The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have to smile when people come on here and make a comment about us still being here, etc. Yet they were interested enough to find this thread and then to comment in it. It's not like this thread opens automatically for them when they turn on their laptop.
wut?
 
This thread is my desktop, as an activex desktop background on windows 98.
 
I leave the forum for years and years and when I come back, this is still going on?! Is this some inside joke among you people? What makes this woman so important to you?

It always fascinates me when people think this case is about "this woman".

No, it's about someone being imprisoned for over 4 years with ongoing legal battles for nearly a decade while being blatantly innocent to anyone with a functioning brain. Putting people in prison for no reason is kinda bad, and it's kinda important to figure out what happened, why people are so dumb to be fooled by a prosecutor who believes in pagan witchcraft, why people believe tabloids over published science, and how to keep it all from happening again to others.
 
Safe-Keeper said:
I leave the forum for years and years and when I come back, this is still going on?! Is this some inside joke among you people? What makes this woman so important to you?
It always fascinates me when people think this case is about "this woman".

No, it's about someone being imprisoned for over 4 years with ongoing legal battles for nearly a decade while being blatantly innocent to anyone with a functioning brain. Putting people in prison for no reason is kinda bad, and it's kinda important to figure out what happened, why people are so dumb to be fooled by a prosecutor who believes in pagan witchcraft, why people believe tabloids over published science, and how to keep it all from happening again to others.

For those who follow this as if it had only been a MySpace or Facebook meme, or fodder for the tabloids (ie. forgetting that someone named Meredith Kercher had been brutally murdered) the fascination had always been about this random Seattleite who got caught up in those prosecutorial fantasies, in a matter which at the end even the Italian Supreme Court said had nothing to do with her.

Oh yes, Raffaele Sollecito also paid the price as collateral damage, as he suffered the same fate. He'd simply refused to turn on a woman who he'd known only for a week..... and risked 25 years in the slammer for that action for which he was honour bound.

But then again, was Safe-Keeper referring to the poster to this thread named Vixen?
 
Last edited:
For those who follow this as if it had only been a MySpace or Facebook meme, or fodder for the tabloids (ie. forgetting that someone named Meredith Kercher had been brutally murdered) the fascination had always been about this random Seattleite who got caught up in those prosecutorial fantasies, in a matter which at the end even the Italian Supreme Court said had nothing to do with her.

Oh yes, Raffaele Sollecito also paid the price as collateral damage, as he suffered the same fate. He'd simply refused to turn on a woman who he'd known only for a week..... and risked 25 years in the slammer for that action for which he was honour bound.

But then again, was Safe-Keeper referring to the poster to this thread named Vixen?[/QUOTE]

Good question. Safe-Keeper didn't clarify that. In this case, since Vixen is the only remaining PGP who posts in this thread, he could be referring to her or Knox. Frankly, Vixen fascinates me and the case (not Knox) fascinates me.
 
Does this remind you of anyone and his group? :D

Plotters in the deep state tried to shoot down Air Force One and foil President Trump’s North Korea summit. A cabal of global elites, including top figures in Hollywood, the Democratic Party, and the intelligence agencies, are responsible for nearly all the evil in the world. And now Trump is going to fix it all with thousands of sealed indictments, sending the likes of Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama straight to Guantanamo Bay.

Or at least that’s how the world is going for the believers of QAnon, the complex pro-Trump conspiracy theory that’s starting to having unpredictable effects in real life. The real news can be bad for Trump, but in QAnon-world, the president and his supporters really are getting sick of winning.

Who Is “Q”?

QAnon springs from a series of cryptic clues that started to be posted online in October 2017. Starting on 4Chan before migrating to the even more fringe 8Chan, the anonymous person behind the clues goes by “Q,” a reference to a high-level government security clearance. The “Anon” in “QAnon” refers to both Q himself, and to Q’s nameless supporters, the “anons.”

Q is supposed to be revealing this top-secret information via the clues, which QAnon fans have dubbed “breadcrumbs.” They’re written in a short bursts, in a reference-heavy style that’s part poem, part ransom note.
https://www.thedailybeast.com/what-is-qanon-the-craziest-theory-of-the-trump-era-explained

"Q"? Need I say it? Crazy followers who believe in conspiracy theories? (Mafia! Masons! US State Dept.! Bent judges! Bent experts!)
Revealing top-secret information? (Mignini has a behind the scenes agreement wherein Raffaele will soon publicly apologize for lying in his book!)

Too funny for words.
 
Does this remind you of anyone and his group? :D


https://www.thedailybeast.com/what-is-qanon-the-craziest-theory-of-the-trump-era-explained

"Q"? Need I say it? Crazy followers who believe in conspiracy theories? (Mafia! Masons! US State Dept.! Bent judges! Bent experts!)
Revealing top-secret information? (Mignini has a behind the scenes agreement wherein Raffaele will soon publicly apologize for lying in his book!)

Too funny for words.

Today I had been minding my own business when I bumped into a friend who had been browsing books a while ago. The friend had got immersed in all things "Monster of Florence", including Preston's book, Spezi's book, and a few other "sources" including e-books and stuff available on-line - there are a lot available on YouTube....

.... the friend started in on some of the nuttier speculations about who may or may not have been this serial killer; and started in on Michele Giuttari and Giuliano Mignini. The friend was all immersed (obsessed?) with pair's persecution of Francesco Calamandrei and Francesco Narducci and had assumed that I was up to speed on that part of Mignini's past. (Which I am not, not really....)

The friend had been aware of Amanda Knox, not fully aware of Raffaele Sollecito and had never heard of Rudy Guede. However in broad brushstrokes (without knowing too much about the Kercher murder trials) assumed that the eventual acquittal for Knox must have been the result of the Italians eventually figuring out that Giuliano Mignini had been a nut.

Of course I mentioned Mignini's failed attempt to have Sollecito and Gumbel thrown in prison because of the book "Honor Bound," and had mentioned the failed attempt to have Knox convicted of defamation for the claim she'd been slapped interrogation. I also mentioned that Mignini had eventually been censured by his peers for failing to afford Sollecito his guaranteed rights at interrogation.

In any event these real-time conversations these days are rare, and it was fun listening to someone immersed in another embarrassment for Mignini earlier in his career. I recounted Miginini's 2011 claim that his real troubles had started with the Narducci affair and the way he'd been exposed back then by Preston.

Unfortunately I did not have these pics below with me - stills taken from a now-removed YouTube video of Mignini being called up from the audience to address a "Satanism and the Law" conference.



 
Last edited:
Today I had been minding my own business when I bumped into a friend who had been browsing books a while ago.

ETA - I also mentioned that Mignini had gone after the West Seattle Herald, as well as Knox's parents. He'd also gone after Frank Sfarzo for the latter's English language blog - a blog that attracted the attention of Michael Winterbottom in his 2014 film based on Barbie Nadeau's book. The Committee for the Protection of Journalists had supported Sfarzo, and Candace Dempsey based her own book partially on information Sfarzo was able to deduce from the antics of the Perugian police.


The friend was hardly surprised by all this.
 
I think one of the most revealing things that Mignini did was actually accuse Spezi and Preston of planting fake evidence in the M of F case. It shows how far he will go to get a confession (which he failed to do). When you read Preston's account of what happened during his interview, it sounds remarkably like what Knox and Sollecito went through. Both were told to "imagine" what might have happened and given suggestions by the police or Mignini. Both were told they didn't need a lawyer. None was informed they were a suspect by the police or Mignini during their interrogations. Preston claims he never signed the typed interview statements that Mignini put before him. MIgnini claims he did. But has this alleged statement ever been presented by Mignini? Not that I'm aware of.

And this man is the hero of the PGP who can do no wrong. He's just a kindly father figure who can sleuth out the truth like his hero, Sherlock Holmes.

GAG
 
I think one of the most revealing things that Mignini did was actually accuse Spezi and Preston of planting fake evidence in the M of F case. It shows how far he will go to get a confession (which he failed to do). When you read Preston's account of what happened during his interview, it sounds remarkably like what Knox and Sollecito went through. Both were told to "imagine" what might have happened and given suggestions by the police or Mignini. Both were told they didn't need a lawyer. None was informed they were a suspect by the police or Mignini during their interrogations. Preston claims he never signed the typed interview statements that Mignini put before him. MIgnini claims he did. But has this alleged statement ever been presented by Mignini? Not that I'm aware of.

And this man is the hero of the PGP who can do no wrong. He's just a kindly father figure who can sleuth out the truth like his hero, Sherlock Holmes.

GAG

The highlighted part is all too common in all police interrogations. It is not against the law for the police to lie or mislead in their interview with anyone. Especially if there is little known, the police will often throw stuff like that into the conversation, like shaking the tree to see what falls out. If the person in the room confesses all the better.

Then again, if they follow the Reid technique, this is what they'll do (from Wikipedia):

The Reid technique's nine steps of interrogation are:
  1. Direct confrontation. Advise the suspect that the evidence has led the police to the individual as a suspect. Offer the person an early opportunity to explain why the offense took place.
  2. Try to shift the blame away from the suspect to some other person or set of circumstances that prompted the suspect to commit the crime. That is, develop themes containing reasons that will psychologically justify or excuse the crime. Themes may be developed or changed to find one to which the accused is most responsive.
  3. Try to minimize the frequency of suspect denials.
  4. At this point, the accused will often give a reason why he or she did not or could not commit the crime. Try to use this to move towards the acknowledgement of what they did.
  5. Reinforce sincerity to ensure that the suspect is receptive.
  6. The suspect will become quieter and listen. Move the theme discussion towards offering alternatives. If the suspect cries at this point, infer guilt.
  7. Pose the "alternative question", giving two choices for what happened; one more socially acceptable than the other. The suspect is expected to choose the easier option but whichever alternative the suspect chooses, guilt is admitted. As stated above, there is always a third option which is to maintain that they did not commit the crime.
  8. Lead the suspect to repeat the admission of guilt in front of witnesses and develop corroborating information to establish the validity of the confession.
  9. Document the suspect's admission or confession and have him or her prepare a recorded statement (audio, video or written).
Police use #1 regardless of whether or not the evidence has actually led the police to the person. "Can you explain why we'd bring you in?" is enough of an open ended question to get them talking.... and then the police lean on #3 to discourage the person from denying anything.

The "alternative question" step is a damned if you do, damned if you don't "when did you stop beating your wife" sort of question.

At the risk of seeming to side with Mignini on this one, what Mignini did with Preston and Knox is all too common.
 
The highlighted part is all too common in all police interrogations. It is not against the law for the police to lie or mislead in their interview with anyone. Especially if there is little known, the police will often throw stuff like that into the conversation, like shaking the tree to see what falls out. If the person in the room confesses all the better.

Then again, if they follow the Reid technique, this is what they'll do (from Wikipedia):

​
Police use #1 regardless of whether or not the evidence has actually led the police to the person. "Can you explain why we'd bring you in?" is enough of an open ended question to get them talking.... and then the police lean on #3 to discourage the person from denying anything.

The "alternative question" step is a damned if you do, damned if you don't "when did you stop beating your wife" sort of question.

At the risk of seeming to side with Mignini on this one, what Mignini did with Preston and Knox is all too common.

I understand how the Reid Technique works.
The critical difference in what Mignini did was that there was no evidence AT ALL against Spezi or Preston and no reason to believe they had anything to do with the M of F murders, the last of which had occurred over 15 earlier. They weren't truly suspects. Their "crime" was in criticizing Mignini's handling of the M of F case. This was a personal vendetta, not a criminal investigation.
 
Last edited:
I understand how the Reid Technique works.
The critical difference in what Mignini did was that there was no evidence AT ALL against Spezi or Preston and no reason to believe they had anything to do with the M of F murders. They weren't truly suspects. Their "crime" was in criticizing Mignini's handling of the M of F case. This was a personal vendetta, not a criminal investigation.

I think what you're saying is that you know why the word "vendetta" comes from Italy!

Still, it is all too common in wrongful convictions - everywhere - for interrogators to lie and present evidence they don't have.
 
Took a little wander over to TJMK to see what the latest nonsense is that their waffling on about. When i read the little box at the top i literally burst out laughing ha ha ha ha

"Breaking news: Sollecito's curse? Sources in Italy tell several of us he's unemployed, cut off from family funds, and leeching off others like himself. RS & AK dont have IQ or EQ vital for high income jobs, if Meredith had taken a Brussels or UN job she'd have out-earned the pair."

You can literally image poor pete hopping mad that Sollecito and Knox are happily leading their lives, that in pure fustration he post some BS crap to try to find something interesting to talk about.
 
Took a little wander over to TJMK to see what the latest nonsense is that their waffling on about. When i read the little box at the top i literally burst out laughing ha ha ha ha

"Breaking news: Sollecito's curse? Sources in Italy tell several of us he's unemployed, cut off from family funds, and leeching off others like himself. RS & AK dont have IQ or EQ vital for high income jobs, if Meredith had taken a Brussels or UN job she'd have out-earned the pair."

You can literally image poor pete hopping mad that Sollecito and Knox are happily leading their lives, that in pure fustration he post some BS crap to try to find something interesting to talk about.

All for Meredith.
 
ROTFLMAO at Q! The poor, pathetic, irrelevant little man. I almost feel sorry for him...almost. He's so desperate for something nasty to say that he posts this sad bunch of nonsense.

"Sources" tell him? Are they the same "sources" that assured him Raffaele and Gumbel would be publicly apologizing to Mignini in the lawsuit he "won"? If so, I suggest Slick Pete gets some new sources.

Unemployed? Last I heard, RS had a new job in Milan as a software developer. He looks pretty darn happy on his FB page, too.

I had a look at the comments on the latest "article" by The Machine. All 23 comments are by the same small handful of Old Faithfuls: Besides Quennell and The Machine, this consists of Hopeful, Cardiol, davidmulhern, Chimera, and Ergon.

Now, that bunch are definitely a "basket of deplorables" to borrow a phrase!
 
It always amazes me how the pro-guilt lunatics claims that they care about Meredith and the Kerchers, when really they are obsessed with Amanda. Amanda has become this emotional punchingbag for all the difficulties they experience in life. When a group rewrites evidence, ignores court rulings and spends half of their time fantasising about Amandas private life, you know they have lost the plot. Their delusions runs so deep they cannot see how their helping merediths sole killer, rudy guede escape real justice. If they cared about meredith they would be solely writing about rudy guede
 
It always amazes me how the pro-guilt lunatics claims that they care about Meredith and the Kerchers, when really they are obsessed with Amanda. Amanda has become this emotional punchingbag for all the difficulties they experience in life. When a group rewrites evidence, ignores court rulings and spends half of their time fantasising about Amandas private life, you know they have lost the plot. Their delusions runs so deep they cannot see how their helping merediths sole killer, rudy guede escape real justice. If they cared about meredith they would be solely writing about rudy guede

But a lone killer like Guede doesn't meet their emotional/psychological needs. Without Amanda, this would have been just your 'happens almost (if not) every day opportunistic burglary-rape-murder' story. But, with Amanda, it becomes the (fake) 'spoiled, rich, entitled, jealous, druggie, Svengali -American slut' story that they can attack with self-righteous glee. Now, which one is more exciting?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom