Cont: The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 27

Status
Not open for further replies.
And was Free Eraser available in 2007/8. What if a laptop is password/PIN protected, as they usually are?

Yes and many other similar programs have been around since Windows 95.

As for passwords, a good tech can crack his way into almost anything. Although I hear CIA or military encoded laptops are difficult. The average Windows machine was pretty damn easy to hack into back in 2007. All you need is a program with its own boot sector. So instead of launching Windows, it would launch a DOS or Linux Shell and a shredder app. With that you can see and shred selected files on the PC.

There are different kinds of pin and password protection. If the password is on the hardware bios it is slightly more difficult but even that can be cracked.
 
Last edited:
This is such a surreal "argument" about the hard drives. There's zero logical reason for a (hypothetically) guilty Knox and Sollecito to have physically disabled their whole hard drives (let alone in the way that it actually was done), and there's beyond zero logical reason for Knox and Sollecito to have physically disabled Kercher's and Romanelli's whole hard drives (let alone in the way that it was actually done). And various pro-acquittal commentators know very well what they are talking about on this issue, and pretty much no pro-guilt commentators (least of all the most prominent one on this site.....) know what they are talking about.

The drives were killed by the "crack" postal police IT bods. End of story.
 
Yes and many other similar programs have been around since Windows 95.

As for passwords, a good tech can crack his way into almost anything. Although I hear CIA or military encoded laptops are difficult. The average Windows machine was pretty damn easy to hack into back in 2007. All you need is a program with its own boot sector. So instead of launching Windows, it would launch a DOS or Linux Shell and a shredder app. With that you can see and shred selected files on the PC.

There are different kinds of pin and password protection. If the password is on the hardware bios it is slightly more difficult but even that can be cracked.

OK, so fair enough, it is difficult to wipe a hard drive without removing it and tampering with it.

So how do you account for Filomena's laptop HD being destroyed to the point of very little data was recoverable even after three years of consultations with expert data recovery technicians?

Sticking to the line,' Rudy dropped it from a height' (failing to give a reason why he would bother) means if it works for one it works for all, FreeEraser not needed.
 
OK, so fair enough, it is difficult to wipe a hard drive without removing it and tampering with it.
Did you ignore what I said. It isn't difficult at all. Wiping an entire hard drive may take time but it's like washing clothes in a machine. Throw the clothes in with detergent, select the cycle and come back in 30 minutes. Sure it consumed 30 minutes but you could be talking on the phone or watching the telly all that time.

So how do you account for Filomena's laptop HD being destroyed to the point of very little data was recoverable even after three years of consultations with expert data recovery technicians?
Maybe I could say why if I actually examined the computer and the hard drive, but it is IMPOSSIBLE to say from the cheap seats. It also might be impossible to say even if you are a world class tech and you could thoroughly examine the drive but we will never know.

Do you know what they tried to recover the data? Did they pay to pull the platters out and insert them into a working hard drive? My guess is 'no. We use to do this for people who would shell out the money. We use to charge $500 plus the cost of the new hard drive and we promised nothing. Some times the data is not recoverable.
 
Last edited:
This is such a surreal "argument" about the hard drives. There's zero logical reason for a (hypothetically) guilty Knox and Sollecito to have physically disabled their whole hard drives (let alone in the way that it actually was done), and there's beyond zero logical reason for Knox and Sollecito to have physically disabled Kercher's and Romanelli's whole hard drives (let alone in the way that it was actually done). And various pro-acquittal commentators know very well what they are talking about on this issue, and pretty much no pro-guilt commentators (least of all the most prominent one on this site.....) know what they are talking about.

The drives were killed by the "crack" postal police IT bods. End of story.

Are the details of the damage done to the drives by the Italian police available?
 
This is such a surreal "argument" about the hard drives. There's zero logical reason for a (hypothetically) guilty Knox and Sollecito to have physically disabled their whole hard drives (let alone in the way that it actually was done), and there's beyond zero logical reason for Knox and Sollecito to have physically disabled Kercher's and Romanelli's whole hard drives (let alone in the way that it was actually done). And various pro-acquittal commentators know very well what they are talking about on this issue, and pretty much no pro-guilt commentators (least of all the most prominent one on this site.....) know what they are talking about.

The drives were killed by the "crack" postal police IT bods. End of story.

I agree with it being surreal and your conclusion.
 
Are the details of the damage done to the drives by the Italian police available?

From Knox's computer consultant.

Following the tests carried out, by various interveners, it therefore appears that the Toshiba disk belonging to Miss A Knox’s Toshiba-brand laptop was damaged with problems evident in the electronic board, which resulted as being inactive, just like the other two. While the contents of two of the three disks have been recovered, following the Krollontrak company’s diagnosis, the third disk seems to have been also damaged in its component mechanics, while CBL Data’s and Recovery Tech’s diagnoses confirm that the third disk has been damaged in its electronic component. In reality, the damaged component is the electronic board, where an integrated circuit sits, sometimes referred to as “BIOS”, containing the binary code that allows access to the data, calibration, writing and reading. This technical specification belongs to the Toshiba manufacturing house, a proprietary [page] technology. The electronic board and the binary data contents of the disk being inextricably linked and intertwined, and the Toshiba logic board being damaged, it has therefore been impossible to recover it. Only a possible intervention by the parent company or its licentiate, by means of supplying the binary/BIOS code, would be able to justify a further intervention. It is however truly incomprehensible that three hard drive units, differing among themselves as to capacity, produced by among the most quoted manufacturers, belonging to and operating on three different laptops, could all three end up damaged in a similar manner and all three react in the same manner to an attempt at reading the data by an external disk controller run by the Operating System residing on an IBM PC furnished by the IAC/CNR Institute and of relative utility for data recovery.
 
OK, so fair enough, it is difficult to wipe a hard drive without removing it and tampering with it.


What? You still don't understand, do you? We're all repeatedly telling you that it's EASY to permanently wipe a hard drive without removing it and tampering (physically) with it.



So how do you account for Filomena's laptop HD being destroyed to the point of very little data was recoverable even after three years of consultations with expert data recovery technicians?

Sticking to the line,' Rudy dropped it from a height' (failing to give a reason why he would bother) means if it works for one it works for all, FreeEraser not needed.


*sigh*

Nobody is suggesting that Guede deliberately dropped Romanelli's laptop from a height (but nice straw man, once again....).

The suggestion is that a feasible route for the damage to Romanelli's laptop is that Guede ACCIDENTALLY knocked it to the floor of her room in the course of his entry into her room via her window. And, in turn, one feasible way in which that could have occurred is if the laptop were plugged into the mains, and Guede - in the dark (having entered via the window and immediately pulled the exterior shutters closed behind him in order to conceal both his presence and the broken glass pane of the window) - tripped or pulled against the power cord, thus pulling the laptop off Romanelli's desk and onto her hard (concreted and aggregate tiling) bedroom floor.
 
Are the details of the damage done to the drives by the Italian police available?


The logic boards were all damaged, in a way that is primarily consistent with an incorrect power adapter being connected (either at the wrong DC voltage and/or in the opposite polarity).

And as I've pointed out before, if these hard drives HAD all been destroyed by a guilty Sollecito (and as I and others also point out, Sollecito absolutely would have had to have known that there were far, far less incriminating and easier ways of destroying data on hard drives than this, and in any case why would he possibly have wanted/needed to destroy the hard drives of Kercher and Romanelli?), and had the police IT guys been competent and professional, they would have been able to confirm and report that the drives were fried even before the police got their hands on them.

The very fact that the police never even made such a claim is, in and of itself IMO, very strong evidence that a) it was the police themselves who fried the drives (in exactly the same way), and a) the police knew full well that it was they who had (at the very least) made an incompetent mistake in having done so. So the optimum strategy for the police at that time was not to outright lie and claim that the drives were destroyed before they even arrived in the lab; and likewise, they were not about to 'fess up and admit that it was they who'd fried the drives. No, their strategy was simply to shrug and say "Oh look, all these drives are fried. Oh well, that's that, never mind, too bad....". Which, IMO, makes them as implicitly guilty as a puppy standing next to a pile of poo.
 
Really? There is news today about an Amanda Knox copy cat, Jemma Lilley*, who was jailed today for 28 years for her gratuitous murder for thrills of an innocent young man in Perth, Australia. Her dream was to kill someone.



After the crime, she was described as:



Strikingly similar to Knox' demeanour in the Questura (cf also Joanna Dennehy).

So yes, Raff wanted 'extreme experiences', Amanda put her rape/murder stories up on her MySpace just a few weeks before moving to Perugia from Germany.

In Capenne prison, where by all accounts she was very happy, dancing and performing and penning yet another rape/stabbing story for which she won a prize [LOL], she wrote a degenerate screen play for a video by H.O.T. rock band,starring herself with two shady characters torturing a young woman strapped to a chair.

What a sick fantasy. Worse, there was an innocent victim bearing the brunt of it.

*Jemma Lilly even looks like Amanda Knox.
You really enjoyed yourself writing this, didn't you?
 
The logic boards were all damaged, in a way that is primarily consistent with an incorrect power adapter being connected (either at the wrong DC voltage and/or in the opposite polarity).

And as I've pointed out before, if these hard drives HAD all been destroyed by a guilty Sollecito (and as I and others also point out, Sollecito absolutely would have had to have known that there were far, far less incriminating and easier ways of destroying data on hard drives than this, and in any case why would he possibly have wanted/needed to destroy the hard drives of Kercher and Romanelli?), and had the police IT guys been competent and professional, they would have been able to confirm and report that the drives were fried even before the police got their hands on them.

The very fact that the police never even made such a claim is, in and of itself IMO, very strong evidence that a) it was the police themselves who fried the drives (in exactly the same way), and a) the police knew full well that it was they who had (at the very least) made an incompetent mistake in having done so. So the optimum strategy for the police at that time was not to outright lie and claim that the drives were destroyed before they even arrived in the lab; and likewise, they were not about to 'fess up and admit that it was they who'd fried the drives. No, their strategy was simply to shrug and say "Oh look, all these drives are fried. Oh well, that's that, never mind, too bad....". Which, IMO, makes them as implicitly guilty as a puppy standing next to a pile of poo.

Those are the clues obvious to everyone other than Vixen who is stil. trying to cram that square peg into a round hole.

The simple fact that 3 or 4 computer drives saw the same damage is telling. NO ONE is going to physically destroy that many computer drives to delete a few files on one machine.
It's time consuming and unwarranted.

The only people we KNOW who removed any of the drives were the Postal police who performed the same process on each machine. Even they know they were responsible for the drive screwup even though they didn't admit it.

Someone of Raffaele's expertise is going to know about file shredders. Especially if he knows that deleting files with OS commands doesn't actually delete the files only the pointers.

I got the impression that Raffaele was a computer geek given he had 3 computers all running different operating systems. He had a Mac. He had a Windows PC and he had Music server running Linux. I read comments he made about the file structure of the Apple OS and the different log files.
 
Those are the clues obvious to everyone other than Vixen who is stil. trying to cram that square peg into a round hole.

The simple fact that 3 or 4 computer drives saw the same damage is telling. NO ONE is going to physically destroy that many computer drives to delete a few files on one machine.
It's time consuming and unwarranted.

The only people we KNOW who removed any of the drives were the Postal police who performed the same process on each machine. Even they know they were responsible for the drive screwup even though they didn't admit it.

Someone of Raffaele's expertise is going to know about file shredders. Especially if he knows that deleting files with OS commands doesn't actually delete the files only the pointers.

I got the impression that Raffaele was a computer geek given he had 3 computers all running different operating systems. He had a Mac. He had a Windows PC and he had Music server running Linux. I read comments he made about the file structure of the Apple OS and the different log files.

If it is possible for the Postal Police to fry the drives by using the wrong voltage, then the same applies to Raff. If he was running a SATA /IDE hooked to the laptops in question then it is quite possible to fry the drives as the voltage of the SATA cables could differ from the PATA.

This is something he could do quite deliberately and quickly.
 
If it is possible for the Postal Police to fry the drives by using the wrong voltage, then the same applies to Raff. If he was running a SATA /IDE hooked to the laptops in question then it is quite possible to fry the drives as the voltage of the SATA cables could differ from the PATA.

This is something he could do quite deliberately and quickly.

You would think this if you were running a suspect-centric investigation.
 
If it is possible for the Postal Police to fry the drives by using the wrong voltage, then the same applies to Raff. If he was running a SATA /IDE hooked to the laptops in question then it is quite possible to fry the drives as the voltage of the SATA cables could differ from the PATA.

This is something he could do quite deliberately and quickly.


LMAO

Firstly, PATA is IDE. And by extension, SATA is not IDE. So it's nonsensical to talk about "running SATA/IDE" (and yes, it's obvious you don't mean "SATA or IDE".

Secondly, both SATA and PATA (IDE) connections are purely data connections. They are not power connections. Both SATA and PATA drives have separate power connections. It's therefore fatuous to talk about "voltage of SATA cables (differing) from the PATA".

Thirdly, why would (a hypothetically guilty) Sollecito possibly have wanted to 1) remove the hard drives from each of these laptops, then 2) connect them up to a totally different rig? It's totally obvious why the postal police would have been needing to do precisely this. But not Sollecito.


YOU REALLY DO NOT KNOW THE FAINTEST THING ABOUT ALL THIS. Each post just adds more to the growing evidence of your lack of knowledge/understanding. PLEASE STOP.
 
If it is possible for the Postal Police to fry the drives by using the wrong voltage, then the same applies to Raff. If he was running a SATA /IDE hooked to the laptops in question then it is quite possible to fry the drives as the voltage of the SATA cables could differ from the PATA.

This is something he could do quite deliberately and quickly.


DOH,!!! Are you logically impaired? As I pointed out earlier even the Postal police didn't 'successfully' damage the three drives. They did recover the data from 2 of the disks.
While the contents of two of the three disks have been recovered,following the Krollontrak company’s diagnosis, the third disk seems to have been also damaged in its component mechanics, while CBL Data’s and Recovery Tech’s diagnoses confirm that the third disk has been damaged in its electronic component. In reality, the damaged component is the electronic board, where an integrated circuit sits, sometimes referred to as “BIOS”, containing the binary code that allows access to the data, calibration, writing and reading


Again, NO ONE is going to try and damage 3 drives this way ESPECIALLY if the files they are concerned with are on one drive and even more so if they know how to delete and/or shred files. I want to say you are stupid...But I won't.

I will say this though. Your analysis is STUPID STUPID STUPID. Raffaele isn't that stupid.

BTW, this doesn't make the Postal police techs stupid. It means they made a mistake. They probably didn't know they fried the drives. All they knew for sure is all of the drives were displaying the same issues. First one didn't copy. Put in the second one. That's strange, it isn't copying either. Try the third. Something is very wrong here.

Someone who majors in computer science (Raffaele) is going to know that the files are stored by magnetic charges on the spinning platters. One can fry the circuit boards and the motor that spins the platters and the files may still reside on those platters may and probably remain fully recoverable. So if you don't want someone to recover any possible data, you are not going to electrically fry the drive. No, what you are going to do is take a screwdriver and a hammer and punch a hole through those platters.

Or alternatively, you'll run a file shredding application.
 
Last edited:
Really? There is news today about an Amanda Knox copy cat, Jemma Lilley*, who was jailed today for 28 years for her gratuitous murder for thrills of an innocent young man in Perth, Australia. Her dream was to kill someone.
Nice touch with the "Amanda Knox copy cat" bit when there is nothing similar between the two cases other than Knox and Lilley are both female. But so are you.

She developed what prosecutors described as a long-term fascination with horror films, murder and serial killers.

Lilley idolised horror film character Freddy Krueger, and had previously told a friend she wanted to kill before she turned 25.

The supermarket shelf-stacker had also penned a book about a serial killer named SOS - a nickname she used during online exchanges with accomplice Lenon.

And Knox had done any of these?

After the crime, she was described as:

During a four-week trial, prosecutor James McTaggart told the court Lilley was so "full of herself and euphoric" after the killing she could not help boasting to a work colleague.

Strikingly similar to Knox' demeanour in the Questura (cf also Joanna Dennehy).
Nonsense. No one described Knox as "full of herself or euphoric" or "boasting" or anything even remotely similar. Making funny faces at Raff is hardly in the same league.

So yes, Raff wanted 'extreme experiences',

Next thing, you'll be telling us that "extreme sports" means hunting down and killing people. Normal people would consider sky diving, bungee jumping, mountain climbing etc as "extreme experiences. But not you. "Extreme experiences" means killing someone.


Amanda put her rape/murder stories up on her MySpace just a few weeks before moving to Perugia from Germany.


And here we go again just as if we've never been through this before. Baby Brother was an ANTI-RAPE story and no one was murdered in either of the stories. But don't let those facts stand in the way of a good lie.

In Capenne prison, where by all accounts she was very happy, dancing and performing

By all accounts? LOL Would you care to provide any of those accounts? No? I didn't think so.

and penning yet another rape/stabbing story for which she won a prize [LOL],

And here we go again.... rape was never mentioned in My Love The girl's injuries were unspecified. interestingly, I see you automatically assume rape . Why is that? Nor was stabbing ever mentioned. Have you already forgotten the in depth discussion about this very subject? You claimed the people were stabbing each other when the word used meant they were injecting themselves. Forgot that, heh? Here's what the Brit newspaper, The Independent, said:

...in a room full of people injecting themselves with drugs. Later she is rushed to the hospital with unspecified injuries...

But, hey...why let the truth get in the way of a good smear, right?

she wrote a degenerate screen play for a video by H.O.T. rock band,starring herself with two shady characters torturing a young woman strapped to a chair.

Hmm...I just watched The Mistral Blows again. There is no young woman strapped to a chair being tortured. Seeing things?

What a sick fantasy. Worse, there was an innocent victim bearing the brunt of it.

*Jemma Lilly even looks like Amanda Knox.

Agreed! There is certainly a very sick fantasy here.
 
Myth Busting about the 'Fried Hard Drives'

Myth Busting about the 'Fried Hard Drives'

TEN MYTHS BUSTED!

Let's bust a few myths about the 'fried' hard drives.

Myth No.1

1. The disks were 'fried' by a geek working alone who was then too embarrassed to admit his calamity.

WRONG. The defense IT forensics expert was there to witness the copying (cloning).

From Mirca Gregori Testimony

There was also a defense technician, if I remember correctly was the engineer Formenti.
:gasp:

So, there was a witness from the defense team, Formenti.

Myth No. 2

2. 'The postale police were grossly incompetent'

Raff's advocate, Giulia Bongiorno, wants to know if they understand what an electric shock (surge) is:

GB:
If you can give me some indication of this, the causes that have caused this breakup of the computer, do you know what an electric shock is?
MG:
I know what an electric shock is from the point of view of electronics, a malfunction of an electric network. So an increase in ... as far as the computer is concerned, because it turns out to be damaged, we do not have the slightest idea about when and how.
GB:
Do you know that out of three, this electric shock was recognized in three computers?
MG:
On the three computers yes, but in any case we can not give an explanation why it may have happened. Surely it is that the moment we went to attack them showed that type of problem.
GB:
Was the same kind of problem all three?
MG:
They were not recognized. [i.e., they were dead]
GB:
All three?
MG:
Exactly. While the others who were perhaps in sequence, some and not others with the same equipment.

Myth No.3

3. 'The IT postal police used the wrong equipment.'

Amanda's advocate, Carlo Dalla Vedova is the purveyor of this particular myth.

CDV:
Are you aware of the possibility of an electric shock?
MG:
We are aware of the possibility of an electric shock/surge, I can not exclude it with certainty, but at the same time the fact that it has worked in other hard disks always the same instrument, always in that same place connected to the same electric network, is however an indicator that it is not so, in one moment it worked in another, not.

In other words, the postal police were highly experienced and followed the same procedure, using the same equipment. Their results were consistent. The probability of three laptops at random all frying is vanishingly remote.

Myth No. 4

'The postal police did not understand voltage'

Again this is a Dalla Vedova suggestion, defending Knox:


CDV: However, are you aware that there is a different voltage between a portable PC and a desktop?
MG:
Yes.
CDV:
Exactly...
MG:
Of the different voltages, 5 or 3 depends on the attack as well which is used.
CDV:
What is voltage on the desktop?
MG:
On the desktop there are also 12 volts.
CDV:
Do you feel like it was impossible to clone the three hard disks that were broken or illegible?
MG:
Precisely because the time when it is not legible can not be read, it is not even reproducible elsewhere, because if I do not take input data, I can not give it back.
CDV:
But are you aware that in any case a cloning was done later?
MG:
I know it was done, but what I can say is that it was possible not with this type of instrumentation that we used.

Myth No 5

'The postale police accidentally applied the wrong voltage'

Carlo Vedova cross-examining Marco Trotta, postal police:

MT:
So the disk of a laptop works with a voltage of 5 volts I think.
CDV:
5 vols?
MT:
Yes 5 volts I think it works. A desktop hard disk works at a voltage of 12 volts. This is what my knowledge is.
CDV:
Of 12?
MT:
Yes.
CDV:
So what if I take the hard disk that has a voltage of 5 times from this computer, the detachment underneath where there are the screws, I extract it by removing the plugs that are inside, I make it as in the photo and attack it to a desktop where has a voltage?
MT:
It can not be done.
CDV:
I can not do it?
MT:
No.
CDV:
Because?
MT:
Because we need adapters.
CDV:
And if I had adapters what?
MT:
You can not go wrong, all the tapes have, are poured and each cable has its corresponding plug, an adapter for a system, for a 2.5 disk, takes power from what they are, from what is voltage 5 volts, just go there, all the tapes have a verse, you can not be wrong.
CDV:
Wrong, is not it possible to attack a hard disk that is on this computer?
MT:
It is possible with an adapter.
CDV:
If I do it, what happens? If I do it without the adapter?
MT:
The system sees a hard drive. No without adapter does not.
CDV:
Does not it stick right?
MT:
It does not attack absolutely.
CDV:
Is there no passage of electricity?
MT:
No, no, just do not put the spinets.

So, we see it is not possible for the police to have 'fried them' accidentally. (In any case, Formenti for the defense was a witness.)

Myth No. 6

'The postal police did not deny they fried the disks'

This myth flies out of the window as Trotta did categorically deny it:

MT:
Regarding the acquisition we do it on the hard disk. The data acquired, it was not possible to perform data acquisition of the hard disk, so it is probably the hard disk that did not work.
GB:
Do you know that even for the other two machines subject to seizure delivered to you, there was an identical problem, that is not asserting to the computer but only the hard disk?
MT:
I did not know anything. Nothing has been communicated to us.
GB:
Does it turn out that all three discs had been shocked?
MT:
No.


Myth No.7

'The reason no data was retrieved from the laptops was because the disks were fried.'

In fact, nowhere is 'frying' stated as the technical reason for the police being unable to retrieve data. The reason was simple: the disks were dead.

MT:
Then they were acquired, the hardisk was acquired by acquiring inside the macbook of Mr. Sollecito Raffaele, was acquired the USB keys of Mr. Raffaele. As for the asus, the other handset could not be scanned, as .the machine did not detect the presence of the seized hard disk There was something that probably did not work.
MC:
Then?
MT:
Similarly it was made ...
MC:
Which other computer was examined?
MT:
A similar operation was made for the Lumumba computer, which was acquired, and a similar attempt was made regarding the computer of Knox, and for the computer of the deceased, Meredit.
MC:
With which outcomes?
MT:
So as far as Meredit's computers are concerned, Amanda's computer and for this computer, it was not possible to perform the acquisition, because our system did not detect the hardware.
<snip>
MT:
I confirm, it is exactly the supports that have been delivered, the eBook G4 by Meredit Kercher, the Mac Book Pro by Raffaele Sollecito, including the Kingston 128 MB key and a 12 8 MB Seitek. I confirm the presence of the Room CDs and the Asus computer model L3 00D always by Raffaele Sollecito. I confirm that it was subsequently done, and the Toshiba laptop from Amanda Knox was also delivered at the same time. I therefore confirm that the report was relevant to the material delivered to us.

[Refering to a slide show:]
MT:
Exactly. Here are the three laptops for which it was not possible to perform the acquisition[retrieval], which the system did not detect.

Or, put another way:

CDV:
The result of this analysis was that the disks were?
MT:
The system did not detect the disk, so it was not possible to perform the acquisition.

Myth No.8

'It must have been Rudy who damaged Filomena Romanelli's Laptop'

This laptop was collected by Filomena from the crime scene and was also damaged. To explain how come this is so, if it is the police who are responsible for mass damage of hard drives, the explanation must be 'it was Rudy what dunnit'.

Gregori testified that this laptop's condition was how he received it, and was also dead.

CDV:
Do you think Romanelli's computer had the same defect of these?
MG:
He had the discourse that did not work, just made special noises, cole if it did not turn well in its normal functionality.
CDV:
Did you say that it was called and you proceeded to turn it on the computer?
MG:
You have turned on taking care to start it with a cd, that is when you turn on a computer the first instruction that performs is to see where to go to get the boot disk. What we did with that kind of ...
GCM:
This of Romanelli's computer?
MG:
That of Romanelli's computer. To avoid using instrumentation, many times on computers that do not need to have a strong intrusive activity, there are some CDs that are practically put on the computer, once put on the computer you turn it on, you enter the configuration of the boot, and it is given to the computer to "start via cd rom", so no hard disk. <snip> A sale started the disk as it comes power supply to the system, to the whole computer, 1 'Hard disk made these strange noises, so it was immediately turned off and even what was done was done, to avoid that maybe the cartridge just like I said before, go to create damage over the support.
CDV:
However, it turns out that the other computers have all been made to computer tests dead?
MG:
Yes.
CDV:
What is the difference between ascertaining a computer in the way it just has ...?
MG:
We can define an identical dead computer mode, because as I said then the disk is loaded in read-only mode. That is the same system that happens when you connect it with a hardware, ie an electronic instrument to protect the data, in that case that CD ROM does so in software mode, ie the disk is loaded in read-only mode. So even if I go there and try to delete a file or write to it, it tells me "access denied". Exactly it is in dead mode, so much so that then the system that appears to the user is not the real operating system that is present on the computer, but it is another system that special way in all ...
CDV:
It can be said that in one case there is a passage of electricity energy and in the other case when the computer is dead no?
MG:
No, however, there is a passage of energy.
CDV:
In both cases?
MG:
In both cases, because when it is there attached that instrument does not block the electric current, but only blocks the writing intervention on the disk and not reading. What is necessary instead to be able to see the data.
CDV:
From the point of view of power supply the same system is identical, is it just a question of software?
MG:
Exact.
CDV:
Thank you, no other questions.

Myth No. 9

'The postal police did their own thing so no-one knows what they got up to'

Fact is, IT forensics is their department and they were perfectly competent, as witnessed by Mr Formenti:

I will then specify what, what I mean by data acquisition. Then, on November 13th, the defenders of Mr. Sollecito presented themselves to the compartment, where they appointed Mr. Formenti as a part consultant, who then attended all the acquisition operations from the 15th. The acquisition was performed ...
MC:
Watch him explain immediately what does acquisition mean?
MT:
Acquisition is a cloning of all data present in magnetic media. Cloning is performed by interposing the hardware in use with the compart ...
MC:
For the moment, is it enough for me to say that acquisition means copying?
MT:
Cloning of all the data present in the medium, even those deleted and part of the written disconon.
MC:
Perfect. While the computers on which, or the computer, on which you have carried out the investigations, were already in the availability of the mobile team since before?
MT:
Yes, the material was delivered to us by the mobile team a few days before.
GCM:
The 13 said?
MT:
On the 13th the parties were notified, on the 15th the defenders presented themselves with the part technical consultant. The acquisition was performed interposing between the hardware supplied to the compartment and the magnetic supports seized to the suspects by inserting between the two appropriate hardware that inhibits the writing of the supports, in order to guarantee the seized media and make the act repeatable at any time . This I think is one of the fundamental things to explain.

Myth No. 10

'How the three laptops got fried is entirely the fault of the incompetent postal police who used the wrong voltage and lacked the integrity to own up to their errors.'

Fact is:
  • The defense was there to witness the clonng at all stages
  • The postal police have a set procedure, with set equipment, which works consistently.
  • It is *impossible* for them to apply the incorrect voltage, even with an adaptor.
  • The laptops were tested in the order of: Lumumba, second: his was NOT damaged at all.
  • The laptops were not 'fried', they were merely dead.
  • Filomena's was also dead.
  • The postal police were asked in open court if they were responsible for the damage.
  • The postal police categorically denied they 'fried' the hard disks.
  • The claim 'the postal police fried three laptops' is 100% a PR hoax.

Source:http://themurderofmeredithkercher.com/Marco_Trotta's_Testimony
 
Last edited:
OK, so fair enough, it is difficult to wipe a hard drive without removing it and tampering with it.

So how do you account for Filomena's laptop HD being destroyed to the point of very little data was recoverable even after three years of consultations with expert data recovery technicians?
Sticking to the line,' Rudy dropped it from a height' (failing to give a reason why he would bother) means if it works for one it works for all, FreeEraser not needed.

False. FR testified that the techs she hired got her data back:

CDV:È chiaro, questo volevo capire, grazie. Senta lei ad oggi ha perso tutti i dati di quel computer?


FR:No, sono riuscita a trovare un tecnico che è riuscito ad aggiustarmi l'hard disk e mi ha salvato i dati, mi ha sostituito l'hard disk.

GCM:Come si chiama, se lo può dire.

FR:No, non lo conosco di persona, era un signore che conosceva uno degli Avvocati nello studio in cui sto, mi ha detto "Proviamo con questo signore magari ti può aiutare", l'ha tenuto circa tre mesi e dopo tre mesi un giorno mi ha chiamato, ha detto "Ho i tuoi dati" e quindi.

CDV:It's clear, I wanted to understand this, thank you. Do you hear her to date lost all the data on that computer?

FR:No, I managed to find a technician who was able to fix the hard disk and saved the data, he replaced the hard disk

GCM:What's his name, if he can say it.


FR:No, I do not know him in person, he was a gentleman who knew one of the lawyers in the studio I'm in, he told me "Let's try this man maybe he can help you", he held it about three months and three months later one day he called, he said "I have your data" and then.
 
Myth Busting about the 'Fried Hard Drives'

TEN MYTHS BUSTED!

Let's bust a few myths about the 'fried' hard drives.

Myth No.1

1. The disks were 'fried' by a geek working alone who was then too embarrassed to admit his calamity.

WRONG. The defense IT forensics expert was there to witness the copying (cloning).

From Mirca Gregori Testimony


:gasp:

So, there was a witness from the defense team, Formenti.

Myth No. 2

2. 'The postale police were grossly incompetent'

Raff's advocate, Giulia Bongiorno, wants to know if they understand what an electric shock (surge) is:



Myth No.3

3. 'The IT postal police used the wrong equipment.'

Amanda's advocate, Carlo Dalla Vedova is the purveyor of this particular myth.



In other words, the postal police were highly experienced and followed the same procedure, using the same equipment. Their results were consistent. The probability of three laptops at random all frying is vanishingly remote.

Myth No. 4

'The postal police did not understand voltage'

Again this is a Dalla Vedova suggestion, defending Knox:




Myth No 5

'The postale police accidentally applied the wrong voltage'

Carlo Vedova cross-examining Marco Trotta, postal police:



So, we see it is not possible for the police to have 'fried them' accidentally. (In any case, Formenti for the defense was a witness.)

Myth No. 6

'The postal police did not deny they fried the disks'

This myth flies out of the window as Trotta did categorically deny it:




Myth No.7

'The reason no data was retrieved from the laptops was because the disks were fried.'

In fact, nowhere is 'frying' stated as the technical reason for the police being unable to retrieve data. The reason was simple: the disks were dead.



Or, put another way:



Myth No.8

'It must have been Rudy who damaged Filomena Romanelli's Laptop'

This laptop was collected by Filomena from the crime scene and was also damaged. To explain how come this is so, if it is the police who are responsible for mass damage of hard drives, the explanation must be 'it was Rudy what dunnit'.

Gregori testified that this laptop's condition was how he received it, and was also dead.



Myth No. 9

'The postal police did their own thing so no-one knows what they got up to'

Fact is, IT forensics is their department and they were perfectly competent, as witnessed by Mr Formenti:



Myth No. 10

'How the three laptops got fried is entirely the fault of the incompetent postal police who used the wrong voltage and lacked the integrity to own up to their errors.'

Fact is:
  • The defense was there to witness the clonng at all stages
  • The postal police have a set procedure, with set equipment, which works consistently.
  • It is *impossible* for them to apply the incorrect voltage, even with an adaptor.
  • The laptops were tested in the order of: Lumumba, second: his was NOT damaged at all.
  • The laptops were not 'fried', they were merely dead.
  • Filomena's was also dead.
  • The postal police were asked in open court if they were responsible for the damage.
  • The postal police categorically denied they 'fried' the hard disks.
  • The claim 'the postal police fried three laptops' is 100% a PR hoax.

Source:http://themurderofmeredithkercher.com/Marco_Trotta's_Testimony

I bet ur jelly you weren't posting here 8 years ago when there was actually a case to discuss lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom