The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have to smile when people come on here and make a comment about us still being here, etc. Yet they were interested enough to find this thread and then to comment in it. It's not like this thread opens automatically for them when they turn on their laptop.
 
I have to smile when people come on here and make a comment about us still being here, etc. Yet they were interested enough to find this thread and then to comment in it. It's not like this thread opens automatically for them when they turn on their laptop.

Hey, I can hardly fathom it and I still make an occasional comment. Why should we care about this tiny group of deluded people and their posts? We're like people who pay to see the circus freaks. Vixen is never going to change. She's determined to post her version of the truth and we are amused by her thinking. I thought it was important at one time to correct her falsities. But that time has long past. This is just a way to fight the boredom I think.
 
Certainly is a slam dunk. Not even Marasca-Bruno could give them a simple 'not guilty'

Amanda lived in the cottage which meant it was perfectly normal for her own DNA to be found there and is not in any way incriminating. The case against Amanda was so weak and there was such a lack of evidence, PGP have to resort to desperate arguments such as making Amanda’s DNA in a place where she lived appear incriminating which destroys the notion there was a slam dunk against Amanda. If the case against Amanda and Raffaele was such a slam dunk, why does Vixen have to resort to lying on an industrial scale as shown in the posts below? Vixen still refuses to answer this question.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=11938562#post11938562
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11942852#post11942852
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11598412#post11598412
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11427461#post11427461
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11951893#post11951893
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11982023#post11982023
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12107306#post12107306
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12200863#post12200863
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12297573#post12297573
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12297575#post12297575
 
Hey, I can hardly fathom it and I still make an occasional comment. Why should we care about this tiny group of deluded people and their posts? We're like people who pay to see the circus freaks. Vixen is never going to change. She's determined to post her version of the truth and we are amused by her thinking. I thought it was important at one time to correct her falsities. But that time has long past. This is just a way to fight the boredom I think.

Like I said; pure entertainment. And Vixen is quite entertaining.
 
Whether the DNA comes from Amanda washing her hands or brushing her teeth matters little as one does both at their own bathroom sink. Neither is remotely incriminating or is proof of a connection to the murder.

I've said it hundreds of times. They could have found Amanda's DNA throughout Meredith's bedroom and that still would have proved nothing. The context matters. Amanda lives in the cottage, we have no idea what her activities inside the house. We should expect to find her DNA. How it got there will always be wild speculation. Finding a stranger's DNA on the other is potentially probative.

That they didn't find Amanda's DNA in that beroom is almost exculpatory, but not quite.

That's exactly your stance. "She could have been caught standing over Mez with a kitchen knife dripping blood, M'Lud, but that doesn't mean she did it!"
 
That's exactly your stance. "She could have been caught standing over Mez with a kitchen knife dripping blood, M'Lud, but that doesn't mean she did it!"

This is exactly what I mean by saying Vixen is pure entertainment!

Notice she doesn't address the fact that no forensic evidence, no court testimony, and no "real scientists" support the "washing her hands" bit. Notice that she doesn't address the proven scientific fact that DNA cannot be time stamped as to when it was left by someone who lived in or frequented the place it was found. Nor does she address the fact that pre-existing DNA can be transferred to the swab used to collect the sample thus producing an innocent mixed sample. She ignores the fact that saliva DNA is obtained from epithelial cells sloughed from the inside of the mouth and which are indistinguishable from the epithelial cells of hands. She ignores the fact that the foreign DNA in MK's blood was never even identified as coming from epithelial cells in the first place; it's origin is unknown. No. She ignores all this and responds with a ridiculous quip. Pure entertainment. Like Trump, you never know what she's going to come up with next. But you can bet it will be :jaw-dropp
 
That's exactly your stance. "She could have been caught standing over Mez with a kitchen knife dripping blood, M'Lud, but that doesn't mean she did it!"

Remember when known knife carrying burglar Rudy Guede was found standing over Mez dripping blood lol I wonder what it implies.
 
That's exactly your stance. "She could have been caught standing over Mez with a kitchen knife dripping blood, M'Lud, but that doesn't mean she did it!"

This is exactly what I mean by saying Vixen is pure entertainment!

Notice she doesn't address the fact that no forensic evidence, no court testimony, and no "real scientists" support the "washing her hands" bit. Notice that she doesn't address the proven scientific fact that DNA cannot be time stamped as to when it was left by someone who lived in or frequented the place it was found. Nor does she address the fact that pre-existing DNA can be transferred to the swab used to collect the sample thus producing an innocent mixed sample. She ignores the fact that saliva DNA is obtained from epithelial cells sloughed from the inside of the mouth and which are indistinguishable from the epithelial cells of hands. She ignores the fact that the foreign DNA in MK's blood was never even identified as coming from epithelial cells in the first place; it's origin is unknown. No. She ignores all this and responds with a ridiculous quip. Pure entertainment. Like Trump, you never know what she's going to come up with next. But you can bet it will be :jaw-dropp

Stacy was right, you are good for a laugh.

The presence of DNA tells us nothing about how it got there. NOTHING. It also tells us nothing about when it got there. NOTHING. All Amanda's DNA tells us is that she was in the cottage prior to its collection.. Not when she was in the cottage or what she was doing when she left it. A point that is conceded and which MB and Dr. Gill points out.
.
 
Last edited:
It's time for a golden oldie!

The Seventeen-Plus Forensic Science Sins of Patrizia Stefanoni

There was a pattern of misconduct and malpractice by Patrizia Stefanoni and the Italian Scientific Police in their forensic investigation of the murder and rape of Meredith Kercher, and the trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito, who were charged with those crimes.

The pattern of misconduct and malpractice included investigations in Patrizia Stefanoni's laboratory, the treatment of evidence, and her court testimony. She ignored and violated numerous essential technical standards for forensic science investigation, violated fundamental standards of ethical behavior, and produced invalid conclusions that contradicted logic and well-known scientific principles.

Stefanoni's misconduct and malpractice resulted in violations of the European Convention of Human Rights, Article 6, right to a fair trial, by Italy, including but not necessarily limited to, the failure to provide adequate time and facilities for the preparation of the defense (Art. 6.3b) and the failure to provide equality of arms to the defense (Art. 6.1).

Here is a summary.

1. Stefanoni failed - indeed, refused repeated requests - to turn over a copy of the best evidence of the DNA profiling investigation, the raw data, called electronic data files (EDFs), to the defense;

2. She suppressed numerous results, including potential exculpatory findings; these include blood stains from the downstairs flat, the full results of the rape kit, and results of tests on the putative semen stain on the pillow;

3. She destroyed evidence, in particular the bra clasp, preventing any DNA profile retest;

4. She entered false reports of data into her reports (RTIGF #1 & #2);

5. She committed perjury, for example, regarding the amount of DNA in the knife blade sample and that RT-PCR was used to quantify that DNA;

6. She delayed providing the minimal DNA data that was given to the defense until late in the trial;

7. She did not reveal in a timely manner to the defense and the court that TMB tests were done and precluded the presence of blood in the luminol foot print hits attributed to Amanda Knox;

8. She and her forensic police team mishandled specimen collection, in particular by swabbing large areas, failing to change gloves, failing to used DNA-free forceps for holding specimens, and by handling DNA specimens with dirty gloves;

9. She and her forensic police team mishandled chain-of-custody, specifically by repackaging the knife from Sollecito's kitchen in a police station without proper control against contamination;

10. She repeated tests that were conducted in secret (as deduced from irregularities in test sample numbering), to obtain false inculpatory results, for the kitchen knife and bra clasp;

11. She apparently manipulated positive control samples in the RT-PCR quantification to obtain high intercept levels probably in order to make unknown DNA samples appear more highly concentrated than they truly were;

12. She used the Qubit fluorometer to quantify DNA concentration in samples without having validated the equipment and procedure;

13. She arbitrarily used certain specimens registering "too low" for DNA concentration on the Qubit fluorometer for DNA profiling, and apparently not others, in a suspect-centered manner, violating good forensic practice. A reading of "too low" with the Qubit may mean there is actually no DNA present;

14. She attempted to conduct LCN DNA profiling in a method she had "invented" without validating the method;

15. She attempted to conduct LCN DNA profiling in a lab not adequately set up to prevent contamination, and thus inherently unsuited for LCN DNA profiling, which is highly sensitive to low concentrations of DNA;

16. She stated in court testimony that she had never been told of a contamination incident in her lab, however, the data she gave to the defense shows several incidents of contamination;

17. She did not supply records of methodology and quality control (such as rate of contamination and corrective measures) nor provide profiles of blank and positive control specimens to the defense, such records and control profiles are ordinarily and necessarily part of a report from a forensic DNA profiling lab;

18. She did not call out all the DNA alleles and profiles detectable on the bra clasp, instead only identifying the victim and one of the suspects (Sollecito), while DNA from several other males was detectable (indicating that the bra clasp had been contaminated).

19. Presented conclusions from the DNA data contrary to reasonable forensic science practice because of the absence of replication and the presence of contamination.

Vixen constantly claims there was a slam dunk case against Amanda and Raffaele. Anyone with a functioning brain cell should understand that the prosecution should not have to resort to the tactics listed above if they have a slam dunk case. It beggars belief that PGP say that there was a slam dunk case against Amanda and Raffaele when the prosecution had to resort to tactics such as lying, supressing evidence etc.
 
Nancy Grace at CrimeCon a little over a year ago:
Then came time for the Q&A, which Grace introduced by preempting a few common questions. "I’ll start off by saying O.J. did it," she announced. "Tot Mom did it." (Tot Mom is Grace’s preferred nickname, and hashtag, for Casey Anthony.) "Jodi Arias did it. And Steven Avery — I don’t care what that high-class lawyer who wrote that 1,200-page brief says, I don’t care what Netflix says — Steven Avery did it." The ballroom, as packed as I saw it all weekend, enthusiastically applauded their agreement.

From there, Grace took questions from the audience, responding as part oracle and part insult comic. JonBenét Ramsey’s real killer? "It’s not Burke [Ramsey]. It’s not the father … " Scott Peterson? "I’ll tell you this: He did it," she answered. "And he’s having a glass of pruno right now," she said mischievously, referencing home-made prison wine. Next was Amanda Knox, the American woman who spent nearly four years in prison in Italy on a murder conviction before she was released in 2011 and acquitted in 2015. Grace’s on-the-spot verdict: "Totally, completely guilty." No cheers or laughter this time. Grace quickly clarified that, while she doesn’t think Knox "did the stabbing" of her roommate Meredith Kercher, she was there, and she lied about it. "I mean, is that such a stretch of the imagination?" Grace asked.

A man sitting a few rows ahead of me in the dark shouted, "Yes!"
https://www.theringer.com/2017/6/28...me-nancy-grace-making-a-murderer-67136cc7ac3a

I couldn't stand Grace even before the Kercher case. She's obnoxious and full of herself.
 
Last edited:
Nancy Grace at CrimeCon a little over a year ago:

https://www.theringer.com/2017/6/28...me-nancy-grace-making-a-murderer-67136cc7ac3a

I couldn't stand Grace even before the Kercher case. She's obnoxious and full of herself.

I've never liked Grace either, and for the same reasons. But what troubles me more is when people like Grace, Alan Dershowitz and Ann Coulter blurt out opinions on cases such as this without taking the time to thoroughly investigate it first. Apparently a PR opportunity is more important to them than the potential harm they can cause the people they're commenting on. Dershowitz's comments were especially embarrassing... he should know better.
 
I've never liked Grace either, and for the same reasons. But what troubles me more is when people like Grace, Alan Dershowitz and Ann Coulter blurt out opinions on cases such as this without taking the time to thoroughly investigate it first. Apparently a PR opportunity is more important to them than the potential harm they can cause the people they're commenting on. Dershowitz's comments were especially embarrassing... he should know better.

Anne Coulter. EW. Just EWWWWWWW!!
 
I've never liked Grace either, and for the same reasons. But what troubles me more is when people like Grace, Alan Dershowitz and Ann Coulter blurt out opinions on cases such as this without taking the time to thoroughly investigate it first. Apparently a PR opportunity is more important to them than the potential harm they can cause the people they're commenting on. Dershowitz's comments were especially embarrassing... he should know better.

CNN legal analyst Paul Callan was the last mainstream holdout for guilt, meaning someone who'd actually put some effort into the case. With the early 2014 reconviction, he'd briefly crossed swords with Steve Moore on primetime CNN.

By the time of the March 2015 exonerations he'd done a complete 180. By then he'd virtually accused the Italians of kidnapping AK from 2007 to 2011. He sounded a lot like Jeffrey Toobin or Steve Moore who'd always said on CNN that the pair's innocence had always been obvious. The night of the 2011 acquittal Toobin had told CNN, "This just means that one cannot be convicted if there's no evidence to support it, not even in Italy."

Perhaps the lone holdout of anyone remotely legit is Dershowitz, but he's not commented, not really, since the 2015 acquittals... so who knows?
 
That's exactly your stance. "She could have been caught standing over Mez with a kitchen knife dripping blood, M'Lud, but that doesn't mean she did it!"

That is not what was said. Wow, the wild extrapolation between "DNA found in her home" and "standing with a knife dripping blood" is ridiculous.
 
That is not what was said. Wow, the wild extrapolation between "DNA found in her home" and "standing with a knife dripping blood" is ridiculous.

Standard for Vixen. Earlier, she invented a scenario I had never suggested and then asked me if I expected her to believe it!
 
Standard for Vixen. Earlier, she invented a scenario I had never suggested and then asked me if I expected her to believe it!

Some weeks ago Vixen defended bringing up some unconnected scenario regarding another case by calling it....

"Exactly similar."

What those two words mean when cited together, nobody knows.
 
CNN legal analyst Paul Callan was the last mainstream holdout for guilt, meaning someone who'd actually put some effort into the case. With the early 2014 reconviction, he'd briefly crossed swords with Steve Moore on primetime CNN.

By the time of the March 2015 exonerations he'd done a complete 180. By then he'd virtually accused the Italians of kidnapping AK from 2007 to 2011. He sounded a lot like Jeffrey Toobin or Steve Moore who'd always said on CNN that the pair's innocence had always been obvious. The night of the 2011 acquittal Toobin had told CNN, "This just means that one cannot be convicted if there's no evidence to support it, not even in Italy."

Perhaps the lone holdout of anyone remotely legit is Dershowitz, but he's not commented, not really, since the 2015 acquittals... so who knows?

I went back and watched the Callan/Moore exchange. Callan simply repeated the prosecution claims, including the "making out" on Nov. 2 outside the cottage, the "cartwheels", and the DNA murder knife. And yes, by 2015, Callan has completely done a 180 turn.
 
I went back and watched the Callan/Moore exchange. Callan simply repeated the prosecution claims, including the "making out" on Nov. 2 outside the cottage, the "cartwheels", and the DNA murder knife. And yes, by 2015, Callan has completely done a 180 turn.

What was notable about that CNN piece was Erin Burnett the host, who seemed stuck on, "all of Knox's odd behaviour". As if buying underwear when all your clothes are behind a police line is odd. However, Burnett and (then CNN host) Piers Morgan were the only two anchors who seemed to have had a brain cramp in relation to the case. John King seemed to have had it figured out, as did (eventually) Drew Griffin.

Of course there was legal analyst Jeffery Toobin, who seemed to go out of his way to avoid saying nasty things about Italy's system while calling RS and AK's innocence obvious. In 2011 he'd said, today's acquittal means that someone cannot be convicted without evidence even in Italy. In 2014 when he'd been on Piers Morgan's show with Gloria Allred (discussing a potential extradition request following the Nencini reconviction) he'd said, Amanda Knox isn't going anywhere; she should settle into a normal life here, as there is a lot of space within the United States to live a good and normal life.

Toobin had not gone into details but his view seemed to have been that extradition would not happen, not on "the evidence" Nencini had convicted on.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom