Funnily enough, there was a (repeated) programme on TV here in the UK just the other day which featured a case that was - IMO - far more analogous to Kercher/Knox/Sollecito and this strange, sad phenomenon of "altruistic punishers". It was the case of the murder of a young woman called Rachel Nickell in 1992. She was killed in a copse on Wimbledon Common in London, in front of her toddler-age son, and there was home video footage of the pretty young Nickell dancing and playing and laughing - so this case was immediately seized upon by the mass media (and by a certain section of the public) in a very similar way to the way in which the Kercher murder was magnified in respect of the youth, vigour, promise and beauty of the (female) victim.
The police in the Nickell case had no forensic leads, so they brought in a forensic psychologist to do a profile of the likely offender. In many respects the profile was (well, turned out to be...) accurate; but the police - aided and abetted by some local hysteria about an oddball character named Colin Stagg who lived near the common - decided that they'd definitely found their man. They raided Stagg's apartment and arrested him, but he gave no-comment interviews and they found no physical evidence whatsoever to connect him to the murder (though he broadly matched a photofit of a character who'd been seen on the common around the time of the murder, yet Stagg claimed he'd been asleep in his apartment at that time - sound familiar....?).
The police now felt that their "golden bullet" tactic to get "justice" (remember, they were all by now utterly convinced that Stagg was the true killer of Nickell - sound familiar...?) was to elicit a confession from Stagg. To that end, they had a female police officer pose as a besotted and somewhat perverted admirer of Stagg's. She contacted him via a lonely hearts' ad that the police knew Stagg had placed, and developed a letter-writing relationship with him. Ultimately, it got to the point where she essentially suggested to Stagg that she would sleep with him (and Stagg was a virgin) if Stagg would confess to having murdered Nickell. Stagg demurred on that, but the police (and the CPS - the prosecuting authority) felt they now had enough evidence to charge and try Stagg for the murder.
Sensationally - and wholly correctly - the trial judge threw the whole case out almost immediately as soon as he learned of the way in which the police had gone about securing their "evidence" via dreadful entrapment, since without the entrapment evidence all the police had was a general likeness between Stagg and the photofit, and the fact that Stagg lived fairly close to the murder spot. Stagg walked free from court, but he walked into a different hell of his own.
And that's because nobody - not the general public, not the media, not the police, not Nickell's (decent, middle-class) parents - thought that Stagg was factually innocent. They ALL thought he was the true murderer of Nickell, and that he'd "got away with it" through a combination of luck, police incompetence and circumstance. The police publicly announced immediately that they were not looking for anyone else in relation to the murder. Nickell's parents made it explicitly clear that while they respected the judgement of the courts, "where is the justice?". Does any of THIS sound familiar.....?
Stagg went though years and years of being a national pariah, in spite of his acquittal. He was generally accepted as the murderer of that lovely vibrant beautiful young girl Rachel Nickell, and it was taken as given that he'd slipped through the net of justice. In (yet) another mirror of the Kercher case, groups were formed to seek "justice for Rachel Nickell" - and (sounds familiar....?) the sole aim of these groups was to get Stagg put back on trial and "properly" convicted for Nickell's murder.
But here's the kicker: in around 2006/2007, the police reopened the Nickell case as a cold case investigation. Advances in DNA technology meant that small semen samples from Nickell's body could now be typed and matched. And the DNA proved to be a match not to Stagg, but to a totally different man, Robert Napper. Napper was already in prison by that time for a series of rapes and a double murder within London, all of which bore interesting similarities to the Nickell murder. Indeed, one of the police thought there was a similarity back in 1992, and contacted the Nickell team, but was brushed off because the Nickell police were now convinced Stagg was their man, and Stagg had a provable alibi for the time of the other rape/murder. In fact, Napper had committed both crimes. When confronted with the DNA evidence, Napper confessed to the Nickell murder. At long last, Stagg's name was completely and indisputably cleared.
Now, can ANYONE see any similarities between this case (specifically in respect of Stagg versus Knox/Sollecito) and the Kercher case? Anyone?