Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
What's interesting is why Amanda Knox covered up for Rudy Guede.

Vixen keeps banging on about how Amanda covered up for Guede but still refuses to answer the question why is the scenario of Amanda committing murder with Guede full of holes as detailed in my list below :-

• Amanda barely knew Rudy, Raffaele did not know Rudy at all and Amanda and Raffaele had only been dating six days. Three virtual strangers came together to commit a brutal sex crazed murder.

• Amanda only had brief contact with Guede and in six years the prosecution could not find any evidence of regular contact with Amanda and Guede and Raffaele had never met Guede. Despite this they were able to plan a murder.

• As the links below show witness testimony stated Amanda had a good relationship with Meredith and no evidence has existed Amanda had any animosity towards Meredith. Despite this Amanda was prepared to help a stranger carry out a brutal sexual assault and murder against Meredith.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/amanda...ehavior-myths/

• The phones of Amanda and Raffaele were tapped in the three days between the discovery of Meredith’s body and the interrogations. Despite this Amanda and Raffaele make no mention of Rudy a man they were supposed to have committed a brutal murder and sexual assault with.

• Amanda spoke only basic Italian and Rudy did not speak English. Despite this Amanda and Rudy were able to plan a murder together.

• There is no contact between Amanda and Raffaele with Rudy after the murder. Is it credible that people could committ a brutal sexual assault and murder together and never contact each other again.

• As per the link below, the evidence which should have existed if Amanda and Rafffaele killed Meredith with Rudy is missing.

http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/FBI2.html

• A woman was supposedly willing to help a stranger carry out a brutal sexual assault and murder against another woman. A scenario with no known precedent.

• The evidence against Guede was solid, credible and irrefutable as seen in the link below.

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/rudy-guede/

The evidence against Amanda and Raffaele was full of holes and had no credibility. The knife was an example of this as can be seen from my post below. If Amanda, Raffaele and Guede committed the same crime together, how is the difference in the quality of the evidence explained?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...7#post11377317

• The methods the prosecution had to resort to with regards to Amanda and Raffaele were clearly the methods prosecutors would resort to when they have a weak case, lack of evidence and the facts don’t support their case as can be seen from the links below. The prosecution didn’t have to resort to these tactics when it came to Guede which indicated the prosecution had plenty of evidence and a slam dunk case. How is this massive difference explained if Amanda, Raffaele and Rudy committed the same crime?


http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/raffaeles-kitchen-knife/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/contam...bwork-coverup/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/meredi...ry-corruption/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/evidence-destroyed/
http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/blood-...irs-apartment/
https://knoxsollecito.wordpress.com/...ele-sollecito/
http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/myths.html
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...4#post11071314
http://www.injusticeinperugia.org/myths.html
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...4#post11071314

• The evidence suggests Meredith was killed between 9.00 pm and 10.00 pm. Raffaele was using his computer at 9.10 pm and 9.26 pm which gives them an alibi for the time Guede murdered Meredith.

• The posts below show some of the falsehoods by Vixen in her posts showing PGP have to resort to lying to argue the case for Amanda and Raffaele’s guilt. I have never heard anyone resorting to lying to argue the case for Rudy’s guilt. How is this difference explained if Amanda, Raffaele and Rudy committed the same crime?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11938562
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11942852
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...2#post11598412
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...1#post11427461
http://www.internationalskeptics.com...3#post11951893
 
Funnily enough, there was a (repeated) programme on TV here in the UK just the other day which featured a case that was - IMO - far more analogous to Kercher/Knox/Sollecito and this strange, sad phenomenon of "altruistic punishers". It was the case of the murder of a young woman called Rachel Nickell in 1992. She was killed in a copse on Wimbledon Common in London, in front of her toddler-age son, and there was home video footage of the pretty young Nickell dancing and playing and laughing - so this case was immediately seized upon by the mass media (and by a certain section of the public) in a very similar way to the way in which the Kercher murder was magnified in respect of the youth, vigour, promise and beauty of the (female) victim.

The police in the Nickell case had no forensic leads, so they brought in a forensic psychologist to do a profile of the likely offender. In many respects the profile was (well, turned out to be...) accurate; but the police - aided and abetted by some local hysteria about an oddball character named Colin Stagg who lived near the common - decided that they'd definitely found their man. They raided Stagg's apartment and arrested him, but he gave no-comment interviews and they found no physical evidence whatsoever to connect him to the murder (though he broadly matched a photofit of a character who'd been seen on the common around the time of the murder, yet Stagg claimed he'd been asleep in his apartment at that time - sound familiar....?).

The police now felt that their "golden bullet" tactic to get "justice" (remember, they were all by now utterly convinced that Stagg was the true killer of Nickell - sound familiar...?) was to elicit a confession from Stagg. To that end, they had a female police officer pose as a besotted and somewhat perverted admirer of Stagg's. She contacted him via a lonely hearts' ad that the police knew Stagg had placed, and developed a letter-writing relationship with him. Ultimately, it got to the point where she essentially suggested to Stagg that she would sleep with him (and Stagg was a virgin) if Stagg would confess to having murdered Nickell. Stagg demurred on that, but the police (and the CPS - the prosecuting authority) felt they now had enough evidence to charge and try Stagg for the murder.

Sensationally - and wholly correctly - the trial judge threw the whole case out almost immediately as soon as he learned of the way in which the police had gone about securing their "evidence" via dreadful entrapment, since without the entrapment evidence all the police had was a general likeness between Stagg and the photofit, and the fact that Stagg lived fairly close to the murder spot. Stagg walked free from court, but he walked into a different hell of his own.

And that's because nobody - not the general public, not the media, not the police, not Nickell's (decent, middle-class) parents - thought that Stagg was factually innocent. They ALL thought he was the true murderer of Nickell, and that he'd "got away with it" through a combination of luck, police incompetence and circumstance. The police publicly announced immediately that they were not looking for anyone else in relation to the murder. Nickell's parents made it explicitly clear that while they respected the judgement of the courts, "where is the justice?". Does any of THIS sound familiar.....?

Stagg went though years and years of being a national pariah, in spite of his acquittal. He was generally accepted as the murderer of that lovely vibrant beautiful young girl Rachel Nickell, and it was taken as given that he'd slipped through the net of justice. In (yet) another mirror of the Kercher case, groups were formed to seek "justice for Rachel Nickell" - and (sounds familiar....?) the sole aim of these groups was to get Stagg put back on trial and "properly" convicted for Nickell's murder.

But here's the kicker: in around 2006/2007, the police reopened the Nickell case as a cold case investigation. Advances in DNA technology meant that small semen samples from Nickell's body could now be typed and matched. And the DNA proved to be a match not to Stagg, but to a totally different man, Robert Napper. Napper was already in prison by that time for a series of rapes and a double murder within London, all of which bore interesting similarities to the Nickell murder. Indeed, one of the police thought there was a similarity back in 1992, and contacted the Nickell team, but was brushed off because the Nickell police were now convinced Stagg was their man, and Stagg had a provable alibi for the time of the other rape/murder. In fact, Napper had committed both crimes. When confronted with the DNA evidence, Napper confessed to the Nickell murder. At long last, Stagg's name was completely and indisputably cleared.

Now, can ANYONE see any similarities between this case (specifically in respect of Stagg versus Knox/Sollecito) and the Kercher case? Anyone? :rolleyes:

What happened in the Rachel Nickell and Kercher cases shows an unfortunate tendency which develops in murder cases. I feel that when deciding whether someone is guilty or innocent of a crime, you should look at the facts of a case objectively and rationally and not let emotion get in the way. Unfortunately when people are accused of a crime many people don't think rationally about the facts of a case and a hysterical lynch mob mentality develops. The result of this mentality is people will think someone is guilty of a crime regardless of the facts and suspects will be villified by the public and media. This happened with Colin Stagg and Amanda and Raffaele. People like Vixen are an example of what happens when a lynch mob mentality develops against people accused of crimes.
 
I highly doubt that the person in that photograph WAS a member of the medical staff. Such medical staff would, I am near-certain, be wearing a uniform of some sort. The person in the photo is wearing denim jeans and a casual sweater. I strongly suspect therefore that the person is a plain-clothes detective or a member of the PM's office. I also suspect there may be other captures of this person in either photos or video, which would further aid identification.

On top of this, as you correctly point out: whether the person was a medical responder or not, the potential for contamination resulting from this photo is clear and significant. At the very least, this person could very well have tracked blood via his/her shoe sole from Kercher's room to the hallway (and potentially to other rooms as well). And the very fact that two people are standing side-by-side next to Kercher's body in itself means that by definition they broke one of the important forensic rules in scenes such as this: create one single-file pathway to the body, in order to minimise the chance of damaging evidence or contaminating the scene. These people were bumbling, incompetent amateurs.

I strongly suspect, in fact, that a mixture of detectives, regular police, PM's staff and medical personnel walked all over and around and in and out of Kercher's room in a relatively unsupervised manner during 2nd November. There's also evidence (video and photographic) to show that even those wearing protective overshoes were not bothering to change their shoes properly as they moved around the cottage, and that their glove protocol was woeful and improper.

The embiggening, emboldening and enreddening above are by me to emphasize the most important ongoing point of all of this case. Idiots were working on it - idiots that were fully incompetent to handle the investigation.
 
They should have bought in Commisario Salvo Montalbano!!! He would have had it solved in a few hours!!!
 
What's interesting is why Amanda Knox covered up for Rudy Guede.

What is interesting is that for the first time since the guilt-PR campaign started that there was a 10-day hiatus in posting here.

What is also interesting is that you imply you know why your tired factoid is true. That factoid has been floated here dozens of times (like above, usually with no citation) and debunked - like Welshman did.

I guess this thread is due for another trip around the guilter merry-go-round of factoids. Factoids with no citations, or in Vixen's case links which actually demonstrate the opposite of the factoid in question.

Hey Vixen, how about reposting the pic of the outside window below Filomena's room, the one with the bars on the window, the one you said showed no bars on it!!!!!

After this thread almost died, we could make the 50th continuation!
 
The embiggening, emboldening and enreddening above are by me to emphasize the most important ongoing point of all of this case. Idiots were working on it - idiots that were fully incompetent to handle the investigation.

I remember that the 2014 film, "The Face of an Angel", made this very point numerous times. Winterbottom's film had a Frank Sfarzo-character as the Oracle at Delphi about the case, to which even the Barbie Nadeau character (played by Kate Beckinsale) conceded, "we all had to read his blog every morning just to keep up."

It was the Sfarzo-character who kept repeating, "Of course you don't understand this case, because you don't read my blog." Then he'd say that the police had been idiots.

Fuelair must have been the film's screenwriter.
 
For about a week there, I was getting a real kick out of watching how long this thread was going without getting any new comments.
 
I remember that the 2014 film, "The Face of an Angel", made this very point numerous times. Winterbottom's film had a Frank Sfarzo-character as the Oracle at Delphi about the case, to which even the Barbie Nadeau character (played by Kate Beckinsale) conceded, "we all had to read his blog every morning just to keep up."

It was the Sfarzo-character who kept repeating, "Of course you don't understand this case, because you don't read my blog." Then he'd say that the police had been idiots.

Fuelair must have been the film's screenwriter.

Sadly, I must admit I was not . On the other hand, the evidence is clear that the Italian police, forensics people and courts ********** the case up completely and royally!!!!!
 
Oh, should add that I was not the person(s) who brought up all the idiocy in the Italian police and courts early on, but as more information from a large number of sources here and in other research showed, idiocy and incompetence it was clearly loaded with.



Also I have no interest in who did what to whom, just in legal system flaws that show up so often in way too many places.
 
Last edited:
What's interesting is why Amanda Knox covered up for Rudy Guede.

Let's see here...
1) leaving Guede's visible bloody shoeprints and handprint under Meredith (since you prescribe to the "staged body" theory"),

2) pointing out Guede's feces in toilet to the police ,

3) listing "a short, black ‘South African’ who played basketball on Piazza Grimana and who had once been to the semi-basement flat when Meredith was there too" (Follain) at the questura during the Nov 5/6 interrogation ,

4) and pointing out to the police Guede's bloody footprint on the bathmat (which, if it had been Sollecito's, the two would have removed)


are all very odd ways of "covering up" for Guede. So odd as to be ludicrous.
 
Oh, should add that I was not the person(s) who brought up all the idiocy in the Italian police and courts early on, but as more information from a large number of sources here and in other research showed, idiocy and incompetence it was clearly loaded with.

Also I have no interest in who did what to whom, just in legal system flaws that show up so often in way too many places.

I concede that you never claimed it for yourself, but you very well could have been the screen writer for Winterbottom's 2014 film.

But you could also have been the ghost author of the 2015 Marasca-Bruno Supreme Court motivations report which acquitted the pair. In the following paragraph from Section 4 of that report they say.....

An objectively wavering process, whose oscillations, however, are also the result of clamorous failures, or investigative ‘amnesia’ and of culpable omissions of investigative activity. Had they been carried out these would, in all probability, have led to a picture if not of certainty, at least of tranquil reliability pointing either towards guilt or innocence of today’s accused. Such a scenario, intrinsically contradictory, constitutes in itself already a first and eloquent signal of an investigation that was never capable of reaching a conclusion beyond any reasonable doubt.​
 
There is something despicable about giving birth and then disposing of the baby stillborn or murdered in a shallow grave on unhallowed ground.

That child had a right to medical care.

What medical care could have been given to a stillborn? "Unhallowed ground"? Only if you believe there is any such thing as "hallowed ground". People used to bury babies in their yards all the time. When my grandmother miscarried at 5 months, she buried it in her yard as did her own mother who lost several babies prematurely. Give the sanctimonious judgments a rest, will ya?
 
I concede that you never claimed it for yourself, but you very well could have been the screen writer for Winterbottom's 2014 film.

But you could also have been the ghost author of the 2015 Marasca-Bruno Supreme Court motivations report which acquitted the pair. In the following paragraph from Section 4 of that report they say.....

​

I like it!!!!! Well said, but not quite my style (of course, I assume this a translation from Italian)...........
 
I like it!!!!! Well said, but not quite my style (of course, I assume this a translation from Italian)...........

Yup, from the Italian.

While the few remaining nutters are trying to tell the world that the M/B report proved that Knox had "rubbed the victim's blood from her hands," or that "Knox had covered up for Rudy,"......

.... the M/B report says about as plainly as it can that the flaws, omissions and clamorous failures of the original investigation meant that, the "investigation that was never capable of reaching a conclusion..."

The nutters then add that the M/B report thought of them as almost, but nit quite guilty. Even though the report from 2015 says as plain as day, that the "investigation that was never capable of reaching a conclusion".

The nutters keep missing that so here it is again. The "investigation that was never capable of reaching a conclusion."
 
The police collected a sample of suspected blood from Amanda's pillow on Dec. 18, 2007. Does anyone know if this sample tested positive for her blood?
 
The police collected a sample of suspected blood from Amanda's pillow on Dec. 18, 2007. Does anyone know if this sample tested positive for her blood?
Polizia Scientifica RTIGF Report
It's Rep 172, mentioned on page 16 (of the pdf):
Rep.172 - Nr. Porzione di federa di cuscino prelevata dalla stanza in uso a KNOX Amanda (già Rep.T) pagg.160 A.F./215 R;
According to the same report, that sample tested positive for nothing:
page 215:
picture.php

...

and just for the record: that "presumed blood" on her nightstand (Rep. 174) also tested positive for nothing:
picture.php

...summarized on page 53 of Dottoressa Stefanoni's presentation
picture.php
 
Last edited:
Except of course he should have written "non-una-vera-dottoressa Stefanoni" ;) :p

Every time someone tries to defend the work of the original investigation/prosecution, they should be forced to deal with the main thesis of the Marasca-Bruno, Supreme Court reason for acquitting the pair:

(it was an) "investigation that was never capable of reaching a conclusion..."​
They should also have to deal with Maneula Comodi's incredible investigative words and implied assumptions on that Dec 2017 YouTube video that Machiavelli, from this very forum here, kindly supplied. More specifically, Comodi treating the bra-clasp lying uncollected on the murder-room floor for 46 days as perfectly normal.

The investigative bungling in the Kercher murder case - the first and main victims being Meredith and her family - goes far beyond the Italian practise that anyone with a Bachelor's Degree (in Italy) can refer to themselves as "dottoressa".
 
KrissyG has been busy penning an idiotic article on TJMK again. I skimmed the article as anything more made me fluctuate between nausea and hysterical laughing. It's akin to watching Trump; vomit or laugh? A favorite was "two anti-black demonizers" under a pic of Prof. Hampikian and Knox. We were also treated to yet more claims of the mafia's influence in the case.
Someone should really inform KrissyG that it's "mafiosa" or "mafia" not "mafias".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom