The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Here we go with appalling logical fallacies. "One cop has been found to be corrupt = therefore, all cops are corrupt".

Stacy's obvious point was that, yes, there are some corrupt cops. And this point is way over the head of the paltry few remaining guilters who think no corrupt cop has ever walked the face of the earth.
 
Their evidence was legally false (Florence Feb 2017 and upheld by the Supreme Court). A false alibi counts as permissible evidence.

Raff gave a false alibi five times.

He still hasn't told us which one is true.

His alibi that he spent the evening with Amanda at his apt. was never proved to be false, it was just not verified.
 
Couldn't watch it for more than two minutes. The same micro smiles flashing across her face like those two Russians who claimed on tv they came to Salisbury to 'see the tallest church tower in the world' (I don't think it is?) and the world's oldest working clock (re the Skirpal poisoning).

That smirking really gives these people away.

They think it's funny.

Ah, yes... back to the "body language" interpretation from someone who is no expert in body language. But very gifted in hyperbole. I'm surprised you don't find some hidden confession of guilt in Amanda's sneezing in hay fever season. Maybe we just have to wait for spring for that.
 
Here we go with appalling logical fallacies. "One cop has been found to be corrupt = therefore, all cops are corrupt".

Hmmmm...that's your incorrect inference. I never said that at all nor was I implying it. Are some cops corrupt? You bet. And I can provide loads of evidence of that.

I do find your inference amusing seeing how it comes from someone who has claimed that the acquitting judges, the defense lawyers, and the defense experts were 'bent', 'corrupt' or 'paid shills'.

Just a reminder since you've taken a week or so off:

Any luck with evidence of that "death bed confessions that got Zellner's client off" yet? How about the evidence that the theft charges were dropped? Or that the knife re-testing was " still incriminating"?

No?
 
Last edited:
Hmmmm...that's your incorrect inference. I never said that at all nor was I implying it. Are some cops corrupt? You bet. And I can provide loads of evidence of that.

I do find your inference amusing seeing how it comes from someone who has claimed that the acquitting judges, the defense lawyers, and the defense experts were 'bent', 'corrupt' or 'paid shills'.

Just a reminder since you've taken a week or so off:

Any luck with evidence of that "death bed confessions that got Zellner's client off" yet? How about the evidence that the theft charges were dropped? Or that the knife re-testing was " still incriminating"?

No?

Hatred is a blinding emotion, vixen has shown this repeatedly. That she cannot see her own hypocrisy should not be surprising at this point. She defends the police, prosecutors against accusations of corruption etc, despite overwhelming evidence. However when it come to the defense and various legal and forensic experts, she claims they are 'bent', 'corrupt' or 'paid shills', even though there is no evidence. LOL I think its a bit funny to be honest, this is part of the reason that it is so easy to prove her wrong. :D :p :o
 
Vixen said:
Here we go with appalling logical fallacies. "One cop has been found to be corrupt = therefore, all cops are corrupt".

Stacy's obvious point was that, yes, there are some corrupt cops. And this point is way over the head of the paltry few remaining guilters who think no corrupt cop has ever walked the face of the earth.

It's hard to imagine who Vixen, or any of the remaining guilter-nutters, think they're influencing with these tedious screeds. There was a time prior to the pair's exonerations in 2015 that there were enough guilter-nutters comment-bombing on-line news outlets that this sort of thing could maintain a force of inertia.

Not now. Question - is there ANYONE out there willing to come forward saying that they are even moderately intrigued by Vixen's postings, or even that they'll give these things the benefit of the doubt?
 
Last edited:
Their evidence was legally false (Florence Feb 2017 and upheld by the Supreme Court). A false alibi counts as permissible evidence.

Raff gave a false alibi five times.

He still hasn't told us which one is true.

Five false alibis? Really. How about you post here what those five different alibis are.

Hint: Don't use what's written in the fake wiki because Ver's 1, 3, 4 and 5 are all the same alibi.
 
Any luck with evidence of that "death bed confessions that got Zellner's client off" yet? How about the evidence that the theft charges were dropped? Or that the knife re-testing was " still incriminating"?

Or that Ryan Ferguson took an Alford Plea?:D

Or, one of my personal favorites, that Jeffrey MacDonald, from prison since like 1982, claiming he's innocent somehow constitutes "innocence fraud".
 
Here we go with appalling logical fallacies. "One cop has been found to be corrupt = therefore, all cops are corrupt".

Yet again PGP embarrass themselves with the inability to understand the simplest concepts. If someone points out the existence of some corrupt and dishonest police officers it doesn't mean they are saying all police officers are corrupt and dishonest. It beggars belief people can't understand this simple notion and Vixen has the cheek to people stupid.
 
This ECHR judgment published 27 Sept 2018 appears to have some relevance (from the press release; the judgment is published only in French). The ECHR found a violation of Convention Article 8:

Italian law on searches did not provide sufficient safeguards against possible abuse of power by the authorities or arbitrariness

In today’s Chamber judgment in the case of Brazzi v. Italy (application no. 57278/11) the European Court of Human Rights held, unanimously, that there had been:

a violation of Article 8 (right to respect for private and family life) of the European Convention on Human Rights.

The case concerns a search carried out by the Italian tax authorities in a house that Mr Brazzi has owned in Italy since 2009 and where his wife and children live during the school year.

The Court found in particular that the interference with Mr Brazzi’s right to respect for his home had not been “in accordance with the law”, within the meaning of Article 8 § 2 of the Convention, because he had not had the benefit of the effective oversight required by the rule of law in a democratic society. No judge had examined the lawfulness or necessity of the warrant for the search of his home, neither before nor after the search.

Italian law did not therefore provide sufficient upstream or downstream safeguards against risks of abuse of power or arbitrariness.
_______

The significance of the Brazzi v. Italy case for the Knox v. Italy case includes the question of whether Mignini or other Italian authorities obtained the proper judicial authorization for searches and seizures (such as taking Knox's cell phone) and for detaining Knox incommunicado - specifically, without allowing her to contact a lawyer - from the time of her arrest until immediately before the arrest hearing.

The detention of Sollecito without a lawyer by Mignini during the period from his arrest to immediately before his arrest hearing has been ruled a violation of Italian procedural law and for this action Mignini was censured by the Italian Superior Council of the Judiciary, the disciplinary body overseeing Italian prosecutors and judges.
 
Last edited:
Hmmmm...that's your incorrect inference. I never said that at all nor was I implying it. Are some cops corrupt? You bet. And I can provide loads of evidence of that.

I do find your inference amusing seeing how it comes from someone who has claimed that the acquitting judges, the defense lawyers, and the defense experts were 'bent', 'corrupt' or 'paid shills'.

Just a reminder since you've taken a week or so off:

Any luck with evidence of that "death bed confessions that got Zellner's client off" yet? How about the evidence that the theft charges were dropped? Or that the knife re-testing was " still incriminating"?

No?


She's famous for it. It's her liet motif.
 
Five false alibis? Really. How about you post here what those five different alibis are.

Hint: Don't use what's written in the fake wiki because Ver's 1, 3, 4 and 5 are all the same alibi.

Do have a read of his police statement 5 Nov 2007, where he openly admits, 'What I told you yesterday was a crock of ****". In that account he claims he came home alone and Knox came in after one. He claimed he was surfing the net all evening. Three so far.

You guess the other two.

As Commodi said, a false alibi is far more incriminating than having no alibi.

Only a crook dreams up a bent alibi.
 
Do have a read of his police statement 5 Nov 2007, where he openly admits, 'What I told you yesterday was a crock of ****". In that account he claims he came home alone and Knox came in after one. He claimed he was surfing the net all evening. Three so far.

You guess the other two.

As Commodi said, a false alibi is far more incriminating than having no alibi.

Only a crook dreams up a bent alibi.

At the end of the trial process - March 2015 - it turned out that neither of them needed an alibi. Even co-prosecutor Comodi as late as Dec 2017 confirmed that the Italian Supreme Court had ruled out RS and AK as involved in the crime.

 
Last edited:
Hmmmm...that's your incorrect inference. I never said that at all nor was I implying it. Are some cops corrupt? You bet. And I can provide loads of evidence of that.

I do find your inference amusing seeing how it comes from someone who has claimed that the acquitting judges, the defense lawyers, and the defense experts were 'bent', 'corrupt' or 'paid shills'.

Just a reminder since you've taken a week or so off:

Any luck with evidence of that "death bed confessions that got Zellner's client off" yet? How about the evidence that the theft charges were dropped? Or that the knife re-testing was " still incriminating"?

No?

She's famous for it. It's her liet motif.

So the answer is "no". One would think that finding evidence of what a person is famous for would be easy peasy. Apparently not since you have failed yet again to provide any such evidence. For rational and honest people, the inability to find corroborating evidence would be a red flag that they might be wrong.

Please try to use and spell lietmotif correctly.
 
Last edited:
Do have a read of his police statement 5 Nov 2007, where he openly admits, 'What I told you yesterday was a crock of ****". In that account he claims he came home alone and Knox came in after one. He claimed he was surfing the net all evening. Three so far.

You guess the other two.

As Commodi said, a false alibi is far more incriminating than having no alibi.

Only a crook dreams up a bent alibi.

I'm glad you think a situation where the police confused Raffaele on dates, refused to let him reference a calendar in the room, and where he recounts an evening that couldn't possibly have been from the night of the murder counts as a "false alibi". It does stand in stark contrast to the consistent alibi he has given from the day Meredith's murder was discovered through to this day. I would expect most honest, open minded people would see this for what it's worth (i.e., not much), but I do understand some people are desperate to make a point and consider this a deliberate, false alibi. From my count that now makes two.

I asked you to list them so no, I'm not going to "guess" what they are. I'll consider your inability to do this as an admission that they don't exist.
 
I'm glad you think a situation where the police confused Raffaele on dates, refused to let him reference a calendar in the room, and where he recounts an evening that couldn't possibly have been from the night of the murder counts as a "false alibi". It does stand in stark contrast to the consistent alibi he has given from the day Meredith's murder was discovered through to this day. I would expect most honest, open minded people would see this for what it's worth (i.e., not much), but I do understand some people are desperate to make a point and consider this a deliberate, false alibi. From my count that now makes two.

I asked you to list them so no, I'm not going to "guess" what they are. I'll consider your inability to do this as an admission that they don't exist.

The final court acquittal in 2015 punctuated this with a period, full stop - by directly implying that RS didn't even need an alibi.
 
The final court acquittal in 2015 punctuated this with a period, full stop - by directly implying that RS didn't even need an alibi.

I agree, but Vixen wants to continue to argue the courts got it wrong and present her 'evidence' to support this. The PGP's claim of five different alibis is part of that argument, but as anyone who has bothered to read what the PGP have posted on their fake wiki knows, it's an entirely bogus claim. I just thought it would be entertaining taking Vixen to task on the claim. As expected, she can't list these different alibis because they don't exist. But in the process she underscores the disingenuousness of the PGP by failing to understand and accept the recollection of the night prior to the night in question was induced by the police and not a legitimate "false confession".
 
I agree, but Vixen wants to continue to argue the courts got it wrong and present her 'evidence' to support this.

Vixen argues that the 2015 acquittal, was from a court that got it wrong.

Except when Vixen claims that it didn't acquit, but got them off on a "not beyond a reasonable doubt" technically. And when Vixen claims that the 2015 court actually stated, which they did not, that they secretly thought the pair guilty.

Vixen varies what she thinks the 2015 court said, depending on what she's trying to argue.
 
Last edited:
So the answer is "no". One would think that finding evidence of what a person is famous for would be easy peasy. Apparently not since you have failed yet again to provide any such evidence. For rational and honest people, the inability to find corroborating evidence would be a red flag that they might be wrong.

Please try to use and spell lietmotif correctly.

ETA: Too late to change my typo of leitmotif. I accidentally juxtaposed the i and the e. I do know how to spell it. Vixen's mistake was that it's one word, not two.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom