Myth Busting about the 'Fried Hard Drives'
TEN MYTHS BUSTED!
Let's bust a few myths about the 'fried' hard drives.
Myth No.1
1. The disks were 'fried' by a geek working alone who was then too embarrassed to admit his calamity.
WRONG. The defense IT forensics expert was there to witness the copying (cloning).
From Mirca Gregori Testimony
So, there was a witness from the defense team, Formenti.
Myth No. 2
2. 'The postale police were grossly incompetent'
Raff's advocate, Giulia Bongiorno, wants to know if they understand what an electric shock (surge) is:
Myth No.3
3. 'The IT postal police used the wrong equipment.'
Amanda's advocate, Carlo Dalla Vedova is the purveyor of this particular myth.
In other words, the postal police were highly experienced and followed the same procedure, using the same equipment. Their results were
consistent. The probability of three laptops at random all frying is vanishingly remote.
Myth No. 4
'The postal police did not understand voltage'
Again this is a Dalla Vedova suggestion, defending Knox:
Myth No 5
'The postale police accidentally applied the wrong voltage'
Carlo Vedova cross-examining Marco Trotta, postal police:
So, we see it is
not possible for the police to have 'fried them' accidentally. (In any case, Formenti for the defense was a witness.)
Myth No. 6
'The postal police did not deny they fried the disks'
This myth flies out of the window as Trotta did categorically deny it:
Myth No.7
'The reason no data was retrieved from the laptops was because the disks were fried.'
In fact, nowhere is 'frying' stated as the technical reason for the police being unable to retrieve data. The reason was simple: the disks were dead.
Or, put another way:
Myth No.8
'It must have been Rudy who damaged Filomena Romanelli's Laptop'
This laptop was collected by Filomena from the crime scene and was also damaged. To explain how come this is so, if it is the police who are responsible for mass damage of hard drives, the explanation must be 'it was Rudy what dunnit'.
Gregori testified that this laptop's condition was how he received it, and was also dead.
Myth No. 9
'The postal police did their own thing so no-one knows what they got up to'
Fact is, IT forensics is their department and they were perfectly competent, as witnessed by Mr Formenti:
Myth No. 10
'How the three laptops got fried is entirely the fault of the incompetent postal police who used the wrong voltage and lacked the integrity to own up to their errors.'
Fact is:
- The defense was there to witness the clonng at all stages
- The postal police have a set procedure, with set equipment, which works consistently.
- It is *impossible* for them to apply the incorrect voltage, even with an adaptor.
- The laptops were tested in the order of: Lumumba, second: his was NOT damaged at all.
- The laptops were not 'fried', they were merely dead.
- Filomena's was also dead.
- The postal police were asked in open court if they were responsible for the damage.
- The postal police categorically denied they 'fried' the hard disks.
- The claim 'the postal police fried three laptops' is 100% a PR hoax.
Source:
http://themurderofmeredithkercher.com/Marco_Trotta's_Testimony