The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
So much for the May 24, 2018 claim by TJMK that "Knox apologists still repost Dalla Vedova’s wrong claim that the ECHR has already “accepted” Knox’s case. It has not," and "Four and a half years down the line and still no decision as to the admissibility of Knox’s ECHR application." The article in Il Messaggero was published a full two years before TJMK's false claim, where they also accused the BBC of "being wrong" when they reported the same thing.

Peter Quennell lied!? Say it ain't so!
 
So much for the May 24, 2018 claim by TJMK that "Knox apologists still repost Dalla Vedova’s wrong claim that the ECHR has already “accepted” Knox’s case. It has not," and "Four and a half years down the line and still no decision as to the admissibility of Knox’s ECHR application." The article in Il Messaggero was published a full two years before TJMK's false claim, where they also accused the BBC of "being wrong" when they reported the same thing.

There are obvious misrepresentations and lies by the guilters regarding the ECHR application and many other aspects of the case.

The ECHR has indeed accepted Amanda Knox's application; the evidence for that is that it was communicated to Italy - to allow Italy to formulate a defense - in April, 2016. Communication of a case by the ECHR means that, insofar as the ECHR can determine at the time of the communication, the case and each claim conveyed in the communication is admissible.

Now, an allowed defense by the respondent state (Italy) is a counter-claim that an application or individual claims in an application are not admissible. The respondent state must indicate any such counter-claim of inadmissibility in its initial response to the communication.

Since there has been no ECHR decision of inadmissibility listed in HUDOC for the case of Knox v. Italy or any claim of that case, it must be understood that the case and all its claims remain pending the ECHR's judgment on the merits. That judgment will include, based on ECHR's usual practice, a decision on the admissibility of each claim listing any counter-claim on admissibility for that claim by Italy, the response by the applicant (Knox), and the ECHR's evaluation. For the claims listed in the Country Profile for Italy summary of Knox v. Italy, it is unlikely that there would be any claim decided inadmissible by the ECHR, as long as each claim was repeated in substance in the final domestic appeal to the Chieffi CSC panel, or had been previously finalized, for example, by the Gemelli CSC panel.
 
Last edited:
Peter Quennell lied!? Say it ain't so!

I'm not so sure it's a case of "lying" as the (few remaining) main posters/contributors on TJMK are so far down the rabbit hole that I suspect they really believe it. They have an uncanny ability to see only what they want /need to see.
 
I'm not so sure it's a case of "lying" as the (few remaining) main posters/contributors on TJMK are so far down the rabbit hole that I suspect they really believe it. They have an uncanny ability to see only what they want /need to see.

There can be a distinction between lying and uttering a falsehood, not knowing it was false.

But when someone utters a falsehood about an easily and objectively determinable fact because they chose to follow (or claimed to follow) their personal beliefs and do not bother to investigate and to truthfully report: that is also lying.

For example: Suppose, regarding an income tax filing, someone earned (based on objective records) $100,000 in a year, but claimed on the tax form, based on their sincere belief, they had only earned $10,000 in that year. That would be considered perjury by the federal government, if the filer did not correct the return to correspond to the objective record.

Here's another example, relevant to this case:

A police officer is sitting in on the questioning of a person, and observes another police officer strike that person to obtain a desired response to a question.

The first police officer sincerely believes that the person being questioned is guilty of some crime, and also believes that the police are morally allowed to hit someone, especially a guilty person, to get that person to utter a desired response.

When questioned, the first police officer states that the person questioned was treated correctly and certainly was not hit by any police officer during the questioning.

Is that statement by the police officer a lie? Does it matter whether or not the police officer had certain sincere beliefs about how the questioning of a person he sincerely believed was guilty should be conducted?
 
Last edited:
There can be a distinction between lying and uttering a falsehood, not knowing it was false.

But when someone utters a falsehood about an easily and objectively determinable fact because they chose to follow (or claimed to follow) their personal beliefs and do not bother to investigate and to truthfully report: that is also lying.
For example: Suppose, regarding an income tax filing, someone earned (based on objective records) $100,000 in a year, but claimed on the tax form, based on their sincere belief, they had only earned $10,000 in that year. That would be considered perjury by the federal government, if the filer did not correct the return to correspond to the objective record.

Here's another example, relevant to this case:

A police officer is sitting in on the questioning of a person, and observes another police officer strike that person to obtain a desired response to a question.

The first police officer sincerely believes that the person being questioned is guilty of some crime, and also believes that the police are morally allowed to hit someone, especially a guilty person, to get that person to utter a desired response.

When questioned, the first police officer states that the person questioned was treated correctly and certainly was not hit by any police officer during the questioning. Is that statement by the police officer a lie? Does it matter whether or not the police officer had certain sincere beliefs about how the questioning of a person he sincerely believed was guilty should be conducted?

Regarding the first highlight: I disagree that it is lying. Blinded by bias? Yes. Having an alternate reality? Yes. Many guilters still claim... and believe... that the TMB negative results do not mean the luminol highlighted footprints were not in blood. That they were not in blood is "an easily and objectively determinable fact" yet the reject it and proffer ludicrous excuses. Why? Because their bias will not allow them to believe otherwise.

Second highlight: I don't think that's a good analogy. Yes, it would be a lie. Whether or not the officer believes "that the police are morally allowed to hit someone", he would still be lying if he says the other officer did not hit the suspect. And he would know that he was lying. His personal belief as to its morality would not change the fact it happened.

I really do think that many of these diehard guilters truly believe things that have been proved false such as Amanda's "bloody footprints", the selective "clean-up" of the murder scene, the timing of the 911 call by Raffaele, et al.
 
Last edited:
Regarding the first highlight: I disagree that it is lying. Blinded by bias? Yes. Having an alternate reality? Yes. Many guilters still claim... and believe... that the TMB negative results do not mean the luminol highlighted footprints were not in blood. That they were not in blood is "an easily and objectively determinable fact" yet the reject it and proffer ludicrous excuses. Why? Because their bias will not allow them to believe otherwise.

Second highlight: I don't think that's a good analogy. Yes, it would be a lie. Whether or not the officer believes "that the police are morally allowed to hit someone", he would still be lying if he says the other officer did not hit the suspect. And he would know that he was lying. His personal belief as to its morality would not change the fact it happened.

I really do think that many of these diehard guilters truly believe things that have been proved false such as Amanda's "bloody footprints", the selective "clean-up" of the murder scene, the timing of the 911 call by Raffaele, et al.

Here's my point: if the person making the false claim has not investigated the easily obtained record of the truth, whether or not they "believe" their statement, and claim that their false statement is a factual statement, they are lying. If they are claiming their statement is "true" they should have factual support for it; making the claim without such support is just another form of lying.

Here's another hypothetical which may show my point:

A country's chief executive claims that his country is contributing 90% of the total funding of an international organization. A check of the actual records show that the actual contribution is only 20% of that organization's funding. Is the chief executive lying? What if that chief executive sincerely believes his statement to be true, perhaps based on some news report or opinion that did not rely on actual records? Does the chief executive have a responsibility to check actual records?

If an internet poster claims that they have posted a statement that is true, but that statement is obviously contradicted by other, readily obtained information known to be true, is that poster's statement not a lie? Even if the statement is based upon a delusion, the statement must be regarded as a lie, because only a psychiatrist or similar expert evaluating that poster in person could be sure that the statement was based upon a delusion. To every person simply reading the internet post, who is not the poster's psychiatrist, it must be considered a lie.
 
Last edited:
Here's my point: if the person making the false claim has not investigated the easily obtained record of the truth, whether or not they "believe" their statement, and claim that their false statement is a factual statement, they are lying. If they are claiming their statement is "true" they should have factual support for it; making the claim without such support is just another form of lying.

Here's another hypothetical which may show my point:

A country's chief executive claims that his country is contributing 90% of the total funding of an international organization. A check of the actual records show that the actual contribution is only 20% of that organization's funding. Is the chief executive lying? What if that chief executive sincerely believes his statement to be true, perhaps based on some news report or opinion that did not rely on actual records? Does the chief executive have a responsibility to check actual records?

If a person truly believes something then they are not lying. That their belief is based on incorrect or incomplete information or even a conscious choice not to investigate that belief, it is still their belief and, therefore, not a lie. A lie is " a false statement made with deliberate intent to deceive; an intentional untruth." If a person believes something to be true, then there is no intent to deceive or to deliberately deceive.

Not that the guilters don't intentionally lie. We saw this with the "Mignini really won his lawsuit against Sollecito who will be making a public apology soon." nonsense.
 
If a person truly believes something then they are not lying. That their belief is based on incorrect or incomplete information or even a conscious choice not to investigate that belief, it is still their belief and, therefore, not a lie. A lie is " a false statement made with deliberate intent to deceive; an intentional untruth." If a person believes something to be true, then there is no intent to deceive or to deliberately deceive.

Not that the guilters don't intentionally lie. We saw this with the "Mignini really won his lawsuit against Sollecito who will be making a public apology soon." nonsense.

So you confirm that, in your opinion, the police officer who witnessed the person who was hit during police questioning in order to make her say certain desired responses, but testified that he saw only that the person questioned was treated correctly and was not hit, and has so testified because of sincere beliefs or delusions including that a police officer hitting someone believed to be guilty isn't really hitting that person, is not lying, even if said testimony is false.
 
So you confirm that, in your opinion, the police officer who witnessed the person who was hit during police questioning in order to make her say certain desired responses, but testified that he saw only that the person questioned was treated correctly and was not hit, and has so testified because of sincere beliefs or delusions including that a police officer hitting someone believed to be guilty isn't really hitting that person, is not lying, even if said testimony is false.

Not at all. I fail to see how you could infer that from what I said. As I said earlier:

"Yes, it would be a lie. Whether or not the officer believes "that the police are morally allowed to hit someone", he would still be lying if he says the other officer did not hit the suspect. And he would know that he was lying. His personal belief as to its morality would not change the fact it happened."

He may believe the other officer had the moral right to hit the suspect, but to deny it happened would be lying.
 
If a person truly believes something then they are not lying. That their belief is based on incorrect or incomplete information or even a conscious choice not to investigate that belief, it is still their belief and, therefore, not a lie. A lie is " a false statement made with deliberate intent to deceive; an intentional untruth." If a person believes something to be true, then there is no intent to deceive or to deliberately deceive.

Not that the guilters don't intentionally lie. We saw this with the "Mignini really won his lawsuit against Sollecito who will be making a public apology soon." nonsense.

So you confirm that, in your opinion, the police officer who witnessed the person who was hit during police questioning in order to make her say certain desired responses, but testified that he saw only that the person questioned was treated correctly and was not hit, and has so testified because of sincere beliefs or delusions including that a police officer hitting someone believed to be guilty isn't really hitting that person, is not lying, even if said testimony is false.

The issue with the guilters' misstatements or lies is one of "intent" and how an observer of someone's behavior - such as internet posts - can "know" the "intent" of that person in posting. How does one "know", for example, that a post that contains a false statement is based on "sincerely held beliefs" or "delusions" rather than an intent to deceive, for example, as a "hoax"? If someone makes a false statement in a post, claiming it is true, on some matter that is readily checked, there is no reason for an observer not to consider it a lie. The poster making the false statement - intentionally, so it is a lie - may simply be too naive or uneducated in that specific area to realize that the falsity of the statement is readily detectable. The "reason" for the lie, if any, is "unknowable" and not necessarily important.

The same issues apply to the obviously false statements that appear in some of the motivation reports of the Italian courts in this case.
Some examples: 1) the Nencini court MR claimed that there had been a clean-up of the DNA of Knox and Sollecito while Guede's remained; 2) Nencini also claimed that Sollecito's DNA was found on the knife; and 3) Nencini claimed that the male DNA on the bra clasp not attributed to Sollecito was the result of the bra being touched by Kercher's female friends.

Are these false statements the result of delusions in the Italian court system - since perhaps they are truly believed by those writing the MR - or are they lies, because the judicial authors have an obligation to check the evidence, including known science, even if that means consulting experts or the literature?
 
Not at all. I fail to see how you could infer that from what I said. As I said earlier:

"Yes, it would be a lie. Whether or not the officer believes "that the police are morally allowed to hit someone", he would still be lying if he says the other officer did not hit the suspect. And he would know that he was lying. His personal belief as to its morality would not change the fact it happened."

He may believe the other officer had the moral right to hit the suspect, but to deny it happened would be lying.

The officer believes, very sincerely or delusionally, that the alleged hitting was "encouraging the obviously guilty suspect to tell the truth".

Hitting is something else. The police are not the ones on trial here, according to the prosecutors.
 
The officer believes, very sincerely or delusionally, that the alleged hitting was "encouraging the obviously guilty suspect to tell the truth".

Hitting is something else. The police are not the ones on trial here, according to the prosecutors.

I fail to see your point here. Again, denying the hitting happened would be lying no matter what his personal beliefs are regarding the morality of hitting suspects.
 
I fail to see your point here. Again, denying the hitting happened would be lying no matter what his personal beliefs are regarding the morality of hitting suspects.

The police officers, the prosecutors, and the Italian judges who commit "official misconduct" by making false statements are lying. Whether or not they are doing so as a result of "sincere beliefs" or even delusions is irrelevant. That's the point.

The guilters, as you acknowledged in a previous post, are also lying, at least for some of their false statements. You pointed out:

"Not that the guilters don't intentionally lie. We saw this with the "Mignini really won his lawsuit against Sollecito who will be making a public apology soon." nonsense."

But you also wish to maintain that:

"I'm not so sure it's a case of "lying" as the (few remaining) main posters/contributors on TJMK are so far down the rabbit hole that I suspect they really believe it. They have an uncanny ability to see only what they want /need to see. "

And you give an example of this as:

"Many guilters still claim... and believe... that the TMB negative results do not mean the luminol highlighted footprints were not in blood. That they were not in blood is "an easily and objectively determinable fact" yet the reject it and proffer ludicrous excuses. Why? Because their bias will not allow them to believe otherwise."

So, sometimes you consider that the nonsensical and false statements in guilter posts are intentional falsehoods - lies - but sometimes, you maintain, the falsehoods are not lies because - based upon your knowledge or your assumption - you claim that the guilters really believe those other statements because of their bias.

I don't believe that I can marshal evidence to convince you that your argument may have a logical inconsistency. It seems to me that it does, because I can't tell when a guilter makes a false statement with intent to deceive or, on the other hand, makes it because of a bias.

And I suspect that false statements made with intent to deceive (lies) may be made because of bias. Furthermore, what if the false statements are made with the intent of gaining support, favor, or amusement among other guilters, or of causing supposed discomfort to the (guilters' assumed) "pro-Knox" PIP?

So perhaps we should end this discussion by agreeing that the Italian judges who needed to make false statements or ignore exculpatory evidence in their motivation reports in order to provisionally convict Knox and Sollecito of the murder/rape of Kercher, or to finally convict Knox of calunnia against Lumumba, were not lying, but delusional or biased. Or maybe they were delusional and biased liars.
 
Last edited:
The police officers, the prosecutors, and the Italian judges who commit "official misconduct" by making false statements are lying. Whether or not they are doing so as a result of "sincere beliefs" or even delusions is irrelevant. That's the point.

The guilters, as you acknowledged in a previous post, are also lying, at least for some of their false statements. You pointed out:

"Not that the guilters don't intentionally lie. We saw this with the "Mignini really won his lawsuit against Sollecito who will be making a public apology soon." nonsense."

But you also wish to maintain that:

"I'm not so sure it's a case of "lying" as the (few remaining) main posters/contributors on TJMK are so far down the rabbit hole that I suspect they really believe it. They have an uncanny ability to see only what they want /need to see. "

And you give an example of this as:

"Many guilters still claim... and believe... that the TMB negative results do not mean the luminol highlighted footprints were not in blood. That they were not in blood is "an easily and objectively determinable fact" yet the reject it and proffer ludicrous excuses. Why? Because their bias will not allow them to believe otherwise."

So, sometimes you consider that the nonsensical and false statements in guilter posts are intentional falsehoods - lies - but sometimes, you maintain, the falsehoods are not lies because - based upon your knowledge or your assumption - you claim that the guilters really believe those other statements because of their bias.

I don't believe that I can marshal evidence to convince you that your argument may have a logical inconsistency. It seems to me that it does, because I can't tell when a guilter makes a false statement with intent to deceive or, on the other hand, makes it because of a bias.

And I suspect that false statements made with intent to deceive (lies) may be made because of bias. Furthermore, what if the false statements are made with the intent of gaining support, favor, or amusement among other guilters, or of causing supposed discomfort to the (guilters' assumed) "pro-Knox" PIP?

So perhaps we should end this discussion by agreeing that the Italian judges who needed to make false statements or ignore exculpatory evidence in their motivation reports in order to provisionally convict Knox and Sollecito of the murder/rape of Kercher, or to finally convict Knox of calunnia against Lumumba, were not lying, but delusional or biased. Or maybe they were delusional and biased liars.

Frankly, I've lost interest in this topic. I'm too engrossed in that travesty that played out in Congress today with Strzok.
 
Frankly, I've lost interest in this topic. I'm too engrossed in that travesty that played out in Congress today with Strzok.
It all started with me wondering if Peter Quennell had lied about the ECHR not accepting Knox's review of the calunnia conviction in Italy.

That part is actually not knowable. At best he got it wrong as Numbers has documented. At worst he lied.

There it sits.
 
It all started with me wondering if Peter Quennell had lied about the ECHR not accepting Knox's review of the calunnia conviction in Italy.

That part is actually not knowable. At best he got it wrong as Numbers has documented. At worst he lied.

There it sits.

One point is that the guilters, with a high degree of consistency, post false and misleading statements about the Knox - Sollecito case.

If they are doing so with intent to deceive (who?), then, as Stacyhs points out, they are lying.

If they have no intent to deceive, why are they resistant to accepting objective information that corrects their false or misleading statements relating to the Knox - Sollecito case? That resistance may indeed be a sign of bias, and bias may induce a conscious or unconscious tendency to not obtain all the relevant information initially, thereby resulting in erroneous statements in posts. And bias may also induce a conscious tendency to lie (knowingly posting false or misleading statements).

But I am not skilled at distinguishing bias-induced errors from intentional falsehoods (lies). I interpret the rejection of empirically-based evidence and logical reasoning by the guilters as intentional, although possibly motivated by bias.

Others may see the consistent production of false and misleading statements relating to this Knox - Sollecito case by the guilters differently.
 
Last edited:
It all started with me wondering if Peter Quennell had lied about the ECHR not accepting Knox's review of the calunnia conviction in Italy.

That part is actually not knowable. At best he got it wrong as Numbers has documented. At worst he lied.

There it sits.

One point is that the guilters, with a high degree of consistency, post false and misleading statements about the Knox - Sollecito case.

If they are doing so with intent to deceive (who?), then, as Stacyhs points out, they are lying.

If they have no intent to deceive, why are they resistant to accepting objective information that corrects their false or misleading statements relating to the Knox - Sollecito case? That resistance may indeed be a sign of bias, and bias may induce a conscious or unconscious tendency to not obtain all the relevant information initially, thereby resulting in erroneous statements in posts. And bias may also induce a conscious tendency to lie (knowingly posting false or misleading statements).

But I am not skilled at distinguishing bias-induced errors from intentional falsehoods (lies). I interpret the rejection of empirically-based evidence and logical reasoning by the guilters as intentional, although possibly motivated by bias.

Others may see the consistent production of false and misleading statements relating to this Knox - Sollecito case by the guilters differently.

To the above, I add that the views of anonymous internet posters are not especially important to the eventual resolution of an ECHR case such as Knox v. Italy. Readers of the posts may or may not find them informative or otherwise of value.

However, of more importance to the final resolution of the case, which must depend, as I understand from my (necessarily limited) reading of Italian law and ECHR case-law, on a revision trial conducted by the Italian judicial system, may be statements in a judicial motivation report.

And the Marasca CSC panel motivation report contains what appears to be false statements that have the potential to unfairly influence Amanda Knox's interests in a just revision trial on the charge of calunnia against Patrick Lumumba.
 
Last edited:
And the Marasca CSC panel motivation report contains what appears to be false statements that have the potential to unfairly influence Amanda Knox's interests in a just revision trial on the charge of calunnia against Patrick Lumumba.
Sometimes I think I'm the only one in the world who likes the M/B report - with the exception of the stuff in it about calunnia.

Then again when I started this I though Hellmann had got it exactly right - that Knox had been convictable but not sentencable on calunnia and innocent of the rest (as was Sollecito).

I turned out to be wrong about calunnia. I hadn't appreciated the nature of the all night interrogation until reading Mignini's own account of it, given to Drew Griffin of CNN in 2010. That was the one where Mignini had to establish he'd asked her no questions, but even with this dubious claim he said he figured out Knox was scared of Lumumba but also that she wished to keep talking.

He intuited all that - and then he said he told her that if she kept talking he act as if "only a notary".

Clearly, Mignini lied to Griffin. He had to because he knew that by asking questions of a suspect (when even Mignini said she was when he unquestioned her) she needed a lawyer and a proper translator.

So he unquestioned her, leading to the 5:45 am, second confession that was markedly different from the one signed at 1:45 am.

It was clear to me by then that Mignini had invented the calunnia charge - which M/B says is the only thing that places Knox at the cottage, which M/B must skate around because the Chieffi court had made calunnia a judicial fact.
 
So has anything of substance happened lately? Vixen-generated noise has robbed this thread of its erstwhile utility as an information source for those of us with an on-and-off interest in the matter.
 
So has anything of substance happened lately? Vixen-generated noise has robbed this thread of its erstwhile utility as an information source for those of us with an on-and-off interest in the matter.

In December 2017 Mignini and Comodi did a TV production (available on YouTube I believe) where they basically retried the case. There was not much opposition to them. I watched it but clicked off of it when Comodi said it was quite normal to let DNA evidence sit in situ for 46 days, and that that had not been a relevant factor in the collection procedure.

What else? Peter Quennell once maintained that Mignini had actually won his defamation action(s) against Sollecito and Gumbel for "Honor Bound", Sollecito's book. Even though the criminal side of that had been thrown out, and that Mignini had withdrawn the civil action - Quennell maintained that proof that Mignini had won was the promised public apology by both Gumbel and Sollecito; and apology that Sollecito and Gumbel (apparently) did not know they were to have provided.

Both PMF websites are now gone, one because the owner passed away two years ago, and he'd been the only one in position to correct some (now) corrupted code.

The two acquitted/exonerated people are getting on with their lives, and the victim's family continues to have an empty place at the table.

The Masonic/Mafia/Big Media conspiracy has turned to other things.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom