The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

That means that all religious martyrs of every stripe attest the truth of their religion?

No, they attest to the fact that they truly believe in what they are dying for. The difference is religious martyrs die for their beliefs, religious witnesses die for their claims. Name another religion who's founding writers willingly died for supernatural events that they claimed they witnessed with names, dates, and places included in their claims.

I think Christianity is different because while all religions diagnose a problem and offer a remedy, Christianity's remedy (salvation) doesn't require any action by the sick person. Christianity says that we are saved by grace through faith and not of anything we do.

I never said that that statement was proof the Christianity was true, it was my reasoning for how Christianity is different from other religions. Every religion has aspects that make them different from one another, I just find the uniqueness of Christianity to be more believable because it means that humans can't fix themselves by what we do or don't do and because of the testimony of its founders. (God's revelation to mankind wasn't done in a cave)
 
Last edited:
I never said that that statement was proof the Christianity was true, it was my reasoning for how Christianity is different from other religions. Every religion has aspects that make them different from one another, I just find the uniqueness of Christianity to be more believable because it means that humans can't fix themselves by what we do or don't do and because of the testimony of its founders. (God's revelation to mankind wasn't done in a cave)

Ahmed says he finds the uniqueness of Islam more believable.

Who should believe? I mean, I get you like the message, or whatever, but that doesn't mean what you believe is true. Ahmed says that I could maybe get 72 virigins in heaven if I become a Muslim, and y'know, that sounds better to me than what you have. I find that more believable, because it means that God really, really loves people who go out of their way for him. That sounds right, doesn't it? If we're picking religions on which one seems nicest , or which one has the best message, then I guess I'm still gonna pick Islam. Or maybe Scientology - apparently if I study Scientology hard enough, I can get superpowers!

But it stil doesn't make any sense to me, y'know. All you religious people, you all keep telling me your religion is the best one, the true one. But none of you really ever seem to have anything more to go on other than say-so or torturous flights of logic. But you all seem so sure. Maybe you're different, boilerup. Can you explain to me how I can know that your religion is true, and Ahmeds isn't? I'm trying to avoid burning in hell, but Erithkos hasn't been much use to me!
 
Last edited:
Your sarcastic tone tells me you have no desire to change your position so I don't take your questions seriously, however for my own satisfaction I'll reply.

Don't put words in my mouth (that seems to be happening with every post I make on this forum). I am providing reasons why Christianity is unique and why I find them to be more believable. I am not giving proofs that my religion is the right one. No one can prove the existence of God or disprove it. I am simply applying reason to my particular faith.

If we're picking religions on which one seems nicest , or which one has the best message...

No, we're not picking them based on your said criteria. I'm basing my beliefs on reason and historical evidence. The reason we all (including yourself) keep saying that our world view is the best one, the true one is because all world views are exclusive, religious or not religious, including yours. Only one can be true.
 
Your sarcastic tone tells me you have no desire to change your position so I don't take your questions seriously, however for my own satisfaction I'll reply.

Sarcastic tone? :confused:

Don't put words in my mouth (that seems to be happening with every post I make on this forum). I am providing reasons why Christianity is unique and why I find them to be more believable. I am not giving proofs that my religion is the right one. No one can prove the existence of God or disprove it. I am simply applying reason to my particular faith.
You make a leap between the reasons and the belief that don;t seem to make any sense to me. You say - Christianity is like, this, and that's lovely. Cool. But how does that make it "more believable"? What's the the reasonable step from "This is how the Bible says it is" to "This is how it actually is"? I mean, as I said, you and Ahmed and Tom all have the same types of arguments to make entirely conflicting conclusions. So sorry if I'm not following. Could you be a little clearer? In what way does the Bible saying the things you say make Christianity more believable, actually make it more believable? I asked Ahmed the same question; I'll let you know what he says.

Oh - and when you say "by applying reason to my particular faith", does that mean you picked the faith first, then reasoned about it? That seems the wrong way round to me. It certainly won't help me find the right religion, either! :(

No, we're not picking them based on your said criteria. I'm basing my beliefs on reason and historical evidence. The reason we all (including yourself) keep saying that our world view is the best one, the true one is because all world views are exclusive, religious or not religious, including yours. Only one can be true.
Exactly. So I'd like to know why yours is. You mentioned "reason"? :confused: And historical evidence? Tom Cruise has lots of historical evidence - I mean, we have first-hand proof that his scriptural book was written in one go, by one man, in the language it is currently studied in. And Joseph Smith, my Morman friend, told me that their holy book was revealed in very recent history, and it's revelation very well documented. So I wonder - can you compete with this?

I still don't understand why your God is true, but Ahmed's isn't. He says he has reason and historical evidence too... how should I tell your claims apart?
 
Last edited:
God has the right to destroy the whole world at any time because of the evil in it.
So, that is the best your all-knowing all-powerful so-called god can come up with, doesn't know how else to deal with the evil he made.

Sounds so much like a child's answer to why their father beats them so hard, "He must love me, he beats me down so well".

The creator of everything, like evil, doesn't know how to get rid of evil, that is no god.

That only shows me that your so-called god is only man-made, because it only comes up with man-made ways to deal with people and poor ones at that.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
Last edited:
Start living a perfect life without sinning, since you seem to have a disability for faith.

Yes, and we generally call that "disability" the ability to be skeptical. It's not exactly a bad thing. Without skepticism, you have this.
 
Ethnikos said:
God has the right to destroy the whole world at any time because of the evil in it.

The praise of a Christian in wholesale genocide and similar acts of immorality was part of what made disturbed about the whole religion in the first place.

Of course, I was always skeptical as to the claims, but that's the part that actually disturbed me.
 
Last edited:
Let's be clear; you are claiming that angels and devils both exist in the real world?

My experiences had angels and demons, but I can not say that they specifically had Jesus in them.
I'll take that as a 'yes'. I think you need to go and do some research on how the brain works, particularly when it is under stress. My girlfriend's mother was complaining that people keep wandering into her room. She named one specific teenager she had seen there; this person was a teenager 30 years ago, and was not likely to be in the same town. My girlfriend's mother is recovering from a sub-arachnoid haemorrhage; hallucinations are a common symptom as the brain repairs itself, apparently.

And for a first-hand account of the tricks a recovering brain can play, see RSL's thread.
 
Last edited:
No, they attest to the fact that they truly believe in what they are dying for. The difference is religious martyrs die for their beliefs, religious witnesses die for their claims. Name another religion who's founding writers willingly died for supernatural events that they claimed they witnessed with names, dates, and places included in their claims.

The founders and followers of the "Heaven's Gate" religion willingly died for their belief in supernatural claims that included dates and places.
 
The point I am trying to make is that if you want to make comparisons between two big monolithic religious entities, you are not going to have a choice of one being right.

Huh? Look, if two absolutely competing claims are made, there are only two possibilities:

1. One is right and the other is wrong.
2. Both are wrong.

So if you say, "Jesus," and Achmed says, "Allah," then either:

1. Achmed is right and you are wrong.
2. You are right and Achmed is wrong.
3. BOTH of you are wrong.

What Volatile is asking you is, how do you know 2. is the correct resolution to the conflict, rather than 1. or 3.?
 
God killed whole civilizations at the flood. If you can accept that, why not do another kill-off again? I don't know why, but some people are just bound for destruction. God allows Satan to continue and do things like set up an idolatrous false church for them to follow. Once people accept the false religion, then God can justifiably kill them, for the sake of the ones who will not be lost.
The wicked souls run with glee into the doors of the temple to false gods to have their dose of false happiness, while the true believers suffer and die as outcasts of the society who rejects everyone who does not worship their idols.
God will set things right by turning joy to sorrow, and misery into gladness.
It seems to me that this is the basis of a claim that could be used to distinguish real from false religions. Is there any evidence that one religious sect/cult/denomination is inexplicably immune from getting killed by acts of God? Can Mormons play golf in thundestorms safe in the knowledge that they are Gods chosen?

On a more serious not, can I'd like to offer the only partial solution I can think of to this problem. If you're the sort of person God wants in heaven, then it seems reasonable God would make you the sort of person who'd feel comfortable in his church. In which case, open your heart to whatever God you feel comfortable with safe in the knowledge that, if you're wrong, God didn't want you anyway.

I think the only three assumptions in the above are a) there is a God, b) some people are chosen by him/her and some aren't and c) he isn't the kind of difficult sod who'd make his religion less of a draw to thos he actually wanted than the false religions of satan.
 
Well, god might have made his presence known, but he didn't have to do that right? He still wouldn't be evil if he tortured to death 99% of humanity, right?
As long as he allows at least one person to live, he's "good"?
Oh, and God is a huge fan of rape and sex slavery:

Lo, a day shall come for the Lord when the spoils shall be divided in your midst. And I will gather all the nations against Jerusalem for battle: the city shall be taken, houses plundered, women ravished; half of the city shall go into exile, but the rest of the people shall not be removed from the city. (Zechariah 14:1-2 )

(Deuteronomy 20:10-14) As you approach a town to attack it, first offer its people terms for peace. If they accept your terms and open the gates to you, then all the people inside will serve you in forced labor. But if they refuse to make peace and prepare to fight, you must attack the town. When the LORD your God hands it over to you, kill every man in the town. But you may keep for yourselves all the women, children, livestock, and other plunder. You may enjoy the spoils of your enemies that the LORD your God has given you.

They must be dividing the spoils they took: there must be a damsel or two for each man, Spoils of dyed cloth as Sisera's spoil, an ornate shawl or two for me in the spoil. (Judges 5:30 )
Zechariah 14 is a prophecy about some apocalyptic events associated with what we would think of as Armageddon. It is allegorical and may be describing how the pure religion is misused and abused by false religion. The raping is a way of making a mental picture of how truth is treated by the world religion of the future end times.
Deuteronomy 20:14, as quoted, is not the best translation, in my opinion. I worked on it for some time and came up with one I think is better.

"Certainly the women and the children and the cattle of the city, all the plunder is to be seized for yourselves. Eat the goods of the enemy, that God gives to you."

Some other translations have it sounding like, "grab the women for your enjoyment." which is wrong because it should be two separate sentences, and the word ואכלת means literally to eat. To me this is another example of the translators being influenced by a flawed Greek translation from the original.
The story in Judges is from the song of Deborah describing the demise of the general of the enemy army that went to war against Israel. It is his mother waiting for him to come home and attributing his lateness to having to spend time dividing the spoils.
The other verse you quoted, I addressed in an earlier post, #1869.
 
Last edited:
I think Christianity is different because while all religions diagnose a problem and offer a remedy, Christianity's remedy (salvation) doesn't require any action by the sick person. Christianity says that we are saved by grace through faith and not of anything we do.

Well, first of, regardless of anything else, that uniqueness would have no bearing on the truth of Christianity.
It is not because that message is unique (it is not, by the way) that it is correct.

Secondly, from a personal point of view, I actually dislike this idea.
I rather dislike the idea that brown-nosing to the big guy put one ahead from the guy that tries to his job and have no time kneeling.
This would be unfair fair and enfuriating in an office environment, what would it be fair about salvation.

Aso, this in not Christianity's unambiguous position there has been a debate, right from the beginning of Christianity between work and salvation.
The Roman catholics, for example, put significantly less emphasis on salvation, so stating that it is Christianity's position is not totally correct.



I also think that Christianity is different because of its emphasis on recording dates, places, and people surrounding core events. The alleged witnesses were killed because of what they were saying, no person is willing to die for something they know is a lie.

Meh; Islam's history is much more complete and better recorded. Also, the original records date back from the founding years rather than relying on the transmission of memories a few generations old.
And, yes, people gave their life for Islam right from the beginning too.
So, by this criterion, Islam would be more correct than Christianity.

Also, if you are referring to the martyr of the apostle, let me mention what has been said to DOC multiple time, which he does not seem to accept.
The only record for the apostle martyrs we have, are from the book of acts, which is included in the Bible.
We can't really use the Bible to prove the Bible. Either the Bible is suspicious, and we have no reason to trust the Book of Acts, or it is a trustworthy source, and we can by-pass the 'proving' and directly accept the Gospel's account.

And, yes, people die for lies all the time. People either believe them or convince themselve to be true.
A lot of people claim, for example, that L. Ron Hubbard ended up believing the crud he sold.
Jim Jones or David Koresh did willing die for their beliefs.
 
Simon39759 said:
Jim Jones or David Koresh did willing die for their beliefs.

Just to be pedantic, I think that one can make the argument that Jim Jones didn't actually die for his "belief", but went with the age-old psychological reaction to finding yourself less and less in control of a situation (much like serial killers, who often kill for a sense of control, do when they're put behind bars); the only real "choice" you get is whether to live or die. So by killing himself and his congregation, he was able to wrest control from government authorities.

Of course, it could also be a mixture of both; belief and psychological. Or perhaps you're right, and he did die for his beliefs.

Hard to tell. Even harder to tell when you're relying on age-old manuscripts made by people that aren't exactly unbiased.
 
Last edited:
Just to be pedantic, I think that one can make the argument that Jim Jones didn't actually die for his "belief", but went with the age-old psychological reaction to finding yourself less and less in control of a situation (much like serial killers, who often kill for a sense of control, do when they're put behind bars); the only real "choice" you get is whether to live or die. So by killing himself and his congregation, he was able to wrest control from government authorities.

Of course, it could also be a mixture of both; belief and psychological. Or perhaps you're right, and he did die for his beliefs.

Hard to tell. Even harder to tell when you're relying on age-old manuscripts made by people that aren't exactly unbiased.


It's probably a mixture of both, the Religious aspect being reinterprated to support what the psychological issues dictate...
 
Zechariah 14 is a prophecy about some apocalyptic events associated with what we would think of as Armageddon. It is allegorical and may be describing how the pure religion is misused and abused by false religion. The raping is a way of making a mental picture of how truth is treated by the world religion of the future end times.

Where's the reference for this? I'd like to read the full article.

Deuteronomy 20:14, as quoted, is not the best translation, in my opinion. I worked on it for some time and came up with one I think is better.

You're a translator?
Or do you mean, "That one sounds icky. I'll make it say something nicer"?

"Certainly the women and the children and the cattle of the city, all the plunder is to be seized for yourselves. Eat the goods of the enemy, that God gives to you."

You missed the whole "forced labor" part, conveniently.
 
... I worked on it for some time and came up with one I think is better.

...

To me this is another example of the translators being influenced by a flawed Greek translation from the original. ...

You don't see the unresolvable discrepancy in what you just said, do you?

See, you and yours alike claim that the bible is god's word, inspired by him. Right? So, for a start, how comes that it needs any interpretation at all?

And second, but more important: How can there be any kind of flawed translation? Do you really want to claim that skydaddy was able to magically make people write his words, but utterly failed to make them translate it properly?

And to go even one step further: Why do we need translations anyway? They seem to make a clear understanding of his words pretty much impossible. On the other side, wasn't it he who made all the people speak different languages, and thus created the need for translations, in the first place? You know, Babylon and all that.

So, to recap this. We have the "word of god" through the Bible. He made people write it up. He wants us to understand it. However, he decided in a rush of anger that different people should speak different languages. So he created the need to have his words translated. However, he can't keep track of all them, it seems, so these translations are flawed.

And you really don't see any problem with that? You still want to say that your brand of a cult is the best, the true one, and base that on an obvious flaw that directly affects the very origin of that cult?

I'd really like to know why it seems to be a prerequisite to give up the ability of clear, logical thinking to become one of these religious fools. If an religion relies on the absence of clear, logical thoughts, it simply means that that religion is unclear and illogical. Which makes it pretty much a no-go for every sane person.

Greetings,

Chris
 
snip

Name another religion who's founding writers willingly died for supernatural events that they claimed they witnessed with names, dates, and places included in their claims.



snip)

The Mormons.
 
I am providing reasons why Christianity is unique and why I find them to be more believable. I am not giving proofs that my religion is the right one.

These two sentences contradict each other.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom