The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
The latest nonsense article by Chimera on TJMK (up for a week) has garnered all of 5 comments by 3 people. LMAO!
 
The latest nonsense article by Chimera on TJMK (up for a week) has garnered all of 5 comments by 3 people. LMAO!

What's it about? What could possibly be of interest 3+ years after the exonerations by Italy's Supreme Court?
 
The latest nonsense article by Chimera on TJMK (up for a week) has garnered all of 5 comments by 3 people. LMAO!

I assume you are referring to the one titled:

Knox v Knox 8: How She Herself Provides Proofs Of Lies #70 To #90


The entire concept of the list is to post Amanda's testimony in trial and compare it to what she wrote in her book, to demonstrate inconsistencies which then, I assume, must mean she is lying.

But here's an interesting tidbit about the sheer stupidity of this list. Of the 20 items listed (70-90) only two of them quote from the book. The other 18 he essentially says "nothing about this in the book but here's what I think....". Worse still, not one of the 20 represents a contradiction - not one!

You'd think at least one of the three people still using the site would have pointed out to Chimera that his list makes no sense at all, but I guess at this point Quennell figures anything to keep the hate going is better than nothing.

Since we've been discussing the lamp -again- I'll share this gem from the list of 20;

71 Trial Versus Book

Knox At Trial In 2009

FM: In your room in via della Pergola, was there a central light?
AK: There was one but it didn’t work, so I used the little bedside lamp.
FM: The lamp.
AK: The little lamp, yes.
FM: And you previously stated that you didn’t look for the lamp either; you only looked for your computer when you went into your room. You didn’t look for your money, you didn’t look for your lamp.
AK: So, I saw the window only the second time that I entered the house. The first time I went into the house I didn’t even think of looking to see if anything was missing, because I saw going into the living room, it really looked like someone had just gone out of the house, everything was in order, just as I had left it. But the second time, I didn’t even think of looking for the lamp: the computer was the important thing for me. All my documents were in it.
FM: But the first time, when you took your shower and then you returned to your room, first you undressed and then you dressed, all this, you did it without any light?
AK: It was the middle of the morning, there was already light.
FM: Did you open your shutters or were they already open?
AK: I don’t remember.
FM: To get to your room, to get to the window, you walked in the dark?
AK: But it wasn’t dark in my room. Often—
FM: I don’t know, I wasn’t there.
AK: All right. Usually I only turned on that little lamp at night. Really at night, or in the evening, when I wanted to…So I didn’t even think of turning it on. It really wasn’t dark in my room when I went in.
GCM: It wasn’t dark, but where was the light coming from? Natural light?
AK: Natural.

Knox In Her Book 2013-15

[Comments] No mention of any of this. The missing lamp is only a red flag, and despite repeated questioning, AK dances around it

*****
The rest of the list doesn't get any better so no need for anyone to waste their time and give Quennell a site hit. It does, however, provide an interesting insight into the inner workings of a guilter's critical thought process, or lack thereof. I didn't bother reading 1-69 but there's no reason to think they are any more insightful.
 
I agree, Numbers.

Over on TJMK they are so desperate for filler for their dying website that they're recycling all the "lies" story Knox allegedly told by posting parts of her trial testimony and then proclaiming that because these things were not discussed n her book, this is evidence her testimony was lies. For example, because Amanda doesn't mention in her book about her lamp being found in MK's room, it's evidence her court testimony about it was a lie. I can smell their desperation from here and it reeks.

I assume you are referring to the one titled:

Knox v Knox 8: How She Herself Provides Proofs Of Lies #70 To #90


The entire concept of the list is to post Amanda's testimony in trial and compare it to what she wrote in her book, to demonstrate inconsistencies which then, I assume, must mean she is lying.

But here's an interesting tidbit about the sheer stupidity of this list. Of the 20 items listed (70-90) only two of them quote from the book. The other 18 he essentially says "nothing about this in the book but here's what I think....". Worse still, not one of the 20 represents a contradiction - not one!

You'd think at least one of the three people still using the site would have pointed out to Chimera that his list makes no sense at all, but I guess at this point Quennell figures anything to keep the hate going is better than nothing.

Since we've been discussing the lamp -again- I'll share this gem from the list of 20;

71 Trial Versus Book

Knox At Trial In 2009

FM: In your room in via della Pergola, was there a central light?
AK: There was one but it didn’t work, so I used the little bedside lamp.
FM: The lamp.
AK: The little lamp, yes.
FM: And you previously stated that you didn’t look for the lamp either; you only looked for your computer when you went into your room. You didn’t look for your money, you didn’t look for your lamp.
AK: So, I saw the window only the second time that I entered the house. The first time I went into the house I didn’t even think of looking to see if anything was missing, because I saw going into the living room, it really looked like someone had just gone out of the house, everything was in order, just as I had left it. But the second time, I didn’t even think of looking for the lamp: the computer was the important thing for me. All my documents were in it.
FM: But the first time, when you took your shower and then you returned to your room, first you undressed and then you dressed, all this, you did it without any light?
AK: It was the middle of the morning, there was already light.
FM: Did you open your shutters or were they already open?
AK: I don’t remember.
FM: To get to your room, to get to the window, you walked in the dark?
AK: But it wasn’t dark in my room. Often—
FM: I don’t know, I wasn’t there.
AK: All right. Usually I only turned on that little lamp at night. Really at night, or in the evening, when I wanted to…So I didn’t even think of turning it on. It really wasn’t dark in my room when I went in.
GCM: It wasn’t dark, but where was the light coming from? Natural light?
AK: Natural.

Knox In Her Book 2013-15

[Comments] No mention of any of this. The missing lamp is only a red flag, and despite repeated questioning, AK dances around it

*****
The rest of the list doesn't get any better so no need for anyone to waste their time and give Quennell a site hit. It does, however, provide an interesting insight into the inner workings of a guilter's critical thought process, or lack thereof. I didn't bother reading 1-69 but there's no reason to think they are any more insightful.

Yes, this started with my post on the preceding page. (see above).

Regarding the highlighted above: what missing lamp? The lamp was never missing. Chimera doesn't even get that simple fact correct.
 
The rest of the list doesn't get any better so no need for anyone to waste their time and give Quennell a site hit. It does, however, provide an interesting insight into the inner workings of a guilter's critical thought process, or lack thereof. I didn't bother reading 1-69 but there's no reason to think they are any more insightful.

Thanks for this. I think....

Typical nutter-guilter. Reminds me of one of the very first "detailed" lists by Kermit of the 150 things Knox needed to answer to prove her innocence - done in early 2011 when she (and Sollecito) were still in prison.

I gave up on this list when Kermit had asked Knox to confess as to the phase of the Moon on Nov 1!!! I'd embarrased myself reading that far and came to my senses with Kermit implying Knox was guilty because she'd not let on she knew the phase of the moon.

The last time I fell for this mega-list approach was in late Summer 2011 when Quennell all but conceded that the DNA evidence had fallen apart during the Hellmann trial.

Despite his implied concession, he counseled his followers to fear-not, Hellmann would still have to convict them because of.....

...... all the other evidence.

Turned out there had been none. Hellmann's court acquitted the pair in 2011.

But I fell for it and asked guilters to supply a list of all this other evidence. Rabbit holes appeared out of nowhere, and I didn't learn my lesson until....

.... spending an unhealthy amount of time finding out why "sex on a train" had been on this "all the other evidence" list.

I could go on. In days' past I have. There's no point these days trying to drill down on Chimera's list of lies. It's 3+ years beyond the eventual exonerations.

I guess the 3 remaining nutters still think Italy needs help solving this case. (And they call us anti-Italy.)
 
Last edited:
Thanks for this. I think....

Typical nutter-guilter. Reminds me of one of the very first "detailed" lists by Kermit of the 150 things Knox needed to answer to prove her innocence - done in early 2011 when she (and Sollecito) were still in prison.

I gave up on this list when Kermit had asked Knox to confess as to the phase of the Moon on Nov 1!!! I'd embarrased myself reading that far and came to my senses with Kermit implying Knox was guilty because she'd not let on she knew the phase of the moon.

The last time I fell for this mega-list approach was in late Summer 2011 when Quennell all but conceded that the DNA evidence had fallen apart during the Hellmann trial.

Despite his implied concession, he counseled his followers to fear-not, Hellmann would still have to convict them because of.....

...... all the other evidence.

Turned out there had been none. Hellmann's court acquitted the pair in 2011.

But I fell for it and asked guilters to supply a list of all this other evidence. Rabbit holes appeared out of nowhere, and I didn't learn my lesson until....

.... spending an unhealthy amount of time finding out why "sex on a train" had been on this "all the other evidence" list.

I could go on. In days' past I have. There's no point these days trying to drill down on Chimera's list of lies. It's 3+ years beyond the eventual exonerations.

I guess the 3 remaining nutters still think Italy needs help solving this case. (And they call us anti-Italy.)[/QUOTE]

Apparently, I'm "insulting" Italy because I mentioned finding some Italian toilets don't flush very efficiently just as Amanda did. :jaw-dropp
 
Yes, this started with my post on the preceding page. (see above).

Regarding the highlighted above: what missing lamp? The lamp was never missing. Chimera doesn't even get that simple fact correct.

If this is the same Chimera that regularly posted on dot nut (is that site now defunct as well?) then s/he's definitely not the brightest crayon in the box. I recall once discussing the fact that the SP tech's didn't change gloves after collecting samples. He advised me that he worked with DNA and, as such, knew a thing or two about handling DNA and he said the techs wore gloves for personal protection from the environment and that it had nothing to do with ensuring evidence didn't get cross-contaminated. :jaw-dropp

Just another one of those professionals Quennell has on his staff!
 
If this is the same Chimera that regularly posted on dot nut (is that site now defunct as well?) then s/he's definitely not the brightest crayon in the box. I recall once discussing the fact that the SP tech's didn't change gloves after collecting samples. He advised me that he worked with DNA and, as such, knew a thing or two about handling DNA and he said the techs wore gloves for personal protection from the environment and that it had nothing to do with ensuring evidence didn't get cross-contaminated. :jaw-dropp

Just another one of those professionals Quennell has on his staff!

When Machiavelli was shown the photos below - showing obvious dirty gloves - he said that all they proved was that the samples they collected had contaminated the gloves, not the other way around.

It was hard to know how to answer that without being snarky....



 
If this is the same Chimera that regularly posted on dot nut (is that site now defunct as well?) then s/he's definitely not the brightest crayon in the box. I recall once discussing the fact that the SP tech's didn't change gloves after collecting samples. He advised me that he worked with DNA and, as such, knew a thing or two about handling DNA and he said the techs wore gloves for personal protection from the environment and that it had nothing to do with ensuring evidence didn't get cross-contaminated. :jaw-dropp

Just another one of those professionals Quennell has on his staff!

When Machiavelli was shown the photos below - showing obvious dirty gloves - he said that all they proved was that the samples they collected had contaminated the gloves, not the other way around.It was hard to know how to answer that without being snarky....

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_5397154cd64bdf2e8d.jpg[/qimg]

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/thum_5397154cd51816a9a7.jpg[/qimg]

Both these declarations remove a lot of the mystery of how these people come to the conclusions they do. With logic like that, no wonder they think TMB negative means blood was present, a hickey is a "wound", a nine pound "boulder" can't be thrown across about 6 ft. through a window, an almost 6 ft. athletic young man can't climb a 13 ft. wall with the aid of a grate and windowsill, and that Stefanoni followed internationally accepted protocols. The mystery is a mystery no more.
 
Both these declarations remove a lot of the mystery of how these people come to the conclusions they do. With logic like that, no wonder they think TMB negative means blood was present, a hickey is a "wound", a nine pound "boulder" can't be thrown across about 6 ft. through a window, an almost 6 ft. athletic young man can't climb a 13 ft. wall with the aid of a grate and windowsill, and that Stefanoni followed internationally accepted protocols. The mystery is a mystery no more.

I don't want to appear that I actually miss them, but.....

To continue with the guilter-nutter "greatest hits", it was also hard to know how to respond respectfully when someone would respond to critique of the investigative DNA work with:

"Stefanoni is not the one on trial here." Yes folks the guilter nutters actually believed that no one should be allowed to challenge the case the inept prosecution brought.

In other words the pair were guilty merely by being charged.

Anyone have any more?
 
I don't want to appear that I actually miss them, but.....

To continue with the guilter-nutter "greatest hits", it was also hard to know how to respond respectfully when someone would respond to critique of the investigative DNA work with:

"Stefanoni is not the one on trial here." Yes folks the guilter nutters actually believed that no one should be allowed to challenge the case the inept prosecution brought.

In other words the pair were guilty merely by being charged.

Anyone have any more?

There have been so many that they all run into each other. I think one of my favorites has been the popular "they found long blonde hairs in Meredith's hands" claim with the suggestion (or outright claim) that they belonged to Amanda. Of course, as was discussed at great length here, A's blonde hair was dyed which is easily identified under a microscope. These hairs were never brought up in court. One does not have to belong to Mensa to understand why.

Perhaps the all time "say whaaaat?" moment that exposes guilter-nutter thinking is the claim that "the police had no reason to lie" when they denied having committed illegal and abusive interrogations on Nov. 5/6. I still roll my eyes at that one.
 
PMF websites

Until 2011, the PMF website dominated the online discussion of this case. In March 2011 the webmasters of that site went to war with one another, and at the end of that month two hates sites emerged, PMF.ORG and PMF.NET.

The character of both was a tad weird. They'd advertised that they were simply trying to keep alive the memory of the original victim to all of this tragedy - Meredith Kercher. Yet their content was marked by their bannings of users/posters who expressed even the remotest hint that AK and RS might be innocent. They equated care for the victim with vitriol aimed at those who would eventually be cleared. And man oh man was the vitriol ripe - against all and sundry who dared express an innocence point of view. After the PMFs split, they then also proceeded to ban users and posters who were associated with the wrong PMF. PMF wars was adequately discussed at the still functioning, but quite dormant, IIP site. (The record of all that is still at IIP.)

Following the March 2015 exonerations of RS and AK, .ORG went behind a password wall. AFAIK it is now gone. Just this past month, .NET seems to have disappeared too.

Quite the sea change. So much for their goal of keeping the victim's name front and centre. It seems nearly all are getting on with their lives. Whereas AK and RS are now cleared of wrongdoing in what Rudy Guede had done on the night of Nov 1, 2007, there still remains the family south of London with a huge hole at the table. After the decade-long online debacle, that family still bears the loss.

Still, it is remarkable the long arc of online forums related to this. Now there is only TJMK, people who post long-since debunked delusions, and the remaining three or four who post echo comments for each others' fantasies. It's been a weird ride.
 
Last edited:
Until 2011, the PMF website dominated the online discussion of this case. In March 2011 the webmasters of that site went to war with one another, and at the end of that month two hates sites emerged, PMF.ORG and PMF.NET.

The character of both was a tad weird. They'd advertised that they were simply trying to keep alive the memory of the original victim to all of this tragedy - Meredith Kercher. Yet their content was marked by their bannings of users/posters who expressed even the remotest hint that AK and RS might be innocent. They equated care for the victim with vitriol aimed at those who would eventually be cleared. And man oh man was the vitriol ripe - against all and sundry who dared express an innocence point of view. After the PMFs split, they then also proceeded to ban users and posters who were associated with the wrong PMF. PMF wars was adequately discussed at the still functioning, but quite dormant, IIP site. (The record of all that is still at IIP.)

Following the March 2015 exonerations of RS and AK, .ORG went behind a password wall. AFAIK it is now gone. Just this past month, .NET seems to have disappeared too.

Quite the sea change. So much for their goal of keeping the victim's name front and centre. It seems nearly all are getting on with their lives. Whereas AK and RS are now cleared of wrongdoing in what Rudy Guede had done on the night of Nov 1, 2007, there still remains the family south of London with a huge hole at the table. After the decade-long online debacle, that family still bears the loss.

Still, it is remarkable the long arc of online forums related to this. Now there is only TJMK, people who post long-since debunked delusions, and the remaining three or four who post echo comments for each others' fantasies. It's been a weird ride.

An excellent and concise summary, Bill.
These sites used Meredith Kercher as an excuse to unleash their own personal nastiness. Their obsessive , continuing, over-the-top and personal attacks on both RS and AK, but especially AK, showed it wasn't really the case itself that interested them, but the opportunity it gave them to express their own unhealthy emotional/psychological needs. It was never "all about Meredith" for so many of them.
 
An excellent and concise summary, Bill.
These sites used Meredith Kercher as an excuse to unleash their own personal nastiness. Their obsessive , continuing, over-the-top and personal attacks on both RS and AK, but especially AK, showed it wasn't really the case itself that interested them, but the opportunity it gave them to express their own unhealthy emotional/psychological needs. It was never "all about Meredith" for so many of them.
I need to repeat kudos to Peggy Ganong on one issue, though. The only time I ever saw Ganong moderate an ad hominem aimed at Amanda Knox, was when a poster had referred to the latter as a "slut".

Despite all the other vitriol on .ORG, once Ganong was solidly in control of it (post-March 2011) the "s" word was the one place she did not allow her users to go. Not even when used against Knox. I've had private PM's with many, many of the usual suspects on that side of the fence, but never with Ganong. If I were ever to have one with her, high on my list of inquiries would be why she drew the line where she had.
 
From an ECHR judgment of 10 July 2018 regarding insufficient compensation for wrongful imprisonment:

"25. .... The Court {ECHR} reiterates that the domestic courts, as the custodians of individual rights and freedoms, should have considered it their duty to mark their disapproval of such wrongful conduct {by the police and domestic courts} to the extent of awarding an adequate and sufficient quantum of damages to Mr Bogdanov, taking into account the fundamental importance of the right to liberty and to a fair trial, even if they considered that breach to have been an inadvertent rather than an intended consequence of the State agents’ conduct. As a corollary, this would have conveyed the message that the State could not set individual rights and freedoms at nought or circumvent them with impunity...."

See: VASILEVSKIY AND BOGDANOV v. RUSSIA 52241/14 74222/14 10/07/2018

The point is that the ECHR will view the case of Knox v. Italy and its eventual resolution by the Italian courts in the same way, as well as any case which Sollecito may have lodged relating to denial of compensation.
 
Last edited:
I need to repeat kudos to Peggy Ganong on one issue, though. The only time I ever saw Ganong moderate an ad hominem aimed at Amanda Knox, was when a poster had referred to the latter as a "slut".

Despite all the other vitriol on .ORG, once Ganong was solidly in control of it (post-March 2011) the "s" word was the one place she did not allow her users to go. Not even when used against Knox. I've had private PM's with many, many of the usual suspects on that side of the fence, but never with Ganong. If I were ever to have one with her, high on my list of inquiries would be why she drew the line where she had.

After reading years and years of hateful, nasty, disgusting commentary on ORG, including classless/tasteless cartoons and photoshoped photos, I find it impossible to give Ganong credit for anything. I agree it's a bizarre limitation enforced on a board known for having no limitations - so long as it was pro-guilt in nature - but that's about it.

Re; dot net, I wonder if it's truly disappeared or if the apparent error messages are nothing more than improvements to the site content?
 
After reading years and years of hateful, nasty, disgusting commentary on ORG, including classless/tasteless cartoons and photoshoped photos, I find it impossible to give Ganong credit for anything. I agree it's a bizarre limitation enforced on a board known for having no limitations - so long as it was pro-guilt in nature - but that's about it.

Re; dot net, I wonder if it's truly disappeared or if the apparent error messages are nothing more than improvements to the site content?

Agreed. The word "slut" may have been banned, but the "slut-shaming" was not. That, and the classless/tasteless cartoons, continue today by certain people.
 
Until 2011, the PMF website dominated the online discussion of this case. In March 2011 the webmasters of that site went to war with one another, and at the end of that month two hates sites emerged, PMF.ORG and PMF.NET.

The character of both was a tad weird. They'd advertised that they were simply trying to keep alive the memory of the original victim to all of this tragedy - Meredith Kercher. Yet their content was marked by their bannings of users/posters who expressed even the remotest hint that AK and RS might be innocent. They equated care for the victim with vitriol aimed at those who would eventually be cleared. And man oh man was the vitriol ripe - against all and sundry who dared express an innocence point of view. After the PMFs split, they then also proceeded to ban users and posters who were associated with the wrong PMF. PMF wars was adequately discussed at the still functioning, but quite dormant, IIP site. (The record of all that is still at IIP.)

Following the March 2015 exonerations of RS and AK, .ORG went behind a password wall. AFAIK it is now gone. Just this past month, .NET seems to have disappeared too.

Quite the sea change. So much for their goal of keeping the victim's name front and centre. It seems nearly all are getting on with their lives. Whereas AK and RS are now cleared of wrongdoing in what Rudy Guede had done on the night of Nov 1, 2007, there still remains the family south of London with a huge hole at the table. After the decade-long online debacle, that family still bears the loss.

Still, it is remarkable the long arc of online forums related to this. Now there is only TJMK, people who post long-since debunked delusions, and the remaining three or four who post echo comments for each others' fantasies. It's been a weird ride.

AIUI the owner of the site, Michael, hasn't been heard of for about two years, leaving a couple of other volunteers to run the site in the meantime. As they are unable to contact him to get the error fixed, the site has gone down.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom