Vixen
Penultimate Amazing
Oh please stop with this nonsense.
Suppose that a woman is stabbed in the street with no eyewitnesses, but the police find a knife hidden in the apartment of the woman's ex-husband (where he lived alone), with significant amounts of the woman's blood still on the knife; and the ex-husband says he was at home (some 10 miles from the murder scene) at the time of the murder, but reliable mobile phone analysis proves his phone was very close to the murder scene just before and just after the murder; and a friend of the ex-husband testifies that the ex-husband had been talking at length with him about his desire to kill his ex-wife.
Now. You and I would probably agree that if all this evidence was put to a court, it's very highly likely that the ex-husband would be found guilty of murder. But none of this evidence proves the elements of the crime in and of itself. All of this evidence is circumstantial. That means, Vixen, that inferences must be drawn from the evidence in order to prove the required elements of the crime, and thus to prove the man's guilt.
So when the convicting court says "Mr A: you stabbed your ex-wife to death", that is ENTIRELY based on hypothesis - even though the court states it as "judicial truth".
The Crown Prosecution Service will not give police permission to charge that man unless they can show real evidence that there is a reasonable prospect of success for conviction. I should think his mobile phone records represent genuine objective scientific evidence that he was in the vicinity of the crime. There is nothing hypothetical about this, unless he comes up with a reasonable explanation.
Criminal law courts in the UK and the USA are crude and basic. It is a simple case of evidence being presented and a jury deciding whether the case has been sufficently proven 'beyond a reasonable doubt'.
No degree in rocket science or philosophy needed. It can be comprised by a bunch of unemployables, Trump supporters and brexiteers.
But hey, do you know what? This is one of the fairest systems of justice.