The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I don't think I've ever seen a more blatant example of willful intellectual dishonesty than this refusal to accept what has so clearly and indisputably been proved. It's either that or being unable/unwilling to admit being wrong.
 
I don't think I've ever seen a more blatant example of willful intellectual dishonesty than this refusal to accept what has so clearly and indisputably been proved. It's either that or being unable/unwilling to admit being wrong.
Next up she'll argue that acquitting them of stealing the money and CC's means they were dropped.

Or...or... maybe it was a typo? Yeah, that's it! A clerical error that included the money and CC's in the charges brought before the court when they shouldn't have been there. It could happen, ya know. Hell, we saw it in the Marasca report when it included "for having not committed the crime"... clearly a clerical error! Italians are so careless and sloppy in their reports.

Or..... maybe she'll just change subjects and avoid it altogether. We've seen that tactic a time or three.
 
Next up she'll argue that acquitting them of stealing the money and CC's means they were dropped.

Or...or... maybe it was a typo? Yeah, that's it! A clerical error that included the money and CC's in the charges brought before the court when they shouldn't have been there. It could happen, ya know. Hell, we saw it in the Marasca report when it included "for having not committed the crime"... clearly a clerical error! Italians are so careless and sloppy in their reports.

Or..... maybe she'll just change subjects and avoid it altogether. We've seen that tactic a time or three.

I'm still waiting for her to produce any evidence that the charges were dropped. I'm also still waiting for her to explain what were those "additional charges" in part D for which they were exonerated.

I suspect we'll see a disappearing act for a while.
 
I'm still waiting for her to produce any evidence that the charges were dropped. I'm also still waiting for her to explain what were those "additional charges" in part D for which they were exonerated.

I suspect we'll see a disappearing act for a while.

I'm still waiting for Vixen to cite one, just one forensic-DNA expert who would support Scientific Police's Stefanoni's DNA forensics for the trial.

Other people have stepped up on her behalf citing only two people:

1. A professor who had told the Massei court in 2009 that Stefanoni's methods did not follow international protocol.

2. Another forensic-DNA expert who conceded that the negative controls had never been made available to him.​
That's it. Despite this, Vixen (and the remaining, all-be-they disappearing guilters) say that Stefanoni's work was sound.
 
I'm still waiting for Vixen to cite one, just one forensic-DNA expert who would support Scientific Police's Stefanoni's DNA forensics for the trial.

Other people have stepped up on her behalf citing only two people:

1. A professor who had told the Massei court in 2009 that Stefanoni's methods did not follow international protocol.

2. Another forensic-DNA expert who conceded that the negative controls had never been made available to him.​
That's it. Despite this, Vixen (and the remaining, all-be-they disappearing guilters) say that Stefanoni's work was sound.

Speaking of Stefanoni, she is now working out of the Naples office instead of the Rome office. I don't know why.
 
"Quoting two-bit hacks means nothing." I literally burst out laughing when I read your response. You've resorted to a classic Trump move: attempt to discredit the messenger when you don't like the message. Among these "two-bit hacks" is Patrick Lumumba, British journalists, Italian journalists, and the comments left by PGP. All of these "two-bit hacks" support my claim that Amanda was presented as a spoiled, rich American.




"Others would be shocked", "barely able to support herself"...LOL!! I love how you just pull (non-) facts out of your nether regions when it suits you. According to Burleigh, Amanda also had money in reserve in Seattle. How many students, there for under a year, would realistically get a "work permit"? Lumumba had no problem hiring her illegally without one but you don't mention that. You also assume that she had to work. In her book, Amanda writes that her school work was much easier than she had anticipated and she had a lot of free time so wanted to find a job. She never mentions needing money. In fact, it was Laura who helped her find the job by introducing her to Juve for that very reason. Oh, dear! Laura who was a budding lawyer and knew it would be an "under the counter" job.



Oh, please. From what you just said above, it is clear you never read any of the articles I linked. Once again, you're just making stuff up because you have nothing else.



What the H does this have go do with anything? This is all "Look! Over here! Shiny!" You really are taking a page from Trump's playbook, aren't ya?




Nope. Definitively acquitted.



It's difficult to be remorseful for an act you never committed. Are you remorseful for not having killed someone?



LOL! More assfacts! She has never claimed she was "beaten up and tortured" by anyone. By the way, she charges between $12K and $15K, not $20K according to news sources. Stop making things up.

My posts below shows three instances where Vixen has made false allegations Amanda has lied. Vixen falsely accuses Amanda of lying that she was tortured in the interrogations which makes four instances I have seen of Vixen falsely accusing Amanda of lying. Considering that Vixen is constantly banging about Amanda telling numerous lies, it is strange that Vixen has to resort to making false accusations Amanda has lied. In addition, Vixen constantly boasts about all the evidence against Amanda and Raffaele and how the case was a slam dunk. It is strange Vixen constantly has to resort to falsehoods to argue her case.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12283599#post12283599
 
DNA contamination in the Minnesota crime lab

In his report on DNA contamination in the Gary Leiterman case, Dr. Theodore Kessis also talks about an interesting event in Minnesota:

"It must be noted however that contamination errors have been documented where no direct processing link between sample and contaminant have been established, raising the specter that a source of contamination can linger in a laboratory for some time.

"One example of such is the detection of two laboratory employee’s profiles in a case processed by the Minnesota Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA). In this case, DNA from these employees was demonstrated in two separate instances despite the fact that these individuals had no relationship to the processing of any evidence in the case. Remarkably, a second error can be seen the corrective action documentation of this event. Here the reviewer notes that one of these employees is excluded as a contributor to the contamination samples, when in reality the[y] are not (Appendix 7).”

It is difficult to see how such an event could happen unless there were secondary or higher-order transfer. It is also a cautionary tale about the reliability of a laboratory's own ability to produce reliable records. Issues such as these are also at the heart of the Leiterman case itself. The relevance of these issues to the Knox/Sollecito case is that DNA contamination and unexpected DNA transfers are real events, not imaginary ones, and that there is no set number of days in between the processing of one item versus the next that guarantees a lack of accidental transfer.
 
I just took a glance at TJMK for kicks. The latest article garnered an entire 12 comments by the usual (very small) basket of despicables. The majority of these comments either talked about the World Cup entirely, never mentioning the case or mentioned the case secondary to the World Cup. :D
 
I'm still waiting for her to produce any evidence that the charges were dropped. I'm also still waiting for her to explain what were those "additional charges" in part D for which they were exonerated.

I'm predicting she does neither one but will still insist we're wrong and she's not.
 
I'm still waiting for her to produce any evidence that the charges were dropped. I'm also still waiting for her to explain what were those "additional charges" in part D for which they were exonerated.

I'm predicting she does neither one but will still insist we're wrong and she's not.

I'm not your guru. If I can pay attention and acquire knowledge, so can you.
 
I'm not your guru. If I can pay attention and acquire knowledge, so can you.

Ah, pure Vixen!:boxedin:

You can't provide any evidence that the theft charges were dropped, either. That's obvious.

If you can pay attention and learn, then why aren't you learning from this:

Exonerates the accused of the residual charge under chapter D) because it was not proven that the crime was committed.
(Massei MR)

Question: What was the residual charge under chapter D?

Answer: The theft of the money and credit cards.

It's easy to learn when you climb your way out of the rabbit hole of self-deception.*

*On second thought, this isn't a case of self-deception. It's a case of knowing you're wrong but refusing to admit it. Hmm.
 
Last edited:
Ah, pure Vixen!:boxedin:

You can't provide any evidence that the theft charges were dropped, either. That's obvious.

If you can pay attention and learn, then why aren't you learning from this:


(Massei MR)

Question: What was the residual charge under chapter D?

Answer: The theft of the money and credit cards.

It's easy to learn when you climb your way out of the rabbit hole of self-deception.*

*On second thought, this isn't a case of self-deception. It's a case of knowing you're wrong but refusing to admit it. Hmm.

Think hard. What does, 'crime did not exist' mean?
 
Think hard. What does, 'crime did not exist' mean?

Read this slowly without your selective guilt colored glasses on from the Nencini report:

The sum of 300 euro was certainly in the bedroom occupied by Meredith Kercher and it was not found after her murder, just as her credit cards were not found; such that the sum of money and the credit cards constituted an object of the theft noted in letter D) of the indictment. It is surely of interest to observe, after the elevated indictment relative to the theft of the sum of the money and the credit cards, there was no further trace of those goods in the court documents or in the minutes of the proceedings. The only reference is on page 471 of the sentence handed down by the Court of Perugia at the first trial, which reads: “the total of the given evidence that was evaluated singularly demonstrates a overall and unitary picture, without holes or incongruencies, that demands as a necessary and strictly consequential result the attribution of the hypothesized facts of the crime to both of the defendants to which is therefore declared the criminal responsibility, with exclusion of the objects of letter D) that are other than the cell phones, of which no evidence emerged incriminating the defendants, for which they are acquitted of the rest of the indictment because the crime doesn’t subsist.”
Rudy Hermann Guede was also absolved of the theft (in his case of the entire indictment) according to article 530,2 by the GUP of the Court of Perugia for not having committed the act. One understands that the Judge evaluated the circumstance as totally devoid of proof, because in the entire body of the sentence there is no evaluation on the subject.
In any case, and noting that both of the defendants and Rudy Hermann Guede were all absolved of the theft in relation to the indictment with reference to the 300 euro and the two credit cards, there remains the fact that both the money and the cards were never found; just as the fact remains that on the evening of November 1st, 2007 it does not result that anyone entered the cottage of Via della Pergola other than the defendants and Rudy Hermann Guede.

How can you seriously claim the theft charges were dropped when Nencini clearly states that all three defendants were acquitted/absolved of the money and CC thefts? Or do want to continue to claim that dropped charges receive an official court ruling? With that kind of silly thinking, I could claim the murder charges were dropped. You've embarrassed yourself enough with this one but if you want to continue down that road, carry on. But I'd think very hard about that if I were you.
 
Last edited:
You have said on several occasions that Italian law is predicated on their fascist days.


Are you now taking it back?


Now, Vixen.

Can you see the difference between a) my actual opinion (which, amazingly, you've managed to reproduce accurately in the above post of yours):

Italian law is predicated on their fascist days

and b) the opinion you ascribed to me in that previous post:

A bunch of racist fascist far right Italians, still in the thrall of Mussolini and Hitler (according to LoJo)

Please take care to consider carefully those two statements. You might be able to divine the difference in them. And then get back to me.
 
Think hard. What does, 'crime did not exist' mean?


It means that the court itself determined that no crime in respect of the money was ever even committed - that is, the money was never even proven to have been stolen, never mind by whom.
 
Last edited:
Now, Vixen.

Can you see the difference between a) my actual opinion (which, amazingly, you've managed to reproduce accurately in the above post of yours):

Italian law is predicated on their fascist days

and b) the opinion you ascribed to me in that previous post:

A bunch of racist fascist far right Italians, still in the thrall of Mussolini and Hitler (according to LoJo)

Please take care to consider carefully those two statements. You might be able to divine the difference in them. And then get back to me.

A piece of advice, LondonJohn: don't hold your breath. Admitting error, no matter how strong the evidence, is not Vixen's strong point.
 
Last edited:
From Massei MR regarding the charges of theft of the money and c. cards:

Visto l'ar. 530 cpp
Assolve gl'imputati dalla residua imputazione di cui al capo D) perché il fatto non sussiste.
From the Italian Code of Criminal Procedure VERDICTS:

Perché il fatto non sussiste :Because the action allegedly committed by the defendant never took place


According to Vixen, there are verdicts in the Italian criminal code for things that were never adjudicated by a court because they were dropped. Extraordinary!
 
Last edited:
I'm still waiting for her to produce any evidence that the charges were dropped. I'm also still waiting for her to explain what were those "additional charges" in part D for which they were exonerated.

I suspect we'll see a disappearing act for a while.[/QUOTE]

Vixen is so easy to predict. Nothing from her in days.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom