The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I sort of expect Italy to annul the callunia decision but expect them to deny compensation just like they did with Raffaele. I read that they have been compensating some torture victims as a result of an ECHR decision.

There's no way to rationally predict what the Italian courts will do based on any one case.

However, in the Contrada case, following the CSC judgment in his revision hearing revoking his sentence of conviction, he was reinstated in the police force for the time from when he was suspended or terminated after arrest until his formal retirement age. Then he was awarded his back pay for that period, according to the Italian media.

See:

https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/20...vra-stipendi-arretrati-con-interessi/3914045/
 
There's no way to rationally predict what the Italian courts will do based on any one case.

However, in the Contrada case, following the CSC judgment in his revision hearing revoking his sentence of conviction, he was reinstated in the police force for the time from when he was suspended or terminated after arrest until his formal retirement age. Then he was awarded his back pay for that period, according to the Italian media.

See:

https://www.ilfattoquotidiano.it/20...vra-stipendi-arretrati-con-interessi/3914045/


Thanks.

I'd like to say universally in the US compensating exonerees is handled better, but it varies so much from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.
 
Harry Rag may have given up on the "mixed blood" lie, but the lies continue on TJMK. On June 12, Hopeful wrote in the comments section of Cardiol MD's article:

The Luminol showed a bloody footprint in the hall with both Knox and Kercher’s DNA in it.

Notice there is no mention of the fact that all the luminol revealed footprints tested negative for blood with TMB. Since the footprint contained no blood, it could not be dated to the time of the murder. The footprint could have been left, innocently and normally, at any time by either of the two girls who regularly walked that hallway barefooted. But true to guilter confirmation bias, Hopeful ignores the well-known fact of the negative TMB tests.

Hopeful also wrote:

Point #10 above names 3 places where Knox DNA was found in Meredith’s blood: bidet, sink, cotton swab box.

Once again, Hopeful ignores the fact that finding the mixed DNA of people who share the same home, especially a bathroom, is common. She ignores the fact that DNA does not have to be deposited at the same time to become mixed. Why do so many guilters have such difficulty understanding that wiping up a blood sample (or any sample), deposited over/next to pre-existing DNA, can (and does) also pick up that DNA? There were five mixed DNA samples found in Sollecito's apartment (Sollecito/Knox and Sollecito/unidentified male). Blood is no different than saliva, etc. when it comes to how it can be mixed with pre-existing DNA.
 
Harry Rag may have given up on the "mixed blood" lie, but the lies continue on TJMK. On June 12, Hopeful wrote in the comments section of Cardiol MD's article:



Notice there is no mention of the fact that all the luminol revealed footprints tested negative for blood with TMB. Since the footprint contained no blood, it could not be dated to the time of the murder. The footprint could have been left, innocently and normally, at any time by either of the two girls who regularly walked that hallway barefooted. But true to guilter confirmation bias, Hopeful ignores the well-known fact of the negative TMB tests.

Hopeful also wrote:



Once again, Hopeful ignores the fact that finding the mixed DNA of people who share the same home, especially a bathroom, is common. She ignores the fact that DNA does not have to be deposited at the same time to become mixed. Why do so many guilters have such difficulty understanding that wiping up a blood sample (or any sample), deposited over/next to pre-existing DNA, can (and does) also pick up that DNA? There were five mixed DNA samples found in Sollecito's apartment (Sollecito/Knox and Sollecito/unidentified male). Blood is no different than saliva, etc. when it comes to how it can be mixed with pre-existing DNA.
We do not know the DNA was mixed. We see the video of the swabbing done over a large area of the bidet or basin. The DNA of two different individuals may have been physically separate and have been deposited at different times. As Steffanoni said in her evidence, the source of the DNA cannot be known. The time of deposition cannot be known. All we know is that the DNA of Knox and Kercher were present on the area that was swabbed, there is no evidence that they were co-located.
 
We do not know the DNA was mixed. We see the video of the swabbing done over a large area of the bidet or basin. The DNA of two different individuals may have been physically separate and have been deposited at different times. As Steffanoni said in her evidence, the source of the DNA cannot be known. The time of deposition cannot be known. All we know is that the DNA of Knox and Kercher were present on the area that was swabbed, there is no evidence that they were co-located.

You are correct. We cannot know if the samples were actually mixed or just picked up at the same time by the way the swabbing was done. But it doesn't really matter as the mixed DNA of cohabitating people is common and normal. Why the guilters think that Knox's DNA mixed with Kercher's blood means Knox killed Kercher is due only to their confirmation bias and certainly not on forensic science.
 
Harry Rag may have given up on the "mixed blood" lie, but the lies continue on TJMK. On June 12, Hopeful wrote in the comments section of Cardiol MD's article:



Notice there is no mention of the fact that all the luminol revealed footprints tested negative for blood with TMB.

It didn't contain MK's DNA either
 
It didn't contain MK's DNA either

True as no footprint revealed by luminol had both their DNA. I think Hopeful was referring to the shoe print (sample 183) found by luminol in the hallway. Who this shoe belonged to was never identified. It could have belonged to any of the girls in the house or even a visitor. Imagine, a shoe picking up (non-blood) DNA from the floor of a house where two people lived. Now, how in the world could that happen? I wonder if Hopeful could figure that out? Some people's critical thinking skills are sadly lacking.
 
Harry Rag may have given up on the "mixed blood" lie, but the lies continue on TJMK. On June 12, Hopeful wrote in the comments section of Cardiol MD's article:



Notice there is no mention of the fact that all the luminol revealed footprints tested negative for blood with TMB. Since the footprint contained no blood, it could not be dated to the time of the murder. The footprint could have been left, innocently and normally, at any time by either of the two girls who regularly walked that hallway barefooted. But true to guilter confirmation bias, Hopeful ignores the well-known fact of the negative TMB tests.

Hopeful also wrote:



Once again, Hopeful ignores the fact that finding the mixed DNA of people who share the same home, especially a bathroom, is common. She ignores the fact that DNA does not have to be deposited at the same time to become mixed. Why do so many guilters have such difficulty understanding that wiping up a blood sample (or any sample), deposited over/next to pre-existing DNA, can (and does) also pick up that DNA? There were five mixed DNA samples found in Sollecito's apartment (Sollecito/Knox and Sollecito/unidentified male). Blood is no different than saliva, etc. when it comes to how it can be mixed with pre-existing DNA.

We do not know the DNA was mixed. We see the video of the swabbing done over a large area of the bidet or basin. The DNA of two different individuals may have been physically separate and have been deposited at different times. As Steffanoni said in her evidence, the source of the DNA cannot be known. The time of deposition cannot be known. All we know is that the DNA of Knox and Kercher were present on the area that was swabbed, there is no evidence that they were co-located.

There is no reason to doubt that any "mixing" of the DNA was done by the sample collection method of swabbing (rubbing) a large area of the entire surface with one swab.

In terms of characterizing any of the falsehoods of the guilters, including those about luminol and DNA, while possibly they are due to "confirmation bias", it is also possible that they are due to "intentional misrepresentations" ("lies").

"Confirmation bias" may imply "good faith" on the part of a person with an unfortunate psychological state or false belief system. "Intentional misrepresentations" would imply "bad faith" - deception - on the part of a person possibly motivated by some agenda.

Examples of such agendas may include, but not be limited to, a desire to entertain some readers of the falsehoods, to defame Knox, to annoy those seen as supporters of Knox, or even to promote some commercial enterprise. This last motivation is the likely explanation for the falsehoods seen in the tabloids "reporting" on the Knox - Sollecito case.

To determine "why someone is spreading lies {falsehoods}, whether or not they’re doing it deliberately, is a tricky enterprise. There are plenty of reasons people create conspiracy theories....{In one case} ... a writer for a shock site ... {constructed} stories that the outlet’s leaders saw as elaborate entertainment."*

*Paraphrased from a Washington Post article:

https://www.washingtonpost.com/blog...-zuckerberg-got-wrong/?utm_term=.56e4611ba819
 
There is also the obvious: some people are just not bright enough to figure things out even when explained to them in simple terms like "TMB negative means no blood was detected". They can't quite connect "no blood detected" with "the print wasn't in blood".

This is when the guilters chime in with "but luminol is way more sensitive to blood than TMB!" Which is why forensic scientists use luminol to double check TMB negative samples for blood. Oh, wait...…..
 
Last edited:
There is also the obvious: some people are just not bright enough to figure things out even when explained to them in simple terms like "TMB negative means no blood was detected". They can't quite connect "no blood detected" with "the print wasn't in blood".

This is when the guilters chime in with "but luminol is way more sensitive to blood than TMB!" Which is why forensic scientists use luminol to double check TMB negative samples for blood. Oh, wait...…..

And while all that is interesting and true. It shouldn't make one bit of difference as this is Amanda's domicile. There is every reason to expect to find Amanda's and Meredith's DNA throughout the cottage as much as you would expect to find their belongings
 
And while all that is interesting and true. It shouldn't make one bit of difference as this is Amanda's domicile. There is every reason to expect to find Amanda's and Meredith's DNA throughout the cottage as much as you would expect to find their belongings

Exactly. Yet certain people seem to have great difficulty processing that fact. They had to resort to the "mixed blood" and the Amanda was "bleeding profusely at the same time" lie. I've not seen a single forensic expert, outside of Garofano, who ever supported that nonsense.
 
Exactly. Yet certain people seem to have great difficulty processing that fact. They had to resort to the "mixed blood" and the Amanda was "bleeding profusely at the same time" lie. I've not seen a single forensic expert, outside of Garofano, who ever supported that nonsense.

I think most people are logically impaired. Seriously, the majority of people simply have NEVER learned critical thinking. They don't understand that it only requires a simple flaw for a proposition to fail.

There is a reason Rudy's DNA at the cottage is incriminating and even with him, it is unnecessary for conviction. It's because he has no history of being upstairs at the cottage. His DNA is not supposed to be there.

The same cannot be said about Amanda. Finding her DNA is neither incriminating or exculpatory. It only proves Amanda had been in the cottage, not when. We know she was in the cottage before and after the murder. The proposition is to find evidence to prove she was there when the murder occurred. And the DNA won't do.

Why don't they get this simple reasoning?
 
I think most people are logically impaired. Seriously, the majority of people simply have NEVER learned critical thinking. They don't understand that it only requires a simple flaw for a proposition to fail.

There is a reason Rudy's DNA at the cottage is incriminating and even with him, it is unnecessary for conviction. It's because he has no history of being upstairs at the cottage. His DNA is not supposed to be there.

The same cannot be said about Amanda. Finding her DNA is neither incriminating or exculpatory. It only proves Amanda had been in the cottage, not when. We know she was in the cottage before and after the murder. The proposition is to find evidence to prove she was there when the murder occurred. And the DNA won't do.

Why don't they get this simple reasoning?

If the case against Amanda was such a slam dunk why do PGP need to resort to arguments which reek of desperation such as making Amanda's DNA in a cottage where she lived sound incriminating.
 
If the case against Amanda was such a slam dunk why do PGP need to resort to arguments which reek of desperation such as making Amanda's DNA in a cottage where she lived sound incriminating.

Perhaps because they're foolish enough to listen to the prosecution's claims instead of doing their own research or listen to other experts who have given their opinions on the prosecution's claims. As AC said, many seem to lack critical thought skills, or their confirmation bias overwhelms their ability to reason things.

For example, the claim that the mixed DNA samples from the bathroom must be mixed blood because the RFU values for Amanda's DNA is the same or greater than Meredith's, which came from blood. But this ignores the fact that Meredith's blood traces where highly diluted and Amanda's DNA likely came from saliva, which is rich in DNA. The prosecution's conclusion is not sustainable but don't tell that to the PGP, they don't want to hear it.
 
I think most people are logically impaired. Seriously, the majority of people simply have NEVER learned critical thinking. They don't understand that it only requires a simple flaw for a proposition to fail.

There is a reason Rudy's DNA at the cottage is incriminating and even with him, it is unnecessary for conviction. It's because he has no history of being upstairs at the cottage. His DNA is not supposed to be there.

The same cannot be said about Amanda. Finding her DNA is neither incriminating or exculpatory. It only proves Amanda had been in the cottage, not when. We know she was in the cottage before and after the murder. The proposition is to find evidence to prove she was there when the murder occurred. And the DNA won't do.

Why don't they get this simple reasoning?

It's not relevant this days what the past PR-guilt campaign broadcast or didn't broadcast.

In 2009, the first Italian court thought that DNA could be date-stamped, so that Knox's DNA found in the bathroom she'd shared for weeks with the victim was somehow incriminating. Judge Massei implied as much.

While at the same time ruling that it was useless to test the presumed semen stain found on the pillow under the victims hips, on the grounds that it could have been her boyfriend's, but adding that DNA could not be date-stamped.

At this point the on-line guilters are doing a disappearing act. The real issue is that in 2009, 2013 and 2014 Italian courts thought that Knox's DNA found in that bathroom was somehow incriminating.
 
It's not relevant this days what the past PR-guilt campaign broadcast or didn't broadcast.

In 2009, the first Italian court thought that DNA could be date-stamped, so that Knox's DNA found in the bathroom she'd shared for weeks with the victim was somehow incriminating. Judge Massei implied as much.

While at the same time ruling that it was useless to test the presumed semen stain found on the pillow under the victims hips, on the grounds that it could have been her boyfriend's, but adding that DNA could not be date-stamped.

At this point the on-line guilters are doing a disappearing act. The real issue is that in 2009, 2013 and 2014 Italian courts thought that Knox's DNA found in that bathroom was somehow incriminating.

Testing it would have determined whether it was Silenzi's or not so that reasoning was ridiculous.

Additionally, I think Meredith used condoms. Did the judge bother asking Silenzi if he and Meredith habitually used condoms before rendering his illogical decision?
 
Last edited:
Perhaps because they're foolish enough to listen to the prosecution's claims instead of doing their own research or listen to other experts who have given their opinions on the prosecution's claims. As AC said, many seem to lack critical thought skills, or their confirmation bias overwhelms their ability to reason things.

For example, the claim that the mixed DNA samples from the bathroom must be mixed blood because the RFU values for Amanda's DNA is the same or greater than Meredith's, which came from blood. But this ignores the fact that Meredith's blood traces where highly diluted and Amanda's DNA likely came from saliva, which is rich in DNA. The prosecution's conclusion is not sustainable but don't tell that to the PGP, they don't want to hear it.

Precisely.

You could bleed a pint of blood and still leave less DNA than spittle from brushing your teeth. (Probably an exaggeration). All we really know is that Amanda's and Meredith's DNA was present in their shared bathroom. The RFU values tell us nothing.

But that doesn't fit their narrative.
 
Exactly. Yet certain people seem to have great difficulty processing that fact. They had to resort to the "mixed blood" and the Amanda was "bleeding profusely at the same time" lie. I've not seen a single forensic expert, outside of Garofano, who ever supported that nonsense.

The PGP belief in mixed blood show how stupid the PGP are and how they are completely unable to engage in thinking. PGP don’t consider the following when thinking about mixed blood :-

* Amanda lived in the cottage which meant it was perfectly normal for Amanda to leave DNA in the bathroom. DNA can’t be time stamped which makes it impossible to determine when DNA was deposited. When Guede killed Meredith he carried Meredith’s blood into the bathroom where it was mixed with Amanda’s DNA which had been previously deposited. PGP can’t understand this simple fact.

* To bleed you need wounds for the blood to come from. Amanda was examined for wounds and no wounds were found which could cause bleeding which meant Amanda could have not been bleeding. PGP can’t understand this simple fact.

* If conclusive evidence existed Amanda had been bleeding and had deposited blood in the bathroom, this would be damming slam dunk evidence. If the prosecution had damming slam dunk evidence against Amanda, why would the prosecution need to resort to the tactics described below? PGP can’t understand the prosecution would not need to resort to these tactics if solid evidence against Amanda.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/raffaeles-kitchen-knife/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/contamination-labwork-coverup/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/meredith-kercher-perjury-corruption/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/evidence-destroyed/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/blood-evidence-downstairs-apartment/
https://knoxsollecito.wordpress.com...old-about-amanda-knox-and-raffaele-sollecito/
http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/myths.html
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11071314#post11071314

* If PGP genuinely believed Amanda had deposited her blood in the bathroom, they have so much faith in this claim and solid slam dunk evidence existed against Amanda why do PGP have to resort to lying to argue their case as detailed in the falsehoods below from Vixen?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=11938562#post11938562
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11942852#post11942852
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11598412#post11598412
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11427461#post11427461
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11951893#post11951893
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11982023#post11982023
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12107306#post12107306
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12200863#post12200863
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12297573#post12297573
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12297575#post12297575
 
The PGP belief in mixed blood show how stupid the PGP are and how they are completely unable to engage in thinking. PGP don’t consider the following when thinking about mixed blood :-

* Amanda lived in the cottage which meant it was perfectly normal for Amanda to leave DNA in the bathroom. DNA can’t be time stamped which makes it impossible to determine when DNA was deposited. When Guede killed Meredith he carried Meredith’s blood into the bathroom where it was mixed with Amanda’s DNA which had been previously deposited. PGP can’t understand this simple fact.

* To bleed you need wounds for the blood to come from. Amanda was examined for wounds and no wounds were found which could cause bleeding which meant Amanda could have not been bleeding. PGP can’t understand this simple fact.

* If conclusive evidence existed Amanda had been bleeding and had deposited blood in the bathroom, this would be damming slam dunk evidence. If the prosecution had damming slam dunk evidence against Amanda, why would the prosecution need to resort to the tactics described below? PGP can’t understand the prosecution would not need to resort to these tactics if solid evidence against Amanda.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/raffaeles-kitchen-knife/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/contamination-labwork-coverup/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/meredith-kercher-perjury-corruption/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/evidence-destroyed/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/blood-evidence-downstairs-apartment/
https://knoxsollecito.wordpress.com...old-about-amanda-knox-and-raffaele-sollecito/
http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/myths.html
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11071314#post11071314

* If PGP genuinely believed Amanda had deposited her blood in the bathroom, they have so much faith in this claim and solid slam dunk evidence existed against Amanda why do PGP have to resort to lying to argue their case as detailed in the falsehoods below from Vixen?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=11938562#post11938562
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11942852#post11942852
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11598412#post11598412
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11427461#post11427461
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11951893#post11951893
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11982023#post11982023
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12107306#post12107306
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12200863#post12200863
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12297573#post12297573
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12297575#post12297575

As Planigale rightly pointed out, it is unknown if the DNA/blood was actually mixed or if the DNA was simply wiped up and deposited on the swab along with the blood by the technician. The tech herself could have unwittingly mixed the DNA and blood. Watching the police video of the tech wiping large areas of the sink supports this very distinct possibility. The PGP can't admit this.

As for Amanda bleeding, it is possible to bleed profusely after being hit in the nose. I've seen the theory put forth by the PGP that Amanda was hit during a struggle with Meredith. But there are problems with this theory. Being hit hard enough in the nose to cause profuse bleeding would leave swelling and/or bruising, neither of which anyone reported seeing on Amanda. Another problem is that, if Amanda had been bleeding "profusely", she had to have cleaned it up as only those couple of small drops were found on the faucet. Which then begs the question: if she cleaned up all this "profuse" blood, why did she not clean the blood on the sink but instead pointed it out to the police?
As said earlier, these PGP are not very good at critical thinking.
 
I think most people are logically impaired. Seriously, the majority of people simply have NEVER learned critical thinking. They don't understand that it only requires a simple flaw for a proposition to fail.

There is a reason Rudy's DNA at the cottage is incriminating and even with him, it is unnecessary for conviction. It's because he has no history of being upstairs at the cottage. His DNA is not supposed to be there.

The same cannot be said about Amanda. Finding her DNA is neither incriminating or exculpatory. It only proves Amanda had been in the cottage, not when. We know she was in the cottage before and after the murder. The proposition is to find evidence to prove she was there when the murder occurred. And the DNA won't do.

Why don't they get this simple reasoning?

Hahahaha If anyone is dumb, it is not Dr Stefanoni who worked as a volunteer after the Indonesia tsunami to identify victims via DNA.

As if she is not aware of the need for scientific rigour.

Killing your roommate doesn't get you off the hook just because 'oh, your honour, I lived there'.

However, I agree with your statement that your reasoning is simple.

You said it.

Only a simpleton would reason so.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom