Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
So the talented Amanda, capable of detecting Guede's DNA and not cleaning it as she cleans her own and Raffaele's didn't see Guede's bloody prints as she cleans the hallway. This IS what you've argued in the past, is it not.

She didn't, she merely pointed out the feces as part of what made the scene so strange. But had she been involved then she would have known it was Guedes and would have flushed it as she was covering for him.

Guede is not tall - he is shorter than Raffaele. And he is black. Apparently she guessed at where he came from. If she was covering for him why would she even mention him?

In her book she called the print a reddish brown splotch the size of an orange, not a "speckle" as you claim.

Please humor me and explain the 'logic' you use to come to the highlighted conclusion above.


She wanted to convey an impression of Patrick Lumumba, who is short and 'Bantu'-looking. Guede is tall and slim 5'11", looks very different from Patrick.
 
Ahahaha what a truly pathetic "article". I love how these nutters think they are pioneering investigative journalists fighting for justice against the dark forces of "the mafias*" and huge PR machines, when in reality all they are is a tiny cadre of weirdos urinating in the wind of their own prejudices and projections.

It's over, "KrissyG". You're wrong. You formed a false, uninformed, ill-educated and overinvested set of beliefs, with zero defensible basis in evidence or logic. There's not one bit of reliable, credible evidence pointing to Knox's/Sollecito's participation in the Kercher murder. And in fact all of the reliable, credible evidence points to Guede - and Guede alone - being the perpetrator. But by all means keep urinating in the wind with these wild, unsubstantiated lash-outs (complete with tell-tale hyperbole and vindictive insults) if it helps foster your delusion that you're "on the side of right and justice". Just know that you're not. It's hilarious to watch though.


* I think the nutters use the term "mafias" to mean any and all of the groups involved in shady organised crime. What it is, in effect, is an attempt to suggest that Sollecito and his immediate family are involved in organised crime, without directly accusing them of being part of the capital-M Mafia.

The PIP really are a crude vulgar lot. Wash your mouth out.
 
Shocked are ya? LOL. Do you think my grandmother or her mother didn't know where they had buried their miscarried fetuses? They didn't dig them up when they moved anymore than my gr. grandmother dug up the graves of her children who were stillborn or had died shortly after birth and take them with them. My gr. grandmother had several children who died shortly before or after birth as was not unusual at that time. Out of 12 known pregnancies, she had 4 children who survived with only 3 reaching adulthood.

No, the 18 yr. old did not seek medical help as she didn't know she was pregnant. If you'd read about the case, you'd know that. No one knew she was pregnant because she didn't look pregnant and had irregular periods due to an eating disorder. I never said the baby's death should not have been investigated. But if it was stillborn as she claims, how can she be accused of murder? And what "medical help" would have been available for a stillborn?

" One of my ex-mother-in-laws mothers-in-law" FIFY

Yes, there was a high infant mortality rate in C19 but I never heard of anyone burying their children in the back yard.

It doesn't make it OK for Skylar to do the same.
 
The PIP really are a crude vulgar lot. Wash your mouth out.


Huh? Which of the PIP are "crude" and "vulgar"?

And since you're quoting my post above that statement, does this imply that part or all of that post of mine is "crude" or "vulgar"? If so, which part precisely?

And of course you don't think "KrissyG" is being crude or vulgar in captioning a photo of Hampikian and Knox with the words "Two Anti-Black Demonizers". I see, "Vixen". I seeeeeeeeeeeee.............. :rolleyes:
 
Yes, there was a high infant mortality rate in C19 but I never heard of anyone burying their children in the back yard.

It doesn't make it OK for Skylar to do the same.


You still seem utterly unaware that she was on trial not for burying her dead-from-natural-causes child in her back garden, but for MURDERING her child? Your grasp of detail and relevance is terribly poor.

Back to the Knox/Sollecito case and the Kercher murder investigation though.....
 
She wanted to convey an impression of Patrick Lumumba, who is short and 'Bantu'-looking. Guede is tall and slim 5'11", looks very different from Patrick.


Utter nonsense. And the part about ethnic differentiation is extraordinary: the idea that Knox would recognise the ethnic differences between a Congolese and an Ivorian is ridiculous on its face (pun intended).

And on top of that, how/why would Knox - if as you suppose she was a) guilty of participating in the Kercher murder with Guede, but b) wanted to try to frame Lumumba instead - possibly think it would be a good idea to falsely name (or even imply the name of) Lumumba "out of the blue", if she had no idea whether or not Lumumba would have a cast-iron alibi for the time of the murder? In fact, worse even than that, Knox would have had to assume that Lumumba WOULD have had a cast-iron alibi, since she knew he was keeping his bar open but didn't need her help because there were insufficient customers.

Face it, Vixen. All the available evidence (and logic capable of being followed by a child) indicates that it was the police (and/or PM) who decided in advance that Lumumba was the prime culprit, owing to the content of Knox's infamous "see you later" text message to Lumumba. Whether Knox was the first person in that room to physically vocalise the name of Lumumba - when, for example, the police asked her "Who did you send that "see you later" text message to?" - is immaterial. The point is that the police convinced themselves they knew the "truth" of Lumumba's involvement, and they then coerced Knox into "remembering" that "truth".

The idea that Knox had any wilful premeditated idea of "framing" Lumumba is not only unsupported by any credible, reliable evidence, it is in fact contradicted by some credible, reliable evidence. And it's contradicted by logic. Another fail.
 
Yes, there was a high infant mortality rate in C19 but I never heard of anyone burying their children in the back yard.

It doesn't make it OK for Skylar to do the same.

My grandmother buried her miscarried fetus around 1930, not the 19th century. And it was the result of spousal abuse. Just because you never heard about it, doesn't mean it never happened. And please show me where I ever said it was OK for Skylar to do the same? HINT: I didn't. As has been pointed out, she wasn't arrested for burying the baby in the backyard, but for murdering it. Unless the coroner can show that baby was killed and wasn't stillborn or died for some unknown reason right after birth, I still don't see how she can be charged with murder.
 
KrissyG has been busy penning an idiotic article on TJMK again. I skimmed the article as anything more made me fluctuate between nausea and hysterical laughing. It's akin to watching Trump; vomit or laugh? A favorite was "two anti-black demonizers" under a pic of Prof. Hampikian and Knox. We were also treated to yet more claims of the mafia's influence in the case.
Someone should really inform KrissyG that it's "mafiosa" or "mafia" not "mafias".

"KrissyG's" latest TJMK slop also shows her complete confusion re: the case of au pair Louise Woodward and Barry Scheck. While Woodward was never acquitted, the judge in her case did essentially overrule the jury and reduced her conviction and, more significantly, her sentence from 15 years to time-served: around 250 days. I'd impart at least some degree of "success" to those developments for which Scheck et al can probably claim some credit. This all occurred 2+ years after the OJ acquittal which I wouldn't characterize as "shortly".
 
Last edited:
She wanted to convey an impression of Patrick Lumumba, who is short and 'Bantu'-looking. Guede is tall and slim 5'11", looks very different from Patrick.

She wanted to convey an impression of Patrick by telling the police he played basketball in Piazza Grimana and had been to the apartment downstairs once when Meredith was there? Riiiiiiiiight.....like the police wouldn't ask the boys downstairs who that could possibly be? You didn't think that theory through very well, did ya?
 
Rudy's footprints were not 'immediately visible', they were feint against the pink terazzo tiles - not even the police 'immediately' spotted them. The fact there is only one set, shows the other set was cleaned up and the others missed.

Really? How did Amanda know it was Guede's faeces? She's certainly a bull faeces expert.

Rudy is hardly a 'short black South African' LOL. So Amanda's covered up for him again.

Wrong. She called the obvious footprint on the bathmat a 'blob' which over time became smaller and smaller, until during her trial and in her book it became just a 'speckle'.

The footprints were readily visible if Knox and Sollecito were actively looking to clean up any signs of themselves. Are you seriously claiming that they wouldn't see the VISIBLE to the naked eye shoeprints as they were actively cleaning each print going down the hallway and out the door? They missed them ALL? Use some common sense here; if they wanted to clean up all the shoe/footprints, they'd have used the mop which would have been the quickest and most efficient method.

As already addressed, if Amanda had been there the night of Nov. 1, she'd have known that was Guede's crap...and flushed it if she were "covering up" for him. Again, use some common sense.

Amanda told the police about "a short, black ‘South African’ who played basketball on Piazza Grimana and who had once been to the semi-basement flat when Meredith was there too." (Follain) Again, use some common sense here. Do you think Amanda couldn't figure out that the police would ask the boys downstairs who Amanda was referring to? REALLY? What an odd way to "cover up" for Guede. Sheesh.

Regarding the bathmat, you are yet again wrong. She called it "a reddish-brown splotch about the size of an orange" in her book. She never referred to it as a "speckle" in her book. I have the e-book and did a search. She uses the word "speckle(d)" once and it's in reference to the city lights. Nor did she call it a "speckle" in her trial testimony. She referred to it as a "bloody stain", a "stain", and a "larger stain" than the "drops like on the sink" (trial transcripts) That's it. I suggest you do some research before just making stuff up that is so easily refuted. It gets tiresome.

It does not go unnoticed that Vixen never acknowledges her false claims and, in fact, even doubles down on her illogical and nonsensical idea that Amanda was trying to cover up for Guede and implicate Lumumba when she told the police about the "South African" who played basketball in Piazza Grimana and was at the boys' downstairs when Meredith was there. :jaw-dropp
 
Crook with knife marked bloody hands standing over body

who did it

*discusses for 100,000 posts*
 
Utter nonsense. And the part about ethnic differentiation is extraordinary: the idea that Knox would recognise the ethnic differences between a Congolese and an Ivorian is ridiculous on its face (pun intended).

And on top of that, how/why would Knox - if as you suppose she was a) guilty of participating in the Kercher murder with Guede, but b) wanted to try to frame Lumumba instead - possibly think it would be a good idea to falsely name (or even imply the name of) Lumumba "out of the blue", if she had no idea whether or not Lumumba would have a cast-iron alibi for the time of the murder? In fact, worse even than that, Knox would have had to assume that Lumumba WOULD have had a cast-iron alibi, since she knew he was keeping his bar open but didn't need her help because there were insufficient customers.

Face it, Vixen. All the available evidence (and logic capable of being followed by a child) indicates that it was the police (and/or PM) who decided in advance that Lumumba was the prime culprit, owing to the content of Knox's infamous "see you later" text message to Lumumba. Whether Knox was the first person in that room to physically vocalise the name of Lumumba - when, for example, the police asked her "Who did you send that "see you later" text message to?" - is immaterial. The point is that the police convinced themselves they knew the "truth" of Lumumba's involvement, and they then coerced Knox into "remembering" that "truth".

The idea that Knox had any wilful premeditated idea of "framing" Lumumba is not only unsupported by any credible, reliable evidence, it is in fact contradicted by some credible, reliable evidence. And it's contradicted by logic. Another fail.

There is another issue which Vixen has consistently refused to address. If Amanda committed murder with Guede and named Lumumba to cover up for Guede why is the notion that Amanda killed Meredith with Guede full of holes as detailed below :-

• Amanda barely knew Rudy, Raffaele did not know Rudy at all and Amanda and Raffaele had only been dating six days. Three virtual strangers came together to commit a brutal sex crazed murder.

• Amanda only had brief contact with Guede and in six years the prosecution could not find any evidence of regular contact with Amanda and Guede and Raffaele had never met Guede. Despite this they were able to plan a murder.

• As the links below show witness testimony stated Amanda had a good relationship with Meredith and no evidence has existed Amanda had any animosity towards Meredith. Despite this Amanda was prepared to help a stranger carry out a brutal sexual assault and murder against Meredith.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/amanda...ehavior-myths/

• The phones of Amanda and Raffaele were tapped in the three days between the discovery of Meredith’s body and the interrogations. Despite this Amanda and Raffaele make no mention of Rudy a man they were supposed to have committed a brutal murder and sexual assault with.

• Amanda spoke only basic Italian and Rudy did not speak English. Despite this Amanda and Rudy were able to plan a murder together.

• There is no contact between Amanda and Raffaele with Rudy after the murder. Is it credible that people could committ a brutal sexual assault and murder together and never contact each other again.

• As per the link below, the evidence which should have existed if Amanda and Rafffaele killed Meredith with Rudy is missing.

http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/FBI2.html

• A woman was supposedly willing to help a stranger carry out a brutal sexual assault and murder against another woman. A scenario with no known precedent.

• The evidence against Guede was solid, credible and irrefutable as seen in the link below.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/rudy-guede/

The evidence against Amanda and Raffaele was full of holes and had no credibility. The knife was an example of this as can be seen from my post below. If Amanda, Raffaele and Guede committed the same crime together, how is the difference in the quality of the evidence explained?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...7#post11377317

• The methods the prosecution had to resort to with regards to Amanda and Raffaele were clearly the methods prosecutors would resort to when they have a weak case, lack of evidence and the facts don’t support their case as can be seen from the links below. The prosecution didn’t have to resort to these tactics when it came to Guede which indicated the prosecution had plenty of evidence and a slam dunk case. How is this massive difference explained if Amanda, Raffaele and Rudy committed the same crime?


http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/raffaeles-kitchen-knife/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/contam...bwork-coverup/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/meredi...ry-corruption/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/evidence-destroyed/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/blood-...irs-apartment/
https://knoxsollecito.wordpress.com/...ele-sollecito/
http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/myths.html
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...4#post11071314
http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/myths.html
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...4#post11071314

• The evidence suggests Meredith was killed between 9.00 pm and 10.00 pm. Raffaele was using his computer at 9.10 pm and 9.26 pm which gives them an alibi for the time Guede murdered Meredith.

• The posts below show some of the falsehoods by Vixen in her posts showing PGP have to resort to lying to argue the case for Amanda and Raffaele’s guilt. I have never heard anyone resorting to lying to argue the case for Rudy’s guilt. How is this difference explained if Amanda, Raffaele and Rudy committed the same crime?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11938562
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11942852
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11598412
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...1#post11427461
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11951893
 
Utter nonsense. And the part about ethnic differentiation is extraordinary: the idea that Knox would recognise the ethnic differences between a Congolese and an Ivorian is ridiculous on its face (pun intended).

And on top of that, how/why would Knox - if as you suppose she was a) guilty of participating in the Kercher murder with Guede, but b) wanted to try to frame Lumumba instead - possibly think it would be a good idea to falsely name (or even imply the name of) Lumumba "out of the blue", if she had no idea whether or not Lumumba would have a cast-iron alibi for the time of the murder? In fact, worse even than that, Knox would have had to assume that Lumumba WOULD have had a cast-iron alibi, since she knew he was keeping his bar open but didn't need her help because there were insufficient customers.

Face it, Vixen. All the available evidence (and logic capable of being followed by a child) indicates that it was the police (and/or PM) who decided in advance that Lumumba was the prime culprit, owing to the content of Knox's infamous "see you later" text message to Lumumba. Whether Knox was the first person in that room to physically vocalise the name of Lumumba - when, for example, the police asked her "Who did you send that "see you later" text message to?" - is immaterial. The point is that the police convinced themselves they knew the "truth" of Lumumba's involvement, and they then coerced Knox into "remembering" that "truth".

The idea that Knox had any wilful premeditated idea of "framing" Lumumba is not only unsupported by any credible, reliable evidence, it is in fact contradicted by some credible, reliable evidence. And it's contradicted by logic. Another fail.


Marasca-Bruno decreed that Knox named Lumumba to cover up for Guede.

Think about it.
 
Marasca-Bruno decreed that Knox named Lumumba to cover up for Guede.

Think about it.

The 2015 Marasca/Bruno report said no such thing. It did, however, say that the investigation of the crime was so inept that there was no way to tell these things one way or another.

You simply repeat long since debunked factoids.
 
She wanted to convey an impression of Patrick by telling the police he played basketball in Piazza Grimana and had been to the apartment downstairs once when Meredith was there? Riiiiiiiiight.....like the police wouldn't ask the boys downstairs who that could possibly be? You didn't think that theory through very well, did ya?

She was a liar then, wasn't she, as she and Guede had chatted each other up at Le Chic sometime before. That's something Knox will never tell you about.

Telling lies to the police. Tut, tut.
 
The 2015 Marasca/Bruno report said no such thing. It did, however, say that the investigation of the crime was so inept that there was no way to tell these things one way or another.

You simply repeat long since debunked factoids.

Marasca-Bruno did say it. You are either losing your grip on reality, or - more likely - are trying to spin the matter to fool readers into thinking it didn't happen.

You could get a job with Putin. 'Nerve gas, what nerve gas? Not us, guv.'
 
My grandmother buried her miscarried fetus around 1930, not the 19th century. And it was the result of spousal abuse. Just because you never heard about it, doesn't mean it never happened. And please show me where I ever said it was OK for Skylar to do the same? HINT: I didn't. As has been pointed out, she wasn't arrested for burying the baby in the backyard, but for murdering it. Unless the coroner can show that baby was killed and wasn't stillborn or died for some unknown reason right after birth, I still don't see how she can be charged with murder.

I just looked up this case on Google, and according to the SUN, the baby did draw breath, if only for a couple of hours. Therefore, it was not stillborn.

Burning it and burying it is indeed suspicious.

A live birth is very different from a miscarriage or a stillborn.

Please don't tell us your grandmother in the 1930's set fire to the foetus before burying it, just to stick up for Brook Skylar Richardson (_sp?)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom