Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
Two completely separate IT forensic experts have ZERO reason to lie (and it is lying by omission to fail to testify it was you who fried the laptops, and even perjury, if that was the case). The defence could have appealed on the point of law of 'witholding exculpatory evidence' (Brady v Maryland in the USA).

Fact is, as several PIP's themselves have pointed out, a forensic IT guy would NOT power up the laptop, they would remove the hard drive intact from the laptop body, without switching it on.

In science it is impossible to prove a negative. Thus, when it was discovered from cloning, the data was not retrievable, probably due to overcircuiting the drive causing a fry-out, being upright honest TRAINED expert witnesses, they were not in a position to say who, why or when the drives shortcircuited, as, having not powered it up, they DO NOT KNOW whether they were working beforehand or not. Thus, they objectively and properly did not assign blame .

If they had discovered a fault in their methods they would have DISCLOSED it. Ethically, they would have said, 'M'Lud, we accidentally put the wrong voltage through it.' They did NOT. OTOH Filomena's laptop was damaged in a similar way BEFORE the police even received her laptop. The short circuit did not happen with Lumumba's laptop. Just as Raff tried to preclude Mez' DNA being on HIS knife by writing that he had accidentally 'pricked her hand' whilst she was round his house cooking, he tries to do the same by insinuating the police pulled the plug at the wall without letting him log off properly, thereby contributing to the loss of data. If we draw a Venn diagram of all the laptops that were damaged and who had had access to them on the murder night - or potentially had access - we find Raff's name at the centre of it. Lumumba's name is out of the diagram all together as his drive was not found to be fried. Raff had no access to it. If it was the police methods that were at fault we should expect Patrick's to have suffered a similar fate, because if it was a fry up by the IT police, then the IT guys didn't spot their error three attempts in a row, so why would light suddenly dawn with the next one. In typical LondonJohn fashion, once again you are accusing decent honest, well-qualified, members of the Rome Forensic Police of being crooks and frauds and in a conspiracy with a mad evil prosecutor.

You were doing fine right up until the highlighted part. I love how you refer to the IT guys as 'experts'. You obviously have never worked in the IT industry. As someone who worked in the computer industry for 3 decades I can say unequivocally that few people in the computer industry refer to themselves as experts. The reason is the knowledgebase is immense and constantly growing. Things are changing constantly. Someone who thinks they know everything quickly finds out there is far too much to know.

Different manufacturers do things differently. The standard for drive connections use to be 5 volts and the cables were keyed so it was impossible for someone to connect it wrong. But this was right at the time where 2.5 inch SATA (Serial ATA) were replacing PATA (Parallel) drives and 3.3 volt drives were becoming popular. Drive connections were not standardized and cables were not necessarily keyed. All the techs would probably know is that for some unknown reason the cloning procedure was failing. They would likely not know they were the cause of the failure and being human wouldn't be interested in coming to the conclusion that it was there own personal incompetence that was the cause.

Please stop trying to pretend you understand this and that you can come to a confident conclusion. I'm the closest thing to an expert on this kind of IT participating in this forum and I KNOW I DON'T KNOW. I also know you don't know either. You keep relying on this idea that people are experts in their jobs when in fact, you don't know that. You keep making assumptions but only if the assumptions support your view. My experience working with IT techs is that some are very very good and the rest are barely adequate and are faking it hoping not to be exposed.

What I do know, it is highly unlikely that Raffaele deliberately tried to fry the drives as there really was no reason for him to do such a thing. I also (reluctantly) came to the same conclusion about the techs. But I am 99.99999 percent sure that the techs somehow were responsible for the failure as drives fail very rarely and the techs were the only people who could have caused the failures.
 
Last edited:
BTW - listening to Comodi try to justify a 46 day delay in collecting the bra-clasp is hilarious, esp. if she thinks it justifies it.....


Comodi says there it is no problem that the bra-claps was collected 46 days later, in a different position and after many people walked through the room.
Mignini says they couldn't take the body temperature because Stefanoni was concerned of contamination.
 
Comodi says there it is no problem that the bra-claps was collected 46 days later, in a different position and after many people walked through the room.
Mignini says they couldn't take the body temperature because Stefanoni was concerned of contamination.

Napoleoni said that the 118 Medical Staff came into the murder room with no anti-contamination garb, to verify the victim's condition.
 
Well, you didn't take a degree in CS so how would you know that you would have no problem? Whereas, I asked my daughter who DID get a degree in computer science two years ago and she told me that they covered very little on hardware. Computer Science is very software oriented as she just told me. The hardware end of it (with the exception of processer etc. design) is what's taught in 2 year trade schools as my husband with 30+ years of experience in both just said.
Stop pontificating on a subject you have no expertise on. I'm almost embarrassed for you. Almost.

Here in the UK you would cover it. A colleague of mine in a previous job had a BSc(Hons) in computer science and had no problem building up PC's from scratch. Another acquaintance who left school at 16 regularly used to update his IT system, by buying individual parts from China and assembling it all himself, at a substantial saving.
 
Actually it was the Perugian 'Postal' police who did the analysis. But why let your ignorance of the facts of the case get in the way of an ill informed opinion.

The odd thing is why would a software scientist (Sollecito) 'fry' a hard drive. This does not destroy the data on the hard drive just makes it hard to access, The actual magnetic disc remains intact, it can be removed from the drive and placed in a new drive, the reason the police / prosecution did not do this was cost. The defence requested for it to be done. If the defence did not want the data accessed why did they request the drives be sent to external agencies to recover the data and why did the prosecution refuse? To access the hard drive on a laptop would require proprietary tools, there is no evidence Sollecito had these certainly they are not listed in the search of his flat.

A software scientist would know the easiest and MOST effective way of destroying data on a hard drive is to rewrite it, code that is easy to obtain, I have at least two programs on my laptop with this capability, and a very simple command line program could do this, which Sollecito could probably have written himself.


A violent criminal in the middle of a heinous act is not likely to do the sensible conventional thing (and don't forget things have changed ENORMOUSLY since 2007/8). Mez' and Filomena's laptops were almost certainly password protected, so I doubt Raff would leave his fingerprints all over the keyboard, or want to register a connection with the internet from the cottage in the murder time frame in destroying the laptops.

When I threw out an old PC recently I removed the hard drive first, no specialist tools needed. I even installed a hard drive into a server casing recently. (With help; other posters might recognise how readily we can depend on our children to be extraordinarily technology savvy, virtually almost from birth.)
 
Last edited:
the good old days

The other thing that Comodi admits to in the interview was their intention to arrest Knox before her mother arrived. She admits that Knox and Sollecito were suspects.

Comodi admits that the prosecution / police regarded Knox and Sollecito as suspects prior to their arrest and intended to arrest them to prevent Knox leaving for the US. They were suspects according to Commodi when they were interviewed, yet they were not interviewed as suspects. If I were Knox's lawyers I would be getting a copy of this interview and forwarding as evidence to ECHR to show how her rights were deliberately denied her by the police / prosecution.
We used to have endless arguments about this point here. Dr. Giobbi's reasons for suspicion were actions taken by the pair in advance of the night of 5 November; therefore, it always made sense that they were suspects from the beginning.
 
The other thing that Comodi admits to in the interview was their intention to arrest Knox before her mother arrived. She admits that Knox and Sollecito were suspects.

Comodi admits that the prosecution / police regarded Knox and Sollecito as suspects prior to their arrest and intended to arrest them to prevent Knox leaving for the US. They were suspects according to Commodi when they were interviewed, yet they were not interviewed as suspects. If I were Knox's lawyers I would be getting a copy of this interview and forwarding as evidence to ECHR to show how her rights were deliberately denied her by the police / prosecution.

This was decided by a court hearing (Matteini), not Comodi or Mignini. They merely made the application. Matteini considered the pair to be potentially extremely dangerous to the public, and as Comodi said, Knox would have fled the country.

The defence, as per convention, got to have their say.
 
This is the Achilles Heel of the Mignini/Comodi prosecution of the pair, and is simply skipped over in any PGP-theory of the crime, and esp. the theory/timeline of how the police/prosecution began to regard them with suspicion.

Depending on what the PGP try to argue, AK and RS were not suspects at all until, "Knox breaks and told us what we already knew." But alternately the pair were regarded as suspects from the beginning; right from Nov 2 when Napoleoni had wondered why Sollecito kept trying to point out the pooh in the other toilet, and Mignini had theorized that no one could have broken in through Filomena's window and that the killer had had to be female because of the way the duvet covered the body.

Anyone who remains interested in catching PGP out on what they claim about the case, watch for this dynamic. Perhaps the best example of it is John Follain's, "A Death in Italy," where the way he writes the period from between the murder and the interrogations, he writes that the police were right to suspect them from the beginning, but then has to reboot the narrative at the interrogation hoping no one will notice. PGP never do.

He sprinkles his narrative prior to the interrogation with all the "clues" that the police had used to bust this case.

Then, after being pampered with chamomile tea, biscuits and bathroom breaks at interrogation, Follain has Knox breaking under the weight of all that good treatment by, out of the blue and with no help from translators or slaps to the back of the head, naming Lumumba. Unmentioned by Follain - Mignini's offer to be "only a notary," as well as complete invisibility of Anna Doninno the translator.

It's good to see that in Dec 2017, Manuela Comodi still does not know how to dance around that Achilles Heel. Folk can only listen to her and think, "Wait a minute, I thought she'd not been a suspect until naming Lumumba and you guys went out to kick down his door? Then declared, "case closed'. Then discovered Rudy two weeks later!"

The pair were not remanded in custody until after they were arrested.

What is it to be, Bill Williams? One minute you moan about 'the rush to close the case' and the next have a whining session about the pair not being charged with murder for a few months. This showed police did not act hastily.
 
Comodi says there it is no problem that the bra-claps was collected 46 days later, in a different position and after many people walked through the room.
Mignini says they couldn't take the body temperature because Stefanoni was concerned of contamination.

Er...this reminds me of a sketch with Peter Cook and Dudley Moore, where Dudley as 'Derek' gets so carried away by his cancer diagnosis that Peter, as 'Clive' has to butt in and remind him, 'Er, Del, the cancer was just a story you made up to explain to Dolly (Derek's wife) why you were [ahem] ...<censored>.

The meme, 'oh the bra clasp is contaminated because it wasn't collected for 42 days' was a PR hoax,remember? _Duh!
 
Chris Halkides said:
We used to have endless arguments about this point here. Dr. Giobbi's reasons for suspicion were actions taken by the pair in advance of the night of 5 November; therefore, it always made sense that they were suspects from the beginning.
The pair were not remanded in custody until after they were arrested.

What is it to be, Bill Williams? One minute you moan about 'the rush to close the case' and the next have a whining session about the pair not being charged with murder for a few months. This showed police did not act hastily.

Both those things are true. The police held a news conference on the 6th and declared "case closed". That case had Lumumba as part of it.

But we were talking about co-prosecutor Manueli Comodi, esp. what she'd said at the Dec 2017 "debate". She'd pretty much admitted that Knox (especially) had been interrogated because she'd been a suspect, a suspect long before the night of the 5th, and that the police and prosecutor's office had to act before Knox's mother got into town on the 6th.

The point being, a point you will never in a million years address, was Knox as suspect before the interrogation or only as a result of the interrogation? Comodi admitted in Dec 2017 that Knox had been suspected beforehand, and therefore Knox had been denied a right to counsel as well as to an independent translator.
 
Last edited:
This is the Achilles Heel of the Mignini/Comodi prosecution of the pair, and is simply skipped over in any PGP-theory of the crime, and esp. the theory/timeline of how the police/prosecution began to regard them with suspicion.

Depending on what the PGP try to argue, AK and RS were not suspects at all until, "Knox breaks and told us what we already knew." But alternately the pair were regarded as suspects from the beginning; right from Nov 2 when Napoleoni had wondered why Sollecito kept trying to point out the pooh in the other toilet, and Mignini had theorized that no one could have broken in through Filomena's window and that the killer had had to be female because of the way the duvet covered the body.
Anyone who remains interested in catching PGP out on what they claim about the case, watch for this dynamic. Perhaps the best example of it is John Follain's, "A Death in Italy," where the way he writes the period from between the murder and the interrogations, he writes that the police were right to suspect them from the beginning, but then has to reboot the narrative at the interrogation hoping no one will notice. PGP never do.

He sprinkles his narrative prior to the interrogation with all the "clues" that the police had used to bust this case.

Then, after being pampered with chamomile tea, biscuits and bathroom breaks at interrogation, Follain has Knox breaking under the weight of all that good treatment by, out of the blue and with no help from translators or slaps to the back of the head, naming Lumumba. Unmentioned by Follain - Mignini's offer to be "only a notary," as well as complete invisibility of Anna Doninno the translator.

It's good to see that in Dec 2017, Manuela Comodi still does not know how to dance around that Achilles Heel. Folk can only listen to her and think, "Wait a minute, I thought she'd not been a suspect until naming Lumumba and you guys went out to kick down his door? Then declared, "case closed'. Then discovered Rudy two weeks later!"

To add to the highlighted part, Mignini also admits that he immediately deduced the break in was staged and that the murder was committed by someone who lived in the cottage because an outsider had no reason to stage a break in. Since it was quickly determined that all other cottage inhabitants had air-tight alibis, that left only Amanda. His shrewd Sherlock Holmes- like powers of observation revealed that no one would climb in through FR's window when the terrace would have been the logical point of entry.* Hmmmm...which Amanda would have known since she lived there. I suppose it was just a coincidence that climbing in through a second story window after throwing a rock through it matched the law office break in that was connected to Guede.

*Regarding the terrace, it IS visible from the road and from apartments across the street which look down on the cottage as pictures prove. Also, I have a friend who was in Perugia a few years ago and drove that road past the cottage. She confirmed the terrace is visible from the road.
 
Here in the UK you would cover it. A colleague of mine in a previous job had a BSc(Hons) in computer science and had no problem building up PC's from scratch. Another acquaintance who left school at 16 regularly used to update his IT system, by buying individual parts from China and assembling it all himself, at a substantial saving.

You are assuming it would be covered. Not having studied computer science, how would you know that? Can you present evidence? Just because a couple colleagues of yours can build a computer from scratch (as my husband has done many times), that does not mean they learned how to do it in college courses (which my husband did not; he taught himself).
 
Bill Williams said:
Depending on what the PGP try to argue, AK and RS were not suspects at all until, "Knox breaks and told us what we already knew." But alternately the pair were regarded as suspects from the beginning; right from Nov 2 when Napoleoni had wondered why Sollecito kept trying to point out the pooh in the other toilet, and Mignini had theorized that no one could have broken in through Filomena's window and that the killer had had to be female because of the way the duvet covered the body.
.....................

It's good to see that in Dec 2017, Manuela Comodi still does not know how to dance around that Achilles Heel. Folk can only listen to her and think, "Wait a minute, I thought she'd not been a suspect until naming Lumumba and you guys went out to kick down his door? Then declared, "case closed'. Then discovered Rudy two weeks later!"
To add to the highlighted part, Mignini also admits that he immediately deduced the break in was staged and that the murder was committed by someone who lived in the cottage because an outsider had no reason to stage a break in. Since it was quickly determined that all other cottage inhabitants had air-tight alibis, that left only Amanda. His shrewd Sherlock Holmes- like powers of observation revealed that no one would climb in through FR's window when the terrace would have been the logical point of entry.* Hmmmm...which Amanda would have known since she lived there. I suppose it was just a coincidence that climbing in through a second story window after throwing a rock through it matched the law office break in that was connected to Guede.

*Regarding the terrace, it IS visible from the road and from apartments across the street which look down on the cottage as pictures prove. Also, I have a friend who was in Perugia a few years ago and drove that road past the cottage. She confirmed the terrace is visible from the road.

If anyone follows the nutter line-of-argument long enough, they notice that PGP cannot decide which of these are true; and inded, need both to be true depending on what item they're alleging:

Knox must simultaneously not be suspected of the murder before the interrogation, but at the same time the cops were justified in fully believing her responsible beforehand.

Knox must simultaneously be a criminal genius, arranging for a (non-existent) clean-up of the scene, a faked burglary, and with the ability to go into a late night interrogation refreshed and with a deceptive game-plan in mind; but at the same time be a goofy-doofus who was attracting all sorts of attention to herself......

..... thus giving cause for cops to suspect her of murder, even though they'd been unaware of their own suspicions until they'd stumbled on the "See you later" SMS message.... with a man who'd had nothing at all to do with the murder!

The nutters juggle two balls with one hand and two with the other and wonder why few believe them.

But at least Comodi knows - Knox had been a suspect well before the interrogation, and they had to deal with her before her mother arrived.

Comodi says it.
 
A violent criminal in the middle of a heinous act is not likely to do the sensible conventional thing (and don't forget things have changed ENORMOUSLY since 2007/8). Mez' and Filomena's laptops were almost certainly password protected, so I doubt Raff would leave his fingerprints all over the keyboard, or want to register a connection with the internet from the cottage in the murder time frame in destroying the laptops.

When I threw out an old PC recently I removed the hard drive first, no specialist tools needed. I even installed a hard drive into a server casing recently. (With help; other posters might recognise how readily we can depend on our children to be extraordinarily technology savvy, virtually almost from birth.)

1. "Almost certainly" again? You are making an assumption for which you have no evidence (yet again). However, it is more likely that Filomena, rather than Meredith, would have a password since she used her laptop for work. But, once again, neither the police nor the prosecution ever claimed or implied that her laptop was damaged by Raffaele. That's YOUR imagination.

2. Speaking of leaving fingerprints, all the laptops were tested for fingerprints by the police. Raffaele's were not found on Filomena's or Meredith's. And there is no report that either laptop was suspiciously wiped clean of prints. And speaking of that, you still have never provided evidence that the lamp was "wiped clean" of fingerprints. Why is that?
 
1. "Almost certainly" again? You are making an assumption for which you have no evidence (yet again). However, it is more likely that Filomena, rather than Meredith, would have a password since she used her laptop for work. But, once again, neither the police nor the prosecution ever claimed or implied that her laptop was damaged by Raffaele. That's YOUR imagination.

2. Speaking of leaving fingerprints, all the laptops were tested for fingerprints by the police. Raffaele's were not found on Filomena's or Meredith's. And there is no report that either laptop was suspiciously wiped clean of prints. And speaking of that, you still have never provided evidence that the lamp was "wiped clean" of fingerprints. Why is that?

Another issue with the Raffaele destroyed his computers claim is why is there no record of the police telling Raffaele the computers were damaged when they were brought in and asking Raffaele to explain this.
 
You are assuming it would be covered. Not having studied computer science, how would you know that? Can you present evidence? Just because a couple colleagues of yours can build a computer from scratch (as my husband has done many times), that does not mean they learned how to do it in college courses (which my husband did not; he taught himself).

I've been tearing computers apart since before IBM introduced the PC1. I've got extensive hands on experience with virtually every type of hard drive ever to make it to mainstream (and some that didn't), including DASD packs on mainframes (uh oh, just dated myself). But I certainly would have no idea which leads I should apply voltage to, what voltage to use or what that would do to the drive. And I am certain Raffaele wouldn't know either. IF he were in a situation where he didn't want data to be accessed by the police the only way to guarantee it (and, btw, the MUCH easier way) is to destructively delete the data using one of many tools available to do it. I know you already know this but Vixen is just talking out her backside.

Vixen also failed to address the basic question of why Raffaele would deliberately destroy four laptops. Her reasoning that Filomena's had to be done else it would look suspicious was hilarious to say the least. They had control of their own laptops, which were at his apartment. They had no reason to destroy Filomena's. If they were concerned there was data on Meredith's laptop then why not just kill it.. only one machine dead - it happens. No, her explanation is kill four of them in a completely unrealistic fashion so as to not look suspicious. You just can't make this stuff up!
 
The meme, 'oh the bra clasp is contaminated because it wasn't collected for 42 days' was a PR hoax,remember? _Duh!

I didn't say it is contaminated because it wasn't collectet for 42 days. The point I tried to make is that the two statements are contradictory. Mignini asked Dr. Lalli to take the body temparature immediatly but Stefanoni was so concerned about contamination that she convinced Mignini to wait until they finished collecting biological evidence (https://youtu.be/gbOjYpH1WdM?t=3812). On the other hand Comodi has no concerns collect a piece of evidence with dirty gloves, 46 days later, from a different spot.
 
Here in the UK you would cover it. A colleague of mine in a previous job had a BSc(Hons) in computer science and had no problem building up PC's from scratch. Another acquaintance who left school at 16 regularly used to update his IT system, by buying individual parts from China and assembling it all himself, at a substantial saving.

You are assuming it would be covered. Not having studied computer science, how would you know that? Can you present evidence? Just because a couple colleagues of yours can build a computer from scratch (as my husband has done many times), that does not mean they learned how to do it in college courses (which my husband did not; he taught himself).

Vixen doesn't really knows what she is talking about. Assembling your own computer is easy. I've built hundreds. If you can use a screwdriver and plug a cable into an outlet, you can build a pc. It's not much harder than building a dresser from IKEA. Usually you almost CAN'T screw it up. The cable connectors are keyed so like a plug in a wall socket, you can hardly get it wrong. But none of these computers are standalone pcs that are easy to assemble, they were laptops and NOBODY, but the manufacturers assembles them. Now if you know what you are doing you may be able to replace the hard drives and upgrade the memory.

The real expertise is with the O/S and the applications. It's this reason that most computer science courses spend little time on the hardware. That is for people that are interested in electronics or semiconductors.
 
I've been tearing computers apart since before IBM introduced the PC1. I've got extensive hands on experience with virtually every type of hard drive ever to make it to mainstream (and some that didn't), including DASD packs on mainframes (uh oh, just dated myself). But I certainly would have no idea which leads I should apply voltage to, what voltage to use or what that would do to the drive. And I am certain Raffaele wouldn't know either. IF he were in a situation where he didn't want data to be accessed by the police the only way to guarantee it (and, btw, the MUCH easier way) is to destructively delete the data using one of many tools available to do it. I know you already know this but Vixen is just talking out her backside.

Vixen also failed to address the basic question of why Raffaele would deliberately destroy four laptops. Her reasoning that Filomena's had to be done else it would look suspicious was hilarious to say the least. They had control of their own laptops, which were at his apartment. They had no reason to destroy Filomena's. If they were concerned there was data on Meredith's laptop then why not just kill it.. only one machine dead - it happens. No, her explanation is kill four of them in a completely unrealistic fashion so as to not look suspicious. You just can't make this stuff up!

Yep.

Raffaele I bet is familiar with shred utilities that will delete everything off a drive and not leave a trace. He'd also know how to reinstall the OS. Why pull the disk drives when all you have to do is make a few keystrokes and mouse clicks?
 
Yep.

Raffaele I bet is familiar with shred utilities that will delete everything off a drive and not leave a trace. He'd also know how to reinstall the OS. Why pull the disk drives when all you have to do is make a few keystrokes and mouse clicks?

Because the forensic IT guys would spot the wholesale deletion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom