Those interested in the ECHR case Knox v. Italy and the legal obligations of Italy following a potential judgment against Italy may wish to read some posts in a blog by Daria Sartori. Ms. Sartori is, according to her professional self-description on her blog, "PhD & Doctor Europaeus in Comparative and European Legal Studies ; Assistant Lawyer, European Court of Human Rights".
In the conclusion of her post dated 22 January 2018, she writes:
"In the Italian legal system, the absence of a comprehensive legislative intervention on the enforcement of ECtHR judgments finding violations of the guarantees of criminal trial has led domestic courts to intervene. Procedural remedies are applied analogically (“ricorso straordinario per errore materiale o di fatto” under article 625bis Code of Criminal Procedure; “incidente d’esecuzione” procedure under articles 666 and following CPP), and a general remedy has been introduced (exceptional review of a final conviction under article 630 CPP).
The most recent developments of the Italian case law deal with the issue of how to extend the effects of an ECtHR judgment to cases other than the one under the ECtHR’s review. In the absence of any organic stance by the executive or by the legislative power, cooperation between higher courts seems to have led to a solution. According to a set of judgments by the Court of Cassation and the Constitutional Court,
the exceptional review under article 630 CPP is now to be considered as the “ordinary” remedy, both to enforce ECtHR’s judgments and to extend the effects of such judgments to similar cases. The “incidente d’esecuzione” procedure, instead, represents a residual solution which may be used when the effects of the ECtHR’s judgments pertain exclusively to the execution phase and do not require the use of any discretional power by the judge."
The highlighted text is a reference to the revision trial described in CPP Articles 629 - 647, with the elements required for a conviction to be allowed under law to be considered for revision listed in Article CPP 630. The article was declare unconstitutionally incomplete by the Italian Constitutional Court in its decision 113 of 2011, and that court added the final judgment of the ECHR that proceedings must be reopened as an element.
Ms. Sartori discusses that Constitutional Court decision in her post dated 23 February 2015.
The blog is at:
https://aninternationallawblog.wordpress.com/author/dariasartori/
Thanks to TomG on IIP for pointing out Ms. Sartori's blog.