Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
Marasca-Bruno did say it. You are either losing your grip on reality, or - more likely - are trying to spin the matter to fool readers into thinking it didn't happen.

You could get a job with Putin. 'Nerve gas, what nerve gas? Not us, guv.'

Vixen constantly bangs on about Amanda telling umpteen lies and repeats the same lie umpteen times The Supreme Court said Amanda covered for Guede.
 
Marasca-Bruno did say it. You are either losing your grip on reality, or - more likely - are trying to spin the matter to fool readers into thinking it didn't happen.

You could get a job with Putin. 'Nerve gas, what nerve gas? Not us, guv.'

Vixen - the following quote from the 2015 Marasca-Bruno report is not for you, because:

1) you've probably never read it
2) you've obviously misunderstood (or been misled) about the context of M/B's words
3) and at best, acc. to M/B, this factoid is purely circumstantial, as a way of M/B being forced to accept the "judicial fact" of Knox's calunnia against Lumumba.​
So this is not for you, it would be wasted on yu anyway. It is posted here if by some miracle there are lurkers left who haven't read the salient part of M/B for themselves.

Nevertheless, even if attribution (of Knox rubbing blood from her hands) is certain, the trial element would not be unequivocal as a demonstration of posthumous contact with that blood, as a likely attempt to remove the most blatant traces of what had happened, perhaps to help someone or deflect suspicion from herself, without this entailing her certain direct involvement in the murder. Any further and more meaningful value would be, in fact, resisted by the fact - which is decisive - that no trace leading to her was found at the scene of the crime or on the victim’s body, so that - if all the above is accepted - her contact with the victim’s blood would have occurred after the crime and in another part of the house.

Another element against her is, certainly, the calumny against Lumumba, which has already been referred to.

It is not understood, however, what pushed the young American to make these serious accusations. The hypothesis that she did so to escape the psychological pressure of the investigators appears extremely fragile, taking into account that the woman must have realised that, sooner or later, these accusations against her employer would have been disproved, considering that she certainly knew that Lumumba had no contact either with Kercher or with the house on via della Pergola. Moreover, the possibility of having an “iron-clad” alibi would then have led to Lumumba being freed and acquitted of the serious accusation.

Nevertheless, the calumny in question also represents circumstantial evidence against the appellant in so much as it could be considered as an initiative to cover for Guede, against whom she would have had an interest to protect herself due to retaliatory accusations against her. All is underpinned by the fact that Lumumba, like Guede, is black, hence the reliable reference to the former, in case the other was seen by someone coming into or going out of the flat.​
Being stuck with the judicial fact of the calunnia conviction, the best that M/B can make of it is to supply a motive, which only "could be considered".

Please also note that this is immediate after the part where M/B narrates its reason for saying that NEITHER KNOX NOR SOLLECITO COULD HAVE TAKEN PART IN THE CRIME.....

..... and the best M/B could do with this business of "covering for Guede" was reach into the calunnia against Lumumba conviction.

And that makes no sense. As outlined by others in this thread, if Knox had been trying to cover for Guede, why'd she leave Guede's feces in the toilet and his bloody foottrack on the bathmat?

And why, when cleaning her own DNA from the murder room, did she purposely leave Guede's forensic presence there?

That's how much sense it makes.
 
Last edited:
She was a liar then, wasn't she, as she and Guede had chatted each other up at Le Chic sometime before. That's something Knox will never tell you about.

Telling lies to the police. Tut, tut.

To "chat up" means to flirt. Serving a drink to a customer is not flirting with them.

Please provide evidence that she and Guede "chatted each other up" at Le Chic. And by evidence, I mean actual quotes from a credible witness. Unless you can do that, we'll throw this on your mountainous pile of made up nonsense.

Knox will never tell you about that because it never happened. She served him a drink or two which was her job.

This is what Follain had to say about your so-called "chatting up" nonsense:

This was about the same time that Rudy went to Le Chic after he was handed a leaflet advertising the bar’s opening. Amanda was working as a waitress that evening. She went up to Rudy and asked, in English, if he wanted to drink something. Rudy asked for a sangria and the two chatted briefly. Amanda told him she came from Seattle, and Rudy mentioned a student friend of his came from there too – did she know him? Amanda said no, and their chat ended there.

Does "they chatted briefly" equate to "chatting up" someone in your mind?
 
I just looked up this case on Google, and according to the SUN, the baby did draw breath, if only for a couple of hours. Therefore, it was not stillborn.

Burning it and burying it is indeed suspicious.

A live birth is very different from a miscarriage or a stillborn.

Please don't tell us your grandmother in the 1930's set fire to the foetus before burying it, just to stick up for Brook Skylar Richardson (_sp?)

The SUN? THE SUN? LOL!! They also reported that she had burned the baby's body which later was revealed to be FALSE. Try and keep up and stop relying on old, discredited tabloid news.

Richardson never burned the baby.

Her attorney blasted a forensic anthropologist who told the prosecution the baby had been burned and said the claim was retracted a month after his client was indicted. But the narrative had already been tainted, igniting a social media firestorm and coloring law enforcement's perspective on the case.

Eventually, a second forensic expert confirmed there were no signs the child was burned, Rittgers wrote in court documents.

"The false information has left the public with the horrible mental picture of a girl burning her baby," the attorney said, "without realizing that version is false, contradicted by science and retracted by the state's doctor."
https://www.cincinnati.com/story/ne...t-turning-case-into-something-sini/399885002/

You obviously don't know that the body was unearthed two months after its death and was so decomposed that the coroner couldn't even tell the sex without doing a DNA test. All that remained was the skeleton from which the coroner cannot determine whether the baby ever drew breath, much less for a couple of hours.
The article I'm linking to explains how it can be determined if a child ever breathed on its own. Every single one requires more than just "skeletal remains", mostly examination of the lungs.

http://www.forensicpathologyonline.com/e-book/sexual-assaults/infant-deaths

From the Sun ariticle:

The infant is believed to have been born sometime between May 6 and May 7, and was alive probably for only a few hours, according to authorities.

Exactly what authorities? The sheriff who falsely reported the baby had been burned? The forensic anthropologist who had to retract his claim the baby had been burned? From nothing I've read does the CORONER ever say the baby was born alive.

As for your ridiculous statement, I am not "sticking up" for Skylar Richardson. My question was, and still is, how can she be accused of murder if they cannot determine if the child was stillborn or not?
 
Last edited:
Vixen - the following quote from the 2015 Marasca-Bruno report is not for you, because:

1) you've probably never read it
2) you've obviously misunderstood (or been misled) about the context of M/B's words
3) and at best, acc. to M/B, this factoid is purely circumstantial, as a way of M/B being forced to accept the "judicial fact" of Knox's calunnia against Lumumba.​
So this is not for you, it would be wasted on yu anyway. It is posted here if by some miracle there are lurkers left who haven't read the salient part of M/B for themselves.

​
Being stuck with the judicial fact of the calunnia conviction, the best that M/B can make of it is to supply a motive, which only "could be considered".

Please also note that this is immediate after the part where M/B narrates its reason for saying that NEITHER KNOX NOR SOLLECITO COULD HAVE TAKEN PART IN THE CRIME.....

..... and the best M/B could do with this business of "covering for Guede" was reach into the calunnia against Lumumba conviction.

And that makes no sense. As outlined by others in this thread, if Knox had been trying to cover for Guede, why'd she leave Guede's feces in the toilet and his bloody foottrack on the bathmat?And why, when cleaning her own DNA from the murder room, did she purposely leave Guede's forensic presence there?

That's how much sense it makes.

You know Vixen will claim that it wasn't Guede's, but Sollecito's footprint. Which makes leaving it even more illogical since they were allegedly cleaning up all traces of themselves. The ONLY logical reason the bathmat wasn't removed/cleaned up is that Knox and Sollecito had no reason to remove it because they didn't kill Meredith.

Another reason that claiming AK and RS were covering for Guede is equally illogical: the staging of the break-in. If they were covering for Guede, why would they stage it a la Guede's method of throwing a rock through the window and climbing into a second story window via a grate below it? The sheer illogical reasoning behind the PGP's "covering for Guede" nonsense reveals just how desperate they are. It's embarrassing.

PGPs remind me of Trump voters. Despite overwhelming evidence that Trump is a lying, immoral pathological narcissist they simply cannot admit they were wrong and move on. They do what Trump does: they double down and defend the indefensible because they are incapable of admitting error.
 
Last edited:
You know Vixen will claim that it wasn't Guede's, but Sollecito's footprint. Which makes leaving it even more illogical since they were allegedly cleaning up all traces of themselves. The ONLY logical reason the bathmat wasn't removed/cleaned up is that Knox and Sollecito had no reason to remove it because they didn't kill Meredith.

Another reason that claiming AK and RS were covering for Guede is equally illogical: the staging of the break-in. If they were covering for Guede, why would they stage it a la Guede's method of throwing a rock through the window and climbing into a second story window via a grate below it? The sheer illogical reasoning behind the PGP's "covering for Guede" nonsense reveals just how desperate they are. It's embarrassing.

PGPs remind me of Trump voters. Despite overwhelming evidence that Trump is a lying, immoral pathological narcissist they simply cannot admit they were wrong and move on. They do what Trump does: they double down and defend the indefensible because they are incapable of admitting error.

The stupidity of the claim is even more obvious than that. Up until the interrogation of 5/6 Nov, Amanda and Raffaele both had always said they were at his place alone. At the time of the interrogation the only people the police were suspecting were Amanda and Raffaele. There is no need to cover for anyone when you are saying you were elsewhere and the police have not indicated they have any idea who committed the crime. Suddenly saying you were there with a black dude immediately puts the police way closer to Guede than they were when you were claiming you weren't there at all.

There's only two ways to look at this - either Vixen realizes just how stupid this idea is but is to ashamed to admit it or she doesn't realize just how stupid it is. Either way, I agree... it is embarrassing.
 
Speaking of Quennell's pathetic "mafia" nonsense, this is the latest Front Page:

Note to IP conference re Amanda Knox. IP rep Hampikian's ONLY achievement was to be main cause of annulment of 2011 appeal, to anger of defense counsel. And to subject Knox and Sollecito to much tougher appeal, requiring desperate measures to bend Supreme Court. In other words Hampikian directly caused mafia involvement Knox and RS must hide for a lifetime. Nice going Hampikian.
(TJMK today)

Bwaaaahaahaaa! So now Quennell has AK and RS hiding from the mafia! You just can't make this stuff up!! Oh, wait...yes, he does!
 
Vixen - the following quote from the 2015 Marasca-Bruno report is not for you, because:

1) you've probably never read it
2) you've obviously misunderstood (or been misled) about the context of M/B's words
3) and at best, acc. to M/B, this factoid is purely circumstantial, as a way of M/B being forced to accept the "judicial fact" of Knox's calunnia against Lumumba.​
So this is not for you, it would be wasted on yu anyway. It is posted here if by some miracle there are lurkers left who haven't read the salient part of M/B for themselves.

​
Being stuck with the judicial fact of the calunnia conviction, the best that M/B can make of it is to supply a motive, which only "could be considered".

Please also note that this is immediate after the part where M/B narrates its reason for saying that NEITHER KNOX NOR SOLLECITO COULD HAVE TAKEN PART IN THE CRIME.....

..... and the best M/B could do with this business of "covering for Guede" was reach into the calunnia against Lumumba conviction.

And that makes no sense. As outlined by others in this thread, if Knox had been trying to cover for Guede, why'd she leave Guede's feces in the toilet and his bloody foottrack on the bathmat?

And why, when cleaning her own DNA from the murder room, did she purposely leave Guede's forensic presence there?

That's how much sense it makes.


Of course it makes sense. Knox & Sollecito planned to point police toward's Guede's presence, but could hardly name him themselves, without incriminating themselves.

Thank you for confirming by direct quote that Marasca-Bruno did conclude 'Knox covered up for Rudy by naming Patrick'.

Prisoners Dilemma: you keep schtum about me, I'll not grass on you.
 
To "chat up" means to flirt. Serving a drink to a customer is not flirting with them.

Please provide evidence that she and Guede "chatted each other up" at Le Chic. And by evidence, I mean actual quotes from a credible witness. Unless you can do that, we'll throw this on your mountainous pile of made up nonsense.

Knox will never tell you about that because it never happened. She served him a drink or two which was her job.

This is what Follain had to say about your so-called "chatting up" nonsense:



Does "they chatted briefly" equate to "chatting up" someone in your mind?


Knox liked Rudy enough to approach him in the street and remind him, 'Hi, I'm Amanda from Seattle'.

Knox doesn't mention this in her book or the trial that she had met him before the joint-smoking night nor that Meredith was present at this for a very short period of time. Guede confirms that Knox made eyes at him during the joint-smoking session.

So it is completely untrue, 'Knox did not know Guede except in passing'.

Let's face it, Amanda let Rudy in to the cottage on the murder night and partied with him.
 
The stupidity of the claim is even more obvious than that. Up until the interrogation of 5/6 Nov, Amanda and Raffaele both had always said they were at his place alone. At the time of the interrogation the only people the police were suspecting were Amanda and Raffaele. There is no need to cover for anyone when you are saying you were elsewhere and the police have not indicated they have any idea who committed the crime. Suddenly saying you were there with a black dude immediately puts the police way closer to Guede than they were when you were claiming you weren't there at all.

There's only two ways to look at this - either Vixen realizes just how stupid this idea is but is to ashamed to admit it or she doesn't realize just how stupid it is. Either way, I agree... it is embarrassing.

Given that Knox virtually ORDERED Napoleoni to take Rudy's faeces away for DNA testing, it is clear she knew 'a black dude's' DNA was going to be found at the scene, especailly given she didn't clean up Rudy's footprints, except by accident, leaving just one set, making it look like he must have hopped out of the door.

She let Patrick rot in prison for nearly three weeks and her colluding mother, quite happily. What she didn't know, was that as an immigrant, police had Guede's DNA data on their migrants database. It is pure luck they matched the crime to him. Imagine if Patrick's good friend from Austria had not been there at Le Chic to provide an alibi for him, he might be serving life right now, with Knox, Guede and Sollecito roaming around scot free.
 
Speaking of Quennell's pathetic "mafia" nonsense, this is the latest Front Page:

(TJMK today)

Bwaaaahaahaaa! So now Quennell has AK and RS hiding from the mafia! You just can't make this stuff up!! Oh, wait...yes, he does!

How else do you think they were sprung from jail, given their watertight 'guilty' verdicts from both the merits trial and the appeal court?
 
Of course it makes sense. Knox & Sollecito planned to point police toward's Guede's presence, but could hardly name him themselves, without incriminating themselves.

Thank you for confirming by direct quote that Marasca-Bruno did conclude 'Knox covered up for Rudy by naming Patrick'.

Prisoners Dilemma: you keep schtum about me, I'll not grass on you.


So they "planned to point police toward's (sic) Guede's presence" by misdirecting the police towards Lumumba. Yeah, that makes loads of sense.....

And you still have reading comprehension issues about the Marasca MR: what it says is that this may be considered as a possibility, but the report has already stated explicitly that it's effectively impossible to understand how/why Knox pointed the finger at Lumumba in that police interrogation (though I and the ECHR know exactly how that came to pass.....).

Lastly, you still have no idea whatsoever of what the Prisoner's Dilemma actually is. It's a very specific flavour of game theory. It absolutely is NOT "You keep schtum about me, I'll not grass on you". It would behove you well not to bandy about intellectually-impressive-looking terms improperly/inappropriately.
 
So they "planned to point police toward's (sic) Guede's presence" by misdirecting the police towards Lumumba. Yeah, that makes loads of sense.....

And you still have reading comprehension issues about the Marasca MR: what it says is that this may be considered as a possibility, but the report has already stated explicitly that it's effectively impossible to understand how/why Knox pointed the finger at Lumumba in that police interrogation (though I and the ECHR know exactly how that came to pass.....).

Lastly, you still have no idea whatsoever of what the Prisoner's Dilemma actually is. It's a very specific flavour of game theory. It absolutely is NOT "You keep schtum about me, I'll not grass on you". It would behove you well not to bandy about intellectually-impressive-looking terms improperly/inappropriately.


Courts of law do not deal in hypotheticals. Judges are paid handsomely to come to a decision, not pontificate about 'possibilities'.

As Bill Williams points out it is a judicial truth that Knox covered up for Rudy.

B'ain't nuthink you can do about it.

In fact Prisoners Dilemma is exactly about optimising your own best interest and in crime that means 'do not grass' on your co-criminals.
 
Last edited:
How else do you think they were sprung from jail, given their watertight 'guilty' verdicts from both the merits trial and the appeal court?


Erm...... because

a) The previous verdicts were actually extremely far from "watertight" - in fact, they were riddled with gross errors in law; and

b) The Marasca SC panel was able to see what pro-acquittal commentators and every single independent expert had been seeing for very many years: not one of the "witnesses" was credible or reliable in any manner; none of the forensic evidence against Knox or Sollecito was credible or reliable; the police and PM had appallingly botched the investigation through a combination of tunnel vision/confirmation bias about the involvement of Knox and Sollecito, and the sheer incompetence/malpractice of the detective, crime scene and forensic lab work; and the previous convicting courts had erred gigantically in the way they had deferred to the prosecution position and improperly assessed evidence/testimony.


Knox and Sollecito were not "sprung" from prison, Vixen. They were definitively acquitted by the Supreme Court of Italy. You keep apparently forgetting this :)
 
Courts of law do not deal in hypotheticals. Judges are paid handsomely to come to a decision, not pontificate about 'possibilities'.

As Bill Williams points out it is a judicial truth that Knox covered up for Rudy.

B'ain't nuthink you can do about it.

In fact Prisoners Dilemma is exactly about optimising your own best interest and in crime that means 'do not grass' on your co-criminals.



OF COURSE courts deal in hypotheticals. Short of compelling direct evidence, inferences always have to be drawn in order to reach a verdict. And that ALWAYS involves hypotheses based on the evidence. Sheesh.

Bill Williams pointed out nothing of the sort.

And please, please stop talking about the Prisoner's (note the apostrophe) Dilemma as if it's some generalised rule about prisoners not grassing each other up. It is not. It is a far, far more specific application of game theory. Please read up more about it.
 
Amanda Knox and her mother Edda Melllas cruelly and wickedly let Patrick Lumumba rot in prison when all along they knew he was wholly innocent of any involvement in Meredith's murder.

Ugh, what horrible vile people.
 
OF COURSE courts deal in hypotheticals. Short of compelling direct evidence, inferences always have to be drawn in order to reach a verdict. And that ALWAYS involves hypotheses based on the evidence. Sheesh.

Bill Williams pointed out nothing of the sort.

And please, please stop talking about the Prisoner's (note the apostrophe) Dilemma as if it's some generalised rule about prisoners not grassing each other up. It is not. It is a far, far more specific application of game theory. Please read up more about it.

Stop talking rubbish. Why do you think judgments use the word 'did' prolifically. Merits courts are there to establish the facts not pontificate on airy-fairy possibilities.

You are ignorant about game theory.


Edited by Agatha: 
Removed derailing material
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Given that Knox virtually ORDERED Napoleoni to take Rudy's faeces away for DNA testing, it is clear she knew 'a black dude's' DNA was going to be found at the scene, especailly given she didn't clean up Rudy's footprints, except by accident, leaving just one set, making it look like he must have hopped out of the door.

She let Patrick rot in prison for nearly three weeks and her colluding mother, quite happily. What she didn't know, was that as an immigrant, police had Guede's DNA data on their migrants database. It is pure luck they matched the crime to him. Imagine if Patrick's good friend from Austria had not been there at Le Chic to provide an alibi for him, he might be serving life right now, with Knox, Guede and Sollecito roaming around scot free.


Oh. So Lumumba's DNA would not have matched the DNA in and around Kercher's genital area, and nor would his palm print have matched the print made in blood on the pillow case found under Kercher's body. And yet you believe the police would have carried on and charged Lumumba, and the courts would have found him guilty. Right.

And, by the way, it wasn't Lumumba's "good friend from Austria" who conclusively alibied him. It was a Swiss university professor who was visiting Perugia with students, who had no prior connection whatsoever with Lumumba, but who engaged Lumumba in a lengthy conversation in "Le Chic" that evening. And while we're talking about him, he had to go above and beyond to get himself to Perugia to alibi Lumumba, since the police effectively rebuffed him several times (in spite of him telling them over the phone that he could prove Lumumba was in his bar that evening). More outstanding police work. And more reading/learning about this case required on your part too.
 
Amanda Knox and her mother Edda Melllas cruelly and wickedly let Patrick Lumumba rot in prison when all along they knew he was wholly innocent of any involvement in Meredith's murder.

Ugh, what horrible vile people.


You'll get over it.
 
Stop talking rubbish. Why do you think judgments use the word 'did prolifically. Merits courts are there to establish the facts not pontificate on airy-fairy possibilities.


Oh please stop with this nonsense.

Suppose that a woman is stabbed in the street with no eyewitnesses, but the police find a knife hidden in the apartment of the woman's ex-husband (where he lived alone), with significant amounts of the woman's blood still on the knife; and the ex-husband says he was at home (some 10 miles from the murder scene) at the time of the murder, but reliable mobile phone analysis proves his phone was very close to the murder scene just before and just after the murder; and a friend of the ex-husband testifies that the ex-husband had been talking at length with him about his desire to kill his ex-wife.

Now. You and I would probably agree that if all this evidence was put to a court, it's very highly likely that the ex-husband would be found guilty of murder. But none of this evidence proves the elements of the crime in and of itself. All of this evidence is circumstantial. That means, Vixen, that inferences must be drawn from the evidence in order to prove the required elements of the crime, and thus to prove the man's guilt.

So when the convicting court says "Mr A: you stabbed your ex-wife to death", that is ENTIRELY based on hypothesis - even though the court states it as "judicial truth".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom