The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do you understand the phrase, 'limited to the mobile phones'?

Oh, lordy and palm to forehead. The VERDICT of GUILTY was limited to the mobile phones!

The VERICT of ACQUITTED was assigned to the "residual charges of Chapter D".

Nencini makes it even clearer:

The sum of 300 euro was certainly in the bedroom occupied by Meredith Kercher and it was not found after her murder, just as her credit cards were not found; such that the sum of money and the credit cards constituted an object of the theft noted in letter D) of the indictment. It is surely of interest to observe, after the elevated indictment relative to the theft of the sum of the money and the credit cards, there was no further trace of those goods in the court documents or in the minutes of the proceedings. The only reference is on page 471 of the sentence handed down by the Court of Perugia at the first trial, which reads: “the total of the given evidence that was evaluated singularly demonstrates a overall and unitary picture, without holes or incongruencies, that demands as a necessary and strictly consequential result the attribution of the hypothesized facts of the crime to both of the defendants to which is therefore declared the criminal responsibility, with exclusion of the objects of letter D) that are other than the cell phones, of which no evidence emerged incriminating the defendants, for which they are acquitted of the rest of the indictment because the crime doesn’t subsist.”
Rudy Hermann Guede was also absolved of the theft (in his case of the entire indictment) according to article 530,2 by the GUP of the Court of Perugia for not having committed the act. One understands that the Judge evaluated the circumstance as totally devoid of proof, because in the entire body of the sentence there is no evaluation on the subject.

In any case, and noting that both of the defendants and Rudy Hermann Guede were all absolved of the theft in relation to the indictment with reference to the 300 euro and the two credit cards

What part of "both defendants and Rudy"..."absolved of the theft ….with reference to the 300 euros and two credit cards" are you still having trouble understanding?

Your refusal to admit the charges were "dropped" is ludicrous.



This means: 'only the mobile phones theft was an issue for this court'. ('Issue' as in the legal meaning of the word.)

ROTFLMAO.

Kimo sabe 'residual'? That means 'an issue considered of trivial note'.

Residual means "remaining" as in "a quantity remaining after other things have been subtracted or allowed for . In this case, the residual charges of Chapt D, the cc and money, that had not been allowed for in the GUILTY VERDICT of the phones.

Honestly, Vixen. I'm embarrassed for you.
 
Last edited:
Taking Commodi's words out of context? Would this be the tv chat show?

So perhaps you can attempt to put Commodi's (sic) words into the correct context? Tell us what she really meant to say there....... :rolleyes:

Yes, Vixen. Please do tell us what Comodi was really saying. Put it in context for us.

Someone cue the "Entertainment Tonight" theme song.
 
...'due to insufficient evidence'. Not 'not guilty' as we know it.

M-B made it clear the pair are highly suspicious and Knox was definitely at the murder scene as of the time of the murder, she named Patrick to deflect away from her knowing it was Guede.

Why would your sweet little pure angel want to protect this 'local burglar from Africa'?

Think about it.

Let us know when the penny drops.

As I said...the case was not dismissed. Get it?

It is common for high court judges to go easy on lower court blunders. Read the complete bungling of the lower court Judge Masipa in the Oscar Pistorius case and how the Supreme Court of Appeal in South Africa gingerly avoiding offending the lower court and then, by implication the legal system.

AK didn’t want to protect the African murderer. She didn’t even know the revolting man’s name. Ask yourself this question...Why would Guede say AK wasn’t there? ...and suddenly remember she was there after her arrest? Why didn’t he just tell the incredible story as strung by the foolish prosecution which pretty much made him an accessory and not the murderer? Why did he wait and then blurt out, “Oh yes. That’s exactly how it happened, ummmm but I’m not going give evidence at the AK/RS case.”

Of course it was due to insufficient evidence which effectively means the case should never have gone to court. ...and just to rub your nose in it, it is only a fool who imagines that a case that should never gone to trial (yes...it should have been dismissed for insufficient evidence) implies somehow that there is an underlying guilt.

Oh, the penny has dropped with a thunderous crash. Did you not hear it? Perhaps I should ask that you prove that you didn’t hear it and failing such proof pronounce that the penny has dropped and you refuse to acknowledge it.

We can all play games. Like chess, some of us are better than others at the game.
 
Last edited:
As I said...the case was not dismissed. Get it?

It is common for high court judges to go easy on lower court blunders. Read the complete bungling of the lower court Judge Masipa in the Oscar Pistorius case and how the Supreme Court of Appeal in South Africa gingerly avoiding offending the lower court and then, by implication the legal system.

AK didn’t want to protect the African murderer. She didn’t even know the revolting man’s name. Ask yourself this question...Why would Guede say AK wasn’t there? ...and suddenly remember she was there after her arrest? Why didn’t he just tell the incredible story as strung by the foolish prosecution which pretty much made him an accessory and not the murderer? Why did he wait and then blurt out, “Oh yes. That’s exactly how it happened, ummmm but I’m not going give evidence at the AK/RS case.”

Of course it was due to insufficient evidence which effectively means the case should never have gone to court. ...and just to rub your nose in it, it is only a fool who imagines that a case that should never gone to trial (yes...it should have been dismissed for insufficient evidence) implies somehow that there is an underlying guilt.
Oh, the penny has dropped with a thunderous crash. Did you not hear it? Perhaps I should ask that you prove that you didn’t hear it and failing such proof pronounce that the penny has dropped and you refuse to acknowledge it.

We can all play games. Like chess, some of us are better than others at the game.

The highlighted part above is essentially what the remaining guilter-PR campaign is claiming. With this latest speaking engagement by Knox in Cincinnati, and with the requisite leafleting campaign of the likes of Peter Quennell and the gang at TJMK, imagine actually trying to follow-up on these sorts of statements - that something dropped for lack of evidence (or an actual acquittal based on a lack of evidence) - is legal shorthand that the court really thought of the pair as guilty(!!!!).

Add this to Co-prosecutor Comodi admitting in 2017 - admitting on film! - that the effect of the 2015 Supreme Court acquittals means that neither AK nor RS are guilty of anything; and the picture gets rounded out for someone briefly taken-in by that guilter-PR campaign.

Like you say, we can all play games, but it is a mystery why some don't just read court documents.
 
Last edited:
As I said...the case was not dismissed. Get it?

It is common for high court judges to go easy on lower court blunders. Read the complete bungling of the lower court Judge Masipa in the Oscar Pistorius case and how the Supreme Court of Appeal in South Africa gingerly avoiding offending the lower court and then, by implication the legal system.

AK didn’t want to protect the African murderer. She didn’t even know the revolting man’s name. Ask yourself this question...Why would Guede say AK wasn’t there? ...and suddenly remember she was there after her arrest? Why didn’t he just tell the incredible story as strung by the foolish prosecution which pretty much made him an accessory and not the murderer? Why did he wait and then blurt out, “Oh yes. That’s exactly how it happened, ummmm but I’m not going give evidence at the AK/RS case.”

Of course it was due to insufficient evidence which effectively means the case should never have gone to court. ...and just to rub your nose in it, it is only a fool who imagines that a case that should never gone to trial (yes...it should have been dismissed for insufficient evidence) implies somehow that there is an underlying guilt.

Oh, the penny has dropped with a thunderous crash. Did you not hear it? Perhaps I should ask that you prove that you didn’t hear it and failing such proof pronounce that the penny has dropped and you refuse to acknowledge it.

We can all play games. Like chess, some of us are better than others at the game.

Guede's story was constantly shifting according to what new info he found out. Even his foster family admitted Guede was an "inveterate liar" who "lied to protect himself.
 
Nothing destroys a belief more than one of the original prosecutors herself debunking a component of the conspiracy theory you've been advancing.

What I am talking about is co-prosecutor Maneula Comodi, with lead PM Giuliano Mignini sitting right there, saying that the 2015 Italian Supreme Court have now ruled out Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito of being part of the murder of Meredith Kercher.

No matter. The purveyors of the guilter-PR campaign will simply wait a week or two, and then double-down on their theory that the 2015 Supreme Court had not vindicated the pair - but rather that that Court had ruled that the pair had been almost, but not quite guilty.
 
As I said...the case was not dismissed. Get it?

It is common for high court judges to go easy on lower court blunders. Read the complete bungling of the lower court Judge Masipa in the Oscar Pistorius case and how the Supreme Court of Appeal in South Africa gingerly avoiding offending the lower court and then, by implication the legal system.

AK didn’t want to protect the African murderer. She didn’t even know the revolting man’s name. Ask yourself this question...Why would Guede say AK wasn’t there? ...and suddenly remember she was there after her arrest? Why didn’t he just tell the incredible story as strung by the foolish prosecution which pretty much made him an accessory and not the murderer? Why did he wait and then blurt out, “Oh yes. That’s exactly how it happened, ummmm but I’m not going give evidence at the AK/RS case.”

Of course it was due to insufficient evidence which effectively means the case should never have gone to court. ...and just to rub your nose in it, it is only a fool who imagines that a case that should never gone to trial (yes...it should have been dismissed for insufficient evidence) implies somehow that there is an underlying guilt.

Oh, the penny has dropped with a thunderous crash. Did you not hear it? Perhaps I should ask that you prove that you didn’t hear it and failing such proof pronounce that the penny has dropped and you refuse to acknowledge it.

We can all play games. Like chess, some of us are better than others at the game.


Casus belli.
 
She was being wry.

She was being wry? That conclusion is based on exactly what?

Tell me, Vixen. Was Nencini being "wry" when he said the following?

In any case, and noting that both of the defendants and Rudy Hermann Guede were all absolved of the theft in relation to the indictment with reference to the 300 euro and the two credit cards
 
Nothing destroys a belief more than one of the original prosecutors herself debunking a component of the conspiracy theory you've been advancing.

What I am talking about is co-prosecutor Maneula Comodi, with lead PM Giuliano Mignini sitting right there, saying that the 2015 Italian Supreme Court have now ruled out Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito of being part of the murder of Meredith Kercher.

No matter. The purveyors of the guilter-PR campaign will simply wait a week or two, and then double-down on their theory that the 2015 Supreme Court had not vindicated the pair - but rather that that Court had ruled that the pair had been almost, but not quite guilty.

I'm quite content to let them hold on to that belief, not that the evidence against them was strong, but rather they were fighting against a system that favors the prosecution. It was really a close call and could have gone either way.
 
I'm quite content to let them hold on to that belief, not that the evidence against them was strong, but rather they were fighting against a system that favors the prosecution. It was really a close call and could have gone either way.

I assume the second "them" refers to AK and RS.

The close call was a coin flip between protecting the system vs. protecting the truth. Italy is still stuck mid-transition between Adversarial vs. Inquisitorial.

Me, I go back to what CNN's Jeffrey Toobin said on the night of the Hellmann acquittals in 2011 - (paraphrase) "This acquittal just shows that someone cannot be convicted without evidence, not even in Italy."

Add this to what Barbie Nadeau had told the CNN audience the night of the Dec 2009 convictions; "The prosecution case was weak, but the defence case was weaker. This very well could be overturned at appeal."
 
I assume the second "them" refers to AK and RS.

The close call was a coin flip between protecting the system vs. protecting the truth. Italy is still stuck mid-transition between Adversarial vs. Inquisitorial.

Me, I go back to what CNN's Jeffrey Toobin said on the night of the Hellmann acquittals in 2011 - (paraphrase) "This acquittal just shows that someone cannot be convicted without evidence, not even in Italy."

Add this to what Barbie Nadeau had told the CNN audience the night of the Dec 2009 convictions; "The prosecution case was weak, but the defence case was weaker. This very well could be overturned at appeal."


Yet it was proven that there was no evidence of Knox/Sollecito in the victim's bedroom nor were the footprints in the hallway tracking the victim's blood. Which says that Massei ignored exculpatory evidence. Why? Pressure from his superiors? To appease the Italian masses? Confidence that an appeal would find Knox/Sollecito innocent? Other?
 
Yet it was proven that there was no evidence of Knox/Sollecito in the victim's bedroom nor were the footprints in the hallway tracking the victim's blood. Which says that Massei ignored exculpatory evidence. Why? Pressure from his superiors? To appease the Italian masses? Confidence that an appeal would find Knox/Sollecito innocent? Other?


Not to mention that Nadeau's very statement - "The prosecution case was weak, but the defence case was weaker" - shows a fundamental inability on her part to understand how the criminal justice system is designed to work (even in Italy....). It's not an equal "battle" between prosecution and defence. If the prosecution case is "weak", then the defendant(s) must be acquitted. End of story. Doesn't matter how "weak" or otherwise the defence case is. The prosecution case must be rock-solid strong in order to prove guilt beyond all reasonable doubt. (And there are rock-solid justifications in law and in ethics as to why it's entirely the burden of the accuser to prove the accusation, and if that can't be done, then the accusation must be withdrawn and the accused person must remain presumed innocent of the accusation.)

So if Nadeau believed what she said, then necessarily she ought to have believed that Knox and Sollecito were wrongfully convicted in 2009. Unfortunately, Nadeau appears to possess neither the legal training nor general intelligence to understand the full implications of what she said.
 
Not to mention that Nadeau's very statement - "The prosecution case was weak, but the defence case was weaker" - .............

For the sake of transparency, I am quoting Nadeau **from memory**.

At times I've looked for a video of Nadeau's words to CNN that night in 2009, and once was successful in finding it, but neglected to save the link. I'd not even started following this case until 2011, and had found it when trying to discover what had been wrong with Nadeau's reporting.

The Winterbottom film from 2014 covered that issue, pretty much trashing the likes of Nadeau and Nick Pisa.

So proceed with this caveat in mind.
 
Last edited:
Bill, that reminds me of the idea that AK and RS had to "prove" they had an alibi. An indisputable alibi most certainly can ascertain innocence, but the lack of one does not ascertain guilt in any way. How does a person, who lives alone and spent the evening quietly reading a book, prove they were home the night a crime happens?
 
Bill, that reminds me of the idea that AK and RS had to "prove" they had an alibi. An indisputable alibi most certainly can ascertain innocence, but the lack of one does not ascertain guilt in any way. How does a person, who lives alone and spent the evening quietly reading a book, prove they were home the night a crime happens?

The computer evidence would have certainly helped.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom