The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps because they're foolish enough to listen to the prosecution's claims instead of doing their own research or listen to other experts who have given their opinions on the prosecution's claims. As AC said, many seem to lack critical thought skills, or their confirmation bias overwhelms their ability to reason things.

For example, the claim that the mixed DNA samples from the bathroom must be mixed blood because the RFU values for Amanda's DNA is the same or greater than Meredith's, which came from blood. But this ignores the fact that Meredith's blood traces where highly diluted and Amanda's DNA likely came from saliva, which is rich in DNA. The prosecution's conclusion is not sustainable but don't tell that to the PGP, they don't want to hear it.

Er, no. The real scientists say quite clearly that Amanda's DNA is as a result of her vigorously rubbing her hands of Meredith's blood.

Remember, Mez was dead. The murderer walked her blood to the bathroom sink. Surprise, surprise we find that person to have left her bloody DNA signature: Amanda Knox.
 
Precisely.

You could bleed a pint of blood and still leave less DNA than spittle from brushing your teeth. (Probably an exaggeration). All we really know is that Amanda's and Meredith's DNA was present in their shared bathroom. The RFU values tell us nothing.

But that doesn't fit their narrative.

So how come Stefanoni is up there <fx indicates a high point> when it comes to forensic science, and you are way down there <fx indicates bottom level> ?
 
As Planigale rightly pointed out, it is unknown if the DNA/blood was actually mixed or if the DNA was simply wiped up and deposited on the swab along with the blood by the technician. The tech herself could have unwittingly mixed the DNA and blood. Watching the police video of the tech wiping large areas of the sink supports this very distinct possibility. The PGP can't admit this.

As for Amanda bleeding, it is possible to bleed profusely after being hit in the nose. I've seen the theory put forth by the PGP that Amanda was hit during a struggle with Meredith. But there are problems with this theory. Being hit hard enough in the nose to cause profuse bleeding would leave swelling and/or bruising, neither of which anyone reported seeing on Amanda. Another problem is that, if Amanda had been bleeding "profusely", she had to have cleaned it up as only those couple of small drops were found on the faucet. Which then begs the question: if she cleaned up all this "profuse" blood, why did she not clean the blood on the sink but instead pointed it out to the police?
As said earlier, these PGP are not very good at critical thinking.


Do you ever read what you write. Your logic is absolutely crazy. Imagine you have a series of blood drops, as a result, say, of a dripping knife.

Are you seriously asking us to accept your claim that Knox' blood spots innocently alternated with Mez' and therefore it was not really a mixed blood sample.

Or do we use the University of Common Sense?
 
Certainly is a slam dunk. Not even Marasca-Bruno could give them a simple 'not guilty'

giphy.gif
 
If the case against Amanda was such a slam dunk why do PGP need to resort to arguments which reek of desperation such as making Amanda's DNA in a cottage where she lived sound incriminating.
Certainly is a slam dunk. Not even Marasca-Bruno could give them a simple 'not guilty'

Well, haven't you been arguing for quite some time know that "instead of declaring them innocent" they "only were declared not guilty" (with much ado about nothing about the meaning and misquoting of Art. 530 CPP)?

So, what is it? A simple not guilty (and spare me the "not proven" nonsense) against a declaration of innocence, or as yo say now "Not even a simple not guilty"?

Just for the record:
Supreme Cout verdict.
 
Last edited:
Hahahaha If anyone is dumb, it is not Dr Stefanoni who worked as a volunteer after the Indonesia tsunami to identify victims via DNA.

As if she is not aware of the need for scientific rigour.

Killing your roommate doesn't get you off the hook just because 'oh, your honour, I lived there'.

However, I agree with your statement that your reasoning is simple.

You said it.

Only a simpleton would reason so.

I'm not sure you understand my point. I'm not arguing that Stefanoni doesn't know how to apply critical thought. I think she misused her position.

I'm referring to those that buy any bs served to them. I've mentioned religion in the past. I've yet to see a proper syllogism where the premises are true that proves a God exists or anything supernatural.

The mixed blood bs is another example of ignorant people unable or unwilling to apply critical thinking skills to the claim. Mixed DNA is NOT mixed blood PERIOD.
.
 
So how come Stefanoni is up there <fx indicates a high point> when it comes to forensic science, and you are way down there <fx indicates bottom level> ?

Why not reference somebody else? Dr. Gill and Greg Hampikian certainly disagree. As does pretty much the entire forensic community. Stefanoni couldn't even get The Rome lab to confirm her results.
 
Certainly is a slam dunk. Not even Marasca-Bruno could give them a simple 'not guilty'

The Italian Supreme Court acquitted them over three years ago. There are so few of the guilters left who deny this. You're among the last.
 
As Planigale rightly pointed out, it is unknown if the DNA/blood was actually mixed or if the DNA was simply wiped up and deposited on the swab along with the blood by the technician. The tech herself could have unwittingly mixed the DNA and blood. Watching the police video of the tech wiping large areas of the sink supports this very distinct possibility. The PGP can't admit this.

As for Amanda bleeding, it is possible to bleed profusely after being hit in the nose. I've seen the theory put forth by the PGP that Amanda was hit during a struggle with Meredith. But there are problems with this theory. Being hit hard enough in the nose to cause profuse bleeding would leave swelling and/or bruising, neither of which anyone reported seeing on Amanda. Another problem is that, if Amanda had been bleeding "profusely", she had to have cleaned it up as only those couple of small drops were found on the faucet. Which then begs the question: if she cleaned up all this "profuse" blood, why did she not clean the blood on the sink but instead pointed it out to the police?
As said earlier, these PGP are not very good at critical thinking.

Do you ever read what you write. Your logic is absolutely crazy. Imagine you have a series of blood drops, as a result, say, of a dripping knife.

Are you seriously asking us to accept your claim that Knox' blood spots innocently alternated with Mez' and therefore it was not really a mixed blood sample.

Or do we use the University of Common Sense?

Do you ever think before you write?

You create a fictitious scenario I never suggested and then ask me if I'm asking you to believe it. Priceless.

Knox's blood was found on the faucet in one place; it did not "alternate with Mez's Meredith's blood." I don't need to ask you anything about it being "mixed blood" as ALL COURTS acknowledged the mixed samples were Kercher's blood and Knox's DNA (not blood). Why do you think that is, Vix? Even you hero, Stefanoni, testified that when and how Knox's DNA was deposited in all those samples could not be determined. Why you think that wiping up visible blood and continuing to wipe in other areas of the basin with the same swatch would not pick up pre-existing DNA is one of those questions only you can answer. Heaven knows no one else can make any sense of it.

I suggest you attend the University of Getting the Facts Straight Before Mouthing Off.
 
So how come Stefanoni is up there <fx indicates a high point> when it comes to forensic science, and you are way down there <fx indicates bottom level> ?

Way up there with Stefanoni (in La La Land):

Garofano

Way down here (on the ground):

Dr. Peter Gill
Prof. Greg Hampikian
Prof. Conti
Prof. Vecchiotti
Prof. Bruce Budowle
Dr. Elizabeth Johnson
Dr. Dan Krane
Dr. Jason Gilder
Five other forensic experts who signed the open letter authored by Johnson and Hampikian.
Dr. Chris Halkides

Hmmmm...all these Ph.D's in forensics vs. Stefanoni's "Dr." which means she graduated from a four year university. Lessee here.....who knows more about forensics? Take a wild guess.
 
Er, no. The real scientists say quite clearly that Amanda's DNA is as a result of her vigorously rubbing her hands of Meredith's blood.

Remember, Mez was dead. The murderer walked her blood to the bathroom sink. Surprise, surprise we find that person to have left her bloody DNA signature: Amanda Knox.

Really? Who are these "real scientists"? You were asked on multiple occasions to provide the testimony of any expert who said that the DNA came from Amanda "vigorously rubbing her hands of Meredith's blood". You couldn't. Because no expert did testify to that.

Since, according to you, Knox's DNA in the sink comes from epithelial cells (rubbing her hands), how can that be differentiated from her DNA derived from her saliva? After all, the DNA from saliva comes from epithelial cells. How do you determine whether the swab picked up epithelial cells from washing hands or from spitting in the sink after brushing her teeth?
 
Last edited:
Really? Who are these "real scientists"? You were asked on multiple occasions to provide the testimony of any expert who said that the DNA came from Amanda "vigorously rubbing her hands of Meredith's blood". You couldn't. Because no expert did testify to that.

Since, according to you, Knox's DNA in the sink comes from epithelial cells (rubbing her hands), how can that be differentiated from her DNA derived from her saliva? After all, the DNA from saliva comes from epithelial cells. How do you determine whether the swab picked up epithelial cells from washing hands or from spitting in the sink after brushing her teeth?

Whether the DNA comes from Amanda washing her hands or brushing her teeth matters little as one does both at their own bathroom sink. Neither is remotely incriminating or is proof of a connection to the murder.

I've said it hundreds of times. They could have found Amanda's DNA throughout Meredith's bedroom and that still would have proved nothing. The context matters. Amanda lives in the cottage, we have no idea what her activities inside the house. We should expect to find her DNA. How it got there will always be wild speculation. Finding a stranger's DNA on the other is potentially probative.

That they didn't find Amanda's DNA in that beroom is almost exculpatory, but not quite.
 
Way up there with Stefanoni (in La La Land):

Garofano

Way down here (on the ground):

Dr. Peter Gill
Prof. Greg Hampikian
Prof. Conti
Prof. Vecchiotti
Prof. Bruce Budowle
Dr. Elizabeth Johnson
Dr. Dan Krane
Dr. Jason Gilder
Five other forensic experts who signed the open letter authored by Johnson and Hampikian.
Dr. Chris Halkides

Hmmmm...all these Ph.D's in forensics vs. Stefanoni's "Dr." which means she graduated from a four year university. Lessee here.....who knows more about forensics? Take a wild guess.

It's time for a golden oldie!

The Seventeen-Plus Forensic Science Sins of Patrizia Stefanoni

There was a pattern of misconduct and malpractice by Patrizia Stefanoni and the Italian Scientific Police in their forensic investigation of the murder and rape of Meredith Kercher, and the trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito, who were charged with those crimes.

The pattern of misconduct and malpractice included investigations in Patrizia Stefanoni's laboratory, the treatment of evidence, and her court testimony. She ignored and violated numerous essential technical standards for forensic science investigation, violated fundamental standards of ethical behavior, and produced invalid conclusions that contradicted logic and well-known scientific principles.

Stefanoni's misconduct and malpractice resulted in violations of the European Convention of Human Rights, Article 6, right to a fair trial, by Italy, including but not necessarily limited to, the failure to provide adequate time and facilities for the preparation of the defense (Art. 6.3b) and the failure to provide equality of arms to the defense (Art. 6.1).

Here is a summary.

1. Stefanoni failed - indeed, refused repeated requests - to turn over a copy of the best evidence of the DNA profiling investigation, the raw data, called electronic data files (EDFs), to the defense;

2. She suppressed numerous results, including potential exculpatory findings; these include blood stains from the downstairs flat, the full results of the rape kit, and results of tests on the putative semen stain on the pillow;

3. She destroyed evidence, in particular the bra clasp, preventing any DNA profile retest;

4. She entered false reports of data into her reports (RTIGF #1 & #2);

5. She committed perjury, for example, regarding the amount of DNA in the knife blade sample and that RT-PCR was used to quantify that DNA;

6. She delayed providing the minimal DNA data that was given to the defense until late in the trial;

7. She did not reveal in a timely manner to the defense and the court that TMB tests were done and precluded the presence of blood in the luminol foot print hits attributed to Amanda Knox;

8. She and her forensic police team mishandled specimen collection, in particular by swabbing large areas, failing to change gloves, failing to used DNA-free forceps for holding specimens, and by handling DNA specimens with dirty gloves;

9. She and her forensic police team mishandled chain-of-custody, specifically by repackaging the knife from Sollecito's kitchen in a police station without proper control against contamination;

10. She repeated tests that were conducted in secret (as deduced from irregularities in test sample numbering), to obtain false inculpatory results, for the kitchen knife and bra clasp;

11. She apparently manipulated positive control samples in the RT-PCR quantification to obtain high intercept levels probably in order to make unknown DNA samples appear more highly concentrated than they truly were;

12. She used the Qubit fluorometer to quantify DNA concentration in samples without having validated the equipment and procedure;

13. She arbitrarily used certain specimens registering "too low" for DNA concentration on the Qubit fluorometer for DNA profiling, and apparently not others, in a suspect-centered manner, violating good forensic practice. A reading of "too low" with the Qubit may mean there is actually no DNA present;

14. She attempted to conduct LCN DNA profiling in a method she had "invented" without validating the method;

15. She attempted to conduct LCN DNA profiling in a lab not adequately set up to prevent contamination, and thus inherently unsuited for LCN DNA profiling, which is highly sensitive to low concentrations of DNA;

16. She stated in court testimony that she had never been told of a contamination incident in her lab, however, the data she gave to the defense shows several incidents of contamination;

17. She did not supply records of methodology and quality control (such as rate of contamination and corrective measures) nor provide profiles of blank and positive control specimens to the defense, such records and control profiles are ordinarily and necessarily part of a report from a forensic DNA profiling lab;

18. She did not call out all the DNA alleles and profiles detectable on the bra clasp, instead only identifying the victim and one of the suspects (Sollecito), while DNA from several other males was detectable (indicating that the bra clasp had been contaminated).

19. Presented conclusions from the DNA data contrary to reasonable forensic science practice because of the absence of replication and the presence of contamination.
 
Vixen said:
Er, no. The real scientists say quite clearly that Amanda's DNA is as a result of her vigorously rubbing her hands of Meredith's blood.

Remember, Mez was dead. The murderer walked her blood to the bathroom sink. Surprise, surprise we find that person to have left her bloody DNA signature: Amanda Knox.
Really? Who are these "real scientists"? You were asked on multiple occasions to provide the testimony of any expert who said that the DNA came from Amanda "vigorously rubbing her hands of Meredith's blood". You couldn't. Because no expert did testify to that.
Since, according to you, Knox's DNA in the sink comes from epithelial cells (rubbing her hands), how can that be differentiated from her DNA derived from her saliva? After all, the DNA from saliva comes from epithelial cells. How do you determine whether the swab picked up epithelial cells from washing hands or from spitting in the sink after brushing her teeth?

Indeed. No expert testified to that. Not even Stefanoni at the 2009 trial. Indeed, even Judge Massei wrote that he'd (provisionally) convicted the pair on "other grounds", other than the factoid that Knox's DNA came from rubbing epithelial cells.

And it was me who asked, ad naseam, for either Vixen or the now declining pool of guilters to name one, just one, DNA expert who'd agreed with Stefanoni's work.

They offered two. Novelli and another I cannot recall at this moment. In offering those two, they probably did not know that Novelli had conceded that Stefanoni had not used international protocols in her procedure, and that the other one conceded that he'd not seen the negative controls so really could not say much.

That's it. Yet Vixen can just chuck into a sentence that, "The real scientists say quite clearly..." by dodging the question as to the identity of those scientists.

Then there's the other canard the incredibly shrinking group of guilters once offered. "Stefanoni was not the one on trial." Remember that one!
 
Last edited:
Indeed. No expert testified to that. Not even Stefanoni at the 2009 trial. Indeed, even Judge Massei wrote that he'd (provisionally) convicted the pair on "other grounds", other than the factoid that Knox's DNA came from rubbing epithelial cells.

And it was me who asked, ad naseam, for either Vixen or the now declining pool of guilters to name one, just one, DNA expert who'd agreed with Stefanoni's work.

They offered two. Novelli and another I cannot recall at this moment. In offering those two, they probably did not know that Novelli had conceded that Stefanoni had not used international protocols in her procedure, and that the other one conceded that he'd not seen the negative controls so really could not say much.

That's it. Yet Vixen can just chick into a sentence that, "The real scientists say quite clearly..." by dodging the question as to the identity of those scientists.

Then there's the other canard the incredibly shrinking group of guilters once offered. "Stefanoni was not the one on trial." Remember that one!

That's the thing with Vixen; she just keeps repeating the same old falsehoods despite her inability to provide any supporting evidence. Like Trump, she thinks we all have faulty memories and can't remember what she's said previously.
 
I leave the forum for years and years and when I come back, this is still going on?! Is this some inside joke among you people? What makes this woman so important to you?
 
I leave the forum for years and years and when I come back, this is still going on?! Is this some inside joke among you people? What makes this woman so important to you?

It's unclear which woman you refer to. If you mean "Amanda Knox", that sentiment "What makes this woman so important to you?" is a bit of a strawman.

The issues of importance at this point are perhaps twofold:

1) There's still outstanding legal action in Italy/Europe concerning the woman.

2) Albeit currently in rapid decline, there has been a multi-year guilter PR-campaign orchestrated against the woman. This campaign has virtually ignored three people:
  • Raffaele Sollecito
  • Rudy Guede, the real (solo) killer
  • Meredith Kercher
At its height the multi-year PR-campaign consisted of four websites and an effort to swamp comments' sections of any on-line newspiece that covered this. There was also an active and organized attempt to disrupt speaking engagements which Amanda Knox made to bar associations and law schools in the US and Canada.

If by "this woman" you meant the poster "Vixen", then you may have a point. When Vixen started posting in April 2015 this forum was at its peek in coverage of this subject, once sustaining a rate of 160 posts per day (per day!!!) in the weeks following the Italian Supreme Court acquittals (in 2015).

But that was then. Posts and "views" of this thread are now down about 93%, and the lone guilter these days is Vixen - not including about half a dozen on the sole remaining hate-website. Both PMF's have closed and the fake-Wiki (began by Edward McCall) has not had a meaningful update since 2014. It's orphaned.

None of this is because anyone is "important to you". My own involvement in wrongful convictions began with a family in our neighbourhood whose son spent 2 years in a Saudi prison for a crime he did not do. I knew the family and saw what it did to them. You don't forget something like that.
 
Last edited:
I leave the forum for years and years and when I come back, this is still going on?! Is this some inside joke among you people? What makes this woman so important to you?

The "inside joke" (if there is one) is to see how many times we can go around the merry-go-round without becoming petrifyingly bored.

A couple of messages upthread, Vixen made mention of the "scientists" who (in effect) supported Patrizia Stefanoni's 2009 DNA forensic analysis for the, then, prosecution in Perugia.

In this thread we've seen that horse on the merry-go-round 30 times. Vixen chucks in the word "scientists" as if it has not been demonstrated 30 times that all forensic-DNA experts say that the DNA case against Sollecito and Knox was junk.

For one thing this debunking of Stefanoni's work was established in 2011. Since then the Italian court-appointed scientists who debunked the work have themselves been the subject of an online discrediting program by the usual guilter-PR campaign suspects. Indeed, anyone who sides with the defence (which even the Italian Supreme Court eventually did) is called a paid shill or part of a Masonic-Mafia-American Media conspiracy to embarrass Italy.

It's addictive seeing the same stuff go around the merry-go-round.....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom