Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
In this case it was both. Convicted rapist killer Rudy Guede was personally congratulated by the Italian CSC for coming up with his fake story about being on a date with Meredith and lacking a condom while she spontaneously died in his presence and covered him with her blood for innocent reasons, in the form of a sentence reduction and words of endearment.

Well...I think we should leave the gross exaggerations to Vixen. She does them so well.;)

It's satire. The reason it seems a bit lame, compared to, for example, J. Swift's A Modest Proposal* is that it is too close to the truth.

No medals for Guede, but he was praised for being the only who expressed regret, not for murdering Meredith Kercher, but for not seeking help. And his sentence was reduced beyond the fast-track reduction because he was not the primary perpetrator, according to the Borsini appeal court motivation report.

An excerpt from the translation of the MR:

"In addition, he was the only one of the defendants to apologize to Meredith’s family, even if referring only to his lack of help to her [in her dying moments], as was recognized by the lawyers of the girl’s relatives who participated as civil parties.

Then, apart from the attempt to staunch the flow of blood from the wound and the proof that it was not he that held the knife that was compatible with the worst of the lesions, it should also be remembered that Guede was the only one, even if in a somewhat fanciful reconstruction of events, to indicate the perpetrators [named as Knox and Sollecito in the MR]."**


*https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Modest_Proposal
https://www.gutenberg.org/files/1080/1080-h/1080-h.htm

**https://borsinibellardi.wordpress.com/contents/reasons-for-the-decision/
 
Translation: here's a reward for your lying story about being sorry Meredith died for no reason while you were on a date with her with no condom.


Again to be fair, Guede's sentence reduction was as much to do with achieving parity with the sentences given to Knox and Sollecito (minus his 1/3 reduction for choosing the fast track trial) as any positive mitigation.

One of the many things which stinks/stank about the total separation of Guede's trial process from Knox's/Sollecito's. The most egregious of which, of course, has to be the bizarre situation in Guede's trials where both the prosecution and defence NEEDED the verdict to state that others were involved.....
 
I understand both your points, but when actual medals were given to the bumbling police...

No big deal, though.



I wonder if they'll ask for those medals back when the ECHR verdict comes down....?

(I don't wonder at all)

(Not that the Marasca SC report wasn't already scathing enough about the widespread incompetence and possible malpractice by the police during this investigation....)
 
Too true. But - especially in 2007 - police would have a very hard time compelling ISPs to release those data. And, as I said, both Gary Glitter and Pete Townsend were caught because their own devices had both their browsing history and (more importantly in both cases as I recall) actual photos stored.

As you say, anyone who knew anything about browsers, the internet, and computing in general* would know that it's ridiculously easy to erase your browsing history permanently from your device. The only way it would ever even be detectable that you'd done so would be if you blanket-deleted everything (and even then, you could just set your default setting to "delete entire cache/history every time I close the browser"). If you selectively deleted the history you believed to be incriminating, then nobody looking at your computer would ever be the wiser (unless, as you say, they cross-checked with your ISP).


* i.e. someone like Sollecito. And NOT someone like nearly all pro-guilt commentators, it would appear.

That's why Vixen's take on this is downright stupid. Raffaele is a computer geek with multiple computers running different operating systems. I don't believe Raffaele fried those computer drives mostly because I dont for one second think there is anything incriminating on them. But also because someone with his expertise would know how to delete browsing history and files.

Frying the hard drive to delete your browsing history is like using a 20 pound sledgehammer to kill flies. Sure, the fly would be dead but nobody would do it that way.
 
Amanda Knox kept a local file on her hard drive "my plan to kill my roommate with this dude i just met and a random guy i saw in the corner once at a party ive never spoken to who will take the blame for me and never testify against me.txt"

^--- what Vixen actually believes

Never underestimate Occam's razor.
 
1) Where do you think Richard Owen might have obtained this "information"...? (And as a follow-up question: what do you think might have been the motivation/bias of the person/persons who supplied Owen with this "information"?)

2) Given that no evidence of this type was ever produced in court, how likely (on a scale of 0-10) do you think it is that this information was reliable and accurate? (as a clue, the answer is a single numeral containing "0")

3) Are you genuinely unaware that both Glitter and Townsend had in fact taken no steps whatsoever to delete their browsing histories or stored images? You're really not very clued up about all things computer/internet are you?

That's where you are wrong. People often believe that hitting the 'clear history' browsing data means their employers or the police cannot see what they've been browsing.

Do you really think people accessing hard core sites don't delete their browsing history automatically, especially before taking their PC in for repairs, which was how Gary Glitter was caught out. Whoever accessed Cabinet Minister Damien Geen's computer in his constituency office certainly didn't download stacks of porn on taxpayers' money in the expectation Inspector Knacker of the Yard could trace it.

I'd say you're not very clued up.
 
But, but....Raff was surfing the internet for info on bleach on his Mac, wasn't he? Why didn't he delete that incriminating evidence? Sheesh.

Never underestimate Occam's razor? That's rich coming from a PGP.

Guede, known burglar/thief/knife wielder/liar, breaks into apartment, sexually assaults and kills Kercher. All by himself. Yep...Occam's razor.
 
You are dangerously close to asking the nutters to provide a timeline into which their claimed-evidence fits, and makes sense. From this seat they mostly just make stuff up. and when cramming the claimed-factoid into a reasonable timeline, then have to conclude that either AK or RS were clairvoyant and had had a well executed plan, while at the same time were goofy, nerdy doofuses.

Before putting their timeline together, though, they now have to deal with Maneula Comodi's Dec 2017 admission that AK had been a suspect before she'd been interrogated. Comodi should have at least waited until the ECHR ruled on Knox's application.

But the issue still stands - a timeline needs to settle on a few larger things - was Knox a suspect before the cops had seized her phone and had asked her about "See you later"? Vixen does not seem to want to deal with that at all.....

<fx tap, tap, tap on a wooden surface> It really hasn't sunk into your skull that of course Italian police have long lists of suspects, just like police forces the world over. Italy also has a legal category of 'Formal Suspect', thus, it is quite possible to be a suspect, as all of the housemates and acquaintances of Mez initially were, without needing a Miranda Rights read out.

As Mignini points out all the British birds (as Grinder called them) were most helpful to the police, never moaning or complaining. Unlike your common felon.
 
1) Where do you think Richard Owen might have obtained this "information"...? (And as a follow-up question: what do you think might have been the motivation/bias of the person/persons who supplied Owen with this "information"?)

2) Given that no evidence of this type was ever produced in court, how likely (on a scale of 0-10) do you think it is that this information was reliable and accurate? (as a clue, the answer is a single numeral containing "0")

3) Are you genuinely unaware that both Glitter and Townsend had in fact taken no steps whatsoever to delete their browsing histories or stored images? You're really not very clued up about all things computer/internet are you?

That's where you are wrong. People often believe that hitting the 'clear history' browsing data means their employers or the police cannot see what they've been browsing.

Do you really think people accessing hard core sites don't delete their browsing history automatically, especially before taking their PC in for repairs, which was how Gary Glitter was caught out. Whoever accessed Cabinet Minister Damien Geen's computer in his constituency office certainly didn't download stacks of porn on taxpayers' money in the expectation Inspector Knacker of the Yard could trace it.

I'd say you're not very clued up.

You do realize that you didn't answer any of LJ's questions, don't you? LJ mentioned nothing about "hitting the 'clear history' browsing data. He said the two had done nothing to delete their browsing histories or stored images.
 
1) Where do you think Richard Owen might have obtained this "information"...? (And as a follow-up question: what do you think might have been the motivation/bias of the person/persons who supplied Owen with this "information"?)

2) Given that no evidence of this type was ever produced in court, how likely (on a scale of 0-10) do you think it is that this information was reliable and accurate? (as a clue, the answer is a single numeral containing "0")

3) Are you genuinely unaware that both Glitter and Townsend had in fact taken no steps whatsoever to delete their browsing histories or stored images? You're really not very clued up about all things computer/internet are you?

Police visiting Raff's apartment were struck by an extremely strong smell of bleach (when his cleaner used the Dettol-like Lysoform, [which Raff was used to in his Medical Orphans boarding school and his papa's surgery]).

Cue: conspiracy theories about how the police only said this to please the mad evil RC Mignini.
 
That's where you are wrong. People often believe that hitting the 'clear history' browsing data means their employers or the police cannot see what they've been browsing.

Do you really think people accessing hard core sites don't delete their browsing history automatically, especially before taking their PC in for repairs, which was how Gary Glitter was caught out. Whoever accessed Cabinet Minister Damien Geen's computer in his constituency office certainly didn't download stacks of porn on taxpayers' money in the expectation Inspector Knacker of the Yard could trace it.

I'd say you're not very clued up.


Seriously, please don't keep pronouncing on things you know nothing about.

Glitter was caught cos he had downloaded illegal photos and videos onto his PC. He even told the repair guy at PC World not to look in his photos and videos folders.

Townsend was caught because he subscribed to an illegal website using his credit card. And, like Glitter, when his computer was seized it had illegal photos/videos downloaded onto it.

Damien Green's HoC PC did indeed have porn sites in its browser history. So somebody (presumably Green himself, as it was his password-protected PC) had indeed surfed for porn and then not deleted the browsing history.

So you are wrong on every count.

And likewise, you continue to be wrong about what happens when you delete your browsing history. Had Sollecito, for example, wanted to go into his brower history and selectively delete everything related to (e.g.) how to destroy DNA at a crime scene that he'd looked at at (say) 3am on 2nd November 2007, then that history would have been erased from his computer. The only way the police could check would be to subpoena records from his ISP.

Why do you continue to hold forth on things you know little or nothing about, Vixen?
 
<fx tap, tap, tap on a wooden surface> It really hasn't sunk into your skull that of course Italian police have long lists of suspects, just like police forces the world over. Italy also has a legal category of 'Formal Suspect', thus, it is quite possible to be a suspect, as all of the housemates and acquaintances of Mez initially were, without needing a Miranda Rights read out.

As Mignini points out all the British birds (as Grinder called them) were most helpful to the police, never moaning or complaining. Unlike your common felon.

And the "British birds" never underwent the same amount of questioning as Knox, either, as they were cleared early on. Let that sink in.
 
Police visiting Raff's apartment were struck by an extremely strong smell of bleach (when his cleaner used the Dettol-like Lysoform, [which Raff was used to in his Medical Orphans boarding school and his papa's surgery]).

Cue: conspiracy theories about how the police only said this to please the mad evil RC Mignini.



Yeah, erm, this "answer" has no relation whatsoever to the matter I was discussing in the post which you quoted.

Have another go.
 
Yeah but presumably the ISP logs would show a bunch of connection or DNS requests to all these crime scene cleanup sites and unexplained activity in general, which we don't have any record of, so it must have been offline data in the end.

If only the prosecution was in contact with Vixen they could have used this damning evidence to win the case, instead of losing badly while handing out gold medals to rapist killer Rudy Guede.

Knox probably had reams of rape murder fantasies on Word, together with her project planning journals plotting to exact revenge on her better-looking, more intelligent and infinitely more popular room mate, whom even the handsome ski-ing hunk downstairs preferred instead of her.
 
<fx tap, tap, tap on a wooden surface> It really hasn't sunk into your skull that of course Italian police have long lists of suspects, just like police forces the world over. Italy also has a legal category of 'Formal Suspect', thus, it is quite possible to be a suspect, as all of the housemates and acquaintances of Mez initially were, without needing a Miranda Rights read out.

As Mignini points out all the British birds (as Grinder called them) were most helpful to the police, never moaning or complaining. Unlike your common felon.


No. Someone is either a witness, or a "person helping police with their inquiries", or a suspect. Romanelli and Mezetti only ever fell into the second category. As did Kercher's British student friends.

If the police consider someone a suspect of a crime, then it's axiomatic that that person must be afforded the full rights of a suspect. Full stop.

<fx slaps head while wondering how so many pro-guilt commentators promote such ignorant and ill-informed ideas about this case>
 
That's why Vixen's take on this is downright stupid. Raffaele is a computer geek with multiple computers running different operating systems. I don't believe Raffaele fried those computer drives mostly because I dont for one second think there is anything incriminating on them. But also because someone with his expertise would know how to delete browsing history and files.

Frying the hard drive to delete your browsing history is like using a 20 pound sledgehammer to kill flies. Sure, the fly would be dead but nobody would do it that way.


LOL One minute Raff's too thick to have fried the computer drives, and the next minute he's a computer whizzkid. Make up your mind.
 
Knox probably had reams of rape murder fantasies on Word, together with her project planning journals plotting to exact revenge on her better-looking, more intelligent and infinitely more popular room mate, whom even the handsome ski-ing hunk downstairs preferred instead of her.



My word. Even by the standard of regular pro-guilt histrionics, this is quite some piece of twisted fantasy.
 
And the "British birds" never underwent the same amount of questioning as Knox, either, as they were cleared early on. Let that sink in.

Hello? They had alibis.

You are wrong. Sophie Purton was also barred from leaving Italy and had her phone wire-tapped, and was interrogated fo hours, simply for being Shaky Hisam's girlfriend.

We never hear poor Sophie complain. She understands the police objective 100%. It was thanks to Raff and Amanda talking in fake Chinese Whispers in the Questura that Shaky was ever fingered at all. Knox loves to maliciously accuse others, doesn't she?
 
Police visiting Raff's apartment were struck by an extremely strong smell of bleach (when his cleaner used the Dettol-like Lysoform, [which Raff was used to in his Medical Orphans boarding school and his papa's surgery]).

Cue: conspiracy theories about how the police only said this to please the mad evil RC Mignini.

The police smelled what they assumed to be bleach. It was never established that they could distinguish bleach from lysoform which the maid had used to clean the apartment the day before.

Additionally, the maid testified that there had been 1 1/2 bottles of bleach in the house before the murder which were found still under the sink. So, explain to me exactly what bleach they used?

Cue: that the police assumed the lysoform smell was bleach.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom