The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's a shame Ergon has pronounced his departure (again), since I'm now intrigued as to the nature of his project which is "not unrelated to this case".

Could it be a campaign for the beatification of Mignini? Could it be the organisation of a global "World-class practices in criminal forensic science methods" lecture tour for Stefanoni? Could it be negotiation of publishing rights for a book entitled "Why I was just an innocent bystander sitting on the toilet, and it was the evil Knox and Sollecito who killed that poor girl and got away with it while I took all the blame" by one Rudy Guede?

I'm eager to learn more!!! Alas, perhaps I will never know........
 
It's a shame Ergon has pronounced his departure (again), since I'm now intrigued as to the nature of his project which is "not unrelated to this case".

Could it be a campaign for the beatification of Mignini? Could it be the organisation of a global "World-class practices in criminal forensic science methods" lecture tour for Stefanoni? Could it be negotiation of publishing rights for a book entitled "Why I was just an innocent bystander sitting on the toilet, and it was the evil Knox and Sollecito who killed that poor girl and got away with it while I took all the blame" by one Rudy Guede?

I'm eager to learn more!!! Alas, perhaps I will never know........

Look to the skies, LJ. The answers are in the stars!;)
 
Ergon said:
:D
Time to end this endless thread of OCD obssession over Amanda Knox
You might want to tell Pete Quennell it's time to retire TJMK.

Speaking of Slick Pete, he promised everyone a public apology was coming from RS and AG over the lawsuit that Mignini "won". It's been almost a year now. Did I miss it?

Truly, a laugh-out-loud comment, highlighted above.

And yes, if Ergon feels a need to say that bit about OCD in this thread (in its 28th continuation) it would be great to do a compare and contrast on the OCD scale with the only remaining guilter website - as you say, Stacyhs - TJMK.

I will believe that Ergon is sincere in that comment if he repeats it on TJMK, or writes about this as his 15th OpEd for TJMK about that very concept.

A couple of random things, because Ergon is nothing if not a man of his word, and will be moving on as he has noted.

First - there have been at least two times (and I apologize if I missed others) when he has been truly gracious and kind to me; true there have been other times when he's been "not so much", but then again I've said some unfortunate things too - and I have apologized to Ergon publicly on at least two occasions for saying something nasty and getting it wrong, and in one case failing to back up my unfortunate words with a proper citation.

But lastly - the reason I joined this discussion in the first place was not because of Amanda Knox. I don't know the woman, and for the sake of transparency have met her all too briefly twice. I met Sollecito once. It's amazing the core stuff "that side of the fence" just gets plain wrong.

But here's the deal - to complete that sentence about OCD, maybe I can amend LJ's amendment of Ergon's statement, with "discussion obsession with (of) the Knox/Sollecito trial process".

C'mon - some of us have spent way, way too much time on this.

Edited by zooterkin: 
Edited for rule 8.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm the first to admit that I am obsessed...not with Amanda Knox, but with the PGP view of the case. As Spock would say, "Fascinating".
 
I'm the first to admit that I am obsessed...not with Amanda Knox, but with the PGP view of the case. As Spock would say, "Fascinating".


Yes. I'd say that I too harbour two separate - but obviously related - strong interests (I'd hesitate to diagnose myself as obsessive!):

1) An interest in the case itself: what most probably really happened (based on a logical, objective analysis of all the available (reliable, credible) evidence), and how/why the judicial process played out in the way it did. The majority of this is of course now over.... but it's NOT completely over: the Knox ECHR application may very well (will, in my opinion) lead to significant ramifications, and may well in turn lead to further judicial actions. So it's entirely wrong to argue that this is all completely finished as of September 2018.

2) An interest in the communication of information and opinions related to this case. This includes everything from the way the mass media reported the case from 2007 right up to the present day (and how/why certain editorial stances were preferred at certain times in the process), right through to "campaigns" waged through social media messageboards and online forums. It's abundantly clear that the embers of this activity are still smouldering, most notably on the part of a small cadre of zealous pro-guilt commentators who continue to (attempt to) flood social media platforms to spread their "message" about the true guilt of Knox and Sollecito. As with Stacy, I am truly mesmerised and fascinated by the ongoing zeal and righteousness of this tiny hard-core of pro-guilt commentators, uncoupled as it is from any proper understanding of the evidence (including, obviously, a proper, objective assessment and understanding of which evidence is credible and reliable, and which is not.....)
 
Yes. I'd say that I too harbour two separate - but obviously related - strong interests (I'd hesitate to diagnose myself as obsessive!):

1) An interest in the case itself: what most probably really happened (based on a logical, objective analysis of all the available (reliable, credible) evidence), and how/why the judicial process played out in the way it did. The majority of this is of course now over.... but it's NOT completely over: the Knox ECHR application may very well (will, in my opinion) lead to significant ramifications, and may well in turn lead to further judicial actions. So it's entirely wrong to argue that this is all completely finished as of September 2018.

2) An interest in the communication of information and opinions related to this case. This includes everything from the way the mass media reported the case from 2007 right up to the present day (and how/why certain editorial stances were preferred at certain times in the process), right through to "campaigns" waged through social media messageboards and online forums. It's abundantly clear that the embers of this activity are still smouldering, most notably on the part of a small cadre of zealous pro-guilt commentators who continue to (attempt to) flood social media platforms to spread their "message" about the true guilt of Knox and Sollecito. As with Stacy, I am truly mesmerised and fascinated by the ongoing zeal and righteousness of this tiny hard-core of pro-guilt commentators, uncoupled as it is from any proper understanding of the evidence (including, obviously, a proper, objective assessment and understanding of which evidence is credible and reliable, and which is not.....)

All ^!
 
Oh boy. So much to say. So much ignorance.

A court dismisses a case in the event that evidence is non-existent or insufficient. When a case is dismissed (with or without prejudice) it is closed prior to trial. It’s not a loophole.

If you want to know about “with prejudice” and “without prejudice” do google.

I haven’t the patience to indulge your pretensions of knowledge founded on ignorance.

I’m not saying you’re entirely ignorant and for those who may think you are, I might be inclined to take the 5th.

So now you understand why it is quite wrong and unprincipled of Marasca-Bruno to have used it. It is a blatant get-out clause, as advised them by Bongiorno.

As you know, a judge cannot come to a verdict that has not been asked for by the counsel.
 
Care to explain that? Eels are not commonly eaten here so the reference strikes no chord with me.

By the way, any luck with evidence of that "death bed confessions that got Zellner's client off" yet? How about the evidence that the theft charges were dropped? Or that the knife re-testing was " still incriminating"?

Refer back to my previous answer, where I pointed out that Massei itself says that part of the charges were dropped.
 
Refer back to my previous answer, where I pointed out that Massei itself says that part of the charges were dropped.


Umm...no. You never quoted Massei itself stating the charges were dropped. Claiming now that you did so does not make it true. Would you care to quote it now? Good luck!


Not that it will do any good, but once again, here are the charges as listed in the Massei Report. Note the money, credit cards and cell phones are included:

(D)
with the felony to which articles 110 and 624 of the Criminal Code apply, because, in complicity amongst themselves, to procure an unjust profit for themselves, in the circumstances of time and place in which chapters (A) and (C) apply, took possession of a sum of approximately 300 Euros, two credit cards, from Abbeybank and Nationwide, both based in the United Kingdom, and two mobile phones, the property of MEREDITH

Here are the verdicts on charges under section D

FOR THESE REASONS
Under articles 533 and 535 of the Criminal Procedure Code
[this Court] Declares
KNOX Amanda Marie and SOLLECITO Raffaele guilty of the crimes ascribed to them under chapter A) of the charges, into said crime being absorbed the felony contested under chapter C), as well as [guilty] under chapter B), D) limited to the mobile phones and E) and, as far as regards KNOX Amanda Marie, additionally the crime she has been charged with under chapter F),

Exonerates the accused of the residual charge under chapter D) because it was not proven that the crime was committed.

I asked you before what the "residual charge under chapt. D" was if not the money and credit cards as listed in the charges? You failed to answer that then as you will fail to do so now. Want to guess why that is?
 
Care to explain that? Eels are not commonly eaten here so the reference strikes no chord with me.

By the way, any luck with evidence of that "death bed confessions that got Zellner's client off" yet? How about the evidence that the theft charges were dropped? Or that the knife re-testing was " still incriminating"?

Refer back to my previous answer, where I pointed out that Massei itself says that part of the charges were dropped.

I'll repeat these as you seem to be ignoring them. I wonder just why that is? Could it possibly be because they're not true? Nah...…:

By the way, any luck with evidence of that "death bed confessions that got Zellner's client off" yet? How about the evidence that the theft charges were dropped? Or that the knife re-testing was " still incriminating"?
 
Last edited:
A guilter in one or more posts on this forum has falsely claimed that the Marasca CSC panel dismissed the murder/rape charges against Knox and Sollecito. The truth is that Knox and Sollecito were finally and definitively acquitted of those charges by the Marasca CSC panel under CPP Article 530, second paragraph (that is, Article 530.2) with the specification "the accused did not commit the fact [act] {of the crime}".

If there had been a dismissal - that is, a decision not to proceed with a trial due to insufficient evidence or other cause, it would have been under CPP Article 529:

"Art. 529 Sentenza di non doversi procedere

1. Se l’azione penale non doveva essere iniziata o non deve essere proseguita (336 s.), il giudice pronuncia sentenza di non doversi procedere indicandone la causa nel dispositivo.

2. Il giudice provvede nello stesso modo quando la prova dell’esistenza di una condizione di procedibilità è insufficiente o contraddittoria. "

Google translation (with minimal corrections):

Art. 529 Sentence of not having to proceed {dismissal of case}

1. If the criminal prosecution had not started or should not be continued (336 s.), the judge pronounces that he should not proceed and indicates the cause in the operative part.

2. The judge proceeds in the same way when the proof of the existence of a condition of procedure is insufficient or contradictory.


A better, more idiomatic translation is provided in the text by Gialuz, Luparia, and Scarpa:

Article 529 Judgment of non-prosecution

1. It the criminal prosecution should not have been initiated or continued, the judge shall deliver a judgment of non-prosecution mentioning the cause in the operative part of the judgment.

2. The judge shall follow the same procedure in case of insufficient or contradictory proof of the existence of a requirement for prosecution.

Note that there is no requirement under Italian law that a dismissal under CPP Article 529 be delivered at the beginning of a trial or at any particular stage of the proceedings.
 
Umm...no. You never quoted Massei itself stating the charges were dropped. Claiming now that you did so does not make it true. Would you care to quote it now? Good luck!


Not that it will do any good, but once again, here are the charges as listed in the Massei Report. Note the money, credit cards and cell phones are included:



Here are the verdicts on charges under section D





I asked you before what the "residual charge under chapt. D" was if not the money and credit cards as listed in the charges? You failed to answer that then as you will fail to do so now. Want to guess why that is?

I'll repeat these as you seem to be ignoring them. I wonder just why that is? Could it possibly be because they're not true? Nah...…:

By the way, any luck with evidence of that "death bed confessions that got Zellner's client off" yet? How about the evidence that the theft charges were dropped? Or that the knife re-testing was " still incriminating"?

Crickets
 
For those who believe this thread is some OCD frenzy about Amanda Knox, the following is what ignited the firestorm. Turns out it had never been about AK, it had been about Giuliano Mignini and his crazy theories.

It was all about Giuliano Mignini's obsession with Satanic sex-cults. Below is a sampling of some of the early press coverage - and just to make it clear that there was no US-media-based frenzy detailing this, I've limited this (in the main) to UK media sources. Yes, the post 2011 acquittal UK media source is from Douglas Preston, but it was clear by then (even in the UK) that those who'd criticized Mignini early on had been right all along:

******************

Oct 19 2008 - https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/...ercher-to-death-in-satanic-ritual-z2358qlbjhc

Amanda Knox ‘stabbed Meredith Kercher to death in satanic ritual’

******************

Dec 4 2009 – https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wo...elic-student-orchestrated-satanic-murder.html

Meredith Kercher trial: how angelic student orchestrated 'satanic' murder

******************

Jun 6 2010 - https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...secutor-tainted-by-satanism-case-1992485.html

Knox prosecutor tainted by 'satanism' case
As Meredith Kercher's killers prepare their appeal, serious questions are being asked about the man who led the case against them

******************

Oct 4 2011 - https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/oct/04/knox-acquittal-only-possible-verdict

Amanda Knox: victim of Italian code which puts saving face before justice
US writer Douglas Preston argues that the rush to judgment over Meredith Kercher was to save prosecutor Guiliano Mignini, the police and the judiciary from public humiliation.

*********************

Sept 29 2016 - https://www.romper.com/p/what-is-the-amanda-knox-satanic-sex-cult-theory-it-was-never-proven-19384

What Is The Amanda Knox Satanic Sex Cult Theory? It Was Never Proven

******************

This is only a taste. The US media sources eventually followed suit, but are not included here because Migniniophiles would want you to believe that it was powerful US media forces which had engineered the eventual total acquittals.

 
Last edited:
So now you understand why it is quite wrong and unprincipled of Marasca-Bruno to have used it. It is a blatant get-out clause, as advised them by Bongiorno.

As you know, a judge cannot come to a verdict that has not been asked for by the counsel.

The case was not dismissed. It went to trial. Remember? The guilty verdict was overruled. A dismissal is a dismissal - no verdict.

The verdict in its final glory is “NOT GUILTY”!

Do try to remember it.
 
For those who believe this thread is some OCD frenzy about Amanda Knox, the following is what ignited the firestorm. Turns out it had never been about AK, it had been about Giuliano Mignini and his crazy theories.

It was all about Giuliano Mignini's obsession with Satanic sex-cults. Below is a sampling of some of the early press coverage - and just to make it clear that there was no US-media-based frenzy detailing this, I've limited this (in the main) to UK media sources. Yes, the post 2011 acquittal UK media source is from Douglas Preston, but it was clear by then (even in the UK) that those who'd criticized Mignini early on had been right all along:

******************

Oct 19 2008 - https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/...ercher-to-death-in-satanic-ritual-z2358qlbjhc

Amanda Knox ‘stabbed Meredith Kercher to death in satanic ritual’

******************

Dec 4 2009 – https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wo...elic-student-orchestrated-satanic-murder.html

Meredith Kercher trial: how angelic student orchestrated 'satanic' murder

******************

Jun 6 2010 - https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...secutor-tainted-by-satanism-case-1992485.html

Knox prosecutor tainted by 'satanism' case
As Meredith Kercher's killers prepare their appeal, serious questions are being asked about the man who led the case against them

******************

Oct 4 2011 - https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/oct/04/knox-acquittal-only-possible-verdict

Amanda Knox: victim of Italian code which puts saving face before justice
US writer Douglas Preston argues that the rush to judgment over Meredith Kercher was to save prosecutor Guiliano Mignini, the police and the judiciary from public humiliation.

*********************

Sept 29 2016 - https://www.romper.com/p/what-is-the-amanda-knox-satanic-sex-cult-theory-it-was-never-proven-19384

What Is The Amanda Knox Satanic Sex Cult Theory? It Was Never Proven

******************

This is only a taste. The US media sources eventually followed suit, but are not included here because Migniniophiles would want you to believe that it was powerful US media forces which had engineered the eventual total acquittals.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_53971526af3cd3ec23.jpg[/qimg]

Here's an informative excerpt from Preston's article in the Guardian:

"About 50% of all criminal convictions in Italy are reversed or greatly modified on appeal. Knox and Sollecito join the 4 million Italians since the war who have seen their lives ruined by false criminal charges, only to be proclaimed innocent after many years of agony and imprisonment.

While they don't like others pointing it out, many Italians are well aware that their judicial system is dysfunctional. Silvio Berlusconi is absolutely right when he says the judiciary needs fundamental reform. The Italian judiciary, a holdover to a great extent from the Mussolini era, when Italy was a police state, acts with no checks and balances, in which prosecutors and police wield enormous power.

If you are arrested for a crime and have no alibi, you are in very serious trouble. The de facto burden of proof is on you to prove your innocence, despite lip service in the Italian constitution to the idea of innocent until proven guilty.

The Italian justice system often seems more concerned with preserving the honour and reputations of powerful individuals than with finding the truth. This, in a nutshell, explains why Knox and Sollecito were not released when Guede was identified, why dubious DNA and forensic lab work was relied upon, why prosecutors and police leaked so much damaging and salacious information to the press, and why these two innocent young people spent 1,450 days in prison for murder they did not commit. It was all about honour, reputation, and the saving of face."

The source of Preston's data on the percentage of convictions reversed or greatly modified on appeal and the number of Italians falsely accused by the authorities since WW II was not given in the article.
 
Last edited:
As I understand it, very few posters still believe that Knox was guilty, right?

In that case, it's fascinating to go back to the original thread to look at the first reactions to Skeptic Ginger's OP.

Also, I love this one, from another thread.

To be fair you'd expect if a prosecutor was going to round up two perfectly normal college students leading productive civil lives and toss them in a dungeon for life the evidence must have been very convincing. Not the typical oh they're just a couple of junkie criminals anyway so even if they didn't do this particular crime oh well wrongful conviction process.

The key to this case is that a criminal with no ties to either student left bloody prints and DNA all over the scene, had a criminal history of break-in styles identical to the one at the cottage, was spotted by an eyewitness carrying a switchblade (at a previous crime), which precisely matched the murder weapon as described by the medical examiner (which ruled out the giant kitchen knife in the prosecution's case). I don't think a lot of that was well known or publicized at the time. If you weren't aware of those facts you had an excuse. If you were, well there's no helping you.
 
Last edited:
Here's another excerpt from one of the articles cited by Bill Williams:

"....He {Mignini} and Giuttari, the court said, were guilty of "almost unheard of" criminal activity, carrying out investigations "in no way related ... to their proper competence", launching criminal cases with no evidence, ordering phone taps with "quite different ends" from those cited when the taps were authorised, taps that were made "for reasons of retaliation ... against people towards whom they had reasons for hostility"."

Source: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...secutor-tainted-by-satanism-case-1992485.html
 
Here's another excerpt from one of the articles cited by Bill Williams:

"....He {Mignini} and Giuttari, the court said, were guilty of "almost unheard of" criminal activity, carrying out investigations "in no way related ... to their proper competence", launching criminal cases with no evidence, ordering phone taps with "quite different ends" from those cited when the taps were authorised, taps that were made "for reasons of retaliation ... against people towards whom they had reasons for hostility"."

Source: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...secutor-tainted-by-satanism-case-1992485.html

For fans of the ECHR, it should be pointed out that Police Officer Giuttari - Mignini's buddy in the Monster of Florence insanity - brought an application before the ECHR against Italy, claiming that Italy had violated his rights under Convention articles 8, 13, 3, and 6.1. His application GIUTTARI c. ITALIE 42733/07 was ruled inadmissible in an ECHR decision published 02/12/2014.

Here's an excerpt of the decision translated by Google from the French original:

"25. Relying on Article 8 of the Convention, the applicant complains of the seizures of which he was the subject.

26. Relying on Article 13 of the Convention, the applicant alleges that he does not have an effective remedy in Italian law to denounce the violation of his right to respect for his private life.

27. Relying on Articles 3 and 6 § 1 of the Convention, the applicant complains of having been the victim of inhuman and degrading treatment and unfairness of the criminal proceedings against him.

43. It follows that this complaint {under Article 8} must be rejected for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies, pursuant to Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention.

46. ​​It follows that this complaint {under Article 13} is manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.

52. The Court considers that the mere initiation of criminal proceedings and the completion of two searches and seizures of documents clearly do not reach the minimum threshold of gravity to fall within the scope of Article 3 of the Convention. Accordingly, no appearance of a breach of that provision can be found in the present case.

53. It follows that this complaint {under Articles 3 and 6.1} is manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention."
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom