Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
Because the forensic IT guys would spot the wholesale deletion.

Nope, sorry.. data can easily be removed without leaving a trace. The area of the drive where the data resided is overwritten with predefined patterns of 0's and 1's that make it impossible to recover what used to be there. I've been using a tool called PGP for years but there are numerous free and licensed tools that do the same thing.

Want to guess again?
 
Yep.

Raffaele I bet is familiar with shred utilities that will delete everything off a drive and not leave a trace. He'd also know how to reinstall the OS. Why pull the disk drives when all you have to do is make a few keystrokes and mouse clicks?

Agreed.

Another aspect of this that Vixen ignores is Raffaele had been dating Amanda for only one week. How much possible incriminating evidence could possibly exist on his drive? It would be a simple task to find those things he was concerned with and delete them. It's not like he had years of history with Amanda and was concerned he could miss some things. And like most people who use a computer constantly, much of their lives are stored there. Photographs, emails, documents, contact information, etc. The thought of losing my computer (or even my phone) is deeply troubling, which is why everything I own is redundantly backed up. With so many easy options available to him it is laughable to think Raffaele would have deliberately destroyed his drive.

The entire argument by Vixen is nonsensical but it typical for a PGP. It makes no difference if it makes sense or not, whether you can prove it or not, whether there is an innocent interpretation or not ... just throw it on that 'mountain' of evidence - it's all about quantity, not quality.
 
Knowing when to put the shovel away is not a strong point of certain PGPs. They just continue to dig and dig and dig ...
 
A violent criminal in the middle of a heinous act is not likely to do the sensible conventional thing (and don't forget things have changed ENORMOUSLY since 2007/8). Mez' and Filomena's laptops were almost certainly password protected, so I doubt Raff would leave his fingerprints all over the keyboard, or want to register a connection with the internet from the cottage in the murder time frame in destroying the laptops.

When I threw out an old PC recently I removed the hard drive first, no specialist tools needed. I even installed a hard drive into a server casing recently. (With help; other posters might recognise how readily we can depend on our children to be extraordinarily technology savvy, virtually almost from birth.)

I'll add that not everyone uses passwords. Not even lawyers. For example, one of the computers that Guede stole...oh, sorry....bought from someone in Milan...er...Perugia belonging to one of the Perugia lawyers was not password protected:

Paolo Brocchi; who, having been contacted by telephone by the operators, confirmed goods had been stolen, stating that the computer was the property of his colleague Matteo Palazzoli and was easy to use because entry of a password was not required for access.
(Motivation Report of Patrizia Lacaita, judge in Guede's trial for stolen property)
 
Because the forensic IT guys would spot the wholesale deletion.

So what?

First, I can't imagine what possible incriminating evidence he could have on it. Second, they wouldn't be able to detect the deletion although, they probably could detect the new installation. And there could be many reasonable explanations for installing a new OS including malware, viruses or other problems.

You have Raffaele performing a time consuming needless and a very ineffective method to remove files when there would be much simpler and more effective methods he would know about and choose first.

You are desperately trying to put a square peg in a round hole.
 
Last edited:
So what?

First, I can't imagine what possible incriminating evidence he could have on it. Second, they wouldn't be able to detect the deletion although, they probably could detect the new installation. And there could be many reasonable explanations for installing a new OS including malware, viruses or other problems.

You have Raffaele performing a time consuming needless and a very ineffective method to remove files when there would be much simpler methods he would know about and choose first.

You are desperately trying to put a square peg in a round hole.

Vixen NEEDS for Raffaele to be responsible for the fried laptops. Otherwise, she'd have to admit that the "professional, well trained, and competent" cops screwed up. And if they screwed up the laptops, that would mean it was equally possible the cops screwed up elsewhere. She can't have that.
 
Vixen NEEDS for Raffaele to be responsible for the fried laptops. Otherwise, she'd have to admit that the "professional, well trained, and competent" cops screwed up. And if they screwed up the laptops, that would mean it was equally possible the cops screwed up elsewhere. She can't have that.

Which is moronic. Even on a Vixen scale it is stupid logic. It proves nothing. Not corruption, just a blunder. People make mistakes. And Vixen misses that these ridiculous arguments only makes Vixen less credible.
 
If anyone is in need of a good laugh, take a peek at Slick Pete's latest Front Page article. It's remarkably asinine even for him. And that's saying something. I think Petey's vying with NvdL for how much drivel he can churn out.
 
If anyone is in need of a good laugh, take a peek at Slick Pete's latest Front Page article. It's remarkably asinine even for him. And that's saying something. I think Petey's vying with NvdL for how much drivel he can churn out.

I don't go looking for crazy unless the occasional visit to this thread qualifies.
 
I've been tearing computers apart since before IBM introduced the PC1. I've got extensive hands on experience with virtually every type of hard drive ever to make it to mainstream (and some that didn't), including DASD packs on mainframes (uh oh, just dated myself). But I certainly would have no idea which leads I should apply voltage to, what voltage to use or what that would do to the drive. And I am certain Raffaele wouldn't know either. IF he were in a situation where he didn't want data to be accessed by the police the only way to guarantee it (and, btw, the MUCH easier way) is to destructively delete the data using one of many tools available to do it. I know you already know this but Vixen is just talking out her backside.

Vixen also failed to address the basic question of why Raffaele would deliberately destroy four laptops. Her reasoning that Filomena's had to be done else it would look suspicious was hilarious to say the least. They had control of their own laptops, which were at his apartment. They had no reason to destroy Filomena's. If they were concerned there was data on Meredith's laptop then why not just kill it.. only one machine dead - it happens. No, her explanation is kill four of them in a completely unrealistic fashion so as to not look suspicious. You just can't make this stuff up!

You can't explain how Filomena's laptop was coincidentally also damaged, except a ridiculous story that 'Rudy must have tripped over the cord and sent it crashing to the rock hard floor'.

To make up for a pitifully weak argument, we get a volley of foul-mouthed abuse, which is just about par for the couse.
 
Agreed.

Another aspect of this that Vixen ignores is Raffaele had been dating Amanda for only one week. How much possible incriminating evidence could possibly exist on his drive? It would be a simple task to find those things he was concerned with and delete them. It's not like he had years of history with Amanda and was concerned he could miss some things. And like most people who use a computer constantly, much of their lives are stored there. Photographs, emails, documents, contact information, etc. The thought of losing my computer (or even my phone) is deeply troubling, which is why everything I own is redundantly backed up. With so many easy options available to him it is laughable to think Raffaele would have deliberately destroyed his drive.

The entire argument by Vixen is nonsensical but it typical for a PGP. It makes no difference if it makes sense or not, whether you can prove it or not, whether there is an innocent interpretation or not ... just throw it on that 'mountain' of evidence - it's all about quantity, not quality.


He was surfing the net wasn't he, looking up 'bleach', according to some reports.
 
I'll add that not everyone uses passwords. Not even lawyers. For example, one of the computers that Guede stole...oh, sorry....bought from someone in Milan...er...Perugia belonging to one of the Perugia lawyers was not password protected:


(Motivation Report of Patrizia Lacaita, judge in Guede's trial for stolen property)

Queen of the non sequitur. You never disappoint.
 
The other thing that Comodi admits to in the interview was their intention to arrest Knox before her mother arrived. She admits that Knox and Sollecito were suspects.

Comodi admits that the prosecution / police regarded Knox and Sollecito as suspects prior to their arrest and intended to arrest them to prevent Knox leaving for the US. They were suspects according to Commodi when they were interviewed, yet they were not interviewed as suspects. If I were Knox's lawyers I would be getting a copy of this interview and forwarding as evidence to ECHR to show how her rights were deliberately denied her by the police / prosecution.

That's an excellent point and I hope Knox's lawyers have already done exactly that. I also found it amusing that at around the 19:19 mark Comodi admitted than she initially thought there was "strong circumstantial evidence of" Knox's guilt because "by accusing Lumuma(sic!" she had "implicitly declared she was present at the killing of Meredith Kercher". Of course Comodi makes no mention of Knox having been subjected to any police coercion, interviewed without a lawyer present, in a language in which she had, at best, only a basic grasp, etc., etc. But it's funny to me that this remark by Comodi lays bare the stupidity of the guilters' standard line that Knox named Lumumba to deflect attention from herself. Sure :rolleyes:....placing oneself a mere few feet away from where a murder is taking place is a great way to throw the cops off your trail.
 
You can't explain how Filomena's laptop was coincidentally also damaged, except a ridiculous story that 'Rudy must have tripped over the cord and sent it crashing to the rock hard floor'.

To make up for a pitifully weak argument, we get a volley of foul-mouthed abuse, which is just about par for the couse.

You can't explain why neither the police nor the prosecution ever claimed , or even implied, that Raffaele had anything to do with Filomena's computer problems.

LJ never said what you put in quotes. He wrote "possibly by tripping over the power cord". (post #1824) Do you not understand the difference between "must have" and "possibly" any better than understanding the meaning of "soon"?

To make up for a pitifully weak argument, you misquote and ignore the blaringly obvious fact that no one but you disputes the 3 laptops were fried while in police custody, including the courts. No one but you claims Raffaele had anything to do with Filomena's laptop problems.

If we made a Ven diagram of all the unsupported and false claims about these laptops, your name would be in the middle.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom