acbytesla
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2012
- Messages
- 41,297
Two completely separate IT forensic experts have ZERO reason to lie (and it is lying by omission to fail to testify it was you who fried the laptops, and even perjury, if that was the case). The defence could have appealed on the point of law of 'witholding exculpatory evidence' (Brady v Maryland in the USA).
Fact is, as several PIP's themselves have pointed out, a forensic IT guy would NOT power up the laptop, they would remove the hard drive intact from the laptop body, without switching it on.
In science it is impossible to prove a negative. Thus, when it was discovered from cloning, the data was not retrievable, probably due to overcircuiting the drive causing a fry-out, being upright honest TRAINED expert witnesses, they were not in a position to say who, why or when the drives shortcircuited, as, having not powered it up, they DO NOT KNOW whether they were working beforehand or not. Thus, they objectively and properly did not assign blame .
If they had discovered a fault in their methods they would have DISCLOSED it. Ethically, they would have said, 'M'Lud, we accidentally put the wrong voltage through it.' They did NOT. OTOH Filomena's laptop was damaged in a similar way BEFORE the police even received her laptop. The short circuit did not happen with Lumumba's laptop. Just as Raff tried to preclude Mez' DNA being on HIS knife by writing that he had accidentally 'pricked her hand' whilst she was round his house cooking, he tries to do the same by insinuating the police pulled the plug at the wall without letting him log off properly, thereby contributing to the loss of data. If we draw a Venn diagram of all the laptops that were damaged and who had had access to them on the murder night - or potentially had access - we find Raff's name at the centre of it. Lumumba's name is out of the diagram all together as his drive was not found to be fried. Raff had no access to it. If it was the police methods that were at fault we should expect Patrick's to have suffered a similar fate, because if it was a fry up by the IT police, then the IT guys didn't spot their error three attempts in a row, so why would light suddenly dawn with the next one. In typical LondonJohn fashion, once again you are accusing decent honest, well-qualified, members of the Rome Forensic Police of being crooks and frauds and in a conspiracy with a mad evil prosecutor.
You were doing fine right up until the highlighted part. I love how you refer to the IT guys as 'experts'. You obviously have never worked in the IT industry. As someone who worked in the computer industry for 3 decades I can say unequivocally that few people in the computer industry refer to themselves as experts. The reason is the knowledgebase is immense and constantly growing. Things are changing constantly. Someone who thinks they know everything quickly finds out there is far too much to know.
Different manufacturers do things differently. The standard for drive connections use to be 5 volts and the cables were keyed so it was impossible for someone to connect it wrong. But this was right at the time where 2.5 inch SATA (Serial ATA) were replacing PATA (Parallel) drives and 3.3 volt drives were becoming popular. Drive connections were not standardized and cables were not necessarily keyed. All the techs would probably know is that for some unknown reason the cloning procedure was failing. They would likely not know they were the cause of the failure and being human wouldn't be interested in coming to the conclusion that it was there own personal incompetence that was the cause.
Please stop trying to pretend you understand this and that you can come to a confident conclusion. I'm the closest thing to an expert on this kind of IT participating in this forum and I KNOW I DON'T KNOW. I also know you don't know either. You keep relying on this idea that people are experts in their jobs when in fact, you don't know that. You keep making assumptions but only if the assumptions support your view. My experience working with IT techs is that some are very very good and the rest are barely adequate and are faking it hoping not to be exposed.
What I do know, it is highly unlikely that Raffaele deliberately tried to fry the drives as there really was no reason for him to do such a thing. I also (reluctantly) came to the same conclusion about the techs. But I am 99.99999 percent sure that the techs somehow were responsible for the failure as drives fail very rarely and the techs were the only people who could have caused the failures.
Last edited: