Stacyhs
Penultimate Amazing
Sometimes I think I'm the only one in the world who likes the M/B report - with the exception of the stuff in it about calunnia.
Then again when I started this I though Hellmann had got it exactly right - that Knox had been convictable but not sentencable on calunnia and innocent of the rest (as was Sollecito).
I turned out to be wrong about calunnia. I hadn't appreciated the nature of the all night interrogation until reading Mignini's own account of it, given to Drew Griffin of CNN in 2010. That was the one where Mignini had to establish he'd asked her no questions, but even with this dubious claim he said he figured out Knox was scared of Lumumba but also that she wished to keep talking. He intuited all that - and then he said he told her that if she kept talking he act as if "only a notary". Clearly, Mignini lied to Griffin. He had to because he knew that by asking questions of a suspect (when even Mignini said she was when he unquestioned her) she needed a lawyer and a proper translator. So he unquestioned her, leading to the 5:45 am, second confession that was markedly different from the one signed at 1:45 am.
It was clear to me by then that Mignini had invented the calunnia charge - which M/B says is the only thing that places Knox at the cottage, which M/B must skate around because the Chieffi court had made calunnia a judicial fact.
But...but...Mignini and the police had no reason to lie about anything!
I think that interview is the one where Mignini also claimed the interrogations weren't recorded due to "budget restraints". Uh-huh. Sure "Mr. 180,000 euros on a 20 minute animation"!