Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
A violent criminal in the middle of a heinous act is not likely to do the sensible conventional thing (and don't forget things have changed ENORMOUSLY since 2007/8). Mez' and Filomena's laptops were almost certainly password protected, so I doubt Raff would leave his fingerprints all over the keyboard, or want to register a connection with the internet from the cottage in the murder time frame in destroying the laptops.

When I threw out an old PC recently I removed the hard drive first, no specialist tools needed. I even installed a hard drive into a server casing recently. (With help; other posters might recognise how readily we can depend on our children to be extraordinarily technology savvy, virtually almost from birth.)

I'll add that not everyone uses passwords. Not even lawyers. For example, one of the computers that Guede stole...oh, sorry....bought from someone in Milan...er...Perugia belonging to one of the Perugia lawyers was not password protected:


(Motivation Report of Patrizia Lacaita, judge in Guede's trial for stolen property)

Queen of the non sequitur. You never disappoint.

Having trouble following the topic, eh? Try using 3X5 cards.
 
He was surfing the net wasn't he, looking up 'bleach', according to some reports.

According to what reports? Is that like the bleach receipts? BTW, You can delete browsing history. And believe me, that is one thing a computer science major would know how to do.
 
The PGP continually maintain that police are bound by their "code of ethics" to act with complete integrity, even therefore confessing to accidentally (or perhaps intentionally) destroying access to information, or corrupting that information, on the hard drives of several computers in this case, whose hard drives were rendered unreadable - at least by the methods of the police. Thus, the PGP argues, the lack of such confession by the police means that Knox and/or Sollecito made the drives unreadable. However, the Marasca CSC panel stated clearly that the police investigators had rendered the computer hard drives unreadable.

The fallacy of the PGP position is the assumption that police officers "must" and in reality do follow a "code of ethics" with no exceptions.

There are many cases where police officers do not act ethically or even legally.

Here is a report on a case where police acted completely without regard to the law, resulting in the wrongful conviction of two men in Kentucky for murder; both served over 20 years in prison as a result of the wrongful conviction. DNA testing showed that neither had been involved in the murder since neither was the source of a hair on the victim's body.

A primary cause of the wrongful conviction was a police detective claiming that one of the accused made a confession. The accused, however, denied making a confession. It turns out that the detective had previously fabricated incriminating statements of a suspect.

The Attorney General of Kentucky (the chief prosecutor of the state) stated: “Put bluntly, the Commonwealth [the State of Kentucky] cannot put credibility into an unrecorded statement taken by a detective who has a documented history of fabricating details of a murder case in his investigative summaries.”

Source: https://www.innocenceproject.org/ke...d-new-dna-testing-evidence-police-misconduct/
 
Last edited:
He was surfing the net wasn't he, looking up 'bleach', according to some reports.

'Reports from the mentally ill'?

No seriously. Has it occurred to you that reasoned debate and discussion (lol yeah) is kinda sorta impossible when the pro-guilt invalids literally invent facts out of thin air?
 
You can't explain how Filomena's laptop was coincidentally also damaged, except a ridiculous story that 'Rudy must have tripped over the cord and sent it crashing to the rock hard floor'.

To make up for a pitifully weak argument, we get a volley of foul-mouthed abuse, which is just about par for the couse.

Why do you think Filomena's laptop was damaged, Vixen, and how, exactly, do you think this is related to the pagan sex ritual murder? Are you insinuating something that makes no sense when you actually take 5 seconds to think it through... again?

Have you, Vixen, yet attempted to explain why every single professional scientist and forensic expert that has looked at the case has explained why all of the evidence is biased, flawed, and faulty and therefore Amanda and Raffaele are completely innocent? (without invoking a global conspiracy orchestrated by Donald Trump, I mean)
 
Why do you think Filomena's laptop was damaged, Vixen, and how, exactly, do you think this is related to the pagan sex ritual murder? Are you insinuating something that makes no sense when you actually take 5 seconds to think it through... again?

Have you, Vixen, yet attempted to explain why every single professional scientist and forensic expert that has looked at the case has explained why all of the evidence is biased, flawed, and faulty and therefore Amanda and Raffaele are completely innocent? (without invoking a global conspiracy orchestrated by Donald Trump, I mean)

You are dangerously close to asking the nutters to provide a timeline into which their claimed-evidence fits, and makes sense. From this seat they mostly just make stuff up. and when cramming the claimed-factoid into a reasonable timeline, then have to conclude that either AK or RS were clairvoyant and had had a well executed plan, while at the same time were goofy, nerdy doofuses.

Before putting their timeline together, though, they now have to deal with Maneula Comodi's Dec 2017 admission that AK had been a suspect before she'd been interrogated. Comodi should have at least waited until the ECHR ruled on Knox's application.

But the issue still stands - a timeline needs to settle on a few larger things - was Knox a suspect before the cops had seized her phone and had asked her about "See you later"? Vixen does not seem to want to deal with that at all.....
 
Last edited:
According to what reports? Is that like the bleach receipts? BTW, You can delete browsing history. And believe me, that is one thing a computer science major would know how to do.

Early Richard Owen.

People think they can delete their history, but they are in for a shock (ask Gary Glitter or Pete Townsend).
 
Amanda Knox kept a local file on her hard drive "my plan to kill my roommate with this dude i just met and a random guy i saw in the corner once at a party ive never spoken to who will take the blame for me and never testify against me.txt"

^--- what Vixen actually believes
 
Early Richard Owen.

People think they can delete their history, but they are in for a shock (ask Gary Glitter or Pete Townsend).



1) Where do you think Richard Owen might have obtained this "information"...? (And as a follow-up question: what do you think might have been the motivation/bias of the person/persons who supplied Owen with this "information"?)

2) Given that no evidence of this type was ever produced in court, how likely (on a scale of 0-10) do you think it is that this information was reliable and accurate? (as a clue, the answer is a single numeral containing "0")

3) Are you genuinely unaware that both Glitter and Townsend had in fact taken no steps whatsoever to delete their browsing histories or stored images? You're really not very clued up about all things computer/internet are you?
 
Amanda Knox kept a local file on her hard drive "my plan to kill my roommate with this dude i just met and a random guy i saw in the corner once at a party ive never spoken to who will take the blame for me and never testify against me.txt"

^--- what Vixen actually believes



Well, to be fair to the nutters..... I believe their "constructed reality" is that Knox and Sollecito had been going online in the immediate aftermath of the murders, in order to do things like google how to clean up a murder scene, or how to destroy DNA, and things like that. And that they then destroyed the hard drives in order to conceal that evidence. And that (I think I've got this right....) they also destroyed Romanelli's and Kercher's hard drives in a cunning plan to make it LOOK like the killer (or the police??) had destroyed all the hard drives as a "job lot".

But of course Sollecito's laptop was always in a totally different location (i.e. Sollecito's apartment) from the others (the girls' cottage). So if the nutters' concoction is that Knox/Sollecito were attempting a diversion/misdirection tactic to make it look like the "real killer" had just gone round destroying hard drives, then it's impossible to account for the destruction of Sollecito's hard drive (for what I hope are ludicrously obvious reasons). And if that's the case, then why would Knox/Sollecito even bother destroying Romanelli's hard drive: there could have been nothing whatsoever on there that would have been incriminating in respect of the murder, and Knox/Sollecito would still have had the problem of Sollecito's laptop in a totally different location.

On top of all this, and as I've mentioned before (though it seemed to go straight over the head of the poster to whom I was responding), had the police IT officers been competent and professional, then they would have had no problem recording and verifying that the hard drives had in fact been killed by the moment they entered the police labs. The police IT officers would not have wanted/needed to draw any further inferences (and indeed they could not have done so), but certainly if that evidence were put before a court, a court could reasonably wonder how/why so many hard drives were destroyed prior to their police seizure - and who might have the motive and opportunity to do so. But..... surprise, surprise..... the police IT officers never produced any report to that end. Why not? Because it was THEY who fried all those hard drives.
 
Early Richard Owen.

People think they can delete their history, but they are in for a shock (ask Gary Glitter or Pete Townsend).

I see. So the plural "reports" now boil down to a single, unverified report by Richard Owen. The same reporter who claimed the washing machine was running when the police arrived (false), that police had bleach purchase receipts (false), that the entire cottage except MK's room and the bathroom had been washed down with bleach (false), and that AK and RS were standing outside with a mop and bucket when the police arrived (false).

Are you seeing a trend here?
 
Well, to be fair to the nutters..... I believe their "constructed reality" is that Knox and Sollecito had been going online in the immediate aftermath of the murders, in order to do things like google how to clean up a murder scene, or how to destroy DNA, and things like that. And that they then destroyed the hard drives in order to conceal that evidence. And that (I think I've got this right....) they also destroyed Romanelli's and Kercher's hard drives in a cunning plan to make it LOOK like the killer (or the police??) had destroyed all the hard drives as a "job lot".

But of course Sollecito's laptop was always in a totally different location (i.e. Sollecito's apartment) from the others (the girls' cottage). So if the nutters' concoction is that Knox/Sollecito were attempting a diversion/misdirection tactic to make it look like the "real killer" had just gone round destroying hard drives, then it's impossible to account for the destruction of Sollecito's hard drive (for what I hope are ludicrously obvious reasons). And if that's the case, then why would Knox/Sollecito even bother destroying Romanelli's hard drive: there could have been nothing whatsoever on there that would have been incriminating in respect of the murder, and Knox/Sollecito would still have had the problem of Sollecito's laptop in a totally different location.

On top of all this, and as I've mentioned before (though it seemed to go straight over the head of the poster to whom I was responding), had the police IT officers been competent and professional, then they would have had no problem recording and verifying that the hard drives had in fact been killed by the moment they entered the police labs. The police IT officers would not have wanted/needed to draw any further inferences (and indeed they could not have done so), but certainly if that evidence were put before a court, a court could reasonably wonder how/why so many hard drives were destroyed prior to their police seizure - and who might have the motive and opportunity to do so. But..... surprise, surprise..... the police IT officers never produced any report to that end. Why not? Because it was THEY who fried all those hard drives.

Yeah but presumably the ISP logs would show a bunch of connection or DNS requests to all these crime scene cleanup sites and unexplained activity in general, which we don't have any record of, so it must have been offline data in the end.

If only the prosecution was in contact with Vixen they could have used this damning evidence to win the case, instead of losing badly while handing out gold medals to rapist killer Rudy Guede.
 
Yeah but presumably the ISP logs would show a bunch of connection or DNS requests to all these crime scene cleanup sites and unexplained activity in general, which we don't have any record of, so it must have been offline data in the end.

If only the prosecution was in contact with Vixen they could have used this damning evidence to win the case, instead of losing badly while handing out gold medals to rapist killer Rudy Guede.

It was the investigating police who were given the gold medals, not Guede. The same police whom M/B later thoroughly lambasted for the inept job they did.
 
Yeah but presumably the ISP logs would show a bunch of connection or DNS requests to all these crime scene cleanup sites and unexplained activity in general, which we don't have any record of, so it must have been offline data in the end.

If only the prosecution was in contact with Vixen they could have used this damning evidence to win the case, instead of losing badly while handing out gold medals to rapist killer Rudy Guede.



Ah but no but because erm proxy servers erm PAYG cellphone connections erm Knox-and-Sollecito-are-guilty-and-evil-cos-I-just-know-they-are-so-SOMETHING-right?

(I don't think that critical thinking and objective analysis are high up on the "positive attributes" list of many pro-guilt commentators.....)
 
People think they can delete their history, but they are in for a shock (ask Gary Glitter or Pete Townsend).

Ask me. They can delete the browsing history on their personal computers. What they can't delete are the browsing records at the ISP.
 
Last edited:
Ask me. They can delete the browsing history on their personal computers. What they can't delete are the browsing records at the ISP.


Too true. But - especially in 2007 - police would have a very hard time compelling ISPs to release those data. And, as I said, both Gary Glitter and Pete Townsend were caught because their own devices had both their browsing history and (more importantly in both cases as I recall) actual photos stored.

As you say, anyone who knew anything about browsers, the internet, and computing in general* would know that it's ridiculously easy to erase your browsing history permanently from your device. The only way it would ever even be detectable that you'd done so would be if you blanket-deleted everything (and even then, you could just set your default setting to "delete entire cache/history every time I close the browser"). If you selectively deleted the history you believed to be incriminating, then nobody looking at your computer would ever be the wiser (unless, as you say, they cross-checked with your ISP).


* i.e. someone like Sollecito. And NOT someone like nearly all pro-guilt commentators, it would appear.
 
It was the investigating police who were given the gold medals, not Guede. The same police whom M/B later thoroughly lambasted for the inept job they did.

In this case it was both. Convicted rapist killer Rudy Guede was personally congratulated by the Italian CSC for coming up with his fake story about being on a date with Meredith and lacking a condom while she spontaneously died in his presence and covered him with her blood for innocent reasons, in the form of a sentence reduction and words of endearment.
 
In this case it was both. Convicted rapist killer Rudy Guede was personally congratulated by the Italian CSC for coming up with his fake story about being on a date with Meredith and lacking a condom while she spontaneously died in his presence and covered him with her blood for innocent reasons, in the form of a sentence reduction and words of endearment.

Well...I think we should leave the gross exaggerations to Vixen. She does them so well.;)
 
Well...I think we should leave the gross exaggerations to Vixen. She does them so well.;)

Italian Appeals Court said:
Taking into account such elements, the Court holds such mitigating circumstances can be accepted. ....
...In addition, he {Guede} was the only one of the defendants to apologize to Meredith’s family,
...
Guede was the only one, even if in a somewhat fanciful reconstruction of events, to indicate the perpetrators.
...
For This Reason
....
The Corte di Assise di Appello of Perugia ...
...
REDUCES

the punishment of the appellant to 16 years of imprisonment."

Translation: here's a reward for your lying story about being sorry Meredith died for no reason while you were on a date with her with no condom.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom