LondonJohn
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- May 12, 2010
- Messages
- 21,467
Did you mean to write:
There's only one actual reason why the prevailing PoV on ISF is towards pro-acquittal/pro-innocence: it's because that is the only PoV which is logically, ethically and legally defensible. The pro-acquittal* position is the CORRECT position. The pro-acquittalconviction position is the WRONG position. Just as there are correct and wrong positions to take on things like the Moon landings, 9/11, the Ramsey murder and so on.
I would quibble with your use of "innocent". As I (and perhaps others) have pointed out, the usual assumption, when there is no credible evidence that someone has committed a crime, is that that person is "innocent" of committing that crime. This is a different concept from the formal "presumption of innocence" that follows an acquittal, since there can be wrongful acquittals. For example, a jury could acquit because it misinterprets a presentation of evidence that otherwise - if it had been better explained by the prosecution - would decisively support a conviction
Aha yes of course I meant to write "pro-guilt" or "pro-conviction" in the third sentence of that paragraph! Late-night brain freeze.....
And so far as the "innocent" issue goes, I'm referring to factual, metaphysical innocence. In the case that we're discussing here, nobody except for Knox, Sollecito and Guede has any chance of knowing with factual certainty whether or not Knox or Sollecito (or Guede, for that matter) participated in the Kercher murder - since none of them can prove indisputably that they did NOT participate in the murder.
But of course law and ethics - as well as sheer logic - dictates that this is a moot point when it comes to assessing guilt of any act (criminal or not). In many ways it's another expression of Russell's teapot analogy, and the whole doctrine of unfalsifiability.
Put simply: unless an accused person on trial can PROVE his/her factual innocence (e.g. through an unimpeachable alibi, or the reliable testimony of a living victim or witness), then no court - nor any other person - can conclude that the person is factually innocent. But, again as has been discussed here many times before, people accused of crimes have zero requirement to prove their innocence (though obviously it's an overwhelming advantage to them if they can do so...), and nor should it detract at all from their perceived culpability if they cannot prove their innocence.
As I've written about many times before here, a knife murder took place a few years ago about 3/4 mile away from where I live, at around 3am. There were no witnesses, and the knife was never found. Now, I was asleep alone in bed at the time (or so I claim!!), and there is no CCTV at or near to the street door of my apartment. So I cannot PROVE that I was not the person who committed the murder. And, what's more, no other person (nor court, had I ever ended up standing trial for the murder for some reason) would be able to state that I was factually innocent of the murder.