The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
He apparently forgets these points of Italian law when they don't agree with his prejudices or show that his investigation and prosecution of the case was a sad farce, an attack on justice and the rights of the innocent.

Looks like he has trouble admitting when he's wrong, too. This seems to be a common characteristic amongst many of the PGP.
 
Last edited:
Looks like he has trouble admitting when he's wrong, too. This seems to be a common characteristic amongst many of the PGP.

Another characteristic of the PGP is the misconception that certain Italian authorities actually understand or follow Italian law or the European Convention and ECHR case law (which Italy and Italian authorities must follow, because of the Italian Constitution and Italy's treaty obligations).

Take, for example, Police Officer Michele Giutarri's application to the ECHR. It was ruled inadmissible by the ECHR because he had failed to exhaust domestic remedies and because he had no grounds for complaint under the Convention:

Giuttarri brought an application before the ECHR against Italy, claiming that Italy had violated his rights under Convention articles 8, 13, 3, and 6.1 when the Italian authorities investigated him and charged him with abuse of power and other offenses. His application GIUTTARI c. ITALIE 42733/07 was ruled inadmissible in an ECHR decision published 02/12/2014.

Here's an excerpt of the decision translated by Google from the French original:

"25. Relying on Article 8 of the Convention, the applicant complains of the seizures of which he was the subject.

26. Relying on Article 13 of the Convention, the applicant alleges that he does not have an effective remedy in Italian law to denounce the violation of his right to respect for his private life.

27. Relying on Articles 3 and 6 § 1 of the Convention, the applicant complains of having been the victim of inhuman and degrading treatment and unfairness of the criminal proceedings against him.

43. It follows that this complaint {under Article 8} must be rejected for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies, pursuant to Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention.

46. ​​It follows that this complaint {under Article 13} is manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.

52. The Court considers that the mere initiation of criminal proceedings and the completion of two searches and seizures of documents clearly do not reach the minimum threshold of gravity to fall within the scope of Article 3 of the Convention. Accordingly, no appearance of a breach of that provision can be found in the present case.

53. It follows that this complaint {under Articles 3 and 6.1} is manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention."
 
Another characteristic of the PGP is the misconception that certain Italian authorities actually understand or follow Italian law or the European Convention and ECHR case law (which Italy and Italian authorities must follow, because of the Italian Constitution and Italy's treaty obligations).

....

Here's another example of the failure of Italian police to follow Italian law and the European Convention, and the consequences - and lack of consequences - for their actions during the unjustified beatings and arrests of peaceful demonstrators at the 2001 G8 meetin in Genoa:

"G8 Genova: Bolzaneto, 26 condannati a pagare danni allo Stato per 6 milioni
Per risarcimenti sborsati alle vittime degli abusi durante il G8 di Genova nel 2001

Sei milioni di euro per i danni causati allo Stato in seguito ai risarcimenti pagati a chi subì gli abusi nella caserma di Bolzaneto durante il G8 di Genova nel 2001. Lo hanno stabilito i giudici della Corte dei conti di Genova che hanno condannato 26 persone, tra personale medico-sanitario, appartenenti della polizia, carabinieri e polizia penitenziaria. Tra questi, come anticipato nell'edizione locale di Repubblica, anche Alfonso Sabella, all'epoca dei fatti capo dell'Ispettorato del Dipartimento dell'amministrazione penitenziaria (Dap) e il generale Oronzo Doria, ex capo area della Liguria degli agenti di polizia penitenziaria.
....
Per il pm, oltre al danno patrimoniale, si doveva aggiungere anche il danno all'immagine dello Stato e delle varie amministrazioni, quantificato in 5 milioni di euro: gli episodi di violenza avvenuti a Bolzaneto "hanno determinato un danno d'immagine che forse non ha pari nella storia della Repubblica"."

Google translation:

G8 Genoa: Bolzaneto, 26 sentenced to pay damages to the State for 6 million
For compensation paid out to victims of abuse during the G8 in Genoa in 2001

Six million euros for the damages caused to the State following the compensation paid to those who suffered the abuse in the Bolzaneto barracks during the G8 in Genoa in 2001. The judges of the Court of Auditors of Genoa who sentenced 26 people, among medical personnel, members of the police, carabinieri and penitentiary police. Among them, as anticipated in the local edition of the Republic, also Alfonso Sabella, at the time of the facts head of the Inspectorate of the Department of Prison Administration (DAP) and General Oronzo Doria, former head of Liguria area of prison police officers.
....
According to the prosecutor, in addition to the damage to assets, the damage to the image of the State and of the various administrations, quantified at 5 million euro, must also be added: the episodes of violence in Bolzaneto "have caused damage to the image that perhaps has no equal in the history of the Republic ".

Source: http://www.ansa.it/liguria/notizie/...to-_b1818cec-c04f-4cb4-ba1e-5e720cc8b611.html

Here's a follow-up to the above case brought by Italy against Italian police authorities:

"G8, Diaz: Procura Corte dei Conti chiede 8 milioni agenti
5 milioni per danno immagine per Gratteri, Caldarozzi e altri

La procura della Corte dei Conti della Liguria chiede un risarcimento danni di oltre 8 milioni di euro (3 milioni di danni patrimoniali e 5 per danno d'immagine) a 27 appartenenti ed ex appartenenti alla polizia di stato, per i pestaggi avvenuti alla scuola Diaz durante il G8 di Genova del 2001. A essere citati dalla procura contabile sono i dirigenti e i funzionari dell'epoca, tra questi anche Francesco Gratteri, allora direttore del servizio centrale Operativo, il suo vice Gilberto Caldarozzi; il capo della Digos di Genova Spartaco Mortola oltre al comandante del primo reparto mobile di Roma, Vincenzo Canterini, il suo vice comandante e i capisquadra; oltre agli altri funzionari coinvolti nei fatti. Per la procura, devono risarcire un danno patrimoniale indiretto, ovvero i risarcimenti alle parti civili pagati dal Ministro, oltre alle spese legali per i processi, il tutto per oltre 3 milioni di euro. Nei prossimi mesi sarà fissata l'udienza davanti ai giudici contabili che dovranno decidere nel merito."

Google translation:

G8, Diaz: Procura Corte dei Conti asks for 8 million agents
5 million for image damage to Gratteri, Caldarozzi and others

The Prosecutor of the Court of Auditors of Liguria asks for damages of more than 8 million euros (3 million damages and 5 for damage to image) to 27 members and former members of the state police, for the beatings occurred at the school Diaz during the G8 of Genoa in 2001. To be cited by the attorney of the accounts are the managers and officials of the time, among them also Francesco Gratteri, then director of the central operational service, his deputy Gilberto Caldarozzi; the head of the Digos of Genoa Spartaco Mortola as well as the commander of the first mobile department of Rome, Vincenzo Canterini, his deputy commander and the foremen; in addition to other officials involved in the facts. For the power of attorney, they must indemnify indirect damage, that is, compensation to the civil parties paid by the Minister, in addition to legal costs for the proceedings, all for over 3 million euros. In the next few months the hearing will be held before the accounting judges who will have to decide on the merits.

Source: http://www.ansa.it/sito/notizie/cro...nti_744effd4-6689-4cdf-af1c-fd2b210efe3f.html

Thanks to european neighbor on IIP Forum for calling attention to these articles.

I should also point out that there were several ECHR judgments that ruled that Italy had violated the Convention rights of the individuals who had been beaten and falsely detained.

These cases are summarized in the Country Profile for Italy, page 6, including the following:

Bartesaghi Gallo and Others v. Italy (applications nos. 12131/13 and 43390/13)

The case concerned the ill-treatment to which 42 demonstrators were subjected by police officers inside a school, in the context of an anti-globalisation demonstration organised to coincide with the 27th summit of the eight major industrialised countries (G8).


Blair and Others v. Italy (applications nos. 1442/14, 21319/14 and 21911/14) and Azzolina and Others v. Italy (applications nos. 28923/09 and 67599/10)

The cases concerned incidents following the G8 Summit in Genoa in 2001, when demonstrators were subjected to violence by law-enforcement officers while in detention. The applicants alleged that they had been subjected to torture and complained that the investigation by the domestic courts had been ineffective, in particular because the statute of limitations had been applied to virtually all the acts committed and because a number of those convicted had been granted a remission of their sentence.
 
Last edited:
This should piss off the (teeny tiny) crowd over on TJMK :D:

https://www.uc.edu/news/articles/2018/09/n201659.html

It certainly pisses me off - all I get is a "page not found".

I too could not get the link to work.

But try this one:

https://search.uc.edu/search?q=cach...&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&access=p&oe=UTF-8

Quote from that page:

"Thu, September 13, 2018

Exoneree Amanda Knox spoke to University of Cincinnati College of Law school students Thursday at the University of Cincinnati College of Law about her experience with a flawed and unfair legal system, the perspective she gained during her ordeal and life after her wrongful conviction."

It's great that there's a site that can piss off the TJMK "crowd" [LOL] and objective followers of this case as well, even if for different reasons.
 
I too could not get the link to work.

But try this one:

https://search.uc.edu/search?q=cach...&output=xml_no_dtd&ie=UTF-8&access=p&oe=UTF-8

Quote from that page:

"Thu, September 13, 2018

Exoneree Amanda Knox spoke to University of Cincinnati College of Law school students Thursday at the University of Cincinnati College of Law about her experience with a flawed and unfair legal system, the perspective she gained during her ordeal and life after her wrongful conviction."

It's great that there's a site that can piss off the TJMK "crowd" [LOL] and objective followers of this case as well, even if for different reasons.

Thanks, Numbers.

For Amanda Knox's talk at UC Law, also try: https://law.uc.edu/news.html

However, the link from that page didn't work either. A conspiracy?:)

FAKE NEWS!
 
Looks like Quennell's "don't let Knox speak" email campaign to law schools, etc. has been a failure. He must be very disappointed.:thumbsup:
 
Looks like Quennell's "don't let Knox speak" email campaign to law schools, etc. has been a failure. He must be very disappointed.:thumbsup:

More importantly, Quennell has never rated a mention for his disruption campaign in any media which covered any one of the speaking engagements - except for here and on TJMK of course.

He did once start a trolling campaign against one school's information officers with whom he'd originally bombarded with his disinformation campaign.

All very sad.
 
I noticed the latest article had garnered exactly 3 comments, including one from the author.

Does the T in TJMK stand for Titanic?
 
I'm still waiting for Vixen to list what the "residual charges under section D" were.
Somehow, I don't think she will. Just call me a pessimist.
 
I have to 'green arrow' this comment.

You might want to start by noting that original co-prosecutor Maneula Comodi believed as late as Dec 2017 that the 2015 Supreme Court ruled that AK and RS were not involved in the crime.
 
I tell you what...if you can identify what the "residual charges" in chapter D for which they were acquitted were, you will be proved correct. I've asked you to do so several times. You have failed to do so each time. I will ask you once again:

What were the residual charges Massei mentions here in the verdicts if not the credit cards and the money?

Do you understand the phrase, 'limited to the mobile phones'?

This means: 'only the mobile phones theft was an issue for this court'. ('Issue' as in the legal meaning of the word.)

Kimo sabe 'residual'?

That means 'an issue considered of trivial note'.
 
More importantly, Quennell has never rated a mention for his disruption campaign in any media which covered any one of the speaking engagements - except for here and on TJMK of course.

He did once start a trolling campaign against one school's information officers with whom he'd originally bombarded with his disinformation campaign.

All very sad.

Donald?
 
Do you understand the phrase, 'limited to the mobile phones'?

This means: 'only the mobile phones theft was an issue for this court'. ('Issue' as in the legal meaning of the word.)

Kimo sabe 'residual'?

That means 'an issue considered of trivial note'.


Totally incorrect.

The Massei court clearly and obviously tried Knox and Sollecito on (among other things, of course) the theft of three classes of items: cash, Kercher's credit cards, and Kercher's mobile phones.

The Massei court found Knox/Sollecito guilty (though God knows how....) of the theft of Kercher's mobile phones. That's why, when discussing the conviction under Charge E, the Massei motivations report makes it clear that the conviction is limited to only part of the charge: the part concerning the mobile phones.

But the Massei court (tried and) acquitted Knox/Sollecito of the theft of the cash and the credit cards. These are prescisely the "residual charges" referred to in the motivations report.

"Kimo Sabe"? (sic)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom