The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
I especially love their "logic" that Knox would somehow have to have mentioned something about her lamp not being in her own (Knox's) room on the morning after the murder! Notwithstanding the fact that, in an innocent-Knox scenario, had the lamp actually not been there on that morning (for example, if Kercher had borrowed Knox's lamp the previous day), there's no reason why Knox necessarily would have had to notice this..... there's also the very clear possibility that Knox's lamp indeed WAS in Knox's room on the morning after the murder - and that it was moved into Kercher's room some time in the afternoon by the police/paramedics who were attending the scene (and they already have "form" in not owning up to their practices during this time period if they didn't conform properly to the required protocols......).

Knox's lamp being in Kercher's room is absolutely irrelevant. It supports neither innocence nor guilt. What does support the very real possibility that the police knew the lamp was irrelevant is the fact it was never listed in the items collected for testing*. Logic says it would have been tested for DNA or fingerprints for a suspect who had no plausible reason to leave either on the lamp.

*Chimera on TJMK falsely claimed it was "wiped clean".
 
Knox's lamp being in Kercher's room is absolutely irrelevant. It supports neither innocence nor guilt. What does support the very real possibility that the police knew the lamp was irrelevant is the fact it was never listed in the items collected for testing*. Logic says it would have been tested for DNA or fingerprints for a suspect who had no plausible reason to leave either on the lamp.

*Chimera on TJMK falsely claimed it was "wiped clean".

One can only speculate about the lamp. It's not really a piece of evidence that confirms anything. The guilters can only posit a 'theory' on how it came to be there. They have no evidence that their theory about this is any more likely than other theories. So how does it prove who committed the murder?

While it might be curious, it's hard to say it's anything more than a curiosity.
 
Knox's lamp being in Kercher's room is absolutely irrelevant. It supports neither innocence nor guilt. What does support the very real possibility that the police knew the lamp was irrelevant is the fact it was never listed in the items collected for testing*. Logic says it would have been tested for DNA or fingerprints for a suspect who had no plausible reason to leave either on the lamp.

*Chimera on TJMK falsely claimed it was "wiped clean".

Yes, it was wiped clean just in case they forgot to remove it before locking the door. Cleverly proactive on their part!

As AC said, it's proof of nothing. Just as pro-guilt will argue turning their phones off was an indicator of guilt, that only works if you wish to view it that way. It's also an indicator that they didn't want to be disturbed. And, applying reverse logic, if they thought of GPS and the problem's it could cause them then why didn't they leave them on and at Raffaele's and use it as evidence that they never went anywhere? Use it to their advantage.

The vast majority of the pro-guilt case is based upon speculation and a bias view of things that in and of themselves prove nothing.

As for Chimera (since you got me looking at the site again - had to see the wiped clean comment) I noticed his 'series' of Knox vs Knox. Supposedly this series would compare Knox testimony in court with what she says in her book and "How She Herself Provides Proofs Of Lies". However, as I started reading through them I noticed a good many of them where he notes "This is omitted from the book". WTF?! How are you showing how Amanda contradicts herself when there is only one instance of her making a comment? There was one where he quotes her trial testimony explaining why she sent the email, and then quotes her from the book where she explains why she sent the email. His comment - "Knox does admit to sending a long email, but doesn’t include it in her book. Read for yourself" with a link to the email. If you're wondering where the contradiction is you're not alone.

It would seem Quennell has reached a new low and this is the type of crap he wants posted on his site. Desperation doesn't begin to describe it.
 
One can only speculate about the lamp. It's not really a piece of evidence that confirms anything. The guilters can only posit a 'theory' on how it came to be there. They have no evidence that their theory about this is any more likely than other theories. So how does it prove who committed the murder?

While it might be curious, it's hard to say it's anything more than a curiosity.

AngloLawyer long ago wrote the definitive a count of "the lamp", concluding that it is simply unknowable how it got into Meredith's room, but was probably used by one of the Postals who had been hesitant to go into the room but eventually did anyway.

The question guilter-nutters never answered (they're mostly gone now) is what was a presumed-guilty AK and RS using it for?
 
AngloLawyer long ago wrote the definitive a count of "the lamp", concluding that it is simply unknowable how it got into Meredith's room, but was probably used by one of the Postals who had been hesitant to go into the room but eventually did anyway.

The question guilter-nutters never answered (they're mostly gone now) is what was a presumed-guilty AK and RS using it for?[/QUOTE]

According to one popular guilter theory, they were using it to look for the earring that was "ripped" from Amanda's ear by Meredith. Of course, there is no evidence to support this theory but since when does that matter?
 
I will interrupt the flow of reminiscence about guilter theories of the significance of the lamp to provide an update on the status of the pending ECHR case Knox v. Italy as described in the Country Profile for Italy, which Profile has been updated as of June, 2018.

The news in the update is that there has been no change in the status of the top-line noteworthy pending cases summarized on page 13 of the Profile.

The cases are listed in the following order:

1. Grand Chamber.

Silvio Berlusconi v. Italy (no. 58428/13)

On 27 November 2013 the Senate of the Italian Republic stripped Mr Berlusconi, the former Prime Minister, of his status as Senator under the terms of Article 7 of Legislative Decree no. 235/2012, on account of a final judgment convicting him of fraud, handed down prior to the entry into force of the provision in question.

Mr Berlusconi relies on Articles 7 (no punishment without law) and 13 (right to an effective remedy) of the Convention, and also on Article 3 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention (right to free elections).

{Communication to Italy: 05 July 2016}
Relinquishment of the case in favour of the Grand Chamber on 6 June 2017
Grand Chamber hearing on 22 November 2017
{Judgment to be published: TBD}

2. Chamber

2.1 Length of proceedings cases following delay in payment of “Pinto” compensation
Around 2,000 cases are pending before the Court where applicants are complaining about one or both aspects related to length and issues linked to the Pinto procedure.

{This group of cases relates to failures of the Italian judicial system to compensate plaintiffs and/or defendants in accordance with the "Pinto" pilot judgment system to make up for unreasonable delays, thus violations of the Convention, in the conclusion of adjudication of domestic court cases. Probably Italy with the help of the ECHR and the Committee of Ministers will develop a modified or new pilot system to attempt to correct for this continuing judicial dysfunction.}

2.2 Francesco Cordella and Others v. Italy (no. 54414/13) and Lina Ambrogi Melle and Others v. Italy (no. 54264/15)

Cases communicated to the parties in April 2016
These applications concern the pollutant emissions from the Ilva steelworks in the city of Taranto. The applicants live (or lived) in the city or the surrounding area. The Ilva plant is the largest steelworks in Europe, and has been the focus of a long-running debate about the effects of its emissions on the environment and the health of the local population.

Relying on Articles 2 (right to life) and 8 (right to respect for private and family life) of the Convention, the applicants complain that the State failed to take all the necessary legal, regulatory and public information measures to protect the environment and the local residents’ health.

Under Article 13 (right to an effective remedy) of the Convention, they also complain that they have no effective domestic remedy in respect of those grievances.

{Judgment to be published: TBD}

2.3 Amanda Marie Knox v. Italy (no. 76577/13)

Case communicated to the parties in April 2016
This case concerns criminal proceedings in which Ms Knox was found guilty of making a false accusation. The offending statements were taken while she was being questioned in the context of criminal proceedings for the murder and sexual assault of her flatmate. The applicant was accused of implicating another person whom she knew to be innocent.

Ms Knox alleges that the criminal proceedings in which she was convicted were unfair, relying on Article 6 §§ 1 and 3 (a) (right to a fair trial – right to be informed promptly of the charge), (c) (right to legal assistance), (e) (right to assistance from an interpreter), Article 3 (prohibition of inhuman and degrading treatment) and Article 8 (right to respect for private and family life) of the Convention.

{Judgment to be published: TBD}
_______

From the above list of the summaries of the noteworthy pending cases, it is clear that the ECHR case Knox v. Italy remains in queue along with other Chamber cases that had been communicated to Italy at about the same date.
 
Last edited:
AngloLawyer long ago wrote the definitive a count of "the lamp", concluding that it is simply unknowable how it got into Meredith's room, but was probably used by one of the Postals who had been hesitant to go into the room but eventually did anyway.

The question guilter-nutters never answered (they're mostly gone now) is what was a presumed-guilty AK and RS using it for?[/QUOTE]

According to one popular guilter theory, they were using it to look for the earring that was "ripped" from Amanda's ear by Meredith. Of course, there is no evidence to support this theory but since when does that matter?

One of the "unsolved" mysteries of this case. One day maybe we'll get the truth of the lamp.
 
One of the "unsolved" mysteries of this case. One day maybe we'll get the th of the lamp.

A guilty Amanda would have had an obvious and plausible explanation for her lamp being in Meredith's room to offer up to the police: Meredith had asked to borrow it to use on her desk as Amanda was staying with Raffaele. A guilty Amanda would have explained it away that easily. An innocent Amanda, not knowing how the lamp got there, would say she didn't know how it got to Meredith's room. Which is exactly what she did. On the other hand, we get unsupported and illogical speculation from the guilt camp that she was looking for some alleged earring "ripped" from her ear but stupidly left the lamp behind after carefully "wiping it clean". It's akin to the "wound/scratch" on AK's neck the guilters claim existed but was never reported in the prison doctor's physical exam report; an exam specifically performed to find any physical evidence of the suspect's involvement in the case. I guess the doctor couldn't distinguish between a hickey and a broken skin scratch/wound. Or...more likely in the eyes of the guilters... he must have been a Mafia doctor, a Mason, or a shill for the not yet hired Marriott PR machine.
 
This is a very interesting article on how a forensic lab supervisor (James Bolding) and prosecutor basically framed a murder suspect (Preston Hughes) by withholding exculpatory evidence and misrepresenting...no, lying about... blood test results to the court. It does a good job of describing what was done, what was not done, what should have been done and the reasons for each.

Luminol (and presumably fluorescein) is particularly reactive to copper (such as the rivets on blue jeans), bleach, enamel paint, turnips, parsnips, horseradish, and furniture polish. It is presumably reactive to all the food items that respond to phenolphthalin. It reacts less dramatically to cigarette ash and smoke. Preston Hughes smoked.

It is therefore not particularly surprising or insightful that the screening tests returned positive. It is absolutely wrong to say, however, that they returned positive for blood. More frequently, such a test will be reported as indicative of blood. That's not much better. The test is also indicative of potatoes. The test is also indicative of copper. The test is also indicative of tobacco. The test is also indicative of bleach.

Screening tests are, however, never reported to the jury in such innocent fashion as "indicative of onions." Though the lab is supposedly a scientific body having no interest in the outcome of the case, the lab personnel almost always testify in a fashion most damaging to the defendant. They almost always testify for the prosecution, they most always testify that the screening test is indicative of blood, and they leave it to the defense to try to convince the jury otherwise.
http://www.skepticaljuror.com/2012/10/hughes-news-fraud-on-court-part-1-of-2.html
 
A guilty Amanda would have had an obvious and plausible explanation for her lamp being in Meredith's room to offer up to the police: Meredith had asked to borrow it to use on her desk as Amanda was staying with Raffaele. A guilty Amanda would have explained it away that easily. An innocent Amanda, not knowing how the lamp got there, would say she didn't know how it got to Meredith's room. Which is exactly what she did. On the other hand, we get unsupported and illogical speculation from the guilt camp that she was looking for some alleged earring "ripped" from her ear but stupidly left the lamp behind after carefully "wiping it clean". It's akin to the "wound/scratch" on AK's neck the guilters claim existed but was never reported in the prison doctor's physical exam report; an exam specifically performed to find any physical evidence of the suspect's involvement in the case. I guess the doctor couldn't distinguish between a hickey and a broken skin scratch/wound. Or...more likely in the eyes of the guilters... he must have been a Mafia doctor, a Mason, or a shill for the not yet hired Marriott PR machine.

It's been 10 1/2 years since the horrible murder of an innocent, and it is over 3 years since AK and RS were definitively acquited of that murder.

This must be the 20th time "the lamp" has come around the merry-go-round, and still the (remaining) nutter-guilters cannot say why a hypothetically guilty AK would have brought the lamp into the victim's room.

They cite an earring "ripped" from AK's ear, yet the only bleeding from her earlobe is what she herself theorized (on the spot) when she spied the speck of blood on the faucet upon her solo return to the cottage on the morning of Nov 2.

On her arrest on Nov 5 she was examined head to toe, and the examiner even took photos of "suspicious" marks on AK's body, one being the hickey; and on the photo itself the police examiner put the disclaimer on it that the photo itself had to be over exposed or else the hickey would not have shown up....

The nutter-guilters never did have anything - except the conviction in 2009. That conviction was overturned in 2011 when the appeals courts let the DNA evidence be properly reviewed; such that it revealed that the DNA evidence and super-witnesses evidence had been garbage.

Yada yada yada yada.... here we are in 2018 and the lamp issue is STILL making the rounds. Three+ years after their full exonerations.
 
It's been 10 1/2 years since the horrible murder of an innocent, and it is over 3 years since AK and RS were definitively acquited of that murder.

This must be the 20th time "the lamp" has come around the merry-go-round, and still the (remaining) nutter-guilters cannot say why a hypothetically guilty AK would have brought the lamp into the victim's room.

They cite an earring "ripped" from AK's ear, yet the only bleeding from her earlobe is what she herself theorized (on the spot) when she spied the speck of blood on the faucet upon her solo return to the cottage on the morning of Nov 2.

On her arrest on Nov 5 she was examined head to toe, and the examiner even took photos of "suspicious" marks on AK's body, one being the hickey; and on the photo itself the police examiner put the disclaimer on it that the photo itself had to be over exposed or else the hickey would not have shown up....

The nutter-guilters never did have anything - except the conviction in 2009. That conviction was overturned in 2011 when the appeals courts let the DNA evidence be properly reviewed; such that it revealed that the DNA evidence and super-witnesses evidence had been garbage.

Yada yada yada yada.... here we are in 2018 and the lamp issue is STILL making the rounds. Three+ years after their full exonerations.

Yes, it's still making the rounds because TJMK brought it up yet again a few days ago in their "expose" of all Knox's "lies".

A certain guilter will be unhappy that yet another "innocence fraud" has been aided and abetted by the Innocence Project: Jerome Johnson was just exonerated after spending 30 years in prison for a murder he did not commit with the help of the Mid-Atlantic Innocence Project. The evidence? A fifteen year-old girl's testimony that she saw him at the crime scene. Her description of the incident changed dramatically but despite this, the jurors believed her. (Shades of Quintavalle, Curatolo, and Capezzali!) Nine years later, another witness placed Johnson far from the crime scene and the real killer confessed saying Johnson was not there. Johnson remained in jail until a few days ago.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/loca...ory.html?noredirect=on&utm_term=.35b8815e4ad7
 
It's been 10 1/2 years since the horrible murder of an innocent, and it is over 3 years since AK and RS were definitively acquited of that murder.

This must be the 20th time "the lamp" has come around the merry-go-round, and still the (remaining) nutter-guilters cannot say why a hypothetically guilty AK would have brought the lamp into the victim's room.

They cite an earring "ripped" from AK's ear, yet the only bleeding from her earlobe is what she herself theorized (on the spot) when she spied the speck of blood on the faucet upon her solo return to the cottage on the morning of Nov 2.

On her arrest on Nov 5 she was examined head to toe, and the examiner even took photos of "suspicious" marks on AK's body, one being the hickey; and on the photo itself the police examiner put the disclaimer on it that the photo itself had to be over exposed or else the hickey would not have shown up....

The nutter-guilters never did have anything - except the conviction in 2009. That conviction was overturned in 2011 when the appeals courts let the DNA evidence be properly reviewed; such that it revealed that the DNA evidence and super-witnesses evidence had been garbage.

Yada yada yada yada.... here we are in 2018 and the lamp issue is STILL making the rounds. Three+ years after their full exonerations.

I wonder how often Amanda even wore earrings. I went back and looked at a bunch of videos and pictures of Amanda and I could only find her wearing earrings in one of them and that was the Diane Sawyer interview years later. Now in all fairness, my search wasn't comprehensive, but I sure looked at a lot of them. Also, she has long hair in most of the pics I looked at.

Still, it seems as if one is desperate if they're hanging their reasoning on that. This is the kind of stuff that drives me crazy. Not just with this, but lots of things. People come up with reasons and explanations when in fact all they really have are minor clues if that.

The earring idea is a classic argument from ignorance and of course it starts with the assumption of guilt. If there is a possible innocent explanation, it is discarded and dismissed, because that just wouldn't do.
 
I wonder how often Amanda even wore earrings. I went back and looked at a bunch of videos and pictures of Amanda and I could only find her wearing earrings in one of them and that was the Diane Sawyer interview years later. Now in all fairness, my search wasn't comprehensive, but I sure looked at a lot of them. Also, she has long hair in most of the pics I looked at.

Still, it seems as if one is desperate if they're hanging their reasoning on that. This is the kind of stuff that drives me crazy. Not just with this, but lots of things. People come up with reasons and explanations when in fact all they really have are minor clues if that.

The earring idea is a classic argument from ignorance and of course it starts with the assumption of guilt. If there is a possible innocent explanation, it is discarded and dismissed, because that just wouldn't do.

Well, the "ripped out earring" is supposedly backed up by this picture:
79Grj.jpg
...

Looks like the lowest stud failed to reflect the light like the others did...

It also shows that Miss Knox had quite a few rings/studs in her ears back then...
Does it matter? ...
 
Last edited:
First, we must remember that the Italian courts show a relatively high level of dysfunction, sometimes (often?) ignoring or blatantly misinterpreting Italian laws and the Italian Constitution.

So here's a brief list of what could happen when and if the ECHR judges that Italy violated Amanda's right to a fair trial under the Convention, and that to restore her rights to what they were before the violation, she is entitled to request a retrial held in conformance with the Convention:

1. The Italian courts will indeed follow the laws of Italy, including the ECHR case-law, grant the revision request, hold a brief trial finding that all the alleged evidence of calunnia was inadmissible and that there was never any evidence of any intent to commit calunnia. The case is dismissed under CPP Article 529 (should never have been started) or 530 (acquittal), and Amanda's criminal record in Italy is cleared. Eventually, she is compensated by Italy for the miscarriage of justice and time wrongfully detained.

2. The Italian courts decide that the Italian Constitutional Court judgment 113 of 2011 simply doesn't apply to Amanda's case, because they don't want it to. They provide some obviously specious reasoning as justification. (This possibility may be unlikely.)

3. The Italian courts examine Amanda's request for revision, but use a less obviously specious reasoning as justification to deny a revision trial or hold the revision trial and decide that despite the ECHR judgment, Amanda has not proven that the case of calunnia against her should be dismissed under Article 529 or 530. For example, the revision court could adopt a fabrication of the trial record, such as that apparently used in the Marasca CSC panel, to claim that Amanda had accused Lumumba before the GIP in her arrest hearing. Or, the revision court could (wrongly) argue that deciding the admissibility of evidence was merely a re-evaluation of evidence, and thus the law did not allow a dismissal in accordance with CPP Article 637.3 (which states that the judge cannot order a dismissal solely on the basis of a re-evaluation of the evidence).

Following a final decision under a scenario such as #2 or #3, Amanda could then launch a new ECHR case against Italy and, after some considerable time, win another ECHR judgment. By then, some years from now, there would be new judges to consider a revision request.

Thanks Numbers. I can't imagine the ECHR ruling against Knox's petition. But I've said that countless times. I keep expecting rationality and what I get are surprises.
 
Well, the "ripped out earring" is supposedly backed up by this picture:
[qimg]http://i.imgur.com/79Grj.jpg[/qimg]...

Looks like the lowest stud failed to reflect the light like the others did...

It also shows that Miss Knox had quite a few rings/studs in her ears back then...
Does it matter? ...

Of course not. There is no evidence that she lost an earring, let alone the lamp was used for looking for one. It's speculation piled on top of speculation. That's all.

I just thought it might be fascinating to discover that Amanda didn't really wear any as I have always viewed her as a bit of a tomboy. And it would be funny if she never did. It's like the dumb claim that she took a chartered jet back to Seattle. The actual facts seem so irrelevant to them.

Thanks for the picture. It blows my idea out of the water. Not that the idea really mattered.
 
Well, the "ripped out earring" is supposedly backed up by this picture:
[qimg]http://i.imgur.com/79Grj.jpg[/qimg]...

Looks like the lowest stud failed to reflect the light like the others did...

It also shows that Miss Knox had quite a few rings/studs in her ears back then...
Does it matter? ...

The bottom stud doesn't show not because it didn't "reflect the light"; there is no stud in that hole because that is the hole that was infected as Amanda described. She had recently had several new piercings because she admired Laura's multiple piercings. It was the "thing" at the time. If this picture was taken shortly after her arrest, the easiest and most logical thing would have been for her to remove the earrings and just let them heal. Taking care of multiple new piercings in prison would have been difficult as they require daily maintenance until they fully heal. That she did, indeed, let the new piercings heal close is evidenced by pictures of her wearing only a single pair of earrings during the trials of 2009 and 2011 like the one in the link below. Notice there is no evidence of the other piercings any longer.

https://www.gettyimages.com/event/a...-perugias-court-of-appeal-picture-id123921736
 
The bottom stud doesn't show not because it didn't "reflect the light"; there is no stud in that hole because that is the hole that was infected as Amanda described. She had recently had several new piercings because she admired Laura's multiple piercings. It was the "thing" at the time. If this picture was taken shortly after her arrest, the easiest and most logical thing would have been for her to remove the earrings and just let them heal. Taking care of multiple new piercings in prison would have been difficult as they require daily maintenance until they fully heal. That she did, indeed, let the new piercings heal close is evidenced by pictures of her wearing only a single pair of earrings during the trials of 2009 and 2011 like the one in the link below. Notice there is no evidence of the other piercings any longer.

https://www.gettyimages.com/event/a...-perugias-court-of-appeal-picture-id123921736



At the risk of going further down a rathole of essentially an irrelevant matter.... I think that the first photo of Knox DOES show a stud in the lowest position on her ear. I just think that it's a different type of stud from the ones immediately above it (which are much shinier) - but it appears to match closely with the studs at the top of her ear.

I can't even remember which ear Knox says became infected (it might be the other ear than the one we can see in that photo....). Regardless, all the available evidence (and, importantly here, lack of evidence) is wholly consistent with Knox dripping/contacting blood from her recent piercing on the top of the tap (faucet) in the day or two prior to the murder; and, crucially, there is a) NO evidence whatsoever that Knox had an earring "ripped out" by Kercher in any form of struggle (and since Knox was apparently wearing studs in her ears rather than earrings, this makes any "ripping out" even more unlikely in any case); and b) there is NO evidence whatsoever that Knox was involved in any kind of physical struggle or altercation (there were zero marks, scratches or bruises on Knox's arms, neck or face - save for the mark on her neck which is entirely consistent with a "love bite" and entirely inconsistent with an injury resulting from a struggle).

In passing, somebody also probably ought to point out (again) to pro-guilt commentators that not even the Perugia police or PM were at all interested in the mark on Knox's neck........
 
Finding blood on the faucet of your own apartment isn't exactly shocking. Unless, as many have noted, you start with an assumption of guilt and view everything through that myopic lens.

Do you know how many times I have found blood in my bathroom (or, often, kitchen) sink when I wasn't even aware I was bleeding?

Some of these guilters would think I was a serial killer.
 
In passing, somebody also probably ought to point out (again) to pro-guilt commentators that not even the Perugia police or PM were at all interested in the mark on Knox's neck........

It's the guilter-nutters' way of unconsciously conceding that the original investigation needed a lot of help in the English-language online forums to make a case.
 
At the risk of going further down a rathole of essentially an irrelevant matter.... I think that the first photo of Knox DOES show a stud in the lowest position on her ear. I just think that it's a different type of stud from the ones immediately above it (which are much shinier) - but it appears to match closely with the studs at the top of her ear.

I can't even remember which ear Knox says became infected (it might be the other ear than the one we can see in that photo....). Regardless, all the available evidence (and, importantly here, lack of evidence) is wholly consistent with Knox dripping/contacting blood from her recent piercing on the top of the tap (faucet) in the day or two prior to the murder; and, crucially, there is a) NO evidence whatsoever that Knox had an earring "ripped out" by Kercher in any form of struggle (and since Knox was apparently wearing studs in her ears rather than earrings, this makes any "ripping out" even more unlikely in any case); and b) there is NO evidence whatsoever that Knox was involved in any kind of physical struggle or altercation (there were zero marks, scratches or bruises on Knox's arms, neck or face - save for the mark on her neck which is entirely consistent with a "love bite" and entirely inconsistent with an injury resulting from a struggle).

In passing, somebody also probably ought to point out (again) to pro-guilt commentators that not even the Perugia police or PM were at all interested in the mark on Knox's neck........

This is a good example of two people seeing the same picture yet seeing different things. A picture with better resolution would clear this up but I've yet to find one. But, as you say, whether or not there is an earring in that hole is irrelevant and not really worth the time or effort to determine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom