The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
As I understand it, very few posters still believe that Knox was guilty, right?

In that case, it's fascinating to go back to the original thread to look at the first reactions to Skeptic Ginger's OP.

Also, I love this one, from another thread.

I didn't belong to ISF back in 2009 so it was interesting to read those early threads. What struck me was the amount of false information that was out there...much of it the same false info that die hard guilters still believe. For example, that Knox did cartwheels during the interrogation. First off, she didn't do "cartwheels" but was doing yoga and, even if you believe they were cartwheels, they weren't done during the interrogation but while she was waiting for RS.
 
I didn't belong to ISF back in 2009 so it was interesting to read those early threads. What struck me was the amount of false information that was out there...much of it the same false info that die hard guilters still believe. For example, that Knox did cartwheels during the interrogation. First off, she didn't do "cartwheels" but was doing yoga and, even if you believe they were cartwheels, they weren't done during the interrogation but while she was waiting for RS.

The main thing that struck me was why the pro guilt crowd people never seemed to wonder why, If Amanda Knox took a giant kitchen knife with her boyfriend to go slaughter her roommate, the crime scene was covered in the prints and DNA of a random burglar? They seemed content that crimes can just have random inexplicable accomplices that don't alter the context or narrative of a case.

On page 1 of the original thread a poster brings that very point up. BTW, nobody ever responded to him, nor anyone else on the issue, in the pursuing 100,000 posts.
 
Umm...no. You never quoted Massei itself stating the charges were dropped. Claiming now that you did so does not make it true. Would you care to quote it now? Good luck!


Not that it will do any good, but once again, here are the charges as listed in the Massei Report. Note the money, credit cards and cell phones are included:



Here are the verdicts on charges under section D





I asked you before what the "residual charge under chapt. D" was if not the money and credit cards as listed in the charges? You failed to answer that then as you will fail to do so now. Want to guess why that is?

That was not an issue listed for trial. It was not even tried. It was dismissed.

It was on the original charge sheet, which is why it is mentioned at all.
 
The case was not dismissed. It went to trial. Remember? The guilty verdict was overruled. A dismissal is a dismissal - no verdict.

The verdict in its final glory is “NOT GUILTY”!

Do try to remember it.

...'due to insufficient evidence'. Not 'not guilty' as we know it.

M-B made it clear the pair are highly suspicious and Knox was definitely at the murder scene as of the time of the murder, she named Patrick to deflect away from her knowing it was Guede.

Why would your sweet little pure angel want to protect this 'local burglar from Africa'?

Think about it.

Let us know when the penny drops.
 
Last edited:
As I understand it, very few posters still believe that Knox was guilty, right?

In that case, it's fascinating to go back to the original thread to look at the first reactions to Skeptic Ginger's OP.

Also, I love this one, from another thread.

You are not aware that Amanda Knox' rent-a-crowd all post on here en masse? The same mob who post on IIP, her fan club.

Read any comments column in the DAILY MAIL about Knox/Sollecito and you'll see the vast majority of people are not fooled by this pair for one nano-second.

The 'Friends of Amanda' are actually a minority. Their profligacy on these pages shouldn't lull you into thinking they represent a balanced view.
 
To be fair you'd expect if a prosecutor was going to round up two perfectly normal college students leading productive civil lives and toss them in a dungeon for life the evidence must have been very convincing. Not the typical oh they're just a couple of junkie criminals anyway so even if they didn't do this particular crime oh well wrongful conviction process.

The key to this case is that a criminal with no ties to either student left bloody prints and DNA all over the scene, had a criminal history of break-in styles identical to the one at the cottage, was spotted by an eyewitness carrying a switchblade (at a previous crime), which precisely matched the murder weapon as described by the medical examiner (which ruled out the giant kitchen knife in the prosecution's case). I don't think a lot of that was well known or publicized at the time. If you weren't aware of those facts you had an excuse. If you were, well there's no helping you.

What struck me was the immediate, knee-jerk reaction to SG's OP. Her position was rejected out of hand. How things have changed!
 
...'due to insufficient evidence'. Not 'not guilty' as we know it.

M-B made it clear the pair are highly suspicious and Knox was definitely at the murder scene as of the time of the murder, she named Patrick to deflect away from her knowing it was Guede.

It said that even if one accepted the prosecution's/convicting lower court's HYPOTHESIS that they'd been at the cottage - even if - it was safe to rule out their participation in the murder. You are reading a guilter-PR version of the report. Here is what the report actually said:

9.4. However, a matter of undoubted significance in favour of the appellants, in the sense that it excludes their material participation in the murder, even if it is hypothesised that they were present in the house on via della Pergola, consists of the absolute lack of biological traces attributable to them (except the clasp which will be dealt with further on) in the murder room or on the victim’s body, where instead numerous traces attributable to Guede were found.​

Nevertheless, even if attribution is certain, the trial element would not be unequivocal as a demonstration of posthumous contact with that blood, as a likely attempt to remove the most blatant traces of what had happened, perhaps to help someone or deflect suspicion from herself, without this entailing her certain direct involvement in the murder. Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.​
 
Last edited:
It said that even if one accepted the prosecution's/convicting lower court's HYPOTHESIS that they'd been at the cottage - even if - it was safe to rule out their participation in the murder. You are reading a guilter-PR version of the report. Here is what the report actually said:

​

​

How many times has Vixen been asked to cite a shred of evidence to support a claim that Amanda was at the cottage at the time of the murder, or that Amanda washed Meredith's blood from her hands. Vixen is incapable of citing such evidence because none exists. All she can do is take Marasca out of context. You'd think someone as brilliant as Vixen claims to be, and who has studied the case as extensively as Vixen claims to have done, would have no problem citing evidence to support such claims.

I find it curious that she keeps making the claims here. She has to know everyone else on this board know the claims are false, and her inability to cite a shred of supporting evidence just makes her look more and more foolish, yet she continues to do it. It's truly fascinating trying to figure out what makes a guilter tick.
 
You are not aware that Amanda Knox' rent-a-crowd all post on here en masse? The same mob who post on IIP, her fan club.

Read any comments column in the DAILY MAIL about Knox/Sollecito and you'll see the vast majority of people are not fooled by this pair for one nano-second.

The 'Friends of Amanda' are actually a minority. Their profligacy on these pages shouldn't lull you into thinking they represent a balanced view.

Not a lot gets by the DAILY MAIL comment section. Have you seen their take on the headline story "Denise reveals reason for her VERY sudden nuptials." Astounding.
 
How many times has Vixen been asked to cite a shred of evidence to support a claim that Amanda was at the cottage at the time of the murder, or that Amanda washed Meredith's blood from her hands. Vixen is incapable of citing such evidence because none exists. All she can do is take Marasca out of context.

Vixen would do well to quote Luca Cheli's commentary on the 2015 Supreme Court report. Cheli highlights four shadows in the report where, in places, it was less than clear - on exactly the same point in other places it was fuzzy. One was to Express an opinion of "exactly when" following the murder AK and RS had definitively been there.

Then again it was not up to any court to prove the pairs' innocence. It was enough that the 2015 court said that the evidence Nencini had had in front of him, actually proved that neither AK nor RS had had any material participation in the murder.
 
Amanda Knox is innocent of killing Meredith Kercher in the same way Ted Bundy is innocent of killing Meredith Kercher. In that neither were there participating or aware the murder was happening. Amanda because she was a few blocks away visiting her boyfriend. Ted Bundy because he was dead at the time, having been executed some years prior for murdering dozens of women. By pointing these basic facts out I am now a Friend of Amanda, and a Friend of Ted Bundy. Two for one special. Though there's about 100 billion other people that have ever existed not being Rudy Guede murdering Meredith Kercher who I am now a Friend Of.
 
That was not an issue listed for trial. It was not even tried. It was dismissed.


I tell you what...if you can identify what the "residual charges" in chapter D for which they were acquitted were, you will be proved correct. I've asked you to do so several times. You have failed to do so each time. I will ask you once again:

What were the residual charges Massei mentions here in the verdicts if not the credit cards and the money?

FOR THESE REASONS
Under articles 533 and 535 of the Criminal Procedure Code
[this Court] Declares
KNOX Amanda Marie and SOLLECITO Raffaele guilty of the crimes ascribed to them under chapter A) of the charges, into said crime being absorbed the felony contested under chapter C), as well as [guilty] under chapter B), D) limited to the mobile phones and E) and, as far as regards KNOX Amanda Marie, additionally the crime she has been charged with under chapter F),

Exonerates the accused of the residual charge under chapter D) because it was not proven that the crime was committed.
 
You are not aware that Amanda Knox' rent-a-crowd all post on here en masse? The same mob who post on IIP, her fan club.

I haven't posted on IIP in 3 1/2 years as I told you before.
I see that you have resorted to the "paid" posters nonsense again. I've always thought it ludicrous but for you to think that 3 1/2 years after the definitive acquittal we'd still be being paid (which never happened in the first place) to post in some forum in a corner of the internet is even more ludicrous. If I accused the (few remaining) posters on TJMK of being paid shills, you'd think I was nuts. And you'd be right.

Read any comments column in the DAILY MAIL about Knox/Sollecito and you'll see the vast majority of people are not fooled by this pair for one nano-second.

So we are supposed to base our opinions on what misinformed random posters on a tabloid comment section believe instead of the evidence? Uh-huh.

The 'Friends of Amanda' are actually a minority. Their profligacy on these pages shouldn't lull you into thinking they represent a balanced view.

The majority of people overwhelmingly believe that anyone arrested and tried for anything is guilty. And once that early formed opinion is in place, most people simply cannot admit they were wrong no matter what the evidence shows otherwise.
 
Vixen said:
Read any comments column in the DAILY MAIL about Knox/Sollecito and you'll see the vast majority of people are not fooled by this pair for one nano-second.
You must be joking.

This pair?

Mignini and Comodi?

Massei and Nencini?

Stefanoni and..... well, she's about it as far as forensic-DNA "experts" are concerned.....

But Vixen needs to stick to the guilter-PR script a bit better. The hoax that Vixen claims is not fomented by AK and RS; it's been fomented by every forensic expert who has ever independently looked at the evidence - or lack of same.
 
This pair?

Mignini and Comodi?

Massei and Nencini?

Stefanoni and..... well, she's about it as far as forensic-DNA "experts" are concerned.....

But Vixen needs to stick to the guilter-PR script a bit better. The hoax that Vixen claims is not fomented by AK and RS; it's been fomented by every forensic expert who has ever independently looked at the evidence - or lack of same.

We mustn't forget that the PR supertanker was capable of buying off the foremost forensic scientists in the world and one of the most respected criminal experts in the world. Then there's the mafia and Masons who bought off not only Hellman and Zanetti with a couple Ferraris, but also the Supreme Court of Italy.

We don't need no stinkin' forensic and criminal experts. We got internet posters in the comment sections!
 
Vixen:

If you won't believe me about the FACT that the Marasca-Bruno report vindicated Amanda Knox AND Raffaele Sollecito, maybe you'll believe Maneula Comodi. You DO know who Maneula Comodi is, don't you?

This is a screen capture from the 2017, late fall YouTube video from the original prosecution team - who are still claiming that Sollecito and Knox are guilty.

But even they can read what the 2015 Supreme Court said. BTW - the translation was done by Machiavelli!

 
Vixen:

If you won't believe me about the FACT that the Marasca-Bruno report vindicated Amanda Knox AND Raffaele Sollecito, maybe you'll believe Maneula Comodi. You DO know who Maneula Comodi is, don't you?

This is a screen capture from the 2017, late fall YouTube video from the original prosecution team - who are still claiming that Sollecito and Knox are guilty.

But even they can read what the 2015 Supreme Court said. BTW - the translation was done by Machiavelli!

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_539715b9afbf970329.jpg[/qimg]

Now, now...we all know that Prosecutor Comodi doesn't know how to properly read a legal court motivation report. Perhaps she should consult the legal eagles on TJMK.
 
Vixen:

If you won't believe me about the FACT that the Marasca-Bruno report vindicated Amanda Knox AND Raffaele Sollecito, maybe you'll believe Maneula Comodi. You DO know who Maneula Comodi is, don't you?

This is a screen capture from the 2017, late fall YouTube video from the original prosecution team - who are still claiming that Sollecito and Knox are guilty.

But even they can read what the 2015 Supreme Court said. BTW - the translation was done by Machiavelli!

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_539715b9afbf970329.jpg[/qimg]

The full youtube 2017 video (1H19M22S) featuring Comodi and Mignini with some others - including one of Guede's lawyers, Nicodemo Gentile - is at:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbOjYpH1WdM

There is a translation to English (subtitles) and some written commentary by Machiavelli.

Mignini's statements about the role of the CSC relating to its evaluation of the merits seems directly at odds with how Italian law (CPP Article 606.1E) is applied, considering that both the Chieffi CSC panel and the Marasca CSC panel used that law to review the merits. He apparently also has a problem understanding that the Marasca CSC panel applied CPP Article 620.1L, which allows the CSC to annul a case without referral when it believes that course is justified. He apparently forgets these points of Italian law when they don't agree with his prejudices or show that his investigation and prosecution of the case was a sad farce, an attack on justice and the rights of the innocent.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom