Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
earlobe infection

It's a little surprising that the spot on Amanda's pillow tested negative for both blood and DNA, if I read the results correctly. The spot may have been from Amanda's infected ear.
 
Funnily enough, there was a (repeated) programme on TV here in the UK just the other day which featured a case that was - IMO - far more analogous to Kercher/Knox/Sollecito and this strange, sad phenomenon of "altruistic punishers". It was the case of the murder of a young woman called Rachel Nickell in 1992. She was killed in a copse on Wimbledon Common in London, in front of her toddler-age son, and there was home video footage of the pretty young Nickell dancing and playing and laughing - so this case was immediately seized upon by the mass media (and by a certain section of the public) in a very similar way to the way in which the Kercher murder was magnified in respect of the youth, vigour, promise and beauty of the (female) victim.

The police in the Nickell case had no forensic leads, so they brought in a forensic psychologist to do a profile of the likely offender. In many respects the profile was (well, turned out to be...) accurate; but the police - aided and abetted by some local hysteria about an oddball character named Colin Stagg who lived near the common - decided that they'd definitely found their man. They raided Stagg's apartment and arrested him, but he gave no-comment interviews and they found no physical evidence whatsoever to connect him to the murder (though he broadly matched a photofit of a character who'd been seen on the common around the time of the murder, yet Stagg claimed he'd been asleep in his apartment at that time - sound familiar....?).

The police now felt that their "golden bullet" tactic to get "justice" (remember, they were all by now utterly convinced that Stagg was the true killer of Nickell - sound familiar...?) was to elicit a confession from Stagg. To that end, they had a female police officer pose as a besotted and somewhat perverted admirer of Stagg's. She contacted him via a lonely hearts' ad that the police knew Stagg had placed, and developed a letter-writing relationship with him. Ultimately, it got to the point where she essentially suggested to Stagg that she would sleep with him (and Stagg was a virgin) if Stagg would confess to having murdered Nickell. Stagg demurred on that, but the police (and the CPS - the prosecuting authority) felt they now had enough evidence to charge and try Stagg for the murder.

Sensationally - and wholly correctly - the trial judge threw the whole case out almost immediately as soon as he learned of the way in which the police had gone about securing their "evidence" via dreadful entrapment, since without the entrapment evidence all the police had was a general likeness between Stagg and the photofit, and the fact that Stagg lived fairly close to the murder spot. Stagg walked free from court, but he walked into a different hell of his own.

And that's because nobody - not the general public, not the media, not the police, not Nickell's (decent, middle-class) parents - thought that Stagg was factually innocent. They ALL thought he was the true murderer of Nickell, and that he'd "got away with it" through a combination of luck, police incompetence and circumstance. The police publicly announced immediately that they were not looking for anyone else in relation to the murder. Nickell's parents made it explicitly clear that while they respected the judgement of the courts, "where is the justice?". Does any of THIS sound familiar.....?

Stagg went though years and years of being a national pariah, in spite of his acquittal. He was generally accepted as the murderer of that lovely vibrant beautiful young girl Rachel Nickell, and it was taken as given that he'd slipped through the net of justice. In (yet) another mirror of the Kercher case, groups were formed to seek "justice for Rachel Nickell" - and (sounds familiar....?) the sole aim of these groups was to get Stagg put back on trial and "properly" convicted for Nickell's murder.

But here's the kicker: in around 2006/2007, the police reopened the Nickell case as a cold case investigation. Advances in DNA technology meant that small semen samples from Nickell's body could now be typed and matched. And the DNA proved to be a match not to Stagg, but to a totally different man, Robert Napper. Napper was already in prison by that time for a series of rapes and a double murder within London, all of which bore interesting similarities to the Nickell murder. Indeed, one of the police thought there was a similarity back in 1992, and contacted the Nickell team, but was brushed off because the Nickell police were now convinced Stagg was their man, and Stagg had a provable alibi for the time of the other rape/murder. In fact, Napper had committed both crimes. When confronted with the DNA evidence, Napper confessed to the Nickell murder. At long last, Stagg's name was completely and indisputably cleared.

Now, can ANYONE see any similarities between this case (specifically in respect of Stagg versus Knox/Sollecito) and the Kercher case? Anyone? :rolleyes:


I got round to watching this programme at last. It was reporter Fiona Bruce giving her take on it as a rookie reporter at the time of the murder.

Some forensic profiler called Paul Britton provided police with a personality sketch of the likely perp. Police looked up all the sex offenders in the area, and homed in on Colin Stagg as one of them, a peeping Tom who watched female swimmers and indecently exposed himself. They called at his door and noticed lots of satanic symbology and vicious-looking samurai-style swords hanging on his wall (Rachel was stabbed >49 times). He was taking in to questioning where his responses were , 'no comment', to almost all questions.

Some stupid policewoman thought she could use her charms to make him 'confess' and Stagg played along with it.

Eventually police linked Robert Napper, a paranoid schizophrenic, a perp connected to another later murder in a woman's house in which he smothered her child. A fibre from Napper's tool box was found on the kid at the scene of the Nickell murder, so it was decided 'Napper did it'.

Whilst it is unfortunate police got carried away with Colin Stagg , he hardly helped himself. One gets the impression he enjoyed his notoriety and his 'no comment' answers means he brought much of the suspicion on himself.

Nothing in common at all with the Kercher murder, other than the courts telling Sollecito his compulsive lying was his own fault for the police interest in him. The courts confirm that Knox, and almost certainly Sollecito, were at the scene of the murder, Knox did wash off Mez' blood and did cover up for Rudy who was also there, but did not wield the fatal blow. All of the forensic evidence, which is solid, points to the killer being Knox.

Police are not looking for any other perpetrator and insist there were others beside Guede. This damns Knox and Sollecito. There is no innocent explanation for their proven presence at the murder scene.
 
Last edited:
Let's see here...
1) leaving Guede's visible bloody shoeprints and handprint under Meredith (since you prescribe to the "staged body" theory"),

2) pointing out Guede's feces in toilet to the police ,

3) listing "a short, black ‘South African’ who played basketball on Piazza Grimana and who had once been to the semi-basement flat when Meredith was there too" (Follain) at the questura during the Nov 5/6 interrogation ,

4) and pointing out to the police Guede's bloody footprint on the bathmat (which, if it had been Sollecito's, the two would have removed)


are all very odd ways of "covering up" for Guede. So odd as to be ludicrous.

Rudy's footprints were not 'immediately visible', they were feint against the pink terazzo tiles - not even the police 'immediately' spotted them. The fact there is only one set, shows the other set was cleaned up and the others missed.

Really? How did Amanda know it was Guede's faeces? She's certainly a bull faeces expert.

Rudy is hardly a 'short black South African' LOL. So Amanda's covered up for him again.

Wrong. She called the obvious footprint on the bathmat a 'blob' which over time became smaller and smaller, until during her trial and in her book it became just a 'speckle'.
 
What medical care could have been given to a stillborn? "Unhallowed ground"? Only if you believe there is any such thing as "hallowed ground". People used to bury babies in their yards all the time. When my grandmother miscarried at 5 months, she buried it in her yard as did her own mother who lost several babies prematurely. Give the sanctimonious judgments a rest, will ya?

I am really shocked. So what happens when a family moves? One of my ex-mother-in-laws dug up her beloved dachshund which was buried in her back garden - when she moved. At least if you bury pets or stillborn babies in designated places you'll always know where they are?

All my family going back hundreds of years are buried in the local church yard. The church itself is dated circa 1450 and under its floor they discovered the remains of an even older church. Before then it was a pagan burial place, being as it is placed on a very scenic spot. Archaelogists discovered ancient inhumation practices. So to my mind, burying unborn children 'in the back yard' seems incredibly sad. As for the person you were originally referring to, did she not seek medical help? If not, it is not so surprising the baby's death was rightly investigated?
 
I got round to watching this programme at last. It was reporter Fiona Bruce giving her take on it as a rookie reporter at the time of the murder.

Some forensic profiler called Paul Britton provided police with a personality sketch of the likely perp. Police looked up all the sex offenders in the area, and homed in on Colin Stagg as one of them, a peeping Tom who watched female swimmers and indecently exposed himself. They called at his door and noticed lots of satanic symbology and vicious-looking samurai-style swords hanging on his wall (Rachel was stabbed >49 times). He was taking in to questioning where his responses were , 'no comment', to almost all questions.

Some stupid policewoman thought she could use her charms to make him 'confess' and Stagg played along with it.

Eventually police linked Robert Napper, a paranoid schizophrenic, a perp connected to another later murder in a woman's house in which he smothered her child. A fibre from Napper's tool box was found on the kid at the scene of the Nickell murder, so it was decided 'Napper did it'.

Whilst it is unfortunate police got carried away with Colin Stagg , he hardly helped himself. One gets the impression he enjoyed his notoriety and his 'no comment' answers means he brought much of the suspicion on himself.

Nothing in common at all with the Kercher murder, other than the courts telling Sollecito his compulsive lying was his own fault for the police interest in him. The courts confirm that Knox, and almost certainly Sollecito, were at the scene of the murder, Knox did wash off Mez' blood and did cover up for Rudy who was also there, but did not wield the fatal blow. All of the forensic evidence, which is solid, points to the killer being Knox.

Police are not looking for any other perpetrator and insist there were others beside Guede. This damns Knox and Sollecito. There is no innocent explanation for their proven presence at the murder scene.



You've got so much wrong in your attempted precis of this case, it's almost as if you didn't watch or comprehend the programme at all (and/or you know next to nothing about the case).

I suggest you go back and read my (accurate) summary, and figure out what you got wrong and/or misrepresented in your post above. And then you might be able to spot the clear areas of similarity between the behaviour of police and prosecutors in the Stagg case and the Knox/Sollecito case.
 
So much for your theory her ears were bleeding as of the night of the murder, and this is why her blood is on the tap /faucet and in the sink and bidet and mixed in with Mez' in Filomena's room.



Wow. You're not aware of the fact that Knox didn't sleep in her own bed in the cottage on the nights of 31st October or November 1st?

Wow.
 
KrissyG has been busy penning an idiotic article on TJMK again. I skimmed the article as anything more made me fluctuate between nausea and hysterical laughing. It's akin to watching Trump; vomit or laugh? A favorite was "two anti-black demonizers" under a pic of Prof. Hampikian and Knox. We were also treated to yet more claims of the mafia's influence in the case.
Someone should really inform KrissyG that it's "mafiosa" or "mafia" not "mafias".


Ahahaha what a truly pathetic "article". I love how these nutters think they are pioneering investigative journalists fighting for justice against the dark forces of "the mafias*" and huge PR machines, when in reality all they are is a tiny cadre of weirdos urinating in the wind of their own prejudices and projections.

It's over, "KrissyG". You're wrong. You formed a false, uninformed, ill-educated and overinvested set of beliefs, with zero defensible basis in evidence or logic. There's not one bit of reliable, credible evidence pointing to Knox's/Sollecito's participation in the Kercher murder. And in fact all of the reliable, credible evidence points to Guede - and Guede alone - being the perpetrator. But by all means keep urinating in the wind with these wild, unsubstantiated lash-outs (complete with tell-tale hyperbole and vindictive insults) if it helps foster your delusion that you're "on the side of right and justice". Just know that you're not. It's hilarious to watch though.


* I think the nutters use the term "mafias" to mean any and all of the groups involved in shady organised crime. What it is, in effect, is an attempt to suggest that Sollecito and his immediate family are involved in organised crime, without directly accusing them of being part of the capital-M Mafia.
 
Last edited:
Rudy's footprints were not 'immediately visible', they were feint against the pink terazzo tiles - not even the police 'immediately' spotted them. The fact there is only one set, shows the other set was cleaned up and the others missed.

Really? How did Amanda know it was Guede's faeces? She's certainly a bull faeces expert.

Rudy is hardly a 'short black South African' LOL. So Amanda's covered up for him again.

Wrong. She called the obvious footprint on the bathmat a 'blob' which over time became smaller and smaller, until during her trial and in her book it became just a 'speckle'.

Nothing in this post is even remotely true.
 
Rudy's footprints were not 'immediately visible', they were feint against the pink terazzo tiles - not even the police 'immediately' spotted them. The fact there is only one set, shows the other set was cleaned up and the others missed. Really? How did Amanda know it was Guede's faeces? She's certainly a bull faeces expert.

Rudy is hardly a 'short black South African' LOL. So Amanda's covered up for him again.

Wrong. She called the obvious footprint on the bathmat a 'blob' which over time became smaller and smaller, until during her trial and in her book it became just a 'speckle'.

So the talented Amanda, capable of detecting Guede's DNA and not cleaning it as she cleans her own and Raffaele's didn't see Guede's bloody prints as she cleans the hallway. This IS what you've argued in the past, is it not.

She didn't, she merely pointed out the feces as part of what made the scene so strange. But had she been involved then she would have known it was Guedes and would have flushed it as she was covering for him.

Guede is not tall - he is shorter than Raffaele. And he is black. Apparently she guessed at where he came from. If she was covering for him why would she even mention him?

In her book she called the print a reddish brown splotch the size of an orange, not a "speckle" as you claim.

Please humor me and explain the 'logic' you use to come to the highlighted conclusion above.
 
So the talented Amanda, capable of detecting Guede's DNA and not cleaning it as she cleans her own and Raffaele's didn't see Guede's bloody prints as she cleans the hallway. This IS what you've argued in the past, is it not.

She didn't, she merely pointed out the feces as part of what made the scene so strange. But had she been involved then she would have known it was Guedes and would have flushed it as she was covering for him.

Guede is not tall - he is shorter than Raffaele. And he is black. Apparently she guessed at where he came from. If she was covering for him why would she even mention him?

In her book she called the print a reddish brown splotch the size of an orange, not a "speckle" as you claim.

Please humor me and explain the 'logic' you use to come to the highlighted conclusion above.

Vixen managed to sneak in a "mixed blood" reference upthread, hoping no one would notice.....
 
Vixen managed to sneak in a "mixed blood" reference upthread, hoping no one would notice.....

Yeah, I saw that. She also repeated, once again, the 'present at the murder, washed blood from hands, covered for Guede' talking points even though she has never offered evidence to support any of it. I have visions of her putting fingers in her ears and humming every time someone tells her there is no evidence to support any of those claims.

As an aside, did you look at the comments following her TJMK article. Quennell seems deeply offended that Hampikian assigns blame to Guede.. he's very defensive of Guede. All for Meredith, I guess.
 
Yeah, I saw that. She also repeated, once again, the 'present at the murder, washed blood from hands, covered for Guede' talking points even though she has never offered evidence to support any of it. I have visions of her putting fingers in her ears and humming every time someone tells her there is no evidence to support any of those claims.

As an aside, did you look at the comments following her TJMK article. Quennell seems deeply offended that Hampikian assigns blame to Guede.. he's very defensive of Guede. All for Meredith, I guess.

I don't look at TJMK these days. Last week, or the week before i took a peek at the remaining PMF site. It's slower than here at ISF.

It is also amazing the way TJMK and the rest have become PR-firms for "poor Rudy" as well as for Giuliano Mignini.
 
So much for your theory her ears were bleeding as of the night of the murder, and this is why her blood is on the tap /faucet and in the sink and bidet and mixed in with Mez' in Filomena's room.

As mentioned already, you do know that Amanda had not slept at the cottage for the past several days, right? No, her explanation is that it had dripped onto the faucet while standing at the sink. Her blood was not found in the sink, bidet or in Filomena's room. For reasons blatantly apparent, you think that her DNA could not have been in her own sink or bidet or on the floor of a room in a place she lived. It got there the same way Meredith's DNA did: on the bottom of her own foot or on the bottom of someone's shoe. Unless of course, you don't think DNA can be transferred in this way as has been proved in studies. Take the blinders off.
 
I am really shocked. So what happens when a family moves? One of my ex-mother-in-laws dug up her beloved dachshund which was buried in her back garden - when she moved. At least if you bury pets or stillborn babies in designated places you'll always know where they are?

All my family going back hundreds of years are buried in the local church yard. The church itself is dated circa 1450 and under its floor they discovered the remains of an even older church. Before then it was a pagan burial place, being as it is placed on a very scenic spot. Archaelogists discovered ancient inhumation practices. So to my mind, burying unborn children 'in the back yard' seems incredibly sad. As for the person you were originally referring to, did she not seek medical help? If not, it is not so surprising the baby's death was rightly investigated?

Shocked are ya? LOL. Do you think my grandmother or her mother didn't know where they had buried their miscarried fetuses? They didn't dig them up when they moved anymore than my gr. grandmother dug up the graves of her children who were stillborn or had died shortly after birth and take them with them. My gr. grandmother had several children who died shortly before or after birth as was not unusual at that time. Out of 12 known pregnancies, she had 4 children who survived with only 3 reaching adulthood.

No, the 18 yr. old did not seek medical help as she didn't know she was pregnant. If you'd read about the case, you'd know that. No one knew she was pregnant because she didn't look pregnant and had irregular periods due to an eating disorder. I never said the baby's death should not have been investigated. But if it was stillborn as she claims, how can she be accused of murder? And what "medical help" would have been available for a stillborn?

" One of my ex-mother-in-laws mothers-in-law" FIFY
 
Last edited:
Ahahaha what a truly pathetic "article". I love how these nutters think they are pioneering investigative journalists fighting for justice against the dark forces of "the mafias*" and huge PR machines, when in reality all they are is a tiny cadre of weirdos urinating in the wind of their own prejudices and projections.

It's over, "KrissyG". You're wrong. You formed a false, uninformed, ill-educated and overinvested set of beliefs, with zero defensible basis in evidence or logic. There's not one bit of reliable, credible evidence pointing to Knox's/Sollecito's participation in the Kercher murder. And in fact all of the reliable, credible evidence points to Guede - and Guede alone - being the perpetrator. But by all means keep urinating in the wind with these wild, unsubstantiated lash-outs (complete with tell-tale hyperbole and vindictive insults) if it helps foster your delusion that you're "on the side of right and justice". Just know that you're not. It's hilarious to watch though.


* I think the nutters use the term "mafias" to mean any and all of the groups involved in shady organised crime. What it is, in effect, is an attempt to suggest that Sollecito and his immediate family are involved in organised crime, without directly accusing them of being part of the capital-M Mafia.[/QUOTE]

I meant to type "mafiose" (the plural), not "mafiosa". The nutters are not attempting to suggest that RS and his immediate family are involved in organized crime; they have come right out and said it on numerous occasions.
 
Rudy's footprints were not 'immediately visible', they were feint against the pink terazzo tiles - not even the police 'immediately' spotted them. The fact there is only one set, shows the other set was cleaned up and the others missed.

Really? How did Amanda know it was Guede's faeces? She's certainly a bull faeces expert.

Rudy is hardly a 'short black South African' LOL. So Amanda's covered up for him again.

Wrong. She called the obvious footprint on the bathmat a 'blob' which over time became smaller and smaller, until during her trial and in her book it became just a 'speckle'.

The footprints were readily visible if Knox and Sollecito were actively looking to clean up any signs of themselves. Are you seriously claiming that they wouldn't see the VISIBLE to the naked eye shoeprints as they were actively cleaning each print going down the hallway and out the door? They missed them ALL? Use some common sense here; if they wanted to clean up all the shoe/footprints, they'd have used the mop which would have been the quickest and most efficient method.

As already addressed, if Amanda had been there the night of Nov. 1, she'd have known that was Guede's crap...and flushed it if she were "covering up" for him. Again, use some common sense.

Amanda told the police about "a short, black ‘South African’ who played basketball on Piazza Grimana and who had once been to the semi-basement flat when Meredith was there too." (Follain) Again, use some common sense here. Do you think Amanda couldn't figure out that the police would ask the boys downstairs who Amanda was referring to? REALLY? What an odd way to "cover up" for Guede. Sheesh.

Regarding the bathmat, you are yet again wrong. She called it "a reddish-brown splotch about the size of an orange" in her book. She never referred to it as a "speckle" in her book. I have the e-book and did a search. She uses the word "speckle(d)" once and it's in reference to the city lights. Nor did she call it a "speckle" in her trial testimony. She referred to it as a "bloody stain", a "stain", and a "larger stain" than the "drops like on the sink" (trial transcripts) That's it. I suggest you do some research before just making stuff up that is so easily refuted. It gets tiresome.
 
I am really shocked. So what happens when a family moves? One of my ex-mother-in-laws dug up her beloved dachshund which was buried in her back garden - when she moved. At least if you bury pets or stillborn babies in designated places you'll always know where they are?

All my family going back hundreds of years are buried in the local church yard. The church itself is dated circa 1450 and under its floor they discovered the remains of an even older church. Before then it was a pagan burial place, being as it is placed on a very scenic spot. Archaelogists discovered ancient inhumation practices. So to my mind, burying unborn children 'in the back yard' seems incredibly sad. As for the person you were originally referring to, did she not seek medical help? If not, it is not so surprising the baby's death was rightly investigated?

How many ex-mother-in-laws do you have?
 
KrissyG has been busy penning an idiotic article on TJMK again. I skimmed the article as anything more made me fluctuate between nausea and hysterical laughing. It's akin to watching Trump; vomit or laugh? A favorite was "two anti-black demonizers" under a pic of Prof. Hampikian and Knox. We were also treated to yet more claims of the mafia's influence in the case.
Someone should really inform KrissyG that it's "mafiosa" or "mafia" not "mafias".

Those are Pete Quennell's words.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom