Well yeah - HE does - but I meant his claims are so unbelievable that I couldn't be making the story up about his claims. Whatever... it was entertaining, no?
Ugh I woudn't pay any time of day (save for the purposes of either a) entertainment, or b) a second-order bemusement about how/why people could allow themselves to get so deeply sucked in to supporting such an untenable and vindictive position....) to what's written on either TJMK or PMF. After all, if any of their "commentators" really did have valid, testable facts or opinions, then it would be pretty incumbent of them (assuming of course that they had a scintilla of intellectual honesty and intellectual rigour) to air them in an (effectively) open forum - of which I'd suggest ISF is by far the most obvious and appropriate (though of course IA/IIP also allows anyone to register and comment, provided they are not deliberately trying to do so under false pretences).
Of course, the mantra of nearly every pro-guilt commentator is that ISF (or JREFF as-was) was "overrun" by pro-acquittal/pro-innocence commentators (some like to add in the spicy rider that this was with the aid of the powers that be here haha), to the extent that no pro-guilt commentator could ever get a fair hearing here. But I contend that this is simply not true. In fact (IMO), the only reason why pro-guilt commentators don't hang around here (or hang around and get their views robustly attacked...) is that their "arguments" are either without merit, or based on false/misleading "facts", or are entirely indefensible.
There's only one
actual reason why the prevailing PoV on ISF is towards pro-acquittal/pro-innocence: it's because that is the
only PoV which is logically, ethically and legally defensible. The pro-acquittal* position is the CORRECT position. The pro-acquittal position is the WRONG position. Just as there are correct and wrong positions to take on things like the Moon landings, 9/11, the Ramsey murder and so on.
In the case of the Kercher murder, there's only one position which bears proper logical scrutiny given the available evidence (and lack of evidence): 1) there is not one piece of credible, reliable evidence pointing to the participation of Knox and/or Sollecito in Kercher's murder; 3) there is sufficient credible, reliable evidence to prove BARD that Guede was involved in Kercher's murder; and c) all of the available reliable, credible evidence is wholly consistent with Guede committing the murder alone. So taken as a whole, the only rational conclusions to reach are that a) Guede almost certainly committed the attack and murder of Kercher alone (and there's a convincing narrative to support that part of the conclusion); and b) Knox and Sollecito almost certainly had nothing whatsoever to do with Kercher's murder (and again there's a convincing narrative to support that part).
And on the criminal slander issue, once again there's only one convincing narrative (the only one that is supported by the available reliable, credible evidence) and only one convincing conclusion to be drawn from that: that Knox was improperly/unlawfully coerced and bullied into confirming to the police what they already "knew" - that she (Knox) had met with Lumumba to take him to the cottage where he'd assaulted and killed Kercher, and that she had subsequently instructed Sollecito to lie to police about the two of them spending the whole of that evening/night alone together in Sollecito's apartment. And all against the backdrop of clear evidence to indicate that the police/PM already considered Knox a criminal suspect (of, at the very least, the serious crimes of lying to police and protecting a murderer, or at the most of being a direct participant in the murder itself), but that they employed the (apparently widely-used but utterly unlawful) tactic of refraining from declaring Knox to be a formal suspect, in order to allow them to extract a confession without the need to inform her of her rights, or that she was a suspect, or any access to legal counsel (or, in Italy, the fact that the police themselves would not even have been allowed to question Knox as a suspect - only the PM would have been allowed to do so, and only in the presence of Knox's lawyer).
But, y'know, maybe some of the more prominent pro-guilt commentators from those sites - the ones who hide inside their walled gardens and make unchallenged (not only unchallenged: cheer-led!) declarative statements about this case - might feel moved to come to ISF and debate those statements, and their general opinions and conclusions about this case. I know that I personally absolutely welcome being challenged on my opinions at any time (indeed, I have challenged myself on many aspect of this case - and there's zero reason why I want/need Knox or Sollecito to be acquitted etc). But at the same time, I know I've come to my conclusions (as, I imagine, have the majority of pro-acquittal commentators) based on a rational, critical-thinking approach to the evidence in this case. I also know that I've never seen a pro-guilt argument which cannot be successfully nullified (at the least) or refuted with reference to the known evidence (along, of course, with a proper assessment of the credibility/reliability of any given piece of evidence). Nevertheless, my mind is not closed on anything.
* I am not keen on the pro-innocence position since it's a position of faith rather than logic/fact/evidence - and for that matter it's absolutely not necessary (nor is it even
possible) to conclude that Knox and Sollecito MUST have had nothing to do with the murder. Just as would be neither necessary nor possible to conclude that my allegorical Mr and Mrs Bianchi (who lived in the apartments opposite the girls' cottage, and who claimed they'd spent the evening/night of the murder watching TV and having an early night, but without any way of unimpeachably verifying their location) MUST have had nothing to do with the murder, had they for some reason found themselves on trial....