The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
AIUI the owner of the site, Michael, hasn't been heard of for about two years, leaving a couple of other volunteers to run the site in the meantime. As they are unable to contact him to get the error fixed, the site has gone down.

Thanks for the info.

It makes that PMF split in March 2011 not just ludicrous and puerile, but devastating to the "let's persecute two innocents in memory of the original victim" movement. They fell over each other to utter to most vile ad hominems thinking that that was the way to honour murder victims, and then they squabbled amongst themselves over who cared for Kercher the most.

http://www.injusticeanywhereforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=1653

ETA - It was a coffee-through-the-nose snorter back then to read the vitriol aimed at one another. One of the .NET posters went as far to claim that the .ORG moderator actually worked for the David Marriott PR firm!!!

We ran out of popcorn watching the thieves fall out with one another.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for the info.

It makes that PMF split in March 2011 not just ludicrous and puerile, but devastating to the "let's persecute two innocents in memory of the original victim" movement. They fell over each other to utter to most vile ad hominems thinking that that was the way to honour murder victims, and then they squabbled amongst themselves over who cared for Kercher the most.

http://www.injusticeanywhereforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=1653

ETA - It was a coffee-through-the-nose snorter back then to read the vitriol aimed at one another. One of the .NET posters went as far to claim that the .ORG moderator actually worked for the David Marriott PR firm!!!

We ran out of popcorn watching the thieves fall out with one another.

Oh, Bill...you're being too cynical. It was all for Meredith, dontcha know?
 
AIUI the owner of the site, Michael, hasn't been heard of for about two years, leaving a couple of other volunteers to run the site in the meantime. As they are unable to contact him to get the error fixed, the site has gone down.

I seem to recall Michael had some serious medical issues. While I truly disliked the guy I do hope he is well.

As an aside, the guy left in charge was none other than the Messiah himself. You'd think he could fix it with a wave of his hand. Unless he's a fraud??... oh, say it ain't so!
 
I need to repeat kudos to Peggy Ganong on one issue, though. The only time I ever saw Ganong moderate an ad hominem aimed at Amanda Knox, was when a poster had referred to the latter as a "slut".

Despite all the other vitriol on .ORG, once Ganong was solidly in control of it (post-March 2011) the "s" word was the one place she did not allow her users to go. Not even when used against Knox. I've had private PM's with many, many of the usual suspects on that side of the fence, but never with Ganong. If I were ever to have one with her, high on my list of inquiries would be why she drew the line where she had.



Oh I suspect I know, Bill. That "s" word is total anathema to anyone who holds/espouses strongly feminist views. And I therefore suspect that, to Ganong, any use of that nasty anti-female word overrode the feelings of personal animosity that she felt (and expressed) against Knox. To her, to allow the use of the "s" word - even against Knox - would have seemed like a betrayal of the sisterhood.
 
Oh I suspect I know, Bill. That "s" word is total anathema to anyone who holds/espouses strongly feminist views. And I therefore suspect that, to Ganong, any use of that nasty anti-female word overrode the feelings of personal animosity that she felt (and expressed) against Knox. To her, to allow the use of the "s" word - even against Knox - would have seemed like a betrayal of the sisterhood.

I have no idea why Ganong nixed the s-word, even when used against Knox. I'm not sure we'll ever know now that both PMF's are gone.
 
Was the word "tramp" still allowed by Ganong?

I used to follow the "innocentisi Tuesdays" that .NET once hosted, as well as contributed to the "Today at PMF" thread at IIP (which still exists) that paralleled it. That was a long time ago.

As for Ganong and .ORG I stopped even the periodic check-ins there at about the same time. I have no memory of anyone using the word "tramp" specifically, although there was some vitriolic word-choice, esp. in relation to Knox.

It's all history now.
 
I used to follow the "innocentisi Tuesdays" that .NET once hosted, as well as contributed to the "Today at PMF" thread at IIP (which still exists) that paralleled it. That was a long time ago.

As for Ganong and .ORG I stopped even the periodic check-ins there at about the same time. I have no memory of anyone using the word "tramp" specifically, although there was some vitriolic word-choice, esp. in relation to Knox.

It's all history now.

.PMF and . ORG may be history, but the vitriol against AK especially continues. One of the worst places is Truecrimepodcasts hosted by, imo, some real whackos. This was posted by "Travis" just last February:

One reason Knox gets these speaking gigs is that she has gone full feminist and leftist which places her in alignment with ‘oppressed’ groups, that is, women, minorities, homosexuals, and those unjustly convicted. These groups sponsor and pay her for a recitation of her oppression at the hands of the Italian justice process while ignoring the mountain of evidence against her. She was not convicted because of her slutty ways or male oppression.

Knox has an internet TV program whose theme is condemnation of those who shame women for being so called ‘sluts’. Probably hits home to Knox. I believe this was the basis for the conflict between her and Meredith. While Meredith seemingly was ‘straight-laced’, she was not a prude and she apparently demanded some commitment, affection, and emotional attachment from her partner before sex. Knox was the opposite.
https://truecrimespodcasts.com/2018...cher-murder-into-lucrative-business/#comments

I found the last bit about what Travis says regarding Meredith interesting. "Straight-laced" but not "a prude" yet she was, according to the British girls, offended by a small pink bunny vibrator being visible in a transparent cosmetic bag in the bathroom. I've always thought that whole story was a load of nonsense that the British girls twisted into something it was not when they believed Knox killed their friend. I doubt Meredith did more than mention it in passing as a funny story.

The other thing Travis says that that I find a good example of the "good girl/ bad girl" roles that the guilters cast M and A in respectively is that M had to have "some commitment, affection, and emotional attachment from her partner before sex." Nothing in M's relationship with Silenzi indicates there was any "commitment" or "emotional attachment" from him. He bragged about very private sexual things with M to his friends. He never took her out on a date. Silenzi told reporters that he "liked her" but wasn't "jealous about her". I interpret that as he didn't care if she saw other men. Follain wrote that Giacomo ignored Meredith when they met in public and that Meredith complained about how he only treated her as a "friend". Yet Silenzi's friend, Marzan, said that he thought "(Silenzi) was more into it (the relationship) than she was".

We really don't know what Meredith's pre-Italy sex life was other than she was not a virgin (nor should we care), but this portrayal of her as the innocent "good girl" is due to the need to contrast her to Amanda's "bad girl" role. Travis' post demonstrates this very well.
 
We really don't know what Meredith's pre-Italy sex life was other than she was not a virgin (nor should we care), but this portrayal of her as the innocent "good girl" is due to the need to contrast her to Amanda's "bad girl" role. Travis' post demonstrates this very well.

Travis assumed that everyone who's met Knox is both stupid and does not have internet of their own - basically that they are hostage to what Knox (and the Mafia-Media-Masonic conspiracy) tells them.

Travis also assumes that no one has ever had access to the guilter-PR effort which once included 4 websites and an active leafleting of many of the events Knox spoke at.

This is all to be considered before Travis's bizarre version of the slut/Madonna spectrum the haters have always operated from. For Pete's sake, acc. to Knox it was Meredith who told her that perhaps uncommitted sex was not for her. That's exceedingly normal conversation between friends that age.

As it always has been, Travis is trying too hard to conjure up a psychosexual theory to justify his biases rather than be led by the evidence. He probably thinks that Cassazione had not exonerated the pair in 2015.

As an aside, one should read the Wikipedia Italian language version of "The murder of Meredith Kercher". The machine translation makes it clear that Cassazione did, in fact, acquit in 2015.
 
Last edited:
AIUI the owner of the site, Michael, hasn't been heard of for about two years, leaving a couple of other volunteers to run the site in the meantime. As they are unable to contact him to get the error fixed, the site has gone down.

That's because Michael died two years ago. I am amazed this thread is still here.....
 
The relevance of the events of this article* to the Knox - Sollecito case, and especially the conviction of Knox for calunnia against Lumumba: 1) a police officer manipulates - escalates - a situation (traffic stop) in an attempt to get an arrest, although the potential arrestee is clearly innocent; 2) the motivation for the attempt to obtain an arrest, an unnamed expert claims, is that each arrest is a positive for an officer's record and career; 3) the officer's superiors and the prosecutor not only cover for the officer but retaliate against the potential arrestee for filing a complaint.

In the Knox case, the Gemelli CSC panel specifically states that her interrogation statements may be used against her for calunnia because she wrote a "defensive" memo in English, which in fact, stated that she had been coerced - including by slaps - to make the interrogation statements by the police. Furthermore: 1) her parents were accused of defamation for telling a news reporter - Follian - that Amanda Knox had been coerced and slapped by the police; and 2) Knox was charged with calunnia against the police and prosecutor for stating in open court that she had been coerced and slapped by the police. Knox was acquitted by the Boninsegna court for this charge of calunnia against the police; the Boninsegna motivation report stated that Knox had not committed the crime of calunnia against the police because there was no proof, beyond a reasonable doubt, that she did not believe that she had been subject to coercion, and indeed her defense rights had been illegally infringed, in violation of the Italian Constitution.

* https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...cials-ruined-his-life/?utm_term=.d231e0c48617
 
The relevance of the events of this article* to the Knox - Sollecito case, and especially the conviction of Knox for calunnia against Lumumba: 1) a police officer manipulates - escalates - a situation (traffic stop) in an attempt to get an arrest, although the potential arrestee is clearly innocent; 2) the motivation for the attempt to obtain an arrest, an unnamed expert claims, is that each arrest is a positive for an officer's record and career; 3) the officer's superiors and the prosecutor not only cover for the officer but retaliate against the potential arrestee for filing a complaint.

In the Knox case, the Gemelli CSC panel specifically states that her interrogation statements may be used against her for calunnia because she wrote a "defensive" memo in English, which in fact, stated that she had been coerced - including by slaps - to make the interrogation statements by the police. Furthermore: 1) her parents were accused of defamation for telling a news reporter - Follian - that Amanda Knox had been coerced and slapped by the police; and 2) Knox was charged with calunnia against the police and prosecutor for stating in open court that she had been coerced and slapped by the police. Knox was acquitted by the Boninsegna court for this charge of calunnia against the police; the Boninsegna motivation report stated that Knox had not committed the crime of calunnia against the police because there was no proof, beyond a reasonable doubt, that she did not believe that she had been subject to coercion, and indeed her defense rights had been illegally infringed, in violation of the Italian Constitution.

* https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...cials-ruined-his-life/?utm_term=.d231e0c48617

Luckily for the man in the article, there was a video showing quite clearly that the police officer's account of the encounter was false and the victim was telling the truth. I still strongly suspect that the Perugia police either deliberately did not record the interrogations knowing their tactics were illegal or they did video them and destroyed them afterwards for the same reason. There is no logical reason for them not have recorded them otherwise. And only fools believe the "we didn't have the budget" excuse.
 
That's because Michael died two years ago. I am amazed this thread is still here.....


Really? That's sad to hear. I mean I fundamentally disagreed with the man's views on this case (and often despised the way he expressed them and allowed others to express them), and he banned me from .org (as was) in a nasty summary manner in which he actually used a swear word as the "reason" for my ban.... but nonetheless it's a shame he's died.
 
And regarding the thread still being here, it's in a sort of semi-suspended-animation really (as it should be). There actually are still genuinely significant loose ends to be tied up in this case, the biggest of which is Knox's application to the ECHR (and what may happen if the ECHR ultimately rules in her favour). And of course the other factor limiting the thread's slowdown into full-on suspended animation is the continued "input" of one particular individual, which is at once both amusing and saddening at the same time.
 
HumanityBlues said:
That's because Michael died two years ago. I am amazed this thread is still here.....
And regarding the thread still being here, it's in a sort of semi-suspended-animation really (as it should be). There actually are still genuinely significant loose ends to be tied up in this case, the biggest of which is Knox's application to the ECHR (and what may happen if the ECHR ultimately rules in her favour). And of course the other factor limiting the thread's slowdown into full-on suspended animation is the continued "input" of one particular individual, which is at once both amusing and saddening at the same time.

Last count, this thread is down 93% in both postings and views from its highest, which was the days after the 2015 Cassazione acquittals. It's hard to believe that even when there was a full-throated guilter presence here (and when the force of gravity seemed to be on their side) it never got as busy as the weeks after March 2015.

The Marasca/Bruno acquital drew 157 pots per day. The Nencini conviction period drew over 160 posts per day.

Perhaps the argument should be - not so much that it is a trickle now, but that it shouldn't have been all that busy/controversial then!
 
Last edited:
Here is a May, 2016 article from Il Messaggero about the April, 2016 communication to Italy of Knox v. Italy.

Meredith, Italia sotto accusa a Strasburgo per Amanda: «Maltrattata in interrogatorio»
La Corte europea dei diritti umani ha accolto in via preliminare il ricorso contro l'Italia presentato da Amanda Knox, la ragazza prosciolta in Cassazione dall'accusa di aver partecipato all'uccisione di Meredith Kercher.

La giovane sostiene di aver subito un processo iniquo e di essere stata maltrattata durante l'interrogatorio. La Corte di Strasburgo ha ritenuto valido il dossier presentato dai legali della Knox ed ha comunicato il ricorso al governo italiano affinchè possa difendersi.

«È ora che la gente cominci ad aprire gli occhi su questa vicenda»: Raffaele Sollecito commenta così la decisione della Corte europea dei diritti umani che ha ammesso il ricorso di Amanda Knox. Lo fa rispondendo all'Ansa. «Amanda - ha detto Sollecito - è stata sentita per 15 ore senza avvocato e con un'interprete non ufficiale. Ci sono stati abusi mai rilevati mediaticamente e meno male che ci sono giudici che danno la giusta importanza a quanto successo».

Sollecito ha quindi ricordato «gli otto anni di processi subiti da due ragazzi innocenti». «A livello mediatico - ha aggiunto - è passata la nostra demonizzazione. La descrizione di due persone che non sono mai esiste nella realtà e sono del tutto estranee alla morte di quella povera ragazza. Per questo - ha concluso Sollecito - non mi stancherò mai di denunciare quanto successo».

Martedì 17 Maggio 2016

Source: https://www.ilmessaggero.it/primopiano/cronaca/meredith_italia_strasburgo_amanda-1739375.html


Meredith: Italy accused in Strasbourg by Amanda: "Abused in interrogation"

The European Court of Human Rights has preliminarily accepted the application against Italy presented by Amanda Knox, the girl acquitted by the Supreme Court of the accusation of having participated in the killing of Meredith Kercher.

The young woman claims to have undergone an unfair trial and to have been mistreated during the interrogation. The Court of Strasbourg found the dossier submitted by Knox's lawyers to be valid and notified the Italian government of the application so that it can defend itself.

“It is time for people to open their eyes to this matter": Raffaele Sollecito commented on the decision of the European Court of Human Rights that admitted the application of Amanda Knox. He did this by responding to {a request for comments from the Italian press agency} Ansa. “Amanda” - Sollecito said - “was heard for 15 hours without a lawyer and with an unofficial interpreter. There have been abuses never detected by the media and thank goodness there are judges {of the ECHR} who give due importance to what happened”.

Sollecito then recalled "the eight years of trials suffered by two innocent youths". "At the media level” - he added - “our demonization has passed. The description of two people who never existed in reality and are completely unrelated to the death of that poor girl. For this” - concluded Sollecito - “I will never tire of denouncing what happened”.

Tuesday 17 May 2016

From: Il Messaggero

Translation by Google translate with my help.
 
Last edited:
.
.
.
“It is time for people to open their eyes to this matter": Raffaele Sollecito commented on the decision of the European Court of Human Rights that admitted the application of Amanda Knox. He did this by responding to {a request for comments from the Italian press agency} Ansa. “Amanda” - Sollecito said - “was heard for 15 hours without a lawyer and with an unofficial interpreter. There have been abuses never detected by the media and thank goodness there are judges {of the ECHR} who give due importance to what happened”.

Sollecito then recalled "the eight years of trials suffered by two innocent youths". "At the media level” - he added - “our demonization has passed. The description of two people who never existed in reality and are completely unrelated to the death of that poor girl. For this” - concluded Sollecito - “I will never tire of denouncing what happened”.
.
.
.


Very, very powerful summation by Sollecito
 
Numbers said:
“It is time for people to open their eyes to this matter": Raffaele Sollecito commented on the decision of the European Court of Human Rights that admitted the application of Amanda Knox. He did this by responding to {a request for comments from the Italian press agency} Ansa. “Amanda” - Sollecito said - “was heard for 15 hours without a lawyer and with an unofficial interpreter. There have been abuses never detected by the media and thank goodness there are judges {of the ECHR} who give due importance to what happened”.

Sollecito then recalled "the eight years of trials suffered by two innocent youths". "At the media level” - he added - “our demonization has passed. The description of two people who never existed in reality and are completely unrelated to the death of that poor girl. For this” - concluded Sollecito - “I will never tire of denouncing what happened”.
Very, very powerful summation by Sollecito

Quite. Sollecito faces a different issue in Italy. He's said that Italians tend to vilify any famous person, not even so much because of the villainy that they were once associated with.

Even doing a cursory survey of 2018 Italian views of the murder in Perugia in 2007 shows that nearly all are onside wit actual innocence of the pair. The Italian language Wikipedia page on this was a bit of a surprise for how blunt it is as to their innocence.

The road to recovery of reputation for both has nothing to do with Rudy Guede's heinous act. Strangley, there have been some who try to repair Guede's reputation, and State TV has played a role in that. It has never really gained traction, which is good to see.

But the challenges Sollecito faces in Italy has to do with his notoriety, not the case per se.
 
Here's an Italian media article which, while noting a decrease in the amounts of money Italy must expend for violations of the European Convention of Human Rights, includes a reference to Knox v. Italy:

From: http://www.ilsole24ore.com/art/norm...ioni--204128.shtml?uuid=AEF3BBOC&refresh_ce=1

6 settembre 2017
corte europea dei diritti dell’uomo
Indennizzi per la violazione dei diritti umani, crollo delle multe all’Italia: da 77 a 16 milioni
Un deciso cambio di rotta che ha portato a una netta diminuzione dell’importo degli indennizzi che l’Italia è tenuta a versare alle vittime di violazioni della Convenzione europea dei diritti dell’uomo commesse a livello nazionale e accertate da Strasburgo. Dai 77 milioni di euro versati nel 2015, l’Italia è scesa a quasi 16 milioni nel 2016 (erano poco più di 5 nel 2014). Un dato positivo, quello che risulta dalla relazione annuale sull’esecuzione delle pronunce della Corte europea dei diritti dell’uomo nei confronti dell’Italia presentata il 1° settembre 2017, con riferimento al 2016, dal Dipartimento per gli affari giuridici e legislativi della Presidenza del Consiglio dei ministri.

L’Italia ha visto anche una diminuzione dei ricorsi pendenti scendendo dal quarto al sesto posto e, per quanto riguarda le sentenze, Roma migliora di ben 5 posizioni la situazione in classifica: 15 le sentenze di condanna che portano fuori l’Italia dalla classifica dei primi dieci Stati con il maggior numero di condanne. Dato positivo, l’indice di ricambio superiore al 93%: in pratica, i procedimenti chiusi sono stati 2.730, un numero di gran lunga superiore rispetto ai nuovi ricorsi assegnati a una formazione giudiziaria (1.409). Questo - si legge nella relazione - vuol dire che il volume dei ricorsi pendenti è pari a 6.180 casi, con un decremento del 18,33% rispetto al 2015 (7.567), anno che già aveva portato a un abbattimento del contenzioso pendente del 50% rispetto al 2014 (14.400 ricorsi pendenti).

….

Per quanto riguarda i ricorsi pendenti di più grande rilievo sono segnalati il caso Berlusconi relativo alla legge Severino in materia di incandidabilità; il ricorso Sallusti sulla previsione del carcere per i giornalisti in caso di diffamazione; i ricorsi sul danno all’ambiente e alla salute relativi all’Ilva, nonché il ricorso di Amanda Knox per le limitazioni del diritto di difesa.


September 6, 2017
A decisive change of course that has led to a sharp reduction in the amount of compensation that Italy is required to pay to victims of violations of the European Convention on Human Rights committed at national level and verified by Strasbourg. From the 77 million euros paid in 2015, Italy fell to almost 16 million in 2016 (they were just over 5 in 2014). A positive result, what emerges from the annual report on the execution of the rulings of the European Court of Human Rights against Italy presented on 1 September 2017, with reference to 2016, by the Department for Legal and Legislative Affairs of the Presidency of the Council of Ministers.

Italy has also seen a decrease in applications pending from the fourth to sixth place and, as regards the judgments, Rome improves the situation in the ranking of 5 positions: 15 sentences of condemnation that lead Italy out of the ranking of first ten states with the highest number of convictions. On a positive note, the turnover index was over 93%: in practice, the closed proceedings were 2,730, a far greater number than the new applications assigned to judicial training (1,409). This - we read in the report - means that the volume of pending applications is equal to 6,180 cases, with a decrease of 18.33% compared to 2015 (7,567), a year that had already led to a reduction in the pending litigation of 50% compared to 2014 (14,400 applications pending).
....

These are the pending applications of greater significance reported {by the ECHR}: the Berlusconi case concerning the Severino law regarding ineligibility for office; the application of Sallusti on the sentence of prison for journalists in a case of defamation; applications alleging damage to the environment and health related to Ilva, as well as the application of Amanda Knox regarding the limitations of the right of defense {in her conviction for calunnia}.
_____

For balance, it should be pointed out that there has been a large increase in cases (applications) from certain eastern European countries, which has also helped decrease the relative number of cases (applications) from Italy.
___
Translation by Google translate with my help.
 
Last edited:
The European Court of Human Rights has preliminarily accepted the application against Italy presented by Amanda Knox, the girl acquitted by the Supreme Court of the accusation of having participated in the killing of Meredith Kercher.

The young woman claims to have undergone an unfair trial and to have been mistreated during the interrogation. The Court of Strasbourg found the dossier submitted by Knox's lawyers to be valid and notified the Italian government of the application so that it can defend itself.

So much for the May 24, 2018 claim by TJMK that "Knox apologists still repost Dalla Vedova’s wrong claim that the ECHR has already “accepted” Knox’s case. It has not," and "Four and a half years down the line and still no decision as to the admissibility of Knox’s ECHR application." The article in Il Messaggero was published a full two years before TJMK's false claim, where they also accused the BBC of "being wrong" when they reported the same thing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom