Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
Myth Busting about the 'Fried Hard Drives'

TEN MYTHS BUSTED!

Let's bust a few myths about the 'fried' hard drives.

Myth No.1

1. The disks were 'fried' by a geek working alone who was then too embarrassed to admit his calamity.

WRONG. The defense IT forensics expert was there to witness the copying (cloning).

From Mirca Gregori Testimony
Quote:
There was also a defense technician, if I remember correctly was the engineer Formenti.

:gasp:

So, there was a witness from the defense team, Formenti

The undersigned writer on 11/02/2008, at 15:00, in the CNR head office at number 137, Viale del Policlinico, Rome, following an arranged meeting with Professor Bernaschi, initially visually inspected the equipment the subject of examination which revealed that said equipment, a Toshiba-brand laptop property of Miss Amanda Knox was in an optimum state of general use. It was observed that the external shell of the Toshiba laptop was without any scrapes and bumps and in good condition and the internal hard disk drive (HDD) unit – usually installed, internally connected, covered with a guard cover forming part of the shell by means of a screw-fixed mechanical covering and an integral part of any laptop – had been dismounted. The computer appeared almost totally covered by a layer of chemical material designed to reveal fingerprints, a white-coloured powder for revealing latent fingerprints. From a declaration made by Professor Bernaschi it appears that the latter had received the computer without any internal disk, inasmuch as it had been dismounted and removed from the apparatus during prior phases of police investigative taskforce and expert activities (see annexed photo no 3).

I was advised by Professor Bernaschi that the latter had been also tasked with examining the disks and associated laptops belonging to the victim, Meredith Kercher, and to Mr Raffaele Sollecito, those also under seizure following investigations by the police taskforce. [page]

The laptops belonging to Ms Kercher and to Mr R Sollecito likewise resulted in being physically separated from their internal drives inasmuch as they were already dismounted prior. Ms Kercher’s laptop is an Apple brand and at the time had not been subject to joint verification activity. As a consequence of the physical states of the disks and of the activity relating to the recovery of their contents, successive evaluative activity was effected. Professor Bernaschi has declared to having already attempted to recover the contents of the three disks the subject of examination, prior to the session on 11 February 2008, with negative results for the two disks belonging to the laptops of the victim and of Mr R Sollecito and partially positive for the Toshiba disk of Miss Knox.http://themurderofmeredithkercher.com/Defence_Computer_Expert_Report_(English)#Contents

Ooops! Don't you just hate it when I find the info that shows you are wrong.
 
Last edited:
Ooops! Don't you just hate it when I find the info that shows you are wrong.

Of course Vixen also ignores the fact that the drives were removed by the Mobile Squad and dusted for fingerprints. When the Postal Police got the laptops the drives were removed and covered in white dusting powder. Since many dusting powders are metallic (many are made from aluminum) it is entirely possible a short occurred as a result of the dust. What else did the MS do with those drives before delivering them to the Postal Police?

BTW, Vixen's (OK, the fake wiki) response to #7 is laughable. Yes, the disks were dead because the logic boards were fried. I wonder which of the idiot's running the fake wiki came up with that one!

ETA: I stand corrected.. after re-reading the statement it was the computer, not the HDD, that was covered with the powder. But it's still true the drives were removed and underwent testing prior to the Postal Police receiving them.
 
Last edited:
From the Defense Computer Consultant about the hard drives.

Technical opinions
1. Technical opinion on the CTU operation
As for the CTU operation, professor Bernaschi has been transparent, technically correct and aimed at the recovery of the contents The conjoint activity has been technically transparent, logically coherent and objectively aimed at resolving the problem of recovering data from the fixed disks of the three laptop units. Even the choice of three of the most well-known and quoted data recovery and salvage companies in Europe has been correct.


2. Technical opinion on forcings or tamperings
Considering the physical state of the Toshiba laptop, as revealed on 11 February and then successively, in my opinion it has not suffered any forcing or tampering, except for the dismounting of the internal drive and the [finger]print-revealing activity.
No signs of forcing appear on the screws that hold the laptop together and the same uniformity in the layer of material, chemical material designed to reveal finger prints, evidences the integrity of the apparatus. It not being possible to proceed with the reading of the files that contain the activity history, we are able to refer only to the visible physical state and what was revealed during the expert examination activity and no evaluation can be effected on possible forcing open, or software intrusions on the contents.

8 [sic; read: 3]. Technical opinion on the unrecoverability of the data
Following the tests carried out, by various interveners, it therefore appears that the Toshiba disk belonging to Miss A Knox’s Toshiba-brand laptop was damaged with problems evident in the electronic board, which resulted as being inactive, just like the other two. While the contents of two of the three disks have been recovered, following the Krollontrak company’s diagnosis, the third disk seems to have been also damaged in its component mechanics, while CBL Data’s and Recovery Tech’s diagnoses confirm that the third disk has been damaged in its electronic component. In reality, the damaged component is the electronic board, where an integrated circuit sits, sometimes referred to as “BIOS”, containing the binary code that allows access to the data, calibration, writing and reading. This technical specification belongs to the Toshiba manufacturing house, a proprietary [page] technology. The electronic board and the binary data contents of the disk being inextricably linked and intertwined, and the Toshiba logic board being damaged, it has therefore been impossible to recover it. Only a possible intervention by the parent company or its licentiate, by means of supplying the binary/BIOS code, would be able to justify a further intervention. It is however truly incomprehensible that three hard drive units, differing among themselves as to capacity, produced by among the most quoted manufacturers, belonging to and operating on three different laptops, could all three end up damaged in a similar manner and all three react in the same manner to an attempt at reading the data by an external disk controller run by the Operating System residing on an IBM PC furnished by the IAC/CNR Institute and of relative utility for data recovery.

On the CTU side, recovery utilities compatible with the Microsoft Windows Operating System and belonging to the “Open Source” category were used, to guarantee an efficacious recovery of data.

Hypotheses
8. General Hypotheses
As previously described, all the electronic boards of the three disks are damaged and inactive and have surely suffered an electric shock, even though not appearing physically damaged. How could an anomalous event like that unleashed at Technical Evaluations and with the corresponding Observations have occurred?

I have shown in the TECHNICAL CHARACTERISTICS that the disk of a laptop is usually supplied with a positive tension of 5 volts (+5V) and one of 0V which is also the reference for the mass logic line and takes advantage of the “IDE” standard to interface to the disk controller that resides on the computer’s motherboard where the Processor is.
The disks under examination are generally installed in laptops in appropriate compartments with obligatory connections that prevent connection errors by means of keyed connectors or restricted access, whilst when they are freely connected to a USB connector it is possible that the connector could be misaligned such that the disks in question present the particularity of having 4 pins free for selection in the case of multiple connections, and then the lining up between the electrical connections and the logical ones is altered and a short circuit is produced.
Another hypothesis is the possibility of trying to connect to another type of connector, taking advantage of the current directly feeding the internal disks of a fixed computer (PC).

I find it interesting that there was no evidence of tampering of any kind and nary a fingerprint. They didn't find Raffaele's fingerprints on those drives.

Vixen would have you believe that

1. Raffaele, a computer science major after a vicious killing removed 3 hard drives from three different laptops of different manufacture without leaving any trace and short circuited the logic boards internal to the hard drives even though someone with that level of computer science education would KNOW that this method would be highly unreliable at destroying the data.
2. That he would choose this UNRELIABLE method despite the availability of well known and easily obtainable inexpensive (FREE) software applications that would RELIABLY SHRED any files that might be of concern.

I have yet to read that a single person from the prosecution EVER suggest that Raffaele damaged these hard drives. This demonstrates just how far off on the Koo Koo branch Vixen has crawled on this one.

I DON'T believe the Postal police or ANYONE deliberately damaged these drives. There was a time I was convinced the police did it. But it is the unreliability of how these drives were damaged that makes it unlikely.

Vixen has a total misunderstanding of how low DC voltages can damage electronic circuitry without any visible signs of it happening. A tiny tiny shock can damage a circuit board.

Static electricity is the enemy of all electronic circuitry. This is why computer components are packaged in static elelectricity bags and proper installation procedures include static mats and grounding straps.

The Postal Police are NEVER going to admit they were the cause. Particularly when there is no actual evidence ...only a logical analysis of the events. All the Postal police know is when they attempted to clone the drives, they couldn't. So it either happened prior to their disassembling and removing the hard drives or in their process of attempting to clone the drives.

As I mentioned before I don't believe Raffaele damaged the drives because of the following reasons.

1. It is highly unlikely there was any evidence that would incriminate anyone. Raffaele had known Amanda for a week. I doubt they were sending emails back and forth planning a murder, especially since neither was very proficient at the other's native language. They lived a couple of blocks away from each other and had been spending every night together. Why email?
2. No incriminating evidence was found on the drives where the data was recovered.
3. No incriminating evidence presented from the ISP of suspicious searches or page hits.
4. No evidence has ever been presented that the drives had ever been physically pulled from the laptops prior to the Postal police's actions.

While I can't say with 100 percent certainty that the Postal police was the cause of the damage, I see no evidence that logically points to another possible source for the damage.

Vixen's wild speculation that Raffaele did this is ridiculously absurd.
 
Last edited:
Of course Vixen also ignores the fact that the drives were removed by the Mobile Squad and dusted for fingerprints. When the Postal Police got the laptops the drives were removed and covered in white dusting powder. Since many dusting powders are metallic (many are made from aluminum) it is entirely possible a short occurred as a result of the dust. What else did the MS do with those drives before delivering them to the Postal Police?

BTW, Vixen's (OK, the fake wiki) response to #7 is laughable. Yes, the disks were dead because the logic boards were fried. I wonder which of the idiot's running the fake wiki came up with that one!

ETA: I stand corrected.. after re-reading the statement it was the computer, not the HDD, that was covered with the powder. But it's still true the drives were removed and underwent testing prior to the Postal Police receiving them.

You stole my thunder a little bit. Not sure about the likelihood that the fingerprint dust caused the problem but what it does show is no evidence that Raffaele had removed the hard drives.
 
You stole my thunder a little bit. Not sure about the likelihood that the fingerprint dust caused the problem but what it does show is no evidence that Raffaele had removed the hard drives.

Well, I'm kinda backpedaling on the dust angle since I can't find any indication that the HDD's themselves were dusted for prints. The other thing that makes it unlikely is that in the report it clearly states it was a titanium based powder, not aluminum, and titanium doesn't conduct electricity very well. It would be interesting, however, to know if they were checked for prints and what the results were.

On a lighter note... I wanted to say how laughable I found myth #7 to be. Specifically, the "myth" is "The Postale Police were grossly incompetent". The evidence to contradict this was that they know what an electrical shock is. Say what?! Conversely, I did read the Milani report and he provides plenty of evidence that shows the Postale Police were incompetent. I'm shocked the fake wiki would miss something like that.
 
The logic boards were all damaged, in a way that is primarily consistent with an incorrect power adapter being connected (either at the wrong DC voltage and/or in the opposite polarity).

And as I've pointed out before, if these hard drives HAD all been destroyed by a guilty Sollecito (and as I and others also point out, Sollecito absolutely would have had to have known that there were far, far less incriminating and easier ways of destroying data on hard drives than this, and in any case why would he possibly have wanted/needed to destroy the hard drives of Kercher and Romanelli?), and had the police IT guys been competent and professional, they would have been able to confirm and report that the drives were fried even before the police got their hands on them.

The very fact that the police never even made such a claim is, in and of itself IMO, very strong evidence that a) it was the police themselves who fried the drives (in exactly the same way), and a) the police knew full well that it was they who had (at the very least) made an incompetent mistake in having done so. So the optimum strategy for the police at that time was not to outright lie and claim that the drives were destroyed before they even arrived in the lab; and likewise, they were not about to 'fess up and admit that it was they who'd fried the drives. No, their strategy was simply to shrug and say "Oh look, all these drives are fried. Oh well, that's that, never mind, too bad....". Which, IMO, makes them as implicitly guilty as a puppy standing next to a pile of poo.

From the Defense Computer Consultant about the hard drives.



I find it interesting that there was no evidence of tampering of any kind and nary a fingerprint. They didn't find Raffaele's fingerprints on those drives.

Vixen would have you believe that

1. Raffaele, a computer science major after a vicious killing removed 3 hard drives from three different laptops of different manufacture without leaving any trace and short circuited the logic boards internal to the hard drives even though someone with that level of computer science education would KNOW that this method would be highly unreliable at destroying the data.
2. That he would choose this UNRELIABLE method despite the availability of well known and easily obtainable inexpensive (FREE) software applications that would RELIABLY SHRED any files that might be of concern.

I have yet to read that a single person from the prosecution EVER suggest that Raffaele damaged these hard drives. This demonstrates just how far off on the Koo Koo branch Vixen has crawled on this one.

I DON'T believe the Postal police or ANYONE deliberately damaged these drives. There was a time I was convinced the police did it. But it is the unreliability of how these drives were damaged that makes it unlikely.

Vixen has a total misunderstanding of how low DC voltages can damage electronic circuitry without any visible signs of it happening. A tiny tiny shock can damage a circuit board.

Static electricity is the enemy of all electronic circuitry. This is why computer components are packaged in static elelectricity bags and proper installation procedures include static mats and grounding straps.

The Postal Police are NEVER going to admit they were the cause. Particularly when there is no actual evidence ...only a logical analysis of the events. All the Postal police know is when they attempted to clone the drives, they couldn't. So it either happened prior to their disassembling and removing the hard drives or in their process of attempting to clone the drives.

As I mentioned before I don't believe Raffaele damaged the drives because of the following reasons.

1. It is highly unlikely there was any evidence that would incriminate anyone. Raffaele had known Amanda for a week. I doubt they were sending emails back and forth planning a murder, especially since neither was very proficient at the other's native language. They lived a couple of blocks away from each other and had been spending every night together. Why email?
2. No incriminating evidence was found on the drives where the data was recovered.
3. No incriminating evidence presented from the ISP of suspicious searches or page hits.
4. No evidence has ever been presented that the drives had ever been physically pulled from the laptops prior to the Postal police's actions.

While I can't say with 100 percent certainty that the Postal police was the cause of the damage, I see no evidence that logically points to another possible source for the damage.

Vixen's wild speculation that Raffaele did this is ridiculously absurd.

So, the conclusion, based on the evidence as presented in testimony from both the prosecution and defense experts, must be that the information on the hard drives was not damaged or destroyed.

The logic boards controlling the hard drives were damaged and this rendered the information that remained on the drives unreadable by the Italian police "experts". Replacing the logic boards with the proper proprietary equivalents by a true expert, which may have required the assistance of the manufacturer, would have made it possible to read the information on the hard drives.

The prosecution and the Italian courts chose not to do this, although it was requested by the defense. This refusal by the Italian courts to grant a reasonable request by the defense for the production of evidence was yet another violation of Italian law and the European Convention of Human Rights, as detailed in ECHR case-law.

Other examples of such violations of defense rights to evidence include but are not limited to the refusal of the prosecution and the Italian courts to provide the raw DNA data - which is essential for the meaningful interpretation of DNA profiles - and to provide biochemical testing for semen and DNA analysis of the stain - presumed to be semen based on the defense's fluorescence testing - on the pillow found under Kercher's body.
 
Last edited:
Myth Busting about the 'Fried Hard Drives'

TEN MYTHS BUSTED!

Let's bust a few myths about the 'fried' hard drives.

Myth No.1

1. The disks were 'fried' by a geek working alone who was then too embarrassed to admit his calamity.

WRONG. The defense IT forensics expert was there to witness the copying (cloning).

From Mirca Gregori Testimony


:gasp:

So, there was a witness from the defense team, Formenti.

Myth No. 2

2. 'The postale police were grossly incompetent'

Raff's advocate, Giulia Bongiorno, wants to know if they understand what an electric shock (surge) is:



Myth No.3

3. 'The IT postal police used the wrong equipment.'

Amanda's advocate, Carlo Dalla Vedova is the purveyor of this particular myth.



In other words, the postal police were highly experienced and followed the same procedure, using the same equipment. Their results were consistent. The probability of three laptops at random all frying is vanishingly remote.

Myth No. 4

'The postal police did not understand voltage'

Again this is a Dalla Vedova suggestion, defending Knox:




Myth No 5

'The postale police accidentally applied the wrong voltage'

Carlo Vedova cross-examining Marco Trotta, postal police:



So, we see it is not possible for the police to have 'fried them' accidentally. (In any case, Formenti for the defense was a witness.)

Myth No. 6

'The postal police did not deny they fried the disks'

This myth flies out of the window as Trotta did categorically deny it:




Myth No.7

'The reason no data was retrieved from the laptops was because the disks were fried.'

In fact, nowhere is 'frying' stated as the technical reason for the police being unable to retrieve data. The reason was simple: the disks were dead.



Or, put another way:



Myth No.8

'It must have been Rudy who damaged Filomena Romanelli's Laptop'

This laptop was collected by Filomena from the crime scene and was also damaged. To explain how come this is so, if it is the police who are responsible for mass damage of hard drives, the explanation must be 'it was Rudy what dunnit'.

Gregori testified that this laptop's condition was how he received it, and was also dead.



Myth No. 9

'The postal police did their own thing so no-one knows what they got up to'

Fact is, IT forensics is their department and they were perfectly competent, as witnessed by Mr Formenti:



Myth No. 10

'How the three laptops got fried is entirely the fault of the incompetent postal police who used the wrong voltage and lacked the integrity to own up to their errors.'

Fact is:
  • The defense was there to witness the clonng at all stages
  • The postal police have a set procedure, with set equipment, which works consistently.
  • It is *impossible* for them to apply the incorrect voltage, even with an adaptor.
  • The laptops were tested in the order of: Lumumba, second: his was NOT damaged at all.
  • The laptops were not 'fried', they were merely dead.
  • Filomena's was also dead.
  • The postal police were asked in open court if they were responsible for the damage.
  • The postal police categorically denied they 'fried' the hard disks.
  • The claim 'the postal police fried three laptops' is 100% a PR hoax.

Source:http://themurderofmeredithkercher.com/Marco_Trotta's_Testimony

We have been through this before. The defence witness is literally that. All they do is witness. They are not allowed to stop the prosecution from making errors, tell them how to do the test better, or do the tests themselves. Their function is just to see that the prosecution carry out a test and that the results of that test are what they subsequently present in court. They are not even allowed to record the testing, nor to have copies of the results. The presence of the defence witness is no guarantee that the test was done correctly.

(It is not even clear that they would have observed any error, when you are in other people's laboratories you assume they know how to use their equipment! The witness will mostly focus on correct identification of the hard discs and clones, and security of the evidence chain. The witness may not even have been present when an attempt was made to interrogate the clone, going through the files on a cloned disc will be hours of work, so I suspect no one pays a witness to sit around for days watching someone work. Indeed it is not necessary, since the witness is only needed for non reproducible testing which interrogating clones is not.)
 
We have been through this before. The defence witness is literally that. All they do is witness. They are not allowed to stop the prosecution from making errors, tell them how to do the test better, or do the tests themselves. Their function is just to see that the prosecution carry out a test and that the results of that test are what they subsequently present in court. They are not even allowed to record the testing, nor to have copies of the results. The presence of the defence witness is no guarantee that the test was done correctly.

(It is not even clear that they would have observed any error, when you are in other people's laboratories you assume they know how to use their equipment! The witness will mostly focus on correct identification of the hard discs and clones, and security of the evidence chain. The witness may not even have been present when an attempt was made to interrogate the clone, going through the files on a cloned disc will be hours of work, so I suspect no one pays a witness to sit around for days watching someone work. Indeed it is not necessary, since the witness is only needed for non reproducible testing which interrogating clones is not.)

You pretty much nailed it. This is boring mundane work. I doubt a defense representative would really be watching this procedure very closely. You kind of assume the tech knows how to attach the cables to his device.
 
So, the conclusion, based on the evidence as presented in testimony from both the prosecution and defense experts, must be that the information on the hard drives was not damaged or destroyed.

Not quite. The data was recovered on 2 of 3 of the computers. 3 out of 4 if you count Filomena's. Recovering the data from Amanda's PC would have required cooperation from Toshiba which was never pursued although the Defense requested the court to order it. The court saw it as a fruitless task and did not.
 
Are you just screwing with me? Please say yes.

Well my initial DOS comment was a joke in that people usually run stuff from Windows nowadays. I was pretending to be a holdout from the 90s. However, Windows' current DOS is not the actual OS like under Win 3.1, so it isn't quite the same thing, or as reliable.

As for formatting your HDD, that's my usual solution to malware. Takes only 30 minutes for everything to be back to normal, so there's little reason for me not to take that road. :)
 
Well my initial DOS comment was a joke in that people usually run stuff from Windows nowadays. I was pretending to be a holdout from the 90s. However, Windows' current DOS is not the actual OS like under Win 3.1, so it isn't quite the same thing, or as reliable.

As for formatting your HDD, that's my usual solution to malware. Takes only 30 minutes for everything to be back to normal, so there's little reason for me not to take that road. :)

I only asked because every joke on the Internet falls flat because some people are joking when you think they are serious and vice versa.

Formatting the hard drive would be the last solution for me, because afterwards you have to reinstall everything. Now if you do proper backups, this isn't an issue. But few people including me do. No, I'd rather run a good virus and malware program that has its own boot sector.
 
Formatting the hard drive would be the last solution for me, because afterwards you have to reinstall everything. Now if you do proper backups, this isn't an issue. But few people including me do.

Tsk tsk. You never know when your hard drive will just die on you. Always have backups. And this isn't a joke! :)
 
Tsk tsk. You never know when your hard drive will just die on you. Always have backups. And this isn't a joke! :)

I know better then most people. I was a sales rep for ADIC a company that specialized in automated tape backup systems. I used to put on corporate presentations and for a while started with this joke. There are two kinds of computer users. Those who do backups and those who will. Basically suggesting that all it takes is one data catastrophe and you will start doing them.
 
Adam Lanza the Sandy Hook School mass killer attempted to destroy his hard drive physically. Why would it be remarkable?

https://www.washingtonpost.com/inve...851e741d196_story.html?utm_term=.cbe7231da807

The article you linked to never said Lanza tried to destroy his hard drive physically. It specifically said the police were not releasing that information:

Police have declined to provide information on the extent of the damage to the drive, but investigators remain hopeful that it can be repaired.

Try reading the articles you link to.
 
You computer geeks may find this very interesting. If I understand it correctly, this is an example of the Italian police screwing up a laptop on which Alberto Stasi said he was working at the time of his girlfriend's murder. Defense experts were able to retrieve the "lost" data that did, indeed, support his alibi statements.

Since I know my computer knowledge limits (unlike some people), I thought perhaps those of you who are experts can give it a look and give your opinions on it.

http://journals.sas.ac.uk/deeslr/article/viewFile/2452/2414
 
You computer geeks may find this very interesting. If I understand it correctly, this is an example of the Italian police screwing up a laptop on which Alberto Stasi said he was working at the time of his girlfriend's murder. Defense experts were able to retrieve the "lost" data that did, indeed, support his alibi statements.

Since I know my computer knowledge limits (unlike some people), I thought perhaps those of you who are experts can give it a look and give your opinions on it.

http://journals.sas.ac.uk/deeslr/article/viewFile/2452/2414

My reading is the Court of Cassation made a mistake. Without evaluating other incriminating evidence, the alibi evidence seems reasonable to me and if it's not, it seems as if they should REQUIRE evidence that it is false to overturn it as opposed to a mere suspicion. That said, I'd want to see the other evidence against the defendant.

But from a computer perspective, one would need a lot more background including the OS, the word processing application etc. I see why they might be suspicious that Stasi could have changed the computer times and then open and closed and saved the document to show use. That said, changing and resetting computer clocks also leaves a trail and you have to know what you're doing so that doesn't show. Their suspicion that he might of done something like this is based on the lack of 'saves' of the thesis during the time in question as many word processing programs, ie MS Word make periodic saves to your document in the background while you are working on it.
 
My reading is the Court of Cassation made a mistake. Without evaluating other incriminating evidence, the alibi evidence seems reasonable to me and if it's not, it seems as if they should REQUIRE evidence that it is false to overturn it as opposed to a mere suspicion. That said, I'd want to see the other evidence against the defendant.

But from a computer perspective, one would need a lot more background including the OS, the word processing application etc. I see why they might be suspicious that Stasi could have changed the computer times and then open and closed and saved the document to show use. That said, changing and resetting computer clocks also leaves a trail and you have to know what you're doing so that doesn't show. Their suspicion that he might of done something like this is based on the lack of 'saves' of the thesis during the time in question as many word processing programs, ie MS Word make periodic saves to your document in the background while you are working on it.

Did you catch that Stasi was acquitted at the first level trial AND the appellate level? Also, according to what I read, the DNA of another man (not Stasi) was found underneath the victim's fingernails. Apparently, the DNA found was not able to be identified by the experts at the time of the murder but other experts hired by the defense later identified the DNA as belonging to a man named Sempio who was a friend of the victim's brother. This was brought to a judge who dismissed it.

I readily admit I don't know anything about this case other than that, but I find it interesting.
 
Last edited:
Did you catch that Stasi was acquitted at the first level trial AND the appellate level? Also, according to what I read, the DNA of another man (not Stasi) was found underneath the victim's fingernails. Apparently, the DNA found was not able to be identified by the experts at the time of the murder but other experts hired by the defense later identified the DNA as belonging to a man named Sempio who was a friend of the victim's brother. This was brought to a judge who dismissed it.

I readily admit I don't know anything about this case other than that, but I find it interesting.

It seems as if they don't have enough work to do and setting up a situation like the Kercher case where at best the reliability of the final judgement will be highly questionable. If there was real evidence of computer tampering, then by all means have another trial. But it seems as the court is punishing the defendant for the carelessness of the police in examining the computer.
 
Laugh of the Day from TJMK Front Page:

Headsup: Overheated Marriott trolls flailing against justice respecters wanting Knox to cease chronic trashings of Italians who in fact treated her extremely well. Those are CRIMES. And Knox is already a felon for life for lying, and in contempt for $100,000 owed Patrick. Perhaps Curt Knox with proven history of anger and abuse should in overdue compensation take entire crime-family behind scene.

Wow. I especially like the "proven history of anger and abuse" line. No research I've done has ever revealed any such "fact".

Here's another Quennell line that's side-splittingly funny, albeit an oldie but a goodie. Talk about being self-unaware:

At least we here at TJMK always try to be fair to her (Amanda).

Posted by Peter Quennell on 03/14/09 at 02:00 AM
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom