Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
Laugh of the Day from TJMK Front Page:



Wow. I especially like the "proven history of anger and abuse" line. No research I've done has ever revealed any such "fact".

Here's another Quennell line that's side-splittingly funny, albeit an oldie but a goodie. Talk about being self-unaware:



Posted by Peter Quennell on 03/14/09 at 02:00 AM

TJMK have spent the last decade vilifying and demonising Amanda and are now claiming they have always been fair to Amanda. Yet another just when I thought PGP could not stoop any lower in their gross stupidity moment.
 
TJMK have spent the last decade vilifying and demonising Amanda and are now claiming they have always been fair to Amanda. Yet another just when I thought PGP could not stoop any lower in their gross stupidity moment.

Every time one of the nutters bleats about the calunnia conviction, it's a reminder that they've never made a convincing argument about AK's and RS's involvement in murder.

It's a tacit admission that at the very least Raffaele had never been involved because none of the satellite prosecutions against him had ever stuck, even in the goofy Italian system.

Finally, it's one thing to maintain a decade-long smear campaign against someone who you believe murdered someone else. It's quite another to do the same against someone you believe once told a single lie a decade before! That's how nutty the nutters have become.

And that's **before** considering that the conviction had been for **calunnia** which only nutters believe is equivalent to a North American felony.
 
Every time one of the nutters bleats about the calunnia conviction, it's a reminder that they've never made a convincing argument about AK's and RS's involvement in murder.

It's a tacit admission that at the very least Raffaele had never been involved because none of the satellite prosecutions against him had ever stuck, even in the goofy Italian system.

Finally, it's one thing to maintain a decade-long smear campaign against someone who you believe murdered someone else. It's quite another to do the same against someone you believe once told a single lie a decade before! That's how nutty the nutters have become.

And that's **before** considering that the conviction had been for **calunnia** which only nutters believe is equivalent to a North American felony.

I saw just the other day a certain someone claim for the umpteenth time that calunnia is the equivalent in the US to obstruction of justice. No matter how many times that is debunked, it's repeated over and over. It's not a matter of ignorance; it's a matter of willful blindness. The need to believe is so strong, it overrides everything else... including the truth.
 
I have personally been working with computers since before there was windows at all. Vixen is simply foisting the utter bollocks that works on other sites here. Not a word of it is true. File wipe and disk wipe code predates windows by a long way. Adding a fancy windows interface to it does not in any way change what it actually does. Anyone who thinks so has no clue about how computers actually work.

Acbytesla has been rigorously correct in this matter, Vixen has been rigorously wrong, much like her tail-gunner vision of cell masts. There is no way to sugar coat that level of ignorance.
 
I saw just the other day a certain someone claim for the umpteenth time that calunnia is the equivalent in the US to obstruction of justice. No matter how many times that is debunked, it's repeated over and over. It's not a matter of ignorance; it's a matter of willful blindness. The need to believe is so strong, it overrides everything else... including the truth.

Knox has talked at umpteen law schools and bar associations. The nutters' assumption is that every breathing lawyer in N.A. is so afraid of the "Marriott PR machine" that not one of them is willing to see calunnia as anything other than a peculiar Italian "honour crime" that has no equivalent on this side of the Atlantic.

Wow, Knox is such an all powerful witch, that whole law schools prevent their students from bringing up the subject on pain of expulsion!

The notion that both American and Canadian law communities are able to see Italian calunnia for what it is completely eludes the nutters.
 
Knox has talked at umpteen law schools and bar associations. The nutters' assumption is that every breathing lawyer in N.A. is so afraid of the "Marriott PR machine" that not one of them is willing to see calunnia as anything other than a peculiar Italian "honour crime" that has no equivalent on this side of the Atlantic.

Wow, Knox is such an all powerful witch, that whole law schools prevent their students from bringing up the subject on pain of expulsion!

The notion that both American and Canadian law communities are able to see Italian calunnia for what it is completely eludes the nutters.

It's all they have left. They cling to it like Jack Dawson clinging to the floating door in Titanic. Without it, they'd go down, down, down......

For all their claims that Amanda is a felon in the US, they've yet to produce a criminal record for her which would be publicly available if it existed. That should tell them something, but noooooooooo.
 
Last edited:
It's all they have left. They cling to it like Jack Dawson clinging to the floating door in Titanic. Without it, they'd go down, down, down......

Not sure if you saw some of the more recent posts by Quennell in the comments section of the 'debate' YouTube that Mach posted, but knowing how much entertainment you get out of his delusional rants I thought I'd share them here;

Quennell said:
The great untalked-about is the cocaine. All sides knew it was a factor. Maori sarcastically talked about it at trial - the Sollecito team really did not like Knox. The defenses wanted to use it as a factor (which I believe it was - Knox on a high through to arrest explains a lot) for a reduced charge; but Curt Knox refused. He really gambled Knox's future there - and in fact lost; the Sollecitos then had to bend 3 courts. Knox sure picked the father from hell as she pretty well says in her book. Good on Edda for taking him to court at least twice.

and

Quennell said:
The Dec 17 interrogation (Knox's first) really was about Dr Mignini giving Knox a chance to admit it was a hazing that went too far and blame the drugs in part. The Kerchers were okay with that. Knox came close but her lawyers stopped the show. Knox was trusting back then, not the paranoid we know today, and in her book describes how she had to be taught to demonize Mignini early in 2008. That was the core reason for demonizing Mignini; he and Knox were actually getting along too well and Knox came real close to changing her tune - as she said she wanted to do in Capanne.

You just can't make this stuff up!
 
Not sure if you saw some of the more recent posts by Quennell in the comments section of the 'debate' YouTube that Mach posted, but knowing how much entertainment you get out of his delusional rants I thought I'd share them here;



and



You just can't make this stuff up!


The trouble is that he does make this stuff up! How conveniently he "forgets" the negative for narcotics hair tests that were done. Some facts are just too inconvenient for his "down the rabbit hole" view of things. The solution? Just pretend they don't exist. It's easier that way.

It's truly pitiful that Quennell and some of his fellow whackos not only need to hate and demonize RS and AK, but they need to extend that hatred and demonization to their families. That is truly sick.
 
Last edited:
The trouble is that he does make this stuff up! How conveniently he "forgets" the negative for narcotics hair tests that were done. Some facts are just too inconvenient for his "down the rabbit hole" view of things. The solution? Just pretend they don't exist. It's easier that way.

It's truly pitiful that Quennell and some of his fellow whackos not only need to hate and demonize RS and AK, but they need to extend that hatred and demonization to their families. That is truly sick.

Well yeah - HE does - but I meant his claims are so unbelievable that I couldn't be making the story up about his claims. Whatever... it was entertaining, no?
 
Well yeah - HE does - but I meant his claims are so unbelievable that I couldn't be making the story up about his claims. Whatever... it was entertaining, no?

Yes, Quennell and TJMK are entertaining now that the case is over and done with. Talk about group just begging for a psychological study.
I know other PGP who think that AK and RS are guilty but who can discuss the evidence and give sensible and reasonable arguments. They don't need to resort to the kind of nonsense Quennell and his band of loonies resort to. In fact, one recently called NvdL's books garbage.
 
Well yeah - HE does - but I meant his claims are so unbelievable that I couldn't be making the story up about his claims. Whatever... it was entertaining, no?


Ugh I woudn't pay any time of day (save for the purposes of either a) entertainment, or b) a second-order bemusement about how/why people could allow themselves to get so deeply sucked in to supporting such an untenable and vindictive position....) to what's written on either TJMK or PMF. After all, if any of their "commentators" really did have valid, testable facts or opinions, then it would be pretty incumbent of them (assuming of course that they had a scintilla of intellectual honesty and intellectual rigour) to air them in an (effectively) open forum - of which I'd suggest ISF is by far the most obvious and appropriate (though of course IA/IIP also allows anyone to register and comment, provided they are not deliberately trying to do so under false pretences).

Of course, the mantra of nearly every pro-guilt commentator is that ISF (or JREFF as-was) was "overrun" by pro-acquittal/pro-innocence commentators (some like to add in the spicy rider that this was with the aid of the powers that be here haha), to the extent that no pro-guilt commentator could ever get a fair hearing here. But I contend that this is simply not true. In fact (IMO), the only reason why pro-guilt commentators don't hang around here (or hang around and get their views robustly attacked...) is that their "arguments" are either without merit, or based on false/misleading "facts", or are entirely indefensible.

There's only one actual reason why the prevailing PoV on ISF is towards pro-acquittal/pro-innocence: it's because that is the only PoV which is logically, ethically and legally defensible. The pro-acquittal* position is the CORRECT position. The pro-acquittal position is the WRONG position. Just as there are correct and wrong positions to take on things like the Moon landings, 9/11, the Ramsey murder and so on.

In the case of the Kercher murder, there's only one position which bears proper logical scrutiny given the available evidence (and lack of evidence): 1) there is not one piece of credible, reliable evidence pointing to the participation of Knox and/or Sollecito in Kercher's murder; 3) there is sufficient credible, reliable evidence to prove BARD that Guede was involved in Kercher's murder; and c) all of the available reliable, credible evidence is wholly consistent with Guede committing the murder alone. So taken as a whole, the only rational conclusions to reach are that a) Guede almost certainly committed the attack and murder of Kercher alone (and there's a convincing narrative to support that part of the conclusion); and b) Knox and Sollecito almost certainly had nothing whatsoever to do with Kercher's murder (and again there's a convincing narrative to support that part).

And on the criminal slander issue, once again there's only one convincing narrative (the only one that is supported by the available reliable, credible evidence) and only one convincing conclusion to be drawn from that: that Knox was improperly/unlawfully coerced and bullied into confirming to the police what they already "knew" - that she (Knox) had met with Lumumba to take him to the cottage where he'd assaulted and killed Kercher, and that she had subsequently instructed Sollecito to lie to police about the two of them spending the whole of that evening/night alone together in Sollecito's apartment. And all against the backdrop of clear evidence to indicate that the police/PM already considered Knox a criminal suspect (of, at the very least, the serious crimes of lying to police and protecting a murderer, or at the most of being a direct participant in the murder itself), but that they employed the (apparently widely-used but utterly unlawful) tactic of refraining from declaring Knox to be a formal suspect, in order to allow them to extract a confession without the need to inform her of her rights, or that she was a suspect, or any access to legal counsel (or, in Italy, the fact that the police themselves would not even have been allowed to question Knox as a suspect - only the PM would have been allowed to do so, and only in the presence of Knox's lawyer).

But, y'know, maybe some of the more prominent pro-guilt commentators from those sites - the ones who hide inside their walled gardens and make unchallenged (not only unchallenged: cheer-led!) declarative statements about this case - might feel moved to come to ISF and debate those statements, and their general opinions and conclusions about this case. I know that I personally absolutely welcome being challenged on my opinions at any time (indeed, I have challenged myself on many aspect of this case - and there's zero reason why I want/need Knox or Sollecito to be acquitted etc). But at the same time, I know I've come to my conclusions (as, I imagine, have the majority of pro-acquittal commentators) based on a rational, critical-thinking approach to the evidence in this case. I also know that I've never seen a pro-guilt argument which cannot be successfully nullified (at the least) or refuted with reference to the known evidence (along, of course, with a proper assessment of the credibility/reliability of any given piece of evidence). Nevertheless, my mind is not closed on anything.


* I am not keen on the pro-innocence position since it's a position of faith rather than logic/fact/evidence - and for that matter it's absolutely not necessary (nor is it even possible) to conclude that Knox and Sollecito MUST have had nothing to do with the murder. Just as would be neither necessary nor possible to conclude that my allegorical Mr and Mrs Bianchi (who lived in the apartments opposite the girls' cottage, and who claimed they'd spent the evening/night of the murder watching TV and having an early night, but without any way of unimpeachably verifying their location) MUST have had nothing to do with the murder, had they for some reason found themselves on trial....
 
Last edited:
Yes, Quennell and TJMK are entertaining now that the case is over and done with. Talk about group just begging for a psychological study.
I know other PGP who think that AK and RS are guilty but who can discuss the evidence and give sensible and reasonable arguments. They don't need to resort to the kind of nonsense Quennell and his band of loonies resort to. In fact, one recently called NvdL's books garbage.

If they're sensible then surely they must acknowledge the case had real weaknesses? I've never encountered any PGP that think the case was anything less than bullet proof.

If I were PGP I would be pissed off that Rudy wasn't forced to testify, the semen stain wasn't tested, the knife wasn't opened, the tile floors weren't chipped off and taken for better testing, the clasp wasn't collected on day 1, etc etc.

It's incomprehensible to me that 100% of the PGP are comfortable with the evidence as presented in Massei's court. It kind of makes our case for us. If their side wasn't filled exclusively with faith based fanatics, they would have had the occasional skeptic and critic of the prosecution's case.
 
Yes, Quennell and TJMK are entertaining now that the case is over and done with. Talk about group just begging for a psychological study.


Yes, exactly this.



I know other PGP who think that AK and RS are guilty but who can discuss the evidence and give sensible and reasonable arguments. They don't need to resort to the kind of nonsense Quennell and his band of loonies resort to. In fact, one recently called NvdL's books garbage.


I can obviously have a lot more respect for any pro-guilt commentators who eschew - or, better still, call out - the strange histrionics and Baghdad-Bob-style nonsense of the likes of Quennell. Nonetheless, I cannot describe any pro-guilt argument as "sensible" or "reasonable", since I think it's impossible to make an argument for guilt that is based in sense or reason (though of course that's not to say that people cannot make pro-guilt arguments in a sensible or reasonable manner, which I suspect is what you meant). I just don't think it's possible for any critical thinker to believe that both "sides" in this case have a certain amount of validity to their views (as might be possible, for example, in debates over, say, austerity economics, or who the best ever heavyweight boxer was....).
 
If they're sensible then surely they must acknowledge the case had real weaknesses? I've never encountered any PGP that think the case was anything less than bullet proof.

If I were PGP I would be pissed off that Rudy wasn't forced to testify, the semen stain wasn't tested, the knife wasn't opened, the tile floors weren't chipped off and taken for better testing, the clasp wasn't collected on day 1, etc etc.

It's incomprehensible to me that 100% of the PGP are comfortable with the evidence as presented in Massei's court. It kind of makes our case for us. If their side wasn't filled exclusively with faith based fanatics, they would have had the occasional skeptic and critic of the prosecution's case.


Very true. I think the closest any pro-guilt argument has got to this is to take the position that Knox and Sollecito were the extraordinarily lucky beneficiaries of some (totally understandable and acceptable, in their view) omissions in the police investigation.

But when you see even Mignini and Comodi still trying to argue in that recent video that the bra clasp was effectively DELIBERATELY left on the floor of Kercher's room for over six weeks, you realise just how bad the scale of the problem is - not only among practically every single pro-guilt commentator, but also among the original prosecutors in the case who are still ludicrously trying to shore up their disintegrating reputations by claiming a) they did absolutely nothing wrong, b) their exemplary work was more than enough to prove the guilt of Knox and Sollecito, and c) the ultimate acquittals of Knox and Sollecito must have been down to either the incompetence of the Supreme Court or as-yet-undiscovered other factors.....
 
If they're sensible then surely they must acknowledge the case had real weaknesses? I've never encountered any PGP that think the case was anything less than bullet proof. If I were PGP I would be pissed off that Rudy wasn't forced to testify, the semen stain wasn't tested, the knife wasn't opened, the tile floors weren't chipped off and taken for better testing, the clasp wasn't collected on day 1, etc etc.

It's incomprehensible to me that 100% of the PGP are comfortable with the evidence as presented in Massei's court. It kind of makes our case for us. If their side wasn't filled exclusively with faith based fanatics, they would have had the occasional skeptic and critic of the prosecution's case.

I have met a very few. One PGP, who belongs to those I previously mentioned and whom I respect, believes that acquittal was the correct decision to based on the evidence even though she believes the two were involved in the murder to some degree.
 
Yes, exactly this.






I can obviously have a lot more respect for any pro-guilt commentators who eschew - or, better still, call out - the strange histrionics and Baghdad-Bob-style nonsense of the likes of Quennell. Nonetheless, I cannot describe any pro-guilt argument as "sensible" or "reasonable", since I think it's impossible to make an argument for guilt that is based in sense or reason (though of course that's not to say that people cannot make pro-guilt arguments in a sensible or reasonable manner, which I suspect is what you meant). I just don't think it's possible for any critical thinker to believe that both "sides" in this case have a certain amount of validity to their views (as might be possible, for example, in debates over, say, austerity economics, or who the best ever heavyweight boxer was....).

Yes, that is exactly what I meant.
 
Ugh I woudn't pay any time of day (save for the purposes of either a) entertainment, or b) a second-order bemusement about how/why people could allow themselves to get so deeply sucked in to supporting such an untenable and vindictive position....) to what's written on either TJMK or PMF. After all, if any of their "commentators" really did have valid, testable facts or opinions, then it would be pretty incumbent of them (assuming of course that they had a scintilla of intellectual honesty and intellectual rigour) to air them in an (effectively) open forum - of which I'd suggest ISF is by far the most obvious and appropriate (though of course IA/IIP also allows anyone to register and comment, provided they are not deliberately trying to do so under false pretences).

Of course, the mantra of nearly every pro-guilt commentator is that ISF (or JREFF as-was) was "overrun" by pro-acquittal/pro-innocence commentators (some like to add in the spicy rider that this was with the aid of the powers that be here haha), to the extent that no pro-guilt commentator could ever get a fair hearing here. But I contend that this is simply not true. In fact (IMO), the only reason why pro-guilt commentators don't hang around here (or hang around and get their views robustly attacked...) is that their "arguments" are either without merit, or based on false/misleading "facts", or are entirely indefensible.

There's only one actual reason why the prevailing PoV on ISF is towards pro-acquittal/pro-innocence: it's because that is the only PoV which is logically, ethically and legally defensible. The pro-acquittal* position is the CORRECT position. The pro-acquittal position is the WRONG position. Just as there are correct and wrong positions to take on things like the Moon landings, 9/11, the Ramsey murder and so on.
In the case of the Kercher murder, there's only one position which bears proper logical scrutiny given the available evidence (and lack of evidence): 1) there is not one piece of credible, reliable evidence pointing to the participation of Knox and/or Sollecito in Kercher's murder; 3) there is sufficient credible, reliable evidence to prove BARD that Guede was involved in Kercher's murder; and c) all of the available reliable, credible evidence is wholly consistent with Guede committing the murder alone. So taken as a whole, the only rational conclusions to reach are that a) Guede almost certainly committed the attack and murder of Kercher alone (and there's a convincing narrative to support that part of the conclusion); and b) Knox and Sollecito almost certainly had nothing whatsoever to do with Kercher's murder (and again there's a convincing narrative to support that part).

And on the criminal slander issue, once again there's only one convincing narrative (the only one that is supported by the available reliable, credible evidence) and only one convincing conclusion to be drawn from that: that Knox was improperly/unlawfully coerced and bullied into confirming to the police what they already "knew" - that she (Knox) had met with Lumumba to take him to the cottage where he'd assaulted and killed Kercher, and that she had subsequently instructed Sollecito to lie to police about the two of them spending the whole of that evening/night alone together in Sollecito's apartment. And all against the backdrop of clear evidence to indicate that the police/PM already considered Knox a criminal suspect (of, at the very least, the serious crimes of lying to police and protecting a murderer, or at the most of being a direct participant in the murder itself), but that they employed the (apparently widely-used but utterly unlawful) tactic of refraining from declaring Knox to be a formal suspect, in order to allow them to extract a confession without the need to inform her of her rights, or that she was a suspect, or any access to legal counsel (or, in Italy, the fact that the police themselves would not even have been allowed to question Knox as a suspect - only the PM would have been allowed to do so, and only in the presence of Knox's lawyer).

But, y'know, maybe some of the more prominent pro-guilt commentators from those sites - the ones who hide inside their walled gardens and make unchallenged (not only unchallenged: cheer-led!) declarative statements about this case - might feel moved to come to ISF and debate those statements, and their general opinions and conclusions about this case. I know that I personally absolutely welcome being challenged on my opinions at any time (indeed, I have challenged myself on many aspect of this case - and there's zero reason why I want/need Knox or Sollecito to be acquitted etc). But at the same time, I know I've come to my conclusions (as, I imagine, have the majority of pro-acquittal commentators) based on a rational, critical-thinking approach to the evidence in this case. I also know that I've never seen a pro-guilt argument which cannot be successfully nullified (at the least) or refuted with reference to the known evidence (along, of course, with a proper assessment of the credibility/reliability of any given piece of evidence). Nevertheless, my mind is not closed on anything.


* I am not keen on the pro-innocence position since it's a position of faith rather than logic/fact/evidence - and for that matter it's absolutely not necessary (nor is it even possible) to conclude that Knox and Sollecito MUST have had nothing to do with the murder. Just as would be neither necessary nor possible to conclude that my allegorical Mr and Mrs Bianchi (who lived in the apartments opposite the girls' cottage, and who claimed they'd spent the evening/night of the murder watching TV and having an early night, but without any way of unimpeachably verifying their location) MUST have had nothing to do with the murder, had they for some reason found themselves on trial....

Did you mean to write:

There's only one actual reason why the prevailing PoV on ISF is towards pro-acquittal/pro-innocence: it's because that is the only PoV which is logically, ethically and legally defensible. The pro-acquittal* position is the CORRECT position. The pro-acquittal conviction position is the WRONG position. Just as there are correct and wrong positions to take on things like the Moon landings, 9/11, the Ramsey murder and so on.
I would quibble with your use of "innocent". As I (and perhaps others) have pointed out, the usual assumption, when there is no credible evidence that someone has committed a crime, is that that person is "innocent" of committing that crime. This is a different concept from the formal "presumption of innocence" that follows an acquittal, since there can be wrongful acquittals. For example, a jury could acquit because it misinterprets a presentation of evidence that otherwise - if it had been better explained by the prosecution - would decisively support a conviction
 
Last edited:
Monica Napoleoni testified to the Massei court that the 118 Medical Staff did not wear anti-contamination garb.

One has to wonder why not when the person standing next to the woman is in anti-contamination gear and the a pile shoe covers is next to the body. I guess the 118 Medical Staff were incapable of contaminating the scene?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom