LondonJohn
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- May 12, 2010
- Messages
- 21,467
The current crop of guilters are heavy on the exact opposite of what Comodi admitted to, with her comment that the March 2015 ISC acquittals ruled out AK and/or RS as Rudy's conspirators.
For instance, Machiavelli goes to great pains at the end of the YouTube piece to say the exact opposite of what Comodi had said at the debate - Machiavelli quotes out of context that the M/B report placed the pair at the scene.
So, regardless of where Italian law is in transitioning from Inquisitorial to Adversarial, Comodi herself contradicts Machiavelli's own orthodoxy as to what M/B did or didn't say.
Comodi said that the ISC ruled them out. Machiavelli said it had ruled them in, even while acquitting them. Can't be both.
Exactly. And the correct position is neither of these. The SC ruled that there was never a case against either Knox or Sollecito in respect of the charges related to the Kercher murder (and indeed that in effect neither should ever have been tried). But it didn't rule (because a) it couldn't, and b) it was never required to) that Knox and/or Sollecito did not participate in the Kercher murder.
I constantly find it hard to understand how so many pro-guilt commentators either cannot understand this concept, and/or how many of them choose to misrepresent it (most notoriously the conscious effort to deceive and mislead via the "insufficient evidence" trope - intending to suggest/convince that this necessarily implies that Knox and Sollecito got away with it by the skin of their teeth....)