Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
It likely happened like this.

'I've got a great idea, let's clean up our remains, but why should we care about Rudy, after all he's ********** off.'

'Yeah great idea. We can leave his evidence here - y'know like the disgusting mess he left in the toilet -'

'Yeah, yeah, let's do that.'


<fast forward outside the cottage>

'Officer Napoleoni, can I have a word'

<Napoleoni swings round>

'Who are you?'

'I live here. I want to show you some faeces I found in the toilet.'



Oh yessss! It makes WAY more sense for a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito to

a) deliberately leave evidence of the third perpetrator - who, if/when caught on account of this evidence is obviously liable to crack and name Knox and Sollecito (or, for that matter, is liable to name them in order to lessen his own punishment) - rather than

b) clean up evidence of EVERYONE, thereby leaving the police with no idea of who was involved, and thereby greatly lessening the chance of them (Knox and Sollecito) ever being caught.

Yeaaaaaaaahhhhhhh. That sounds about right.

Sheesh.
 
Vixen said:
It likely happened like this.
'I've got a great idea, let's clean up our remains, but why should we care about Rudy, after all he's ********** off.'

'Yeah great idea. We can leave his evidence here - y'know like the disgusting mess he left in the toilet -'

'Yeah, yeah, let's do that.'


<fast forward outside the cottage>

'Officer Napoleoni, can I have a word'

<Napoleoni swings round>

'Who are you?'

'I live here. I want to show you some faeces I found in the toilet.'
Oh yessss! It makes WAY more sense for a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito to

a) deliberately leave evidence of the third perpetrator - who, if/when caught on account of this evidence is obviously liable to crack and name Knox and Sollecito (or, for that matter, is liable to name them in order to lessen his own punishment) - rather than

b) clean up evidence of EVERYONE, thereby leaving the police with no idea of who was involved, and thereby greatly lessening the chance of them (Knox and Sollecito) ever being caught.

Yeaaaaaaaahhhhhhh. That sounds about right.

Sheesh.
Why is Vixen even bothering with, "It likely happened like this"? The encounter between Napoleoni and Sollecito about the pooh is well documented. Even John Follain in his book relates that this was the earliest that Napoleoni suspected that Sollecito might have been involved in the crime, the investigative genius she had been!

But for the purposes of this thread - does anyone need any more proof that Vixen is just going to make things up, so that she can vilify two innocents? Despite this scenario being well documented and testified to from all sides, Vixen just changes it to suit her own disgusting purposes.

ETA - and Vixen's "It likely happened like this" is fresh from her saying that it is factual that Knox had covered for Rudy. Now Vixen is implying that Knox had tried to frame Rudy. Such is the thinking of the nutters.
 
Last edited:
It likely happened like this.

'I've got a great idea, let's clean up our remains, but why should we care about Rudy, after all he's ********** off.'

'Yeah great idea. We can leave his evidence here - y'know like the disgusting mess he left in the toilet -'

'Yeah, yeah, let's do that.'


<fast forward outside the cottage>

'Officer Napoleoni, can I have a word'

<Napoleoni swings round>

'Who are you?'

'I live here. I want to show you some faeces I found in the toilet.'

Earlier you claimed that Knox cleaned up Guede's bloody shoeprints and only accidentally left some because they weren't 'obviously visible' against the "pink terrazo floors"*. How was this setting up Guede?

I do wish you would make up your mind! Pick one:

1) Knox was covering for Guede or

2) Knox set up Guede

It can't be both.

*Wrong yet again. The tiles going down the hallway were neither pink nor terrazzo. Filomena's room had a terrazzo floor.
 
It likely happened like this.

'I've got a great idea, let's clean up our remains, but why should we care about Rudy, after all he's ********** off.'

'Yeah great idea. We can leave his evidence here - y'know like the disgusting mess he left in the toilet -'

'Yeah, yeah, let's do that.'


<fast forward outside the cottage>

'Officer Napoleoni, can I have a word'

<Napoleoni swings round>

'Who are you?'

'I live here. I want to show you some faeces I found in the toilet.'

Vixen,
You believe the bloody footprint on the bathmat is Raffaele's, not Rudy's.

So your hypothesis is that Amanda and Raffaele cleaned up all of the physical evidence of themselves in the murder room (including DNA, ahem), left the physical evidence of Rudy (including microscopic fragments of DNA, cough), but left a bloody footprint in the bathroom.

Is that about right?

Can you describe how your brain processed this information and you said to yourself "YEAH, that makes sense!!!" at the end of it?
 
Vixen,
You believe the bloody footprint on the bathmat is Raffaele's, not Rudy's.

So your hypothesis is that Amanda and Raffaele cleaned up all of the physical evidence of themselves in the murder room (including DNA, ahem), left the physical evidence of Rudy (including microscopic fragments of DNA, cough), but left a bloody footprint in the bathroom.

Is that about right?

Can you describe how your brain processed this information and you said to yourself "YEAH, that makes sense!!!" at the end of it?

Vixen previously said that they left the footprint there on purpose because they didn't think the police could figure out it was Sollecito's and it was their way of 'putting one over' on the police. Yeah, I know...it made no sense then either.
 
Vixen,
You believe the bloody footprint on the bathmat is Raffaele's, not Rudy's.

So your hypothesis is that Amanda and Raffaele cleaned up all of the physical evidence of themselves in the murder room (including DNA, ahem), left the physical evidence of Rudy (including microscopic fragments of DNA, cough), but left a bloody footprint in the bathroom.

Is that about right?

Can you describe how your brain processed this information and you said to yourself "YEAH, that makes sense!!!" at the end of it?

The perps at the crime scene had a thousand and one things to think about during that long murder night. In their panic and exhaustion, there were bound to be one or things they overlooked amongst all that cleaning, moving the body, frying the laptops, undressing Mez, setting a burglary scene in Filomena's room (strangely similar to the 'prank' Knox played on her chum a few months before), dealing with the pipes at Raff's flat, etc., etc., it was inevitable they'd accidentally leave Knox' lamp in Mez' room and Raff's dirty great footprint on the bathmat. Perhaps the pair thought it would be a great existential joke.
 
Oh yessss! It makes WAY more sense for a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito to

a) deliberately leave evidence of the third perpetrator - who, if/when caught on account of this evidence is obviously liable to crack and name Knox and Sollecito (or, for that matter, is liable to name them in order to lessen his own punishment) - rather than

b) clean up evidence of EVERYONE, thereby leaving the police with no idea of who was involved, and thereby greatly lessening the chance of them (Knox and Sollecito) ever being caught.

Yeaaaaaaaahhhhhhh. That sounds about right.

Sheesh.


Someone who is deviant enough to set up a fake burglary scene and fake rape scene, is also evil enough to get a kick out of trying to pin the murder on the perp that ran away.

Remember, Knox' favourite refrain is 'ah, but I lived there. You can't prove I was there. Prove I did it, suckers!'
 
Someone who is deviant enough to set up a fake burglary scene and fake rape scene, is also evil enough to get a kick out of trying to pin the murder on the perp that ran away.

Remember, Knox' favourite refrain is 'ah, but I lived there. You can't prove I was there. Prove I did it, suckers!'


What a totally sick post!
 
Someone who is deviant enough to set up a fake burglary scene and fake rape scene, is also evil enough to get a kick out of trying to pin the murder on the perp that ran away.

Remember, Knox' favourite refrain is 'ah, but I lived there. You can't prove I was there. Prove I did it, suckers!'

So let's see... I assume you're not sick enough to claim that Meredith had consensual sex with Guede. And I know you understand that the evidence shows Meredith's bra was removed after her neck was cut but before she died. The forensic evidence is; Guede's DNA IN Meredith; Guede's DNA on Meredith's bra; Guede's palm print on a sheet under Meredith's body; Guede telling us he was there and covered in blood. There is NO forensic trace of Amanda and only a discredited speck of Raffaele's DNA on the metal hook of the bra clasp.

Given this scenario which do you think a logical person would conclude:

1. Guede sexually assaulted and murdered Meredith
2. Amanda and Raffaele killed Meredith then staged a rape and managed to remove all forensic trace of themselves while leaving Guede's behind in numerous places.

Not surprisingly, Vixen, you think it's #2. And you consider yourself logical.. ha!
 
So let's see... I assume you're not sick enough to claim that Meredith had consensual sex with Guede. And I know you understand that the evidence shows Meredith's bra was removed after her neck was cut but before she died. The forensic evidence is; Guede's DNA IN Meredith; Guede's DNA on Meredith's bra; Guede's palm print on a sheet under Meredith's body; Guede telling us he was there and covered in blood. There is NO forensic trace of Amanda and only a discredited speck of Raffaele's DNA on the metal hook of the bra clasp.

Given this scenario which do you think a logical person would conclude:

1. Guede sexually assaulted and murdered Meredith
2. Amanda and Raffaele killed Meredith then staged a rape and managed to remove all forensic trace of themselves while leaving Guede's behind in numerous places.

Not surprisingly, Vixen, you think it's #2. And you consider yourself logical.. ha!


As Micheli* wryly remarked, if Rudy was a rapist, he didn't actually complete the job.

There was no consensual sex between Mez and Guede. Massei established it was Knox who let Guede in.

Rudy sexually assaulted Mez.

However, Knox and Raff stripped the body after Guede had left and posed it to make sure police thought it was 'the random burglar overcome with lust' and to deflect from the female perpetrator.

The proof? the body was covered with a duvet and on top of that was scattered papers of a similar nature to those in Filomena's room, to make it look like a burglary. Amanda trailed Meredith's blood into Filomena's room and trailed back a shard of the broken glass. The smashed window happened after the murder.

There is zero DNA evidence of Guede in Filomena's room, but a mixed DNA of Knox and Mez in a spot of Mez' blood on her carpet.

According to PIP logic, no DNA, no presence.

*This is why Micheli is a top legal brain, whilst you are just an IT technician.
 
Last edited:
Someone who is deviant enough to set up a fake burglary scene and fake rape scene, is also evil enough to get a kick out of trying to pin the murder on the perp that ran away.

Remember, Knox' favourite refrain is 'ah, but I lived there. You can't prove I was there. Prove I did it, suckers!'


Did you read my post fully?

If a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito point the police towards Guede, and then Guede subsequently tells the police that Knox and Sollecito were also involved (and, as I said, there's every chance that Guede would have been offered an incentive to do so), then suddenly Knox and Sollecito are in pretty big trouble, aren't they?

Whereas if a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito try to ensure the police can trace NONE of the three of them, they stand a far, far greater chance of never getting caught.

Therefore it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever for a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito to "pin the murder" on Guede, regardless of what you might regard as their "deviancy". Rather, unless a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito have some bizarre desire to get caught and punished, the ONLY logical approach for them would be to get rid of evidence from all three of the (hypothetical) perpetrators.

How difficult can it be to understand this?

(I would, in this respect, challenge you to present an example of any serious crime group enterprise in history where a subset of the perpetrators have made a deliberate decision to lead investigating authorities to one or more of the other perpetrators in the group......)
 
The perps at the crime scene had a thousand and one things to think about during that long murder night. In their panic and exhaustion, there were bound to be one or things they overlooked amongst all that cleaning, moving the body, frying the laptops, undressing Mez, setting a burglary scene in Filomena's room (strangely similar to the 'prank' Knox played on her chum a few months before), dealing with the pipes at Raff's flat, etc., etc., it was inevitable they'd accidentally leave Knox' lamp in Mez' room and Raff's dirty great footprint on the bathmat. Perhaps the pair thought it would be a great existential joke.


Oh dear.
 
Did you read my post fully?

If a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito point the police towards Guede, and then Guede subsequently tells the police that Knox and Sollecito were also involved (and, as I said, there's every chance that Guede would have been offered an incentive to do so), then suddenly Knox and Sollecito are in pretty big trouble, aren't they?

Whereas if a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito try to ensure the police can trace NONE of the three of them, they stand a far, far greater chance of never getting caught.

Therefore it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever for a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito to "pin the murder" on Guede, regardless of what you might regard as their "deviancy". Rather, unless a hypothetically-guilty Knox and Sollecito have some bizarre desire to get caught and punished, the ONLY logical approach for them would be to get rid of evidence from all three of the (hypothetical) perpetrators.

How difficult can it be to understand this?

(I would, in this respect, challenge you to present an example of any serious crime group enterprise in history where a subset of the perpetrators have made a deliberate decision to lead investigating authorities to one or more of the other perpetrators in the group......)


A key concept in law is chronology.

When the crime happened, police were not aware Rudy was involved, although the kids were.

The kids were taken in for questioning. Rudy was kicking his heels in Germany, incognito.

During questioning, news was broken to Amanda that Raff had withdrawn his alibi for her (i.e., that the pair had been together all evening in his apartment).

It was at this point, Amanda had a meltdown and blurted out that she had taken Patrick to the cottage for sex with Mez (what kind of a degenerate person does this?) and had witnessed Patrick raping Mez, heard thuds and a harrowing scream.

Accusing Patrick seemed a good idea at the time for the scheming madam, for it meant Patrick, who knew nothing at all, was now locked up for the crime as a key suspect.

At this juncture, neither Amanda or Raff knew they would still be under investigation. However, it is not surprising they were given:

  • Amanda's confession she was present at the murder
  • Raff making a signed witness statement for the police saying Amanda went out between 20:45 and 01:00 and that his alibi had been a lie.
  • When luminol tests were carried out, the kids' footrpints were highlighted in the hallway and in Amanda's room
  • Raff's apartment smelt strongly of bleach when visited by police.
  • Phone records came back showing the pair had both turned off their phones circa 20:45 and did not switch them back on until next day.
  • Raff claimed he was on his laptop all evening. IP records came back that there was no internet activity after 21:30, the last human one at 21:10.
  • The pair claimed they did not wake up until circa 10:00 next morning. IP records showed they played heavy metal music at 5:30am.
  • A knife found in Raff's apartment was found to have Amanda's DNA on the hilt and Mez' on the blade ( a near full profile).
  • Numerous other anomalies. None of their five alibis checked out.

Moving forward in the chronology: police match DNA found on a toothbrush in Rudy's bedsit (weird how he had an apartment when he's supposed to be a drifter) with the migrants database.

From a distance Rudy has followed the news whilst on the run and notes with satisfaction neither Amanda nor Raff have grassed on him

Therefore, he reciprocates and does not grass on them. However, he describes Raff down to a T, as the strange Italian man wielding a knife on the threshold of Mez' room. Quite a feat, if he had never met him

On Rudy's arrest, Raff wrote that he felt anxiety that Rudy might say 'strange things about me'.

Back to the chronology.

Now that Rudy is arrested and charged together with Raff and Amanda the tactic changes to 'Rudy did it all by himself'.

Kimo sabe?
 
<snip>

(I would, in this respect, challenge you to present an example of any serious crime group enterprise in history where a subset of the perpetrators have made a deliberate decision to lead investigating authorities to one or more of the other perpetrators in the group......)


Mats Brink

Hatton Garden Robbery
 
As Micheli* wryly remarked, if Rudy was a rapist, he didn't actually complete the job.

There was no consensual sex between Mez and Guede. Massei established it was Knox who let Guede in.

Rudy sexually assaulted Mez.

However, Knox and Raff stripped the body after Guede had left and posed it to make sure police thought it was 'the random burglar overcome with lust' and to deflect from the female perpetrator.

The proof? the body was covered with a duvet and on top of that was scattered papers of a similar nature to those in Filomena's room, to make it look like a burglary. Amanda trailed Meredith's blood into Filomena's room and trailed back a shard of the broken glass. The smashed window happened after the murder.


ETA

I am really disgusted by your 'did not complete the job' comment it is a really sick and horrible thing to say.

There is zero DNA evidence of Guede in Filomena's room, but a mixed DNA of Knox and Mez in a spot of Mez' blood on her carpet.

According to PIP logic, no DNA, no presence.

*This is why Micheli is a top legal brain, whilst you are just an IT technician.

Micheli is a lawyer not a forensic pathologist. His opinion on evidence of rape is of no value. The truth is (I have not quoted a reference as it is so widely accepted but could do so if necessary), that there is no way, post mortem, to prove rape. Rape is a crime based on consent. There is no way to know if the victim was raped or not short of a contemporaneous recording. The definition of rape varies, in the UK the presence of the suspects DNA within the vagina of the victim would be sufficient (the definition being penetration by any implement including fingers); in other countries it has to be penile penetration. In the absence of semen we cannot know if the victim was raped by penile penetration or not. One can say it is not proven but one cannot say it is proven not to have occurred. All your flippant 'did not complete the job' means that the assailant did not ejaculate within the victim, in fact there is evidence that he pulled out and ejaculated on the pillow.
 
Last edited:
Micheli is a lawyer not a forensic pathologist. His opinion on evidence of rape is of no value. The truth is (I have not quoted a reference as it is so widely accepted but could do so if necessary), that there is no way, post mortem, to prove rape. Rape is a crime based on consent. There is no way to know if the victim was raped or not short of a contemporaneous recording. The definition of rape varies, in the UK the presence of the suspects DNA within the vagina of the victim would be sufficient (the definition being penetration by any implement including fingers); in other countries it has to be penile penetration. In the absence of semen we cannot know if the victim was raped by penile penetration or not. One can say it is not proven but one cannot say it is proven not to have occurred. All your flippant 'did not complete the job' means that the assailant did not ejaculate within the victim, in fact there is evidence that he pulled out and ejaculated on the pillow.

Rudy's version is corroborated by the evidence (i.e., they fooled around, but then stopped because there were no condoms). Albeit he paints himself in a consensual light and there is no evidence for that.

It was Raff and his defence team who did not want the pillow stain tested 'in case it turned out to be Raff's'.

Sure, they made an application after the trial. Says it all really.

How disgusting Raff and Amanda interfering with the body.
 
Last edited:
Mats Brink

Hatton Garden Robbery


1) It's "Brinks Mat". Not "Mats Brink".

2) In neither of these cases did a subset of the perpetrators (not-yet-identified-by-authorities perpetrators, OBVIOUSLY*) make a deliberate decision to lead investigating authorities to one or more of the other perpetrators in the group.

Other than that.... GREAT EXAMPLES!


* This should go without saying. There are obviously innumerable examples of apprehended co-perpetrators agreeing to give up other as-yet-unapprehended co-perps. And in addition, the hypothetical Knox/Sollecito "reasoning" you've been offering has been based on Knox and Sollecito having been as-yet unidentified or unapprehended.
 
A key concept in law is chronology.

When the crime happened, police were not aware Rudy was involved, although the kids were.

The kids were taken in for questioning. Rudy was kicking his heels in Germany, incognito.

During questioning, news was broken to Amanda that Raff had withdrawn his alibi for her (i.e., that the pair had been together all evening in his apartment).

It was at this point, Amanda had a meltdown and blurted out that she had taken Patrick to the cottage for sex with Mez (what kind of a degenerate person does this?) and had witnessed Patrick raping Mez, heard thuds and a harrowing scream.

Accusing Patrick seemed a good idea at the time for the scheming madam, for it meant Patrick, who knew nothing at all, was now locked up for the crime as a key suspect.

At this juncture, neither Amanda or Raff knew they would still be under investigation. However, it is not surprising they were given:

  • Amanda's confession she was present at the murder
  • Raff making a signed witness statement for the police saying Amanda went out between 20:45 and 01:00 and that his alibi had been a lie.
  • When luminol tests were carried out, the kids' footrpints were highlighted in the hallway and in Amanda's room
  • Raff's apartment smelt strongly of bleach when visited by police.
  • Phone records came back showing the pair had both turned off their phones circa 20:45 and did not switch them back on until next day.
  • Raff claimed he was on his laptop all evening. IP records came back that there was no internet activity after 21:30, the last human one at 21:10.
  • The pair claimed they did not wake up until circa 10:00 next morning. IP records showed they played heavy metal music at 5:30am.
  • A knife found in Raff's apartment was found to have Amanda's DNA on the hilt and Mez' on the blade ( a near full profile).
  • Numerous other anomalies. None of their five alibis checked out.

Moving forward in the chronology: police match DNA found on a toothbrush in Rudy's bedsit (weird how he had an apartment when he's supposed to be a drifter) with the migrants database.

From a distance Rudy has followed the news whilst on the run and notes with satisfaction neither Amanda nor Raff have grassed on him

Therefore, he reciprocates and does not grass on them. However, he describes Raff down to a T, as the strange Italian man wielding a knife on the threshold of Mez' room. Quite a feat, if he had never met him

On Rudy's arrest, Raff wrote that he felt anxiety that Rudy might say 'strange things about me'.

Back to the chronology.

Now that Rudy is arrested and charged together with Raff and Amanda the tactic changes to 'Rudy did it all by himself'.

Kimo sabe?


Nope. None of this makes any sense whatsoever.

There's no getting away from the bald fact that it would have made zero sense - at any point in your "chronology" - for a hypothetically-guilty Knox/Sollecito to do anything other than a) remove as much physical evidence of ALL THREE co-perpetrators from Kercher's room and other incriminating areas; and b) seek to incriminate NOBODY: not themselves, not Guede, not Lumumba. Nobody.


Comprendez? (Not "Kimo (sic) sabe?")
 
Rudy's version is corroborated by the evidence (i.e., they fooled around, but then stopped because there were no condoms). Albeit he paints himself in a consensual light and there is no evidence for that.

It was Raff and his defence team who did not want the pillow stain tested 'in case it turned out to be Raff's'.

Sure, they made an application after the trial. Says it all really.

How disgusting Raff and Amanda interfering with the body.



Precisely how have you arrived at the conclusion that Knox or Sollecito "interfered with the body"?

Thanks in advance for your precise, (reliable & credible) evidence-based response.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom