Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
Obviously you weren't paying attention when Stacy, Numbers and others were posting example after example of police misconduct. I'm glad you think professionals have a code of conduct but history shows otherwise. And yes, they ARE working in a cubicle with no one reviewing their work or findings. They work in a lab. One person works on a drive - it's a one man job. And there is no oversight.

I present several points;

- Raffaele's computer was running when collected by the police.
- Amanda emailed her family and friends on 4 Nov, so her drive was just fine at that point.
- It would be nearly impossible for Raffaele to fry the logic board of a hard drive unless he had a DC power supply and a schematic to know where to apply power.
- No reason to destroy the drives when they could have easily deleted whatever data they felt was incriminating.
- WHY would he destroy Filomena's drive?

Your problem is you WANT this to be about Raffaele frying drives so you go into denial, but there is plenty of circumstantial evidence to conclude the machines were fine when taken into custody.

I am not suggesting any kind of motive. I'm suggesting incompetence and accidental destruction of the drives. These are the same 'professionals' that didn't know about Linux meta data.

I already told you: if Mez', Knox' and Raff's were deliberately damaged, then of course you would have to also damage Filomena's or it immediately looks suspicious to have been selective.

Like the 'random burglar' scenario, Knox and Raff will have been aware a chance burglar would damage laptops in a chance way. Although being a said burglar, awfully strange he didn't just put them in his 'Swag' bag and make off with them, as I thought that was supposed to be Rudy's speciality.

If you use a programme to delete the data on the drive, that would certainly raise a suspicion as to what was being deleted.

Mez' laptop could have been password protected, so sterner measures had to be taken.
 
Agreed the reasoning was rather circular here, but he was referring to the defence arguments, not the quality of Curatolo.

But don't bring Curatolo up. He was not a reliable witness. He contradicted himself not once but twice (the buses/costumes and the kiosk operator who saw him on his bench at 6:40 when he said he slept in the park until 8:30-9am). What this shows is a prosecutor desperate to put Amanda and Raffaele in the area and contradict their alibi. An honest prosecutor would never have used him. That neither Massei or Nencini disregarded Curatolo tells us all we need to know about those two courts.

And speaking of coincidences - since you keep bringing that up when discussing the drives - why were there three "witnesses" who didn't say anything for months until a reporter - the same reporter each time - speaks to them, then suddenly they remember seeing or hearing something. Curatolo, Quintavalle, Capazelli.
 
Two completely separate IT forensic experts have ZERO reason to lie (and it is lying by omission to fail to testify it was you who fried the laptops, and even perjury, if that was the case). The defence could have appealed on the point of law of 'witholding exculpatory evidence' (Brady v Maryland in the USA).

Fact is, as several PIP's themselves have pointed out, a forensic IT guy would NOT power up the laptop, they would remove the hard drive intact from the laptop body, without switching it on.

In science it is impossible to prove a negative. Thus, when it was discovered from cloning, the data was not retrievable, probably due to overcircuiting the drive causing a fry-out, being upright honest TRAINED expert witnesses, they were not in a position to say who, why or when the drives shortcircuited, as, having not powered it up, they DO NOT KNOW whether they were working beforehand or not. Thus, they objectively and properly did not assign blame .

If they had discovered a fault in their methods they would have DISCLOSED it. Ethically, they would have said, 'M'Lud, we accidentally put the wrong voltage through it.' They did NOT.OTOH Filomena's laptop was damaged in a similar way BEFORE the police even received her laptop. The short circuit did not happen with Lumumba's laptop.

Just as Raff tried to preclude Mez' DNA being on HIS knife by writing that he had accidentally 'pricked her hand' whilst she was round his house cooking, he tries to do the same by insinuating the police pulled the plug at the wall without letting him log off properly, thereby contributing to the loss of data.

If we draw a Venn diagram of all the laptops that were damaged and who had had access to them on the murder night - or potentially had access - we find Raff's name at the centre of it. Lumumba's name is out of the diagram all together as his drive was not found to be fried. Raff had no access to it.

If it was the police methods that were at fault we should expect Patrick's to have suffered a similar fate, because if it was a fry up by the IT police, then the IT guys didn't spot their error three attempts in a row, so why would light suddenly dawn with the next one.In typical LondonJohn fashion, once again you are accusing decent honest, well-qualified, members of the Rome Forensic Police of being crooks and frauds and in a conspiracy with a mad evil prosecutor.

I've read quite a bit of the testimony and nowhere have I found that the IT techs were even ASKED if they had fried the hard drives. There is nothing that requires the techs to volunteer information that they have not been specifically asked. And in this case, their failure to volunteer that information is self-serving as their professional reputations were on the line. To think they'd have said:

"Me lud, being honest, decent, upright professionals, we want to volunteer the information that we're incompetent at our job and fried three hard drives of the laptops that may have held critical evidence in the case."

Draw all the Ven diagrams you want. The fact remains that neither the police nor the prosecutors ever claimed, or even implied, that Raffaele had anything to do with the hard drive destruction. Only you claim that. You cannot, no matter how you try to twist and turn it, claim that they ever DENIED having ruined the laptops which the courts found they had. THAT information they would have volunteered. Dance around that, Vix. Dance.

As for Lumumba's laptop not being fried, has it ever occurred to you that they had three laptop to ISA bus adaptors that they hooked up upside down simultaneously to the hard drives, turned them on thus frying all three at the same time? And you're right about one thing: even they realized their screw-up and hooked up PL's laptop correctly.
 
It's called sarcasm. Rather too subtle for you, perhaps, but Comodi was remarking on the illogicality of the Fifth Chamber's reasoning, in the way a stand-up comedian might make an acute social obervation with a poker face, which is meant to highlight the absurdity of it.

Well, no. Comodi was making a statement on what she thought the 2015 Supreme Court had said about AK and/or RS having been at the cottage on the night in question.

It is sophistry to turn her plain statement on its head. But then again.... this means that even you agree that she'd said those words, it's just that you need to invent a reason to turn the implication of her statement on its head. It's what you do when faced with plain evidence - you call Nencini's claim that Raffaele's DNA had been found on the knife, "a typo". Must be nice to have a sophist reason for everything.
 
Last edited:
I've read quite a bit of the testimony and nowhere have I found that the IT techs were even ASKED if they had fried the hard drives. There is nothing that requires the techs to volunteer information that they have not been specifically asked. And in this case, their failure to volunteer that information is self-serving as their professional reputations were on the line. To think they'd have said:

"Me lud, being honest, decent, upright professionals, we want to volunteer the information that we're incompetent at our job and fried three hard drives of the laptops that may have held critical evidence in the case."

Draw all the Ven diagrams you want. The fact remains that neither the police nor the prosecutors ever claimed, or even implied, that Raffaele had anything to do with the hard drive destruction. Only you claim that. You cannot, no matter how you try to twist and turn it, claim that they ever DENIED having ruined the laptops which the courts found they had. THAT information they would have volunteered. Dance around that, Vix. Dance.

As for Lumumba's laptop not being fried, has it ever occurred to you that they had three laptop to ISA bus adaptors that they hooked up upside down simultaneously to the hard drives, turned them on thus frying all three at the same time? And you're right about one thing: even they realized their screw-up and hooked up PL's laptop correctly.


Wrong. The Supreme Court is not a fact-finding (merits) court and does not have the remit to 'find the IT guys fried the laptops'.

IIRC Massei left the issue of blame open. Fact is, if the IT guys didn't power the laptops up beforehand (which is correct procedure) they are not in a position to say whether or not the drives were OK beforehand.

Unlike you, as professional witnesses, they refrained from conjecture and speculation, sticking to the objective observable facts.

If they were aware they HAD fried them, they would have been ethically obliged to DISCLOSE this neutral fact.
 
But don't bring Curatolo up. He was not a reliable witness. He contradicted himself not once but twice (the buses/costumes and the kiosk operator who saw him on his bench at 6:40 when he said he slept in the park until 8:30-9am). What this shows is a prosecutor desperate to put Amanda and Raffaele in the area and contradict their alibi. An honest prosecutor would never have used him. That neither Massei or Nencini disregarded Curatolo tells us all we need to know about those two courts.

And speaking of coincidences - since you keep bringing that up when discussing the drives - why were there three "witnesses" who didn't say anything for months until a reporter - the same reporter each time - speaks to them, then suddenly they remember seeing or hearing something. Curatolo, Quintavalle, Capazelli.

Add to this....

To find a motive for Amanda to have been involved in this, Nencini (in 2014) cherry-picks ONE of Rudy's lies about that evening, that Amanda and Meredith had argued about rent money.

No matter that no other judge or prosecutor had ever claimed this. Nencini just pulls it out of Rudy's statement, a statement which also included his claim that the sex he'd had with the victim had been consensual and that it had been Meredith who'd let him in to the cottage.

It's the completely cherry-picking of evidence that marks the prosecution, as well as the convicting courts.
 
I already told you: if Mez', Knox' and Raff's were deliberately damaged, then of course you would have to also damage Filomena's or it immediately looks suspicious to have been selective.

Like the 'random burglar' scenario, Knox and Raff will have been aware a chance burglar would damage laptops in a chance way. Although being a said burglar, awfully strange he didn't just put them in his 'Swag' bag and make off with them, as I thought that was supposed to be Rudy's speciality.

If you use a programme to delete the data on the drive, that would certainly raise a suspicion as to what was being deleted.

Mez' laptop could have been password protected, so sterner measures had to be taken.

Seriously, you are so clueless about what you're suggesting it's hard to even take you serious.

Filomena's and Meredith's computers were NOT turned on; Raffaele's computer was at his apartment, not the cottage. Exactly how was he going to explain a surge that killed two computers not turned on in one location and another computer running (and part of his alibi) at another location?

I can permanently delete data off a hard drive and NO ONE will be able to detect I did it. I've told you this several times now.

I tell you what... I'll personally hand you an old, spare hard drive that works perfectly well. I'll give you a week to figure out a way to fry it's logic board and I bet you can't do it. You will either not fry it or you will physically burn components using AC current.
 
Add to this....

To find a motive for Amanda to have been involved in this, Nencini (in 2014) cherry-picks ONE of Rudy's lies about that evening, that Amanda and Meredith had argued about rent money.

No matter that no other judge or prosecutor had ever claimed this. Nencini just pulls it out of Rudy's statement, a statement which also included his claim that the sex he'd had with the victim had been consensual and that it had been Meredith who'd let him in to the cottage.

It's the completely cherry-picking of evidence that marks the prosecution, as well as the convicting courts.


As Comodi said, 'Motive has nothing to do with evidence'. All it does is help give the court a better understanding of what may have happened. Whether the savage killing was due to hygiene, strange men coming around, missing rent money, or Mez resisting a sex assault, the end result and means remains the same. It doesn't add to or lessen the crime.

Mitigation and sentence pleading is something that comes in AFTER the verdict. That's the only time 'motive' is legally useful as an argument.

For example, provocation, jealousy, self-defence and - under Scottish Law - 'fighting talk', which means you are allowed to use this in mitigation for slugging someone.
 
I already told you: if Mez', Knox' and Raff's were deliberately damaged, then of course you would have to also damage Filomena's or it immediately looks suspicious to have been selective.Like the 'random burglar' scenario, Knox and Raff will have been aware a chance burglar would damage laptops in a chance way. Although being a said burglar, awfully strange he didn't just put them in his 'Swag' bag and make off with them, as I thought that was supposed to be Rudy's speciality.

If you use a programme to delete the data on the drive, that would certainly raise a suspicion as to what was being deleted.

Mez' laptop could have been password protected, so sterner measures had to be taken.

OMG...and you think that Raff damaging only Meredith's, Amanda's, and his own computer wouldn't look suspicious? ROTFLMAO!

You really think that, after having killed Meredith, Guede was going to put 4 laptops in his "swag" bag that would connect him to the murder just like the stolen laptop from the law office had connected him to that burglary a week or so before? What was he going to do with them? Fence them? No one has ever accused Guede of being stupid but apparently you think he was.
 
Wrong. The Supreme Court is not a fact-finding (merits) court and does not have the remit to 'find the IT guys fried the laptops'.

IIRC Massei left the issue of blame open. Fact is, if the IT guys didn't power the laptops up beforehand (which is correct procedure) they are not in a position to say whether or not the drives were OK beforehand.

Unlike you, as professional witnesses, they refrained from conjecture and speculation, sticking to the objective observable facts.

If they were aware they HAD fried them, they would have been ethically obliged to DISCLOSE this neutral fact.

You're getting close now!

But we know Amanda's laptop was working because she sent an email on 4 Nov. We know Raffaele's laptop was working because it was running when the police pulled the plug and walked off with the lid still open. And we can assume Meredith's laptop was working as there was no evidence to suggest otherwise.

And please, please, please -- stop with this silliness of 'ethical obligation to disclose'. You've been given countless examples of police corruption. It happens. People don't like owning up to mistakes. They never disputed the fault was theirs and they knew darn well that's what the assumption was. Why is that?

Keep trying..
 
Seriously, you are so clueless about what you're suggesting it's hard to even take you serious.

Filomena's and Meredith's computers were NOT turned on; Raffaele's computer was at his apartment, not the cottage. Exactly how was he going to explain a surge that killed two computers not turned on in one location and another computer running (and part of his alibi) at another location?

I can permanently delete data off a hard drive and NO ONE will be able to detect I did it. I've told you this several times now.

I tell you what... I'll personally hand you an old, spare hard drive that works perfectly well. I'll give you a week to figure out a way to fry it's logic board and I bet you can't do it. You will either not fry it or you will physically burn components using AC current.

If I had taken Computer Science - as Raff did - for my degree, I am sure I would have no problem.

(NB: NO, Raff would not have 'only studied software'. That's nonsense. Even my Accountancy qualifications had a 'systems analysis' module in it, albeit pretty basic.)
 
It's called sarcasm. Rather too subtle for you, perhaps, but Comodi was remarking on the illogicality of the Fifth Chamber's reasoning, in the way a stand-up comedian might make an acute social obervation with a poker face, which is meant to highlight the absurdity of it.


That seems fitting, given the amount of stand-up comedy in this case.

The funniest part was when the police smacked Amanda Knox around and made her sign a confession she wouldn't have been able to read accurately, let alone write.

It was a real knee-slapper (though it wasn't her knees they slapped)! Those wacky Perugians. Comic geniuses, the lot of 'em!
 
As Comodi said, 'Motive has nothing to do with evidence'. All it does is help give the court a better understanding of what may have happened. Whether the savage killing was due to hygiene, strange men coming around, missing rent money, or Mez resisting a sex assault, the end result and means remains the same. It doesn't add to or lessen the crime.

Mitigation and sentence pleading is something that comes in AFTER the verdict. That's the only time 'motive' is legally useful as an argument.

For example, provocation, jealousy, self-defence and - under Scottish Law - 'fighting talk', which means you are allowed to use this in mitigation for slugging someone.
Please stop with the familiar name for the victim. It makes you sound hopelessly enmeshed.

I was not taking about Comodi's assessment of motive. I was taking about her admission that the 2015 Supreme Court thought that AK and RS were not at the scene of the crime. This despite you and a small cadre of nutters thinking that the 2015 Supreme Court had written something else.
 
If I had taken Computer Science - as Raff did - for my degree, I am sure I would have no problem.

(NB: NO, Raff would not have 'only studied software'. That's nonsense. Even my Accountancy qualifications had a 'systems analysis' module in it, albeit pretty basic.)

I didn't say he "only studied software", I said he was into software, not hardware. You are trivializing a task that is not at all trivial to pull off.

And as previously pointed out - exactly how was Raffaele planning to explain a spontaneous 'surge' that magically managed to fry the hard drive logic board of two laptops not turned on in one location and two laptops that were up and running in another location?

You're arguing for an incredibly difficult task that would be completely illogical to do in the first place. I don't even know why you're trying to argue this point when no one - not the prosecution, not the police, not the courts - no one ever suggested they were destroyed deliberately by Raffaele.
 
Wrong. The Supreme Court is not a fact-finding (merits) court and does not have the remit to 'find the IT guys fried the laptops'.

IIRC Massei left the issue of blame open. Fact is, if the IT guys didn't power the laptops up beforehand (which is correct procedure) they are not in a position to say whether or not the drives were OK beforehand.

Unlike you, as professional witnesses, they refrained from conjecture and speculation, sticking to the objective observable facts.

If they were aware they HAD fried them, they would have been ethically obliged to DISCLOSE this neutral fact.

The Supreme Court didn't have to find that the IT guys fried the laptops because it was never denied by the police or prosecution thus stating:

The computers of Amanda Knox and Kercher, which might have been useful to the investigation, were, incredibly, burned by the careless actions of the investigators, causing a short circuit due probably to an erroneous power supply; and they cannot give any more information, given that the damage is irreversible.

Oh, please, enough with the "If they were aware they HAD fried them, they would have been ethically obliged to DISCLOSE this neutral fact". Ethically obliged? You mean the way Stefanoni ethically disclosed the negative TMB tests without being confronted with her own SAL cards by the defense? Give me a break. You want so desperately to believe this that you just ignore the obvious: they weren't asked and they didn't volunteer the damning information because they were protecting their reputations. They screwed up.
 
If I had taken Computer Science - as Raff did - for my degree, I am sure I would have no problem.

(NB: NO, Raff would not have 'only studied software'. That's nonsense. Even my Accountancy qualifications had a 'systems analysis' module in it, albeit pretty basic.)

Well, you didn't take a degree in CS so how would you know that you would have no problem? Whereas, I asked my daughter who DID get a degree in computer science two years ago and she told me that they covered very little on hardware. Computer Science is very software oriented as she just told me. The hardware end of it (with the exception of processer etc. design) is what's taught in 2 year trade schools as my husband with 30+ years of experience in both just said.
Stop pontificating on a subject you have no expertise on. I'm almost embarrassed for you. Almost.
 
Two completely separate IT forensic experts have ZERO reason to lie (and it is lying by omission to fail to testify it was you who fried the laptops, and even perjury, if that was the case). The defence could have appealed on the point of law of 'witholding exculpatory evidence' (Brady v Maryland in the USA).

Fact is, as several PIP's themselves have pointed out, a forensic IT guy would NOT power up the laptop, they would remove the hard drive intact from the laptop body, without switching it on.

In science it is impossible to prove a negative. Thus, when it was discovered from cloning, the data was not retrievable, probably due to overcircuiting the drive causing a fry-out, being upright honest TRAINED expert witnesses, they were not in a position to say who, why or when the drives shortcircuited, as, having not powered it up, they DO NOT KNOW whether they were working beforehand or not. Thus, they objectively and properly did not assign blame .

If they had discovered a fault in their methods they would have DISCLOSED it. Ethically, they would have said, 'M'Lud, we accidentally put the wrong voltage through it.'

They did NOT.

OTOH Filomena's laptop was damaged in a similar way BEFORE the police even received her laptop. The short circuit did not happen with Lumumba's laptop.

Just as Raff tried to preclude Mez' DNA being on HIS knife by writing that he had accidentally 'pricked her hand' whilst she was round his house cooking, he tries to do the same by insinuating the police pulled the plug at the wall without letting him log off properly, thereby contributing to the loss of data.

If we draw a Venn diagram of all the laptops that were damaged and who had had access to them on the murder night - or potentially had access - we find Raff's name at the centre of it. Lumumba's name is out of the diagram all together as his drive was not found to be fried. Raff had no access to it.

If it was the police methods that were at fault we should expect Patrick's to have suffered a similar fate, because if it was a fry up by the IT police, then the IT guys didn't spot their error three attempts in a row, so why would light suddenly dawn with the next one.

In typical LondonJohn fashion, once again you are accusing decent honest, well-qualified, members of the Rome Forensic Police of being crooks and frauds and in a conspiracy with a mad evil prosecutor.

Actually it was the Perugian 'Postal' police who did the analysis. But why let your ignorance of the facts of the case get in the way of an ill informed opinion.

The odd thing is why would a software scientist (Sollecito) 'fry' a hard drive. This does not destroy the data on the hard drive just makes it hard to access, The actual magnetic disc remains intact, it can be removed from the drive and placed in a new drive, the reason the police / prosecution did not do this was cost. The defence requested for it to be done. If the defence did not want the data accessed why did they request the drives be sent to external agencies to recover the data and why did the prosecution refuse? To access the hard drive on a laptop would require proprietary tools, there is no evidence Sollecito had these certainly they are not listed in the search of his flat.

A software scientist would know the easiest and MOST effective way of destroying data on a hard drive is to rewrite it, code that is easy to obtain, I have at least two programs on my laptop with this capability, and a very simple command line program could do this, which Sollecito could probably have written himself.
 
The other thing that Comodi admits to in the interview was their intention to arrest Knox before her mother arrived. She admits that Knox and Sollecito were suspects.

Comodi admits that the prosecution / police regarded Knox and Sollecito as suspects prior to their arrest and intended to arrest them to prevent Knox leaving for the US. They were suspects according to Commodi when they were interviewed, yet they were not interviewed as suspects. If I were Knox's lawyers I would be getting a copy of this interview and forwarding as evidence to ECHR to show how her rights were deliberately denied her by the police / prosecution.
 
Actually it was the Perugian 'Postal' police who did the analysis. But why let your ignorance of the facts of the case get in the way of an ill informed opinion.

The odd thing is why would a software scientist (Sollecito) 'fry' a hard drive. This does not destroy the data on the hard drive just makes it hard to access, The actual magnetic disc remains intact, it can be removed from the drive and placed in a new drive, the reason the police / prosecution did not do this was cost. The defence requested for it to be done. If the defence did not want the data accessed why did they request the drives be sent to external agencies to recover the data and why did the prosecution refuse? To access the hard drive on a laptop would require proprietary tools, there is no evidence Sollecito had these certainly they are not listed in the search of his flat.
A software scientist would know the easiest and MOST effective way of destroying data on a hard drive is to rewrite it, code that is easy to obtain, I have at least two programs on my laptop with this capability, and a very simple command line program could do this, which Sollecito could probably have written himself.


Ah but the evil, cunning genius Sollecito (and the equally evil, cunning genius Knox) obviously got rid of all the gear prior to his arrest!! And not only that, he/they also knew enough about the progression of the police investigation (and thus the impending likelihood of their arrests after going to the police HQ on 5th November) to leave it until later than 4th November to destroy their hard drives!
 
The other thing that Comodi admits to in the interview was their intention to arrest Knox before her mother arrived. She admits that Knox and Sollecito were suspects.
Comodi admits that the prosecution / police regarded Knox and Sollecito as suspects prior to their arrest and intended to arrest them to prevent Knox leaving for the US. They were suspects according to Commodi when they were interviewed, yet they were not interviewed as suspects. If I were Knox's lawyers I would be getting a copy of this interview and forwarding as evidence to ECHR to show how her rights were deliberately denied her by the police / prosecution.

This is the Achilles Heel of the Mignini/Comodi prosecution of the pair, and is simply skipped over in any PGP-theory of the crime, and esp. the theory/timeline of how the police/prosecution began to regard them with suspicion.

Depending on what the PGP try to argue, AK and RS were not suspects at all until, "Knox breaks and told us what we already knew." But alternately the pair were regarded as suspects from the beginning; right from Nov 2 when Napoleoni had wondered why Sollecito kept trying to point out the pooh in the other toilet, and Mignini had theorized that no one could have broken in through Filomena's window and that the killer had had to be female because of the way the duvet covered the body.

Anyone who remains interested in catching PGP out on what they claim about the case, watch for this dynamic. Perhaps the best example of it is John Follain's, "A Death in Italy," where the way he writes the period from between the murder and the interrogations, he writes that the police were right to suspect them from the beginning, but then has to reboot the narrative at the interrogation hoping no one will notice. PGP never do.

He sprinkles his narrative prior to the interrogation with all the "clues" that the police had used to bust this case.

Then, after being pampered with chamomile tea, biscuits and bathroom breaks at interrogation, Follain has Knox breaking under the weight of all that good treatment by, out of the blue and with no help from translators or slaps to the back of the head, naming Lumumba. Unmentioned by Follain - Mignini's offer to be "only a notary," as well as complete invisibility of Anna Doninno the translator.

It's good to see that in Dec 2017, Manuela Comodi still does not know how to dance around that Achilles Heel. Folk can only listen to her and think, "Wait a minute, I thought she'd not been a suspect until naming Lumumba and you guys went out to kick down his door? Then declared, "case closed'. Then discovered Rudy two weeks later!"
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom