Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
Did you mean to write:

There's only one actual reason why the prevailing PoV on ISF is towards pro-acquittal/pro-innocence: it's because that is the only PoV which is logically, ethically and legally defensible. The pro-acquittal* position is the CORRECT position. The pro-acquittal conviction position is the WRONG position. Just as there are correct and wrong positions to take on things like the Moon landings, 9/11, the Ramsey murder and so on.
I would quibble with your use of "innocent". As I (and perhaps others) have pointed out, the usual assumption, when there is no credible evidence that someone has committed a crime, is that that person is "innocent" of committing that crime. This is a different concept from the formal "presumption of innocence" that follows an acquittal, since there can be wrongful acquittals. For example, a jury could acquit because it misinterprets a presentation of evidence that otherwise - if it had been better explained by the prosecution - would decisively support a conviction


Aha yes of course I meant to write "pro-guilt" or "pro-conviction" in the third sentence of that paragraph! Late-night brain freeze.....

And so far as the "innocent" issue goes, I'm referring to factual, metaphysical innocence. In the case that we're discussing here, nobody except for Knox, Sollecito and Guede has any chance of knowing with factual certainty whether or not Knox or Sollecito (or Guede, for that matter) participated in the Kercher murder - since none of them can prove indisputably that they did NOT participate in the murder.

But of course law and ethics - as well as sheer logic - dictates that this is a moot point when it comes to assessing guilt of any act (criminal or not). In many ways it's another expression of Russell's teapot analogy, and the whole doctrine of unfalsifiability.

Put simply: unless an accused person on trial can PROVE his/her factual innocence (e.g. through an unimpeachable alibi, or the reliable testimony of a living victim or witness), then no court - nor any other person - can conclude that the person is factually innocent. But, again as has been discussed here many times before, people accused of crimes have zero requirement to prove their innocence (though obviously it's an overwhelming advantage to them if they can do so...), and nor should it detract at all from their perceived culpability if they cannot prove their innocence.

As I've written about many times before here, a knife murder took place a few years ago about 3/4 mile away from where I live, at around 3am. There were no witnesses, and the knife was never found. Now, I was asleep alone in bed at the time (or so I claim!!), and there is no CCTV at or near to the street door of my apartment. So I cannot PROVE that I was not the person who committed the murder. And, what's more, no other person (nor court, had I ever ended up standing trial for the murder for some reason) would be able to state that I was factually innocent of the murder.
 
One has to wonder why not when the person standing next to the woman is in anti-contamination gear and the a pile shoe covers is next to the body. I guess the 118 Medical Staff were incapable of contaminating the scene?


I highly doubt that the person in that photograph WAS a member of the medical staff. Such medical staff would, I am near-certain, be wearing a uniform of some sort. The person in the photo is wearing denim jeans and a casual sweater. I strongly suspect therefore that the person is a plain-clothes detective or a member of the PM's office. I also suspect there may be other captures of this person in either photos or video, which would further aid identification.

On top of this, as you correctly point out: whether the person was a medical responder or not, the potential for contamination resulting from this photo is clear and significant. At the very least, this person could very well have tracked blood via his/her shoe sole from Kercher's room to the hallway (and potentially to other rooms as well). And the very fact that two people are standing side-by-side next to Kercher's body in itself means that by definition they broke one of the important forensic rules in scenes such as this: create one single-file pathway to the body, in order to minimise the chance of damaging evidence or contaminating the scene. These people were bumbling, incompetent amateurs.

I strongly suspect, in fact, that a mixture of detectives, regular police, PM's staff and medical personnel walked all over and around and in and out of Kercher's room in a relatively unsupervised manner during 2nd November. There's also evidence (video and photographic) to show that even those wearing protective overshoes were not bothering to change their shoes properly as they moved around the cottage, and that their glove protocol was woeful and improper.
 
One has to wonder why not when the person standing next to the woman is in anti-contamination gear and the a pile shoe covers is next to the body. I guess the 118 Medical Staff were incapable of contaminating the scene?

To be fair: I think both person on the picture are wearing shoe covers.
 
I highly doubt that the person in that photograph WAS a member of the medical staff. Such medical staff would, I am near-certain, be wearing a uniform of some sort. The person in the photo is wearing denim jeans and a casual sweater. I strongly suspect therefore that the person is a plain-clothes detective or a member of the PM's office. I also suspect there may be other captures of this person in either photos or video, which would further aid identification.

On top of this, as you correctly point out: whether the person was a medical responder or not, the potential for contamination resulting from this photo is clear and significant. At the very least, this person could very well have tracked blood via his/her shoe sole from Kercher's room to the hallway (and potentially to other rooms as well). And the very fact that two people are standing side-by-side next to Kercher's body in itself means that by definition they broke one of the important forensic rules in scenes such as this: create one single-file pathway to the body, in order to minimise the chance of damaging evidence or contaminating the scene. These people were bumbling, incompetent amateurs.

I strongly suspect, in fact, that a mixture of detectives, regular police, PM's staff and medical personnel walked all over and around and in and out of Kercher's room in a relatively unsupervised manner during 2nd November. There's also evidence (video and photographic) to show that even those wearing protective overshoes were not bothering to change their shoes properly as they moved around the cottage, and that their glove protocol was woeful and improper.

Yes, but they did prevent the taking of body temperature in order to not disturb evidence, so there's that... :rolleyes:
 
To be fair: I think both person on the picture are wearing shoe covers.

Wilson, that one picture doesn't really have enough detail to say definitively one way or another, but my initial take on it was I was looking at the sole and heel of the shoe, a distinction you can't typically make out when a bootie is over the shoe. Do you have other photos of this person that perhaps makes it clearer?
 
What Napoleoni testified to about the 118 Medical Staff

These are the things that Napoleoni told the Massei court about the 118 Medical Staff who attended to the victim in situ.

- She said that she prints from police/118 Medical staff had been requested because everyone had been unsure whether or not Postal Police Battistelli had entered the room (to ascertain death) without protective clothing.

- Battistelli's "sneakers" had been photographed and i.d.'ed​
Then this:

Napoleoni's testimony page 229 AmandaKnoxCase.com said:
TESTE - Io ho indossato… no, io ho indossato dei calzari e dei
guanti sterili.
PUBBLICO MINISTERO - nel primo ingresso che ha fatto.
TESTE - Sì, nel primo ingresso perché trattando reati contro
la persona e violenza sessuale, noi li abbiamo con noi.
Li portiamo.
PUBBLICO MINISTERO - ecco, tutti quelli che sono entrati
avevano questa..?
TESTE - Sì, sì, certo. Sì, sì. Adesso tranne, no, il personale
del 118.

WITNESS - I wore ... no, I wore sandals and shorts
sterile gloves.
PUBLIC MINISTRY - in the first entry he did.
WITNESS - Yes, in the first entry because dealing with crimes against
the person and sexual violence, we have them with us.
We bring them.
PUBLIC MINISTRY - here, all those who have entered
did they have this ..?
WITNESS - Yes, yes, of course. Yes, yes. Now except, no, the staff
of 118.​
Yet in Dec 2017 at the so-called "debate", Assistant Prosecutor Maneula Comodi says in that YouTube video that there was nothing unusual about leaving the bra-clasp in the murder room for 46 days, because she'd assumed it was sealed and sterile.
 
Last edited:
To be fair: I think both person on the picture are wearing shoe covers.

I agree with TruthCalls; I noticed the sole and heel distinction, too. Additionally, the shoe covers were a light blue (see the pile), not black.

EDIT: On closer inspection, I think the "pile of shoe covers" is actually a piece of clothing. The similarity of color to shoe covers was confusing.
 
Last edited:
In the Dec 18, 2007 police video, both Meredith's and Amanda's black table lamps are shown still on the desk in Meredith's room. Further proof that AK's lamp was not seen as important evidence by the police.
 
I’ve been following the case of 18 year old Brooke Skylar Richardson who is accused of killing her newborn baby and burying it in the backyard of her parents home. The Richardson family claims that the baby was stillborn. The following excerpts from a March 14 Cosmopolitan article indicate that a demonization frenzy (similar to the Knox/Sollecito case on a much smaller scale) was created by statements made by the Warren County Ohio Sheriff's Office which have since been somewhat walked back—i.e., the body of the dead baby wasn’t burned.

The following two excerpts are from the Cosmopolitan piece:

EXCERPT #1
The outrage first took hold on Facebook. Within days of Skylar's arrest and same-day release on bond, a closed Facebook group called ‘Justice For Baby Doe in Carlisle, Ohio’ popped up, and another called ‘Justice For Baby Carlisle.’ "Our Goal here is to Support Justice for Baby Carlisle," the original description of the second group read. "Baby Carlisle is the newborn baby who was born Alive, then murdered, burned, and its charred bones buried in a shallow grave behind the 'Monster Mom's' House that belongs to her parents." (The names and descriptions of the groups have since been changed.)

EXCERPT #2
The groups now have 1,396 and 952 members respectively. One of the admins, Terri Schneider, parks her car outside the Richardson home, armed with bottles of Coke and crackers, so she can take pictures of the family coming and going to post on the group page. "White SUV just pulled out of the garage," she posted on July 24 at 10:37 pm. Schneider did not return my request for comment, and Tiffany Cooke, the administrator of the other page, replied, "I don't want to be a part of your ******** story."
- - - - -
Does Peggy Ganong come to mind?



I found this statement from a friend of Skylar Richardson to be quite perceptive: "The part that really bugs me the most about this whole thing is that …people are in love with the idea of Skylar being a bad person even though she is not. …They want entertainment, and it's sick because it's her life that's entertaining them.”
- - - - -
Does Vixen come to mind?
 
Last edited:
Sept79, it's the exact frame of mind that we've all seen from so many PGP. They revel in having someone to hate and demonize. I think it makes them feel somehow better about themselves. Sick.

I saw so many similarities between the two cases: people who made up their minds about guilt based on misinformation they read in the press, people who love a salacious story and who see themselves as "justice warriors" for a victim, and a prosecutor who spreads lies.

The "murdered" and "charred bones" details came from an August 4 press conference, called by Warren County Prosecutor David Fornshell. (The video has since been removed from his professional Facebook page.) Fornshell, who publicly identifies as "extraordinarily pro-life," announced that Skylar had been indicted for five felony charges: aggravated murder, involuntary manslaughter, child endangerment, tampering with evidence, and gross abuse of a corpse. He said he'd decided not to seek the death penalty, but the aggravated murder charge he's seeking could mean life in prison, as well as additional lengthy sentences for the other charges.

"Sometime during the night of May 6 to May 7, 2017, she did give birth to a newborn infant and that she caused the death of that infant," Fornshell says in the video. "To be frank with you, I'm not sure that we ever will be able to provide to you the exact medical cause of death, and the reason is because the child was after death burned and subsequently buried." He later adds that, because they couldn't determine a cause of death, he cannot not say with certainty that the baby was not burned alive.

Completely false information. The baby was not burned, there were no "charred bones". Note the added for shock and totally speculated "he cannot not say with certainty that the baby was not burned alive". It's reminiscent of the Knox "showered in a blood covered bathroom" and other false stories the police/prosecutor released.

In the same video, Fornshell implicates some involvement by Skylar's mother, Kim Richardson. "Skylar and her family, particularly her mother, were pretty obsessed with external appearances," he says. "You have a situation where she's a cute recent high school graduate, she was a cheerleader... I think that kind of perception is one that Skylar wanted to perpetuate and her mother wanted to perpetuate. …A lot of this, from my perspective in viewing this evidence, came down to a situation where if members of the community were to find out that the Richardson girl was pregnant and perhaps gave birth, and even if after giving birth gave that child up for adoption, that was something that simply was not going to be accepted in that household, at least by Skylar and her mother."

Notice how he makes accusations that are rank speculation about Sklyar's mother and for the motives. Nothing of this comes from actual evidence. It is all what the prosecutor has dreamed up in his own "extremely pro-life" mind. Shades of "Halloween rituals" and "sex game gone wrong" Mignini nonsense!

People are attacking Skylar's mother, against whom there is no evidence of any wrongdoing, just as they attacked Amanda's and Raffaele's families.

People who have a psychological need to demonize and spew hatred toward people they don't know for their own entertainment hide behind their "justice for" websites. It's nothing more than a way for them to feel morally superior and vent their own ugly demons.
 
Last edited:
altruistic punishment

These people sound like "altruistic punishers," a phrase that I first recall seeing here. However, I am not sure that the two cases are entirely comparable. Let us assume for the sake of argument that the baby was stillborn. Would it still not have been a crime to bury the body as they did? Also, the prosecutor made the charge of burning the body, although the factual basis of this looks uncertain at the moment. It is not as if the altruistic punishers made that part up entirely, although they may have embellished it.
 
Last edited:
These people sound like "altruistic punishers," a phrase that I first recall seeing here. However, I am not sure that the two cases are entirely comparable. Let us assume for the sake of argument that the baby was stillborn. Would it still not have been a crime to bury the body as they did?

Yes, a stillborn birth must be reported but it certainly is a minor crime compared to being accused of murder. They could also charge her with "abuse of a corpse" although I think that's stretching since she only buried the body and did not burn it .

A question I have is, if only skeletal remains were found, how do they know the baby wasn't stillborn as Skylar claims? I don't see how they could possibly convict her of murder when they can't prove the baby wasn't stillborn.
 
These people sound like "altruistic punishers," a phrase that I first recall seeing here. However, I am not sure that the two cases are entirely comparable. Let us assume for the sake of argument that the baby was stillborn. Would it still not have been a crime to bury the body as they did? Also, the prosecutor made the charge of burning the body, although the factual basis of this looks uncertain at the moment. It is not as if the altruistic punishers made that part up entirely, although they may have embellished it.


Funnily enough, there was a (repeated) programme on TV here in the UK just the other day which featured a case that was - IMO - far more analogous to Kercher/Knox/Sollecito and this strange, sad phenomenon of "altruistic punishers". It was the case of the murder of a young woman called Rachel Nickell in 1992. She was killed in a copse on Wimbledon Common in London, in front of her toddler-age son, and there was home video footage of the pretty young Nickell dancing and playing and laughing - so this case was immediately seized upon by the mass media (and by a certain section of the public) in a very similar way to the way in which the Kercher murder was magnified in respect of the youth, vigour, promise and beauty of the (female) victim.

The police in the Nickell case had no forensic leads, so they brought in a forensic psychologist to do a profile of the likely offender. In many respects the profile was (well, turned out to be...) accurate; but the police - aided and abetted by some local hysteria about an oddball character named Colin Stagg who lived near the common - decided that they'd definitely found their man. They raided Stagg's apartment and arrested him, but he gave no-comment interviews and they found no physical evidence whatsoever to connect him to the murder (though he broadly matched a photofit of a character who'd been seen on the common around the time of the murder, yet Stagg claimed he'd been asleep in his apartment at that time - sound familiar....?).

The police now felt that their "golden bullet" tactic to get "justice" (remember, they were all by now utterly convinced that Stagg was the true killer of Nickell - sound familiar...?) was to elicit a confession from Stagg. To that end, they had a female police officer pose as a besotted and somewhat perverted admirer of Stagg's. She contacted him via a lonely hearts' ad that the police knew Stagg had placed, and developed a letter-writing relationship with him. Ultimately, it got to the point where she essentially suggested to Stagg that she would sleep with him (and Stagg was a virgin) if Stagg would confess to having murdered Nickell. Stagg demurred on that, but the police (and the CPS - the prosecuting authority) felt they now had enough evidence to charge and try Stagg for the murder.

Sensationally - and wholly correctly - the trial judge threw the whole case out almost immediately as soon as he learned of the way in which the police had gone about securing their "evidence" via dreadful entrapment, since without the entrapment evidence all the police had was a general likeness between Stagg and the photofit, and the fact that Stagg lived fairly close to the murder spot. Stagg walked free from court, but he walked into a different hell of his own.

And that's because nobody - not the general public, not the media, not the police, not Nickell's (decent, middle-class) parents - thought that Stagg was factually innocent. They ALL thought he was the true murderer of Nickell, and that he'd "got away with it" through a combination of luck, police incompetence and circumstance. The police publicly announced immediately that they were not looking for anyone else in relation to the murder. Nickell's parents made it explicitly clear that while they respected the judgement of the courts, "where is the justice?". Does any of THIS sound familiar.....?

Stagg went though years and years of being a national pariah, in spite of his acquittal. He was generally accepted as the murderer of that lovely vibrant beautiful young girl Rachel Nickell, and it was taken as given that he'd slipped through the net of justice. In (yet) another mirror of the Kercher case, groups were formed to seek "justice for Rachel Nickell" - and (sounds familiar....?) the sole aim of these groups was to get Stagg put back on trial and "properly" convicted for Nickell's murder.

But here's the kicker: in around 2006/2007, the police reopened the Nickell case as a cold case investigation. Advances in DNA technology meant that small semen samples from Nickell's body could now be typed and matched. And the DNA proved to be a match not to Stagg, but to a totally different man, Robert Napper. Napper was already in prison by that time for a series of rapes and a double murder within London, all of which bore interesting similarities to the Nickell murder. Indeed, one of the police thought there was a similarity back in 1992, and contacted the Nickell team, but was brushed off because the Nickell police were now convinced Stagg was their man, and Stagg had a provable alibi for the time of the other rape/murder. In fact, Napper had committed both crimes. When confronted with the DNA evidence, Napper confessed to the Nickell murder. At long last, Stagg's name was completely and indisputably cleared.

Now, can ANYONE see any similarities between this case (specifically in respect of Stagg versus Knox/Sollecito) and the Kercher case? Anyone? :rolleyes:
 
We were discussing this exact case in another forum I belong to. Yes, it bears a striking resemblance to the Knox/Sollecito case. I wonder if Vixen believes Stagg is guilty?
 
We were discussing this exact case in another forum I belong to. Yes, it bears a striking resemblance to the Knox/Sollecito case. I wonder if Vixen believes Stagg is guilty?


Well, nobody can believe Stagg is guilty in 2018, since it's now proven beyond all reasonable doubt that Napper was the real killer (unless there are any genuine nutcases who believe that Stagg and Napper teamed up.......).

But it would be entirely unsurprising to find a certain shared psychology between a) those who believed, between around 1994 and 2005, that Stagg was the true Nickell murderer who got away with it; and b) those who have believed, since around 2008, that Knox and Sollecito truly participated in Kercher's murder and got away with it. And it would be even less surprising to find a strong shared psychology between those who actively campaigned for the vilification and condemnation of Stagg and Knox/Sollecito.

Of course, the critical difference is that Stagg can now shut up those who vilified him and campaigned against him for so long, since he can now effectively prove that he had nothing to do with the murder (though imagine what would have happened had the police never found the DNA trace of Napper....). By contrast, Knox and Sollecito will never be able to prove to the pro-guilt nutters that they had nothing to do with the Kercher murder (unless, that is, Guede one day makes a reliable full confession to being the only assailant - something that I personally believe he will never ever do, even though I strongly suspect he WAS the sole assailant).
 
Well, nobody can believe Stagg is guilty in 2018, since it's now proven beyond all reasonable doubt that Napper was the real killer (unless there are any genuine nutcases who believe that Stagg and Napper teamed up.......).
But it would be entirely unsurprising to find a certain shared psychology between a) those who believed, between around 1994 and 2005, that Stagg was the true Nickell murderer who got away with it; and b) those who have believed, since around 2008, that Knox and Sollecito truly participated in Kercher's murder and got away with it. And it would be even less surprising to find a strong shared psychology between those who actively campaigned for the vilification and condemnation of Stagg and Knox/Sollecito.

Of course, the critical difference is that Stagg can now shut up those who vilified him and campaigned against him for so long, since he can now effectively prove that he had nothing to do with the murder (though imagine what would have happened had the police never found the DNA trace of Napper....). By contrast, Knox and Sollecito will never be able to prove to the pro-guilt nutters that they had nothing to do with the Kercher murder (unless, that is, Guede one day makes a reliable full confession to being the only assailant - something that I personally believe he will never ever do, even though I strongly suspect he WAS the sole assailant).

I wouldn't be so sure about that. Donald Trump still believes the Central Park Five are guilty even after DNA identification and the confession of the real killer exonerated them.

Guede will never confess and tell the truth. There is nothing to gain from it but much to gain from not doing so as there are people who believe his lies. Look at his FB page and those who think he was just the poor victim of racism.
 
I’ve been following the case of 18 year old Brooke Skylar Richardson who is accused of killing her newborn baby and burying it in the backyard of her parents home. The Richardson family claims that the baby was stillborn. The following excerpts from a March 14 Cosmopolitan article indicate that a demonization frenzy (similar to the Knox/Sollecito case on a much smaller scale) was created by statements made by the Warren County Ohio Sheriff's Office which have since been somewhat walked back—i.e., the body of the dead baby wasn’t burned.

The following two excerpts are from the Cosmopolitan piece:

EXCERPT #1
The outrage first took hold on Facebook. Within days of Skylar's arrest and same-day release on bond, a closed Facebook group called ‘Justice For Baby Doe in Carlisle, Ohio’ popped up, and another called ‘Justice For Baby Carlisle.’ "Our Goal here is to Support Justice for Baby Carlisle," the original description of the second group read. "Baby Carlisle is the newborn baby who was born Alive, then murdered, burned, and its charred bones buried in a shallow grave behind the 'Monster Mom's' House that belongs to her parents." (The names and descriptions of the groups have since been changed.)

EXCERPT #2
The groups now have 1,396 and 952 members respectively. One of the admins, Terri Schneider, parks her car outside the Richardson home, armed with bottles of Coke and crackers, so she can take pictures of the family coming and going to post on the group page. "White SUV just pulled out of the garage," she posted on July 24 at 10:37 pm. Schneider did not return my request for comment, and Tiffany Cooke, the administrator of the other page, replied, "I don't want to be a part of your ******** story."
- - - - -
Does Peggy Ganong come to mind?



I found this statement from a friend of Skylar Richardson to be quite perceptive: "The part that really bugs me the most about this whole thing is that …people are in love with the idea of Skylar being a bad person even though she is not. …They want entertainment, and it's sick because it's her life that's entertaining them.”
- - - - -
Does Vixen come to mind?


I know nothing about Skylar and her baby, but it has to be noted that crimes against babies and small children stir up strong emotions in people.

I absolutely loathe and hate Maxine Carr and Ian Huntley, for example. ETA I should add, I wouldn't ever stalk these people. If I came across them, I'd probably give them a pointed glare (as per Paddington Bear).
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't be so sure about that. Donald Trump still believes the Central Park Five are guilty even after DNA identification and the confession of the real killer exonerated them.

Guede will never confess and tell the truth. There is nothing to gain from it but much to gain from not doing so as there are people who believe his lies. Look at his FB page and those who think he was just the poor victim of racism.

What's interesting is why Amanda Knox covered up for Rudy Guede.
 
We were discussing this exact case in another forum I belong to. Yes, it bears a striking resemblance to the Knox/Sollecito case. I wonder if Vixen believes Stagg is guilty?

In am abroad at the moment, so haven't had a chance to see the Rachel Nickell programme, which i believe I set to 'record' before I left.

It was one of the most heinous crimes in recent times, that, together with Jill Dando, or even Jo Cox, innocent defenceless people killed just by stepping out into a public place.
 
These people sound like "altruistic punishers," a phrase that I first recall seeing here. However, I am not sure that the two cases are entirely comparable. Let us assume for the sake of argument that the baby was stillborn. Would it still not have been a crime to bury the body as they did? Also, the prosecutor made the charge of burning the body, although the factual basis of this looks uncertain at the moment. It is not as if the altruistic punishers made that part up entirely, although they may have embellished it.

There is something despicable about giving birth and then disposing of the baby stillborn or murdered in a shallow grave on unhallowed ground.

That child had a right to medical care.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom