The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 28

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow. You visit Italy and then you insult their country whilst there.

The Ugly American abroad strikes again!

Wow. THIS is your take on Stacyhs's little snippet? That she's insulting Italy?

Any normal person would read this as self-criticism, of a foreigner who is struggling with what to a local would be trivial.

Once again, the guilter-PR campaign strikes, turning the plain meaning of something into something else.
 
It doesn't change the facts at all. Prisoners on Death Row wishing to commute their sentences to Life without Parole instead do go before a board for a Clemency Hearing, using the parole board facilities.

If you recall Numbers and LondonJohn argued vociferously that there was no such hearing and that all such appeals were done via the attorneys.

(I note Numbers is now pretending that he knew about the clemency hearings all along.)


No. What happened in that case was that the prisoner's attorneys appealed to the state governor for clemency (and there were strong grounds in this particular instance: the other participants in the murder were not given the death penalty, the man was very young at the time of the crime, and had been on death row for almost 20 years (during which time he'd apparently been a model prisoner), and there were other problems concerning the original trial). The state governor then asked the parole board to give him a recommendation as to whether the sentence should be commuted. And as part of this process, the parole board held a meeting with the prisoner himself. The parole board then made its recommendation for clemency to the state governor, and the governor accepted their recommendation and grated clemency (with a reduction to life without parole.......).

So it's only in extremely rare circumstances that a prisoner on death row gets to appear in front of a parole hearing. And that's when - as I said before - one of the very few people with the power to change the sentence of a death row prisoner (either a state governor, or the US President, or the Supreme Court) directs the parole board to make a recommendation. Those with the power to grant clemency can (and often do) make their decisions without involving the parole board.

So the situation is this: prisoners on death row cannot seek a downgrading of their sentence from the parole board. What they can do (having exhausted all appeals, usually) is to appeal (or, more accurately, for their attorneys to appeal) for clemency - usually to the state governor first, and then to the Supreme Court. Very few appeals for clemency are ever granted, and almost all of them involve extraordinary circumstances (as in the case under discussion). And of those appeals for clemency, only a proportion of them involve the parole board.
 
Wow. You visit Italy and then you insult their country whilst there.

The Ugly American abroad strikes again!


Uhhhh..... just how has she "insulted their country"? What a strange, blinkered assessment to make of that post.
 
Uhhhh..... just how has she "insulted their country"? What a strange, blinkered assessment to make of that post.

The guilter-PR campaign used to go on and on about how those who believe in RS's and AK's innocence are anti-Italy.

All that despite that very same guilter-PR campaign declaring that Italy's judiciary can be influenced by or meddled with by various combinations of Mafia, Masons or American media interests.

Those who believe in RS's and AK's innocence are very critical of the court process from 2009 onwards, but in the main are satisfied with the 2015 Supreme Court outcome - acquittal and exoneration of the pair.

Vixen doesn't actually believe what she posts about this, it's just that this "innocentisi hate Italy" talking point is her way of feeling she belongs to the guilter-group, by chucking into a post a worn talking point.....

..... obviously with no thought, that it had nothing to do with Stacyhs's observation about Italian locks and toilets.
 
No. What happened in that case was that the prisoner's attorneys appealed to the state governor for clemency (and there were strong grounds in this particular instance: the other participants in the murder were not given the death penalty, the man was very young at the time of the crime, and had been on death row for almost 20 years (during which time he'd apparently been a model prisoner), and there were other problems concerning the original trial). The state governor then asked the parole board to give him a recommendation as to whether the sentence should be commuted. And as part of this process, the parole board held a meeting with the prisoner himself. The parole board then made its recommendation for clemency to the state governor, and the governor accepted their recommendation and grated clemency (with a reduction to life without parole.......).

So it's only in extremely rare circumstances that a prisoner on death row gets to appear in front of a parole hearing. And that's when - as I said before - one of the very few people with the power to change the sentence of a death row prisoner (either a state governor, or the US President, or the Supreme Court) directs the parole board to make a recommendation. Those with the power to grant clemency can (and often do) make their decisions without involving the parole board.

So the situation is this: prisoners on death row cannot seek a downgrading of their sentence from the parole board. What they can do (having exhausted all appeals, usually) is to appeal (or, more accurately, for their attorneys to appeal) for clemency - usually to the state governor first, and then to the Supreme Court. Very few appeals for clemency are ever granted, and almost all of them involve extraordinary circumstances (as in the case under discussion). And of those appeals for clemency, only a proportion of them involve the parole board.

One comment, LJ.. in the case of Federal clemency requests it is only the President who can issue one. The Supreme Court has no involvement. In some state level clemency cases the State Supreme Court has been involved, but that is fairly rare AFAICT.

FWIW... I actually forgot how we ended going down this path and so had to backtrack a few pages to find the beginning;

LondonJohn said:
Incidentally, if I'm not mistaken, in most (if not all) US states which have the death penalty, all those convicted of death penalty offences DO indeed have an automatic right to appeal - this was clearly introduced as another attempt to safeguard against the possibility of wrongful convictions when the punishment stakes were so high (and, of course, ultimately irreversible).

Vixen said:
The same conditions apply. It has to be done correctly.

The appeal is between thirteen to fifteen stages. It includes admitting your guilt, showing remorse and apologising to your victim's family.

I wish the Kercher trial could have been in the USA death penalty state, perhaps Texas, as I would just LOVE to hear Knox and Sollecito do all of the above.
Even then, it is still a decision to be made by a panel.

Obviously Vixen went down this path so she could make her nasty/snarky comment highlighted above. But in doing so she make a big mistake. She claimed the process used in a PAROLE hearing is used in an APPEAL. This is a patently false claim. It really wasn't a big deal except it was key to the swipe she wanted to direct towards Amanda and Raffaele. And here we are, some three pages after the claim and she's still flailing about, doing everything she can to avoid simply admitting she had it wrong.

For the record, clemency requests are NOT part of the appeal process. Clemency requests are considered an executive act of mercy on a convicted felon. Clemency is NOT a guaranteed right like appeals are.
 
Obviously Vixen went down this path so she could make her nasty/snarky comment highlighted above. But in doing so she make a big mistake. She claimed the process used in a PAROLE hearing is used in an APPEAL. This is a patently false claim. It really wasn't a big deal except it was key to the swipe she wanted to direct towards Amanda and Raffaele. And here we are, some three pages after the claim and she's still flailing about, doing everything she can to avoid simply admitting she had it wrong.

The last three pages have had nothing to do with the trials Raffaele and Amanda faced.

The last three pages have been to deal with a persistent poster who does not let facts stand in the way of an opportunity to slur or slutshame people.

The medium is the message.
 
The last three pages have had nothing to do with the trials Raffaele and Amanda faced.

The last three pages have been to deal with a persistent poster who does not let facts stand in the way of an opportunity to slur or slutshame people.

The medium is the message.

Of course they didn't. Vixen just wanted to share with us her fantasy scenario of Amanda and Raffaele groveling for forgiveness for a crime they didn't commit. In the process she named the wrong process under which this would have happened had they been guilty of the crime. She could have done the same thing but said "...during their parole hearing..." and saved us three pages. Then again, she could also have just admitted she meant parole hearing and also saved us three pages. But admitting an error, even a minor one, is not something Vixen handles well and, as Stacy likes to say, there is an entertainment value to it.
 
I came across this definition on Wikipedia and, oh I don't know, for some reason it made me think of this thread.

******** asymmetry principle

The amount of energy needed to refute ******** is an order of magnitude bigger than to produce it.

I'd link to the page but as it contains a bad word I don't think the software here will allow it.
 
Wow. You visit Italy and then you insult their country whilst there.

The Ugly American abroad strikes again!

I'd say it's more like the Ugly Brit/Finn twists a post beyond recognition once again. I was not criticizing Italy but merely mentioning two observations of things that occurred that were relevant to the Kercher case . And, if I were the "Ugly American" who dislikes Italy, it's hardly likely that I'd keep returning to it time and again including plans for next spring.

Try again, Vixen. No one here falls for your nonsense. We know you far too well.
 
I'd say it's more like the Ugly Brit/Finn twists a post beyond recognition once again. I was not criticizing Italy but merely mentioning two observations of things that occurred that were relevant to the Kercher case . And, if I were the "Ugly American" who dislikes Italy, it's hardly likely that I'd keep returning to it time and again including plans for next spring.

Try again, Vixen. No one here falls for your nonsense. We know you far too well.

I don't know anyone who has to tell their sister or roommate how to flush the toilet. Perhaps it is a deficiency specific to Americans?
 
I don't know anyone who has to tell their sister or roommate how to flush the toilet. Perhaps it is a deficiency specific to Americans?

At least you are consistent; still misrepresenting what was said to meet your own bias. Read what I wrote again. It had nothing to do with how to flush a toilet. Perhaps reading comprehension is a deficiency specific to Brits/Finns?

Interestingly, not once have we observed the same peculiarity with Swiss toilets.
 
At least you are consistent; still misrepresenting what was said to meet your own bias. Read what I wrote again. It had nothing to do with how to flush a toilet. Perhaps reading comprehension is a deficiency specific to Brits/Finns?

Interestingly, not once have we observed the same peculiarity with Swiss toilets.


Stacyhs, you need to write an urgent academic paper in this matter and send it direct to the new Italian regime, including fascist Bongiorno, so that she can get an immediate full pardon effected.
 
Stacyhs, you need to write an urgent academic paper in this matter and send it direct to the new Italian regime, including fascist Bongiorno, so that she can get an immediate full pardon effected.

You're so cute when you're attempting to be clever.
 
Vixen, you are wrong. You are wrong in more ways than I can politely describe. Give it up.
 
The recent ECHR case G.I.E.M. S.R.L. AND OTHERS v. ITALY [GC] 1828/06 34163/07 19029/11 28/06/2018 illustrates that Italian courts can fail to follow Italian law, the Italian Constitution, ECHR case-law, and the European Convention of Human Rights. Such failures can lead to judgments of a violation of the Convention by the ECHR.

I anticipate that Knox v. Italy will lead to a judgment against Italy because of the Italian courts' failures to follow Italian law and Constitution and ECHR case-law and the Convention in the conviction of Amanda Knox for calunnia against Partrick Lumumba.

Here's some discussion of some points of how the ECHR views cases based on its Grand Chamber judgment against Italy in the recent case:

"In the case of G.I.E.M. S.r.l. and Others v. Italy, the Court has found several violations of the Convention. The cases concerned the confiscation of land as provided for by legislation in the event of unlawful site development. The applicants alleged that that this confiscation had an insufficient legal basis.

The Court noted, in particular, that the applicants had had their property confiscated although none of them had been formally convicted. It reiterated its case-law to the effect that a criminal sanction cannot be imposed on an individual without personal criminal liability being established and declared beforehand." Source: ECHR home page

Here is an excerpt from the above ECHR judgment concerning Italian law. Note paragraph 91, which is certainly applicable to Knox v. Italy:

The following excerpt is from the ECHR judgment. Paragraph 91 is of particular relevance as it points out the importance of "intent" as an element of Italian law:

"A. General principles of criminal law

88. Article 27 § 1 of the Italian Constitution provides that “criminal liability is personal”. The Constitutional Court has affirmed on several occasions that there can be no strict liability in criminal matters (see, inter alia, Constitutional Court judgment no. 1 of 10 January 1997). Article 27 § 3 of the Constitution provides: “Punishments ... shall aim at rehabilitating the convicted person”.

89. The second and third paragraphs of Article 25 of the Constitution provide that “no punishment may be inflicted except by virtue of a law in force at the time the offence was committed”, and that “no restriction may be placed on a person’s liberty save for as provided by law”.

90. Article 1 of the Criminal Code states that “no one may be punished for an act which is not expressly defined by law as constituting a criminal offence, under any penalty which is not prescribed by law”. Article 199 of the Criminal Code on security measures provides that no one may be subject to security measures which are not provided for by law, or in cases other than those provided for by law.

91. The first paragraph of Article 42 of the Criminal Code provides that “no one may be punished for an act or omission constituting a criminal offence provided by law if, in committing the acts, the perpetrator did not have the corresponding awareness and intent [coscienza e volontà]”. The same rule is set out in section 3 of Law no. 689 of 25 November 1989 as regards administrative offences.

92. Article 5 of the Criminal Code provides that “no one may plead ignorance of criminal law in order to obtain exemption from liability”. The Constitutional Court (in judgment no. 364/1988) ruled that this principle did not apply in the case of an unavoidable error, so that the provision must henceforth be read as follows: “no one may plead ignorance of criminal law in order to obtain exemption from liability, save in the case of an unavoidable error”. The Constitutional Court stated that the possible origin of any objectively unavoidable error regarding criminal law was the “absolute obscurity of the law”, the “erroneous assurances” of persons institutionally responsible for assessing the lawfulness of the acts to be performed, or the “extremely chaotic” state of case-law."

The Boninsegna court judgment established in its final acquittal of Knox that she did not have intent to commit calunnia against the police because of the illegal manner that they carried out the interrogation. Since the interrogation was carried out in an illegal manner, Knox could not have had intent to falsely accuse Lumumba; she was coerced. Thus, she should not have been convicted under Italian law.

In its case-law, the ECHR has established that a conviction by a state that contradicts the state's domestic law is a violation of the Convention under Article 6.1. (In the G.I.E.M. case, the ECHR judged that there had been a violation of Article 7, and thus it would be redundant for it to examine the case under Article 6.1.)
 
Last edited:
Wot? Could Vixen finally have taken someone's advice to "give it up"?

(Not holding my breath.)

She's busy on the (TWO) threads about Russian monarchy, Finnish independence/involvement in WWII, and restoration of lands to people 80+ years of age.
 
Those interested in the ECHR case Knox v. Italy and the legal obligations of Italy following a potential judgment against Italy may wish to read some posts in a blog by Daria Sartori. Ms. Sartori is, according to her professional self-description on her blog, "PhD & Doctor Europaeus in Comparative and European Legal Studies ; Assistant Lawyer, European Court of Human Rights".

In the conclusion of her post dated 22 January 2018, she writes:

"In the Italian legal system, the absence of a comprehensive legislative intervention on the enforcement of ECtHR judgments finding violations of the guarantees of criminal trial has led domestic courts to intervene. Procedural remedies are applied analogically (“ricorso straordinario per errore materiale o di fatto” under article 625bis Code of Criminal Procedure; “incidente d’esecuzione” procedure under articles 666 and following CPP), and a general remedy has been introduced (exceptional review of a final conviction under article 630 CPP).

The most recent developments of the Italian case law deal with the issue of how to extend the effects of an ECtHR judgment to cases other than the one under the ECtHR’s review. In the absence of any organic stance by the executive or by the legislative power, cooperation between higher courts seems to have led to a solution. According to a set of judgments by the Court of Cassation and the Constitutional Court, the exceptional review under article 630 CPP is now to be considered as the “ordinary” remedy, both to enforce ECtHR’s judgments and to extend the effects of such judgments to similar cases. The “incidente d’esecuzione” procedure, instead, represents a residual solution which may be used when the effects of the ECtHR’s judgments pertain exclusively to the execution phase and do not require the use of any discretional power by the judge."

The highlighted text is a reference to the revision trial described in CPP Articles 629 - 647, with the elements required for a conviction to be allowed under law to be considered for revision listed in Article CPP 630. The article was declare unconstitutionally incomplete by the Italian Constitutional Court in its decision 113 of 2011, and that court added the final judgment of the ECHR that proceedings must be reopened as an element.

Ms. Sartori discusses that Constitutional Court decision in her post dated 23 February 2015.

The blog is at:
https://aninternationallawblog.wordpress.com/author/dariasartori/

Thanks to TomG on IIP for pointing out Ms. Sartori's blog.
 
Last edited:
Those interested in the ECHR case Knox v. Italy and the legal obligations of Italy following a potential judgment against Italy may wish to read some posts in a blog by Daria Sartori. Ms. Sartori is, according to her professional self-description on her blog, "PhD & Doctor Europaeus in Comparative and European Legal Studies ; Assistant Lawyer, European Court of Human Rights".

In the conclusion of her post dated 22 January 2018, she writes:

"In the Italian legal system, the absence of a comprehensive legislative intervention on the enforcement of ECtHR judgments finding violations of the guarantees of criminal trial has led domestic courts to intervene. Procedural remedies are applied analogically (“ricorso straordinario per errore materiale o di fatto” under article 625bis Code of Criminal Procedure; “incidente d’esecuzione” procedure under articles 666 and following CPP), and a general remedy has been introduced (exceptional review of a final conviction under article 630 CPP).

The most recent developments of the Italian case law deal with the issue of how to extend the effects of an ECtHR judgment to cases other than the one under the ECtHR’s review. In the absence of any organic stance by the executive or by the legislative power, cooperation between higher courts seems to have led to a solution. According to a set of judgments by the Court of Cassation and the Constitutional Court, the exceptional review under article 630 CPP is now to be considered as the “ordinary” remedy, both to enforce ECtHR’s judgments and to extend the effects of such judgments to similar cases. The “incidente d’esecuzione” procedure, instead, represents a residual solution which may be used when the effects of the ECtHR’s judgments pertain exclusively to the execution phase and do not require the use of any discretional power by the judge."

The highlighted text is a reference to the revision trial described in CPP Articles 629 - 647, with the elements required for a conviction to be allowed under law to be considered for revision listed in Article CPP 630. The article was declare unconstitutionally incomplete by the Italian Constitutional Court in its decision 113 of 2011, and that court added the final judgment of the ECHR that proceedings must be reopened as an element.

Ms. Sartori discusses that Constitutional Court decision in her post dated 23 February 2015.

The blog is at:
https://aninternationallawblog.wordpress.com/author/dariasartori/

Thanks to TomG on IIP for pointing out Ms. Sartori's blog.

I'm not sure what this means. Can you clarify?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom