The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I assume the second "them" refers to AK and RS.

The close call was a coin flip between protecting the system vs. protecting the truth. Italy is still stuck mid-transition between Adversarial vs. Inquisitorial.

Me, I go back to what CNN's Jeffrey Toobin said on the night of the Hellmann acquittals in 2011 - (paraphrase) "This acquittal just shows that someone cannot be convicted without evidence, not even in Italy."

Add this to what Barbie Nadeau had told the CNN audience the night of the Dec 2009 convictions; "The prosecution case was weak, but the defence case was weaker. This very well could be overturned at appeal."

Yes. Raffaele and the Knox girl. I had my doubts the final result would go their way. Toobin is wrong, we have seen it happen not only in Italy but in other countries as well.
 
Yes. Raffaele and the Knox girl. I had my doubts the final result would go their way. Toobin is wrong, we have seen it happen not only in Italy but in other countries as well.

I also had serious doubts that they would be acquitted. Not because I doubted their innocence but, after seeing the ridiculous findings of Massei, the previous S. C., and Nencini, I had no faith in the Italian courts.

As for the computers, don't you know that it was Raffaele who burned the hard drives in order to destroy evidence and not the police?:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I also had serious doubts that they would be acquitted. Not because I doubted their innocence but, after seeing the ridiculous findings of Massei, the previous S. C., and Nencini, I had no faith in the Italian courts.

As for the computers, don't you know that it was Raffaele who burned the hard drives in order to destroy evidence and not the police?:rolleyes:

Of course, as we know, much of the data was eventually recovered and once the defense experts had an opportunity to properly scan the data they uncovered the Naruto cartoon being opened at 21:26. Given all of the physical evidence that essentially proved Meredith was already attacked at this point, the computer evidence should have helped significantly.
 
Of course, as we know, much of the data was eventually recovered and once the defense experts had an opportunity to properly scan the data they uncovered the Naruto cartoon being opened at 21:26. Given all of the physical evidence that essentially proved Meredith was already attacked at this point, the computer evidence should have helped significantly.

The key word here is "should". But, as we know, the prosecution was hell bent on claiming the murder occurred well after the evidence pointed to an earlier time. They had to do that in order to fit it to a scream that some claimed to have heard during at an unspecified time by an unspecified person in a neighborhood where screams were not uncommon. They had to fit it to a drug addled addict's claim of seeing the pair. How any court could have accepted Curatolo as being credible is unfathomable.

ETA: I read Nara Capezzali's testimony again and she seemed very defensive and sometimes very irritated whenever she was challenged by the defense regarding her contradictory testimony. I also find it interesting how certain she was about being told about the murder the morning after she heard a scream about 9:30 A.M. which was hours before the murder was even discovered. She was also certain she saw posters of AK, RS, PL and RG that same day when no such posters existed and there was no connecton to RG yet. But this woman is supposed to be a credible witness. Incredible.
 
Last edited:
The key word here is "should". But, as we know, the prosecution was hell bent on claiming the murder occurred well after the evidence pointed to an earlier time. They had to do that in order to fit it to a scream that some claimed to have heard during at an unspecified time by an unspecified person in a neighborhood where screams were not uncommon. They had to fit it to a drug addled addict's claim of seeing the pair. How any court could have accepted Curatolo as being credible is unfathomable.

Exactly. The courts SHOULD have....

- Acknowledged the computer evidence meant at least one of them was still at Raffaele's apartment at 21:30
- Accepted that the clothes Meredith was wearing, the failure to call her mother back and the stomach content analysis indicated Meredith was attacked shortly after arriving home, so well before 21:30.
- Disregarded the knife evidence, not just because the knife was removed from it's sterile collection bag at the police station (something that deserved FAR more criticism that it received) but because science proved sample 36B was not connected to Meredith.
- Accepted that Amanda and Raffaele did not know Guede and that the likelihood of the two of them conspiring with Guede to do anything, let alone commit a violent crime, was practically non-existent.
- Admitted that it was not possible to conduct a selective clean-up and as such, the complete lack of forensic trace of either Amanda or Raffaele in Meredith's room was evidence of their non-involvement.
- Concluded that the very late collection of the bra clasp, considering the scene was not secured, and the very improper way that it was collected, rendered the DNA results unreliable.
- Allowed for a sound test to be performed which would have proven that Nara's testimony was unreliable (and any reasonable person would have concluded her additional testimony of hearing multiple people running in opposite directions stunk of coaching)
- Seriously questioned why three witnesses came forward so late, and only after having the same reporter speak to them, to provide testimony that, in each case, had serious contradictions.

Etc., etc., etc. This brings back memories of my initial reaction after reading the Massei report. I was literally stunned with how often the court speculated, assumed, fabricated, disregarded available innocent interpretation, dismissed contradictory evidence and ignored definitive scientific results. It was clear the court's decision to convict was predetermined and the report was an effort to justify it - and it failed miserably.
 
The key word here is "should". But, as we know, the prosecution was hell bent on claiming the murder occurred well after the evidence pointed to an earlier time. They had to do that in order to fit it to a scream that some claimed to have heard during at an unspecified time by an unspecified person in a neighborhood where screams were not uncommon. They had to fit it to a drug addled addict's claim of seeing the pair. How any court could have accepted Curatolo as being credible is unfathomable.

ETA: I read Nara Capezzali's testimony again and she seemed very defensive and sometimes very irritated whenever she was challenged by the defense regarding her contradictory testimony. I also find it interesting how certain she was about being told about the murder the morning after she heard a scream about 9:30 A.M. which was hours before the murder was even discovered. She was also certain she saw posters of AK, RS, PL and RG that same day when no such posters existed and there was no connecton to RG yet. But this woman is supposed to be a credible witness. Incredible.

The testimony of Nara lacked credibility and was full of holes. If Nara said she had seen posters of AK, RS, PL and RG before the body had been discovered and no such poster existed, this indicates Nara and was delusional and was suffering from mental disorders. PGP villify Amanda for having mental disorders eg calling Amanda a psychopath but were perfectly happy for someone with mental disorders to provide testimony against Amanda. Yet another example of vile hypocrisy by PGP.
 
The testimony of Nara lacked credibility and was full of holes. If Nara said she had seen posters of AK, RS, PL and RG before the body had been discovered and no such poster existed, this indicates Nara and was delusional and was suffering from mental disorders. PGP villify Amanda for having mental disorders eg calling Amanda a psychopath but were perfectly happy for someone with mental disorders to provide testimony against Amanda. Yet another example of vile hypocrisy by PGP.

I don't think Capezzalli had mental disorders. I do think she may have heard someone scream and/or someone(s) running up the metal stairs at sometime, but that it was unconnected to Meredith's murder. As she testified, she heard a lot of noises all the time because of where the car park was in relation to her apartment and the type of people who hung out there at all hours of the night. A girl had been raped in the parking garage and a drug addict had overdosed and died, too. Not a nice area.
I don't think she was intentionally lying, but I do think she made assumptions from what she later learned and incorporated them into her "memory". After all, she did not go to the police with this story until 25 days after the murder. By that time, it had been all over the news and in the newspapers. I also think she was confused about when things she included in her testimony actually happened. This would explain claiming she saw posters of all four suspects when it was impossible and that she found out about the murder hours before it was discovered. She simply was not a reliable witness.

Reading the testimony, I also think Mignini was leading her. Whenever Bongiorno, especially, zeroed in on contradictory testimony, Mignini interrupted. He did it so often that Bongiorno protested to the judge.
 
Last edited:
This is a recent interview of Amanda on a Scandinavian talk show (in English). I thought it was well done.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CckT0twVsDQ

It's good to see that Amanda Knox and Maneula Comodi agree on something.... that the 2015 Supreme Court acquittals were a full vindication of both Knox and Sollecito, and that neither had had anything to do with the otherwise brutal crime.

 
In Chicago today, 18 men were exonerated and released from prison. A "dirty cop", Sgt. Ronald Watts pleaded guilty to planting evidence, extortion, and falsifying police reports along with his team. Several more cases stemming from arrests by Watts and his team are under investigation. Fifteen men last year were also exonerated due to Watts' corruption.

https://chicago.cbslocal.com/2018/0...ictions-tied-to-corrupt-cop-to-be-exonerated/

What? Corrupt, lying police? Say it ain't so!
 
In Chicago today, 18 men were exonerated and released from prison. A "dirty cop", Sgt. Ronald Watts pleaded guilty to planting evidence, extortion, and falsifying police reports along with his team. Several more cases stemming from arrests by Watts and his team are under investigation. Fifteen men last year were also exonerated due to Watts' corruption.

https://chicago.cbslocal.com/2018/0...ictions-tied-to-corrupt-cop-to-be-exonerated/

What? Corrupt, lying police? Say it ain't so!

He was being wry.
 
Bill, that reminds me of the idea that AK and RS had to "prove" they had an alibi. An indisputable alibi most certainly can ascertain innocence, but the lack of one does not ascertain guilt in any way. How does a person, who lives alone and spent the evening quietly reading a book, prove they were home the night a crime happens?

Their evidence was legally false (Florence Feb 2017 and upheld by the Supreme Court). A false alibi counts as permissible evidence.

Raff gave a false alibi five times.

He still hasn't told us which one is true.
 
This is a recent interview of Amanda on a Scandinavian talk show (in English). I thought it was well done.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CckT0twVsDQ


Couldn't watch it for more than two minutes. The same micro smiles flashing across her face like those two Russians who claimed on tv they came to Salisbury to 'see the tallest church tower in the world' (I don't think it is?) and the world's oldest working clock (re the Skirpal poisoning).

That smirking really gives these people away.

They think it's funny.
 
In Chicago today, 18 men were exonerated and released from prison. A "dirty cop", Sgt. Ronald Watts pleaded guilty to planting evidence, extortion, and falsifying police reports along with his team. Several more cases stemming from arrests by Watts and his team are under investigation. Fifteen men last year were also exonerated due to Watts' corruption.

https://chicago.cbslocal.com/2018/0...ictions-tied-to-corrupt-cop-to-be-exonerated/

What? Corrupt, lying police? Say it ain't so!

Here we go with appalling logical fallacies. "One cop has been found to be corrupt = therefore, all cops are corrupt".
 
Couldn't watch it for more than two minutes. The same micro smiles flashing across her face like those two Russians who claimed on tv they came to Salisbury to 'see the tallest church tower in the world' (I don't think it is?) and the world's oldest working clock (re the Skirpal poisoning).

That smirking really gives these people away.

They think it's funny.

They do? It is so good this thread has a mind reader to fill us in like this.... we are grateful.
 
Their evidence was legally false (Florence Feb 2017 and upheld by the Supreme Court). A false alibi counts as permissible evidence.

Raff gave a false alibi five times.

He still hasn't told us which one is true.

Yes he has. The court seems to agree since it acquitted him. Even co-prosecutor Maneula Comodi agreed that the court acquitted him.

 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom