Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
The current crop of guilters are heavy on the exact opposite of what Comodi admitted to, with her comment that the March 2015 ISC acquittals ruled out AK and/or RS as Rudy's conspirators.

For instance, Machiavelli goes to great pains at the end of the YouTube piece to say the exact opposite of what Comodi had said at the debate - Machiavelli quotes out of context that the M/B report placed the pair at the scene.

So, regardless of where Italian law is in transitioning from Inquisitorial to Adversarial, Comodi herself contradicts Machiavelli's own orthodoxy as to what M/B did or didn't say.

Comodi said that the ISC ruled them out. Machiavelli said it had ruled them in, even while acquitting them. Can't be both.


Exactly. And the correct position is neither of these. The SC ruled that there was never a case against either Knox or Sollecito in respect of the charges related to the Kercher murder (and indeed that in effect neither should ever have been tried). But it didn't rule (because a) it couldn't, and b) it was never required to) that Knox and/or Sollecito did not participate in the Kercher murder.

I constantly find it hard to understand how so many pro-guilt commentators either cannot understand this concept, and/or how many of them choose to misrepresent it (most notoriously the conscious effort to deceive and mislead via the "insufficient evidence" trope - intending to suggest/convince that this necessarily implies that Knox and Sollecito got away with it by the skin of their teeth....)
 
This is proof that the current guilt-crowd (not so crowded, though) takes their points straight from Mignini. They should start every claim with, "but Mignini assures us that....."

And yes, you are right, Stacyhs. The fact that those in the "debate" didn't bother to correct others for their own glaring errors tells us all we need to know about the video.

This would have been far more interesting if they actually invited people to challenge what they were claiming.

Another error - Marioni states "she was sentenced to 3 years, and then got more time on appeal." This, of course, is incorrect. Her sentence was increased to 3 years on appeal. No one corrected him.

I also found this comment from Mignini interesting;

"So - apart from the fact that they lied when they said they were at Sollecito's home, because that's what they were saying all the time."

This contradicts guilters, who are always claiming they kept changing their alibi.

It would have been nice if someone had pointed out to Migini and Comodi that aside from Amanda's statement elicited from a coercive interrogation they had NO evidence against them. They claim they had sufficient evidence to arrest but in fact they had nothing and, if you remove Amanda's interrogation statement, they still have nothing.
 
Did you misread Welshman's post?

He stated that the police IT officers never claimed - in court or anywhere else - that Sollecito (or Knox, for that matter) had destroyed those hard drives himself prior to their seizure by the police.

Whereas your "response" to that post was about an entirely different matter: whether or not the police IT officers had admitted in court that one of them had destroyed the hard drives*.

Can you see the difference?


* And on that matter, it's still difficult to comprehend that you could not conceive of a reason why the police IT officers might not have wanted to admit (whether in court or anywhere else) that it was they who had destroyed the hard drives - even if it was they who had done so (and if they knew it was their fault)......


Two completely separate IT forensic experts have ZERO reason to lie (and it is lying by omission to fail to testify it was you who fried the laptops, and even perjury, if that was the case). The defence could have appealed on the point of law of 'witholding exculpatory evidence' (Brady v Maryland in the USA).

Fact is, as several PIP's themselves have pointed out, a forensic IT guy would NOT power up the laptop, they would remove the hard drive intact from the laptop body, without switching it on.

In science it is impossible to prove a negative. Thus, when it was discovered from cloning, the data was not retrievable, probably due to overcircuiting the drive causing a fry-out, being upright honest TRAINED expert witnesses, they were not in a position to say who, why or when the drives shortcircuited, as, having not powered it up, they DO NOT KNOW whether they were working beforehand or not. Thus, they objectively and properly did not assign blame .

If they had discovered a fault in their methods they would have DISCLOSED it. Ethically, they would have said, 'M'Lud, we accidentally put the wrong voltage through it.'

They did NOT.

OTOH Filomena's laptop was damaged in a similar way BEFORE the police even received her laptop. The short circuit did not happen with Lumumba's laptop.

Just as Raff tried to preclude Mez' DNA being on HIS knife by writing that he had accidentally 'pricked her hand' whilst she was round his house cooking, he tries to do the same by insinuating the police pulled the plug at the wall without letting him log off properly, thereby contributing to the loss of data.

If we draw a Venn diagram of all the laptops that were damaged and who had had access to them on the murder night - or potentially had access - we find Raff's name at the centre of it. Lumumba's name is out of the diagram all together as his drive was not found to be fried. Raff had no access to it.

If it was the police methods that were at fault we should expect Patrick's to have suffered a similar fate, because if it was a fry up by the IT police, then the IT guys didn't spot their error three attempts in a row, so why would light suddenly dawn with the next one.

In typical LondonJohn fashion, once again you are accusing decent honest, well-qualified, members of the Rome Forensic Police of being crooks and frauds and in a conspiracy with a mad evil prosecutor.
 
Last edited:
Two completely separate IT forensic experts have ZERO reason to lie (and it is lying by omission to state it was you who fried the laptops, and even perjury, if that was the case). The defence could have appealed on the point of law of 'witholding exculpatory evidence' (Brady v Maryland in the USA).

Fact is, as several PIP's themselves have pointed out, a forensic IT guy would NOT power up the laptop, they would remove the hard drive intact from the laptop body, without switching it on.

In science it is impossible to prove a negative. Thus, when it was discovered from cloning the data was not retrievable, probably due to overcircuiting the drive causing a fry-out, being upright honest TRAINED expert witnesses, they were not in a position to say who, why or when the drives shortcircuited, as, having not powered it up, they DO NOT KNOW whether they were working before hand or not. Thus, they objectively and properly did not assign blame .

If they had discovered a fault in their methods they would have DISCLOSED it. Ethically, they would have said, 'M'Lud, we accidentally put the wrong voltage through it.' They did NOT.

OTOH Filomena's laptop was damaged in a similar way BEFORE the police even received her laptop. The short circuit did not happen with Lumumba's laptop.

Just as Raff tried to preclude Mez' DNA being on HIS knife by writing that he had accidentally 'pricked her hand' whilst she was round his house cooking, he tries to do the same by insinuating the police pulled the plug at the wall without letting him log off properly, thereby contributing to the loss of data.

If we draw a Venn diagram of all the laptops that were damaged and who had had access to them on the murder night - or potentially had access - we find Raff's name at the centre of it. Lumumba's name is out of the diagram all together as his drive was not found to be fried.

If it was the police methods that were at fault we should expect his to have suffered a similar fate, as if it was a fry up, then the IT guys didn't spot their error three attempts in a row.

In typical LondonJohn fashion, once again you accusing decent honest members of the Rome Forensic Police of being crooks and frauds and in a conspiracy with a mad evil prosecutor.

Nonsense. It would be extreme incompetence to fry the drives and there would be massive motivation to not confess to the screw-up.

Regardless, as you've been told many times before, deliberately frying the drive logic board is NOT an easy thing to do. These were not blown with AC current as components would have been physically burnt.

And BTW, I've seen nothing either way to 'prove' this but if Raffaele is claiming his laptop was up and running when the police took it then the drive HAD to be fried by the police.
 
No. He is not.

He is simply pointing out the manner in which the police collected his laptop. His presumed aim in writing that is to demonstrate the heavy-handed approach the police were taking to conducting their search and seizure. What he is NOT doing is claiming that the way in which the police seized his laptop was in any way a contributory factor to the destruction of its hard drive. That's your false inference. And as others have already pointed out to you, the act of pulling the mains plug of a laptop's power supply out of the wall and then moving the laptop from A to B with the lid still open and the laptop still powered up is NEVER something that is likely to have any impact whatsoever upon the hard drive - let alone frying it and rendering it useless.

The part where Sollecito writes "if it had been handled properly" clearly is not a reference to his description of the way in which the laptop was collected by the police. Rather, it's obviously a reference to the way in which the laptop's hard drive was subsequently treated in the laboratory by the "crack" police IT officers. Again, others have already pointed you to Sollecito's own words in the same book:

"But almost all of that evidence would soon be destroyed"

and

"The police blamed the problem on an electrical surge, although they could not begin to account for how it happened three times in a row."


Those words confirm that Sollecito's claim is that the hard drives (and their data) were destroyed by the police NOT at the time of collection from Sollecito's apartment, but later on, in the police's own laboratories.


Next.........


What complete and utter tosh. As if it's going to be PC Plod knocking at the door who does the scientific forensic testing.
 
*sigh*

It would have been perfectly possible for a competent, thorough police IT officer to testify to something like this in court:

"I removed the hard drive from Sollecito's laptop and saw no visible damage. I then carefully connected the correct power and data connectors to the hard drive, and attempted to power up the drive via my own rig in order to interrogate it. However, I discovered at that point that the hard drive would not spin up, because logic board of the hard drive appeared to have been significantly damaged. It is therefore my opinion that the logic board was damaged (to the extent that the entire hard drive was rendered inoperable and unrecoverable) prior to the laptop arriving in my laboratory."
 
This would have been far more interesting if they actually invited people to challenge what they were claiming.

Another error - Marioni states "she was sentenced to 3 years, and then got more time on appeal." This, of course, is incorrect. Her sentence was increased to 3 years on appeal. No one corrected him.

I also found this comment from Mignini interesting;

"So - apart from the fact that they lied when they said they were at Sollecito's home, because that's what they were saying all the time."

This contradicts guilters, who are always claiming they kept changing their alibi.

It would have been nice if someone had pointed out to Migini and Comodi that aside from Amanda's statement elicited from a coercive interrogation they had NO evidence against them. They claim they had sufficient evidence to arrest but in fact they had nothing and, if you remove Amanda's interrogation statement, they still have nothing.


Unfortunately for you, sophistry has no place in a court of law.
 
What complete and utter tosh. As if it's going to be PC Plod knocking at the door who does the scientific forensic testing.


What?

It was YOU who was claiming that Sollecito was seeking to explain the frying of his hard drive's logic board on the police officer who collected the laptop from Sollecito's apartment.

We are sooooooo deep into Bizarro World by now...........
 
Sums things up very well, eh? :D

So, you admit to agreeing with Maneula Comodi that the 2015 Supreme Court ruling said that AK and RS were not Rudy's confederates, and therefore Comodi admits that the M/B motivations report does not put them at the cottage.

Thanks for clarifying that.
 
Where was I practicing sophistry?

A sophist is a person who reasons with clever but fallacious and deceptive arguments...​
You weren't particularly clever, you just laid things out in a linear, non-fallacious manner.

The only sophist on this thread is..........
 
Nonsense. It would be extreme incompetence to fry the drives and there would be massive motivation to not confess to the screw-up.

Regardless, as you've been told many times before, deliberately frying the drive logic board is NOT an easy thing to do. These were not blown with AC current as components would have been physically burnt.

And BTW, I've seen nothing either way to 'prove' this but if Raffaele is claiming his laptop was up and running when the police took it then the drive HAD to be fried by the police.

Don't talk rubbish. Professionals have a code of conduct. These guys aren't sitting in a cublicle with no-one reviewing their work or their findings.

Not once, not twice, but three times, and by coincidence <fx twilight zone theme> Filomena's is also damaged. She does not mention seeing any dents on the laptop body to suggest it was dropped from a height to the floor 'by Rudy'.

Professional code of conduct means:
  • Not taking on work which you are not competent to carry out
  • Objectivity
  • To maintain professional objectivity, it means guarding against self-review (or, 'marking your own homework')
  • Guarding against conflict of interest (if the IT guys were biased, they should have declined to do the testing)
  • Guard against intimidation. (If Mignini had pressurised them to keep schtum about frying the laptops, they should have refused).

You are suggesting that compound all of this, not one, but TWO forensic IT guys were actively dishonest, fraudulent and lacked professional integrity.

You provide no motive other than some notion of 'too proud to admit they screwed up'.

Really?
 
Last edited:
Once again Mignini repeats the same failed logic regarding Curatolo. It's one (of many) of my pet peeves with this case.

Curatolo was adamant that he saw Amanda and Raffaele on the same evening disco buses were running and people were celebrating in costume. Mignini points out that Amanda and Raffale had placed themselves elsewhere on Halloween so therefore that can't be the night Curatolo saw them. At no time does Mignini consider that Curatolo is confused, that Curatolo misidentified them or that Curatolo is just a liar. No, Mignini insists it is not possible that Curatolo was wrong about seeing them but has no problem accepting he was wrong about seeing them at the same time he saw the disco buses. And, not surprisingly, he fails to mention the kiosk operator who further contradicted Curatolo's account of the evening and following morning. Mignini cherry picks what he wants and discards everything that contradicts it.
 
So, you admit to agreeing with Maneula Comodi that the 2015 Supreme Court ruling said that AK and RS were not Rudy's confederates, and therefore Comodi admits that the M/B motivations report does not put them at the cottage.

Thanks for clarifying that.

Were you paying attention? She clearly states the burglary was faked and only one person had a motive to fake it.
 
*sigh*

It would have been perfectly possible for a competent, thorough police IT officer to testify to something like this in court:

"I removed the hard drive from Sollecito's laptop and saw no visible damage. I then carefully connected the correct power and data connectors to the hard drive, and attempted to power up the drive via my own rig in order to interrogate it. However, I discovered at that point that the hard drive would not spin up, because logic board of the hard drive appeared to have been significantly damaged. It is therefore my opinion that the logic board was damaged (to the extent that the entire hard drive was rendered inoperable and unrecoverable) prior to the laptop arriving in my laboratory."


Then it illustrates the professional integrity of the forensic IT guys they did not say this.
 
Bill Williams said:
So, you admit to agreeing with Maneula Comodi that the 2015 Supreme Court ruling said that AK and RS were not Rudy's confederates, and therefore Comodi admits that the M/B motivations report does not put them at the cottage.

Thanks for clarifying that.

Were you paying attention? She clearly states the burglary was faked and only one person had a motive to fake it.

Apologies for not being clear. My bad.

I was noting what Comodi had said about the 2015 Supreme Court acquittals. She had noted that the 5th Chambers had said that if Rudy had had confederates, then those people were not AK and.or RS. She may dispute the factuality of that, but she admits that that was what the 2015 ISC had said.

This statement from Comodi is in contrast to what a few current guilters say about the 2015 Suprpeme Court, they say (like Machiavelli did at the concluding text-overlay on the video) that M/B had said that AK and RS had been at the cottage at the time in question.

For me, even if she disagreed with it, she knows that M/B had written....
Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.​
In short, on that point Comodi reads the M/B report correctly, and not with the spin that you and Machiavelli put on to it.
 
Last edited:
Once again Mignini repeats the same failed logic regarding Curatolo. It's one (of many) of my pet peeves with this case.

Curatolo was adamant that he saw Amanda and Raffaele on the same evening disco buses were running and people were celebrating in costume. Mignini points out that Amanda and Raffale had placed themselves elsewhere on Halloween so therefore that can't be the night Curatolo saw them. At no time does Mignini consider that Curatolo is confused, that Curatolo misidentified them or that Curatolo is just a liar. No, Mignini insists it is not possible that Curatolo was wrong about seeing them but has no problem accepting he was wrong about seeing them at the same time he saw the disco buses. And, not surprisingly, he fails to mention the kiosk operator who further contradicted Curatolo's account of the evening and following morning. Mignini cherry picks what he wants and discards everything that contradicts it.

Agreed the reasoning was rather circular here, but he was referring to the defence arguments, not the quality of Curatolo.
 
Don't talk rubbish. Professionals have a code of conduct. These guys aren't sitting in a cublicle with no-one reviewing their work or their findings.

Not once, not twice, but three times, and by coincidence <fx twilight zone theme> Filomena's is also damaged. She does not mention seeing any dents on the laptop body to suggest it was dropped from a height to the floor 'by Rudy'.

Professional code of conduct means:
  • Not taking on work which you are not competent to carry out
  • Objectivity
  • To maintain professional objectivity, it means guarding against self-review (or, 'marking your own homework')
  • Guarding against conflict of interest (if the IT guys were biased, they should have declined to do the testing)
  • Guard against intimidation. (If Mignini had pressurised them to keep schtum about frying the laptops, they should have refused).

You are suggesting that compound all of this, not one, but TWO forensic IT guys were actively dishonest, fraudulent and lacked professional integrity.

You provide no motive other than some notion of 'too roud to admit they screwed up'.

Really?

Obviously you weren't paying attention when Stacy, Numbers and others were posting example after example of police misconduct. I'm glad you think professionals have a code of conduct but history shows otherwise. And yes, they ARE working in a cubicle with no one reviewing their work or findings. They work in a lab. One person works on a drive - it's a one man job. And there is no oversight.

I present several points;

- Raffaele's computer was running when collected by the police.
- Amanda emailed her family and friends on 4 Nov, so her drive was just fine at that point.
- It would be nearly impossible for Raffaele to fry the logic board of a hard drive unless he had a DC power supply and a schematic to know where to apply power.
- No reason to destroy the drives when they could have easily deleted whatever data they felt was incriminating.
- WHY would he destroy Filomena's drive?

Your problem is you WANT this to be about Raffaele frying drives so you go into denial, but there is plenty of circumstantial evidence to conclude the machines were fine when taken into custody.

I am not suggesting any kind of motive. I'm suggesting incompetence and accidental destruction of the drives. These are the same 'professionals' that didn't know about Linux meta data.
 
Apologies for not being clear. My bad.

I was noting what Comodi had said about the 2015 Supreme Court acquittals. She had noted that the 5th Chambers had said that if Rudy had had confederates, then those people were not AK and.or RS. She may dispute the factuality of that, but she admits that that was what the 2015 ISC had said.

This statement from Comodi is in contrast to what a few current guilters say about the 2015 Suprpeme Court, they say (like Machiavelli did at the concluding text-overlay on the video) that M/B had said that AK and RS had been at the cottage at the time in question.

For me, even if she disagreed with it, she knows that M/B had written....
​
In short, on that point Comodi reads the M/B report correctly, and not with the spin that you and Machiavelli put on to it.

It's called sarcasm. Rather too subtle for you, perhaps, but Comodi was remarking on the illogicality of the Fifth Chamber's reasoning, in the way a stand-up comedian might make an acute social obervation with a poker face, which is meant to highlight the absurdity of it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom