Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
The fact finding trial did indeed find overwhelming evidence.

The trial is the important court.

The Appeal Court upheld the convictions.

The pair were let off due to backchanneling shenanigans. The Bruno-Marasca court makes it clear the pair were not 'found innocent', on the contrary, it sets out their proven presence at the murder scene, the faked burglary and states the annulment is due to 'insufficient evidence'.

It broke legal convention in that it failed to send the claim of 'flawed investigation' and 'press influence' back to the Appeal Court, which it what it should have done.

Are you still on about this?

The final appeal's court acquitted the pair, on the grounds that even if one accepted the prosecution's evidence, none of it overcame the real issue - none of it put either of the pair in the murder room at the time of the murder. The absolute best the prosecution demonstrated - even before considering exculpatory evidence - was put Knox and Sollecito in the cottage after the murder and in another location other than the murder room....

...... something they never denied.

Once again, for the umptheenth time, from the exonerating court....

Nevertheless, even if attribution (of Knox having wiped blood from her hands) is certain, the trial element would not be unequivocal as a demonstration of posthumous contact with that blood, as a likely attempt to remove the most blatant traces of what had happened, perhaps to help someone or deflect suspicion from herself, without this entailing her certain direct involvement in the murder. Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.​
That is "best case" for the prosecution. In reality, though, there is much reason to consider that the "above" not be accepted.

Where you come up with "The Appeal Court upheld the convictions" is pure double-think.

9.4.3. It can easily be observed that the conclusion that there was a lack of an evidentiary framework consistent and sufficient to support the prosecution’s hypothesis regarding the more serious case of murder certainly reverberates on the residual, secondary accusations, listed here, d) theft of cellular phones and e) simulation of a crime.

10. The intrinsic contradictory nature of the evidence, emerging from the text of the appealed verdict, in essence undermines the connective tissue of the same, leading to its annulment.​
 
Please stop telling lies about me. I have never claimed to be a computer expert.

Then why are you claiming stuff contrary to at least two computer experts on this forum? On top of that, you are lying about what Raffaele wrote in his book, a book you also claimed never to have read.
 
Please read the court records. For example, Gregori or Trotta.

The fried laptops were discussed thoroughly and in detail. Why does Welshman have to resort to lies?

(Well we know why.)

There is no record of the police claiming Raffaele destroyed his own computers and the police never gave testimony of this in court. Vixen has to resort to lies such Raffaele destroying his own computers and has to cheek to ask why would I need to resort to lying when I have not lied. This is typical of the vile hypocrisy we see from PGP.
 
Did you miss this bit?

They pulled the plug out of the wall socket and carried it away still open. I’m convinced to this day that the computer could have exonerated me completely, and probably Amanda too, if it had been handled properly.
He is precluding the finding of data deletion by blaming the cops who collected it.

Is this just ignorance or are you being deliberately obtuse?

I gave you the relevant quote from Raffaele's book above, but will repeat it here for your benefit;

"The police blamed the problem on an electrical surge, although they could not begin to account for how it happened three times in a row."

It is routine for people to unplug their laptops and move to a new location with them up and running. This does not harm a laptop. Even people such as yourself, with absolutely no computer hardware knowledge, should know this so why do you keep up with this meme?
 
Please stop telling lies about me. I have never claimed to be a computer expert.

No, you just constantly contradict actual computer experts with your ignorant and incorrect claims and ignore that the courts found MK's, RS's, and AK's computers were all damaged while in police custody. A fact that neither the police nor the prosecution ever denied.

Did you miss this bit?

They pulled the plug out of the wall socket and carried it away still open. I’m convinced to this day that the computer could have exonerated me completely, and probably Amanda too, if it had been handled properly.
He is precluding the finding of data deletion by blaming the cops who collected it.

Did you miss this bit which you so conveniently left out?

But almost all of that evidence would soon be destroyed

"Would soon be destroyed" means it was not yet destroyed. Or is the Vixen Dictionary definition of "soon" the opposite of the Cambridge Dictionary (and every other English dictionary): in or within a short time; before long; quickly.

Stop embarrassing yourself.
 
Please read the court records. For example, Gregori or Trotta.

The fried laptops were discussed thoroughly and in detail. Why does Welshman have to resort to lies?

(Well we know why.)


Please provide the testimony of any of the computer techs who said the hard drives were ruined when they were taken into police custody. Good luck!

Please provide any evidence put forward by the prosecution that the hard drives on the three computers were damaged when taken into custody. Good luck!

Please provide any evidence that the police techs denied having fried the hard drives. Good luck.

You won't and (well, we know why.)
 
After 10 1/2 years and five trials - not to mention countless books as well as actual peer-reviewed studies of all the original non-evidence....

.... Giuliano Mignini remains convinced that Amanda Knox had been at the cottage that night Nov 1, 2007. Despite the highest court in Italy finding that at best the prosecution case....

Any further and more meaningful value (about the prosecution case) would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.​
The remaining guilters will line up behind Mignini. Their case these days is Mignini's case, as outlined in his missive about the alleged defamation that Maori was supposed to have leveled against him. There is nothing else these days....

..... and what Mignini had been about in Dec 2017 is about the best he can do. Despite what the Italian Supreme Court found almost three years ago.
 
Last edited:
Then why are you claiming stuff contrary to at least two computer experts on this forum? On top of that, you are lying about what Raffaele wrote in his book, a book you also claimed never to have read.

I said nothing of the sort. You are a compulsive less than frank dissembler in this matter.
 
Last edited:
There is no record of the police claiming Raffaele destroyed his own computers and the police never gave testimony of this in court. Vixen has to resort to lies such Raffaele destroying his own computers and has to cheek to ask why would I need to resort to lying when I have not lied. This is typical of the vile hypocrisy we see from PGP.

Welshman has to resort to cheeky misrepresentations to evade the fact the IT forensic guys were cross-examined in depth before the court.

Not one said he was responsible, or their colleagues, for the laptops' damage.

Welshman misspeaks on an industrial scale, even when readers have seen Raff's own quotes from his book.

This is typical of the vile fabrications characteristic of the besotted hybistrophilic PIP's.
 
I said nothing of the sort. You are a compulsive less than frank dissembler in this matter.

Nice one.

But it still does not change that Raffaele, in his book, did not say that the techs had damaged his laptop simply by unplugging it.
 
Welshman has to resort to cheeky misrepresentations to evade the fact the IT forensic guys were cross-examined in depth before the court.

Not one said he was responsible, or their colleagues, for the laptops' damage.

Welshman misspeaks on an industrial scale, even when readers have seen Raff's own quotes from his book.

This is typical of the vile fabrications characteristic of the besotted hybistrophilic PIP's.



Did you misread Welshman's post?

He stated that the police IT officers never claimed - in court or anywhere else - that Sollecito (or Knox, for that matter) had destroyed those hard drives himself prior to their seizure by the police.

Whereas your "response" to that post was about an entirely different matter: whether or not the police IT officers had admitted in court that one of them had destroyed the hard drives*.

Can you see the difference?


* And on that matter, it's still difficult to comprehend that you could not conceive of a reason why the police IT officers might not have wanted to admit (whether in court or anywhere else) that it was they who had destroyed the hard drives - even if it was they who had done so (and if they knew it was their fault)......
 
Did you miss this bit?

They pulled the plug out of the wall socket and carried it away still open. I’m convinced to this day that the computer could have exonerated me completely, and probably Amanda too, if it had been handled properly.
He is precluding the finding of data deletion by blaming the cops who collected it.


No. He is not.

He is simply pointing out the manner in which the police collected his laptop. His presumed aim in writing that is to demonstrate the heavy-handed approach the police were taking to conducting their search and seizure. What he is NOT doing is claiming that the way in which the police seized his laptop was in any way a contributory factor to the destruction of its hard drive. That's your false inference. And as others have already pointed out to you, the act of pulling the mains plug of a laptop's power supply out of the wall and then moving the laptop from A to B with the lid still open and the laptop still powered up is NEVER something that is likely to have any impact whatsoever upon the hard drive - let alone frying it and rendering it useless.

The part where Sollecito writes "if it had been handled properly" clearly is not a reference to his description of the way in which the laptop was collected by the police. Rather, it's obviously a reference to the way in which the laptop's hard drive was subsequently treated in the laboratory by the "crack" police IT officers. Again, others have already pointed you to Sollecito's own words in the same book:

"But almost all of that evidence would soon be destroyed"

and

"The police blamed the problem on an electrical surge, although they could not begin to account for how it happened three times in a row."


Those words confirm that Sollecito's claim is that the hard drives (and their data) were destroyed by the police NOT at the time of collection from Sollecito's apartment, but later on, in the police's own laboratories.


Next.........
 

Comodi specifically says that the Final Cassazione ruling was definitive in acquitting AK and RS, and further that even if Rudy had been helped by two conspirators........

.... that those conspirators were not AK and/or RS.

BTW - listening to Comodi try to justify a 46 day delay in collecting the bra-clasp is hilarious, esp. if she thinks it justifies it.....

BTW2 - the final talking points (in white print over a black screen) are Machiavelli's own, not part of the "debate". They also leave out major parts of a section in which Machiavelli quotes from.
 
Last edited:
And on top of it all.....

One of the experts in the "debate" claims to have written a book about Exhibit 36, which he calls "the knife", and states that blood traces were "found on the handle and on the blade" which led to Amanda Knox.

But this he neglects that:
  • Exhibit 36 was the bra-clasp, not the knife
  • No blood traces were found on either the handle or the blade of the knife, Exhibit 165; and
  • It led to Amanda Knox only because trace DNA of hers had been found. It is very arguable if Kercher's had ever been found on the knife, hidden in a striation, one that no one else ever saw except for Stefanoni. No other expert saw the striation.
Other than that, the "expert" seemed to know a lot about the case.
 

It's amazing how a group of nothing but pro-guilt people can make someone sound guilty, isn't it?

In the opening the host states, as an example of circumstantial evidence, that AK and RS waited outside the house for the carabinieri after finding the door open. He says wouldn't it have been logical for them to have gone into the house to inspect it? No one corrects him by stating that they had gone into the house and inspected it and that's how they found the break in. Nope. Silence.

I loved the part where Fiorucci proclaimed there was blood on the blade and handle of the knife and no one corrected him. Crickets on their part.

Then there's the claim by Mignini that he observed the utmost anti-contamination procedures being carried out by the SP when the police's own video shows quite otherwise. Let's also mention that Stefanoni admitted in court she didn't change gloves between handling potential evidence because DNA doesn't transfer if it's dry.

One of Mignini's favorite "facts", even repeated in the closing, is the "fact" that Amanda washed her hands of Meredith's blood as found by the courts. Naturally, no mention is made of the fact that no forensic evidence of this was ever produced and Stefanoni testified the source of AK's DNA in the blood not identifiable. Ho hum.

Comodi claimed the "luminol enhanced footprints were in blood". Naturally, no one mentioned they all tested negative for blood.

And Mignini's Sherlock Holmesian ability to determine, almost immediately, that the break-in was staged without a glass test to determine direction of breakage. Naturally, no mention is made of the glass imbedded in the exterior side of the shutter.

Comodi states bloody footprint on the mat is Sollecito's. No one mentions Vinci found otherwise and no judge determined it was Sollecito's.

Vixen likes to accuse the PIP of sticking to the "PR crib sheet" when this video is clearly the crib sheet for the TJMK crowd. Mignini whines about the American media influence and how only the local Perugia media reported it accurately. No mention that his and his police leaks were the source of their "accuracy". He even insinuates that the judges were being influenced by the US government and M/B had to acquit because they needed to wrap it up due to Amanda being in the US and we wouldn't extradite her. It was nothing but a self-serving echo chamber.
 
Last edited:
Comodi specifically says that the Final Cassazione ruling was definitive in acquitting AK and RS, and further that even if Rudy had been helped by two conspirators........ .... that those conspirators were not AK and/or RS.
BTW - listening to Comodi try to justify a 46 day delay in collecting the bra-clasp is hilarious, esp. if she thinks it justifies it.....

BTW2 - the final talking points (in white print over a black screen) are Machiavelli's own, not part of the "debate". They also leave out major parts of a section in which Machiavelli quotes from.


Comodi is wrong on even this, though. And I think it's probably due to the ongoing failure of the Italian judiciary to properly understand that they don't work in an inquisitorial-based "this is the truth of the matter" system any longer (though it's still shocking to see that even a fairly senior Italian prosecuting magistrate doesn't seem to understand how her own system actually works in the 21st Century...).

The acquittals of Knox and Sollecito on the murder-related charges were NOT a statement of "truth" - neither a judicial nor factual "truth" - that Sollecito and Knox did not participate in Kercher's murder. And that is not, and was never, what the courts were required to determine. The ONLY thing that the courts were asked to determine - just as in courts in places such as England and the US - was whether or not it could be proven BARD from the evidence presented that Knox and/or Sollecito were guilty of the crimes with which they were charged and tried.

And it's a simple binary choice: 1) if there exists sufficient evidence to prove BARD a person's guilt of a particular crime, then that person should be pronounced guilty of that crime and convicted; 2) but if that standard is not met (whether there's zero evidence of guilt, or a fair amount of evidence of guilt but just not enough to meed the BARD standard), then the person should be pronounced not guilty and acquitted (and should preserve the presumption of innocence).

Obviously, if a person is convicted (and remember, a conviction should only happen if the court believes there is sufficient evidence to prove guilt BARD), then indeed the court is effectively establishing the judicial "truth" that the person committed the crime. But, crucially, an acquittal does NOT mean - or even imply - that the person did not commit the crime*. All it means, and all it should ever mean, is that the court cannot be satisfied that the person committed the crime, and that the person should therefore retain the presumption (important word) of innocence.

Now, there are extremely sound ethical reasons why all of the above should be so, and why it is in fact easily the best (or least bad, depending on your PoV) way of dealing with people accused of criminal offences through judicial trials. And within this framework, it's vitally important to understand that it is not (and must never be) the responsibility of the accused person to prove (or even to argue) his innocence. Rather, the full burden rests with the prosecution - and ultimately the court - to prove his guilt. If the prosecution and court cannot get to that point of proof (to the BARD standard), then the person must be acquitted, and must retain exactly the same presumption of innocence as every other individual in society. Furthermore, if the person is acquitted, then (provided the acquittal is fair and within the law) neither law nor ethics allows for a "no smoke without fire" interpretation. Again, it's a binary outcome: either the person provably did it, or the person should be presumed innocent of having done it (which, again, is NOT the same as saying that the person DIDN'T do it).



* Unless, for example, the person actually can prove his innocence (e.g. via an unimpeachable alibi), or the court determines that no crime was ever committed (e.g. a rape trial where the court rules that it was consensual sex and not rape).
 
Comodi specifically says that the Final Cassazione ruling was definitive in acquitting AK and RS, and further that even if Rudy had been helped by two conspirators........

.... that those conspirators were not AK and/or RS.

BTW - listening to Comodi try to justify a 46 day delay in collecting the bra-clasp is hilarious, esp. if she thinks it justifies it.....BTW2 - the final talking points (in white print over a black screen) are Machiavelli's own, not part of the "debate". They also leave out major parts of a section in which Machiavelli quotes from.

That was one of the most laughable parts. Collecting the bra hook section immediately was "not necessary or possible". IN A SEXUAL ASSAULT MURDER CASE?! Really? Did they have a quota on how many pieces of evidence they could collect and had to wait 47 days before they could collect more? Truly laughable.
 
Last edited:
Vixen likes to accuse the PIP of sticking to the "PR crib sheet" when this video is clearly the crib sheet for the TJMK crowd. Mignini whines about the American media influence and how only the local Perugia media reported it accurately. No mention that his and his police leaks were the source of their "accuracy". He even insinuates that the judges were being influenced by the US government and M/B had to acquit because they needed to wrap it up due to Amanda being in the US and we wouldn't extradite her. It was nothing but a self-serving echo chamber.

This is proof that the current guilt-crowd (not so crowded, though) takes their points straight from Mignini. They should start every claim with, "but Mignini assures us that....."

And yes, you are right, Stacyhs. The fact that those in the "debate" didn't bother to correct others for their own glaring errors tells us all we need to know about the video.
 
Bill Williams said:
Comodi specifically says that the Final Cassazione ruling was definitive in acquitting AK and RS, and further that even if Rudy had been helped by two conspirators........ .... that those conspirators were not AK and/or RS.
BTW - listening to Comodi try to justify a 46 day delay in collecting the bra-clasp is hilarious, esp. if she thinks it justifies it.....

BTW2 - the final talking points (in white print over a black screen) are Machiavelli's own, not part of the "debate". They also leave out major parts of a section in which Machiavelli quotes from.

Comodi is wrong on even this, though. And I think it's probably due to the ongoing failure of the Italian judiciary to properly understand that they don't work in an inquisitorial-based "this is the truth of the matter" system any longer (though it's still shocking to see that even a fairly senior Italian prosecuting magistrate doesn't seem to understand how her own system actually works in the 21st Century...).

The current crop of guilters are heavy on the exact opposite of what Comodi admitted to, with her comment that the March 2015 ISC acquittals ruled out AK and/or RS as Rudy's conspirators.

For instance, Machiavelli goes to great pains at the end of the YouTube piece to say the exact opposite of what Comodi had said at the debate - Machiavelli quotes out of context that the M/B report placed the pair at the scene.

So, regardless of where Italian law is in transitioning from Inquisitorial to Adversarial, Comodi herself contradicts Machiavelli's own orthodoxy as to what M/B did or didn't say.

Comodi said that the ISC ruled them out. Machiavelli said it had ruled them in, even while acquitting them. Can't be both.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom