The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
How does anyone of intelligence keep claiming luminol proves the presence of blood when more sensitive TMB testing says the traces were not made from blood? Quite perplexing . . . .

Luminol is several magnitudes more sensitive to blood than TMB.

Luminol only reacts to substances with organic ferrous substances, such as red blood cells, which may have had its colour washed out with bleach, but the iron contained therein remains and this is what luminol reacts to.

Oh, and it also reacts with horseradish and turnip juice.

So we have the comical sight of the Friends of Amanda claiming the pair dunked their feet in turnip juice before padding around at the time of the murder, thus causing the luminol to react.

Strangely, Raff and Amanda never mentioned this in their alibis (x 5 all of which were deemed false and a pack of lies. Even Raff told the police, 'What I told you before was a bucket of ****. Amanda told me to lie for her').

His words, not mine, or the police's.

Go figure.
 
Luminol is several magnitudes more sensitive to blood than TMB.

Luminol only reacts to substances with organic ferrous substances, such as red blood cells, which may have had its colour washed out with bleach, but the iron contained therein remains and this is what luminol reacts to.

Oh, and it also reacts with horseradish and turnip juice.

So we have the comical sight of the Friends of Amanda claiming the pair dunked their feet in turnip juice before padding around at the time of the murder, thus causing the luminol to react.

Strangely, Raff and Amanda never mentioned this in their alibis (x 5 all of which were deemed false and a pack of lies. Even Raff told the police, 'What I told you before was a bucket of ****. Amanda told me to lie for her').

His words, not mine, or the police's.

Go figure.



You don't know what you're talking about.

(As one of many possible hints to address your ignorance: go and read up about the two-part TMB test* - i.e. not the combined "Hemastix"-type test - and figure out stuff about its sensitivity and specificity (the actual measure that matters here) versus Luminol)


* And the two-part test was the test that should have been performed upon those samples. If the forensic morons world-class experts in this case chose to use the combined TMB test, then they were ignorant and negligent.
 
Last edited:
Ah, the old "luminol is (several magnitudes) more sensitive to blood than TMB" argument.

Ranges of values for the sensitivities for both the luminol test and the TMB test have been reported in the forensic literature. Some values suggest that luminol test slightly more sensitive, but I have seen claims that both tests can detect blood that is diluted up to 1 part in 1,000,000. However, let us assume for the purposes of illustration that TMB detects blood to 1 part in 10,000 and that luminol detects blood to one part in 100,000, a tenfold difference in sensitivity. However, there is a 10,000 fold range (from undiluted blood to blood that has been diluted ten thousand fold) in which both will be positive. In other words each and every dilution would have to be between 10,000- and 100,000-fold to be TMB-negative and luminol-positive in this hypothetical situation.
http://viewfromwilmington.blogspot.com/2012/07/presumptive-blood-testing-in.html


Sarah Gino testified that
“She [defense expert witness Sarah Gino] added that, in her own experience, analyses performed with TMB on traces revealed by Luminol give about even results: 50% negative, 50% positive, [Massei MR, pg.276]”

Professor Tagliabracci, specified, without being refuted (hearing of July 18 2009, p. 174), that the tetramethylbenzedine (TMB) test is very sensitive, so much as to give a positive result even with only five red blood cells present. Dr. Stefanoni herself, moreover, clarified (preliminary hearing of October 4 2008) that, while a positive test result could be deceptive due to reactivity of the chemical [evidenziatore] with other substances, a negative result gives certainty that no blood is present.
(Hellmann MR)


As for your (now-to-be-expected) made up scenario regarding "the pair dunked their feet in turnip juice before padding around at the time of the murder", you forget that

1. none of the luminol detected "bloody footprints" were forensically identified as either Amanda's or Raffaele's. The prosecution just claimed they were.

2. luminol also reacts with cleaning agents, metals commonly found in soil, et al.

3. If the luminol was reacting to Meredith's blood, why did some of the samples not have her DNA and others no DNA at all?

Go figure.
 
Last edited:
Luminol is several magnitudes more sensitive to blood than TMB.

Luminol only reacts to substances with organic ferrous substances, such as red blood cells, which may have had its colour washed out with bleach, but the iron contained therein remains and this is what luminol reacts to.

Oh, and it also reacts with horseradish and turnip juice.

So we have the comical sight of the Friends of Amanda claiming the pair dunked their feet in turnip juice before padding around at the time of the murder, thus causing the luminol to react.

Strangely, Raff and Amanda never mentioned this in their alibis (x 5 all of which were deemed false and a pack of lies. Even Raff told the police, 'What I told you before was a bucket of ****. Amanda told me to lie for her').

His words, not mine, or the police's.

Go figure.

This argument is like claiming a Lamborghini isn't fast because a Bugatti is faster. TMB is extremely sensitive and a negative result is treated as definitive evidence that no blood exists.

The list of substances that Luminol will react with is extensive. Every technical journal describing the use of Luminol stresses it's propensity for false positives and the absolute need to run confirmatory tests.

No one has suggested "dunked their feet in turnip juice before padding around at the time of the murder" - that's purely your imagination. From a defense POV, it's not necessary to prove, or even suggest, what the trace is from. All the defense needed to do was prove what it wasn't, and the prosecution's TMB and DNA results did that quite effectively.

So once again - explain with a credible scientific explanation how Luminol positive prints in Amanda's room could be TMB negative, DNA positive (Amanda ONLY) and still be made from Meredith's blood. And while you're chewing on that, explain how she stepped in Meredith's blood yet left no trace within Meredith's room.

The only comical sight I see is you coming up with lame excuses and poor attempts at humor to deflect the questions you can not answer.

Oh, and we also have you, faced with definitive evidence that proves you wrong, yet you still can't admit it. But that's not a comical sight... that's just sad.
 
This argument is like claiming a Lamborghini isn't fast because a Bugatti is faster. TMB is extremely sensitive and a negative result is treated as definitive evidence that no blood exists.

The list of substances that Luminol will react with is extensive. Every technical journal describing the use of Luminol stresses it's propensity for false positives and the absolute need to run confirmatory tests.

No one has suggested "dunked their feet in turnip juice before padding around at the time of the murder" - that's purely your imagination. From a defense POV, it's not necessary to prove, or even suggest, what the trace is from. All the defense needed to do was prove what it wasn't, and the prosecution's TMB and DNA results did that quite effectively.

So once again - explain with a credible scientific explanation how Luminol positive prints in Amanda's room could be TMB negative, DNA positive (Amanda ONLY) and still be made from Meredith's blood. And while you're chewing on that, explain how she stepped in Meredith's blood yet left no trace within Meredith's room.The only comical sight I see is you coming up with lame excuses and poor attempts at humor to deflect the questions you can not answer.

Oh, and we also have you, faced with definitive evidence that proves you wrong, yet you still can't admit it. But that's not a comical sight... that's just sad.

Please tell me you don't actually expect to get those explanations from her, do you?
 
Please tell me you don't actually expect to get those explanations from her, do you?

Of course not. Leopards never change their spots. Besides, as it relates to the test results, there is no explanation that would support her claim as it's not possible.

But I do think it's necessary to remind her from time to time that WE know there is evidence that proves her wrong, that we know she is incapable of disputing this and that her attempts to redirect or obfuscate are both obvious and, at times, entertaining.
 
Of course not. Leopards never change their spots. Besides, as it relates to the test results, there is no explanation that would support her claim as it's not possible.

But I do think it's necessary to remind her from time to time that WE know there is evidence that proves her wrong, that we know she is incapable of disputing this and that her attempts to redirect or obfuscate are both obvious and, at times, entertaining.

We most certainly do.
 
Luminol is several magnitudes more sensitive to blood than TMB.

Luminol only reacts to substances with organic ferrous substances, such as red blood cells, which may have had its colour washed out with bleach, but the iron contained therein remains and this is what luminol reacts to.

Oh, and it also reacts with horseradish and turnip juice.

So we have the comical sight of the Friends of Amanda claiming the pair dunked their feet in turnip juice before padding around at the time of the murder, thus causing the luminol to react.

So Vixen, Luminol reacts with a multitude of other substances besides blood and turnip juice. This is why among professionals it is known as a "presumptive test" for blood, not a confirmatory test, and is why it is followed by other "confirmatory tests". The confirmatory test later run by the investigators was TMB, which was negative, proving the substance was not blood.

This has been explained to you numerous times. Is there something about this you do not understand? If not, we may be able to go into a bit more detail, since you appear to have not had much of an education, and things need to be spelled out for you at a more basic level than most.

Strangely, Raff and Amanda never mentioned this in their alibis (x 5 all of which were deemed false and a pack of lies. Even Raff told the police, 'What I told you before was a bucket of ****. Amanda told me to lie for her').

His words, not mine, or the police's.

Go figure.

You used quotes here. Were those Raffaele's exact words? Or is this one of those "lies psychopaths tell" things? I hope you're not still getting your information from people who believe Amanda is still in prison, and has not been exonerated. Something is wrong with those people.
 
Last edited:
So Vixen, Luminol reacts with a multitude of other substances besides blood and turnip juice. This is why among professionals it is known as a "presumptive test" for blood, not a confirmatory test, and is why it is followed by other "confirmatory tests". The confirmatory test later run by the investigators was TMB, which was negative, proving the substance was not blood.

.... which is why it is completely beside the point to spin the argument on the relative sensitivities of Luminol vs. TMB.

How many pages of discussion here and elsewhere has gone down that rabbit hole?

The short way of looking at it is this: if luminol gives a reaction, then it could be blood. It could be other substances too.

If TMB shows that it is not blood, then it must have been one of those other substances. This is after even considering that if it had been blood, why was there no indication of a similar item of evidence in the murder room? How did Knox get the blood on the sole of her foot to begin with?

Which in turn cycles back to the core reason why the 2015 Italian Supreme Court ultimately threw out all the forensics in relation to Stefanoni's work and the two convicting courts' interpretation of those factoids.

If there are no forensics of AK or RS in the murder room, those forensic factoids found outside of the room must have some innocent explanation.

It's not rocket science. The only reason to try to make it complicated is so that a casual observer won't see the sleight of hand.
 
presumptive versus confirmatory tests for blood

TMB is still a presumptive test. Two common old-style of confirmatory tests were the Takayama test or the Teichmann (spelling?) test. A confirmatory test for blood is the RSID test that detects glycophorin A, a protein on the surface of red blood cells. There is also HemaTrace, which some but not all authors list as a confirmatory test.
 
TMB is still a presumptive test. Two common old-style of confirmatory tests were the Takayama test or the Teichmann (spelling?) test. A confirmatory test for blood is the RSID test that detects glycophorin A, a protein on the surface of red blood cells. There is also HemaTrace, which some but not all authors list as a confirmatory test.

True, TMB is a still a presumptive test. But luminol positive samples are followed up with TMB (or similar), as Stefanoni did, because it can eliminate but not confirm the source being blood. Which it did. We all know you know this. Vixen, on the other hand, also knows this but refuses to accept it in this case because it doesn't confirm her bias.

If we follow Vixen's logic that luminol is so much better at detecting blood than TMB, then it is a waste of time to ever test with TMB. Someone needs to tell all the thousands of forensic labs that they've been wrong and wasting their time all these years with those irrelevant TMB tests.
 
TMB is still a presumptive test. Two common old-style of confirmatory tests were the Takayama test or the Teichmann (spelling?) test. A confirmatory test for blood is the RSID test that detects glycophorin A, a protein on the surface of red blood cells. There is also HemaTrace, which some but not all authors list as a confirmatory test.
Agreed they are both presumptive, but I think the important thing to remember is that while positive results are considered presumptive (due to reacting to numerous non-blood substances) negative results are, for the most part, considered definitive.

I found the following summary from The GIST (The Glasgow Insight into Science and Technology) a very straightforward explanation on the use of presumptive tests. The key points to take away are;

- A positive presumptive test indicates the possible presence of blood
- All presumptive tests are presumptive because they react to numerous substances and are prone to false positives.
- A negative presumptive test is assumed to mean no blood is present.
- A positive Luminol test must be followed by confirmatory tests to prove;
- The sample is blood
- The sample is human blood
- Positive identification of who's blood it is.

I think anyone who has followed this case for any length of time, or true crime in general, would know all of this, and this would include Vixen. But apparently when the science doesn't support their theory, people like Vixen simply decide to ignore the science.

From The GIST said:
Daring to presume

All of the techniques described in this article are classed as presumptive tests. This is because they are prone to false positives so, while a negative result is assumed to mean that blood is not present, a positive result is a presumptive positive for blood and further analytical methods are required to confirm that blood is present. A negative result should be confirmed by using a positive control (for example a known blood sample) as the liquid solutions used in these presumptive tests are susceptible to degradation.

Once you have a presumptive positive for blood as well as analysis to confirm the sample is blood, you need to determine whether or not the blood is human and then you can move on to the process of attempting to discover who the blood came from.

So, magic detection sprays do exist, but sadly they do not provide all the answers that they appear to on the television. For that, more scientific analysis is required.
 
If Vixen cannot admit that the theft charges, for which AK was formally acquitted, were not "dropped", then I highly doubt she will admit that the "bloody footprints" were not made in blood as proved by the TMB.

Facts? Shmacts! Who needs facts when we've got our beliefs?
 
Two separate tests versus one single test

That summary from Glasgow is good. Sometimes the confirmatory test and the species test are covered in a single experiment.
 
Latest laugh from TJMK

"John Douglas failed to look at Knox and Sollecito’s MAJOR drug history. At UW Knox was using drugs extensively. Raf was using drugs several years before the murder. John Douglas accepted too much on faith from his source: Friends of Amanda!"

Extensive drug use???? ha ha ha ha give me a break lol there is zero evidence that apart from smoking the odd joint every now and then, like many other students (including meredith), that Amanda and raff had a drug problem. There is literally zero evidence that prior to smoking the joint with amanda, that raffaele had taken any drugs. Amanda smoking th odd joint in seattle/perugia hardly equals a drug problem. The use of drugs at universities are rife, and the majority of students will at some point experiment. The TJMK crowd like usual are trying to make a mountain out of a molehil. They do not have sources that "know" things about a secret drug history, they are desperate!
 
Latest laugh from TJMK

"John Douglas failed to look at Knox and Sollecito’s MAJOR drug history. At UW Knox was using drugs extensively. Raf was using drugs several years before the murder. John Douglas accepted too much on faith from his source: Friends of Amanda!"

Someone should tell whoever wrote this that the case has been solved, and it was solved 3 1/2 years ago - in acquittals.

And, yes, that sounds exactly like a mistake that the originator of criminal profiling would make. Simply interview the "Friends of Amanda" and take everything they said at face value.

Yes, that's it. :boggled:
 
At UW Knox was using drugs extensively. Raf was using drugs several years before the murder.

There is no evidence that Amanda used drugs other than weed...just like Meredith. There is evidence that Amanda did not use narcotics of any kind: the negative hair test. That test can show narcotics use going back months and even years. It is only limited by the length of the hair as the drugs stay in the hair forever.
The police also did a hair drug test of Raffaele which also showed no narcotics use. If it had, the prosecution would have used it.The PGP ignore these facts just like they ignore the negative TMB tests and the fact that no DNA of Meredith was found in supposed "bloody" footprints.

Willful blindness big time.
 
True, TMB is a still a presumptive test. But luminol positive samples are followed up with TMB (or similar), as Stefanoni did, because it can eliminate but not confirm the source being blood. Which it did. We all know you know this. Vixen, on the other hand, also knows this but refuses to accept it in this case because it doesn't confirm her bias.

If we follow Vixen's logic that luminol is so much better at detecting blood than TMB, then it is a waste of time to ever test with TMB. Someone needs to tell all the thousands of forensic labs that they've been wrong and wasting their time all these years with those irrelevant TMB tests.

LOL Now Stacyhs is teaching Chris Halkides chemistry. ROFLMAO
 
LOL Now Stacyhs is teaching Chris Halkides chemistry. ROFLMAO

What a stupid comment.

From someone who tries to teach Dr Peter Gill forensic-DNA analysis, and who tries to teach John Douglas police-work; and.....

..... who cannot name one bona fide scientist who ever supported Patrizia Stefanoni's forensics.

And..... who thinks Chris Halkides is wrong.

Talk about gas-lighting this thread!!!!
 
Latest laugh from TJMK

"John Douglas failed to look at Knox and Sollecito’s MAJOR drug history. At UW Knox was using drugs extensively. Raf was using drugs several years before the murder. John Douglas accepted too much on faith from his source: Friends of Amanda!"

Extensive drug use???? ha ha ha ha give me a break lol there is zero evidence that apart from smoking the odd joint every now and then, like many other students (including meredith), that Amanda and raff had a drug problem. There is literally zero evidence that prior to smoking the joint with amanda, that raffaele had taken any drugs. Amanda smoking th odd joint in seattle/perugia hardly equals a drug problem. The use of drugs at universities are rife, and the majority of students will at some point experiment. The TJMK crowd like usual are trying to make a mountain out of a molehil. They do not have sources that "know" things about a secret drug history, they are desperate!

He admitted having an LSD and cocaine drug habit, also marijuana (which is not necessarily innocuous). He wrote about it on his FB page and that his Papa threatened him with rehab.

Knox herself couldn't wait to stick the knife in, as it were, grassing on his drug use in her Prison Diary, which she knew would be read by the screws.

If you go to Amazon, you can read Nick van der Leek ;) on that topic. Perhaps even give him one star. :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom