Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
Knox probably had reams of rape murder fantasies on Word, together with her project planning journals plotting to exact revenge on her better-looking, more intelligent and infinitely more popular room mate, whom even the handsome ski-ing hunk downstairs preferred instead of her.

GlamorousAshamedDromaeosaur-max-1mb.gif
 
Seriously, please don't keep pronouncing on things you know nothing about.

Glitter was caught cos he had downloaded illegal photos and videos onto his PC. He even told the repair guy at PC World not to look in his photos and videos folders.

Townsend was caught because he subscribed to an illegal website using his credit card. And, like Glitter, when his computer was seized it had illegal photos/videos downloaded onto it.

Damien Green's HoC PC did indeed have porn sites in its browser history. So somebody (presumably Green himself, as it was his password-protected PC) had indeed surfed for porn and then not deleted the browsing history.

So you are wrong on every count.

And likewise, you continue to be wrong about what happens when you delete your browsing history. Had Sollecito, for example, wanted to go into his brower history and selectively delete everything related to (e.g.) how to destroy DNA at a crime scene that he'd looked at at (say) 3am on 2nd November 2007, then that history would have been erased from his computer. The only way the police could check would be to subpoena records from his ISP.

Why do you continue to hold forth on things you know little or nothing about, Vixen?

So not such a 'secure' site after all, then. What about that lecturer in geophysics recently who thought he was safe using an encrypted 'dark web'' bouncing off anonymous servers all over the world, yet he was traced, to his great horror.
 
No. Someone is either a witness, or a "person helping police with their inquiries", or a suspect. Romanelli and Mezetti only ever fell into the second category. As did Kercher's British student friends.

If the police consider someone a suspect of a crime, then it's axiomatic that that person must be afforded the full rights of a suspect. Full stop.

<fx slaps head while wondering how so many pro-guilt commentators promote such ignorant and ill-informed ideas about this case>

You really do not have the first idea how the Italian legal system works, do you?
 
<fx tap, tap, tap on a wooden surface> It really hasn't sunk into your skull that of course Italian police have long lists of suspects, just like police forces the world over. Italy also has a legal category of 'Formal Suspect', thus, it is quite possible to be a suspect, as all of the housemates and acquaintances of Mez initially were, without needing a Miranda Rights read out.

As Mignini points out all the British birds (as Grinder called them) were most helpful to the police, never moaning or complaining. Unlike your common felon.

And the "British birds" never underwent the same amount of questioning as Knox, either, as they were cleared early on. Let that sink in.

Hello? They had alibis.

You are wrong. Sophie Purton was also barred from leaving Italy and had her phone wire-tapped, and was interrogated fo hours, simply for being Shaky Hisam's girlfriend.

We never hear poor Sophie complain. She understands the police objective 100%. It was thanks to Raff and Amanda talking in fake Chinese Whispers in the Questura that Shaky was ever fingered at all. Knox loves to maliciously accuse others, doesn't she?

Try and follow what we're talking about here.

You said the British girls never moaned or complained like Knox. I said they didn't undergo the same amount of questioning that Knox did. It was those long hours of questioning and the resulting exhaustion that Knox complained about. Once again: the British girls did not undergo questioning to nearly the same extent.

Oh, good lord. Sophie was NOT Shakey's girlfriend! He had hit on her but they didn't date! As for that last bit about why Shakey wasn't "fingered", that's even beyond your usual lunacy and not worth responding to.
 
Bill Williams said:
You are dangerously close to asking the nutters to provide a timeline into which their claimed-evidence fits, and makes sense. From this seat they mostly just make stuff up. and when cramming the claimed-factoid into a reasonable timeline, then have to conclude that either AK or RS were clairvoyant and had had a well executed plan, while at the same time were goofy, nerdy doofuses.

Before putting their timeline together, though, they now have to deal with Maneula Comodi's Dec 2017 admission that AK had been a suspect before she'd been interrogated. Comodi should have at least waited until the ECHR ruled on Knox's application.

But the issue still stands - a timeline needs to settle on a few larger things - was Knox a suspect before the cops had seized her phone and had asked her about "See you later"? Vixen does not seem to want to deal with that at all.....
<fx tap, tap, tap on a wooden surface> It really hasn't sunk into your skull that of course Italian police have long lists of suspects, just like police forces the world over. Italy also has a legal category of 'Formal Suspect', thus, it is quite possible to be a suspect, as all of the housemates and acquaintances of Mez Meredith initially were, without needing a Miranda Rights read out.

As Mignini points out all the British birds (as Grinder called them) were most helpful to the police, never moaning or complaining. Unlike your common felon.

You have serious reading comprehension issues.

Please provide a time-line of the crime, all the way to when AK and RS were arrested. Provide the place on that timeline when Knox became a suspect according to the legal definition Mignini himself gave to Drew Griffin in 2010 during the CNN interview between the two of them.

Hint: Maneula Comodi sat right beside Mignini at the Dec 2017 "debate" and said that Knox had been a suspect before the interrogation. Mignini did not correct her which he should have, given what he'd told Drew Griffin in 2010.

It seems not even Comodi and Mignini can agree on a timeline. No wonder the 2015 Supreme Court acquitted the pair.
 
You really do not have the first idea how the Italian legal system works, do you?


Yes. Yes I do. And I know full well how the Italian police and PMs routinely abuse the process in order that the police interrogate people whom they consider suspects, without "formally" declaring them a suspect.

If the police - whether in Italy or the UK or US - believe someone to be a suspect of a criminal offence, then that person must be afforded the appropriate rights. Simple as.
 
Vixen said:
You really do not have the first idea how the Italian legal system works, do you?
And this coming from the woman who thinks using "for not having committed the crime" under 530.2 acquittals is a clerk typo.:jaw-dropp

Vixen believes the Italian system is riddled with typos. For instance, when the 2015 court acquitted the pair, she says that that was not true. She also believes that when Judge Nencini said that Raffaele's DNA had been found on the knife, that that had been a typo too.
 
Last edited:
Ask me. They can delete the browsing history on their personal computers. What they can't delete are the browsing records at the ISP.

So much for your claim of being #1 computing expert on this forum.

I know better than you.

Being quick on the mouse trigger at times, I’m personally elated to know that files aren’t necessarily gone after being deleted and emptied in the recycle bin. What you’re really doing in this case is deleting the location of those files, which merely hides them from the operating system. Emptying the bin frees up disk space and removes the pointer details from the file directory, but the files themselves still lurk. Unless that data has been physically removed from the hard drive, those files can be recovered with forensic recovery – even when the entire drive has been formatted and seemingly wiped clean.
https://www.storagecraft.com/blog/data-recovery-forensic-technology-can-cant/

And:

Hale explained that when a person deletes a file on a computer, the data doesn't actually disappear, but remains on the hard drive until it gets overwritten by new data. The computer's operating system may also keep records of deleted files in something called a "swap" or "recovery" file.

A computer's internal hard drive can keep records of how it was used, who used it, and when, Hale wrote. This digital evidence can point to information that once lived on a hard drive or memory stick, but was later altered or deleted. For example, agents might even be able to see where an incriminating paragraph was erased from a word processing document.

"Computer users typically do not erase or delete this evidence, because special software is typically required for that task," agent Hale wrote.

https://abcnews.go.com/Technology/fbis-digitial-detectives-recover-deleted/story?id=15470999


So much for your specious claim Raff would have time to run a load of software programmes at the crime scene should he want to delete incriminating data.
 
So much for your claim of being #1 computing expert on this forum.

I know better than you.

https://www.storagecraft.com/blog/data-recovery-forensic-technology-can-cant/

And:



https://abcnews.go.com/Technology/fbis-digitial-detectives-recover-deleted/story?id=15470999


So much for your specious claim Raff would have time to run a load of software programmes at the crime scene should he want to delete incriminating data.

If you had any idea how things worked, and if you had been paying attention to the last 1000 posts on the subject you would realize that all of us here who know how computers work know the OS does not remove data from the drive, it merely deletes the link to it. But that is why we've been saying one uses any number of tools available to permanently delete the data. Browsing history, cache and downloads are all stored in standard directory structures. It is very easy to navigate to those directories and destroy the data using one of these utilities.

I can delete (either fully or selectively) my browsing history, temp files (i.e., the cache), anything I might have downloaded, etc., and do it in less than five minutes. If you knew ANYTHING about computers you would understand this. Instead, you recite that which we already know and embarrassingly gloat as if you've uncovered some unknown secret.
 
So much for your claim of being #1 computing expert on this forum.

I know better than you.

https://www.storagecraft.com/blog/data-recovery-forensic-technology-can-cant/

And:



https://abcnews.go.com/Technology/fbis-digitial-detectives-recover-deleted/story?id=15470999


So much for your specious claim Raff would have time to run a load of software programmes at the crime scene should he want to delete incriminating data.

This is a perfect example of someone not knowing what they don't know. You think you've somehow proven the experts here, with decades of IT experience, wrong. You haven't. You've only exposed your own narcissism once more by gloating over something you think you know, but don't.
 
This is a perfect example of someone not knowing what they don't know. You think you've somehow proven the experts here, with decades of IT experience, wrong. You haven't. You've only exposed your own narcissism once more by gloating over something you think you know, but don't.

................. but she has everyone talking about her! Me included!
 
LOL One minute Raff's too thick to have fried the computer drives, and the next minute he's a computer whizzkid. Make up your mind.

There is a difference between understanding electronics and components and understanding programs. Raffaele is knowledgeable about the latter. He understands about programming and log files. He probably has a basic understanding of pc and network architecture. That doesn't mean he has a grasp on voltages and semiconductors which is what one might need to deliberately fry the hard drives.

When one studies a computer science curriculum the focus is not on the electrical properties but on programming applications and operating systems. This is what Raffaele's college studies was about. When Raffaele went looking for a job in the US, he was applying at Microsoft and other software companies, NOT hardware companies. His thesis was about social networking not the properties of the latest CPU or of LIDAR.
 
So much for your specious claim Raff would have time to run a load of software programmes at the crime scene should he want to delete incriminating data.

Again, you DON'T know what your talking about. Time consuming would be to mess with the hard drives. Five or six mouse clicks and walk away while the application cleans the drive of any trace.

Do yourself a favor and Google 'file shredders'. You will find dozens of military grade file shredding applications.
 
Last edited:
So much for your claim of being #1 computing expert on this forum.

I never said that. In fact, I bet I'm not. I know IT hardware and data communications architecture extremely well and I bet on those 2 facets of the industry I probably am or at least I used to be....given I'm retired and new stuff comes out every day. So who knows today.

What I do KNOW is YOU VIXEN barely understands this at all and are desperately trying to fit a square peg in a round hole.

BTW, the sure fire way to absolutely positively wipe all is to damage the drive....... BUT NOT THE WAY these drives were damaged. Not by frying the logic boards because the files would most likely be fine still residing on the disk platters. What you do is punch a hole through the disk drives. When I bought used servers from Bank of America. We punched a hole clean through every single drive before the servers could leave their facilities.

But this is them being paranoid which is good.
 
Again, you DON'T know what your talking about. Time consuming would be to mess with the hard drives. Five or six mouse clicks and walk away while the application cleans the drive of any trace.

Do yourself a favor and Google 'file shredders'. You will find dozens of military grade file shredding applications.

Since the PGP either have no ability to understand what you and others are saying about this matter, or they choose not to reveal their lack of knowledge in this area by actually doing some online research, here's one site I found by Googling "file shredder":

https://www.lifewire.com/free-file-shredder-software-programs-2619149

An excerpt:

"File shredder programs are software tools that permanently delete files on your computer. As you may or may not know, deleting a file just hides it from the operating system. It isn't really gone until that same space is overwritten by something else.

This is exactly what a file shredder does - it overwrites selected files using a specified data sanitization method, ensuring that's [sic] it can never be un-deleted with a file recovery program."

Wiping the hard drive (completely erasing all information, making impossible the recovery of the information stored prior to wiping) using software is also discussed on this site:

https://www.lifewire.com/how-to-wipe-a-hard-drive-2624527

The computer hard drives in question were not wiped nor were the files shredded. The Italian police attempting to examine the hard drives damaged the electronic circuits of the drives, making the drives unreadable with the methods available to the police. The Marasca CSC panel noted clearly that the investigators had done this damage.

The end. For reasonable people, that is.
 
Police visiting Raff's apartment were struck by an extremely strong smell of bleach (when his cleaner used the Dettol-like Lysoform, [which Raff was used to in his Medical Orphans boarding school and his papa's surgery]).

Cue: conspiracy theories about how the police only said this to please the mad evil RC Mignini.

Police went to Sollecito's apartment late on the night of Nov. 5/6. There, Finzi says he noticed the smell of bleach. But earlier on that same day (Nov. 5), the cleaning lady had cleaned his apartment with Lysoform. So what did she have to say? Her testimony:

Question: Let’s return to the day of 5th November, which is the last day that you saw Raffaele, because he was arrested the next day. You told us that there were 3 people in the house?
Answer: Yes it was on the last day.
Question: Can you repeat who was there?
Answer: There was Amanda and a friend.
Question: As well as Raffaele?
Answer: Yes
Question: What did you do, did you clean?
Answer: Yes, yes, I cleaned like I normally did.
Question: Did you see or smell anything particular that comes to mind, that could come to mind now. Do you remember anything in particular, of anything unusual that happened that day? Answer: No, no, because I saw everything to be normal, there was nothing. Question: There was nothing odd? Answer: No. Question: Were there any strange odours? Answer: No, nothing. Question: No kind of strange odour? Answer: No Question: A smell of beach? Answer: No, nothing. Maori: Thank-you.

So the cleaning lady smelled nothing out of the ordinary, including bleach, when she came to clean the afternoon of Nov. 5. Do you want to claim that RS and AK waited to bleach the house clean between the time the cleaning lady left and the time they went to RS's friends for dinner on Nov. 5?
 
So much for your claim of being #1 computing expert on this forum.

I know better than you.

https://www.storagecraft.com/blog/data-recovery-forensic-technology-can-cant/

And:



https://abcnews.go.com/Technology/fbis-digitial-detectives-recover-deleted/story?id=15470999



So much for your specious claim Raff would have time to run a load of software programmes at the crime scene should he want to delete incriminating data.

The words 'grandmother' and 'suck eggs' come to mind.

That is why most of us have a secure delete program, this overwrites the data on the hard drive: "remains on the hard drive until it gets overwritten by new data".
 
Again to be fair, Guede's sentence reduction was as much to do with achieving parity with the sentences given to Knox and Sollecito (minus his 1/3 reduction for choosing the fast track trial) as any positive mitigation.
One of the many things which stinks/stank about the total separation of Guede's trial process from Knox's/Sollecito's. The most egregious of which, of course, has to be the bizarre situation in Guede's trials where both the prosecution and defence NEEDED the verdict to state that others were involved.....

But was this sentencing fair?

First Guede was sentenced to 30 years (including the fast-track discount) by the Micheli court, while Knox and Sollecito were sentenced to 26 years and 25 years, respectively, by the Massei court.

On appeal, Guede's sentence was reduced to 16 years by the Borsini appeal court.

In contrast, Knox and Sollecito were acquitted of the murder/sexual assault by the Hellmann appeal court, but Knox was convicted of calunnia against Lumumba and sentenced to 3 years (essentially the time served after the initial remand period).

Since of the three accused, only Guede's DNA was found within Meredith Kercher's body or in her room, including on her purse, while his bloody hand print and shoe prints were also found in the room, it is clear that Guede is responsible for the sexual assault and murder of Kercher.

The reduction in Guede's sentence is the product of the highly distorted and biased "reasoning" of the Borsini appeal court, whose verdict was published 22 December 2009, possibly relying on the Massei court verdict, published 4-5 December 2009. The Borsini court shifted the responsibility for the murder/rape from Guede to Knox. Thus, had the Borsini court verdict followed the Hellmann court verdict, there would have been no reason for an unbiased court to reduce Guede's sentence.
 
Last edited:
Police visiting Raff's apartment were struck by an extremely strong smell of bleach (when his cleaner used the Dettol-like Lysoform, [which Raff was used to in his Medical Orphans boarding school and his papa's surgery]).

Cue: conspiracy theories about how the police only said this to please the mad evil RC Mignini.

Please do not use technical terms you do not know the meaning of. It only displays that that your biased opinions are based on ignorance.

Lysoform is not Dettol like. Lyssoform is essentially formalin, an aqueous solution of an aldehyde; formaldehyde. Dettol is an aqueous solution of a phenol; chloroxylenol. They are chemically very different, smell different and are both different from 'bleach'. The smell of formalin will be familiar to most people who have done biology as it is a widely used preservative. The smell of Dettol is principally the 'pine' scent that is added. This is designed to be a lingering 'clean' odour. But any 'pine fresh' product e.g. toilet cleaner, air freshener, detergent, will have a similar odour.

Bleach does not have much of a smell, hydrogen peroxide like agents may produce oxygen and ozone; essentially odourless. Hypochlorites may produce chlorine which is pungent but short lived as it is rapidly reactive. The smell of bleach might be familiar to police officers as it is an ingredient in Luminol spray, though they might not know that it contains bleach.

Someone may know because I cannot be bothered to look, did they use Luminol spray at Sollecito's? Because if they did that would explain the 'odour' of bleach.

ETA a number of cleaning agents including bleach products may have added odours e.g. lemon fresh.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom