The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've long suspected Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito were a mermaid and merman, and perhaps through their special powers present in ancient folktales were able to murder Meredith Kercher without leaving any evidence of themselves behind in the murder room.

Alternatively they just didn't do it, and the burgler who left evidence of himself everywhere Rudy Guede murdered Meredith by himself. But I for one think the magical sea creature explanation is far more likely.
 
I've long suspected Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito were a mermaid and merman, and perhaps through their special powers present in ancient folktales were able to murder Meredith Kercher without leaving any evidence of themselves behind in the murder room.

Alternatively they just didn't do it, and the burgler who left evidence of himself everywhere Rudy Guede murdered Meredith by himself. But I for one think the magical sea creature explanation is far more likely.

The pair left plenty of evidence of themselves at the murder scene. There are:

Raff's copious DNA firmly on the hook of Mez' bra
Their bloody footprints highlighted in luminol
Knox' DNA mixed in with Mez' blood
Knox' blood mixed in with Mez' blood
Their deliberate and knowingly false alibis.

Have you got an hour?
 
The pair left plenty of evidence of themselves at the murder scene. There are:

Raff's copious DNA firmly on the hook of Mez' bra
Their bloody footprints highlighted in luminol
Knox' DNA mixed in with Mez' blood
Knox' blood mixed in with Mez' blood
Their deliberate and knowingly false alibis.

Have you got an hour?

You really must get past 2009, Vix.

Love the use of "firmly on the hook". Is that intended to make us think that DNA can be "loosely" on something? Funny how not a shred of him is found on any part of Meredith's body (unlike Guede) or anywhere else on her clothing (unlike Guede) or on her purse (unlike Guede) or a handprint (unlike Guede) or a clearly identified shoeprint in blood (unlike Guede). His LCN (unlike Guede's) DNA on the bra was determined to likely be from contamination (unlike Guede).

"Bloody" footprints that tested NEGATIVE FOR BLOOD.
"Bloody" (see above) footprints that were never identified as belonging to either of them by forensics.
Gee....Knox's DNA found mixed with her roommate's in the bathroom they shared and on the floor they both walked on for months. I guess every crime scene where they find mixed DNA means the survivor is the killer, heh? They found Knox's and Sollecito's DNA mixed in four places at his apt. Who killed whom? They found Sollecito's mixed with an unidentified man's, too. Did Raffaele kill him?
Knox's blood mixed with Kercher's? Not according to ANY court, even those that convicted her.
False alibis? Um...no. No one ever proved they were not home that night. No one. Unless of course, you believe a drugged out bum with mental problems who said it was Halloween night.

Like I said, try and get past 2009.
 
Last edited:
The pair left plenty of evidence of themselves at the murder scene. There are:

Raff's copious DNA firmly on the hook of Mez' bra
Raffaele's sample was within a mixed sample where there were three other X-profiles present. Tell me who those three others were and we'll talk.
Their bloody footprints highlighted in luminol
It was never demonstrated to be blood. You realize, don't you, that it belongs to the prosecution to first demonstrate the substance, which they did not.
Knox' DNA mixed in with Mez' blood
Found in the bathroom which they'd shard for seven weeks.
Knox' blood mixed in with Mez' blood
There was no mixed blood. None of even the convicting courts claimed there had been mixed blood.
Their deliberate and knowingly false alibis.

Have you got an hour?
This took less than an hour. Compare the **one** alibi they've claimed since 2007 with the moving goalposts of motive claimed by the various prosecution teams, as well as the three courts which did not rule in their favour.

For instance, the 2013 Supreme Court annuled Hellmann's acquittals partly on the issue that the "sex game gone wrong" motive had not been explored in either of the lower acquitting or convicting courts.

And when the 2014 court took this, they substituted an "argument over rent money" motive - an issue that ONLY Rudy Guede had ever mentioned.

There. 2 minutes 40 seconds. I'm amazed you tried to slip in "mixed blood" The chief internet cut-and-paster with that had been The Machine/Harry Rag and even he's not repeated that one for four years now.
 
Last edited:
The pair left plenty of evidence of themselves at the murder scene. There are:

Raff's copious DNA firmly on the hook of Mez' bra
Their bloody footprints highlighted in luminol
Knox' DNA mixed in with Mez' blood
Knox' blood mixed in with Mez' blood
Their deliberate and knowingly false alibis.

Have you got an hour?

Of course I meant accurate, scientifically valid evidence. I didn’t mean evidence that was proven to be due to contamination or manipulative, abusive police interrogation, or flat out made up by psychopaths, even. But you already knew that, didn’t you?
 
It always astounds me that anyone with at least a normal intellect could keep claiming the "bloody footprints" nonsense when Stefanoni herself testified that TMB negative means no blood was present. Talk about willful blindness and intellectual dishonesty. Sadly, I'm seeing a lot of both recently. I wonder if it's some kind of virus.
 
You really must get past 2009, Vix.

Love the use of "firmly on the hook". Is that intended to make us think that DNA can be "loosely" on something? Funny how not a shred of him is found on any part of Meredith's body (unlike Guede) or anywhere else on her clothing (unlike Guede) or on her purse (unlike Guede) or a handprint (unlike Guede) or a clearly identified shoeprint in blood (unlike Guede). His LCN (unlike Guede's) DNA on the bra was determined to likely be from contamination (unlike Guede).

"Bloody" footprints that tested NEGATIVE FOR BLOOD.
"Bloody" (see above) footprints that were never identified as belonging to either of them by forensics.
Gee....Knox's DNA found mixed with her roommate's in the bathroom they shared and on the floor they both walked on for months. I guess every crime scene where they find mixed DNA means the survivor is the killer, heh? They found Knox's and Sollecito's DNA mixed in four places at his apt. Who killed whom? They found Sollecito's mixed with an unidentified man's, too. Did Raffaele kill him?
Knox's blood mixed with Kercher's? Not according to ANY court, even those that convicted her.
False alibis? Um...no. No one ever proved they were not home that night. No one. Unless of course, you believe a drugged out bum with mental problems who said it was Halloween night.

Like I said, try and get past 2009.


Still in denial after all these years..?
 
It always astounds me that anyone with at least a normal intellect could keep claiming the "bloody footprints" nonsense when Stefanoni herself testified that TMB negative means no blood was present. Talk about willful blindness and intellectual dishonesty. Sadly, I'm seeing a lot of both recently. I wonder if it's some kind of virus.

Add to this....

.... it's been 11 years since the horrible murder, and not one court - not one - claimed there had been mixed blood. Not one.

The convicting courts cited a lot of bogus evidence, but none of them cited mixed blood.

Yet Vixen just chucks that factoid into a post, here in August 2018 - three or four years after even The Machine/Harry Rag (still active in his own pro-guilt PR campaign) himself gave up on claiming mixed-blood.

Yet Vixen just chucks it into her post.

And around and around we go, where it stops nobody knows.
 
Add to this....

.... it's been 11 years since the horrible murder, and not one court - not one - claimed there had been mixed blood. Not one.

The convicting courts cited a lot of bogus evidence, but none of them cited mixed blood.

Yet Vixen just chucks that factoid into a post, here in August 2018 - three or four years after even The Machine/Harry Rag (still active in his own pro-guilt PR campaign) himself gave up on claiming mixed-blood.

Yet Vixen just chucks it into her post.

And around and around we go, where it stops nobody knows.

The simple answer is it will never stop. Just like there are still people who believe - and argue to that effect - that the moon landings were staged, I believe there will always be people who believe Amanda and Raffaele committed the murder. That Vixen would compile a list like this after all these years is all the evidence I need to know she will never change.

How many times has it been pointed out to her that the Luminol prints were never positively ID'ed, that they tested negative for blood and, more importantly IMO, most did not contain Meredith's DNA. She can't offer a single, credible explanation for this but nonetheless clings to the belief that they are evidence of Amanda stepping in and tracking Meredith's blood. Never mind Amanda's footprint was nowhere to be found in Meredith's bedroom. Apparently Amanda stepped in her blood but left no prints while doing so.

How many times has it been explained to her the amount of DNA extracted from the clasp, when divided by seven, results in an amount of DNA that would be considered LCN. Yet she continues to claim it was a copious amount of DNA. Yes, the entire sample was a copious amount, but since the ratio of Raffaele to Meredith was 1:6, plus other minor male donors, Raffaele's DNA contribution was minuscule. Yet she will never acknowledge this, nor can she explain how Raffaele's would be only 1/6th of Meredith's if his was a direct transfer.

Vixen's confirmation bias owns her and it always will.
 
Never mind Amanda's footprint was nowhere to be found in Meredith's bedroom. Apparently Amanda stepped in her blood but left no prints while doing so.

Vixen's confirmation bias owns her and it always will.

As far as the 2015 Supreme Court acquittals were concerned, this was the sina qua non of the case.

Of all the bogus evidence the convicting courts relied on, I've already said that many of the staples of the on-line guilter-PR campaign (like mixed blood) never even made it to those courts.

The 2015 motivations report (in explaining the acquittal) reviewed some of those bogus items - even seemed to regard some with suspicion - but in the end had to dismiss them all because.....

..... without any credible evidence that either AK or RS had been in the murder room, there must by necessity be some other explanation for the other bogus stuff. You know, things like "mixed DNA" is hardly surprising when found in the bathroom AK and the victim had shared for weeks.

And on and on this increasingly disappearing guilt-PR campaign goes. Us commenting on it here is the ONLY oxygen they get these days. Peter Quennell keeps promising doom and gloom for AK and RS as well as all who've ever agreed with their innocence, but so far all he is is a bag of wind.

We here are the only ones who put up a sail....
 
(Snip)

She can't offer a single, credible explanation for this but nonetheless clings to the belief that they are evidence of Amanda stepping in and tracking Meredith's blood. Never mind Amanda's footprint was nowhere to be found in Meredith's bedroom. Apparently Amanda stepped in her blood but left no prints while doing so.

(snip)

Vixen's confirmation bias owns her and it always will.

Good point. How does Knox step in Kercher's blood but leave no print until she gets to the hallway and Romanelli's room? Guede couldn't manage it, but somehow Knox did?

Although confirmation bias can cause people to lose objectivity, when you mix it with the inability to ever admit error, it becomes an even bigger problem.
 
Good point. How does Knox step in Kercher's blood but leave no print until she gets to the hallway and Romanelli's room? Guede couldn't manage it, but somehow Knox did?

Although confirmation bias can cause people to lose objectivity, when you mix it with the inability to ever admit error, it becomes an even bigger problem.

Very true, but this begs the question; does Vixen realize she is wrong but continues to argue these points because admitting her error is not an option, or does she really think these points are valid? And if she really does think they're valid, and if she really thinks she's as intelligent as she claims, then why can't she substantiate them. Scientifically prove a TMB negative, DNA negative sample could still be Meredith's blood. Even more challenging, explain how the prints in Amanda's bedroom, that were TMB negative, DNA positive (Amanda) were made by Meredith's blood. And explain why no prints in Meredith's bedroom, which is where Amanda would have HAD to have stepped in Meredith's blood if she was going to track it around the cottage. Vixen just won't go there because she can't (the best we ever get is her quoting Massei, as if that made it valid). IMO, she truly believes the traces are Meredith's blood and she just blacks out when evidence to the contrary is presented. Perhaps this is how her inability to admit she is wrong manifests itself. Who knows.
 
Does Vixen realize she is wrong but continues to argue these points because admitting her error is not an option, or does she really think these points are valid? And if she really does think they're valid, and if she really thinks she's as intelligent as she claims, then why can't she substantiate them. Scientifically prove a TMB negative, DNA negative sample could still be Meredith's blood. Even more challenging, explain how the prints in Amanda's bedroom, that were TMB negative, DNA positive (Amanda) were made by Meredith's blood. And explain why no prints in Meredith's bedroom, which is where Amanda would have HAD to have stepped in Meredith's blood if she was going to track it around the cottage. Vixen just won't go there because she can't (the best we ever get is her quoting Massei, as if that made it valid). IMO, she truly believes the traces are Meredith's blood and she just blacks out when evidence to the contrary is presented. Perhaps this is how her inability to admit she is wrong manifests itself. Who knows.


How does anyone of intelligence keep claiming luminol proves the presence of blood when more sensitive TMB testing says the traces were not made from blood? Quite perplexing . . . .
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom