and what's "evil?" If it's the God of Abraham we're all in trouble because very few of us believe that all of what he/she/it promotes is actually "good" (reference my last post concerning rape/slavery for example).

"Good" and "evil" are, by their very definitions, subjective. Thus, we have laws. Not to determine "good" and "evil," per se, but to allow us a distinction between what is allowed and what is not.


Ethnikos says the "evil" will perish. But how can we know whom his God will consider evil? By the words found in the bible we can be pretty certain that the murdering rapist who uses war as an excuse has more of a chance to get into heaven than the straight laced fellow who does not partake in war, nor indulge in the spoils thereof.
 
You don't see the unresolvable discrepancy in what you just said, do you?
No. I am pretty sure the form that the Old Testament is in today in the Hebrew did not happen before the time of Moses, quite a bit later than the tower of Babel.
The translation into the Greek happened much later. Some scholars think that some of the earliest translations indicate there was another version of the Hebrew text that no longer exists, and this could explain some of the discrepancies between the Septuagint version and the Hebrew versions we have now. If that is true, the Greek is valuable for preserving the variations that we would not know about otherwise.
The medieval scribes seemed content with taking whatever Greek translations were available and translating that into Latin. The English translators seem to have worked mainly from the Latin versions from Erasmus to make the King James translation, that most later English versions seem to have been influenced by.
My opinion is that we will be able to make some improvements on our understanding of the scripture, and it is a worthwhile endeavor. I am not put off by the fact that it takes a little work, or that it was written in an archaic language.
 
Last edited:
Huh? Look, if two absolutely competing claims are made, there are only two possibilities:

1. One is right and the other is wrong.
2. Both are wrong.

So if you say, "Jesus," and Achmed says, "Allah," then either:

1. Achmed is right and you are wrong.
2. You are right and Achmed is wrong.
3. BOTH of you are wrong.

What Volatile is asking you is, how do you know 2. is the correct resolution to the conflict, rather than 1. or 3.?

I disagree with the idea that Judaism, Christianity and Mohammedism share the same god. I think we end up with three different gods. In the old mesopotamian world you could find a temple, like a ziggurat, having several levels, each representing a planet or god, seven in number. In Roman times you find a planet or god represented in one of seven days of the week. Looking at today's week, you find three gods being represented three different days. Friday for Allah, Saturday for yhwh, Sunday for "Christianity?".
None of these can be right because they all demonstrate a degree of rebellion. The first says, god is not like person who could get tired and need to rest. The second says, we do not accept this version of the Messiah. The third says, watching for the sunrise reminds us of Christ raising from the tomb, and the day of the sun replaces the Sabbath of the Jews.

A little problem with reading comprehension, there?

I'll try to make it even simpler:

You say, "Jesus."

Achmed says, "Allah."

The two statements contradict each other. Both you and Achmed offer supporting statements for your claims (no evidence, but supporting statements.)

So both you and Achmed can't be right. At least one of you MUST be wrong. It's possible that both of you could be wrong. So we have three possibilities:

1. Achmed is right and you are wrong; OR
2. You are right and Achmed is wrong; OR
3. Both you AND Achmed are wrong.

You say "2." Most of the participants in this discussion say "3." We are asking your reasons for picking Possibility No. 2 instead of Possibility No. 1 or Possibility No. 3.
 
No. I am pretty sure the form that the Old Testament is in today in the Hebrew did not happen before the time of Moses, quite a bit later than the tower of Babel.

What are you talking about?

http://www.bible-researcher.com/driver1.html


The earliest surviving form of the Hebrew text is perhaps that found in the Samaritan Pentateuch (Genesis–Deuteronomy). This text must date from a period before the secession of the Samaritans from Judaism, but it is preserved only in manuscripts the earliest of which is tentatively assigned to the eleventh century A.D.
<snip>

witness to the Hebrew text is provided by the Scrolls from Qumran, commonly called the Dead Sea Scrolls, dated c. 150 B.C. to A.D. 75 or thereabouts. These include fragments, often minute, of every book in the Old Testament except Esther, one complete scroll of Isaiah and another of which approximately half has been lost, and a commentary on the first two chapters of Habakkuk containing most of their text. All these agree essentially with the 'received text' of the Old Testament except for orthographic variations or occasional variant readings hardly affecting the sense, and so suggest that stabilization of text is already beginning. Fragments, however, of Samuel and one of Jeremiah have a shortened form of the text like that of the Septuagint in these books. The only other fragment of this period is that known as the Nash Papyrus, which cannot be exactly dated, containing two excerpts from the Law (Exodus 20.2–17 and Deuteronomy 6.4–5); its chief interest is that the words are more or less clearly spaced.

<snip>

Very few manuscripts are said to have survived the destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70. Soon after that disaster, therefore, the Jewish religious leaders set about defining the canon and finally standardizing the text. This last process went on for many centuries and resulted in the production of an eclectic text based on arbitrary rather than scientific principles. This was the Massoretic (so called from the Hebrew massorah, 'tradition') or traditional text found in all Hebrew Bibles.

<snip>

The Hebrew text as thus edited by the Massoretes became virtually a single recension probably remaining substantially unaltered from the second century A.D., but this text has not survived in any manuscripts dated before the ninth to eleventh centuries A.D.


The translation into the Greek happened much later.


The earliest version is the Greek translation made in Egypt in the third and second centuries B.C.
 
Last edited:
Well why then? Obviously this world has been affected by it and death is truly a reality because of it, so why do you choose not to believe in the concept of original sin?

Why do you choose to ignore the concept of original death? There's nothing you can do about it, except live a good life so that when the end comes you will understand why.


M.
 
Now, note first of all that the first phrase of your translation makes utterly no sense on it's own (dependent clause), so we look to the second half of the sentence for clarification or we can simply rearrange the phrases as such:
Thanks for fixing that. I didn't get around to putting it in good English and left it pretty much just word for word, in the original order. The main point I was trying to make is there are two separate complete thoughts in the verse.
So, your reinterpretation of the first sentence still has God ordering the 'chosen people' to take and own slaves.
Could be. Or possible future wives.
In no way, whatsoever, does his mother is waiting deny the fact that women being raped was considered part of the plunder. In fact, it rather hurts your position as it shows that it was considered normal and proper for women to be raped or, at the very least, considered property for dividing spoils of war - so, slavery or rape (and again, slavery generally brings rape with it), which one do you and your god advocate?
I think you missed my point. These were the people who expected to do that to the Israelites, and nothing to do with God ordering anything.
Excuse me, what???
Show me the context in which this passage somehow is equated to truth being treated by the world religion of the future end times. That doesn't even make sense given a re-reading of the passage presented. The passage explicitly states that women will be ravished (ravished = rape, btw) and that the Lord is advocating this ravishment (rape). To take those two words as anything else would mean to completely extricate them from the current context (for example):
My point was that there is no actual historical event that this prophecy corresponds to. It is a future apocalyptic event, as can be see from the phrase, The Day of The Lord. Such prophesies are notorious for being highly symbolic. I just happen to be biased in my interpretation, just like everyone else. God is not ordering for people to be raped. This is an indication of what sort of people it is who attack God's people.
So, now we have 2 passages that advocate slavery (and the ensuing rape associated) and 1 passage that still advocates rape.
No, you are flat out wrong. All you have are assumptions based on the most vile sort of people that you imagine, and not based on the actions of a godly people.
 
This might not be especially helpful, but go ahead and check it out.
Since I found this really nice tool, NetBible, that breaks down the word eat into like 80 different spellings in the Hebrew. You can click on the one form used in the verse in question and, in this case, find all 16 verses in the Bible that uses the same strict spelling. The 15 other verses use the word in the most literal sense possible. That causes me to reject the given translation of enjoyment.

I get it! So it's sort of like a Chinese take-out menu. You have 80 choices for one word, 66 choices for another, and 58 for yet another. You choose the ones you like! I understand. That being said, I'd like wonton soup, pork fried rice, kung pou chicken and almond cookies for dessert. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom