Was Amanda Knox told in full detail the reasons for her arrest? When was she informed that if she accused someone during questioning, she would be assuming the responsibilities of a witness and could be charged with the crime of calunnia (false accusation) if the accusation was untrue? Italian law, CPP Article 64, requires such notification by the police when a suspect is questioned.
In the ECHR case Lutsenko v. Ukraine 6492/11, the ECHR states that it is a violation of the Convention to not fully explain, in a way the person can understand, why they are being arrested or detained, and that explanation must be provided immediately upon the arrest, and not, for example, hours later.
The relevance is that Knox was apparently not informed of the reasons for her arrest, or the charges for which she was being arrested, at the time of her arrest by the Italian authorities. The defense guarantees provided by Italian laws CPP Articles 63 and 64 were not carried out by the authorities, so the arrest could not be considered in accordance with Italian law, and thus arbitrary and contrary to the European Convention of Human Rights on that basis, as well as for other reasons.
Here is a relevant excerpt from Lutsenko v. Ukraine (inline citations omitted for clarity):
"77. The Court reiterates that Article 5 § 2 of the Convention contains the elementary safeguard that any person arrested should know why he is being deprived of his liberty. By virtue of this provision any person arrested must be told, in simple, non-technical language that he can understand, the essential legal and factual grounds for his arrest, so as to be able, if he sees fit, to apply to a court to challenge its lawfulness.... In case of several concurring investigations, the authorities shall provide the person concerned with at least a minimum of information about each of them, if the materials from those investigations can serve as a basis for his detention....
78. Turning to the circumstances of the present case, the Court notes that it is in dispute between the parties whether and to what extent the applicant was informed of the formal reasons for his arrest. However, it is not disputed by the Government that at the time of his arrest on 26 December 2010 the applicant was not informed of the existing application for his detention prepared by the GPO on 25 December 2010. The Court considers that this particular event was pertinent to the applicant’s detention and ultimately served as a basis for his detention. In fact, the applicant only came to be informed of the prosecutor’s application of 25 December during the court hearings that took place on 27 December 2010, more than twenty hours after his arrest.
79. The foregoing considerations are sufficient to enable the Court to conclude that the authorities did not comply with their obligations under Article 5 § 2 of the Convention. There has accordingly been a violation of this provision."
In the ECHR case Lutsenko v. Ukraine 6492/11, the ECHR states that it is a violation of the Convention to not fully explain, in a way the person can understand, why they are being arrested or detained, and that explanation must be provided immediately upon the arrest, and not, for example, hours later.
The relevance is that Knox was apparently not informed of the reasons for her arrest, or the charges for which she was being arrested, at the time of her arrest by the Italian authorities. The defense guarantees provided by Italian laws CPP Articles 63 and 64 were not carried out by the authorities, so the arrest could not be considered in accordance with Italian law, and thus arbitrary and contrary to the European Convention of Human Rights on that basis, as well as for other reasons.
Here is a relevant excerpt from Lutsenko v. Ukraine (inline citations omitted for clarity):
"77. The Court reiterates that Article 5 § 2 of the Convention contains the elementary safeguard that any person arrested should know why he is being deprived of his liberty. By virtue of this provision any person arrested must be told, in simple, non-technical language that he can understand, the essential legal and factual grounds for his arrest, so as to be able, if he sees fit, to apply to a court to challenge its lawfulness.... In case of several concurring investigations, the authorities shall provide the person concerned with at least a minimum of information about each of them, if the materials from those investigations can serve as a basis for his detention....
78. Turning to the circumstances of the present case, the Court notes that it is in dispute between the parties whether and to what extent the applicant was informed of the formal reasons for his arrest. However, it is not disputed by the Government that at the time of his arrest on 26 December 2010 the applicant was not informed of the existing application for his detention prepared by the GPO on 25 December 2010. The Court considers that this particular event was pertinent to the applicant’s detention and ultimately served as a basis for his detention. In fact, the applicant only came to be informed of the prosecutor’s application of 25 December during the court hearings that took place on 27 December 2010, more than twenty hours after his arrest.
79. The foregoing considerations are sufficient to enable the Court to conclude that the authorities did not comply with their obligations under Article 5 § 2 of the Convention. There has accordingly been a violation of this provision."