The key word here is "should". But, as we know, the prosecution was hell bent on claiming the murder occurred well after the evidence pointed to an earlier time. They had to do that in order to fit it to a scream that some claimed to have heard during at an unspecified time by an unspecified person in a neighborhood where screams were not uncommon. They had to fit it to a drug addled addict's claim of seeing the pair. How any court could have accepted Curatolo as being credible is unfathomable.
Exactly. The courts
SHOULD have....
- Acknowledged the computer evidence meant at least one of them was still at Raffaele's apartment at 21:30
- Accepted that the clothes Meredith was wearing, the failure to call her mother back and the stomach content analysis indicated Meredith was attacked shortly after arriving home, so well before 21:30.
- Disregarded the knife evidence, not just because the knife was removed from it's sterile collection bag at the police station (something that deserved FAR more criticism that it received) but because science proved sample 36B was not connected to Meredith.
- Accepted that Amanda and Raffaele did not know Guede and that the likelihood of the two of them conspiring with Guede to do anything, let alone commit a violent crime, was practically non-existent.
- Admitted that it was not possible to conduct a selective clean-up and as such, the complete lack of forensic trace of either Amanda or Raffaele in Meredith's room was evidence of their non-involvement.
- Concluded that the very late collection of the bra clasp, considering the scene was not secured, and the very improper way that it was collected, rendered the DNA results unreliable.
- Allowed for a sound test to be performed which would have proven that Nara's testimony was unreliable (and any reasonable person would have concluded her additional testimony of hearing multiple people running in opposite directions stunk of coaching)
- Seriously questioned why three witnesses came forward so late, and only after having the same reporter speak to them, to provide testimony that, in each case, had serious contradictions.
Etc., etc., etc. This brings back memories of my initial reaction after reading the Massei report. I was literally stunned with how often the court speculated, assumed, fabricated, disregarded available innocent interpretation, dismissed contradictory evidence and ignored definitive scientific results. It was clear the court's decision to convict was predetermined and the report was an effort to justify it - and it failed miserably.